"id","site","timestamp","year","place","dataset","answers","reviewed","reviewResult","reviewComments","details","isCurrent","isOpen","submitter","reviewer","score","relativeScore"
"2ec81933-0237-4579-97d6-275d84a8f531","global","2016-12-12T21:41:42","2016","mx","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""in the main page for compranet you can find the link to the contracts"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://datos.gob.mx/libreusomx"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Secretaría de la Función Pública"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://sites.google.com/site/cnetuc/contrataciones"",""descValue"":""Compranet contracts per year""},{""urlValue"":""https://datos.gob.mx/busca/dataset/procedimientos-de-contratacion-2017"",""descValue"":""Compranet contracts""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data is up to date. You can download the data in XLS and the license is open. ",,"Yes","Yes","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"8ab26a9c-97ca-4b8d-a699-563f24020efa","global","2017-06-14T22:49:54","2016","dk","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Remember cvr.dk and redirects"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://hjaelp.virk.dk/sites/default/files/vilkaar_for_brug_af_danske_offentlige_data_v4.pdf"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Danish Business Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://datacvr.virk.dk/data/"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This was changed and reviewed as part of GODI public dialogue phase. See the forum thread: https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-companies-dk/5261","Data require registration = By default login requires NemID (available for anyone above 15 years with Danish CPR number and for Danish registered companies). For everyone else you need to manually request data using a contact form.","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","50","50"
"094a2b76-d173-4c8d-b9f9-2a73867b7ed2","global","2017-08-07T08:48:28","2016","sg","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched for water quality data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Singapore National Water Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Arsenic"",""Fluoride levels"",""Nitrates"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.sg/dataset/drinking-water-quality"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.pub.gov.sg/Documents/WQ2016.pdf"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This entry was updated after a discussion between members of Open Knowledge International and the government of Singapore (see discussion here: https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-water-sg/5398/3). In this year, we accept national aggregate water quality data. These have been published by the Singapore government in 2016.
In the future water quality data must also be available at the level of water sources (for instance taps). Aggregated, national figures alone will not suffice to reach a high score.",,"Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","60","60"
"3fb93347-41b7-47b2-a992-b2d7b1d2ff7d","global","2017-08-07T08:22:54","2016","fr","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Visit both parliament chambers OpenData websites and explore the different datasets published"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Assemblée nationale, Sénat"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Author of bill"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.assemblee-nationale.fr/travaux-parlementaires/dossiers-legislatifs"",""descValue"":""Bills data from National Assembly""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.assemblee-nationale.fr/travaux-parlementaires/debats"",""descValue"":""Debates data from National Assembly""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.assemblee-nationale.fr/travaux-parlementaires/votes"",""descValue"":""Votes data from National Assembly""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.senat.fr/dosleg/"",""descValue"":""Bills data from Senate""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This entry was changed after a discussion on the Open Knowledge Forum, see here: https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-draftlegislation-fr/5581
Some data is available in machine-readable, open formats, including JSON, XML, CSV or Postgre SQL 8.4 format. See as stated the relevant sites: https://data.assemblee-nationale.fr & https://data.senat.fr. However, the bill content is required to be machine-readable, so that the entire dataset can count as machine-readable. Since the bill content (i.e. bill text) is not machine-readable, the dataset is not considered to be machine-readable.","The submitter described how the French draft legislation dataset is composed. The bottom line: Senate and National Assembly publish data to very different degrees. The different key data characteristics are spread across different data files, and are hard to put together.
1) Content of bills is never published as machine-readable data, only as HTML and PDF files on the official websites. 2) Authors of bills are missing from Senate's data but sufficiently enough present at least for all discussed bills in National Assembly's data. Yet, author names are not part of the bill texts. The National Assembly requires author names to be collected through ids in another dataset. This means users need to put these datasets together. 3) Only the National Assembly publishes data on voting records [but not for all votes]. The Senate does not publish any voting record as data. Votes on bills per member are partially published as OpenData for the National Assembly when a public scrutiny happened (which is the case for most important bills but not all), and associating a vote to a bill is very complex. Votes at the Senate are only published in html pages on the official website. 4) Transcripts of discussions around a bill are published as separate datasets that are not trivial to bind with bills data. 5) Final status of bills can easily be found in Senate's data. Ongoing status is available in National Assembly's data although it needs to be interpreted from analysing information on all parliamentary steps.
Data is released with the national French Open License, but with an explicit warning that it remains subject to the 2002-1064 decree https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/affichTexte.do?cidTexte=JORFTEXT000000413818 which authorizes the data owner to refuse to grant the license to a reuser, hence making it not really openly licensed. See https://rip.journal-officiel.gouv.fr/index.php/pages/juridiques Further discussion here https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-national-laws-france/5461/6","Yes","No","anonymous","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"19650e60-3c23-463c-bb08-607090d853f6","global","2017-02-01T09:11:17","2016","fi","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no clear indication if the government spending data is either collected by the Ministry of Finance or the Office of Statistics. \n\n\n""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Unknown"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Statistics about spending, on central government and municipal level, are published here:
https://pxnet2.stat.fi/PXWeb/pxweb/fi/StatFin/
https://pxnet2.stat.fi/PXWeb/pxweb/fi/Kuntien_talous_ja_toiminta
This information is available through an XML-based API. The data does however not contain information about individual transactions.","Yes","No","Aleksi Knuutila","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"1bccabba-8097-476f-9b50-43931a81c4a5","global","2016-12-28T00:54:48","2016","fr","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is released with the national French Open License, but with an explicit warning that it remains subject to the 2002-1064 decree https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/affichTexte.do?cidTexte=JORFTEXT000000413818 which authorizes the data owner to refuse to grant the license to a reuser, hence making it not really openly licensed. See https://rip.journal-officiel.gouv.fr/index.php/pages/juridiques""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Already knowing the name of the dataset, looked for it on data.gouv.fr"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Very easy to navigate through to find national laws.""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""DILA"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.data.gouv.fr/fr/datasets/legi-codes-lois-et-reglements-consolides/"",""descValue"":""LEGI: Official database of versionned laws""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","All data is available, and it is easy to navigate.
B7: Data is released with the national French Open License, but with an explicit warning that it remains subject to the 2002-1064 decree https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/affichTexte.do?
",,"Yes","No","Open Knowledge","Oscar Montiel","80","80"
"fcc5b1d2-fe6f-485a-b3de-05fa652c89a4","global","2017-06-22T15:11:29","2016","gb","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Electoral Commission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"A key feature of this indicator is that data is available at polling station level. In the United Kingdom the Representation of the People Act 1983 requires polling stations to combine votes with at least one additional polling station before any counting occurs. This is to protect the identity of voters in the event that a candidate receives a low number of votes.
The Representation of the People Act can be found at: https://www.parliament.uk/about/living-heritage/transformingsociety/electionsvoting/womenvote/parliamentary-collections/collections-the-vote-and-after/representation-of-the-people-act-1918/
Therefore the United Kingdom does not provide election results of major electoral contests at polling station level. The Electoral Commission provides election results at higher levels, available at: https://www.electoralcommission.org.uk/our-work/our-research/electoral-data
","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"b0b98aad-0a5f-4366-a379-6ab9e9a39572","global","2017-06-22T15:38:09","2016","ar","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Subsecretaría de recursos hídricos"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Argentina did not provide all relevant water quality indicators within our assessment timeframe. Fecal Coliform, Arsenic, and Fluoride were missing.
The data to be assessed were found at: https://bdhi.hidricosargentina.gov.ar/
After our review timeframe was over, Argentina added new water quality data. Now the Argentinian government publishes water quality data at: https://datos.ambiente.gob.ar/dataset/calidad-de-agua. This data contains several water quality indicators (measured in many areas around the country). As the government states, the displayed water quality indicators can vary across areas. Quality indicators include temperature, pH, conductivity, among others. The data is openly licensed and up to date.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"cf49b084-270e-4cf9-95e9-caff67d232b5","global","2017-06-22T15:21:32","2016","be","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""FOD Binnenlandse Zaken"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"This entry shows a 0% score because Belgium does not provide election results at the poll station level. It does publish electoral results, but at higher levels.
In the public dialogue phase reasons following reasons were mentioned as to why Belgium does not provide poll station data:
Counting stations are required to mix (paper) ballots from polling stations (which in turn have multiple ballot boxes) before counting may start. There are only results available on the counting station and municipality level. When voting is done electronically (depends on the municipality), votes are counted at municipality level, again to protect the voters.
Therefore it is currently not possible for Belgium to provide poll station data. ","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"1045af42-0418-457d-80b0-80dc6f235e2a","global","2016-12-09T04:49:13","2016","gb","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data from Environment Agency's Water Quality Archive is re-usable under the Open Government Licence, as are the annual reports from the drinking water regulators.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""This answer refers to downloads from Environment Agency's Water Quality Archive. Outputs from the drinking water regulators are mainly in PDF.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Environment Agency's Water Quality Archive data is available as a single download per year but, as noted above, this data covers only England.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The most recent public data available from Environment Agency's Water Quality Archive is for 2015.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Answered Yes as some data is accessible online. However coverage is far from complete. See comments below.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Water quality data for Britain is not generally well signposted. (EA's Water Quality Archive was launched in early 2016 but is light on documentation.)""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I had pre-existing knowledge of the agencies responsible and the location of their data. However I also performed searches of Google, Data.gov.uk and Gov.uk, and explored the websites of the above mentioned agencies in order to establish whether there was further data available."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://environment.data.gov.uk/water-quality/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This answer refers to data from Environment Agency's Water Quality Archive. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Environment Agency (England); Natural Resources Wales; Scottish Environment Protection Agency; Drinking Water Inspectorate (England and Wales); Drinking Water Quality Regulator for Scotland"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Rivers and other water bodies are monitored by Environment Agency (England), Natural Resources Wales and Scottish Environment Protection Agency. Public water supplies are monitored by the Drinking Water Inspectorate (England and Wales) and the Drinking Water Quality Regulator for Scotland.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Arsenic"",""Fluoride levels"",""Nitrates"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Data per water source""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""These response are based on data available, most recently for 2015, from Environment Agency's Water Quality Archive. Measurements are based on 58 thousand sampling points in rivers and other water bodies. Please note that these are not specifically drinking water sources. Equivalent public data is not available for Scotland or Wales. Annual reports from the drinking water regulators do not provide detailed data or data in a re-usable format.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://environment.data.gov.uk/water-quality/"",""descValue"":""Water Quality Archive (Environment Agency)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dwi.gov.uk/about/annual-report/2015/index.html"",""descValue"":""Annual Reports (Drinking Water Inspectorate)""},{""urlValue"":""https://dwqr.scot/information/annual-report/"",""descValue"":""Annual Reports (Drinking Water Quality Regulator for Scotland)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Only EA's water data is published in CSV format. Water quality reports for the entire British territory are only available as PDF. Data from Environment Agency's Water Quality Archive is re-usable under the Open Government Licence, as are the annual reports from the drinking water regulators.
The most recent public data available from Environment Agency's Water Quality Archive is for 2015. Data can be downloaded at once, but only for English territory.
Water quality reports are available at: https://www.dwi.gov.uk/about/annual-report/2016/index.html https://environment.data.gov.uk/water-quality/view/landing","This submission needs careful consideration on review, as the scores exclusively refer to England's Water Quality Archive (only applying to English water quality). There are significant gaps in coverage. Although the release of EA's Water Quality Archive represents progress since last year, availability of open data on water quality in Great Britain remains generally poor and coverage far from complete.
Background: The monitoring of water quality is divided in Great Britain.
Rivers and other water bodies are monitored by the Environment Agency (England), Natural Resources Wales and the Scottish Environment Protection Agency. Public water supplies (this includes water from taps) are monitored by the Drinking Water Inspectorate (England and Wales) and the Drinking Water Quality Regulator for Scotland.","Yes","No","Owen Boswarva","Danny Lämmerhirt","85","85"
"14d1e14e-bd27-4e08-ac23-177c820e47cb","global","2017-06-15T11:29:41","2016","nl","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to the index of 2015, to the KvK website, searched around the site a bit"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Kamer van Koophandel"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.kvk.nl/producten-bestellen/bedrijfsprofiel/"",""descValue"":""Bedrijfsprofiel""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Corrected after the public dialogue phase",". Data are available for free online on the Chamber of Commerce (Kamer van Koophandel) Company Profile (Bedrijfsprofiel) webpage. However, they are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name, Chamber of Commerce number, or address of an entity in order to find it. One needs to click on the ""Order"" button in order to be redirected to the ""Search"" feature. Results include Company name, Address, Chamber of Commerce number, and Settlement (Vestigings) number but whether these are up to date is not known. Data are given in .HTML format and cannot be downloaded at once. One has the option of buying Company Profile information for between € 2.65 and € 9.50. The price you pay depends on the number of parts available for that company. You will receive at least the information from the excerpt and where available also history, filings, corporate relationships and up to 3 standard accounting. You can only order the Company through a Commercial Account. To complete your order you need to log in the next step with your access code. After checkout you will see the Company directly to your screen. The Chamber of Commerce retains all intellectual property rights and other rights with respect to all or via this website (including all texts, graphics and logos). It is not permitted to copy information on this site, download or in any way publish, distribute or reproduce without the prior written consent of the Chamber of Commerce or the appropriate consent of the owner. You may print and / or download information on this website for your own personal use.","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","15","15"
"d78bf015-4f71-423c-861c-dd908abade33","global","2017-06-15T08:33:38","2016","nl","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Land registry"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Based on comments from the public dialogue ","This category is looking for tenure type and property value. Both are not available in the Netherlands due to privacy regulations in the Netherlands. Parcel Boundaries are available here: https://data.overheid.nl/data/dataset/kadastrale-kaart-01","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","0","0"
"e54a5475-164e-42d0-8fe2-791d534e546c","global","2017-06-15T08:21:47","2016","nl","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""WFS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Someone had to send a forum message about it "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.overheid.nl/licenties-voor-hergebruik"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Land Registry "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Zipcodes"",""Addresses"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Data available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.overheid.nl/data/dataset/adressen-inspire-geharmoniseerd/resource/13d0f25e-b97a-491f-8d47-a8bf0031883d"",""descValue"":""Open Data Portal ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This was changed as part of the public dialogue phase","This was changed based on the comments we got from OpenState. See here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1dlNq3x5Y0rmUCmADk3nqZICk_Og9V0gLbcXj_L497m0/edit#gid=0","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","100","100"
"1a884de8-3885-4254-842e-ee5c9ebbefb5","global","2017-06-15T00:56:59","2016","us","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Only one of the resources has an open license""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""This is an updated after the Public Dialogue"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal Business Oportunities"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://catalog.data.gov/dataset/federal-business-opportunities-data"",""descValue"":""GSA list of FedBizOppps""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.fbo.gov/?s=opportunity&mode=list&tab=list"",""descValue"":""List of all the available opportunities with Federal Government.""},{""urlValue"":""ftp://ftp.fbo.gov/datagov/FBOFullXML.xml"",""descValue"":""Feed for all available opportunities""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This changes are made after the Public Dialogue phase. Full entry is here https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-procurement-us/5206",,"Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","80","80"
"7ac03fdd-3537-4418-a842-dfabe3babdca","global","2017-06-15T00:53:33","2016","ua","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""This is an update after the Public Dialoge"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.rada.gov.ua/open/main/index"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Verkhovna Rada"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.ua/passport/0d856776-5185-441e-9b0c-933eb61bc8f0"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.rada.gov.ua/open/data/doc"",""descValue"":""Open Data portal of Verkhovna rada""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.rada.gov.ua/ogd/zak/laws/readme.txt"",""descValue"":""Algorithm of generating links to texts""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This is an update after the Public Dialogue phase. Full conversation is here https://discuss.okfn.org/t/revised-entry-for-national-laws-ukraine/5171",,"Yes","Yes","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"524dc206-50df-46ee-8c9b-78644a5cf0f9","global","2017-06-15T00:42:17","2016","ua","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""This is an update based on the Public Dialogue phase"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ukraine State Service of Geodesy, Cartography and Cadastre"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Parcel boundaries (inc. latitude and longitude)"",""Parcel ID"",""Property value (i.e. Price Paid, Property Tax Value)"",""Tenure Type (ie. leasehold, freehold, protected lands, public lands, customary lands)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://map.land.gov.ua/kadastrova-karta"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","the data is accessible only as access-controlled data, which is not entirely machine-readable (hence answered ""no"" in our survey), is not for free (property value must be paid), therefore also not openly licensed (since this contradicts one core requirement of open licensing, namely that ""The license must not impose any fee arrangement, royalty, or other compensation or monetary remuneration as part of its conditions""), not downloadable at once (not downloadable at all).",,"Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","30","30"
"7276100b-d6eb-4e38-8ef6-3c72003aec7f","global","2017-06-04T21:01:58","2016","ua","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""State Treasury Service of Ukraine (A joint project between Treasury service and ministry of finance)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The data on ttp://spending.gov.ua/web/guest or here - https://api.e-data.gov.ua:8080/api/rest/1.0/transactions is in aggregated level and is not transactional data level. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"d655e8d0-1c46-48ea-bef8-7cab81d5aded","global","2017-06-04T17:42:59","2016","tt","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"This is a correction to a previous submission. Data in this URL - https://www.finance.gov.tt/expenditure-2017/ is not transactional level data but estimates and do not fit the criteria. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"7b78c729-0d4d-4188-ad1e-55e5f6b28753","global","2017-03-22T07:10:02","2016","tw","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""KML"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""search on Taiwan's open data portal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.tw/license#eng"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of the Interior"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Parcel boundaries (inc. latitude and longitude)"",""Parcel ID"",""Property value (i.e. Price Paid, Property Tax Value)"",""Tenure Type (ie. leasehold, freehold, protected lands, public lands, customary lands)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.tw/node/34315"",""descValue"":""The land information includes about 20 fields, including the border, number of land, land area, type, use area, landowners and so on.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This entry has been modified after the Public Dialogue phase. Entry is here https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-land-tw/5349",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"e30b452c-c9fe-4564-a23d-a4aa3c06d7d1","global","2017-06-04T21:31:40","2016","th","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bureau of the budget The Comptroller General's Department Office of Public Sector Anti-Corruption Commission (PACC) Electronic Government Agency (Public Organization) (EGA)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"According to the forum - https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-spending-th/5395/3 this website (https://govspending.data.go.th/) is based on estimates and not transaction level data","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"8cc24217-e335-4ab9-bc53-e04fbe15c588","global","2017-03-23T07:09:52","2016","tw","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""These data are Map Tiles in format of JPG and MBTiles.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search on Taiwan's open data portal with the key word \""Taiwan e-Map(臺灣通用電子地圖)\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.tw/license#eng"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of the Interior"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.tw/node/24888"",""descValue"":""National Map Tiles""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.tw/node/33384"",""descValue"":""National Map MBTiles""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","These changes were added after the Public Dialogue. Full dialogue here https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-map-tw/5388","The location of Taiwan national map open data is at https://data.gov.tw/node/24888.
The data is available in bulk and it's also in an open format.
At the same time, the information aboved also links to https://data.gov.tw/node/17214.","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"bfb683fb-098d-42de-9f0b-a864f90aee3e","global","2017-06-04T17:37:09","2016","ch","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Swiss Federal Statistics Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"This is a correction to the previous submission. Data is aggregated and does not fit the criteria. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"43635bc1-ee42-4068-ab29-5687cefc74c2","global","2017-03-07T04:19:06","2016","sg","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Singapore Elections Department"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission since not all required data is available. Data available (https://www.eld.gov.sg/elections_past_results.html / https://data.gov.sg/dataset/presidential-election-results) in Presidential elections 2011, Parliamentary elections 2015 and Parliamentary By-elections 2016 results only represent results for major electoral contests. On the data.gov.sg site it is possible to see major results by constituency, and results are machine-readable and formatted for easy reuse. Submitter notes that previously, the information was available only on the webpage of the Singapore Elections Department (https://www.eld.gov.sg/) in HTML format, which required users to scrape and reformat before they could use the data.
The process to find the data it’s pretty straightforward. As submitter notes, in Singapore, number of votes at constituency level is equivalent to that at polling station level. Data is open licensed: https://data.gov.sg/open-data-licence. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"bcaca769-32cc-4a60-a244-6ad6481c80c5","global","2017-03-20T19:44:37","2016","sg","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Singapore Land Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","https://www.onemap.sg/index.html ","Singapore has a very good geoportal with a significant amount of information, even thought not under un open license. However, I have not been able to find relief related data anywhere. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"45ceed6c-111a-476d-a0df-f36411ea766e","global","2017-06-04T18:12:25","2016","vc","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"This is a correction to a previous submission. Data on the ministry website is high level aggregated data that does not fit the criteria. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"1c9c0521-be3e-4f08-a664-e5294f7f4403","global","2017-06-04T21:32:48","2016","lc","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Data here - https://data.govt.lc/dataset/expenditure
is aggregated and not in transactional level ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"cd7353b2-5884-4ebe-8941-abbe777f4c52","global","2017-06-04T20:44:27","2016","kn","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Data does not exist online. Only estimates can be found. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"6f4cfd87-8637-4f34-968e-f96a68bea869","global","2017-06-15T00:21:53","2016","ro","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""This is an update based on the Public Dialogue phase"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.ro/base/images/logoinst/OGL-ROU-1.0.pdf"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Romanian Permanent Electoral Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.roaep.ro/istoric/"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This is an updated entry based on Public Dialoge, the full entry is here https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-elections-ro/5232",,"Yes","Yes","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"0118a049-8c75-4d0b-b4a3-97c9150163a9","global","2016-12-29T22:00:56","2016","mx","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""KML"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The data could be downloaded (initially ) in PDF, GIF, TIFF, JPEG. \nAnother option is: that the user can draw their own polygon and download it in KML format. But this is an advanced option; not by default the country polygon""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""According to https://discuss.okfn.org/t/joint-request-to-adjust-mexico-2016-godi-submissions/4439""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled \""Mapa Mexico\"" and I found it ranked at the top"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.inegi.org.mx/terminos/terminos_info.aspx"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""INEGI (National Institute of Statistics, Geography and Informatics)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://gaia.inegi.org.mx/mdm6"",""descValue"":""Mapa Digital de México""},{""urlValue"":""datos.gob.mx/busca/dataset/red-nacional-de-caminos"",""descValue"":""roads""},{""urlValue"":""datos.gob.mx/busca/dataset/cuerpos-de-agua"",""descValue"":""water""},{""urlValue"":""inegi.org.mx/geo/contenidos/geoestadistica/M_Geoestadistico.aspx"",""descValue"":""national borders ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Enrique Zapata for his contribution.",,"Yes","No","Sergio Araiza","Codrina Maria Ilie","85","85"
"17e51cbd-a9a3-47b0-aa79-b89b1f4bf806","global","2017-04-04T15:28:22","2016","mx","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Mexicos Open Data Repository->Search for Air Quality."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://datos.gob.mx/libreusomx"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Nacional de Ecología y Cambio Climático"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://datos.gob.mx/busca/dataset/calidad-del-aire"",""descValue"":""Mexico's Open Data Repository""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Data is not updated. Only historical data available from different states and cities in separated datasets.
Thank you to the original submitter Ricardo Alanís","Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","85","85"
"69e4e7a4-fbd7-4b41-b560-37aa9f0ec180","global","2016-12-05T08:22:49","2016","ro","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""menus from ministry of finance site"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.mfinante.ro/copyright.html?pagina=copyright"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.mfinante.ro"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Finance Website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mfinante.ro/buget2016.html?pagina=domenii"",""descValue"":""Budget 2016""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mfinante.gov.ro/execbug.html?pagina=buletin"",""descValue"":""Implemented Budget + excel ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept, the implemented budget is provided in excel files, but the current budget law is only in PDF. ",,"Yes","Yes","Cristian Balulescu","Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"3035d266-ec34-48c1-acc6-7c0c25912bd9","global","2017-06-14T23:59:44","2016","ro","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""browse on parliament chambers sites"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://legislatie.just.ro/Public/Termeni"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Chamber of Deputies - Legislative Council, Ministry of Justice"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.cdep.ro/pls/legis/legis_pck.frame"",""descValue"":""Chamber of Deputies website - Legislative Repertoire""},{""urlValue"":""https://legislatie.just.ro/Public/Acasa"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Justice - Legal Portal""},{""urlValue"":""https://legislatie.just.ro/ServiciulWebLegislatie.htm"",""descValue"":""Law API""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","Yes","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"44e42fff-e1e1-4368-87cd-64d2dd31f09d","global","2017-06-14T23:54:35","2016","pl","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""JSON"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google search for \""zamówienia publiczne\"" shows UZP as one of the first results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Urząd Zamówień Publicznych (UZP, Public Procurement Office)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://bzp0.portal.uzp.gov.pl/?ogloszenie=browser"",""descValue"":""central bulletin available online where all contracting processes are posted""},{""urlValue"":""https://websrv.bzp.uzp.gov.pl/BZP_PublicWebService.asmx"",""descValue"":""Procurement API""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This is an updated entry after the Public Dialogue phase. Full entry is here https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-procurement-pl/5333/6",,"Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","80","80"
"35771e6d-e9c4-4910-ba8b-a79fdce109c8","global","2017-06-14T23:49:36","2016","py","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Industria y Comercio"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data is available here https://www.set.gov.py/portal/PARAGUAY-SET/InformesPeriodicos?folder-id=repository:collaboration:/sites/PARAGUAY-SET/categories/SET/Informes%20Periodicos/listado-de-ruc-con-sus-equivalencias but it's not fully compliant so won't be considered",,"Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"8a8af527-63a5-4386-84a5-b0b5ed002ae8","global","2017-03-14T20:20:34","2016","pr","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Centro de Recaudación de Ingresos Municipales"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Jacobo Orenstein for the contribution.","Some data available might be available at https://www.satasgis.crimpr.net/cdprpc/. However, the site is not currently working. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"60c84859-c728-4aca-a4b7-780d7f131dd2","global","2016-12-14T17:36:04","2016","pr","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":"" At the bottom of the first website there are links to \""Politica de privacidad\"" and \""Terminos y condiciones\"". You would expect one of these links to lead to licencing information, but they just return you to the same webpage. The second website has no specification as to licensing or whether the data is in the Public Domain.\n""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Used search engine to find \""Comision Estatal de Elecciones\"" website. Clicked on pop-up about 2016 election results. Clicked on \""Escrutinio General\"". On resulting webpage, on left sidebar, clicked on \""Actas por Precinto, Unidad y Colegio\"", then clicked on \""Actas\"". This led me to the second webpage."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Procedure is not obvious. You have to explore quite a bit to get to the second website.\n""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""There is no statement as to licensing information of results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no statement as to licensing information of data.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Comision Estatal de Elecciones - State Electoral Commission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://ww2.ceepur.org"",""descValue"":""Official State Electoral Commission website""},{""urlValue"":""https://elecciones2016.ceepur.org/Escrutinio_General_77/index.html#es/reportdefault/Actas.xml"",""descValue"":""Drop down menus provide 2016 electoral results down to the level of individual polling stations""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The first website provides access to the second website, but finding the latter is not obvious.""}]","Yes","Yes","By request of submitter, information was updated in several categories, with the only difference that the datasets do not include description of spoiled votes, but only null or invalid votes. Also, on format, submitter requested it would be included the XML format, but the data is available only through HTML format, which was included.
As the submitter notes, finding the second elections data website does not have an obvious route. As for public domain, there are links to ""Politica de privacidad"" and ""Terminos y condiciones"", which usually contain this sort of information but they return to the homepage. These pages were also non existent through Google search queries. Historical data (1923-2001) (https://209.68.12.238/consulta.html) contain a “All rights reserved” disclaimer by the end of the webpage. ","The second website provides electoral results for the Puerto Rico's recent 2016 election. The first website can provide electoral information about previous elections.","Yes","No","Jacobo Orenstein","Paola Mosso","45","45"
"2face610-7f4c-44eb-aa97-12da79fe67ca","global","2017-06-04T20:45:50","2016","pk","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The data is aggregated and does not fit the criteria. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"c7adef3d-ec7f-4ea2-adcf-068e9b027e7e","global","2017-06-04T17:39:26","2016","om","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance Oman"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"This is a correction to a previous submission. Data in this link https://www.mof.gov.om/التقارير-المالية/الحساب-الختامي-للدولة is not transactional data and therefore does not fit the criteria ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"823d2b9b-ae1c-4f27-83f1-405c410b40c7","global","2016-12-14T17:58:32","2016","pr","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""You can email support@estado.pr.gov to request datasets.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data are available for free through a search mask by entering an entity's name or register number.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I used a readily available Internet search engine."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""There is no statement as to licensing information of data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no statement as to licensing information of data.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Departamento de Estado de Puerto Rico - Puerto Rico Department of State"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://prcorpfiling.f1hst.com/"",""descValue"":""The Puerto Rico Department of State - Registry of Corporations and Entities website""},{""urlValue"":""https://prcorpfiling.f1hst.com/CorporationSearch.aspx"",""descValue"":""Corporations and Entities Search""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The Puerto Rico Department of State - Registry of Corporations and Entities website offers a Corporations and Entities Search feature where one can find company information for free by entering an entity's name or register number. Results include Registry number, Corporation Name, Class, Profit, Status, and once an entity's name is selected, Street and Mailing Address are also given.
However, update frequency is not known and there is an announcement that the ""Puerto Rico Department of State"" does not warrant or guarantee the accuracy of information presented by this service. More specifically, ""The content presented through this Portal is supplied by agencies and public corporations of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico. Each of these agencies and corporations is solely responsible to ensure the currency, reliability, accuracy and veracity of the information they provide. The administrator of this Portal is not responsible for, and does not guarantee, updating, reliability, accuracy and veracity of the information contained herein."" Data cannot be downloaded in bulk and another announcement informs that ""the content presented by this Registry is ‘Public Information’ and the online services are intended for interactive participation. We reserve the right to block access to the site if we detect automated bulk data gathering tools. For business need of structured data feeds, please contact support@estado.pr.gov."" Finally, the Portal contains information that is protected by copyright and author moral rights (https://estado.pr.gov/en/terms-of-use/).","A notification states that you can obtain bulk data by emailing support@estado.pr.gov..","Yes","No","Jacobo Orenstein","Evangelia Kampouri","15","15"
"a659a168-51e1-42e7-b557-0ac143304cb1","global","2017-04-03T20:23:58","2016","pr","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Agency budget webpage states at the bottom Copyright © 2013 Estado Libre Asociado de Puerto Rico. But, individual agency reports do not mention any type of copyright.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Individual agency reports are in .htm format. Isn't this an open data format?""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Readily available searching on popular search engine. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Oficina de Gerencia y Presupuesto - Office of Management and Budget"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www2.pr.gov/presupuestos/PresupuestoAprobado2016-2017/Pages/PRESUPUESTO-POR-AGENCIA.aspx"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Isn't .htm or .html an open data format?","Yes","No","Jacobo Orenstein","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"7ca97685-7398-43c6-9a7f-4c2fd7513fca","global","2017-06-14T23:35:32","2016","py","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""This is an update based on the Public Dialogue"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://datos.congreso.gov.py/opendata/avisolegal;jsessionid=8f695eeac1b8abd8754ef9db946c"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""SILpy - SISTEMA DE INFORMACIÓN LEGISLATIVA"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://sil2py.diputados.gov.py/"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://datos.congreso.gov.py/opendata/api"",""descValue"":""API with projects""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This is an update based on the Public Dialogue phase. Full entry is here https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-draftlegislation-py-incorrect-in-2017/5179/3",,"Yes","Yes","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"92c706af-aeb3-4a48-8c66-d05a673be820","global","2017-06-14T23:33:17","2016","nl","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched, could not find it find for long time, looked into last year's GODI. Data was corrected in the public dialogue"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Economy"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.tenderned.nl/over-tenderned/datasets-aanbestedingen"",""descValue"":""TenderNed is part of PIANOo, the Procurement Expertise of the Ministry of Economic Affairs""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.overheid.nl/data/dataset/https-www-tenderned-nl-over-tenderned-open-data/resource/66df5de7-e56b-4498-8cc1-be5ce8bd048d"",""descValue"":""Dutch portal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This was modified based on the forum comment and the spreadsheet that was attached to it - https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1dlNq3x5Y0rmUCmADk3nqZICk_Og9V0gLbcXj_L497m0/edit#gid=0","Data for the portal is in CC00, but the actual updated data says the following:
16. Intellectual Property Rights
The (intellectual property) rights to TenderNed, including the rights to the texts, images, design, data files, photos and other (still and / or moving) images, audio material, formats, software, brands (including brand TenderNed and TenderNed domain) and other materials owned by the Dutch State. The use of the logo or other rights is permitted only after prior written consent of PIANOo , the management organization of TenderNed.
