(French) Il s'agit des données sur les projets ou propositions de lois discutés au parlement ainsi le vote desdits projets ou propositions (ne pas confondre avec les lois déjà adoptées). Les données concernant ces projets et propositions de lois doivent être disponibles lors de toute la durée de la session parlementaire.
Question | Answer | Comment |
---|---|---|
Openly licenced | No | CC by see: https://www.data.gv.at/katalog/dataset/9b40a0af-a6fe-47ff-9624-2ea8f40c746f |
In an open and machine-readable format | CSV, HTML, XML | |
Downloadable at once | Yes | https://www.data.gv.at/katalog/dataset/9b40a0af-a6fe-47ff-9624-2ea8f40c746f |
Up-to-date | Yes | every 15 Minutes |
Publicly available | No | |
Available free of charge | No | |
findable | 4 | My assessment of findability: It is hard to find the data (I give a score of 1). I visited the main website of ZAMG, then had to look for a long time to understand that the "products" button contains weather information. Then had to click two levels deeper (the naming of the links is not obvious: I clicked through "general forecast" -> "homepage and APP" ). I arrived at a page that offers all our required data: https://www.zamg.ac.at/cms/de/produkte/wetter/allgemeine-vorhersagen/wetter-fuer-ihre-homepage-und-mobile-anwendungen |
findable_steps | Search on the website | |
licence_url | https://www.data.gv.at/katalog/dataset/9b40a0af-a6fe-47 | |
Collected by government | Yes | |
usability | 3 | |
collector_name | ZAMG - Zentralanstalt für Meterologie und Geodynamik | |
Controlled access | Yes | |
characteristics | Temperature extremes, Temperature average, Wind speed, Wind direction, Precipitation Amount, Precipitation Probability, Forecast for current day and four following days | I added the characteristics "precipitation amount" and "precipitation probability" |
location | https://www.zamg.ac.at/cms/de/aktuell - , https://warnungen.zamg.at/html/de/heute/alle/at/ - , https://www.zamg.ac.at/cms/de/wetter/wetterwerte-analyse - ZAMG, Subpage, Wind speed, temperature extremes, Wind direction and precipitation amount. Only available for current day, https://www.zamg.ac.at/cms/de/wetter/wetterkarte - , https://www.zamg.ac.at/cms/de/wetter/wetteranimation - , https://www.data.gv.at/katalog/dataset/9b40a0af-a6fe-47 - Data.gov.at, Subpage, currently measured data (no forecasting), available for various stations, contains all required data elements in numerical data, https://www.data.gv.at/katalog/dataset/464ce024-8e5b-43 - Data.gov.at, Subpage, historical data for accumulated precipitation amount, https://www.zamg.ac.at/cms/de/produkte/wetter/allgemeine - ZAMG, Subpage, |
The original submission was amended, because it referred to current weather measurements (containing all required data elements for various weather stations in numerical values, it is openly licensed, available for free, downloadable at once). This data is fully open. However, it is not forecasting data. The reviewer found a forecasting dataset, available at: https://www.zamg.ac.at/cms/de/produkte/wetter/allgemeine-vorhersagen/wetter-fuer-ihre-homepage-und-mobile-anwendungen This dataset contains all required characteristics for 5 days and is considered the reference forecast dataset, because it is most representative for the parameters the Index assesses. It can be retrieved at once via FTP server but is not openly licensed and has to be paid on a monthly basis. To do so, users have to sign up for the service. It is available as HTML or in raw data (XML or CSV). I added the characteristics "precipitation amount" and "precipitation probability" Thank you, Günther Tschabuschnig, for submitting to the Global Open Data Index. Reviewers assessment of findability: It is hard to find the data (I give a score of 1). I visited the main website of ZAMG, then had to look for a long time to understand that the "products" button contains weather information. Then had to click two levels deeper (the naming of the links is not obvious: I clicked through "general forecast" -> "homepage and APP" ). I arrived at a page that offers all our required data: https://www.zamg.ac.at/cms/de/produkte/wetter/allgemeine-vorhersagen/wetter-fuer-ihre-homepage-und-mobile-anwendungen