Therefore it is not openly licensed. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","80","80"
"c384a3ee-36e9-4667-a570-aeb659477c2b","global","2017-06-14T23:29:53","2016","no","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""This is an update based on "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Norwegian Directorate of Elections"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://valgresultat.no/resources/xlsx/valgresultater-2015.xlsx"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This entry was updated after the Public Dialogue phase. Full discussion is here https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-election-results-norway/5412",,"Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","65","65"
"91cbac30-f2d1-49da-939d-dcf1e35271ee","global","2017-06-04T20:53:02","2016","uy","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Agencia de Compras y Contrataciones del Estado"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted","According to the forum thread: https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-spending-uy/5223 Data is not available in a transactional level. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","0","0"
"f2eddfb5-cb42-421a-912a-4ab70d2193f2","global","2017-06-14T23:15:44","2016","no","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""JSON""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""API available""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Centre of Air Pollution Modelling"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.luftkvalitet.info/omnettstedet.aspx"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This entry was updated after Dialogue Phase, full discussion here https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-emissions-no/5427/4",,"Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","65","65"
"9c26ef36-2ce5-4493-9338-c0b43e860a2c","global","2017-06-14T23:16:32","2016","nz","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched for \""New Zealand laws\"", this site was the first result. Searched for \""data set of all New Zealand laws\"", was directed to data.govt.nz and then a URL to the XML feed."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.legislation.govt.nz/about.aspx#copyright"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Parliamentary Counsel Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.legislation.govt.nz/subscribe"",""descValue"":""New Zealand Legislation""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.govt.nz/dataset/show/776"",""descValue"":""New Zealand Legislation on New Zealand Open Data Catalogue""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This was changed after the comments on the public dialogue phase. ",,"Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","85","85"
"88e7342f-2467-484e-8fb3-c2e0df461a07","global","2017-06-14T23:14:59","2016","nz","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I entered the search \""NZ bills\"" into Google and the top result took me to the NZ Parliament webpage which gives details of all bill before the Parllament, which Minister or Member of Parliament introduced each, and its stage in the legislative process. This linked me to the full text of the bill on the legislation.govt.nz site"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/1994/0143/latest/DLM345939.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Parliamentary Counsel Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.parliament.nz/en/pb/bills-and-laws/bills-proposed-laws/"",""descValue"":""NZ Parliament online page for proposed bills""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.legislation.govt.nz/bill/results.aspx?search=ta_bill_A_bc%40bcur_an%40bn%40rn_25_a&p=1"",""descValue"":""Parliamentary Counsel office, mostly laws however some bills data is available""},{""urlValue"":""ttp://www.legislation.govt.nz/subscribe/"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This was change after the public dialogue phase",,"Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","85","85"
"92715a71-4364-419e-910d-f7895612be72","global","2017-06-14T23:12:07","2016","no","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to Geonorge.no, and tried to find a dataset matching the criteria."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/no/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Norwegian Mapping Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.geonorge.no/"",""descValue"":""Geonorge.no - geodata-portal for Norway""},{""urlValue"":""https://kartkatalog.geonorge.no/metadata/kartverket/n250-kartdata/442cae64-b447-478d-b384-545bc1d9ab48"",""descValue"":""N250 map data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Entry modified based on the Public Dialoge. Full thread is here https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-national-maps-norway/4461/7",,"Yes","Yes","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"8cdbcf0a-84e8-4c54-a8b2-6f7a7d68c316","global","2017-06-04T17:35:48","2016","nir","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Finance, UK Treasury (all NI departments)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Actual expenditure data from the Northern Ireland Executive is available through the UK Treasury OSCAR database https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/hmt-oscar-publishing-from-the-database, however, this is not the same as transaction-level expenditure.","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"3b4972e6-dc99-4830-a676-e645293551c2","global","2017-06-04T18:09:51","2016","np","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance, Nepal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"This is a correction to a previous submission. Data in this URL - https://mof.gov.np/en/content/mof-link-pages-9.html is not transactional level data but an aggregated one and does not fit the criteria. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"eea14c14-5f23-4bd8-ba24-d19e35d44d4e","global","2017-06-04T17:32:45","2016","na","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance of Namibia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"This is a correction to the previous submission. Data from the Ministry of Finance this link - https://www.mof.gov.na/older-budget-documents is not transactional level data ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"60c07a67-c8cf-460b-9db8-d55bc9edb4e0","global","2017-06-04T18:11:11","2016","mz","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Republic of Mozambique Ministry of Economics and Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"This is a correction to a previous submission. Data in on the ministry website is not transactional level data but an aggregated one and does not fit the criteria. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"8ba847d2-9648-4c6b-af73-b7f2a3fd78a6","global","2017-03-22T14:23:27","2016","mx","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Directorio de Unidades Económicas bulk in datos.gob.mx"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.inegi.org.mx/inegi/contenidos/espanol/acerca/condiciones.asp?c=492 and https://datos.gob.mx/libreusomx"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""INEGI"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www3.inegi.org.mx/sistemas/descarga/"",""descValue"":""National Institute of Statistics and Geography - National Statistical Directory of Economic Units""},{""urlValue"":""https://datos.gob.mx/busca/dataset/bulk-de-denue"",""descValue"":""Bulk download for DENUE""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data is true and was verified in the public dialogue phase: https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-company-register-mexico/4760","In this comment I am providing the link to the bulk download of the DENUE, available in datos.gob.mx
https://datos.gob.mx/busca/dataset/bulk-de-denue ","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","85","85"
"95c8aa9f-95b2-4488-8d13-8e60685b8065","global","2017-06-04T20:49:00","2016","my","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Accountant General's Department of Malaysia and National Audit Department"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Previous submission referred to this - https://www.audit.gov.my/index.php/laporan . Data is aggregated and therefore not fit the criteria. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"3deb4126-a7de-4e6a-82ae-0c03bb8a370f","global","2017-06-04T17:41:16","2016","mw","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Republic of Malawi The Ministry of Finance, Economic Planning & Development"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"This is a correction to a previous submission. Data in this URL - https://www.finance.gov.mw/index.php/data-a-statistics is not transactional level data but an aggregated one and does not fit the criteria. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"9566d8ff-451d-40e3-ba36-adae4ad7f1c3","global","2017-06-14T23:02:52","2016","mx","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""TXT"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""The INEGI site has everything ordered by subject, I just need to decide where to go and how disaggregated I want the data to be."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.inegi.org.mx/terminos/terminos_info.aspx and https://datos.gob.mx/libreusomx"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""INEGI and the National Comisssion on Population"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://datos.gob.mx/busca/dataset/proyecciones-de-la-poblacion-de-mexico/resource/08070f55-0a97-48fb-bfe9-e8a6c33a7f28"",""descValue"":""The datasets specified are related to the 'National Population Census' which in most countries is done every 5 or 10 years because of its costs. Nonetheless, Mexico DOES officialy release current population statistics as 'Demographic indicators'. This dataset is released by the National Population Comission, the entity officialy in charge of making demographic statistics in Mexico.""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.inegi.org.mx/sistemas/bie/cuadrosestadisticos/GeneraCuadro.aspx?"",""descValue"":""Indicadores macroeconómicos de coyuntura Producto interno bruto trimestral a precios constantes según actividad""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.inegi.org.mx/sistemas/bie/cuadrosestadisticos/GeneraCuadro.aspx?s=est&nc=621&c=25447"",""descValue"":""Tasa de desocupación nacional (unemployment data)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www3.inegi.org.mx/sistemas/temas/default.aspx?s=est&c=17484"",""descValue"":""Indicadores de demografía y población (population data)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.inegi.org.mx/sistemas/bie/cuadrosestadisticos/GeneraCuadro.aspx?s=est&nc=492&c=23920"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""There is an alternative link - https://datos.gob.mx/busca/dataset/proyecciones-de-la-poblacion-de-mexico"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This was reviewed and changed according to the forum post in the public dialogue - https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-national-statistics-mexico/4898",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","100","100"
"fb538734-fb16-4ec1-a312-150e69131c51","global","2017-03-21T22:58:48","2016","mx","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""TXT"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search for election results in the National Electoral Institute website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Nacional Electoral"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://siceef.ife.org.mx/pef2012/SICEEF2012.html#"",""descValue"":""National Electoral Information System""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.mx/archivos2/portal/Elecciones/PEF/2014-2015/"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The reviewer comments states that
'Rejected submission since not all required data is available. Data available (https://www.ine.mx/archivos2/portal/Elecciones/PEF/2014-2015/#resultados) include results for major electoral contests, registered votes and invalid votes, but no information on spoiled ballots. Data is up to date, available in HTML and CSV, downloadable at once for each election. Historical data also available: https://www.ine.mx/archivos3/portal/historico/contenido/Historico_de_Resultados_Electorales/'
In this sense I would like to clarify that the normative translation for 'spoiled ballots' to Mexico is 'Voto Nulo (More info on the treatment of spoiled ballots in Mexico here: https://www.ine.mx/docs/IFE-v2/DECEYEC/DECEYEC-MaterialesLectura/docs/03_VotoNulo.pdf).
In this regard the two links provided with electoral information provide data on 'Voto Nulo', and the cases in which the electoral authority can determine a vote as invalid: eg. vote for two or more candidates, votes for no candidate, ballot is mutilated or incomplete,
Also in the National Electoral Information System, once a search by district is done, users can find an 'observations' column, which states the unique ID of Challenges to specific ballot stations.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Oscar Montiel","80","80"
"c1344b04-601f-4fe9-8743-00d75c1de56f","global","2017-03-22T19:53:12","2016","mx","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""JSON""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search for 'Pronostico del clima por municipio' in datos.gob.mx"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://datos.gob.mx/libreusomx"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""SMN/CONAGUA"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Precipitation Probability"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://datos.gob.mx/busca/dataset/pronosticos-del-tiempo-por-municipios/resource/3156977b-3460-450b-9c13-c64d680a0e1b"",""descValue"":""Web Service that allows to obtain the data of the current forecast by cities, with detailed meteorological information by municipality (temperature, rain, humidity, pressure, cloudiness, direction and speed of the wind, etc.) in compressed json format, the Information is updated every hour fifteen minutes.""},{""urlValue"":""https://smn.cna.gob.mx/es/pronosticos/pronosticossubmenu/pronostico-meteorologico-general"",""descValue"":""SMN, 1-day forecasts available in written text""},{""urlValue"":""https://smn.cna.gob.mx/es/pronostico-del-tiempo-por-municipios"",""descValue"":""SMN, 7-day forecasts in numerical and iconic form (contains all required data)""},{""urlValue"":""https://datos.gob.mx/busca/dataset/pronosticos/resource/756d8f04-0a63-465b-bbd1-84401331662c"",""descValue"":""Data.gob.mx, archive of forecasts (updated a month before review)""},{""urlValue"":""https://smn.cna.gob.mx/es/pronosticos/pronosticossubmenu/pronostico-extendido-a-96-horas"",""descValue"":""Precipitation, downloadable as PDF""},{""urlValue"":""https://smn.cna.gob.mx/es/pronosticos/pronosticossubmenu/pronostico-extendido-a-96-horas"",""descValue"":""4-day forecast for temperature, wind speed, and precipitation amount""},{""urlValue"":""datos.gob.mx/busca/dataset/temperatura-maxima-excel"",""descValue"":""Historical temperature extremes (observations)""},{""urlValue"":""datos.gob.mx/busca/dataset/temperatura-promedio-excel"",""descValue"":""Historical temperature averages (observations)""},{""urlValue"":""datos.gob.mx/busca/dataset/hidrometeorologia"",""descValue"":""Open Data Portal, Precipitation Forecast (7 days)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The data has been updated but won't be considered for this edition of GODI since the resource wasn't available in bulk before the GODI was closed.
Data is ‘openly licensed’, ‘open and machine readable formats’ and ‘downloadable at once’ dimensions, based on the following comments:
1) The right dataset for weather forecast can be found here: https://datos.gob.mx/busca/dataset/pronosticos-del-tiempo-por-municipios1 ","Comment in response to the reviewers comment 'The review takes following dataset as reference, because it meets the dataset requirements: https://smn.cna.gob.mx/es/pronostico-del-tiempo-por-municipios. The content is not downloadable, and there is no copyright note on the website that would explain whether the data is openly licensed. '
The dataset is available as open data in https://datos.gob.mx/busca/dataset/pronosticos-del-tiempo-por-municipios
This API is openly licensed and meets all the requirements asked by the GODI. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Oscar Montiel","65","65"
"7ea15688-9af2-43f0-a7c3-a6e46c0426c8","global","2017-06-14T22:40:04","2016","fi","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON"",""PX"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""It's all available from Statistics Finland web page."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.stat.fi/org/lainsaadanto/copyright_en.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Statistics Finland"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.stat.fi/index_en.html "",""descValue"":""Statistics Finland""},{""urlValue"":""https://pxnet2.stat.fi/PXWeb/pxweb/en/StatFin/StatFin__tym__tyti/?tablelist=true#_ga=1.155577341.758652768.1487797244"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://pxnet2.stat.fi/PXWeb/pxweb/en/StatFin/StatFin__vrm/?rxid=5255379d-119e-4e24-b4ec-44813230bae2"",""descValue"":""Population data (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://pxnet2.stat.fi/PXWeb/pxweb/en/StatFin/StatFin__kan__vtp/?tablelist=true#_ga=1.151038591.758652768.1487797244"",""descValue"":""GDP data (English)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This data was corrected according to a submission from the public dialogue phase- https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-national-statistics-finland/5467","Data is up-to-date according to the revisions of the reivsions of the national statistics data - https://tilastokeskus.fi/til/ntp/rev.html#_ga=2.73492561.2145767376.1495560696-1114078735.1495560012","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","100","100"
"3d690b4b-c92d-43b4-94b1-6c40997054dc","global","2017-06-14T22:36:33","2016","fi","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Got a lead from OKI Forum"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.fi"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" population register Center"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Zipcodes"",""Addresses"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Data available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.avoindata.fi/data/fi/dataset/rakennusten-osoitetiedot-koko-suomi"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This is based and checked as part of the public dialogue phase. Files were in OPT and were not machine readable. ","This is a correction based on this forum thread - https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-locations-finland/5471/2","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","80","80"
"5184728e-96d9-43b8-a1bb-ce052c91a066","global","2017-06-04T20:37:30","2016","ko","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"This is a correction of the original submission. Data from the Ministry of Finance is not available in transactional level ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"a3acbc4f-1bad-49bc-988c-e7d856ab911e","global","2017-06-04T21:35:08","2016","ke","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Treasury and KENAO, Office of the Auditor General, Office of the Controller of Budget"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Reports here - https://cob.go.ke/national-government/ are aggregated and not in transactional level data","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"fc5f8e58-9dba-45a1-a57f-51f69bcaa5ed","global","2017-06-14T22:30:48","2016","in","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Googled Union Budget data for India"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.in/sites/default/files/Gazette_Notification_OGDL.pdf"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://indiabudget.nic.in/glance.asp"",""descValue"":""The Ministry of Finance posts the budget here""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.in/keywords/union-budget"",""descValue"":""It can also be found on the open data portal but delayed""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This entry was updated based on the Public Dialogue, entry can be found here https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-budget-in/5433",,"Yes","Yes","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"4303d9ec-4a41-4ae1-8d0e-b437af87fd86","global","2017-06-14T22:24:23","2016","in","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""went to the Ministry website; searched statistics on data.gov.in"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.in/sites/default/files/Gazette_Notification_OGDL.pdf"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Statistics & Programme Implementation"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.in/catalogs#path=sector/statistics-9382"",""descValue"":""Open data portal statistics catalog""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mospi.gov.in/download-tables-data"",""descValue"":""Ministry site for data""},{""urlValue"":""https://164.100.34.62/index.php/home"",""descValue"":""Micro data""},{""urlValue"":""https://censusindia.gov.in/"",""descValue"":""Census data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mospi.gov.in/"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Statistics & Programme Implementation""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This entry was updated after the Public Dialogue phase with entries that appear [here](https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-statistics-in/5435)",,"Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","70","70"
"ab2e49ff-0ab3-4926-aa41-bb24984d6976","global","2017-06-14T22:20:58","2016","in","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Central Pollution control board has links on page. Search of air quality in open data portal will bring up data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.in/sites/default/files/Gazette_Notification_OGDL.pdf"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Central Pollution Control Board"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.cpcb.gov.in/CAAQM/Auth/frmViewReportNew.aspx"",""descValue"":""Department database""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.in/search/site/air%20quality"",""descValue"":""Open data portal air quality""},{""urlValue"":""https://cpcbenvis.nic.in/airpollution/air%20data%202011-2007/AIRTAB.html"",""descValue"":""Air quality from department website""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This entry was updated after the Public Dialogue phase. Discussion can be found here https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-emissions-in/5432",,"Yes","Yes","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"9fa388d2-1edf-479c-9e9e-d95601096b4f","global","2017-06-14T22:16:06","2016","in","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""It is collected by state and local agencies no the central government."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data is not available in the format we look for but we were pointed to resources that go in that direction.
>Land registration is a State Subject according to Constitution of India. However, under e-Governance initiative, the Central government has put in lot of resources to ensure that all land records are computerized at state level, which are in advanced stages of implementation. Links to the land records system/websites of the states i.e. Goa: https://egov.goa.nic.in/dslr/f114new.aspx; Odisha : https://bhulekh.ori.nic.in/; Uttarakhand : https://devbhoomi.uk.gov.in/; Uttar Pradesh : https://upbhulekh.gov.in/public/public_ror/Public_ROR.jsp; Madhya Pradesh : https://landrecords.mp.gov.in/newweb/index.html; Gujarat : https://anyror.gujarat.gov.in/; Rajasthan : https://apnakhata.raj.nic.in/; Tamil Nadu :https://eservices.tn.gov.in/eservicesnew/index.html; Karnataka : https://bhoomi.karnataka.gov.in
Public dialogue can be found [here](https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-land-in/5424)
",,"Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"be44dc66-9137-487f-9609-4061b4b0ca08","global","2017-06-04T20:43:19","2016","id","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Data is aggregated and does not fit the criteria. The data, therefore, does not fit the criteria. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"f4f4dc6a-f012-43a8-8430-221d7bbbeaba","global","2017-06-04T20:41:42","2016","in","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Comptroller and Auditor General"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"This is a correction based on the forum thread - https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-spending-in/5434
Data is not in transactional data and aggregated, and therefore does not fit the criteria ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"6aa37ad4-0603-44a6-8ef4-280991831b0a","global","2017-06-14T22:03:42","2016","in","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This is an update based on the Public Dialogue""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""This is and update based on "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Election Commission of India"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://eci.nic.in/eci_main1/ElectionStatistics.aspx"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data doesn't meet the characteristics being assessed but the data that is available can be used with a complying license. ","Rejected submission because not all required data is available. By-elections (https://eci.nic.in/eci_main1/bye_elec_results_2016.html): general results, registered and rejected votes. As for General Election to Legislative Results, as submitter noted, we can only access general results, by electoral zone (https://eciresults.nic.in/). Data is up to date, available in PDF.","Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"e364156f-8cd0-48bf-9829-e54748f606fd","global","2017-06-04T18:08:24","2016","gy","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"This is a correction to a previous submission. Data on this URL - https://finance.gov.gy/documents-publications/category/mid-year-reportsis not transactional level data but an aggregated one and does not fit the criteria. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"f99e9628-1e3a-4736-9bdf-8eae26dad596","global","2017-06-04T17:29:42","2016","gt","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is a login ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Get in to the URL with the user prensa and the password prensa. Make searches using as a guide this document https://portalgl.minfin.gob.gt/Descargas/Documents/Clasificador%20Presupuestario%20E4.pdf"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Finanzas Públicas"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Government office which had the transaction"",""Date of transaction"",""Amount of the transaction""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://sicoin.minfin.gob.gt/sicoinweb/login/frmlogin.htm"",""descValue"":""Spending system""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Data in the government system is lacking the name of the vendor and is not individual transactions. Data, therefore, is not available. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"3a152cc4-00fd-470d-8f95-23a244910254","global","2017-06-04T21:05:03","2016","sv","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-spending-hr/5414/3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The data here - https://www.mh.gob.sv/portal/page/portal/PTF/Presupuestos_Publicos/Presupuestos_ejecutados is estimates of spending, not spending transactions. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"9bfb08e3-c4e9-4251-8059-9b14fc369c97","global","2017-06-14T21:24:14","2016","fi","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""JSON""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""This is an update based on the Public Dialoge"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.fi"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Finnish Environment Institute (SYKE)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Arsenic"",""Nitrates"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Data per water source"",""Available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://rajapinnat.ymparisto.fi/api/vesla/2.0/odata/Result_Wide?%24top=100&%24filter=AnalyteCode%20eq%20%27THCF%27"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://rajapinnat.ymparisto.fi/api/vesla/2.0/odata/Result_Wide?%24top=10&%24filter=AnalyteCode%20eq%20%27AS%27"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://rajapinnat.ymparisto.fi/api/vesla/2.0/odata/Result_Wide?%24top=10&%24filter=AnalyteCode%20eq%20%27NO23N%27"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.syke.fi/fi-FI/Avoin_tieto/Avoimet_rajapinnat/Avoimen_ymparistotiedon_rajapinnat(37459)#Pintaveden_laatutietojen_rajapinta"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://rajapinnat.ymparisto.fi/api/vesla/2.0/"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This is an update based on the Public Dialogue, conversation can be found [here](https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-water-quality-finland/5472)",,"Yes","Yes","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"83c0b0a1-ba88-4e13-9990-2b2f02deaacc","global","2017-06-14T21:16:46","2016","dk","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Looked for denmark cadaster, got a couple results including old index. Followed the links there.\t"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://eng.gst.dk/media/gst/2364686/Conditionsforuseofopenpublicgeographicdata.pdf"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Styrelsen for Dataforsyning og Effektivisering"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Parcel boundaries (inc. latitude and longitude)"",""Parcel ID"",""Property value (i.e. Price Paid, Property Tax Value)"",""Tenure Type (ie. leasehold, freehold, protected lands, public lands, customary lands)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://download.kortforsyningen.dk/content/geodataprodukter?field_korttype_tid_1=441"",""descValue"":""Cadaster for the whole country, region or municipality""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This is an updated submission based on the Public Dialogue, dicussion is [here](https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-land-dk/5172/3)",,"Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","85","85"
"af16e101-d1d6-43e4-a66c-ac47a9fc4217","global","2017-06-14T21:08:36","2016","cz","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Last election was in 2013""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""This is a modification based on public dialogue"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.czso.cz/csu/czso/podminky_pro_vyuzivani_a_dalsi_zverejnovani_statistickych_udaju_csu"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Český statistický úřad / Czech Statistical Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://volby.cz/opendata/opendata.htm"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","Yes","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"14295b55-9861-4694-824f-d0f6dcf57cc0","global","2017-06-04T21:03:39","2016","hr","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance, Republic of Croatia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"According to the forum thread - https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-spending-hr/5414/3 the data for Croatia is not in transactional level ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"c0d1db13-fe99-4b5b-bf4a-8bc1b2955d20","global","2017-06-04T20:51:03","2016","cr","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Contraloría General de la República"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Data here: https://cgrweb.cgr.go.cr/apex/f?p=10263:3:0::NO::: and https://www.hacienda.go.cr/contenido/139-cifras-mensuales-de-ingresos-gastos-y-financiamiento-del-gobierno-central are not available in transaction level. The data are therefore don't meet GODI criteria ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"a28cc9dd-92d4-4f5a-9575-5537b499bbdf","global","2017-06-04T21:06:27","2016","bt","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance and National Statistics Bureau (NSB)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Data here - https://www.nsb.gov.bt/publication/publications.php?id=4 Is annual report - which is not transaction level data - https://www.nsb.gov.bt/publication/publications.php?id=4","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"aecae790-5315-4e2b-8265-2b399dd6482c","global","2017-06-14T19:06:59","2016","co","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1) En el portal de datos abiertos del Estado Colombiano se accede por HTML al portal de Transparencia Económica. 2) Esto conduce a la informacion detallada de Cuánto y a quién se contrató por Sector 3) Aparece el gasto por entidad y al hacer click en el nombre de la entidad me sale el detalle de la información de las entidades adscritas con el valor contrado, el valor pagado, la fecha, etc."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://herramientas.datos.gov.co/es/terms-and-conditions-es"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Hacienda y Crédito Público"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Individual record of transactions"",""Government office which had the transaction"",""Date of transaction"",""Name of vendor"",""Amount of the transaction""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.datos.gov.co/Econom-a-y-Finanzas/Contratos-por-Sector/79qt-rbcu"",""descValue"":""Información de la contratación del nivel nacional discriminado por sector y si continua profundizando encontrara la información discriminada por la Entidad, el valor contratado y pagado con el detalle descrito.""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.datos.gov.co/Econom-a-y-Finanzas/Ejecuci-n-comparada-de-gastos-del-Presupuesto-Gene/r7pp-8p9p"",""descValue"":""La matriz presenta el detalle de los rubros de gastos del Presupuesto General de la Nación a nivel general o por sector o entidad específica según los filtros escogidos. Muestra información del año seleccionado y su comparación con los 4 años anteriores por rubro. Las columnas detallan las asignaciones, compromisos o contratos realizados, obligaciones (a la recepción de bienes y servicios) y finalmente, los pagos con sus porcentajes de ejecución en cada caso. El archivo resultante es susceptible de exportar al formato de MSExcel para su manipulación o análisis.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This entry was modified based on the discussion during the public dialogue. Source is [here](https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-government-spending-colombia/4855)",,"Yes","Yes","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"dd5bc724-a62c-411f-b130-9fb0182290d7","global","2017-06-04T20:39:51","2016","cl","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""ChileCompra - Ministerio de Hacienda"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"This is a correction based on the discussion in the forum - https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-government-spending-chile/4854 Chile only has procurement data, not transactional level spending data. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"1f1efa55-08dd-4a5f-836b-6824cb6f4cfa","global","2017-06-14T18:15:12","2016","bg","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Submission based on public dialogue"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://lex.bg/laws/ldoc/2133094401"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Article 4 of the The Copyright and related rights act (https://lex.bg/laws/ldoc/2133094401) excludes normative acts from the copyright domain and thus makes them public domain.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Assembly of the Republic of Bulgaria"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.parliament.bg/bg/laws"",""descValue"":""legislation""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This entry was updated based on the dialogue. It can be found [here](https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-national-laws-bulgaria/4273)",,"Yes","Yes","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"a4a54c4e-9bd8-4012-b369-d3308e82bafa","global","2016-11-24T20:44:24","2016","br","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The extraction returns a .csv file automatically. Other information can be found only in .pdf format.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The dataset is downloadable at once but it is not an easy process. You have to set all parameters in the platform to \""mark all options\"" and then extract the file.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The platform has yearly data and the latest available is 2014.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""For SNIS there is no need to request access or register, but there is a System from the Ministry of Health that I was unable to have access which is the SISAGUA (Information System for Human Consumption Water Quality Surveillance).""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I tried to find in many places, but it was not easy to find this source. I had to consult with specialists in the domain. After finding the platform, it took me some time to find the necessary information inside it.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1) Looked for \""water quality data\"" at google; 2) Found some reports and information at the Water National Agency (Agência Nacional das Águas) in Brazil, but couldn't find something very robust; 3) Consulted with specialists, that showed me how to use the SNIS platform."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.snis.gov.br/institucional-snis"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I couldn't find a specific license, but the institutional sheet at the main website of the platform shows a public use statement that roughly translates as \""All data from SNIS are public, yearly updated and available free of charge to anyone interested\"".""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The data is consolidated by the government, but it is originally provided by the water and sanitation companies in each municipality.""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is provided in a .csv file and it is easy to find municipalities and its indicators. SNIS also provided extensive material on methodological issues and guides to use the system and analyze the data.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministério das Cidades"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The brazilian Ministry of Cities (and more specifically the National Secretariat of Environmental Sanitation) is responsible for consolidating the data on water and sanitation in Brazil.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Fluoride levels"",""Data per water source""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""SNIS provides information on fecal coliforms and fluoride levels both in absolute level (number of samples measured that reported being out of the standard) and as an indicator. The information is provided per water source and it was supposed to be available for the entire country, but only the municipalities that reported data are available, which is around 700 (Brazil has more than 5500 municipalities). Information on arsenic levels, nitrate levels and total dissolved solids were not found.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://app.cidades.gov.br/serieHistorica/"",""descValue"":""Website of the SNIS (Sistema Nacional de Informações sobre Saneamento), a platform that consolidates water and sanitation data in Brazil""},{""urlValue"":""https://dados.gov.br/dataset/mspainelsage_72/resource/0c1acd83-f458-41c2-bddd-b8fc386c20f9"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://dados.gov.br/dataset/mspainelsage_72"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The platform's name roughly translates to \""National System of Sanitation Information\"".""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","There are some other possible data sources for this kind of information:
The National Water Agency (ANA) has a portal for Water Quality Assessment (https://portalpnqa.ana.gov.br/avaliacao.aspx) that produces reports on the topic, but is really outdated;
The Oswaldo Cruz Foundation (FIOCRUZ) has a Water Quality Map (https://www.geoprocessamento.icict.fiocruz.br/svs/agua/atlas.htm) that doesn’t seem to work correctly (at least when the survey was filled); and
The Ministry of Health, as mentioned above, has a platform called SISAGUA (Information System for Human Consumption Water Quality Surveillance), but I was unable to have access, so I cannot identify what kind of information I could get there. The link is https://sisagua.saude.gov.br/sisagua/login.jsf","Yes","No","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Oscar Montiel","85","85"
"7bcd77b3-2f47-4127-aa80-842db13112e7","global","2017-06-14T17:23:47","2016","br","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Once in IBGE's website you go to downloads section, click in \""Geociências\"" (Geoscience), choose the files: organização_do_territorio (territory organization)> malhas_territoriais (territory modal)> malhas_municipais (municipal modal) and choose Brasil"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.ibge.gov.br/home/disseminacao/eventos/missao/principios_fundamentais_orientacoes_divulgacoes.shtm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Brazilian Geography and Statistics Institute (Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística - IBGE)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://downloads.ibge.gov.br/downloads_geociencias.htm"",""descValue"":""Brazilian Geography and Statistics Institute (Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística - IBGE)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This is an updated submission based on public dialogue, it can be seen here https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-administrative-boundaries-brazil/4534?u=tlacoyodefrijol",,"Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","85","85"
"59afec97-1c3c-4873-a325-6b9585f13a4f","global","2017-06-04T17:34:22","2016","bw","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Government of Botswana Ministry of Finance and Economic Developmen"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"This is a correction to the previous submission. The website of the Ministry of Finance does not have transactional level data - https://www.finance.gov.bw/","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"82ee3739-2500-4c3f-8cfd-bdffa7c7455d","global","2017-06-14T16:57:03","2016","br","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Queries can be made but the data is not in structured text""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1) Google \""Dados Abertos Câmara dos Deputados\"" and \""Dados Abertos Senado\""; 2) Get the first links"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://dadosabertos.senado.gov.br/dataset/lista-detalhada-de-materias-por-ano"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Senado Federal; Câmara dos Deputados"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www2.camara.leg.br/transparencia/dados-abertos/dados-abertos-legislativo"",""descValue"":""Open Data for Draft Legislation provided by the Chamber of Deputies""},{""urlValue"":""https://dadosabertos.senado.gov.br/"",""descValue"":""Open Data for Draft Legislation provided by the Federal Senate""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.camara.leg.br/buscaProposicoesWeb/pesquisaSimplificada"",""descValue"":""Research portal for Draft Legislation provided by the Chamber of Deputies""},{""urlValue"":""https://www25.senado.leg.br/web/atividade"",""descValue"":""Research portal for Draft Legislation provided by the Federal Senate""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Updated after public dialogue. Can find the whole discussion at https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-draft-legislation-brazil/4464",,"Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","65","65"
"e4ec9006-3499-4791-8ca5-42f50cb20964","global","2017-03-06T18:13:36","2016","be","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""bPost"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Bart Hanssens for his contribution to the index. ","The official entity responsible with the postcodes in Belgium is the bPost. In the product specification for the The administrative map of Belgium vector version (Admin Vector) postcodes are mentioned, but as described the dataset is not fully compliant with GODI. Addresses are missing. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"50969f80-9988-44c1-be0c-0f8b4f516c15","global","2017-05-22T21:31:58","2016","be","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON"",""TXT"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google first search result"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.nbb.be/en/disclaimer-and-legal-information/copyright-and-use-information"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Statistics Belgium (Statbel), National Bank of Belgium (for Gross Domestic Product)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://statbel.fgov.be"",""descValue"":""Statbel is the official webpage of Statistics Belgium (national statistics office)""},{""urlValue"":""https://statbel.fgov.be/en/statistics/opendata/"",""descValue"":""Open data portal of Statistics Belgium""},{""urlValue"":""https://bestat.economie.fgov.be/bestat/"",""descValue"":""BeStat is the dynamic dataportal of Statistics Belgium""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.nbb.be/en/statistics?l=nl"",""descValue"":""Belgian National Bank""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","Yes","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"fd9e18de-6af0-4070-b6c4-2762c502e845","global","2017-06-14T16:07:55","2016","ar","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Updated based on public dialoge"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://datos.jus.gob.ar/dataset/base-de-datos-legislativos-infoleg"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Justicia y Derechos Humanos. Sistema Argentino de Información Jurídica."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://datos.jus.gob.ar/dataset/base-de-datos-legislativos-infoleg"",""descValue"":""Base Infoleg de Normativa Nacional""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.saij.gob.ar/buscador/leyes-nacionales-vigentes"",""descValue"":""National Laws in force""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data is available in csv linking to the actual laws. Won't change that format is not open because they only have the actual laws available in html.",,"Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","80","80"
"6caabf41-26e8-4403-8fe0-4f947868dc83","global","2017-06-14T15:57:12","2016","ar","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Dialogue phase new data source"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.datos.gob.ar/acerca/marco-legal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Camara Nacional Electoral"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://datos.gob.ar/dataset/resultados-electorales-2015"",""descValue"":""Resultados electorales de 2015""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","All the data is there but you have to download all the codes separately. Changed data to available and with a compliant license but bulk is still unavailable since you need to download codes and ballots separately. ",,"Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","85","85"
"df7c361b-6a99-4ccf-8941-6feac98eb914","global","2016-12-23T15:56:29","2016","ch","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is available for personal use: \""publication of the whole database, or of parts of it, by any means is strictly forbidden\"". https://zefix.admin.ch/hrweb/eng/about.htm""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is not possible to browse through the database or access data without providing a search term. \n\nHowever, there are daily summaries of new entries, changes and deletions to the register available to download on this page: https://zefix.admin.ch/shab/ but they are likely meant more as notifications than as a comprehensive resource.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data are available through a search mask.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""First result in search engines"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal Commercial Registry Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://zefix.admin.ch/zfx-cgi/hrform.cgi/hraPage?alle_eintr=on&pers_sort=original&pers_num=0&language=4&col_width=366&amt=007"",""descValue"":""Central Business Names Index""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
Company data are available online free of charge via the Federal Commercial Registry Office website's Central Business Names Index feature. Data are provided through a search mask and one needs to enter at least three letters on the Business Name field in order to receive results. Results are given in .HTML format and at a glance include Company name, City, and Identification number. If one selects the Identification number or the .PDF option, more characteristics are provided in .HTML (one can then select an .XML excerpt) and .PDF format respectively. These include Identification number, Legal Status, Date of Entry, Business Name, Legal seat (city), Share Capital (CHF), Paid in (CHF), and Company Address. Data are regularly updated, but cannot be downloaded in bulk. As the submitter has noted, it is not possible to browse through the database or access data without providing a search term. However, there are daily summaries of new entries, changes and deletions to the register available to download on this page: https://zefix.admin.ch/shab/ but they are likely meant more as notifications than as a comprehensive resource. Lastly, data is available for personal use: ""publication of the whole database, or of parts of it, by any means is strictly forbidden"". ",,"Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","Danny Lämmerhirt","50","50"
"0947edc9-fa6f-4d6c-b21a-20a416d85acf","global","2017-05-26T11:24:22","2016","tw","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Our reviewer searched on Taiwan's open data portal. The review was updated after a change was proposed by a user. Because the dataset was not initially found, I subtracted a point for findability."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.ly.gov.tw/principle.action"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Legislative Yuan of Taiwan"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.ly.gov.tw/getds.action?id=20"",""descValue"":""Contains all required information on proposed bills""},{""urlValue"":""https://law.moj.gov.tw/Eng/index.aspx?type=s"",""descValue"":""Drafts: Laws and Regulations Database of The Republic of China""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"This review has been updated after the user afro 0525 told us that data is available in bulk and an open, machine-readable format.
Thank you, afro 0525 and Alyssa Beaton for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Yes","Yes","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","100","100"
"7ff96384-362d-48f3-9c50-a815d00db312","global","2017-05-26T11:05:02","2016","nir","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Found it after a user in our forum sent the link to the GODI team"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Land and Property Services"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Zipcodes"",""Addresses"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Data available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.nidirect.gov.uk/articles/pointer#toc-0"",""descValue"":""Website of NI Government services, contains postcodes and addresses from the pointer dataset""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This review was changed, thanks to a notification by Bob Harper. Thank you, Bob Harper, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The original review was changed during GODI's public dialogue phase. The original submitter Bob Harper referred only to a free postcode register available at: https://www.nisra.gov.uk/geography/postcode.htm Central Postcode Directory (November 2015) https://ons.maps.arcgis.com/home/item.html?id=d7fe815217504f4eac0cb07170747094 UK ONS Postcode Directory (November 2016)
Bob Harper further elaborates: ""However, there are no address references. The data is particularly difficult to find. It exists in different places, with different levels of updated-ness, and with different access arrangements. Percularity with the Northern Ireland data - though it is included alongside the Great Britain postcodes (UK Government Licence), it carries a separate licence https://www.ons.gov.uk/methodology/geography/licences Furthermore, the data is both available free of charge, but you can also also be charged £260+VAT by the government department if you are not aware of this https://mapshop.nidirect.gov.uk/Catalogue/Digital-products/Address-data-and-gazetteers/Central-Postcode-Directory/197a466c-60ce-4373-813a-8cccc6480f74.""","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","50","50"
"79d7dee7-260b-4b11-a85f-14f2ec51def2","global","2017-03-12T09:47:31","2016","in","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""India Meteorological Department"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original submission by Nisha Thompson. Thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The submission was not accepted, because it referred to observations and not forecasts (see portal for observational data here: https://www.imdaws.com/viewawsdata.aspx). This data is provided in xls format and can be downloaded once a user registered on the website.
The India Meteorological Department makes forecasts available for the entire country at https://www.indiaweather.gov.in/,
as well as for departments: https://www.indiaweather.gov.in/?page_id=942&tags=Kolkata. there are departmental websites that provide additional information.
Wind forecasts are only available for the current day when visiting the local forecast pages. Generally the data is hard to find and navigate, because it seems to be placed in many different places. Since no wind forecasts are available for the following two days the data is not considered to be fully available online.
The data is not openly licensed at the moment. ","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"8b5a7b87-855e-45d6-bc66-6e200fea5b15","global","2017-03-17T14:10:21","2016","in","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML, PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google search with keywords, Guide to Law online, Parliament of India, House of the People, click on Bills Introduced under Legislation"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Law and Justice, Legislative Department"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://164.100.47.194/Loksabha/Legislation/billintroduce.aspx"",""descValue"":""Parliament of India - Lok Sabha House of the People, Legislation, Bills Introduced""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","India's draft legislation is available at the following link: https://164.100.47.194/Loksabha/Legislation/billintroduce.aspx. The title and status are available in HTML, while the content and author are available to view and download in PDF. I accessed the information by completing a web search with keywords, consulted the links on the Guide to Law online for India where I was directed to the Parliament of India, House of the People, click on Bills Introduced under Legislation.","Originally submitted by Nisha Thompson, which points to the OGD Platform for India: https://data.gov.in/catalogs/ministry_department/lok-sabha-secretariat. Bill voting and transcript information may be available here, however I was unable to locate this data specifically. ","Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","45","45"
"7f7bc60c-6b13-46b6-ad69-4928275d88b7","global","2017-02-01T05:48:28","2016","in","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Look up Ministry websites and there are sections for water quality"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is not standardized and will require a bit of processing.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Drinking Water and Sanitation and The Central Ground Water Board"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Arsenic"",""Fluoride levels"",""Nitrates"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Data per water source"",""Available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://indiawater.gov.in/imisreports/Reports/WaterQuality/rpt_WQM_HabitationWiseLabTesting_S.aspx?Rep=0&RP=Y"",""descValue"":""Water quality for drinking water""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.india-wris.nrsc.gov.in/GWLevelApp.html?UType=R2VuZXJhbA==?UName="",""descValue"":""water quality for groundwater gis portal""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.cgwb.gov.in/contaminated-areas.html"",""descValue"":""water quality for groundwater""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.in/catalog/water-quality-affected-habitations"",""descValue"":""open data portal water quality but outdated""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","65","65"
"3dac93f1-5322-47e6-aa37-4d656f167f18","global","2017-01-31T18:02:44","2016","in","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""On the home page of the Ministry"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Corporate Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.in/catalog/company-master-data"",""descValue"":""Open Data Portal ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mca.gov.in/MinistryV2/incorporatedorclosedduringthemonth.html"",""descValue"":""website""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
Details of Indian Companies or LLPs incorporated and details of Foreign Companies or Foreign LLPs having established a place of business in India from November, 2013 onwards is available for free in .XLS format on the Ministry of Corporate Affairs website. Data include Corporate Identification Number (CIN), Company Name, Date of Registration, Month, State, Registrars of Companies (ROC), Class, Company Status, Company Type, Category, Authorised Capital, Paidup Capital, Activity Code, Activity Description, Registered Office Address, and E-mail.The dataset is updated monthly and downloadable at once:
https://www.mca.gov.in/MinistryV2/incorporatedorclosedduringthemonth.html
However, there is a copyright policy, ""The contents hereof are the sole and exclusive property Ministry of Company Affairs ('MCA'), Government of India. Unless otherwise indicated and may not be, for whatsoever purpose, reproduced, stored, copied or archived in any manner, format or medium whatsoever either in full or in parts without the prior express written consent of MCA.""
https://www.mca.gov.in/Ministry/pdf/MCAprivacypolicy.pdf
Data are also available for free online on the Open Data portal in .CSV format. They include Corporate Identification Number, Company Name, Date of Registration, Registered State, Registrar of Companies, Company Class, Company Status, Company Type,Company Category, Authorised Capital, Paidup Capital, Registered Office Address, and Sub Category. However, the datasets are divided according to city/region so they cannot be downloaded at once. They are also outdated as they appear to be up to the 31st March 2015:
https://data.gov.in/catalog/company-master-data",,"Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Evangelia Kampouri","80","80"
"4dfb5c8e-334b-4c2d-a737-cc28d1e20c6c","global","2017-03-10T14:17:19","2016","co","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""INSTITUTO GEOGRAFICO AGUSTIN CODAZZI and other decentralized entities in Antioquia, Bogotá, Cali and Medellin"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Fernandauisa L for the contribution.
","https://www.cadastraltemplate.org/cadastraltemplate/colombia.php","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"0d69445d-9887-40b1-8546-04635a91b1c7","global","2017-03-15T16:35:38","2016","co","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Institute of Health"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","The submission referred to dataset that had water quality under the Health Ministry, however, this data is aggregated and gives water sources a ranking or score. This is not actually the data according to the parameters so had to reject the submission.
https://www.ins.gov.co/sivicap/Normatividad/2016%20Estado%20de%20la%20vigilancia%20de%20la%20calidad%20del%20agua%202015.pdf
https://www.datos.gov.co/Salud-y-Protecci-n-Social/SIVICAP-2015/yjkc-jgd2","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"86eec890-d86e-4be9-91dd-428b0a0cc9b2","global","2016-12-05T22:51:48","2016","co","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""reviewer: I have reviewed https://visor.codigopostal.gov.co/472/visor/ because the data found here is compliant with the requirements. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Ingresar al portal web Datos.gov.co y buscar Códigos Postales Nacionales"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://herramientas.datos.gov.co/es/terms-and-conditions-es"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Códigos Postales Nacionales"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Zipcodes"",""Addresses"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Data available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://visor.codigopostal.gov.co/472/visor/"",""descValue"":""view/discover service for post codes from Códigos Postales Nacionales""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The post codes are available for download in a tabular form. Although the table does contain information related to the geographical extent for each code, the process of creating the geometry is far from trivial. ","Para mayor información se podrá consultar en:
https://www.codigopostal.gov.co/
https://visor.codigopostal.gov.co/472/visor/
","Yes","No","Juan Felipe Devia Rodriguez","Codrina Maria Ilie","45","45"
"c492fcc2-72ee-4d7b-a9b2-d7ddf3c52865","global","2017-03-10T19:14:38","2016","co","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Superintendencia de Sociedades"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission had to be rejected because not all four characteristics could be found online. More specifically, datasets included Company Names and Unique Identifiers, but not Company Addresses. According to submitter, the annualized data available both in the data portal and in the information system of companies in Colombia correspond to the latest available. This is because companies have a deadline to report until March of the following year. The data for 2016 comes after March 2017 and the available data are updated. The Superintendency of Companies makes available to the public the database with the financial statements of the 26,611 companies in the real sector that reported their balance sheets, income statements and cash flow for 2015 (thousands of pesos). Balance sheets and statements of income are available for free online on the Open data Portal under the creative commons public license. Accessing cash flows requires a user name and password but balance sheets and statements of income do not. The geographic coverage is national and the update frequency is weekly, although data appear to be from 2015. Each dataset is available separately and downloadable at once in .XLS format. However, information includes NIT (Número de Identificación Tributaria - Colombian business tax number), Business Name, City, Department, CIIU (Unified Industrial Information Code), and Sector, but not full Company Address. https://www.datos.gov.co/Econom-a-y-Finanzas/Balance-general-2015/axpt-nxv2 https://www.datos.gov.co/Econom-a-y-Finanzas/Estados-de-Resultados-2015/4nua-mduk https://www.datos.gov.co/Econom-a-y-Finanzas/Flujo-de-Efectivo-2015/qap6-cmfd Also, the Business Reporting and Reporting System - SIREM - presents the financial statements with a cut at December 31 of each year that are supplied by the companies that are subject to supervision, control and inspection by this Superintendency and that belong to the real sector of the economy. Data are downloadable at once for free in a .ZIP file that contains .XLS formats. Again, information includes NIT (Número de Identificación Tributaria - Colombian business tax number), Business Name, City, Department, CIIU (Unified Industrial Information Code), and Sector, but not full Company Address. https://www.supersociedades.gov.co/asuntos-economicos-y-contables/estudios-y-supervision-por-riesgos/SIREM/Paginas/default.aspx",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"e45e1319-ebb5-4143-8396-696e0f8e167b","global","2016-12-14T23:14:13","2016","co","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I changed the original submission to NO. The original submitter had listed https://herramientas.datos.gov.co/es/terms-and-conditions-es \nas proof. However, this link applies to the website that led me to the source where the data is. The Camera de Representates website (where the data is found) is actually not in open data. This can be verified by clicking on the \""Terms and Conditions\"" at the bottom of the home page. ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The original submission had indicated: JSON, RDF, CSV, XML.\n\nI could not find any of these formats. Data can be downloaded in PDF and Doc. only. In the case of votes, in .rar""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I changed the submission to NO because I could not find a means of downloading data in bulk. Different versions of each bill have to be downloaded separately. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Ingresar a www.datos.gov.co y buscar Leyes y Proyectos de Ley del Estado Colombiano"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://herramientas.datos.gov.co/es/terms-and-conditions-es"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Changed this to 1, since the data is not available in a machine readable format. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Cámara de Representantes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I changed the original submission to indicate that votes are not available. While the website does have a page where one can search record of votes based on the date they took place, I was not able to open the document. The document is in .rar format which my computer does not support. Therefore, since it the information is in a format that not everyone can have access to, I have marked it as missing. \nI also changed the original submission to indicate that transcripts of debates are missing. The website lists the proposed versions of the bill that has resulted from each debate, but not the transcript of the debates themselves. \nThe required characteristics are all clearly present. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.camara.gov.co/portal2011/proceso-y-tramite-legislativo/proyectos-de-ley?view=proyectosdeley"",""descValue"":""Camara de Representantes website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.camara.gov.co/portal2011/prueba-proceso/4928-asistencia-y-votaciones-legislatura-2016-2017"",""descValue"":""Record of Votes""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The original submission stated the following as the source:https://www.datos.gov.co/Funci-n-p-blica/Leyes-y-Proyectos-de-Ley-del-Estado-Colombiano/fsmt-qjvv\n\nHowever, this website just lists the websites where one may find the bills (and a variety of other government publications). I have listed as the source the website where the information on draft legislation can actually be found. ""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission should be accepted because all the required characteristics are present in the data set. ","As a reviewer I changed the source to a more appropriate URL, and used it for the rest of my review. I was able to reach this source through the URL reported by the original submitter. I changed B3 to indicate that Votes and Transcripts are missing. I also changed B4 to NO since bulk download does not seem to be an option. I changed B7 to No after using the Camera de Representates website as a point of reference. I also changed B8 to indicate that data is only available in PDF and Doc.
The submission will be accepted because the required characteristics are present. ","Yes","No","Juan Felipe Devia Rodriguez","Juela Xhaferraj","45","45"
"61417764-cb77-4344-b4f2-ce4f6be0fa09","global","2016-12-14T23:10:40","2016","co","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I changed this to No. There is no statement of open license. Furthermore, in a highlighted yellow box on each law it states \""Copyright reserved\"".\n\nOriginal submission provided the following URL as proof of open license: \nhttps://herramientas.datos.gov.co/es/terms-and-conditions-es\nThis URL is not relevant to the source where the data is found. ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Original submission indicated: JSON, RDF, CSV, TSV, XML\nI could not find any of these formats. The data is only available in HTML. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I changed this to NO because I could not see option to download data in bulk.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Last updates were made December 30th 2016 (today is March 8, 2017)""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Ingresar a www.datos.gov.co y buscar Leyes y Proyectos de Ley del Estado Colombiano"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://herramientas.datos.gov.co/es/terms-and-conditions-es"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Cámara de Representantes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""All the characteristics are present. Date of last amendment can be found by clicking on \""Summary of Notes of Effectiveness\"". ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.camara.gov.co/portal2011/index.php/proceso-y-tramite-legislativo/buscador-legislativo"",""descValue"":""Congress website""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The original submission had indicated https://www.datos.gov.co/Funci-n-p-blica/Leyes-y-Proyectos-de-Ley-del-Estado-Colombiano/fsmt-qjvv\nas a source. However, this website contains no data, just links to the sites where the data can be found. I have indicated the site where the full text of laws is published.\nLaws may also be published on https://www.imprenta.gov.co/gacetap/gaceta.nivel_1\nHowever, whenever I tried to search for laws on the site, the website crashed. For this reason, I cannot verify the contents of this site. The review is based entirely on the Congress website listed in B2.2""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission will be accepted because all characteristics are present in the dataset. ","As a reviewer I have indicated a more appropriate source for the data. I changed B5 and B7 to No. The only other change I made was to indicate that data is only available in html., and no other formats. ","Yes","No","Juan Felipe Devia Rodriguez","Juela Xhaferraj","45","45"
"b68a3674-2fa7-4cf6-bfe2-763ca4db14c1","global","2016-12-05T22:54:46","2016","co","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The WFS is 1:500.000, thus not compliant with the requirements. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Ingresa al portal del IGAC y acceda la sección de mapas de Colombia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.igac.gov.co/wps/wcm/connect/0b3aa8004eef2fd4a7abf730262db5f2/Licencia_y_condiciones_de_uso_car.pdf?MOD=AJPERES"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Geográfico Agustín Codazzi- IGAC"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://geoportal.igac.gov.co/ssigl2.0/visor/galeria.req?mapaId=7"",""descValue"":""Portal IGAC Mapas Nacionales""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The WFS provides access to 1:500000 vector data - not compliant to the requirements. [https://geocarto.igac.gov.co:8080/geoservicios/quinientos_mil/wfs].",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","65","65"
"aeb0599a-2608-43aa-baf9-28fe18582f31","global","2017-04-04T15:21:34","2016","co","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1.Ingresar al home del instituto estadístico. 2. Seleccionar en el home la temática de interés (mercado laboral, PIN, desempleo, población) 3. Acceder a los datos en formatos"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Departamento Administrativo Nacional de Estadística - DANE"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.dane.gov.co/index.php/estadisticas-por-tema/demografia-y-poblacion/series-de-poblacion"",""descValue"":""Contiene información sobre la población de Colombia por grupo de edad y género desde 1985 y proyectada hasta 2020 (population data)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dane.gov.co/files/investigaciones/poblacion/proyepobla06_20/Municipal_area_1985-2020.xls"",""descValue"":""Contiene información sobre la población de Colombia por grupo de edad y género desde 1985 y proyectada hasta 2020 (population data in table)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.datos.gov.co/Mapas-Nacionales/PROYECCIONES-POBLACI-N-Viviendas-por-a-o-y-depar/ribh-jt5t"",""descValue"":""Proyecciones Población - Viviendas por año y depar""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.datos.gov.co/Mapas-Nacionales/PROYECCIONES-POBLACI-N-hogares-por-a-o/enep-fdt5"",""descValue"":""Proyecciones Población - hogares por año""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.datos.gov.co/Mapas-Nacionales/PROYECCIONES-POBLACI-N-Caracterizaci-n-poblaci-n/2yih-wg7m"",""descValue"":""Proyecciones Población - Caracterización población""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dane.gov.co/index.php/estadisticas-por-tema/cuentas-nacionales/cuentas-nacionales-trimestrales/historicos-producto-interno-bruto-pib"",""descValue"":""Históricos Producto Interno Bruto -PIB- (GDP data)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dane.gov.co/index.php/estadisticas-por-tema/mercado-laboral/empleo-y-desempleo"",""descValue"":""Gran Encuesta Integrada de Hogares -GEIH- Mercado Laboral (unemployment data)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"License mentions that you can use and reuse but there is no explicit mention of commercial use allowed or explicitly saying that the data is in the public domain.
Original submission by Carolina Escobar","Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","80","80"
"f007c74a-82cc-4a1e-9ffc-3df9eb5edb02","global","2017-03-15T10:04:10","2016","hk","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""according to paragraph 2, unless otherwise specified, statistical tables, charts, reports, datasets, feature articles, classifications and press releases on this website are also listed in DATA.GOV.HK. Such contents may be downloaded, distributed and reproduced free of charge for both commercial and non-commercial purposes subject to the Terms and Conditions as stipulated under DATA.GOV.HK.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Go to Data.Gov.HK"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.censtatd.gov.hk/home/important_notices/index.jsp"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""terms and conditions in data.gov.hk: https://data.gov.hk/en/terms-and-conditions""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Census and Statistics Department"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.censtatd.gov.hk"",""descValue"":""Census and Statistics Department""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.hk/en/"",""descValue"":""DATA.GOV.HK""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.censtatd.gov.hk/hkstat/sub/sp250.jsp?tableID=030&ID=0&productType=8"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.hk/en-data/dataset/hk-censtatd-tablechart-gdp/resource/19f34253-fa88-472b-96b3-8c229f3b1e62"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.censtatd.gov.hk/hkstat/sub/sp150.jsp?tableID=001&ID=0&productType=8"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.hk/en-data/dataset/hk-censtatd-tablechart-popn/resource/e609ea95-f792-4fb0-8020-a87d2b9c6499"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.censtatd.gov.hk/hkstat/sub/sp200.jsp?tableID=006&ID=0&productType=8"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.hk/en-data/dataset/hk-censtatd-tablechart-statistics-on-labour-force-unemployment-and-underemployment/resource/e4c9d975-b47b-4ae0-8a0b-84bc4f180315"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Following a discussion in our forum: https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-national-statistics-hong-kong/4907/5, this data counts as openly licensed.
The license requirement to ""reproduce and distribute data accurately, fairly and sufficiently"" does not affect the creation of derivatives of the data, e.g. using the data to perform analysis, adapting the data in commercial products; and the distribution of such derivatives.",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Danny Lämmerhirt","100","100"
"caad509a-7ad4-4876-8bac-232f2904cf3a","global","2017-04-07T12:36:41","2016","be","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""open license""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""After registration, one gets a username/password for FTP access""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is available as webservice (public search) one request at a time https://kbopub.economie.fgov.be/kbopub/zoeknaamfonetischform.html\nBulk download requires registration""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""CSV bulk can be downloaded for free, online (human) requests are free, and in addition there is a (non-free) API/webservice""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Data.gov.be and google search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://economie.fgov.be/fr/modules/publications/bce/licence_open_data.jsp"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""FPS Economy (Banque-Carrefour des Entreprises / Kruispuntbank van Ondernemingen)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://economie.fgov.be/nl/ondernemingen/bce/pub/opendata/"",""descValue"":""request bulk download""},{""urlValue"":""https://kbopub.economie.fgov.be/kbopub/zoeknummerform.html"",""descValue"":""website (html form)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data is available as webservice (public search) one request at a time https://kbopub.economie.fgov.be/kbopub/zoeknaamfonetischform.html
Bulk download requires registration.
This review exclusively refers to the dataset that is downloadable in bulk available at https://kbopub.economie.fgov.be/kbo-open-data/kbo-open-data/signup?form=&lang=en Therefore points were subtracted for registration requirement. The data is, however, available in bulk, and is in an open format. The license available at https://economie.fgov.be/fr/modules/publications/bce/licence_open_data.jsp limits reusability as following clause states: Le preneur de licence s’engage à ce que les données ne soient pas altérées ni leur sens dénaturé.","The review needed to be changed, because during a link was down that had been submitted during the very first submission. We kept the reviewer's original comments:
Comment Evangelia Kampouri: ""I could not find any data on the data.gov.be and https://economie.fgov.be websites as suggested by the submitter. According to the open data license agreement (https://economie.fgov.be/nl/modules/publications/kbo/licence_open_data.jsp), ""the licensee may not reuse the data for a purpose other than the one stated in his registration as a user of the files 'open data'"" so it appears that in order to access the data, a registration was to be expected. Also, ""the licensor shall make the information available in the form of CSV files of the licensee on the website https://kbopub.economie.fgov.be/kbo-open-data. The data is the first Sunday of the month [sic] and updated at the latest on Monday."" The link should redirect to a user registration form, however the links lead nowhere (https://kbopub.economie.fgov.be/kbo-open-data/kbo-open-data/signup?form=&lang=en). The link provided by the submitter (https://data.gov.be/nl/node14657) redirects to an error: ""page could not be found"". Hence, the link provided by the submitter was replaced with the website address https://kbopub.economie.fgov.be/kbopub/zoeknummerform.html which appears to be the only way of finding company data. Entities can be searched for free through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name, number, activity, license, or address of an entity in order to find it. The data cannot be downloaded at once, thus I changed the answer to B5 accordingly. Rather than .CSV format as stated by the submitter, the list of enterprises/establishment units is presented in .HTML format and can also be downloaded in .PDF form. The search results were presented based on the ""situation in the CBE database on 13/02/2017"" (today's date is 14/02/2017) so data appear to be updated regularly.""
Cookbook available https://economie.fgov.be/nl/modules/publications/kbo/cookbook_open_data.jsp","Yes","No","Bart Hanssens","Danny Lämmerhirt","85","85"
"52b3b7d6-002e-484b-bfd2-982ead117ae8","global","2017-03-07T21:11:18","2016","co","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON"",""RDF"",""TSV"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Colombia Compra Eficiente changed the update to monthly""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Entrar a datos.gov.co y buscar \""procesos de contratación pública\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://herramientas.datos.gov.co/es/terms-and-conditions-es"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Colombia Compra Eficiente"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.datos.gov.co/Gastos-Gubernamentales/SECOP-I-Consolidado/ewm2-yzgs"",""descValue"":""Procesos de compra publicas registrados en SECOP I (Sistema Electrónico de Contratación Pública)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.datos.gov.co/Gastos-Gubernamentales/SECOP-II-Consolidado/b57x-htnb"",""descValue"":""Procesos de compra publicas registrados en SECOP II (Sistema Electrónico de Contratación Pública)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Submission is accepted as up to date, the data is published monthly on the procurement website with the same information as the other data sets. https://www.colombiacompra.gov.co/transparencia/datos-csv","Colombia Compra Eficiente changed the update to monthly","Yes","Yes","Camilo Niño","Danny Lämmerhirt","100","100"
"1fb33cee-61b4-42cf-96a2-1675b3da7831","global","2017-05-16T16:34:24","2016","be","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""GML"",""SHP""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Through a correction on the GODI forum"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://statbel.fgov.be/en/statistics/opendata/licence/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Statistics Belgium"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://statbel.fgov.be/en/statistics/opendata/datasets/tools/big/SH_STAT_SECTORS.jsp"",""descValue"":""Website of Statistics Belgium, containing the geographical shapes (polygons) of the smallest statistical unit, which is a subdivision of an administrative unit""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ngi.be/NL/NL1-5-2.shtm"",""descValue"":""AdminVector""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"There are several datasources one could refer to. This review refers to data on statistical units, provided by Statistics Belgium. Alternative datasources are https://data.gov.be/ or https://www.ngi.be/NL/NL1-5-2.shtm
Thank you, Bart Hannsens, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index","Yes","Yes","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","100","100"
"7ce2099a-54f5-4e68-b7a5-68f6c5e147d7","global","2017-05-16T13:17:48","2016","be","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched through ministry websites"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""Dutch version: https://www.ejustice.just.fgov.be/eli/wet/2014/04/19/2014011298/justel; French version: https://www.ejustice.just.fgov.be/eli/loi/2014/04/19/2014011298/justel: Art. XI.172 § 2 states \""Er bestaat geen auteursrecht op officiële akten van de overheid.\"" which translates to \""there is no copyright on official acts of the public authorities\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""FOD Justitie"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.juridat.be/"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Justice""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The data is available through the Ministry of Justice portal, https://www.juridat.be/. Laws are searchable by department and domain, where content and amendments are available, in addition to supplementary information, such as signatures. The original review was amended: laws are not copyrightable in Belgium and are therefore considered to be in the public domain.
Thank you Alyssa Beaton, Bart Hannsens, Lucia Decuyper and Michael Robert Beatty for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","65","65"
"fda5a87a-0dc0-4492-8aeb-1f8b13d2041c","global","2017-05-16T13:00:26","2016","nir","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched on data.gov.uk"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""This URL explains public domain status of Company House data: https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/free_company_data_third_party_in#incoming-557695. Company House places no restriction on how the information is used, but advises all customers to take their own legal advice regarding possible breach of third party copyright."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Companies House"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://download.companieshouse.gov.uk/en_output.html"",""descValue"":""Free Company Data Product""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission was reviewed and it was concluded that the data is openly licensed, based on following evidence which states that there is no open licence for the data: https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/free_company_data_third_party_in#incoming-557695.
However, the evidence also states: ""CH places no restriction on how the information is used, but advises all customers to take their own legal advice regarding possible breach of third party copyright."" The data counts as available in public domain.",,"Yes","Yes","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","100","100"
"729cda9e-0698-4e6b-9039-7089d3cf4b64","global","2017-05-15T20:16:33","2016","be","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Going to the website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""Budget is a law which cannot be copyrighted as this source shows: https://www.ejustice.just.fgov.be/eli/wet/2014/04/19/2014011298/justel https://www.ejustice.just.fgov.be/eli/loi/2014/04/19/2014011298/justel"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""FOD Budget & Beheerscontrole"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.begroting.be/NL/pages/budgetOnline.aspx"",""descValue"":""Dutch page""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.begroting.be/FR/Pages/budgetOnline.aspx"",""descValue"":""French page""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","A comment by Bart Hanssens helped to clarify the legal openness of Belgiums budget: As explained on the website at the bottom of https://www.begroting.be/NL/Pages/budgetDefinition.aspx1, the budget is actually passed as a law. The law on accouting and organisation of the budget (https://www.ejustice.just.fgov.be/eli/wet/2003/05/22/2003003367/justel1 - ""Wet houdende organisatie van de begroting en van de comptabiliteit van de federale Staat""), article 44 - 47 explain that a budget-as-a-law-proposal has to be submitted and approved by the Parliament every year.
And official acts like laws are not copyrighted in Belgium, as mentioned in https://www.ejustice.just.fgov.be/eli/wet/2014/04/19/2014011298/justel
https://www.ejustice.just.fgov.be/eli/loi/2014/04/19/2014011298/justel","This is a revision to Bart Hanssens' submission. ","Yes","Yes","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","100","100"
"724794e9-2f72-4d14-ba70-a7d7bf622e4e","global","2017-05-09T17:54:24","2016","ro","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission referred to procurement data (contracts and planned expenditures), but not monetary transactions from government to a vendor.
Budget execution is published by the Ministry of Finance, but no transactional spending. Thank you, Cristian Balulescu, Diana Krebs, and Ovidiu Voicu for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"0bae9f80-f640-4aed-a8ff-c83b0d7f54ec","global","2017-03-11T22:15:01","2016","in","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""India Post"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Nisha Thompson for the contribution. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"b91a573f-ca67-4e25-b65d-4bd479a394c8","global","2017-03-29T10:17:38","2016","in","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX"",""WFS"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""The data are available on OGD Platform India, Bhuvan, Survey of India website."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.in/sites/default/files/Gazette_Notification_OGDL.pdf"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Not all themes are available for download in one go. Registering, searching and identifying the layers are necessary steps. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Survey of India, Department of Science and Technology, National Remote Sensing Centre"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""In order to download data one must register to the Indian Geo-Platform of ISRO. ""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.in/catalog/bhuvan"",""descValue"":""Data viewer and download""},{""urlValue"":""https://bhuvan.nrsc.gov.in/data/download/index.php"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.surveyofindia.gov.in/"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.surveyofindia.gov.in/pages/display/59-publications"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.portal.gsi.gov.in/portal/page?_pageid=127,529486&_dad=portal&_schema=PORTAL"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.surveykshan.gov.in/"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I thank Akhilesh Srivastava for his valuable contribution to the index and for pin pointing to the viewer, making this review much more approachable. ","The data is fully available in the OGD India website mentioned above with their links. The information available on OGD India and is completely open for reuse and further studies and research. Maps are available at https://data.gov.in/catalog/bhuvan-geoportal-nrscisro.
Bhuvan (https://bhuvan.nrsc.gov.in/data/download/index.php) is the gateway on Indian Earth Observation. It gives an easy way to experience, explore and visualize IRS images over Indian region. Bhuvan platform provides wide ranging information through its interactive maps and a number of products which are available on its site. The data is available for download to every one and the policy clearly states that the data can be distributed and further used for developing applications and research. But data doesn't include administrative boundaries, public equipments, transport systems, etc.
Survey of India (https://www.surveyofindia.gov.in/), the National Survey and Mapping Organisation of the country under the Department of Science & Technology, provides varrious types of mapping data. The full list of available mapping products is here: https://www.surveyofindia.gov.in/pages/display/59-publications.
Some information is also available in the site https://www.portal.gsi.gov.in/portal/page?_pageid=127,529486&_dad=portal&_schema=PORTAL and https://www.surveykshan.gov.in/
We have already submitted the responses on 20th Sep 2016 which is accessible at old site i.e. https://global.census.okfn.org/submission/f4771f4b-75e2-4dbe-8a71-ffb1eafd6bc9, but, unfortunately it was not considered for review. You are requested to kindly consider this resubmission in this new format for review.","Yes","No","Akhilesh Srivastava","Codrina Maria Ilie","85","85"
"f7ff4d8b-d399-4cff-af98-09a44071673a","global","2017-03-16T01:25:08","2016","co","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Ingrese al portal de datos abiertos datos.gov.co, le di clic en Descubre y luego busque por PRONÓSTICO DEL TIEMPO el cual me llevo al enlace del portal del IDEAM - https://www.pronosticosyalertas.gov.co/datos-de-pronostico"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.ideam.gov.co/web/atencion-y-participacion-ciudadana/condiciones-y-terminos-de-uso-de-la-informacion"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto de Hidrología, Meteorología y Estudios Ambientales"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Precipitation Probability"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.pronosticosyalertas.gov.co/datos-de-pronostico"",""descValue"":""Allí cualquier persona puede descargar los datos en formato CSV sobre pronóstico de las ciudades y municipios que componen el territorio nacional de Colombia (latitud, longitud, región, departamento, fecha, hora, temperatura, velocidad del viento, dirección del viento, pronóstico) para un intervalo de tiempo de 3 horas a 8 días.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is valid. However, not all data can be downloaded at once, because the user has to retrieve forecast information for individual cities/regions individually through a search interface.
Thank you, Carlos Julio Leon Caicedo and Juan Felipe Devia Rodriguez, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Los datos se encuentran enlazados en el portal de datos abiertos del estado colombiano en el siguiente enlace: https://www.datos.gov.co/Ambiente-y-Desarrollo-Sostenible/PRON-STICO-DEL-TIEMPO/st8p-pai8","Yes","No","anonymous","Danny Lämmerhirt","85","85"
"ee48ec15-3723-4e04-b2c9-efcbcba6e89c","global","2017-04-14T10:21:06","2016","gb","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"" through the OK forum"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""In order to use these data in a GIS environment, the user must know how to handle and process tabular data to obtain vector data. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" Royal Mail "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is only a sample available to download without request. \t\n\nDVD and FTP (for orders under 2Gb)""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Zipcodes"",""Addresses"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Data available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ordnancesurvey.co.uk/business-and-government/products/addressbase-products.html"",""descValue"":""AdressBase""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We appreciate Owen Boswarva for his valuable contribution to the Global Open Data Index. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","50","50"
"ecbffaed-94da-4529-b803-2d054156a279","global","2017-04-14T10:08:57","2016","ca","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""SHP"",""WFS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Environment Canada Search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Environment Canada"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Arsenic"",""Fluoride levels"",""Nitrates"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Data per water source"",""Available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://ec.gc.ca/eaudouce-freshwater/default.asp?lang=En&n=6F77A064-1"",""descValue"":""Environment Canada Fresh Water Quality Monitoring & Surveillance""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission by Tracey P. Lauriault was correct. However, not all data is up-to-date, which is why this parameter was changed. Thank you very much, Tracey P. Lauriault, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","This is a complicated set of data that does not lend itself well to the nature of the questions asked here. Water quality measures and monitoring and surveillance is a multi-jurisdictional responsibility in Canada as the number of fresh water bodies is the highest in the world and these are not all in populated areas.
The data that are assessed are collected for specific sites which are part of the EC Fresh Water Monitoring network. Canada is an incredibly large country with some of the greatest numbers of water sources in the world. It is not possible to have all the water monitored. Therefore sites are monitored where populations and campers have access to. In addition, the jurisdiction for water monitoring is not at the federal level as inland waters are the responsibility of the provinces and the territories and cities. Read here https://ec.gc.ca/eaudouce-freshwater/default.asp?lang=En&n=50947E1B-1 and see the variables list here for one particular site https://aquatic.pyr.ec.gc.ca/webdataonlinenational/en/Measurements/ChooseVariables/Sites/YT08AB0010/Projects/PYLTM/Regions/0 Also see https://www.ec.gc.ca/eaudouce-freshwater/default.asp?lang=En&n=EFDA57C6-1
Different monitoring stations update at different rates. See here https://ec.gc.ca/eaudouce-freshwater/default.asp?lang=En&n=50947E1B-1 and see here https://www.ec.gc.ca/eaudouce-freshwater/default.asp?lang=En&n=EFDA57C6-1
The data must be downloaded by station. This is a massive and complicated database and it does not make sense to download all at once unless one is a scientists and has the database resources to do so. Read here https://ec.gc.ca/eaudouce-freshwater/default.asp?lang=En&n=50947E1B-1 also see https://www.ec.gc.ca/eaudouce-freshwater/default.asp?lang=En&n=EFDA57C6-1
The data is not openly licensed, because only non-commercial re-use allowed (https://ec.gc.ca/default.asp?lang=En&xml=5830C36B-1773-4E3E-AF8C-B21F54633E0A)","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","50","50"
"493113db-e621-443f-8546-1e94007c48fc","global","2017-04-04T08:51:41","2016","mx","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google: division politica de mexico datos abiertos"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Council for Biodiversity"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.conabio.gob.mx/informacion/gis/"",""descValue"":""GIS system""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Special thanks to Enrique_Zapata for providing info in Forum. All the characteristics are available in the GeoInformation Portal https://www.conabio.gob.mx. Select ""Political division"" where there is Boundary Level 1 + 2 available for download. The meta tab has the link to download the shapefiles. The license of the data is Creative Commons Non-Commercial so it is not openly licensed.
Enrique Zapata referred to INEGI and stated the required data is available and openly licensed. However. The data on INEGI do not contain borders of polygons. Because conabio.gob.mx. allows to download shapefiles with polygon borders, this datasource is our reference of assessment (matching the necessary characteristics). The terms of use stated by INEGI therefore also do not apply - the data of Conabio is usable only for non-commercial purposes (and therefore not open).
Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","From Enrique_Zapata in Forum: After these analyses, we would like to kindly request the GODI to take into account the following clarifications: Administrative Boundaries Inclusion of two new datasets: State and Municipality boundaries: inegi.org.mx/geo/contenidos/geoestadistica/catalogoclaves.aspx State and Municipality polygons: www.inegi.org.mx/geo/contenidos/geoestadistica/M_Geoestadistico.aspx3 Question B3, include all characteristics as present Question B6, there are regular updates made by INEGI more than once a year.
","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","80","80"
"72924359-3306-4ee3-8bd6-c6aaa3a13f5e","global","2017-04-04T16:50:01","2016","sg","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google for \""singapore government procurement data\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.sg/open-data-licence"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Awards per government office"",""Tender status"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.sg/dataset/government-procurement"",""descValue"":""Government Procurement""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Changed the availability of the data because it doesn't cover all the characteristics it mentioned before. ",,"Yes","Yes","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"0d8502f9-db28-48a3-99c1-b4378f348f14","global","2017-04-04T16:40:55","2016","hk","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Go to Data.Gov.HK"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.hk/en/terms-and-conditions"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Government Logistics Department"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.hk/en-data/dataset/hk-gld-gldetb-gldetb-tendernotice"",""descValue"":""Open Tenders issued via e-Tender Box""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Changed submission. Only open tenders appear, not awards. ",,"Yes","Yes","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"fef9d67f-ca1c-4962-851a-e8e424168d0d","global","2017-04-04T16:37:11","2016","ro","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data portal resources is no longer available, the data from the e-procurement portal can be exported as PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried a search engine for e-procurement in Romanian. https://www.e-licitatie.ro/ is one of the results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.ro/base/images/logoinst/OGL-ROU-1.0.pdf"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Agency for Digital Agenda of Romania"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.e-licitatie.ro/Public/Common/Content.aspx?f=PublicHomePage"",""descValue"":""E-procurement portal""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.ro/dataset/achizitii-publice-2007-2015-contracte"",""descValue"":""Open Data Portal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Changed submission because the data is not actually available for download.
Thank you to original submitted Arianit Dobroshi",,"Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","65","65"
"e4e80e18-77ce-4983-8689-51cae7af3a85","global","2017-04-04T16:19:30","2016","ru","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""google it"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.ru/information-usage"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Federal Treasury"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://zakupki.gov.ru/epz/opendata/search.html"",""descValue"":""open data datasets""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","RSS feed only allows for up to 500 entries when downloading the data",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Oscar Montiel","85","85"
"c2e0b24a-d0db-4578-815f-5c1bdfb0bb92","global","2017-04-04T16:04:16","2016","th","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I went through the https:www.data.go.th website and I found the งบประมาณ และการใช้จ่ายของภาครัฐ (Procurement) on the site."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.go.th/LicenceDetails.aspx?id=3a937417-8ccb-42a1-8923-a920851008db&ReturnId=cf4f29ce-5ebe-43b8-8c09-7352830f2f5e"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Comptroller General's Department and Electronic Government Agency (Public Organization) (EGA)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.go.th/Datasets.aspx?kw=%E0%B8%A3%E0%B8%B2%E0%B8%A2%E0%B8%87%E0%B8%B2%E0%B8%99%E0%B8%81%E0%B8%B2%E0%B8%A3%E0%B8%88%E0%B8%B1%E0%B8%94%E0%B8%8B%E0%B8%B7%E0%B9%89%E0%B8%AD%E0%B8%88%E0%B8%B1%E0%B8%94%E0%B8%88%E0%B9%89%E0%B8%B2%E0%B8%87%E0%B8%82%E0%B8%AD%E0%B8%87%E0%B8%AB%E0%B8%99%E0%B9%88%E0%B8%A7%E0%B8%A2%E0%B8%87%E0%B8%B2%E0%B8%99%E0%B8%A0%E0%B8%B2%E0%B8%84%E0%B8%A3%E0%B8%B1%E0%B8%90"",""descValue"":""Data Sest of Comptroller General's Department (CGD) CGD is one of the major central agencies that monitors, controls and administers public funds. The Department’s main tasks are to oversee and control public expenditure : to ensure all government agencies comply with all rules and regulations related to public finances; and to supply fiscal information, analysis and advice to ministerial top management and 1. Controlling the Receipt and Disbursement System The CGD facilitates, controls and streamline receipts and disbursements for Government funds countrywide. CGD is designated to issue rules and regulations on disbursement and revenue remittance. CGD is responsible for ensuring that the budget is expended in a correct and productive manner and beneficial to the country as a whole. The CGD is the cashier and accounting unit for government’s assets, liabilities, revenues and expenditures, the CGD is responsible for preparing all necessary financial statements and reports for policy-making bodies such as government and parliament. The CGD also designs, regulates and implements government accounting systems in government agencies including CGD itself as the central accounting unit and all other units that are required by law to perform accounting functions as an independent accounting entity. Additionally, CGD provides training programs and advice in accounting systems and procedures for all government agencies. As mentioned before, CGD controls financial management for the government. Consequently, CGD manages cash reserves throughout the country using technical tools such as statistical or econometric models to forecast the appropriate reserves both at the national and provincial level based upon past data. The CGD is responsible for compelling government agencies to comply with fiscal laws and regulations to maintain fiscal discipline. In addition, CGD is obliged to keep the laws and regulations updated to keep pace with the changing social and economic environment. The Department established auditing standards and manuals for internal auditors in all government agencies. In response to the internal audit literature issued, CGD also provides consulting services as well as internal audit training for its clients. 2. Administering Non-budgetary Funds With authority from the Ministry of Finance, the Department controls all types of non-budgetary funds including revolving funds, agency deposits, foreign loans, imprest cash, bill transfer and other funds excluded from the budgetary process. CGD will be responsible for improving government salary structure and pension system jointly with the Office of Civil Service Commission. Additionally, it will have to take care in the matter of other fringe benefits for government officials.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data is not updated and is not available to download in bulk",,"Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","70","70"
"0d94cd3f-2459-41cb-a4aa-f2cf3ef57d9f","global","2017-04-04T15:45:12","2016","lv","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I already knew the URL but otherwise it is difficult to find this data. Go to https://www.ur.gov.lv . You have to know to click on \""E-PAKALPOJUMI\"" (which does not mention open data) which will expand a submenu saying \""Atvērtie dati\"". Follow a link from there."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Enterprise Register of the Republic of Latvia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://dati.ur.gov.lv/register/"",""descValue"":""Enterprise Register open data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The link that would link to the license https://www.ur.gov.lv/atvertie-dati.html
takes you to a PDF document that explains the datasets but not the licenses.
Thank you to original submitter Uldis Bojars",,"Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","80","80"
"b66e47d6-3ed0-4b01-9b4a-a22c8bdaf0fd","global","2017-04-04T15:41:05","2016","pr","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""GeoJSON"",""KML"",""KMZ"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Conducted a search in website https://data.pr.gov/ maintained by the Puerto Rico Institute of Statistics."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto de Estadisticas de Puerto Rico - Puerto Rico Institute of Statistics"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.pr.gov/en/Desarrollo-e-Infraestructura/Mapa-oficial-de-los-Municipios/fvqe-f7x9"",""descValue"":""Municipal Map""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.pr.gov/en/Desarrollo-e-Infraestructura/Mapa-oficial-de-los-Barrios/bq3m-25mu"",""descValue"":""Barrios Map""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The license bit in the metadata doesn't specify the dataset is in the public domain, it is only a link to the publisher.
Thank you to original submitter Jacobo Orenstein",,"Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","80","80"
"6b033db3-aca0-4374-b3e6-c3322a0c46b8","global","2017-04-04T15:38:16","2016","pl","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google search's first page of results for \""country map\"" links to GeoPortal which then links to web-browser or data in a bulk."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Centralny Ośrodek Dokumentacji Geodezyjnej i Kartograficznej (CODGiK, Central Geodetic and Cartographic Documentation Centre)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://codgik.gov.pl/index.php/darmowe-dane/prg.html"",""descValue"":""Bulk download in SHP""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The license provided in is not open https://codgik.gov.pl/index.php/darmowe-dane.html
It states ""The Client has no right to reproduce, sell, share or otherwise to market or distribute the content Geoportal, in whole or in part, in particular transfer or share it in the computer systems and networks, or any other ICT systems.""
Thank you to original submitter Krzysztof Madejski","Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","80","80"
"2a8f5e4f-2c1a-49e8-8d1f-964227e5a340","global","2017-04-04T15:10:57","2016","fi","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""JSON"",""RDF""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""A link to the data can be discovered fairly quickly with searches"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Oikeusministeriö"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.finlex.fi"",""descValue"":""Semanttinen Finlex -project""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original submitter Aleksi Knuutila. ","Consolidated legislation data set is not openly licensed, as stated in the link provided. It is CC-BY-NC","Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","80","80"
"be9ad03c-3399-4eb0-b4c7-da5d181d4671","global","2017-04-04T15:12:32","2016","nz","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Most LINZ data is available for use and re-use via a Creative Commons License 3.0 with attributions Some data relates to personal data (property title) and an additional license is required for use. Aerial or elevation imagery is not LINZ data and requires a separate attribution""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""GeoJSON"",""KML"",""KMZ"",""SHP"",""SHX"",""WFS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""the datasets required for this theme are offered in one of these formats.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""specific datasets are downloadable. Users can view online without registering but registration is required for large downloads https://data.linz.govt.nz/terms-of-use/ ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""You are required to complete the online registration processes if you wish to:\n3.2.1.\tBrowse or appraise data that includes any personal information;\n3.2.2.\tDownload data up to 3.5GB (zipped), including the relevant licence and metadata files;\n3.2.3.\tConsume API or web services; or\n3.2.4.\tYou shall not use the LDS APIs in a manner that adversely impacts the stability of the LDS service or adversely impacts other users of the LDS APIs. Furthermore, LINZ reserves the right to rate limit or block applications that make a large number of calls to the APIs that are not primarily in response to direct user actions. https://data.linz.govt.nz/terms-of-use/""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"" Check through generic types of datasets to find right cluster then use search fields"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Datasets more relevant than maps for my purposes due to scale issues""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.linz.govt.nz/data/licensing-and-using-data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Most LINZ data is available for use and re-use via a Creative Commons License 3.0 with attributions ""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""some effort to set up and then can be automated""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" Land Information New Zealand (LINZ)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Government agency""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.linz.govt.nz/data/"",""descValue"":""https://data.linz.govt.nz/data/""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.linz.govt.nz/land/maps/linz-topographic-maps/map-chooser"",""descValue"":""LINZ Map Chooser""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Datasets include maps and Land Title information""}]","Yes","Yes","We thank Kay Scarlet for her contribution the Global Open Data Index.","LINZ staff are responsive to feedback for improvement of services","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","85","85"
"b2d8a729-df40-444b-9320-b86fb73d68c8","global","2016-12-15T14:18:18","2016","gr","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.minfin.gr/?q=en/content/terms-of-use""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""direclty from the site"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Hellenic Parliament"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.minfin.gr/?q=el/content/%CF%80%CF%81%CE%BF%CF%8B%CF%80%CE%BF%CE%BB%CE%BF%CE%B3%CE%B9%CF%83%CE%BC%CF%8C%CF%82-2017"",""descValue"":""Greek Goverment Budget""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""only in Greek so far. not translated in English yet""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is valid. Thank you Kleanthis Koupidis for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The General Accounting Office is responsible for the dissemination and publicity of the Annual Budget. Unfortunately, the General Accounting office has chosen to publish the related data in formats, which essentially prevents further use of this information by the public. The annual budget is published as unstructured PDF documents, while the internal breakdown formations change almost every year. This makes comparisons of actual spending with the budget , particularly difficult. Some experimental projects have been made using data scraping techniques , however, for a reliable and efficient solution the General Accounting Office should re-evaluate the data publishing policies applied.
QA note: Changed to data is not opened. Copyright - Ministry of Finance © 2014 ","Yes","No","Kleanthis Koupidis","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"ea887679-b53a-4541-affb-88e2b0fd6a58","global","2017-04-04T14:49:30","2016","cz","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google \""address points download\"" in Czech: adresní místa stažení"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Český úřad zeměměřický a katastrální"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Zipcodes"",""Addresses"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Data available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://nahlizenidokn.cuzk.cz/stahniadresnimistaruian.aspx"",""descValue"":""Website of RÚIAN (ČÚZK)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you Honza Cibulka for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The license does not comply with the requirements of the Open Definition, because reusability is limited, according to this URL: https://nahlizenidokn.cuzk.cz/Napoveda/index.htm?id=idh_podminkyuzivaniaplikace. ","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","80","80"
"aec2b1da-0df7-47cd-b32b-2c8f1b5eec16","global","2017-04-04T14:08:41","2016","ca","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""AsciiDoc""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Canada Post Website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Canada Post"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Zipcodes"",""Addresses"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Data available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.canadapost.ca/web/en/products/details.page?article=licensed_data_produc"",""descValue"":""Postal Code Address Data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you Tracey P. Lauriault for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The full specification for the file format can be found at: https://www.canadapost.ca/cpo/mc/assets/pdf/business/postalcodetechspecs_en.pdf.
Canada Post is a crown corporation and request to make this file open to the public has been made on numerous occasions.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","50","50"
"b5961bb3-20ed-4754-89ef-c9a2b9ec3599","global","2017-04-04T13:54:49","2016","ca","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Googled for air quality data Canada"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Air Pollution Surveillance Program (NAPS)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://maps-cartes.ec.gc.ca/rnspa-naps/data.aspx"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you, Tracey P. Lauriault, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The original submission referred to a database presenting pollutant emissions of industries, available by regions. Whilst this information is of tremendous value, it does not match the Index's required data characteristics, which is air quality measurements (the difference is that emission data measure pollutants at the source, while air quality data measure their concentration in the air). Pollutant emission data meet almost all criteria of open data, but are not consistently updated (Comment submitter: ""These are national data and are updated in an uneven way. Daily updated data are available from the provinces, territories and by cities who must report these data to the chief medical officer of health"").
The review refers to another dataset from the National Air Pollution Surveillance Program (NAPS).
It is available at: https://maps-cartes.ec.gc.ca/rnspa-naps/data.aspx. This data contains annual data per measurement stations for all required pollutants. It is therefore not updated. The downloaded file indicates that the data is incomplete. Therefore it is assumed that the download function is not bulk.
The Environment and Climate Change Website, hosting the data, does not allow for commercial use (https://www.ec.gc.ca/default.asp?lang=En&xml=5830C36B-1773-4E3E-AF8C-B21F54633E0A#copy). Therefore the data is not considered openly licensed.
","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","50","50"
"105eb591-745f-43c4-9c94-f4ab52619718","global","2017-04-04T13:25:00","2016","ca","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Statistics Canada Website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.statcan.gc.ca/eng/reference/licence"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Statistics Canada"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www12.statcan.gc.ca/census-recensement/2011/dp-pd/index-eng.cfm"",""descValue"":""2011 Census""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statcan.gc.ca/tables-tableaux/sum-som/l01/cst01/lfss01a-eng.htm"",""descValue"":""Labour Force Survey""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statcan.gc.ca/eng/nea/list/gdp"",""descValue"":""GDP""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you, Tracey P. Lauriault, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Census data are collected every 5 years, population estimates are done every year. For each census the data has to be retrieved individually (so there is no link to datasets containing time series).
As the submitter states: ""This data is very well described and has excellent accompanying documentation.""","Yes","Yes","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","100","100"
"27e7459e-96eb-46fb-8e87-09ae872bf53d","global","2017-04-04T13:12:01","2016","ca","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""GML"",""JSON"",""KMZ"",""SHP""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I communicated with the Map Librarian at Carleton University"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://open.canada.ca/en/open-government-licence-canada"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Natural Resources Canada"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://geogratis.gc.ca/api/en/nrcan-rncan/ess-sst/93b9a6e6-1264-47f6-ad55-c60f842c550d.html"",""descValue"":""Lakes and rivers in Canada - Canvec""},{""urlValue"":""https://geogratis.gc.ca/api/en/nrcan-rncan/ess-sst/4c9def46-716d-42c1-a29f-ca8291655588.html"",""descValue"":""Transport networks in Canada – Canvec""},{""urlValue"":""https://geogratis.gc.ca/api/en/nrcan-rncan/ess-sst/7e2e5007-c827-4ed6-b01f-706dbada7779.html"",""descValue"":""Elevation in Canada - Canvec""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you, Tracey Lauriault, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Each set is downloadable on its own, for the entire country. Updated as required. Some of the datasets are updated more frequently at the local level and those are produced by the provinces, terriroties and cities.
Data use requires geomatics expertise and software. As the original submitter Tracey Lauriault notes: ""these data were difficult to find. Also keep in mind that Provinces, Territories and cities also produce some of these data and these would be at different scales and would have different update schedules.""","Yes","Yes","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","100","100"
"db8919e2-e718-47b6-9c44-d7080358b8be","global","2017-04-04T11:30:13","2016","bg","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Environment agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you Boyan Yurukov for contributing to the Global Open Data Index","Air quality data is available on a daily basis, but only for air pollution concentration exceeding the recommended daily threshold values. THis data is available as open data here ( https://opendata.government.bg/organization/izpalnitelana-agentziya-po-okolna-sreda) as well as public data here (https://eea.government.bg/airq/bulletin-en.jsp).
The data does not conform with the required characteristics, that air quality data must be readily available per air monitoring station (also pollution levels below thresholds), or at least for the biggest cities. ","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"9ac7a7fc-58df-435d-9aa1-4ab565009002","global","2017-04-04T10:46:06","2016","gt","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1. Go to Segeplan's webpage segeplan.gob.gt 2. Select SNIT (Territorial Information System) 3. Select Downloads."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Secretaría General de Planificación"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://ide.segeplan.gob.gt/descargas.php"",""descValue"":""Ide-Segeplan downloads""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.segeplan.gob.gt/nportal/index.php/servicios/sistemas-en-linea/sinit"",""descValue"":""Sistema Nacional de información Territorial""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.segeplan.gob.gt/nportal/index.php/servicios/sistemas-en-linea/sinit"",""descValue"":""Infraestructura de Datos Especiales (IDE)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.segeplan.gob.gt/nportal/index.php/ide-descargas"",""descValue"":""Downloads""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you Daniel Villatoro for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The shapefiles that can be downloaded at https://www.segeplan.gob.gt/nportal/index.php/ide-descargas fulfils all the characteristic. There is a ""Access to Public Information"" law. It specifies access to information, but not whether the data can be freely reused by anyone for any purpose. Therefore the license does not count as open. ","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","80","80"
"a3d81664-0fd0-4c96-a39e-2b0a40563ca6","global","2017-04-04T10:07:25","2016","tw","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of the Interior"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you, lycurgus kk, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The original submission does not count as valid. The submitter refers to a spending list for subsidies (downloadable as XLS, and openly licensed as https://data.gov.tw/license#eng). According to the source website, the data presents subsidies by the Ministry of the Interior to the county government, groups and individuals of the subsidy schedules (aggregated).
The data is not itemised, therefore does not meet the required level of detail (transaction level, displaying the recipient).
Subsidies are also only one part of the spending record. Expenditure data from the procurement process needs to be contained. ","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"8f78a4f9-b39f-4ddd-a745-6308ff3eeb5e","global","2017-04-04T08:32:23","2016","nz","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Googled for NZ population, then browsed to Top statistics"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.stats.govt.nz/about_us/about-this-site/copyright-terms-of-use.aspx"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Statistics New Zealand"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.stats.govt.nz/browse_for_stats/snapshots-of-nz/top-statistics.aspx"",""descValue"":""Top statistics""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.stats.govt.nz/"",""descValue"":""Statistics New Zealand homepage""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.stats.govt.nz/browse_for_stats/population.aspx"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.stats.govt.nz/browse_for_stats/economic_indicators/GDP.aspx"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.stats.govt.nz/browse_for_stats/income-and-work/employment_and_unemployment.aspx"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.stats.govt.nz/infoshare/"",""descValue"":""Infoshare database""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you Jonathan Hunt for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Added XLS format to B8, updated B9 to 2 as data is in XLS & CVS files.","Population statistics are outdated. Last census data relate to 2013, latest birth and death statistics are available for 2015 (an update of annual data for 2016 was postponed from February 2017 to May 2017).
GDP for latest quarter via https://www.stats.govt.nz/tools_and_services/releases_csv_files/csv-files-for-infoshare.aspx, but not clear which rows apply to GDP without additional research.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","85","85"
"c60ce425-6e10-4096-b0cb-66fbd1fb4ad3","global","2017-04-04T08:14:02","2016","th","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I went through the https://service.nso.go.th/ website and I found the National Statistics on the site."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://service.nso.go.th/nso/web/about/webpolicy03.pdf https://service.nso.go.th/nso/web/about/webpolicy02.pdf https://service.nso.go.th/nso/web/about/webpolicy01.pdf"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Statistical Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://164.115.22.198/statv2/bipage/national%20Accounts.html"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://164.115.22.198/statv2/bipage/Labor.html"",""descValue"":""Labour data""},{""urlValue"":""https://164.115.22.198/statv2/bipage/pop.html"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://web.nso.go.th/"",""descValue"":""National Statistical Office main site""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data for Gross Domestic Product (annual) and Gross National Product (quarterly) are not updated. Therefore the original submission was amended.
Thank you Phimluck Klangwichit for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","1) Administration and Management of National Statistical System. The statistical system in Thailand is regarded as the decentralized system; the National Statistical Office has played the major role in producing basic statistics, while the other government agencies can also produce statistics for their own purposes. Thus to respond the needs of users effectively and cost effective, the National Statistical Office has set up the first – ever Statistical Master Plan (2011 – 2015) for being a tool in administration and management statistical system of the country in order to produce standardized and harmonized statistics. The National Statistical Office also introduces StatXML and web service to link and exchange statistical information to be jointly used among government agencies. 2) Statistical Data Production. Data Production is regarded as one of the major mission of the National Statistical Office, especially the production of Basic Statistics for policy and measures formulation, including monitoring and evaluation of the economic and social development of the country. There are about 20 – 25 projects of statistical surveys and census conducted each year, based on strictly statistical techniques. In addition around 10 -15 projects of special surveys on public opinion, concerning interesting issues, are conducted to seek public opinion on the Government policies, and the needs from the Government. Moreover, the National Statistical Office has done also statistical analysis with its own produced data then presented some related indicators for measuring economic and social trends. 3) Statistical Service. There are various means in providing statistical service by the National Statistical Office, i.e. publication, CD-ROM, Databank and via internet of NSO website at https://www.nso.go.th Data provided are of both NSO production and of which other statistical agencies. The National Statistical Office also provides training courses on statistics and computer, including advisory service. The service also includes the consultation about the use of statistical data and special request of statistical tabulation. The users of both public and private sectors in and outside the country can equally access to our statistical service.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","85","85"
"96286dac-2720-47ab-903b-d0570b467312","global","2017-04-03T21:37:39","2016","tr","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""index stesine giriş yaptım. National statistic bölümüne girip adımları takip ettim."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.turkstat.gov.tr/PreYasalUyari.do"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Türkiye İstatistik Kurumu (Turkish Statistical Institute)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.tuik.gov.tr/"",""descValue"":""Türkiye İstatistik Kurumu (Turkish)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.turkstat.gov.tr/Start.do"",""descValue"":""Turkish Statistical Institute (English)""},{""urlValue"":""www.officialstatistics.gov.tr"",""descValue"":""Statistics portal (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.turkstat.gov.tr/PreTablo.do?alt_id=1007"",""descValue"":""Labour data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.turkstat.gov.tr/PreTablo.do?alt_id=1027"",""descValue"":""Population data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Thank you Zeynep Yılmaz for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Amended name of agency to Türkiye İstatistik Kurumu (Turkish Statistical Institute). Data is not updated according to the required timeframe since GDP data is outdated (2015). Added XLS format, removed CVS & RDF as not found (data either XLS, Word doc, or HTML). Added link to legal notice.
","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","85","85"
"48296f81-f25e-4e6e-9951-31062c42d9f3","global","2017-04-03T21:29:59","2016","cr","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" Tribunal Supremo de Elecciones"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Election results per year (https://www.tse.go.cr/estadisticas_elecciones.htm) can be downloaded at once and they are available in XLS format, although by municipal level, not by polling station. All required data is available and open licensed. As the submitter stated, the files are not built as databases but as tables or tabbed document, which contain macros and formulas, which results in extensive effort to make data usable.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"4cf7f895-3bb5-4789-a67b-051c105f6e12","global","2017-04-03T21:26:03","2016","ro","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Once I found the Statistics Institute, you have to browse through the menus quite a bit to find them per the criteria."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.insse.ro/cms/en/content/copyrighten"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Statistics Institute, Romania"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.insse.ro/cms/en"",""descValue"":""National Statistics Institute main website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.insse.ro/cms/en/comunicate-de-presa-view?field_categorie_value_i18n[0]=6&field_categorie_value_i18n[1]=14&field_categorie_value_i18n[2]=15&created=1&field_cuvinte_cheie_value=&items_per_page=20"",""descValue"":""National Statistics Institute, Romania - Press releases""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.insse.ro/cms/en/content/gross-domestic-product-fourth-quarter-2016-provisional-data-1"",""descValue"":""Latest GDP data (with link to table for past years/quarters)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.insse.ro/cms/en/content/ilo-unemployment-31"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.insse.ro/cms/en/content/vital-statistics-24"",""descValue"":""Population data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you Arianit Dobroshi for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Found website very difficult to navigate and find data, man pages contain no relevant content - data was found through press releases page provided.","The original submission referred to birth rates. However, a census of the entire national population is required to be available.
Census data is not provided in machine-readable formats. Since not all characteristics are in the required file formats (some are provided in XLS), this category does not count as machine-readable. ","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","65","65"
"0f38d4e3-44d6-4a6a-8ab5-0034b761653f","global","2017-04-03T20:53:30","2016","do","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"" Busqué en google la página de JCE; una vez allí busqué en las distintas pestañas, hasta que bajo la pestaña \""dependencias\"" ví una subpestaña denominada \""elecciones 2016\"". Hice click en dicha pestaña y allí encontré varios varios cuadros que dan acceso a descargar los resultados electorales por nivel de elección, pero estos están en PDF. Al final, se encuentra uno denominado \""Excel por Colegios\"". "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" Junta Central Electoral"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://transparencia.jce.gob.do/Repositorio/EntryId/5413"",""descValue"":""Junta Central Electoral (JCE) Website""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Finding the data requires an extensive effort. Searched for elections results on Google, arrived in a webpage from JGE with the results available as PDFs hosted in ISSUU, downloadable as PDFs files. After that, it required further exploration of the website, to the Dependencias section where we can access the 2016 election results in PDF files. They do have all the required and optional data by electoral zone. By accessing to a new page, which accounts as the portal for electoral data (https://transparencia.jce.gob.do/Repositorio/EntryId/5395) it is possible to download the data as a XLSX files, with data by polling station. Same with past elections (https://jce.gob.do/Dependencias/Elecciones/Elecciones-Anteriores). Submitter also had similar trouble finding the data.
License seems to be closed. Paragraph reads: ""All contents of the Portal de Transparencia de la Junta Central Electoral Web Site are: Derechos Reservados 2017 JCE and/or its suppliers. All rights reserved.""",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","80","80"
"6558c6d8-93b7-4ece-b493-aac9ed471586","global","2017-04-03T20:34:25","2016","mk","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON"",""PX"",""TSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched for the Statistical Agency of Macedonia. The statistical data portal is similar to what some other countries in the region are using."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""State Statistical Office of the Republic of Macedonia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.stat.gov.mk/Default_en.aspx"",""descValue"":""State Statistical Office of the Republic of Macedonia""},{""urlValue"":""https://makstat.stat.gov.mk/PXWeb/pxweb/en/MakStat/MakStat__Naselenie__Vitalna"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://makstat.stat.gov.mk/PXWeb/pxweb/en/MakStat/MakStat__PazarNaTrud__Plati"",""descValue"":""Labour market data""},{""urlValue"":""https://makstat.stat.gov.mk/PXWeb/pxweb/en/MakStat/MakStat__PazarNaTrud__Plati"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.stat.gov.mk/IndikatoriTS_en.aspx?id=14"",""descValue"":""Key indicator - unemployment""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Original submission stated that the data is openly licensed referring to Article 44 of the Law on State Statistics: ""Official statistical data published in accordance with the Programme shall be public and available to anyone, and shall be published by the Office and the authorised bodies.""
However this does not specify free reusability by anyone for any purpose.
Quarterly unemployment statistics can be found in the key indicators section of the website in HTML format (main statistics database has yearly data).","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","80","80"
"eed84f27-6617-405f-b1ee-8750969bcb80","global","2017-04-03T20:20:39","2016","lv","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""PX"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Go to the main page of https://www.csb.gov.lv/ and press sidebar button \""Datubāzes\"". You will find a page that lists the different statistics datasets available."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://likumi.lv/ta/id/50601-informacijas-atklatibas-likums#p-564240"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Centrālā statistikas pārvalde"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.csb.gov.lv/dati/statistikas-datubazes-28270.html"",""descValue"":""Statistikas datubāze""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.csb.gov.lv/en/dati/statistics-database-30501.html"",""descValue"":""Statistics Database""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.csb.gov.lv/en/statistikas-temas/gross-domestic-product-key-indicators-30517.html"",""descValue"":""GDP data (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.csb.gov.lv/en/statistikas-temas/population-key-indicators-30624.html"",""descValue"":""Population data (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.csb.gov.lv/en/statistikas-temas/employment-and-unemployment-key-indicators-30679.html"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data (English)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Uldis Bojars for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Website easy to navigate and data regularly updated.","According to the Freedom of Information Law the information that is published by institutions providing state functions can be interpreted as ""generally accessible information"" that is compatible with Public domain approach. The law does not require for the institutions to publish declarations or licenses with the information (they can be provided on voluntary basis).
Update frequency: GDP quarterly (most recent Q4 2016), population monthly (most recent M2 2017), unemployment quarterly (most recent Q4 2016)","Yes","Yes","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","100","100"
"1190597f-8678-4e94-b94c-9fc8b3e5f67a","global","2017-04-03T20:20:22","2016","pk","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" Election Commission of Pakistan"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data is only available for constituencies, not by polling station. Data available (https://data.gov.ro/organization/autoritatea-electorala-permanenta) include results for major electoral contests, registered votes and invalid votes, but no information on spoiled ballots. Data is up to date, in HTML format. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"25fd12ba-9e17-40e6-900f-3b32c5f62ad7","global","2017-04-03T20:18:11","2016","ru","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" Central Election Commission of the Russian Federation"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data is up to date, in XML format, only for electoral zones, not by polling station. License states that “information placed in the form of public data is publicly available (Article 7, paragraph 4, of Federal Law No. 149-FZ), which means that there are no restrictions on its use (Article 7, paragraph 1, of Federal Law No. 149-FZ)”. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"ac20b902-bd98-4199-84bf-435e0dc3d4f4","global","2017-04-03T20:15:52","2016","nir","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" The Electoral Office for Northern Ireland"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data is available at a electoral district level, not by polling station. Submitter states that it's up to the election board in each municipality if they want to count votes for each election circuit (=voting place) or not. The spreadsheet includes votes per circuit where it is counted that way. For small circuits/voting places, results are accumulated to a technical circuit to ensure a secret election.
No information given on license of the data. Submitter states that machine-readable version was not available immediately following the election. Link provided by submitter with downloadable file (https://valgresultat.no/om-valgresultat?type=ko&%C3%A5r=2015) is no longer available.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"22835e46-55ea-4a77-b45b-49ff078a3a87","global","2017-04-03T20:14:51","2016","mw","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" Malawi Electoral Commission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Datasets are timely and available in PDF format, only available by electoral zone level. According to the definition of null and void votes, spoiled ballots would be included in this count: a vote cast is null and void if: the ballot paper has been torn into two or more parts; or has been classified as such pursuant to section 83. A null and void vote shall not be regarded as valid and shall not be counted in determining the results of the elections”.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"01e58b27-c1e1-4a25-9428-8203df381219","global","2017-04-03T20:13:36","2016","jp","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications (MIC)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","As submitter noted, data is nos available at polling station level. It is possible to download various types of nation-wide datasets at once, by election type and year. Submitter states that local governments collect raw data and Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications (MIC) gathers data submitted by local governments. This MOC's Terms of Use is fully compatible with CC-BY 4.0.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"9dc5c28c-9be0-47af-b4f0-c5970bffc8a0","global","2017-04-03T17:17:33","2016","it","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""normattiva is a very famous website for all the italian lawyers"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""public domain - article 5 of the italian copyright law https://www.normattiva.it/uri-res/N2Ls?urn:nir:stato:legge:1941-04-22;633!vig="",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Presidenza del Consiglio dei Ministri"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.normattiva.it/"",""descValue"":""web site with all the italian law""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The data is not in bulk and can not be downloadable at once. ","This is an amendment for the original submission by Maurizio Napolitano","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","85","85"
"ce1f22b1-f7f8-4a77-8f29-bfc7514fc81c","global","2017-04-03T17:14:15","2016","gh","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you, Franka Vaughan, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Data are only available on an aggregated level, but not as transactions to single recipients (here: https://www.mofep.gov.gh/?q=fiscal-data)","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"1402a08d-bb25-463b-9ad9-58d53262a609","global","2017-04-03T17:13:32","2016","tn","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""select statistics area or key indicators"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ins.tn/"",""descValue"":""National Statistics Insitute""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mizaniatouna.gov.tn/tunisia/template_fr/"",""descValue"":""IZANIATOUNA PORTAL OF THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE OF TUNISIA""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.finances.gov.tn/index.php?option=com_jdownloads&view=viewcategory&catid=9&Itemid=306&lang=fr"",""descValue"":""Budget Laws from 2011 onwards.""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mizaniatouna.gov.tn/tunisia/template_fr/ou_va_l_argent.php"",""descValue"":""Treemap for the budget""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mizaniatouna.gov.tn/tunisia/template_fr/boost_fr.xlsx"",""descValue"":""Full boost dataset""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The GODI team could not find an open license for this website ","This is an amend to the original submission","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","80","80"
"c1e8143a-5587-4175-95bb-15e844037b1c","global","2017-04-03T17:10:57","2016","se","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Googled for \""government budget\"" (statsbudget 2016 in swedish)."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""No specific As per swedish FOIA this document is likely to be part of a decision and not protected by copyright, However, no specific text on the webpage says so."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.regeringen.se/rattsdokument/proposition/2015/09/prop.-2015161/"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Finance website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.regeringen.se/contentassets/49618bcb4fd94b6081d9696f55bc7f8d/forslag-till-statens-budget-for-2016-finansplan-och-skattefragor-kapitel-1-12-och-bilagor-1-16.pdf"",""descValue"":""Draft Budget Law 2016""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.regeringen.se/4a6f5d/globalassets/regeringen/dokument/finansdepartementet/tema-statens-budget/bp-for-2016/bilaga-2-tabellsamling-makroekonomisk-utveckling-och-offentliga-finanser.xlsx"",""descValue"":""Table Collection macroeconomic developments and public finances""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.regeringen.se/4a7ae3/globalassets/regeringen/dokument/finansdepartementet/tema-statens-budget/bp-for-2016/bilaga-1-specifikation-av-budgetens-utgifter-och-inkomster-2016.xlsx"",""descValue"":""Appendix 1 Specification of budget expenditure and revenue in 2016""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data is correct ","this is a review to amend Peter Krantz submission - all the characteristics exist","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","100","100"
"59d9b4ac-9b73-4a17-9a7b-8236d57a3802","global","2017-04-03T17:06:46","2016","za","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""By prior knowledge I knew where the data was held, so I googled government budget South Africa and found the results I needed in the first search page."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Republic of South Africa National Treasury"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.treasury.gov.za/documents/national%20budget/"",""descValue"":""Republic of South Africa National Treasury""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.treasury.gov.za/documents/national%20budget/2016/Schedules,%20Annexures%20and%20Appendices%20to%20the%202016%20Division%20of%20Revenue%20Bill.xls"",""descValue"":""Link to excel file""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The website of the treasury does not have a license and it is not open. ","This is an amend to Tricia Govindasamy ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","80","80"
"b96f5b41-4cbe-449a-b240-7c9ad35eddc1","global","2017-04-03T17:01:45","2016","pl","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Simple google search for \""country budget\"" led me to the dataset. Steps: 1. Google \""Budżet Państwa\"" 2. https://www.finanse.mf.gov.pl/budzet-panstwa/informacje-podstawowe 3. https://www.finanse.mf.gov.pl/pl/web/bip/ministerstwo-"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://isap.sejm.gov.pl/DetailsServlet?id=WDU20011121198"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance, Regionalne Izby Obrachunkowe (RIO, regional chambers of accounts)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.finanse.mf.gov.pl/pl/web/bip/ministerstwo-finansow/dzialalnosc/finanse-publiczne/budzet-panstwa/ustawy-budzetowe/2016/ustawa"",""descValue"":""Budget bill with amendments""},{""urlValue"":""https://danepubliczne.gov.pl/dataset/budzet_resortu_finansow"",""descValue"":""Polish Open Data Portal - the budget of the ministry of finance (2001 - now)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mf.gov.pl/ministerstwo-finansow/ministerstwo-finansow/budzet-i-majatek-ministerstwa/-/asset_publisher/VU7o/content/budzet-resortu-finansow?redirect=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.mf.gov.pl%2Fministerstwo-finansow%2Fministerstwo-finansow%2Fbudzet-i-majatek-ministerstwa%3Fp_p_id%3D101_INSTANCE_VU7o%26p_p_lifecycle%3D0%26p_p_state%3Dnormal%26p_p_mode%3Dview%26p_p_col_id%3Dcolumn-2%26p_p_col_count%3D1#p_p_id_101_INSTANCE_VU7o_"",""descValue"":""Website ministry of finance - budget, revenue, expenditure 2001 onwards""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","All characteristics exist ","This is a revision submission ","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","100","100"
"0bd6ebf6-90f4-483b-a5c5-c23babd4896b","global","2017-04-03T17:01:52","2016","hk","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Treasury"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Hong Kong releases expenditure figures on an aggregated level and separated for different expenditure types (here. https://www.try.gov.hk/internet/eharch_annu_statend16_ds.html#p). Data is not separated as transactions to recipients, therefore the data does not qualify for the index. ","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"a948ca20-f161-4574-848b-364027050c76","global","2017-04-03T16:56:17","2016","bg","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""opened the page of the ministry"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.minfin.bg/bg/page/1101"",""descValue"":""Budget proposal bill ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Could not find a license on the Ministry of Finance website","This is a revision of the original submission of Boyan Yurukov. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","80","80"
"ef7d4c5b-a0b0-404a-88e4-afe5b5599d05","global","2017-04-03T16:49:34","2016","do","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1-Accedí a google.com, sometí una búsqueda con el nombre \""dirección general de presupuesto\"", 3-Entré a la página de inicio de la DIGEPREs; y luego, en \""estadísticas presupuestarias\"". Una vez allí pude acceder a los gráficos."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.transparenciafiscal.gob.do/terminos-de-uso"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Dirección General de Presupuesto"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.digepres.gob.do/estadisticas-ejecucion-presupuestaria/Home/"",""descValue"":""Página web de la Dirección General de Presupuesto""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.transparenciafiscal.gob.do/"",""descValue"":""Portal de Transparencia Fiscal de la República Dominicana patrocinado por el Ministerio de Hacienda.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The license on the portal is not open - Todos los Derechos Reservados - in https://www.transparenciafiscal.gob.do/terminos-de-uso","This is a revision to the original submission of Miguel Reyes Taveras","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","80","80"
"985d6282-d620-48fe-9b7d-f7f11a030fea","global","2017-04-03T16:44:03","2016","tz","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I knew the existence of the data, so it was a matter of remembering the correct URL."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Bureau of Statistics"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.nbs.go.tz/nbstz/index.php/english/statistics-by-subject/population-and-housing-census/258-2012-phc-shapefiles-level-one-and-two"",""descValue"":""National Bureau of Statistics""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.nbs.go.tz/nbstz/index.php/english/statistics-by-subject/population-and-housing-census/259-2012-phc-shapefiles-level-three"",""descValue"":""National Bureau of Statistics""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I could not find the dataset on the government portal which has this license - https://opendata.go.tz/en/pages/kanuni-na-masharti
The statistics office website doesnt have terms of use or a license. ","This is a correction to the original submission of Joachim Mangilima","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","80","80"
"6b0eca2f-7c3b-4b85-988a-12251e5d3b04","global","2017-04-03T16:42:43","2016","it","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ragioneria Generale dello Stato"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you, Maurizio Napolitano, for submitting to the Global Open Data Index.","There is an open data portal linking to a public administration database. There is information available on payments, but aggregated not indicating the recipient. (Link to open database: https://www.rgs.mef.gov.it/VERSIONE-I/OPENDATA/SpeseBS/2017/
Link to government expenditures: https://www.bdap.tesoro.it/Pagine/OpenBDAP-PagamentiBilancioStato.aspx)
The data does not qualify for submission.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"f306af81-a5ce-485e-bdd9-77c0a14e370f","global","2017-04-03T16:34:30","2016","za","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""A google search of administrative boundaries of South Africa did not provide me with relevant data. From prior knowledge I knew the source."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Municipal Demarcation Board"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.za/datasets/municipal-demarcation-board-district-boundaries.html"",""descValue"":""District Boundaries""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.za/datasets/municipal-demarcation-board-ward-boundaries.html"",""descValue"":""Ward Boundaries""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.za/datasets/municipal-demarcation-board-municipal-boundaries.html"",""descValue"":""Municipal Boundaries""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The license mention that third-party data that is publish on the portal (the case of this submission need to agree to commercial use. Therefore we decided this data is not openly licensed. ","The data is not really hosted on the portal, and the license therefore cant really apply to it. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","80","80"
"d7c8ee19-5758-4ae1-92a7-4e1c3cb16695","global","2017-04-03T16:21:59","2016","pl","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""First DuckDuckGo result for \""air quality\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Główny Inspektorat Ochrony Środowiska (Chief Inspectorate Of Environmental Protection)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://powietrze.gios.gov.pl/pjp/current"",""descValue"":""Website presenting current results + archival data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The index team found the license contradicting and confusing. Therefore, we decided the license was not open. ","This is an amending submission, changing the license to not open. Modifying the original submission of Krzysztof Madejski","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","80","80"
"f4810ee6-f279-4f3e-bc57-03f5abe0d0e8","global","2017-04-03T16:17:24","2016","pe","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""MEF, Minister of Economics and Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you, Antonio Cucho Gamboa, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Expenditure figures for executed budgets are available on an aggregated program level. There are no transactional data (including recipients) contained in the data.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"4b227b74-9992-4d73-be59-e747465fd149","global","2017-04-03T16:11:35","2016","lv","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""PX"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is not updated on a daily basis ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I looked at the previous OKFN index."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.vvc.gov.lv/export/sites/default/docs/LRTA/Likumi/Freedom_of_Information_Law.doc"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Central Statistical Bureau of Latvia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.csb.gov.lv/en/statistikas-temas/metodologija/weather-conditions-and-air-quality-latvia-38299.html"",""descValue"":""Air quality level ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data was reviewed and found that it is not updated on a daily basis. We changed the timely question to 'no'. ","This is a correction to a submission Toms Ceļmillers","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","85","85"
"d3dd6288-fe4b-427b-b1d0-94bfb2c15104","global","2017-03-31T23:54:47","2016","ir","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Supreme Court Audit"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct. Could not find spending data online for Iran ","Some spending can be found here https://www.dmk.ir/ShowPage.aspx?page_=form&order=show&lang=1&sub=0&PageId=1898&codeV=1&tempname=DMKTemplate but it is not in the right aggregated level. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0","0"
"bfe9fea6-65f6-433c-b450-1b9571071de8","global","2017-03-31T23:45:27","2016","pa","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Departamento de Presupuesto ANTAI"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I have found in Panama small spending reports, but these were without the names of the institutions that spent them. I also found - https://www.panadata.net/contraloria/ that shows full spending data, but it is not an official government source, and I was not able to find the source. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0","0"
"e7483ad5-7f23-4b6d-a4f5-7d1934befe8d","global","2017-03-28T20:11:29","2016","mx","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Secretaría de Hacienda y Crédito Público"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The portal does not have the characteristics to fit as the data we are looking for, nor is it in the right aggregation level. ","The data portal of budget transparency has a section where reports of the spent budget is available but there is no information about the vendors or the type of transaction. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0","0"
"0f0f3854-f24f-4cf0-bb04-87bc6032541b","global","2017-03-31T23:22:18","2016","ar","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Hacienda. Secretaría de Hacienda. Subsecretaría de Presupuesto"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data on the national portal is contracts and not spending ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0","0"
"e7497e3b-d017-4e2d-9a4f-77481e2f76f4","global","2017-03-31T17:23:56","2016","th","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Had to use the index results from last year. Could not find the budget on the https://data.go.th portal."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bureau of Budget"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.bb.go.th/bbhome/page.asp?option=content&dsc=ҳѧ%E0%A2%BB&folddsc=29001"",""descValue"":""Contains the budget for the fiscal year 2017""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Budget data is available as pdf, downloadable. However, there is no machine-readable version of it. No statement or license could be found that would indicate legal openness. The data could not be found on the official open data portal of Thailand. ","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","60","60"
"89854f23-5b48-4b77-b155-30da21cb11ef","global","2017-03-31T17:01:29","2016","tt","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Googled \""Expenditures for the Fiscal Year 2017\"" knew the search term from last year's index."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.finance.gov.tt/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/Estimates-Expenditure-2017-Final-Book-Numbered.pdf"",""descValue"":""Contains Estimates of the Expenditures for the Fiscal Year 2017""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.finance.gov.tt/category/final-estimates/"",""descValue"":""Planned revenue and expenditures are available here""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The budget is available in separate files for planned revenue and planned expenditure (pdf). No terms of use or licenses could be found that would indicate whether data is usable openly.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"9c295adc-a161-45b5-970c-8e2a16ebdc5c","global","2017-03-31T16:35:02","2016","tz","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Googled for Tanzania Ministry of Finance, did google site search for budget."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Tanzania Ministry of Finance and Economic Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.mof.go.tz/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=1158:executive-budget-proposal-2016-2017-as-passed-by-national-assembly&catid=20:budget-books&Itemid=205"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Finance and Planning, Executive Budget Proposal 2016-2017 as passed by National Assembly""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Data could be found in PDF format. All required information is contained, yet the data is neither openly licensed (no obvious terms of use could be found), nor is it machine-readable.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","60","60"
"1c81750f-7038-4620-bf5f-6cff8db05d78","global","2017-03-31T16:24:46","2016","pe","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Economía y Finanzas"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Datosabiertos.gob.pe does not show Peruvian budget data. The budget data is available in different classifications, yet only on the highest level (such as program level, as downloadable PDF, here: https://www.mef.gob.pe/es/documentacion-sp-19127/guias--reportes-del-presupuesto-publico). There are only the biggest sub-program budgets listed, which is why there is not the entire budget published online. The data does not fulfill the criteria. ","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"04cc8100-36b6-49ea-afee-1e47272f128e","global","2017-03-31T15:02:06","2016","tr","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Republic of Turkey Prime Ministry, Undersecretariat of Treasury"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"There are high-level figures on expenditures, but no data on a transactional level. The data does not count as available online.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"9433cc1f-b41a-4179-8885-197658736d34","global","2017-03-31T14:52:13","2016","bs","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Government of the Bahamas"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"There is no spending data available. Only a presentation of mid-year budgets, by department and cost group is provided.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"cb7e10a5-bb4d-431e-b964-718a526fed77","global","2017-03-31T14:41:12","2016","bd","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"No spending information could be found online. Only budget information were accessible at: https://mof.gov.bd/en/","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"f1e26389-88f6-4f68-86ae-5c875b497362","global","2017-03-31T14:31:45","2016","bb","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Government of Barbados Treasury Department"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"There are highly aggregated expenditure figures available from the Government of Barbados Treasury Department. However, no transactional data is provided.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"f10531ae-b6c1-4bb3-bf42-1e51c6821387","global","2017-03-31T14:23:24","2016","bb","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Barbados Lands and Surveys Department"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Usually this should be part of "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"No data is available online.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"c2683472-6516-4499-9f63-a67718651afa","global","2017-03-31T14:04:27","2016","bo","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Economía y Finanzas Públicas"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Some information such as press announcements could be found online. However, no detailed presentation of budget per department and sub-department could be found. The data is not available online.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"8852a244-4c2b-49d5-8012-e721661bba92","global","2017-03-31T13:49:11","2016","za","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Treasury "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","There is no transactional level spending data available for South Africa ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0","0"
"29b15536-45e6-46aa-b86b-0daa00a77aba","global","2017-03-31T13:26:33","2016","zm","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance - Zambia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Could not found spending transaction data on the ministry website or other portals",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0","0"
"96e8212d-a6f2-4f31-99ca-9ab10b166e1c","global","2017-03-31T13:19:46","2016","ve","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Oficina Nacional de Presupuesto adscrita al Ministerio del Poder Popular para la Economía y Finanzas"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data was not found by the reviewer. Reviewer didnt found a way to request the data as well. ","There is no data in transactional data level on the website of the Treasury of Venezuela - https://www.ine.gov.ve/index.php?option=com_content&id=543&Itemid=20","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0","0"
"d0b7bd86-8843-4d8d-b85d-bdae586a4344","global","2017-02-27T20:06:00","2016","us","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Note from the site: Agencies are required to submit reports within 30 days of making awards, except for the Department of Defense which delays reporting for 90 days in order to protect operations.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Looked for United States Government Spending"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.copyright.gov/title17/92chap1.html#105"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bureau of the Fiscal Service "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Individual record of transactions"",""Government office which had the transaction"",""Date of transaction"",""Name of vendor"",""Amount of the transaction""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.usaspending.gov/DownloadCenter/Pages/DataDownload.aspx"",""descValue"":""Filter for spending data from the Federal Government""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","While there is a notice on public domain, the website also have a new D&B that states the following
You shall not access, use or disseminate D&B Open Data in bulk, (i.e., in amounts sufficient for use as an original source or as a substitute for the product and/or service being licensed hereunder)
Except for data elements identified above as D&B Open Data, under no circumstances are you authorized to use any other D&B data for commercial, resale or marketing purposes (e.g., identifying, quantifying, segmenting and/or analyzing customers and prospective customers). Systematic access (electronic harvesting) or extraction of content from the website, including the use of ""bots"" or ""spiders"", is prohibited. Federal government entities are authorized to use the D&B data for purposes of acquisition as defined in FAR 2.101 and for the purpose of managing Federal awards, including sub-awardees, or reporting Federal award information.
This shows that it is not open ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","65","65"
"9df6e29a-cae1-4ea3-a116-cf0d048be435","global","2017-03-30T14:59:44","2016","ru","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Treasury Russia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission was pointing towards https://zakupki.gov.ru/epz/main/public/home.html to display purchases by government in a procurement register.
The submitter stated that there is a registry of federal government subsidies available at: https://rs.budget.gov.ru. This link gave a 404 error, it was not available online.
The Ministry of Finance of the Russian Federation shows a monthly list of executed budget: https://old.minfin.ru/en/statistics/conbud/execute/?id_4=25646. A web interface presents aggregated budgets: https://budget.gov.ru/static-report/mdxexpert/index.html?reportId=7fc2adbc-4ff3-45bf-a34e-b4fc88ca97f8.
Thank you, Ivan Begtin, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"a941f37f-d962-420d-9398-24a1c1ef66b3","global","2017-03-30T12:22:29","2016","tn","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministère des Finances"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The original submission referred to aggregated spending figures available at: https://www.mizaniatouna.gov.tn/tunisia/template_fr/index.html
This data is not conform with the required data characteristics.
Alternative sources are an open data catalogue, but no links to the data are provided (see here: https://www.data.gov.tn/fr/index.php?option=com_mtree&task=listcats&cat_id=77). Therefore the data must be considered not published online.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"6b933cdf-ff90-49d8-b4f2-91111188e0c8","global","2017-03-30T11:04:33","2016","si","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Commission for the Prevention of Corruption"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you, Arianit Dobroshi, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Slovenia's spending data is provided by the Supervizor application (see: https://www.kpk-rs.si/en/project-transparency/supervizor-73). As the official website states ""the aplication indicates contracting parties, the largest recipients of funds, related legal entities, date and amount of transactions and also purpose of money transfers. It also enables presentation of data using graphs as well as printouts for specified periods of time and other.""
At the time of review the application was not available at (https://supervizor.kpk-rs.si/), a 403 error was shown. Therefore it was assume that the data is not available online.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"4a188b21-4912-4e38-b49f-f89a7a0f5d86","global","2017-03-30T10:35:55","2016","be","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" FOD Beleid en Ondersteuning"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The FOD Beleid en Ondersteuning provides spending data as yearly expenditures (at: https://www.begroting.be/NL/figures/Documents/Uitgaven%202017ini%20NL.pdf) This data does not show single transactions and what the money was exactly spent on. Other data shows the planned expenditure, which is not actual spending data (e.g. https://www.begroting.be/NL/figures/Documents/AT_54K2107001.pdf)
The initial submission by Bart Hanssens is correct. Thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"f89d6455-1298-42e7-8c57-92c7901ecaec","global","2017-03-30T09:42:13","2016","at","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bundesministerium für Finanzen (Federal Ministry of Finance)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original submission by Mathias Huter was accepted. Thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The Ministry of Finance releases monthly information on implemented budget (available in XLS). The datasets shows the monthly aggregate spending of Ministries and other major State bodies of the federal level. It is regularly updated. (see ""Budgetvollzug"", at: https://www.bmf.gv.at/budget/das-budget/budget-2016.html)
Statistik.at provides spending data broken down into ministry or COFOG classification (see: https://www.statistik.at/web_de/statistiken/wirtschaft/oeffentliche_finanzen_und_steuern/oeffentliche_finanzen/einnahmen_und_ausgaben_des_staates/index.html)
Data.gov.at provides statistics on income and expenditure on a state- and city-level (aggregated to total income and spending).
However, none of these break-downs show what government entities spend the money on. No itemized spending data is available. Thus, the level of detail, required by this survey, is not met. ",,"Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"229fdabc-12aa-42cf-ae3f-78c53d3cd013","global","2017-03-30T06:02:42","2016","vc","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Electoral Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission since not all required data is available and data is available only for constituency level. Results available (https://www.stats.gov.vc/LinkClick.aspx?fileticket=fDQWYW2IFeg%3D&tabid=60Elections ) include results for major electoral contests, registered votes and invalid votes, but no information on spoiled ballots. Navigation for results is straightforward. Results of the December 9th 2015 General Elections and Summary of Elections Results 2001-2010 available in PDF format.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"66d41862-f235-4287-a254-e16b0c4e734e","global","2017-03-30T05:59:21","2016","py","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Tribunal Superior de Justicia Electoral"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data is available by constituency, not by polling station. By accessing to the 2013 general elections dataset through the open data portal (https://www.datos.gov.py/dataset/elecciones-generales-2013#), it is not possible to download the proposed datasets in CSV or XLS, getting a 404 error. There’s a message in the comment section indicating that this dataset does not present the whole general elections data, but only: Summary of electoral political division, Mercosur Voting results and Results of governors by department. This dataset indicates that is licensed under CC-BY.
When accessing to a website dedicated to these elections -by searching for these results on the electoral institution- (https://tsje.gov.py/e2013/) it is possible to access general results, registered votes and invalid votes, no info on spoiled ballots, in HTML format. There are no visible links to datasets in this website. 2015 municipal elections results datasets are not available.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"7a121c79-f05f-452e-892f-7f922d7e4d4d","global","2017-03-30T05:33:35","2016","pa","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Tribunal Electoral"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data available only by constituency level. Website has a confusing navigation, making it really hard to find the data. By clicking a banner indicating elections results (https://www.tribunal-electoral.gob.pa/html/index.php?id=1075), it is visibly stated that the data is “preliminary data”. By checking the datasets (https://www.tribunal-electoral.gob.pa/html/fileadmin/user_upload/Elecciones/elecciones-2014/Cuadro_01_-_Presidente.pdf), in PDF format, it is possible to access the results for major electoral contests, registered votes and invalid votes, but no information on spoiled ballots.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"3780bc39-da0f-4d5f-9b58-02485160c369","global","2017-03-30T05:30:36","2016","ls","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Lesotho Independent Electoral Commission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data available only by country level. As submitter noted, results available (https://www.spr.gov.my/index.php/component/content/article?layout=edit&id=74=) include registered votes, major results and invalid votes, no information for spoiled ballots. Data is up to date, available in HTML.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"b1bdcd69-19ce-41a1-8b18-174655ec4430","global","2017-03-30T05:27:54","2016","my","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Election Commission of Malaysia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data available only by country level. As submitter noted, results available (https://www.spr.gov.my/index.php/component/content/article?layout=edit&id=74=) include registered votes, major results and invalid votes, no information for spoiled ballots. Data is up to date, available in HTML.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"92210c8d-6333-4158-bd09-96776926e14d","global","2017-03-30T05:19:20","2016","pt","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Comissão Nacional de Eleições"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data is available only by country level. Results available (https://www.cne.pt/content/eleicao-para-o-presidente-da-republica-2016) include registered votes, major results and invalid votes, no information for spoiled ballots. Available in PDF.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"b73fdbe6-ec58-4cbd-ab76-032392297dd5","global","2017-03-30T05:14:24","2016","nl","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Kiesraad"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Not easy to navigate to specific elections and no information on polling stations available. Consistent format for data are CSV and HTML. No information given on license of the data.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"6a058337-8209-4291-8eb6-f4b7df346dfc","global","2017-03-30T05:10:32","2016","de","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Innenministerium for general elections, otherwise local level"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","All required data is findable but not by polling station level, but constituencies and municipalities. Consistent formats for data (foundable at https://www.govdata.de/web/guest/suchen/-/searchresult/q/wahlergebnisse/s/relevance_desc - General portal, https://www.bundeswahlleiter.de/bundestagswahlen/2013/ergebnisse.html - Bundestagswahl 2013) are CSV and HTML. No open license.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"2f8b0454-b39e-447d-b52a-fc102df9cfad","global","2017-03-30T04:59:26","2016","im","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Cabinet Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data is only available at constituency level. Information is available accounts for total votes, general results and rejected ballot papers, (https://www.gov.im/categories/home-and-neighbourhood/elections-and-voting/general-election/election-results/) on PDF files, updated timely and is open licensed (https://www.gov.im/about-this-site/open-government-licence/). Submitter states that there’s a Committee appointed to review most recent general election processes to increase transparency.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"8f427b3c-5a6a-422e-a331-d4c928c4b28e","global","2017-03-30T04:38:05","2016","th","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Office of The Election Commission of Thailand Department of Consular Affairs, Kingdom of Thailand"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission since data available by electoral zone (constituencies), not by polling station level. It is possible to access the data by PDF format.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"7d22626b-6c61-43fe-ad49-0d5345a00b61","global","2017-03-30T04:32:45","2016","at","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Interior (Bundesministerium für Inneres)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Information is not available by polling station, but for municipal level.
CSV format is consistent with required datasets. Information is also available in HTML. As submitter states, as for findability, that one problem is that the data also gets published on the Ministry of Interior Website, but without copyright attribution and also no link to the open data resource on the OGD Portal.
Submitter states that the Ministry of Interior is not publishing by themselves. They are asked by Open Data community to do it and then do it. So the amount of time between the election and the publication is not fixed or institutionalized, and takes some time.
All data on data.gv.at is open definition compatible so far, with a CC-BY 3.0 AT (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/at/deed.de)
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"59f0ea73-0380-43a3-b4eb-d98fceb50d33","global","2017-03-30T04:15:39","2016","mz","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Comissão Nacional de Eleições (CNE)\t"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission because not all required data is available and data is only available by country level. Results available (https://eleicoes.cne.pt/sel_eleicoes.cfm?m=vector / https://www.cne.pt/content/eleicao-para-o-presidente-da-republica-2016) include results for major electoral contests, registered votes, invalid votes but no information on spoiled ballots.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"3845e280-7f91-40b7-acae-714149931e53","global","2017-03-17T21:44:06","2016","co","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON"",""RDF"",""TSV"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""go to datos.gov.co and search \""Resultados Presidencia Primera Vuelta 2014\"", \""Resultados Camara Elecciones 2014\"", \""Resultados Senado Elecciones 2014\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://herramientas.datos.gov.co/es/terms-and-conditions-es"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Registraduría Nacional del Estado Civil"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.datos.gov.co/Participaci-n-ciudadana/Resultados-Presidencia-Primera-Vuelta-2014/2mw2-9wys"",""descValue"":""Presidential election""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.datos.gov.co/Resultados-Electorales/Resultados-Camara-Elecciones-2014/d2bu-6aca"",""descValue"":""House of representatives""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.datos.gov.co/Resultados-Electorales/Resultados-Senado-Elecciones-2014/fyi5-nzv3"",""descValue"":""Senate""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Submission was accepted. Invalid votes are available and include in its counting spoiled ballots. As it is stated in the organisation supervising the elections -Registraduría Nacional del Estado Civil-, “if the citizen mistakenly marks the electoral card, he or she may request a new replacement card from the voting juries. The suffragan must return the badly filled electoral card and verify that the jury annuls it” (sums it to the invalid votes) (https://www.registraduria.gov.co/Actores-Proceso-Electoral.html). “Broken votes” (“Votos rotos”) are not measured in Colombia by current jurisdiction.","The information is available at Colombia open data portal (datos.gov.co)","Yes","Yes","Juan Felipe Devia Rodriguez","Paola Mosso","100","100"
"375e76ee-b217-48d2-a0e2-79de0b1caa3f","global","2017-03-30T04:08:07","2016","gr","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Interior"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission since not all required data is available and data is available by electoral district, and afterwards by selecting Municipality. . Results available for Parliamentary Elections 2015, European Elections 2014 and Referendum 2015 include registered votes, major results, invalid and blank votes, no information for spoiled ballots.
As submitter noted, there is no button or link to directly download the data. Users may need to extensively scrape the data if they wish to download them.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"a8325ad2-edb8-4875-8be4-58076871b25d","global","2017-03-30T04:06:36","2016","sv","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Tribunal Supremo Electoral (TSE)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","
Rejected submission since not all required data is available and data is available by electoral zones, at some cases in more detail. Data available include results for major electoral contests, registered votes, invalid votes and several other categories (such as abstentions, missing, remaining and unused ballots), but no information on spoiled ballots.
There are different formats available for the latest elections results, although we are able to find the last major elections results on HTML format. 2015 elections data is available through PDF files and HTML (https://www.tse.gob.sv/resultados2015/). The data in HTML format is not easy to find on the website. 2014 Presidential elections in HTML + XLXS format (https://www.tse.gob.sv/elecciones/elecciones-2014). Possible to download the data at a polling station level, including the 5 categories 2012 Presidential elections data only available in HTML. Some data for previous elections is available in PDF files. As the submitter notices, to collect the data needs scraping conversion tools.
As for public domain, the submitter answered that the info is of public domain, but it is expressed on the Terms and Services (https://www.tse.gob.sv/modApp/tos.html) that: “Digital materials are owned by the Supreme Electoral Tribunal or a third party to whom the service is provided. All content and materials are governed by international copyright law, trademark. Any use that does not meet the purpose of the creation of the digital material will be in violation of said laws. The content found in all materials developed by Supreme Electoral Tribunal are not owned by the user who consumes them and a different use for which it was created is prohibited”.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"0fcb6122-4af9-4452-b72c-dcfa67b22ee7","global","2017-03-30T04:04:00","2016","bw","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Botswana Independent Electoral Commission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission since not all required data is available and data available only by constituency level. Results available (https://www.iec.gov.bw/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=15&Itemid=121) include results for major electoral contests, registered votes and invalid votes (rejected votes), but no information on spoiled ballots. Data is up to date, available in PDF, downloadable at once for each 2014 election. No info on historical results.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"8d5ba74c-c130-4d70-af54-836de5445d4e","global","2017-03-27T19:15:40","2016","se","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Geological Survey of Sweden – SGU"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Submission accepted","Original submission was rejected because could no locate all the parameters from B3. Sweden does have water quality data here:
https://www.sgu.se/produkter/geologiska-data/oppna-data/grundvatten-oppna-data/vattenkvalitetsdata-per-grundvattenforekomst/
However not all the parameters are present or easily findable. ","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"0dde85bf-8d59-47d4-a0b8-46366c5d60a3","global","2017-03-27T19:12:06","2016","no","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Norwegian Food Safety Authority (Mattilsynet)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Submission accepted","Original submission was rejected because I could not identify all the paramters for B3. Norway has an open data portal with water quality data here:
https://data.norge.no/data/mattilsynet/vannverk-vannforsyningssystemanalyse
However, even though the submission said all parameters were present I could not locate all the parameters. So I had to reject the submission.","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"2bf52c8b-5707-49d3-b6d9-53b10b775865","global","2017-01-23T18:52:46","2016","us","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""From USGS site: USGS-authored or produced data and information are considered to be in the U.S. public domain. While the content of most USGS Web pages is in the U.S. public domain, not all information, illustrations, or photographs on our site are. Some non USGS photographs, images, and/or graphics that appear on USGS Web sites are used by the USGS with permission from the copyright holder. These materials are generally marked as being copyrighted. To use these copyrighted materials, you must obtain permission from the copyright holder under the copyright law.\n\nFrom data.gov site: No license information was provided. If this work was prepared by an officer or employee of the United States government as part of that person's official duties it is considered a U.S. Government Work.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""KML"",""TSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""https://www.waterqualitydata.us/portal/""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Downloaded all data added from 1 Jan 2017 to 23 Jan 2017. Only 600 results (out of over 2 million water sites)""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to data.gov, entered in water quality, over 25,000 datasets came up. I scrolled down until I found a resource that was national and sounded comprehensive on data quality."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www2.usgs.gov/laws/info_policies.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Not a water quality expert so hard to say...table i downloaded is clear and labeled appropriately. More documentation could be provided on the portals on how to assess water quality data and what indicators to look out for""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""US Geological Survey"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Arsenic"",""Fluoride levels"",""Nitrates"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""List of all parameters of USGS data: https://help.waterdata.usgs.gov/parameter_cd?group_cd=% confirms the following characteristics are theoretically present. But county level information provides varying degrees of information. Not all states and counties are represented. The link to a map of all the sites where water data is collected gives a 404 error https://help.waterdata.usgs.gov/output-formats#nwis_mapper. National results coverage of all water quality data confirms data from all 50 states (Puerto Rico and Guam not confirmed) https://www.waterqualitydata.us/coverage/""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://waterdata.usgs.gov/"",""descValue"":""This site is the public web interface to the USGS National Water Information System, a system that is based on several development efforts that were established in our water science centers. This system became an operational production system in 2001.""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.waterqualitydata.us/"",""descValue"":""The Water Quality Portal (WQP) is a cooperative service sponsored by the United States Geological Survey (USGS), the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), and the National Water Quality Monitoring Council (NWQMC). It serves data collected by over 400 state, federal, tribal, and local agencies.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Submission is acceptable. ","https://www.waterqualitydata.us/ site is much more user friendly than https://waterdata.usgs.gov/ - not sure when this new portal was created? valuable addition and good to see data sharing across USGS, US EPA and USDA on water quality","Yes","No","Sierra Williams","Nisha Thompson","85","85"
"8a844761-060b-4eb5-8a7f-76fb0a08d4f4","global","2016-12-09T05:12:43","2016","gb","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""CSV and XLS are noted as the formats most typically used.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no single source or format for publication of spending data at the transaction level. Many departments and agencies record their spending data on Data.gov.uk, but it is not straight-forward to separate these datasets from other datasets within the Government Spending theme.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update periods are highly variable between departments but few update their data every month.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I have previously used Government spending data, so was able to find examples and supporting documentation by searching Gov.uk."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/version/3/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I have provided a standard link to the Open Government Licence as this is the licence that virtually always applies to re-use of Government spending data.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Individual data releases are usually easy to use, but it is very difficult to compare and reconcile data across departments as there is no standard schema or data dictionary in use.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""All Central Government departments and numerous other agencies and local authorities"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Central Government departments are required to publish payments data but there are some gaps in areas of government where responsibility is devolved to Wales or Scotland.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Individual record of transactions"",""Government office which had the transaction"",""Date of transaction"",""Name of vendor"",""Amount of the transaction""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/cabinet-office-spend-data"",""descValue"":""Cabinet Office spend data over £25,000 (as an example)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.uk/government/news/letter-to-government-departments-on-opening-up-data"",""descValue"":""Prime Minister's letter of May 2010""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/guidance-for-publishing-spend-over-25000"",""descValue"":""Guidance for publishing spend over £25,000 (HM Treasury)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""As there is no single source for this data I have provided an example and links to supporting information. (I have not included HM Treasury's OSCAR database of public spending as that does not provide data at the transaction level.)""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is correct. There are many URL to be added , but there is not enough space for them. ",,"Yes","No","Owen Boswarva","Mor Rubinstein","70","70"
"0cf47548-95ea-4d27-9775-a75d37c45142","global","2017-03-22T23:20:34","2016","fi","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""https://www.ilmanlaatu.fi/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Finland Meteorological Institute"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ilmanlaatu.fi/"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Evaluation done based on data filled by community. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","65","65"
"16b0ebba-00c3-4795-925c-265acbd6a73b","global","2017-03-22T23:15:26","2016","th","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Past evaluation."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.go.th/TermsAndConditions.aspx"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Office of Air and Noise Pollution"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://aqnis.pcd.go.th/"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.go.th/Default.aspx"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This evaluation was based on the data available before.",,"Yes","No","Ricardo Alanís","Ricardo Alanís","70","70"
"72ba4bb4-a7f3-4c92-9414-2bff6d6e5d2f","global","2017-03-22T22:48:37","2016","br","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" INCRA - Instituto Nacional de Colonização e Reforma Agrária ( National Institute of Colonization and Agrarian Reform); Ministério do Desenvolvimento Social e Agrário."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Bárbara Barbosa for her valuable contribution to the Global Open Data Index.
","There are some datasets available (a href=""https://certificacao.incra.gov.br/Certifica/certREPR_HISTORICO_IMOVELsrch.asp"">data about rural land ownership, aggregate data, montlhy national report with aggregated data). ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"0347af82-fab6-4cff-857e-f92bf60025b2","global","2017-03-22T21:23:57","2016","br","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""CORREIOS, Ministério das Comunicações "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"27385813-06f3-4f67-b7d7-bf9d70c8a6e0","global","2017-03-22T22:35:23","2016","be","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""FOD Financien / Kadaster"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Bart Hanssens for the valuable contribution to the Global Open Data Index.
","There is relevant data available as a view/discovery service - CadGIS Viewer Public. However, it is not fully compliant with the requirements of this theme. There is no accessible information related to land property and even if the basic info (ID, area, type) can be downloaded as CSV, the SHP / GML export with more details requires payment.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"cb883287-71b2-43e5-8fc1-17b107850573","global","2017-03-22T22:22:51","2016","au","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""TSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""GNAF is provided as Pipe-seperated files that can be assembled into a relational database using supplied scripts https://www.psma.com.au/sites/default/files/g-naf_-_getting_started_guide.pdf""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Dataset is updated and published quarterly""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""google search for national location data australia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The release of GNAF has been well publicised in Australia and worldwide""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.au/dataset/geocoded-national-address-file-g-naf/resource/09f74802-08b1-4214-a6ea-3591b2753d30"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The EULA terms are based on the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license (CC BY 4.0). However, an important restriction relating to the use of the open G-NAF for the sending of mail has been added.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Reference material is provided for the assembly into a relational database. A version has been provided this year in single PSV file format. https://portal.govhack.org/datasets/2016/australia/psma/gnaf-flat-file-in-psv.html""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" PSMA Australia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PSMA Australia Limited is an unlisted public company owned by Australia’s federal, state and territory governments""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Zipcodes"",""Addresses"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Data available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""GNAF contains address, postcode and co-ordinates for every address in the country""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.au/dataset/geocoded-national-address-file-g-naf"",""descValue"":""GNAF""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""G-NAF (Geocoded National Address File) is a trusted index of Australian address information. It contains the state, suburb, street, number and coordinate reference (or “geocode”) for street addresses in Australia""}]","Yes","Yes","I thank dearly to Toby Bellwood for his attention and help with this review.","GNAF is the national geocoded address file, and as such, it fulfills the requirements as it gives coordinates for all addresses including their postcodes, which is more accurate than postcode centroids or polygons. There are non-free versions of postcode boundaries (https://www.psma.com.au/products/postcode-boundaries) and centroids (https://postcode.auspost.com.au/product_display.html?id=4). The ABS also freely publishes approximations of postcode boundaries to coincide with the 5-yearly Census release https://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/Lookup/by%20Subject/1270.0.55.003~July%202016~Main%20Features~Postal%20Areas%20(POA)~8","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","100","100"
"7f7f1c05-f758-4348-9697-d2aed7b9173f","global","2017-03-22T22:08:31","2016","at","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Justice"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Robert Harm and Stefan Kasberger for the valuable contribution to the Global Open Data Index.
","There are some relevant data available, after registration, but not fully compliant with the requirements of this theme.","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"83845be4-0bac-4bb6-8fbb-22c0cd4cbce3","global","2017-03-22T21:41:53","2016","fi","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Land Survey of Finland"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"There is data available for parcel boundaries and ID, but no information on land tenure or property value.
The data is under an open license. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"0c7efb66-dd39-47c8-a151-2a33bea55738","global","2016-12-07T07:32:54","2016","fi","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Creative Commons 4.0 BY NAME""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""GML"",""SHP"",""WFS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""WFS is only available in testing service, not in actual production service. Also Mapinfo MIF available (not in the list).""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Services for testing the data is totally open, but you need to give your e-mail address in order to use the actual on-line service. ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Just google or look from the main page of NLS Finland"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.maanmittauslaitos.fi/en/professionals/digital-products/datasets-free-charge/terms-use-license/national-land-survey-open-data-cc-40-licence"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Land Survey of Finland"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://tiedostopalvelu.maanmittauslaitos.fi/tp/kartta?lang=en"",""descValue"":""File service of open data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","100","100"
"54d54979-53b2-4e0a-9f17-11d3441a740f","global","2017-03-22T21:06:55","2016","uy","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Dirección Nacional de Catastro "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"There are some datasets available on the National Open Data Catalogue, however they are not fully compliant with the requirements of this theme. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"38b9e070-efcf-4e5b-951c-9aa61047ef47","global","2017-01-18T04:31:07","2016","bs","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Registrar General’s Department"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is assumed that the Registrar General Department collects this data as it is required to present Deeds and Titles to this agency ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Unable to find a reputable online source for data regarding Land Ownership for the Bahamas. An exert from Real Estate Laws in the Bahamas by Dr. Peter D. Maynard stated: ""The title searches are conducted at the Registry of Records. As a system of registered land has not yet been introduced, such searches are a tedious necessity in an archaic system. In addition, a search is done of the cause list and files of the Supreme Court Registry. ""
https://www.maynardlaw.com/documents/real_estate_law_in_the_bahamas.htm","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"5b90c9fb-c8af-4d92-8580-f8b625485132","global","2017-01-18T06:47:14","2016","bs","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bahamas Postal Service"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The responsible agent for post in the country ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"It's reported that postcodes do not exist in this country.","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"7f9fc69f-4aa7-4314-87f6-ca08777fcb02","global","2017-03-22T20:33:39","2016","th","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Lands"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Phimluck Klangwichit for the valuable contribution to the Global Open Data Index.
","There are some search services (1 and 2), provided by the Department of Lands, but the datasets are not fully compliant with the requirements of the Global Open Data Index requirements. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"5d18149a-04ab-4b6d-a00a-cd8b80c2acb3","global","2017-03-22T20:23:01","2016","th","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Thailand Post"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""according to the Universal Postal Union""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Phimluck Klangwichit for the valuable contribution to the Global Open Data Index.
"," There is a dataset available form the Data Set of Bank of Thai, but it is not fully compliant with the requirement of this theme. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"6816009c-e6cb-40f5-a4e6-576287aceba3","global","2017-03-22T20:10:21","2016","th","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Rural Roads Geo-Informatics and Space Technology Development Agency (Public Organization) Delivering Values From Space Electronic Government Agency (Public Organization) (EGA)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Phimluck Klangwichit for the valuable contribution to the Global Open Data Index.
","There is a 1:1500k roads data available as a un-georeferenced map. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"b735307e-9d49-4113-81cd-6a4743e1a851","global","2016-12-27T15:26:46","2016","tz","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Lands"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The ministry of lands has this data, but it's not available online yet.","Yes","No","Joachim Mangilima","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"f5fb428e-78f8-4326-aef5-c1f7b7138638","global","2017-03-22T19:51:42","2016","tz","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Tanzania Communication Regulatory Authority and National Bureau of Statistics"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Joachim Mangilima for his valuable contribution to the Global Open Data Index.
","There are some datasets available from the Tanzania Communication Regulatory Authority and for administrative level one-two and three from National Bureau of Statistics, however they are not compliant with the requirements of the theme. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"49b4490f-b9bf-4b2e-84e3-ed1ed6452d7d","global","2017-01-20T01:51:59","2016","tt","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Land and Surveys Division of the Ministry of Agriculture, Land and Fisheries "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Performing a search requires payment""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"""The Land and Surveys Division of the Ministry of Agriculture, Land and Fisheries sells electronic and hard-copy maps to the general public."" https://www.ttconnect.gov.tt/gortt/portal/ttconnect/!ut/p/a1/jdDBCoJAEAbgp_G6MyUr2s2DmRpERqV7CY1tNXQ3bNMeP-sWljW3Gb4ffgYYJMBk1pYi06WSWfXcmXWI1lOkgWPiao0OTuNg4iGNTHtp9SB9A7E_74FHJ4toZyLif3n8Mu7P_IZL2AMbY35IB2BY8wVGeoTARKXy109SV-amLYA1_MQb3pBb058LrS_XmYEGdl1HhFKi4uSoanKuDfyUKtRVQzLAcKm3yT0406pdug8LzhQ0/dl5/d5/L2dBISEvZ0FBIS9nQSEh/?WCM_GLOBAL_CONTEXT=/gortt/wcm/connect/gortt+web+content/TTConnect/Citizen/Role/ABusinessPerson/GeneralBusinessServices/Maps+and+Survey+Control","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"2ea6160b-37b9-47ed-81a0-8f2a286afc78","global","2017-01-19T22:25:52","2016","tt","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Trinidad and Tobago Postal Corporation "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Requisite to access postal code: \""Please indicate the following when making a request for a postal code:\n\nThe full address of the location inclusive of number (building /lot / light pole) and street name\nAdvise on whether the address of the building is on the left hand or right hand side upon entry into the street\nIndicate any adjoining streets to that location (before and after)\""\nWe assume the information for postal code would then be relayed via personal email""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"From the Trinidad and Tobago Postal Corporation ""The launch of the Postal Code System (TT-PCS) on March 28, 2012 is also a significant milestone. As part of this project TTPost intends to launch an internet - based postal code finder that would allow the public to search for their own postcodes online from our website, whenever and wherever it is convenient to them. Currently, customers can send postal code queries to our email address at postcode@ttpost.net ""
This concludes that the portal is not available as yet.","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"3feaecc4-f69d-4609-84e5-dc9d41df62a7","global","2017-02-03T10:52:29","2016","tn","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The website https://www.poste.tn/codes.php allows to map a locality to a zip code, but the data is not open; however, no raw data is available and the data does not include longitude/latitude ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google search for \""code postal Tunisie\"" and it is the first result "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""https://www.poste.tn/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Zipcodes""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.poste.tn/codes.php"",""descValue"":""website""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","30","30"
"84b07c8f-3437-4511-b53c-38021beb784a","global","2017-02-03T11:48:07","2016","tn","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""La conservation de la propriété foncière (CPF)\n\n""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" https://www.cpf.gov.tn/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Katelyn Rogers","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"3abb6822-2d85-49b2-99a6-d399736c0081","global","2017-03-22T12:35:14","2016","ch","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal Office of Topography swisstopo "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Oleg Lavrovsky for his valuable contribution to the Global Open Data Index. ","There is a relevant dataset available from swisstopo, the Official index of cities and towns including postal codes and perimeter. However, it is not fully compliant with the requirements of the Global Open Data Index 2016, as the dataset does not contain address. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"d2200411-0da0-4ffa-88e2-d9201303c656","global","2017-03-22T10:25:28","2016","uy","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Correo Uruguayo"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"There are valuable datasets available form the Correo Uruguayo, but none are fully compliant with the requirement of this theme. There have been no address links to postcodes found . ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"ca69b6c7-a00c-4bc4-b7dc-43d34a86e677","global","2017-01-11T16:32:51","2016","uy","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""As this web site is a catalogue, the formats may vary, I selected the most used.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Go to Datos y Servicios (menu) and click Descargas and choose \n""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Go to ide.uy web site"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://ide.uy/legal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Look at 4. Condiciones de acceso y utilización del sitio web""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It depends on the dataset.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Servicio Geográfico Militar"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://visualizador.sgm.gub.uy/gmaps/index.html"",""descValue"":""Geoservicios del Geográfico Militar de Uruguay""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I have changed B5, B6 and B7 to NO because on the initial website provided I have not identified data compliant with the requirements of this theme. Thus, I have reviewed the view service provided by Military Geographical Service (SGM).
There have been other services indicated, such as this one, but it has not been working on the period of this reviewing process (app 1 month).
We acknowledge and thank Chino Carranza for the valuable contribution to this theme, helping us with insightful answers.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","30","30"
"d8bcfb11-ab25-48cd-9a86-ea374434c3ad","global","2017-01-20T00:38:40","2016","tt","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Land and Surveys Division of the Ministry of Agriculture, Land and Fisheries"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"I was unable to find a reputable online source for map of Trinidad ad Tobago. The Land and Surveys Division of the Ministry of Agriculture, Land and Fisheries sells electronic and hard-copy maps to the general public however I do not believe this would have been suitable for this survey ","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"8d6436bb-28e7-4459-b081-341d88fdd805","global","2017-03-21T22:50:56","2016","bs","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" The Bahamas National Trust"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Alesha Aris for the valuable contribution to the Global Open Data Index.
","The page Accessing Geographic Maps where this information will be is in progress.","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"9f2acc2b-ce24-4506-9815-d75984d674b3","global","2017-03-21T22:39:34","2016","tt","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Environmental Management Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Data was not found to be open and the current air quality monitoring network status could not be verified.","Yes","No","Ricardo Alanís","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"0621a0f6-7daa-44e8-bc18-bd4bbf059727","global","2017-03-21T22:37:20","2016","bs","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bahamas Environment, Science and Technology Commission (BEST) "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Open data was not found for the Bahamas.","Yes","No","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"aeedd486-2b30-4076-81a7-752bfd086777","global","2017-03-21T22:21:59","2016","za","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google->Site->Request Data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Environmental Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.saaqis.org.za/RequestData.aspx"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Data is only available on request. Also, data ownership is given to the cities, not open.
https://www.saaqis.org.za/RequestData.aspx","Yes","No","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"b466aeef-35d9-4e35-ac05-454a3cc5604c","global","2017-03-21T22:17:50","2016","si","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google->Site exploration->Data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Slovenian Environmental Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.arso.gov.si/"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Data is available but bulk data was not found.","Yes","No","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","65","65"
"10581c19-d56f-4603-ba99-946d510f0a0b","global","2017-03-21T22:13:45","2016","py","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Office of Statistics, Interviews and Census."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"No data was found.","Yes","No","Ricardo Alanís","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"8ffa723d-d984-4015-a899-d7a7312bb6d6","global","2017-03-21T22:05:03","2016","gt","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search google, enter site, avoid password."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Insivumeh"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.insivumeh.gob.gt:8080/calidadaire/datoshorarios.htm"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Data is available given the characteristics listed here.","Yes","No","Ricardo Alanís","Ricardo Alanís","80","80"
"12df0f94-2f69-4c26-8220-84e52dd08de4","global","2016-12-27T14:07:52","2016","tz","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Lands, Housing and Human Settlements Development"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The Ministry of lands has this data, but it's not available online. Upon request it can be made available mainly in a print out format.","Yes","No","Joachim Mangilima","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"487125e4-3822-46cc-a500-f81da425b878","global","2017-01-24T20:31:25","2016","ve","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""N/A"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Selected no, because I found absolutely no evidence that that is happening nation level. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"There is a law of land ownership, there is no data on how it is managed or divided. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"68b9c526-c768-47bc-82fb-03dedfaffc83","global","2017-03-21T21:31:54","2016","ve","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""IPOSTEL – Instituto Postal Telegráfico de Venezuela"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Mariengracia Chirinos for the valuable contribution to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"c91acff8-53c9-46fe-91b5-4dcdf868b944","global","2016-12-10T22:00:50","2016","at","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Umweltbundesamt - Environment Agency Austria"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.umweltbundesamt.at/umweltsituation/luft/"",""descValue"":""Homepage Umweltbundesamt""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bmlfuw.gv.at/umwelt/luft-laerm-verkehr/luft.html"",""descValue"":""Homepage Ministry of Environment""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ozon-info.at"",""descValue"":""Ozone App""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.umweltbundesamt.at/umweltsituation/luft/luftschadstoffe/"",""descValue"":""Luftschadstoffe""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Corrected: Data available in HTML format from Official Sources.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","65","65"
"488b35e1-6059-4bd2-9712-0720e774af8d","global","2017-03-21T21:14:01","2016","bd","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Environment"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No official source was found."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Data is only available from organizations or similar.","Yes","No","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"28480895-ef61-4fe8-aa15-fc5b01a4484b","global","2017-03-21T21:15:23","2016","al","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Environment"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Data was not found in the needed quality.","Yes","No","Ricardo Alanís","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"507ec159-1359-434f-b38f-61c05e955c85","global","2017-03-21T20:39:55","2016","ve","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Geográfico de Venezuela Simón Bolívar adscrito al Ministerio del Poder Popular para la Planificación"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"There is the official Visualizador geográfico del Instituto Geográfico de Venezuela Simón Bolívar, but it doesn't seem to be online anymore. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"784f33ec-b525-4138-ba7f-2745f214e5d3","global","2017-01-16T19:24:35","2016","ls","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Disclaimer: https://www.centralbank.org.ls/home/disclaimer.php""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled government budget lesotho, budget data lesotho, finance data lesotho. It took me about 15 mins to find something useful"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Central Bank of Lesotho, Africa Development Bank (Lesotho Data Portal)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence for "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Amount of the transaction""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.centralbank.org.ls/"",""descValue"":""Central Bank of Lesotho""},{""urlValue"":""https://lesotho.opendataforafrica.org/"",""descValue"":""Lesotho Data Portal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","There is no spending data for Lesotho - The links: https://www.centralbank.org.ls/ or https://lesotho.opendataforafrica.org/ do not contain datasets that meet the spending category criteria and does not have individual transactions. ",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Mor Rubinstein","65","65"
"b1de74f1-98ab-4663-bab5-b00154e6a6cd","global","2017-01-17T12:26:08","2016","zw","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"7a634636-4479-4c75-bcc4-ecd1a60abb8e","global","2016-12-15T13:00:53","2016","gr","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""JSON"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""RSS,API""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Expenses are published as part of the “Clarity” program of Law 3861/2010."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Administrative Reform and e-Governance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Individual record of transactions"",""Government office which had the transaction"",""Date of transaction"",""Name of vendor"",""Amount of the transaction""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://opendata.diavgeia.gov.gr"",""descValue"":""https://diavgeia.gov.gr/en""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Excellent!","Expenses are published as part of the “Clarity” program of Law 3861/2010, which introduced for the first time in Greece the obligation to publish all the decisions of government and all administrative entities on the Internet.","Yes","Yes","Kleanthis Koupidis","Diana Krebs","100","100"
"6a0b26ff-3cac-4603-96e4-c491fa676945","global","2016-12-14T09:57:36","2016","au","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of the Treasury, Department of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The Australian Government does not publish Government Spending data as defined by this census.
Aggregated Government Spending is published at https://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/PrimaryMainFeatures/5512.0?OpenDocument
and
https://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/mf/5519.0.55.001","Yes","No",,"Diana Krebs","0","0"
"685a413b-9b98-47b5-a5f5-a9356a6d41dc","global","2017-01-26T03:55:24","2016","ag","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Unfortunately I was unable to identify a government portal for the given datasets.
","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"a8809316-0aa3-4163-b06c-a6aa80a3a108","global","2016-12-27T13:56:21","2016","tz","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of finance and planning"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The data is available upon request from the ministry of finance and planning in a print out format.","Yes","No","Joachim Mangilima","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"0a558a8c-3481-43a6-9f84-8fe783f50c9f","global","2016-12-08T08:59:30","2016","al","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""PDF are offered as well, but they are not working. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""From the Ministry of Finance home page, I selected reports from the top menu bar and from the drop down selected Treasury. From there I selected Pagesat e Kryera 2016. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministria e Financave"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Individual record of transactions"",""Government office which had the transaction"",""Date of transaction"",""Name of vendor"",""Amount of the transaction""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.financa.gov.al/al/raportime/thesari/pagesa-te-kryera-nga-drejtoria-e-pergjithshme-e-thesarit/pagesat-e-kryera-2016"",""descValue"":""Records of government payments made in 2016""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Diana Krebs","80","80"
"2d234fea-623d-4994-b687-16f8115e3fb6","global","2016-12-12T09:18:58","2016","af","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The Ministry of Finance does not release information on the implementation of budget. There are quarterly reports but they are not accessible online.","Yes","No","anonymous","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"d5df67bf-948d-417d-a893-4c9a3d4d5343","global","2016-11-14T17:19:00","2016","se","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Regeringskansliet"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Probabably available in paper form after FOIA request.","Yes","No","Peter Krantz","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"7228e325-ddcd-4007-926f-cf187432c402","global","2016-12-02T14:14:45","2016","sk","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I've used URLs from last year."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.rozpocet.sk/"",""descValue"":""Official Budget and Spending Portal""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.finance.gov.sk/Default.aspx?CatID=3569"",""descValue"":""Section of official MoF Portal regarding Spending""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"There is summary information about spending on monthly basis available at https://www.rozpocet.sk/ and https://www.finance.gov.sk/ (see for example https://www.rozpocet.sk/app/homepage/rozpocetVCislach/monitoringStatnehoRozpoctu/mesacnePlnenie/2016/ and also for example https://www.finance.gov.sk/Default.aspx?CatID=10601) but those do not match the definition used by Census (above all, individual transactions are missing).
The data is updated daily which indicates it does exist somewhere in digital form of data.","Yes","No","Peter Hanecak","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"9aecfbbb-4eda-4878-8138-6cd459a7c292","global","2016-12-16T08:05:22","2016","sg","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The Singapore government publishes spending data only for open-tender procurement (https://data.gov.sg/dataset/government-procurement) and at an aggregated level (https://data.gov.sg/dataset/government-fiscal-position-annual).","Yes","No","anonymous","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"dd138f6f-b804-433b-9f36-cc3a5527d7b8","global","2016-12-08T21:45:58","2016","rs","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance, Treasury"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Aleksandar Ivić","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"eff6e581-5246-4690-b178-d18e5f16e5a9","global","2016-12-05T11:36:04","2016","jp","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Kiban Chizu Joho, 5m DEM data and GSI map are under protection of Survey Law.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""GML"",""WFS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Kiban Chizu Joho is provided in GML format.\nGSI map is TMS tile.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Major feature is updated immediately on GSI map.\n(such as new motorway, abandoned railway, major buildings)""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Need user registration\nhttps://ssousm.gsi.go.jp/piss/Attention.aspx""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Go to GSI, expand the menu of \""地図・空中写真・地理調査\"", and find those dataset page"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.gsi.go.jp/\n\n""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Geospatial Information Authority of Japan"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Kiban Chizu Joho contains all road data in Japan, so it covers national traffic routes.\n\nNational borders are on GSI map.\nlike this.\nhttps://maps.gsi.go.jp/#7/25.050769/126.232910/&base=std&ls=std&disp=1&vs=c1j0l0u0f0""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://fgd.gsi.go.jp/download/menu.php"",""descValue"":""Kiban Chizu Joho, National Basemap of Japan""},{""urlValue"":""https://maps.gsi.go.jp/"",""descValue"":""GSI Map of Japan""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.gsi.go.jp/kankyochiri/Laser_demimage.html"",""descValue"":""5m mesh DEM ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Data that can be downloaded is an XML document file or JPGIS2.x format, encoded in JPGIS2.x (GML) format.","Yes","No","Satoshi IIDA","Codrina Maria Ilie","50","50"
"e864b2b9-59de-4837-8f2f-0f0a0a5f78ff","global","2016-11-10T15:02:54","2016","tw","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""KML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""search on Taiwan's open data portal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.tw/license#eng"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Transportation and Communications"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Zipcodes"",""Addresses"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Data available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.tw/node/37759"",""descValue"":""Location datasets""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","Yes","lycurgus kk","Codrina Maria Ilie","100","100"
"f8b9e43a-7820-4410-ab70-88bc00e01d87","global","2017-03-20T23:34:10","2016","ir","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""reserved PBO country and use its content with attribution is permitted. \n""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""The right links were provided in the forum post on the matter. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""mefa.ir: https://mefa.ir/Portal/Home/default.aspx"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I cannot read farsi, but translating some tables with google translate gave me the indication that the budget is detailed up to sub-department and budget description level. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://mefa.ir/Portal/Home/default.aspx"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Economic Affairs and Finance""},{""urlValue"":""https://rc.majlis.ir/fa/legal_draft/show/1001514"",""descValue"":""Research Center for the Parliament Website Budget Bill""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mporg.ir/Portal/View/Page.aspx?PageId=53c97db7-9f2d-4017-ac5d-82d072ee5501"",""descValue"":""The 2017 budget""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mporg.ir/FileSystem/View/File.aspx?FileId=4fff0fae-4939-4f03-927a-00546f1cdc4c"",""descValue"":""Budget File in PDF""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept see comments above. ","Submission by the reviewer with the help from mkhani: https://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-government-budget-iran-new-submissions-required/4880/2","Yes","No","Anna Alberts","Anna Alberts","45","45"
"80854719-7c01-433e-a1fa-031140a04ce5","global","2017-01-16T19:11:39","2016","ls","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""© 2017 Ministry of Finance | All rights reserved""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The last available dataset is from 2012-2013: https://www.finance.gov.ls/official_documents.php?id=budget_documents&div=budget_book""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Googled"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance Lesotho"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.finance.gov.ls/official_documents.php?id=budget_documents&div=budget_book"",""descValue"":""Budget Book 2012-2013""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Very outdated!""}]","Yes","Yes","Some data is published, but not up to date. I added the latest budget document I could find. ",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Anna Alberts","30","30"
"4a059ed2-94cd-42aa-9989-9b776ec8f917","global","2017-02-03T10:43:20","2016","tn","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""la Base de Données Topographiques Nationale à partir des cartes au 1/25 000ème (BDTN25K) est en cours de réalisation au profit de la Direction Générale de l’Aménagement du Territoire (DGAT).\n\n(According to the CNCT database is under construction that will make a map at a scale of 1:25,000 available)\n\nOther maps are available but are not downloadable \n\nhttps://www.cnct.defense.tn/index.php/fr/produits-et-services/produits/item/183-cartes\n\nhttps://www.cnct.defense.tn/index.php/fr/produits-et-services/produits/item/185-bases-de-donnees""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Centre National de la cartographie et de la Télédétection"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Maps are also made available by the \""Ministère de l'équipement, de l'habitat et de l'aménagement du territoire\""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Katelyn Rogers","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"424289b5-4d3a-45fa-a3a0-780da649acc4","global","2017-01-18T17:32:30","2016","na","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I google searched government budget Namibia and it took about 5 minutes to go through the website to find this data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Namibia Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.mof.gov.na/"",""descValue"":""Namibia Ministry of Finance""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mof.gov.na/older-budget-documents/-/document_library_display/AUJmJJqOUYPx/view/345303?_110_INSTANCE_AUJmJJqOUYPx_redirect=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.mof.gov.na%2Folder-budget-documents%3Fp_p_id%3D110_INSTANCE_AUJmJJqOUYPx%26p_p_lifecycle%3D0%26p_p_state%3Dnormal%26p_p_mode%3Dview%26p_p_col_id%3Dcolumn-2%26p_p_col_count%3D1"",""descValue"":""Budget Document""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mof.gov.na/older-budget-documents?p_p_id=110_INSTANCE_AUJmJJqOUYPx&p_p_lifecycle=0&p_p_state=normal&p_p_mode=view&p_p_col_id=column-2&p_p_col_count=1&_110_INSTANCE_AUJmJJqOUYPx_struts_action=%2Fdocument_library_display%2Fview_file_entry&_110_INSTANCE_AUJmJJqOUYPx_redirect=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.mof.gov.na%2Folder-budget-documents%2F-%2Fdocument_library_display%2FAUJmJJqOUYPx%2Fview%2F345303%3F_110_INSTANCE_AUJmJJqOUYPx_redirect%3Dhttp%253A%252F%252Fwww.mof.gov.na%252Folder-budget-documents%253Fp_p_id%253D110_INSTANCE_AUJmJJqOUYPx%2526p_p_lifecycle%253D0%2526p_p_state%253Dnormal%2526p_p_mode%253Dview%2526p_p_col_id%253Dcolumn-2%2526p_p_col_count%253D1&_110_INSTANCE_AUJmJJqOUYPx_fileEntryId=345313"",""descValue"":""The actual budget""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept. Added the Budget Documents themselves. ",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Anna Alberts","60","60"
"c722963c-6bb5-45c7-a0b7-42d8604aa878","global","2017-01-28T02:05:01","2016","ch","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal office of Topography"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Can be found here, no acces to data https://www.cadastre.ch/","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"f582fb01-40b3-449f-b39b-4b80ddeafbfa","global","2016-11-22T08:59:43","2016","sg","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""JSON""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""User has to make multiple API queries to retrieve the full dataset. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""A one-time registration for an API is required. ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google for \""onemap API\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""OneMap is well-known as the government's geospatial data portal. ""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.onemap.sg/home/TNC.htm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Singapore Land Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Zipcodes"",""Addresses"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Data available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://docs.onemap.sg/"",""descValue"":""OneMap 2.0 APIs""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Zhaowei Lin","Codrina Maria Ilie","70","70"
"4714fa48-c10d-4677-a007-7e4e9c0b5017","global","2016-12-31T09:23:11","2016","mm","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The link for the official website https://www.mof.gov.mm/en""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Although I have searched additionally for the Myanmar Budget, using google translate, beyond an article stating the the 2017 budget was for the first time available, it was not possible to find it online. ","The 2015 result from the Open Budget Index shown that the data is exist https://survey.internationalbudget.org/#rankings
There are no evidence found from the Ministry of Finance official website to confirm that the data exist.","Yes","No","anonymous","Anna Alberts","0","0"
"b0ecef61-2382-4585-9af2-c32b0aec184b","global","2017-03-20T23:08:26","2016","se","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Lantmäteriet"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Peter Krantz for the valuable contribution to the Global Open Data Index. ","Only available after purchase. Two separate datasets need to be combined for them to be fully compliant with the requirements of this theme.
Price list https://www.lantmateriet.se/globalassets/kartor-och-geografisk-information/geodataprodukter/villkor-och-avgifter/avgifter_och_leveransinformation_for_geodata.pdf
","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"4c9934b7-d433-4781-ad80-3929cb1be583","global","2017-03-20T23:03:58","2016","se","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" PostNord Sverige AB"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"You can purchase data exports in machine readable form (CSV, KML, shapefile TXT, XLS) from https://www.postnummerservice.se/. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"3fd1079b-a4f0-4a36-a622-47a4a03cff2f","global","2017-01-19T16:25:29","2016","mz","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""All documents are in Portuguese and I only speak english. I had to use google translate."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Republic of Mozambique Ministry of Economics and Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.dno.gov.mz/"",""descValue"":""Republic of Mozambique Ministry of Economics and Finance""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dno.gov.mz/docs/OE2017/Lei_OE_2017.pdf"",""descValue"":""The Budget law 2016""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Anna Alberts","60","60"
"a57670ff-433f-47f0-bae5-5ae1eeb8b537","global","2016-11-25T04:53:36","2016","my","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""© Copyright Ministry of Finance Malaysia.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is up-to-date but previous uploads for previous years are no longer available publicly online. Example: when budget 2017 is already tabled in the parliament, the previous budgets are removed from the Budget webpage and replaced with only budget 2017.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled Ministry of Finance Malaysia and look into the website. Search for the word \""Budget\""."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.treasury.gov.my/index.php/en/budget/estimated-federal-expenditure.html"",""descValue"":""2017 Estimated Federal Expenditure""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept",,"Yes","No","Hazwany Jamaluddin","Anna Alberts","60","60"
"91ba0eef-1345-4199-b12f-c41490a900ea","global","2017-03-20T22:59:44","2016","ch","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal Office of Topography"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"1:500 000 map
1:1000000 map
","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"bfe3c29e-a7b2-4bf2-bf1a-a03758e931c0","global","2017-01-17T15:07:29","2016","mw","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Copyright © 2017 Ministry of Finance. All Rights Reserved. Developed by StarMedia Malawi.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I google searched Government Budget Malawi and found this source on the first page of search results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Comment Reviewer: I tried following these steps but to no avail. The 2017 Budget documents on the front page were merely the budget speech ad the financial statement""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Republic of Malawi The Ministry of Finance, Economic Planning & Development "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.finance.gov.mw/"",""descValue"":""The Ministry of Finance, Economic Planning & Development ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.finance.gov.mw/index.php/documents/doc_download/263-2016-2017-draft-program-based-budget"",""descValue"":""Draft Program Based Budget 2016 -2017""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Added another document: namely the draft budget 2016-2017. Hence, not the full approved budget. Therefore, I have indicated that the data is not up to date (only a previous draft of the budget available). ",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Anna Alberts","45","45"
"9a025d74-87d7-44bf-acb1-db4e1999a818","global","2016-12-12T22:13:07","2016","gt","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no explicit license, however we do find the following text under this link (https://www.minfin.gob.gt/index.php/2012-07-26-18-03-15): \nIn compliance with the provisions of the Law on Access to Public Information (Decree 57-2008 of the Congress of the Republic), we provide you with this portal, with the purpose of facilitating the exercise of the fundamental right that everyone has to access To the information generated, administered or held by the Ministry of Public Finance. In this way, it contributes to guarantee the transparency in the management and execution of the resources of the public administration.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Fist hit on google"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Finanzas Publicas"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""The bugdet is published only in an image PDF not in open format "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.minfin.gob.gt/index.php/?option=com_content&view=article&id=3311&Itemid=195"",""descValue"":""The Budget website 2017""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.minfin.gob.gt/images/archivos/preprobado2017/globales_060117.xls"",""descValue"":""the excel file for the budget""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Fully updated this submission. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Anna Alberts","80","80"
"eb37a1ba-c75f-4e96-b912-4fcce8aa4da0","global","2016-11-14T17:17:23","2016","se","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Also available in MapInfo format.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Via FTP server.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Account registration necessary.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""googled for \""öppna geodata\"" (open geodata)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.lantmateriet.se/sv/Kartor-och-geografisk-information/Kartor/oppna-data/villkor/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""CC-BY""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Lantmäteriet"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Based on the product \""GSD-Översiktskartan, vektor\"" and \""GSD-Höjddata, grid 50+\""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.lantmateriet.se/sv/Kartor-och-geografisk-information/Kartor/oppna-data/hamta-oppna-geodata/"",""descValue"":""Website of the Swedish mapping, cadastral and land registration authority""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Peter Krantz","Codrina Maria Ilie","85","85"
"808bb418-b8d2-463e-8e75-0688bb20b291","global","2017-03-20T22:43:21","2016","za","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Municipal Demarcation Board"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Tricia Govindasamy for the valuable contribution to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"bad886fa-f23e-4c3c-ab93-bb437c809f56","global","2017-03-20T22:41:17","2016","za","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" South Africa Post Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"There is some data available here, but I could not discover what is the encoding to read it. The initial submitter has specified that the data is not geocoded.","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"ddcca5c6-fb6a-4963-b8a0-a70674f0e9f0","global","2016-12-07T17:02:53","2016","co","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""En el portal web del Departamento Nacional de Planeación se accede desde el Home a la sección Programas/Inversiones y Finanzas Públicas, se da click para desplegar la sección Datos y Estadísticas y accede a Seguimiento , por lo que la información se encuentra a 3 clicks de distancia."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.dnp.gov.co/Paginas/Pol%C3%ADtica-de-privacidad.aspx"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""License text: Política Datos Abiertos\n\nSe podrá hacer uso, transformación, distribución, redistribución, reutilización, compilación, extracción, copia, difusión, modificación y/o adaptación de los datos y de la información publicados en formato de datos abiertos en este sitio web, en todo caso debe citarse la fuente de los datos objeto del uso, rehúso y/o transformación, la entidad productora de los datos publicados no será responsable de la utilización que de sus datos hagan las personas que transformen y/o usen dichos datos, ni tampoco de los daños sufridos o pérdidas económicas que, de forma directa o indirecta, produzcan o puedan producir perjuicios económicos, materiales o sobre datos y aplicaciones, provocados por el uso y/o transformación de los datos. Esta licencia de uso se rige por la legislación colombiana, independientemente del entorno jurídico del usuario, cualquier disputa que llegue a surgir en la interpretación de estos términos se resolverá bajo el amparo de la Ley colombiana\n""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""La información esta ordenada y clasificada, es fácil de filtrar, seleccionar y analizar.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Departamento Nacional de Planeación-DNP"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Es la entidad que diseña y controla las políticas de desarrollo económico, social y ambiental del país, en coordinación con los ministerios y los entes territoriales.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""El presupuesto se encuentra desagregado por sector, unidad o departamento ejecutor, enlazado con la entidad cabeza del sector, descripción de la actividad a ejecutar con los recursos asignados, así como el detalle de los recursos, incluyendo la fuente de los mismos.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.dnp.gov.co/programas/inversiones-y-finanzas-publicas/Datos-y-Estadisticas/Presupuesto%20de%20Inversion/Paginas/Seguimiento.aspx"",""descValue"":""Este conjunto de datos contiene información anualizada de los presupuestos del gobierno central""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept","Serie histórica desde 2009","Yes","Yes","Adriana Vargas Tamayo","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"1802259e-43d2-4f10-94ac-6cd887617baa","global","2017-01-12T20:04:16","2016","za","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""georeferenced raster data: PNG, GeoTIFF, JPEG.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I had prior knowledge on maps data sources. A google search led me to the web links."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Municipal Demarcation Board, South African National Biodiversity Institute, Republic of South Africa National Department of Environmental Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""bgis.sanbi.org"",""descValue"":""South African National Biodiversity Institute""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","https://egis.environment.gov.za/ / Republic of South Africa National Department of Environmental Affairs","There are GIS datasets and picture maps.","Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Codrina Maria Ilie","60","60"
"e3b220ba-4dfe-4e97-a6ba-fb66a8569ce8","global","2016-12-15T19:58:44","2016","si","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Copyright is claimed in the footer \""2016 MOP - Surveying and Mapping Authority of the Republic of Slovenia - All rights reserved.\""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""view/search service""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried an online search engine for \""e-katastar Slovenija\"". E-prostor is one of the results. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Geodetic Administration of Republic of Slovenia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Parcel boundaries (inc. latitude and longitude)"",""Parcel ID"",""Property value (i.e. Price Paid, Property Tax Value)"",""Tenure Type (ie. leasehold, freehold, protected lands, public lands, customary lands)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://prostor3.gov.si/javni/login.jsp?jezik=sl"",""descValue"":""Prostorski Portal RS""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Codrina Maria Ilie","45","45"
"b7a54a66-0c27-4a16-9a72-c1602c0baf58","global","2016-12-15T13:31:54","2016","si","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Unclear whether data exists. Emails to postal regulatory authority igor.sbrizaj@akos-rs.si and Slovenia Post info@posta.si cc vesna.sabeder@posta.si have not been answered so far. Will add a comment if they respond.""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Unclear."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"65267164-2989-407a-a234-4851b12366e1","global","2016-12-03T14:27:34","2016","si","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Free data available under Creative Commons BY 2.5 https://www.e-prostor.gov.si/si/dostop_do_podatkov/dostop_do_podatkov/\n\nfor the datasets mentioned above.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""SHP"",""WFS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Availability up to 2015.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Registration is required to get access to the data, see here https://www.e-prostor.gov.si/si/brezplacni_podatki/""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried a web search engine for e-cadaster of Slovenia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.e-prostor.gov.si/si/dostop_do_podatkov/dostop_do_podatkov/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Surveying Authority of Republic of Slovenia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Datasets include:\n\nbasic topographic maps at scales of 1: 5,000 and 1: 10,000,\nNational topographic model scale of 1: 5,000,\ngovernment topographic maps at scales of 1: 25,000 and 1: 50,000,\nSlovenian state maps at scales of 1: 250,000, 1: 500,000, 1: 750,000 and 1: 1,000,000,\ndigital elevation models DMV0050, DMV0125, DMV0250 and DMV1000,\nbasic geodetic system,\nRegister of Geographical Names 1: 5,000, 1: 25,000 and 1: 250 000,\nRecords state border,\nRegister of Spatial Units,\ncadastral zones and the same ratings from the land cadastre,\ncadastre of public infrastructure,\ncollection of real estate valuation,\ndistribution maps on network leaves and geolocation files orthophotos.\n\nhttps://www.e-prostor.gov.si/si/brezplacni_podatki/""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://egp.gu.gov.si/egp/"",""descValue"":""Surveying Authority of Republic of Slovenia""},{""urlValue"":""https://gis.arso.gov.si/wfs_web"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Some minor layers are available free of charge in the WFS format ""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Codrina Maria Ilie","85","85"
"218ce495-d47f-4661-9b3d-4302a7404e83","global","2016-12-05T13:46:15","2016","sk","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Go to data.gov.sk, find at least one Address Registry dataset, click the tag \""register adries\"" and we have list of all datasets from Address Registry."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.sk/dataset/register-adries-register-vchodov"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Interior"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Zipcodes"",""Addresses"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Data available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.sk/dataset?tags=register+adries"",""descValue"":""Address Registry, published via Natioanl Data Portal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Data from Address Registry is published by NASES (organization running data.gov.sk) based on agreement with Ministry of Interior (responsible for Address Registry).
Data is available under CC-BY license and is split into multiple dataset, copying ""upstream"" data model: from list of regions at the top, though counties, cities and streets to the list of actual address points. All the data required for Census is available, although some of it requires combining together several datasets and then running a query. Additional hurdle is that coordinates are not in GPS but in S-JTSK (Slovak norm).","Yes","Yes","Peter Hanecak","Codrina Maria Ilie","100","100"
"c77a3bc5-87c8-482e-b28b-0cac4519c691","global","2016-12-05T14:32:26","2016","sk","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Some portals are mentioned on Cadastre Authority portal or know from local media."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Geodesy, Cartography and Cadastre Authority of Slovak Republic"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Parcel boundaries (inc. latitude and longitude)"",""Parcel ID"",""Tenure Type (ie. leasehold, freehold, protected lands, public lands, customary lands)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://mapka.gku.sk/mapovyportal"",""descValue"":""Cadastre Map Portal""},{""urlValue"":""https://cica.vugk.sk/default.aspx"",""descValue"":""Cadastre Data Viewer""},{""urlValue"":""https://kataster.skgeodesy.sk/"",""descValue"":""Portal of Cadastre Electronic Services""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.katasterportal.sk/kapor/"",""descValue"":""Cadastral Portal (old one)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I have decided to consider this submission as valid, even though there is no data referred to property value, because I think that given access to name of the owner of a parcel is a very valuable and useful information.","In general, Geodesy, Cartography and Cadastre Authority provides data through several portals, each time with more or less different subset of data and functionality and each time quite explicitly not in machine-readable form and only ""for personal (small scale) use"".
In particular, data on property value is not publicly available, citing data protection needs.","Yes","No","Peter Hanecak","Codrina Maria Ilie","45","45"
"d0e00764-24e8-495a-abaa-dbee1e59e2a9","global","2017-03-20T20:05:04","2016","se","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""The site has a menu option called \\\""previous elections\\\"", where on the left is a list of ecelctions from 1998 to the lastest national exection in 2014."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Valmyndigheten"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.val.se/"",""descValue"":""Valmyndigheten (The election agency) conducts elections and national referendums""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.scb.se/sv_/Hitta-statistik/Statistik-efter-amne/Demokrati/"",""descValue"":""The National Archive's ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Submission is valid. Data is up to date, by polling station. There are many ways to select datasets, per region, per municipality. Final results for the last election are available in HTML, XLS, CSV.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","80","80"
"22803727-9af8-47e9-b413-0ab580026ef4","global","2016-12-05T12:44:31","2016","sk","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""view service""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I followed link from last year, it still works."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Geodesy, Cartography and Cadastre Authority of Slovak Republic"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://mapka.gku.sk/mapovyportal/"",""descValue"":""ZBGIS Map Client""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The initial link given by the submitter didn't ""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Maps are available via interactive portal without means to export data for the general public (other than printing in PDF). Maps are available in resolutions up to 1:2000 .
There is a copyright notice at the bottom of the page, apart from that, no other license is available specifically for the data - so ""No"" is indicated as an answer in this regard.
The data, though, should be available for download, even in bulk, machine/readable formats, for a fee. We couldn't test this functionality, therefore we couldn't specify the formats of the data other than HTML and JSON (as available though portal, discover-able with some reverse engineering).
To the best of our knowledge, the data for the whole of Slovakia is updated approximately once in 3 years. The map seems to be up-to-date at the moment, but no information about last updates is provided.","Yes","No","Peter Hanecak","Codrina Maria Ilie","45","45"
"c09b0a6b-ca3c-4c15-8af9-70338673b0c4","global","2016-12-16T09:18:29","2016","sg","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""view service""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search for \""Singapore land ownership data\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Singapore Land Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Parcel boundaries (inc. latitude and longitude)"",""Parcel ID"",""Property value (i.e. Price Paid, Property Tax Value)"",""Tenure Type (ie. leasehold, freehold, protected lands, public lands, customary lands)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.sla.gov.sg/inlis/#/"",""descValue"":""SLA Integrated Land Information Service""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","15","15"
"6b40c4f2-5f3e-48ac-9f8b-25fccb3cac33","global","2017-03-20T18:57:59","2016","rs","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Republic Geodetic Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Aleksandar Ivić for the valuable contribution to the Global Open Data Index.
","There is information related to land ownership, on the official geoportal and from the Real Estate Cadastre and Land Ownership register. However, there is no info on tenure type and property value. Comment from initial submitter ""Land Ownership is not searchable. For full information, it has to be used with Cadastre."".","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"b6c9b38e-0060-4b5a-8744-93699b23c7b1","global","2016-12-08T21:44:59","2016","rs","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Republic Geodetic Authority - RGA "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The legal mandate""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Since it is paid data, it is not widely used. The accuracy of the register is questionable. In parallel Post Office developed own address register.","Yes","No","Aleksandar Ivić","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"2c6d60cf-4540-4970-b1e5-af51fc846e5a","global","2016-12-08T21:23:40","2016","rs","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""view service\n""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update is periodicaly, period up to 5 years. Last one in 2013\n""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Third result on google search with query \""Nacionalna mapa Srbije\"" - Serbia National Maps "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""https://www.rgz.gov.rs/default.asp?LanguageID=3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.geosrbija.rs/rga/default.aspx?gui=1&lang=1"",""descValue"":""0,4 m for teritory of Serbia 0,1 m for 166 urban areas""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Data is Paid, Republic Geodetic Authority rulebook;
Available for free for governmental agencies which have signed contracts for exchange of data with RGA
","Yes","No","Aleksandar Ivić","Codrina Maria Ilie","30","30"
"bb442de2-246b-4f33-8fa8-2940f01ffb31","global","2017-03-20T18:27:48","2016","us","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""U.S. Census Bureau"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Katherine Wikrent for the valuable contribution to the Global Open Data Index.
","There are datasets available form the U.S. Census Bureau, but none are fully compliant with the requirement of this theme. There have been no address links to postcodes found . ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"37123062-4cba-4f2a-a1d5-b950ccfb6bdc","global","2016-12-14T14:47:47","2016","pr","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Basic fiscal audit reports for the Government of Puerto Rico are available at https://www.hacienda.gobierno.pr/inversionistas/estados-financieros-del-estado-libre-asociado-de-puerto-rico-financial-statements-commonwealth-puerto-rico, but only up to FY 2014, and without detailed records of spending at a detailed transactional level. There is an up to date contract database at the Office of the Comptroller's website and at data.pr.gov."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Puerto Rico Institute of Statistics sponsors https://www.transparenciafinanciera.pr, which is attempting to collect transaction level information of the expenses of all of Puerto Rico's government agencies.""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The Puerto Rico Institute of Statistics sponsors https://www.transparenciafinanciera.pr, which is attempting to collect transaction level information of the expenses of all of Puerto Rico's government agencies.","Yes","No","Jacobo Orenstein","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"63b7afde-490a-40d1-bc38-62014d6e31d2","global","2017-01-14T12:19:23","2016","pt","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search for government spending takes us directly to the https://www.pordata.pt/Portugal/Despesas+do+Estado+em+percentagem+do+PIB+por+algumas+fun%C3%A7%C3%B5es-2778 website."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""INE, PorData"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Information is either widespread to a different variety of websites or only the overall spending budget is available."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.pordata.pt/Portugal/Despesas+do+Estado+em+percentagem+do+PIB+por+algumas+fun%C3%A7%C3%B5es-2778"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"There is no data available on day-to-day spending with individual record of transactions and complete informationa about it.
According to IBP's Open Budget Survey the data exists (there is a year end report).
Portugal government claims that they have reformed management of public accounts but the link where the data was acessible in 2015 is no longer available and no other place was found with the information: https://www.portugal.gov.pt/pt/os-temas/20150504-reformas-estruturais/fin-pub/pin-pub-1.aspx .
Information available in INE https://www.ine.pt/xportal/xmain?xpid=INE&xpgid=ine_cnacionais only until the year 2011.","Yes","No","Joana Solipa Batista","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"f23c09e2-1e57-48b1-a075-76d654f05a35","global","2016-12-08T13:11:26","2016","pl","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Each institution does it on its own.""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Each institution does it on its own."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"eb66d214-2849-4165-b6a7-d4171cab01c5","global","2017-03-20T12:17:56","2016","ru","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""ФГУП «Почта России» (Russian Post)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Evgeny Karev for the valuable contribution to the Global Open Data Index.
","There is a .dbf file available from the Russian Post. However the available data is not geocoded.","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"2e8daa43-a96b-404b-b0dd-610decd257e4","global","2017-01-28T01:54:32","2016","nz","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Treasury of New Zealand"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"There are forecasts and reports quite updated but no actual spending data","Yes","No","anonymous","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"b59402be-c263-4707-9e9c-ba6ed036af9a","global","2016-12-20T10:26:20","2016","ph","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Budget and Management"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.dbm.gov.ph/?page_id=16451"",""descValue"":""Budget of Expenditures and Sources of Financing FY 2017""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Data is available at an aggregate level on the DBM website, but is not machine readable or bulk-downloadable. Details are down to the level of statements of receipts by municipalities. However, no data is available at the transaction level.
https://www.dbm.gov.ph/?page_id=16451 (Budget of Expenditures and Sources of Financing FY 2017)
","Yes","No","anonymous","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"e535047a-c3c9-45ca-8010-b90235c6c47d","global","2017-03-20T11:29:10","2016","jm","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data extracted from 'Estimates of Expenditure (Net of Appropriations-in-Aid),' of the Estimates of Expenditure for FY 2010-2011 through 2016-2017 -this is not the actual spending data, and it is not transactional. ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Ministry of Finance & Public Service (MOFPS)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""The Ministry of Finance & Public Service (MOFPS)"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data extracted from 'Estimates of Expenditure (Net of Appropriations-in-Aid),' of the Estimates of Expenditure for FY 2010-2011 through 2016-2017 -this is not the actual spending data, and it is not transactional. ""}]","Yes","Yes",,"There is no transactional spending dataset, I could not find the relevant data on the government portal ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","0","0"
"9abb4e65-713c-47ff-8081-799d399e214a","global","2017-01-20T15:24:36","2016","ca","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is supposedly available but link doesn't work. ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""In the Canada Data site looked for spending data. Data set is there but it's not updated. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Treasury Board of Canada Secretariat"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://open.canada.ca/data/en/dataset/2eed2fba-1626-4d2e-a511-389cc6b51ddf"",""descValue"":""Expenditure Authority for Current Fiscal Year (2013-14)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Data is supposedly available but link doesn't work. The data set would be found here https://open.canada.ca/data/en/dataset/2eed2fba-1626-4d2e-a511-389cc6b51ddf","Yes","No","anonymous","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"cf70c0f0-3396-4471-b574-c8827807cba5","global","2017-03-20T10:57:03","2016","bg","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://opendata.government.bg/dataset/plashtaniya-v-sebra-i-drugi-plashtania-v-bnb and https://opendata.government.bg/dataset/pernctbp-ha-o6wectbehnte-nopbhkn-no-3adbjixntejiha-npouedypa-ot-3ott \nThose links are a good progress, but do not have a transaction level data and information like the name of the vendor ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This is a really good progress from the Bulgarian government, but it is really hard to work with high level aggregated data like this. No transactional data is available. ",,"Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","0","0"
"a8532895-623c-454c-89e2-079f756573ae","global","2017-01-27T16:57:42","2016","bo","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Economía y Finanzas Públicas"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I could not find spending data at all on the government site: https://www.economiayfinanzas.gob.bo/index.php?opcion=com_contenido&ver=contenido&id=3619&id_item=439&seccion=221&categoria=303 Therefore, I can approve this submission that there is no government spending data. ",,"Yes","No","David Opoku","Mor Rubinstein","0","0"
"af9e902a-4796-4d23-b24a-0884aafcedcd","global","2017-01-27T15:09:51","2016","nl","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerie van Financiën"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"79ae29a9-a33d-4629-b793-5a7c7e05318a","global","2016-12-13T15:24:16","2016","np","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Government of Nepal, Ministry of Land Reform and Management ,Department of Land Reform and Management"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.dolrm.gov.np"",""descValue"":""Government of Nepal, Ministry of Land Reform and Management ,Department of Land Reform and Management""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"There are no links whatsoever. ","Yes","No","Manish Marahatta","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"bdfe42a5-cc25-4040-9e98-239b30e06391","global","2017-03-20T10:06:27","2016","np","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""General Post Office (GPO"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Manish Marahatta for the valuable contribution to the Global Open Data Index.
","The General Post Office (GPO offers a search service, however the data is not georeferenced. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"690427a4-01b0-4a3f-836d-1cc3d855d7ea","global","2017-03-20T09:34:34","2016","np","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" Survey Department of the Ministry of Land Reform and Management"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Shubham Ghimire for the valuable contribution to the Global Open Data Index.
","Some data available at Central Bureau of Statistics.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"f7cc182d-50ed-473f-8ad7-0be8f0cc2abd","global","2017-01-18T10:23:34","2016","na","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Directorate of Survey and Mapping, Ministry of Lands and Resettlement"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"e51125d6-45dc-4c06-81d5-7f6698f728ab","global","2017-03-20T08:42:34","2016","na","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""NAM Post"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Tricia Govindasamy for her contribution to the Global Open Data Index. ","There might be some data available https://nsa.org.na/page/spatial-data-surveys-cartography-and-regional-affairs - Spatial Data and National Spatial Data Infrastructure (NSDI), but there is no evidence that there are geocoded zipcodes, as well.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"08a720b0-28ce-45a6-aa59-6ba7f5a8286d","global","2017-01-27T16:45:16","2016","ke","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Can't find licensing info. Website says Copyright © 2017. The National Treasury. Datasets in Kenya Open Data are CC BY""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""4 different PDFs""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Link to treasury website. Tab on the top says Budget. Folders of years from 2007 - 2017. Kenya Open Data portal has a number of budget datasets comparing spending and budget data. Not extensive but datasets from 2010/2011 and 2014"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Very easy to navigate""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Treasury https://www.treasury.go.ke/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Review: Detailed information for all budget items. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.treasury.go.ke/component/jdownloads/category/6-budget.html?Itemid=-1"",""descValue"":""pdfs of 2016-2017 recurrent and development budgets""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.opendata.go.ke/datasets?bbox=33.383408%2C-5.208916%2C42.434669%2C5.937294&q=budget"",""descValue"":""Kenya Open Data Portal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data Open Data Portal not up to date""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept","PDF information is extensive but requires considerable effort to do anything useful with this info. IBP has provided some useful recommendations here https://www.internationalbudget.org/opening-budgets/open-budget-initiative/open-budget-survey/country-info/?country=ke ","Yes","No","Sierra Williams","Anna Alberts","45","45"
"fe7b3164-9aaf-44ac-bffb-68184686184f","global","2016-11-14T10:06:11","2016","ko","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""© Copyright Ministry of Finance Malaysia.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is in PDF. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is downloadable but it is a scanned pdf, you cannot play around with data. \nReview: The detailed datasets per ministry with the sub-ministry and program information is one-per-one downloadable in PDF. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I went to the government website to find the budget, it linked me to the Ministry of Finance website, there I found the budget plan for 2017."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://mf.rks-gov.net/desk/inc/media/6DDD4133-1111-41F8-AC33-AEC173203E63.pdf"",""descValue"":""Draft Law on The Budget of the Republic of Kosovo for Year 2017""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept",,"Yes","No","Blina Meta","Anna Alberts","45","45"
"dc34ebff-237a-46fa-9c78-5766b7346032","global","2016-12-08T15:44:16","2016","me","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is published as .pdf document.\n""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searching the Library on the website of Ministry of Finance."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.google.me/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=2&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwjUuauH9-TQAhUHXiwKHdVxBAYQFggeMAE&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.sluzbenilist.me%2FPravniAktPreuzimanje.aspx%3Ftag%3D%257B82645E04-9907-4859-A985-AD9FF73E7EF2%257D&usg=AFQjCNGi1ymMvK13pHP9RTc1jmM4DBtDtw"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Review: cannot check this license due to language issues""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.mf.gov.me/ResourceManager/FileDownload.aspx?rid=226118&rType=2&file=Zakon%20o%20budzetu%20Crne%20Gore%20za%202016.%20godinu.pdf"",""descValue"":""It can be found on many websites of institutions.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","accept",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Anna Alberts","80","80"
"891e880b-11dc-46c5-a18f-512bca2b2915","global","2016-11-21T14:13:27","2016","np","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""© Copyright 2003 - 2016. Ministry of Finance . All Rights Reserved. ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I go through the Government of Nepal Ministry of Finance website and I found the government budget for Fiscal Yera 2016/17 on the site."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Government of Nepal, Ministry Of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Review: cannot check this due to language limitations. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://mof.gov.np/en/content/mof-link-pages-9.html"",""descValue"":""Ministry Of Finance, Nepal ""},{""urlValue"":""https://mof.gov.np/uploads/document/file/Red_Book_English%20Fy2016-17_20160912045153.pdf"",""descValue"":""Detailed expenditure estimates""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept",,"Yes","No","Shubham Ghimire","Anna Alberts","60","60"
"dacf93d9-6347-42f8-b286-92e34cf98d6a","global","2016-12-15T16:28:00","2016","nir","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The PDF is downloadable at once. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""A. Go to northernireland.gov.uk, click on 'Budget' B. Google 'Northern Ireland Budget'"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.northernireland.gov.uk/crown-copyright and https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/version/3/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Finance / NI Executive"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.northernireland.gov.uk/topics/work-executive/budget"",""descValue"":""Northern Ireland Budget 2016/17""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.northernireland.gov.uk/sites/default/files/publications/nigov/2016-17-budget-document.pdf"",""descValue"":""PDF Budget Law""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept","This is not data, per se. It is a summary of agreed government spending by department and area of spend in PDF format.","Yes","No","Bob Harper","Anna Alberts","80","80"
"623cc6f5-e0fa-43bd-8ad6-7d1a8d8449f5","global","2016-11-24T16:35:09","2016","om","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The website of the Ministry of Finance does not indicate that the budget is openly licensed, but the same document can be downloaded from the website of the Ministry of Legal Affairs where the terms and conditions of the website state that it is in the public domain.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Go to the homepage of the website of the Ministry of Finance, select Financial Reports on main menu, select Annual Budget, then select year range."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.mof.gov.om/%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AA%D9%82%D8%A7%D8%B1%D9%8A%D8%B1-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%8A%D8%A9/%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D9%88%D8%A7%D8%B2%D9%86%D8%A9-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B9%D8%A7%D9%85%D8%A9-%D9%84%D9%84%D8%AF%D9%88%D9%84%D8%A9/%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D9%88%D8%A7%D8%B2%D9%86%D8%A9-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B9%D8%A7%D9%85%D8%A9-%D9%84%D9%84%D8%B3%D9%86%D8%A9-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%8A%D8%A9-2015"",""descValue"":""Website of the Ministry of Finance""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept ","The Financial Law in Oman requires the Annual Budget to be ratified by Royal Decree, which means that it must be published in the Official Gazette as an official document exempt from copyright protection.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Anna Alberts","80","80"
"801653b9-bb20-41d7-ae5e-f639aa0bf428","global","2016-12-19T06:39:37","2016","pk","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The website is under copyright of the ministry, and there is no explicit open data license. ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""2016-2017 is available""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Googled "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.finance.gov.pk/fb_2016_17.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.finance.gov.pk/fb_2016_17.html"",""descValue"":""Its a government website ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.finance.gov.pk/budget/abs_2016_17.pdf"",""descValue"":""Annual Budget Statement 2017""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Changed everything to PDF, and added additional budget data sources. Accept. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Anna Alberts","60","60"
"8cac1710-40d7-4291-beed-6047a5b6dc24","global","2017-01-20T14:23:41","2016","no","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Each individual table is available as CSV. Entire chapters are available as spreadsheets (XLSX) and in HTML-format for web-viewing.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""It's downloadable as 9 XLSX-files, which I assume is enough to qualify for a «Yes» here.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Familiar with the data from before, so I knew about all the links from before."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.norge.no/nlod"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""License is stated in the entry in the national open data portal:\nhttps://data.norge.no/data/finansdepartementet/statsbudsjettet-2017""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.norge.no/data/finansdepartementet/statsbudsjettet-2017"",""descValue"":""Entry on national open data portal - most recent goverment budget""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statsbudsjettet.no/Statsbudsjettet-2017/Dokumenter1/#72054"",""descValue"":""Statsbudsjettet.no - Spreadsheets""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statsbudsjettet.no/Statsbudsjettet-2017/Dokumenter1/Utlisting-av-tabeller-i-dokumentene/"",""descValue"":""Statsbudsjettet.no - Table-generator""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept",,"Yes","Yes","Bergheimivar L","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"31aabee6-37c6-4db3-a8fe-4fb7bba8965c","global","2017-01-24T22:56:32","2016","nz","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""see https://www.budget.govt.nz/budget/2016/data-library/index.htm#estimates\n""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There is a six=monthly fiscal update - https://www.budget.govt.nz/budget/2016/data-library/index.htm#estimates""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""My 2016 New Zealand budget search in Google returned these sites as their top results"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International licence . You are free to copy, distribute and adapt the work, as long as you attribute the work to the Crown and abide by the other licence terms. - See more at: https://www.budget.govt.nz/about/index.htm#licensing"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The New Zealand Treasury"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.budget.govt.nz/budget/2017"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.treasury.govt.nz/budget/2017"",""descValue"":""\""This is the home page for Budget 2016 for the Government of New Zealand. ... Most of these documents are tabled in Parliament by the Minister of Finance on Budget Day, 26 May 2016. \""""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.budget.govt.nz/budget/2016/documents-data.htm"",""descValue"":""The 2016 data and overviw""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.budget.govt.nz/budget/excel/data/b16-revenue-data.xls"",""descValue"":""Revenue XLS""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.budget.govt.nz/budget/excel/data/b16-expenditure-data.xls"",""descValue"":""Expenditure XLS""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The 2017 budget data is only presented on the 25th of May 2017. ""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept","I have been conservative with my response to B9 as I do not personally download this machine-readable data.","Yes","Yes","Keitha Booth","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"4a4201e0-db69-4da7-9103-1a4b6a3f279e","global","2017-01-12T15:34:05","2016","nl","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to the Indey of 2015, opened the website linked in the 2015 Index for this category"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://opendefinition.org/licenses/cc-zero/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Rijksoverheid"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://opendata.rijksbegroting.nl/begrotingsstaten.csv"",""descValue"":""Begrotingsstaten""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept",,"Yes","Yes","Ploegerieke L","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"4fe60903-d4c7-49ac-af11-2201591da058","global","2016-11-21T17:23:18","2016","mk","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to Ministry of Finance website > Public Finances > Budget > Documents"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.wipo.int/wipolex/en/text.jsp?file_id=263877"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Official texts of a political, legislative, administrative and judicial nature and their official translations are note considered copyright works (Art 16, Law on Copyright and Related Rights, 2010))""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.finance.gov.mk/files/u6/Budzet%202016%20-%20za%20objavuvanje.xml"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Finance""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.finance.gov.mk/mk/node/4105"",""descValue"":""PDF Budget 2017""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Under the budget heading. Documents. Not available in English.""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept",,"Yes","Yes","Arianit Dobroshi","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"36e35077-8626-4c08-bacb-3ad62f4a924d","global","2016-12-13T19:45:44","2016","lv","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""TO REVIEWER: The State budget is intended to be open and there are no copyrights or patents covering it. The webpage does not contain an official statement that it is public domain.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Detailed budget information is contained in its appendices (XLS files), in particular in the Appendix 4.\n\nNote: the budget page shows incorrect file type icons. Appendices are XLS files even though the icons can make one think that those are PDF files.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Detailed State budget is located in a ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Entered words \""valsts budžets\"" in a search engine and clicked the first result. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""-"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The state budget is published as semi-structured XLS files (cell text indentation level shows budget entry hierarchy, not entirely machine-readable).\n\nI am uncertain if to rate the dataset usability as 1 or 2. The difficulty in using these files is that cell indention is Excel formatting feature and it can be lost when converting to other formats using open source tools. Without this information the budget file is useless.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Latvijas Republikas Finanšu ministrija"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.fm.gov.lv""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I am not sure how to evaluate if there are descriptions for budget sections. Every budget entry (spreadsheet line) has a title which can be viewed as a description. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.fm.gov.lv/lv/sadalas/valsts_budzets/"",""descValue"":""the main page for Latvia State budget""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.fm.gov.lv/lv/sadalas/valsts_budzets/2017__gada_budzets/"",""descValue"":""Latvia State budget 2017 (main page)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.fm.gov.lv/files/valstsbudzets/2017/FMLikp04_131016_proj2017.xls"",""descValue"":""detailed 2017 budget file (XLS)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""To get to detailed state budget files (from Latvia State budget 2017 page) see \""4.pielikums\"" for the main budget and \""5.pielikums\"" for the special / social insurance fund budget.""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"d1e44437-e9cd-4b21-aaec-1840ba4ddb9a","global","2016-12-05T11:28:10","2016","jp","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled for the data and found the data in the first search result."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.mof.go.jp/english/notice.htm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.mof.go.jp/budget/budger_workflow/budget/index.html"",""descValue"":""in Japanese""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mof.go.jp/english/budget/budget/index.html"",""descValue"":""in English""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bb.mof.go.jp/hdocs/bxss010bh28.html"",""descValue"":""Published in PDF, Excell, and XML format.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Checked with google translate and as far as I can see correct. ",,"Yes","Yes","Masahiko Shoji","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"6b847b64-ad4f-4b41-a1ab-29fb44914ea7","global","2017-01-05T20:59:27","2016","jm","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""A preview is made available before choosing to download the document ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The data sets for 2014 and 2015 were already uploaded. At the time of completing this questionnaire, data for 2016 had not been uploaded as yet, however given that 2016 had recently ended approximately a week ago some time to process would suggest a gap before upload""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I entered the key word \""Jamaica open data government budget\"". The \""Jamaica Open Data Portal\"" - data.gov.jm/ was the first result in the list of suggestions by Google. Upon clicking the site, I entered the key word \""Budget\"" The results for 2014 and 2015 loaded with a brief description. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://opendatacommons.org/licenses/by/1.0/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""License description was readily found on the site at https://opendefinition.org/licenses/odc-by/""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""DKAN is the platform used to disseminate the information collected.""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance and the Public Service"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Budget data extracted from the Jamaica Budget Information System (JaBIS) for FY 2014-2015 and 2015-2016.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""1. Website description: Data available for Pattern, Head, Function, Sub-function, Program, Sub-program, and Activity (with codes and descriptions). Values available for approved, revised, statutory, and appropriations-in-aid. \n2. The government departments were included with corresponding figures for budget""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.jm/dataset/budget"",""descValue"":""Budget data extracted from the Jamaica Budget Information System (JaBIS) for FY 2014-2015 and 2015-2016. Data available for Pattern, Head, Function, Sub-function, Program, Sub-program, and Activity (with codes and descriptions).""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.jm/dataset/estimates-expenditure/resource/d517d37a-682c-4bbc-accd-90f24fc564b9#{view-graph:{graphOptions:{hooks:{processOffset:{},bindEvents:{}}}},graphOptions:{hooks:{processOffset:{},bindEvents:{}}}}"",""descValue"":""Open Data Portal Estimated Expenditure""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Adjusted the exact link for the Jamaican budget to make sure the latest 2016-2017 estimated expenditure are reflected",,"Yes","Yes","Alesha Aris","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"48d35b51-8225-48b6-8082-2672c406817f","global","2016-11-27T21:06:14","2016","it","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""from the home page https://www.rgs.mef.gov.it follow the link for open data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.agid.gov.it/cad/art-52-accesso-telematico-riutilizzo-dati-pubbliche-amministrazioni"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""open by default: The data can be re-used freely under the terms of the license Italian Open Data License (IODL 2.0) https://www.dati.gov.it/iodl/2.0/""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministero dell'Economia e delle Finanze"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.rgs.mef.gov.it/VERSIONE-I/OPENDATA/SpeseBS/2017/"",""descValue"":""Spese del bilancio dello Stato ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.openbilanci.it/"",""descValue"":""Open Budget Portal Italy for municipal data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.rgs.mef.gov.it/_Documenti/VERSIONE-I/OPENDATA/2017/LB/LB_EF_2017_Open_Data_-_Dati.csv"",""descValue"":""The CSV file for the data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"da4d2c60-2a2e-423d-98cf-9f21a0107431","global","2016-12-12T13:59:28","2016","id","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""2017 only in PDF, 2016 in XLS""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I was invited to the launching of portal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Reviewer: it was incredibly hard to find the data, but that can be due to language issues. ""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.data-apbn.kemenkeu.go.id/Dataset"",""descValue"":""Indonesia State Budget Data Portal""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.data-apbn.kemenkeu.go.id/Dataset/ambilFileDariDisk/1061"",""descValue"":""Budget XLS for 2016""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.kemenkeu.go.id/Data/uu-apbn-tahun-2017"",""descValue"":""Budget Law 2017 in PDf""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.kemenkeu.go.id/Data/nota-keuangan-rapbn-tahun-2017"",""descValue"":""Budget Bill 2017""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept, adjusted B7 and added sources to B2.2",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Anna Alberts","60","60"
"e3f21c69-4996-4273-9a42-95874232f0ff","global","2017-01-20T23:15:01","2016","gy","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF download: scanned in (not scrapable)""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I perused the Ministry of Finance to find the Budget Estimates"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data was easy to find and download""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://finance.gov.gy/documents-publications/category/budget-estimates"",""descValue"":""Budget Estimates""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept. ",,"Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Anna Alberts","60","60"
"b5de6c92-c8e9-4a92-989b-3d1365a37729","global","2017-01-18T21:42:35","2016","gh","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The budget for 2017 is only available in PDF, but the provision fiscal data for the years 2015 and 2016 are available in excel: https://www.mofep.gov.gh/sites/default/files/fiscal_data/PROVISIONAL%20FISCAL%20DATA%20JAN%20-%20DEC%202016.xlsx""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance website and searched under Financials "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""Its just available. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance, Ghana "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.mofep.gov.gh/?q=fiscal-data"",""descValue"":""fiscal data under Financials ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mofep.gov.gh/?q=budget-statements"",""descValue"":""this provides the budget execution reports ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mofep.gov.gh/?q=budget-statements"",""descValue"":""The budget statements for 2017""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Adjusted: B5 and B8. ",,"Yes","No","Franka Vaughan","Anna Alberts","65","65"
"cad2451d-6d3b-4647-9bc0-e3f59c3a3cce","global","2017-01-19T13:58:14","2016","fi","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Links from Ministry of Finance page"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://budjetti.vm.fi/indox/opendata-csv.jsp"",""descValue"":""Machine readable data 2014-""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","accept","The data is available since 2014 in CSV and XML. The data asset is also available on Finnish data portal Avoindata.fi.
On the page ( https://budjetti.vm.fi/indox/index.jsp ) data is available in PDF and HTML but not in CSV, XLS or neither through API. The page is hosted by Ministry of Finance. The main datasets are the ones Government proposes to the Parliament. The Parliament amends the budget perioidically. See the discussion in Finnish: https://avoindata.net/245/onko-valtion-budjettidata-saatavilla-avoimena-ja-milloin
Machine readable data for 2015 can be found here - https://budjetti.vm.fi/indox/opendata-csv.jsp","Yes","No","Aleksi Knuutila","Anna Alberts","85","85"
"a6db6ff2-7ce8-47d1-a48f-39efb7c90e15","global","2016-12-31T09:39:07","2016","kh","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""A bundle of Zipped PDFs. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""See reviewer comment"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Budget was available under the main website tab under Law and Regulation. ""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Economy and Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The link to the official website https://www.mef.gov.kh/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is a number of PDFs for download with one simple table that seems to be a government department budget overview. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.mef.gov.kh/laws-and-regulation/budget.html"",""descValue"":""The Budget on the Cambodian Ministry of Finance website""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Comment Reviewer: this should be checked again by somebody speaking the language. But with my limited understanding, I think the ZIP file contains at least one table with the estimates for 2017 on an overview level. ","The 2015 result from the Open Budget Index shown that the data is exist https://survey.internationalbudget.org/#rankings
There are no evidence found from the Ministry of Economy and Finance official website to confirm that the data exist.","Yes","No","anonymous","Anna Alberts","60","60"
"450bf818-de9a-4f71-8136-bc22e1a1cad4","global","2017-01-18T20:02:51","2016","bw","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The data for 2017-2018 comes online on the first of April, the website says. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I google searched government budget Botswana and this source was on the first page of search results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Government of Botswana Ministry of Finance and Economic Development"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.finance.gov.bw/"",""descValue"":""Government of Botswana Ministry of Finance and Economic Development""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.finance.gov.bw/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=192&catid=23&Itemid=109"",""descValue"":""Overview of tables in PDFs""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Anna Alberts","60","60"
"a5aca83c-130f-477f-ac2b-74334dbc5605","global","2016-12-30T08:59:28","2016","bt","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""See comment: https://discuss.okfn.org/t/about-the-submission-of-bhutan/4507""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Yes, data for 2016-2017 is available. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Visit websites, visit publications and look for the report that you are interested in. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""All available data are for use of public without any fees/charges. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance and National Statistics Bureau (NSB)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It seems to be a sector/performance based budget, more than an administrative based. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.mof.gov.bt/publications/reports/"",""descValue"":""Financial reports, Annual Financial Statements, Bhutan Trade Statistics, Budget Reports, National Revenue Reports, Performance Indicator Reports""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.nsb.gov.bt/publication/publications.php?id=4"",""descValue"":""National Account Reports""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mof.gov.bt/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/BudgetReport2016-17-ENG.pdf"",""descValue"":""Budget 2016-2017 in PDF""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept",,"Yes","No","Executive Director, BMF","Anna Alberts","60","60"
"fe473adc-ce65-4e98-af8b-9753ac9551b8","global","2016-12-13T15:57:29","2016","pa","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""For this dataset the license has not been specified.\nhttps://www.datosabiertos.gob.pa/dataset?license_id=notspecified""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF Review: changed B8, open data was not available anymore, and the full budget was only available in PDF.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1. Google Search for Open data Panamá, 2. click on MEF link, 3. Download Data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Is easy to find trough the portal, on the website is not that easy. Review: the open data portal link was empty, the execution data for 2016 per month was available, but not the state budget as a whole. ""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Economía y Finanzas (MEF)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""In the law in the government gazette the departments and sub-departments and programs are provided. https://www.mef.gob.pa/es/direcciones/presupuestoNacion/Documents/pre_2017_ley.pdf""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.datosabiertos.gob.pa/dataset/http-www-mef-gob-pa-es-paginas-presupuestodelestado-aspx"",""descValue"":""Open Data Portal (Recently Launched)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.datosabiertos.gob.pa/organization/mef"",""descValue"":""Open Data Portal - MEF filter = Empty""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mef.gob.pa/es/Paginas/home.aspx"",""descValue"":""MEF website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mef.gob.pa/es/direcciones/presupuestoNacion/Documents/pre_2017_ley.pdf"",""descValue"":""Budget law in gazette""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The law is available from the government gazette. But the machine readable data only for expenditure per month. ","Although the government has recently launched the ""Open Data Portal on the cKan platform, there is a lack of appropriate diffusion and communication strategies for citizens to access and reuse information, in addition the few datasets are mostly oriented to Accountability issues based on the transparency law (wich is important for some citizens), but there is a lack of useful data for the citizens.","Yes","No","Victor Díaz Navarro","Anna Alberts","60","60"
"58fb1925-aec7-45f1-b9be-6cabd8d66ae9","global","2016-12-20T09:34:53","2016","ph","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No indication of license or of being in public domain on DBM site. See here: https://www.dbm.gov.ph/?page_id=10856\n\nOn data.gov.ph the 2016 document is available and openly licensed (https://data.gov.ph/policy/), but the 2017 is not yet there.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Also offered on DBM site: scanned PDF.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The publications are easy enough to find; the difficulty is in knowing which publication is the one with the actual budget. This may be easier for those with actual domain knowledge.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Homepage -> Budget Documents -> 2017 -> National Expenditure Program"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Budget and Management"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is detailed down to the line item level. Departments, sub-departments are described before the line items according to their UACS codes.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.dbm.gov.ph/?page_id=16379"",""descValue"":""DBM Publications - National Expenditure Program 2017""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Anna Alberts","80","80"
"c238fd31-5b1a-46b1-8287-089914dfd976","global","2017-01-18T10:20:32","2016","na","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Namibia Statistics Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://nsa.org.na/page/spatial-data-surveys-cartography-and-regional-affairs/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no data on the website. Once you request, it will be sent. Request form: https://nsa.org.na/page/request-form/""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"ca3e14ff-a1ce-4aef-a2ef-d4c0c1e5f3c9","global","2017-01-16T15:00:41","2016","no","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""GML"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Zip codes: XLSX, tab-separated\nZip code borders: SOSI 4.0, ESRI Shape""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Looked up on the national portal, found links for borders to data.kartverket.no. Since I know the latter portal is being phased out, I found the correct dataset on geonorge.no"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.norge.no/nlod/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Dataset for zip codes is under an NLOD-license, zip code borders is under CC BY 4.0""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Posten Norge AS"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Zipcodes"",""Addresses"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Data available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.norge.no/data/posten-norge/postnummer-i-norge"",""descValue"":""Entry on national open data portal (data.norge.no)""},{""urlValue"":""https://kartkatalog.geonorge.no/metadata/kartverket/postkretser/462a5297-33ef-438a-82a5-07fff5799be3"",""descValue"":""Zip code borders""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","Yes","Bergheimivar L","Codrina Maria Ilie","100","100"
"1cfb51db-c837-425f-ab83-4acca721bc3c","global","2017-01-14T12:15:20","2016","pt","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""All rights reserved""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""mainly PDF and embedded in web pages""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Not possible to access or retrieve all the info at once""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update yearly""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""No registration required""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""It can be downloaded on individual files, free of charge""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Finding the place where the data resides was easy, but accessing it took some time due to being necessary to use a search mechanism on the page""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""googled: \""orcamento estado portugal\"" and navigated the menus from the landing page"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""pretty straightforward""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""DGO - Direção Geral do Orçamento"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Government Budget Agency""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Descriptions are not very detailed""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.dgo.pt/politicaorcamental/Paginas/OEpagina.aspx?Ano=2012&TipoOE=Orçamento%20Estado%20Aprovado&TipoDocumentos=Lei%20/%20Mapas%20Lei%20/%20Relatório"",""descValue"":""Complete budget available by search index and in .PDF format from 1959 onwards""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dgo.pt/Paginas/default.aspx"",""descValue"":""main page for the Government Budget Agency""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dgo.pt/politicaorcamental/Paginas/OEpagina_ficheirosdeDados.aspx?Ano=2017"",""descValue"":""Some budget information in XML format (starting in 2016)""},{""urlValue"":""https://online.dgo.pt/DadosCidadao/Orcamento_CG.Entrada.aspx"",""descValue"":""Data visualization of Govt. Budget (only for 2015 and 2016)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept","Info. should have more detailed descriptions
Data formats should be human readable
Some documents are missing and some search options have no documents
","Yes","No","Oliveirauis L","Anna Alberts","65","65"
"03c58774-489d-4d23-b491-8036bc742997","global","2016-12-31T08:58:07","2016","mm","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Responsibilities for land management are divided among the Ministry of Agriculture and Irrigation for lowland agricultural land, and the Ministry of Natural Resources and Environmental Conservation (MONREC) for upland (forest) lands. Residential land, meanwhile, is managed at the city level. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The official website to the Myanmar President's Officer https://www.president-office.gov.mm/en/""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","https://opendevelopmentmyanmar.net/topics/land/#land-policy-and-administration ","There are no evidence to confirm that the data exist.","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"232bd03c-1234-4fc2-8c7b-99f94d4908d7","global","2016-12-12T10:09:20","2016","ru","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""through official website of the Ministry of finance of the Russian Federation"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.ru/information-usage and https://minfin.ru/opendata/ (bottom of the page)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""TERMS OF USE OF OPEN DATA\n\nUsers without a contract with the Russian Federation Ministry of Finance can use (including re) open data available, free of charge, in perpetuity, without compensation and without limitation territory of use, including a right to copy, publish, distribute, open data, modify the open data and combine them with other information, use open data to the non-commercial and commercial purposes, to use to create computer programs and applications.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance of the Russian Federation"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://minfin.ru/opendata/"",""descValue"":""open data section""},{""urlValue"":""https://budget.gov.ru/"",""descValue"":""governmental information system with open data section""},{""urlValue"":""https://minfin.ru/OpenData/7710168360-BA_expense/"",""descValue"":""Overall budgetary list of the federal budget for the current fiscal year and the planned period: expenses""},{""urlValue"":""https://minfin.ru/OpenData/7710168360-BA_source/"",""descValue"":""Overall budgetary list of the federal budget for the current financial year and planning period: the sources of financing the budget deficit""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept, the open data portal for the ministry of finance provides all necessary data. However, the first link provided ""https://budget.gov.ru/"" gives a mostly empty website, no content for the budget etc. ",,"Yes","Yes","Mikhail Parfentev","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"d2181366-b0f2-4025-8656-46c43003de74","global","2017-01-26T04:38:04","2016","kn","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF download format \n""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""By visiting the Ministry of Finance website I was quickly connected to their publication page and able to view budget documents"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://mof.gov.kn/publications/"",""descValue"":"" BUDGET ESTIMATES""},{""urlValue"":""https://mof.gov.kn/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/Estimates-2017-Volume-I.pdf"",""descValue"":""Budget estimates 2017 Vol 1""},{""urlValue"":""https://mof.gov.kn/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/Estimates-2017-Volume-II.pdf"",""descValue"":""Budget estimates 2017 Vol 2""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Changed question B9, to difficult because the data is only available in pdf. ",,"Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Anna Alberts","60","60"
"baffcb63-c08b-4e5f-bc1a-672285e83c1d","global","2017-01-24T19:51:24","2016","lc","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF download of the document ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The available documents go up to 2013""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I decided to visit the Ministry of Finance page, by perusing the page I accessed the given resource tab and from there able to read their publication to the web. However the data for government budget was small and not recent"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The given documentation does not include a detailed lay out of the government's budget. It is geared towards a presentation format that describes the objectives and adjustments for the fiscal year. Although good for users to investigate the country's objectives it does not coincide well with the objective of open data to measure and actual figures and performance""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.finance.gov.lc/resources/"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Finance Resource Page""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.finance.gov.lc/resources/index/26"",""descValue"":""Minsitry of Finance Budget publications""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Comment Reviewer: changed question B2 to No because I could only find a number of outdated budget speeches on the website of the ministry of finance. ",,"Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Anna Alberts","30","30"
"da1c78e8-b2ea-4676-8aa4-188a42ec73af","global","2017-01-25T07:49:29","2016","vc","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Checked the website + the website of the statistics office and indeed could only find the budget speech. ","The Ministry of Finance is the responsible entity for the collection and publication of budget data. However I was unable to find a representation of the via an online source. However they have steadily uploaded their Budget Speech over the years but I did not find it to be conducive with the survey's criteria
https://www.finance.gov.vc/finance/","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Anna Alberts","0","0"
"3760ed0a-f22d-4746-9115-7a24bd6d13ec","global","2017-03-19T21:07:28","2016","al","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.financa.gov.al/al/raportime is not a license. The Website claims that all content is copyrighted under the government of Albania ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.financa.gov.al/al/raportime/thesari/pagesa-te-kryera-nga-drejtoria-e-pergjithshme-e-sherbimeve-financiare/pagesat-e-kryera-2015"",""descValue"":""This leads to a calendar with Payment detail, not the budget. This link was handed in by the person handing it in.""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.financa.gov.al/files/userfiles/Buxheti/Buxheti_ne_vite/Buxheti_2017/Tabela_1_-_Buxheti_2017_(institucionet_me_programe_dhe_shpenzimet_e_tjera).xls"",""descValue"":""This is the actual budget file for 2017.""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.financa.gov.al/al/legjislacioni/buxheti-thesari-borxhi/buxheti/buxheti-ne-vite/buxheti-2017/ligji-i-buxhetit-2017"",""descValue"":""Website for the Budget of 2017, with all accompanying documents and documentation""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.financa.gov.al/al/legjislacioni/buxheti-thesari-borxhi/buxheti/buxheti-ne-vite"",""descValue"":""Multi-annual Budget webpage providing budgets of previous years and forecasts""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"I had corrected the previous submission license question. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","80","80"
"c287f30f-1d06-4ea2-a383-71d09b9cd831","global","2016-11-25T07:53:25","2016","rs","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no restrictions but there is no open license available.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""pdf""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search engine, first hit."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It would be really hart to extract the data from the pdf file. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Assembly"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Budget is brought by National Assembly in the form of the Law. Ministry of Finance is the legislator.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.parlament.gov.rs/narodna-skupstina-/uloga-i-nacin-rada/finansiranje-narodne-skupstine/budzet-za-tekucu-godinu.909.html"",""descValue"":""Link to the Law""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept","Ministry of Finance is aware of Open Data initiative, but not willing to participate.","Yes","No","Aleksandar Ivić","Anna Alberts","60","60"
"e4b851fd-befd-4d51-ac5f-9951e493c875","global","2016-11-22T08:32:40","2016","sg","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The data is available as a CSV download or JSON via API. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google for \""singapore government budget data\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.sg/open-data-licence"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is available both by government department and by sector of spending (e.g. Social Development and Economic Development). ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.sg/dataset/government-fiscal-position-annual"",""descValue"":""Government Fiscal Position""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.sg/dataset/government-operating-revenue"",""descValue"":""Government Operating Revenue""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.sg/dataset/government-operating-expenditure-by-sector"",""descValue"":""Government Operating Expenditure""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.singaporebudget.gov.sg/budget_2016/Home.aspx"",""descValue"":""Budget 2016 Signapore""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.sg/dataset/3ae25473-60fa-4b36-9318-b9288e816a44/download"",""descValue"":""Full Download link""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept","Government revenue data broken down by type is also available to the public. ","Yes","Yes","Zhaowei Lin","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"331357ba-3cb4-486e-adc3-d164d00dad7a","global","2016-12-02T14:06:54","2016","sk","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Link from last year works and website structure is still the same."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.rozpocet.sk/"",""descValue"":""Official Budget Website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.rozpocet.sk/app/xlsFile?xlsFileName=/imgs/2016/0/sk_2016_0_upraveny.xls"",""descValue"":""Xls file with all available budget data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept","Status is same as in 2015. Hopefully, new portal (providing API in open format, explicit license for data and various other improvements) will be launched next year.","Yes","No","Peter Hanecak","Anna Alberts","80","80"
"ecfb4199-cfa4-47a0-b45d-8d12d9d15711","global","2016-12-03T12:41:43","2016","si","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Footer states \n\""© 2016 Ministry of Finance | Government of the Republic of Slovenia\""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""\n""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried a web search engine for the Ministry of Finance of Slovenia, looked for Budget"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance, Republic of Slovenia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""General budget is downloadable at once as a CVS file https://www.mf.gov.si/si/delovna_podrocja/proracun/sprejeti_proracun/2016/sprejeti_proracun_republike_slovenije_za_leto_2016/ \n\nDescriptions for budget sections available on the same link as PDF documents.\n""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.mf.gov.si/si/delovna_podrocja/proracun/sprejeti_proracun/"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Finance, Republic of Slovenia""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mf.gov.si/si/delovna_podrocja/proracun/sprejeti_proracun/2016/sprejeti_proracun_republike_slovenije_za_leto_2016/"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Anna Alberts","80","80"
"e37fa9df-3274-4b1f-b814-2d90b8239042","global","2017-01-20T14:33:16","2016","no","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Spending at a transactional level is not collected (from each organization/agency)."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Records of spending on a transactional level is not openly available online, and have to be requested.
Higher-level numbers are available:
Monthly expenses: https://www.dfo.no/no/Forvaltning/Statsregnskapet/Manedlig-statsregnskap/
Statistics Norway: https://www.ssb.no/statistikkbanken/selecttable/hovedtabellHjem.asp?KortNavnWeb=statsregn&CMSSubjectArea=offentlig-sektor&checked=true","Yes","No","Bergheimivar L","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"3fb4e14f-b9e9-47b1-b24b-bd57656c4372","global","2016-12-23T15:36:51","2016","ch","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Comment Reviewer: on the website the full budget download function was not located. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search the efv.admin.ch website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is hard to find via the ministry of finance website. Requires clicking through different links until you are one the data portal. ""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal Finance Administration"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.efv.admin.ch/efv/de/home/finanzberichterstattung/daten/datencenter.spa.EIS.app/eisui/index.html#/home"",""descValue"":""The information system for the Swiss federal budget""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.efv.admin.ch/efv/de/home/finanzberichterstattung/finanzberichte/budget.html"",""descValue"":""Budget Law ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept, changed B5 because I could not find one download function for all the budget data. ",,"Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","Anna Alberts","65","65"
"0df6e709-0bc1-48dc-9201-252956d006c3","global","2016-11-10T13:55:35","2016","tw","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""search on Taiwan's open data portal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.tw/license#eng"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Directorate General of Budget, Accounting and Statistics of Executive Yuan"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.tw/node/35302"",""descValue"":""Government Budget""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept: the data can be downloadable at the indicated link at once. There is no way for me to check whether B3 is indeed correct, however the datasets are extensive and google translate limited translations show that the departments and detailed revenues and expenditures are indicated. ",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"4df74e5b-0d9e-40be-b327-a6c3b8042897","global","2017-01-18T06:26:07","2016","bs","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Only PDF file available""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Difficulty downloading PDF file of the document""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""The website government website https://www.bahamas.gov.bs/ was easily found via google. From there the National Budget tab was found"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No historical data for comparison or review""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.bahamas.gov.bs/wps/portal/public/National%20Budget/Budget%20Documents/!ut/p/b1/vZTZkqIwFIafpR-A5oQ1XKICouyLEm4skUVkEdywefqxp6Zqlqq252J6kqtUfX_9Oec_CR3ThBMkJEosZumIjtvtrSy2l_LYbuv3cyxsWNBMWeawqfEggB46huyIc8ZG_AMgDwA-WDI81S-ZH_onwF_5fwRw8Jl-TUcBYaTZWS80ZZV37vlQrEhnq70VXE8llILWDtTynE6IcLMMgVqAeAbpzQ9TIfJ0QnWLkjrUaXvckapwlV6n8B2Kjj0796Cmdvvbmg-kPM71-5uae6NJLvi4Uc2s400_VvycI51rzio23SfpMYGq7zV7V5Mp6fdJ5ifirLycl1N0MUjWZPtYc91xA5FwpUg7vLw87h8_LfG9A9-BZxF9FpI1PzYZTR6Y-AsWrAB0BLLnIxewheiAjoDb-Ie3Th-r0TvAAP5MR9aYmihYI1M5-VZYgSXFllnhEU7hYCoX0w_sMVDOyLIiJ1154USeelnOtn8a2kwgPQynSFiGPPjAfbWhxtv40QgxcGSeAc1G_9uQ_a8t1RwbvrzC34aGc_99hgs6LpPmddg1r_CKJQHxIuYkLADHYZFeHYjAPx77oCjeZkGQce7FzpZdywNrD_3UIlxRR6zO7PK92C69yUr1bmm7rTRvMiRcO23auRZCX58a6G7rFb6YMTro-VHDJFksPTbU74YIBV80x7XOqcVmPkjOfGuM4sE-KHydri-rXe7NbtcRUymJFjakTWMkloC7mzEjmVQ7ZTqYG0BGf-WnPWNkajtU1qKWksQ1NUtlQnldpX2UAudwWze6M0PX2BpQyhINc_nxKTRxraqG4M0HhH_u4eUbCbZQAQ!!/dl4/d5/L2dBISEvZ0FBIS9nQSEh/"",""descValue"":""Budget Documents""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bahamas.gov.bs/wps/wcm/connect/3da6c75f-489a-4eb8-9952-9336991b4507/MOF-BUD-9x9-FINAL%281%29.pdf?MOD=AJPERES"",""descValue"":"" Budget Communication 2016 - 17 ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bahamas.gov.bs/wps/wcm/connect/c6018ebc-31b3-49a4-b186-6793fe51501b/CapitalExpenditureDetails+2016-2017.csv?MOD=AJPERES"",""descValue"":""Part of the budget is available in CSV""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept. Some additional data is available in CSV, but the main budget law as a comprehensive document only available in pdf. ",,"Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Anna Alberts","45","45"
"50463047-16a9-47e3-8ade-9e5e65d8294d","global","2016-12-01T20:07:58","2016","tr","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""As a non turkish speaker it is hard to judge if all budget data is available. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Knowledge Acquisition Request to https://www.bimer.gov.tr/bimer-bilgi-edinme and approximately 15 day, they send. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Comment Reviewer: via Wikipedia I found the turkish government budget article, in the direct link under the article, the link to the budget website was provided. There on the front-page a menu item is Budget, citizen budget and you can easily click to the current and past years budget laws and documents. ""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Comment reviewer: it seems that detailed tables are not accessible or even removed, therefore this is deemed only the budget per government department. As a non turkish speaker it is hard to judge if all budget data is available, but the 2016 draft law seems detailed enough. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.bimer.gov.tr/bimer-bilgi-edinme"",""descValue"":""knowledge acquisition""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bumko.gov.tr/TR,61/merkezi-yonetim-butce-kanunu-ve-ekleri.html"",""descValue"":""The Turkish Central government budget website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bumko.gov.tr/TR,6289/2016.html"",""descValue"":""Budget 2016 with documents""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bumko.gov.tr/Eklenti/9383,mybktasarisi2016.pdf?0"",""descValue"":""Draft Budget law and annexes 2016""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Comment reviewer: the budget documents seem available. Although, what is odd it seemed that only the 2016 draft budget law was complete. Other documents seem to contain to little data, and mostly provided lists of budget for universities, that I only considered that draft budget law 2016 as a full budget document. ",,"Yes","No","Adem Emre Topçu","Anna Alberts","45","45"
"5b71995a-19a4-4d5e-b6d5-f7683aabaf89","global","2016-12-05T02:24:21","2016","ua","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""It's an archive file with multiple xls files/sheets""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Published a week after approval""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It would've been easier if there was a single portal dedicated to country budget.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search for \""Закон про державний бюджет України\"", \""Виконання державного бюджету\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Ukraine._Law_on_Copyright_and_Related_Rights"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Budgetary data is published in a law. All laws in Ukraine are in public domain""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Budget is prepared by Ministry of Finance and published by parlament""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Extensive effort is needed to convert XLS into actual readable data.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance / Verkhovna Rada"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Ministry of Finance provides the data, palriament approves it and publishes it""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There are multiple classifications on different XLS sheets""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://zakon3.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/928-19/page2"",""descValue"":""Budget plan 2016""},{""urlValue"":""https://zakon3.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/80-19"",""descValue"":""Budget plan 2015""},{""urlValue"":""https://zakon4.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/719-18"",""descValue"":""Budget plan 2014""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.treasury.gov.ua/main/uk/doccatalog/list?currDir=146477"",""descValue"":""Budgetary Execution 2007-2016""},{""urlValue"":""https://spending.gov.ua/"",""descValue"":""THE OFFICIAL PORTAL OF PUBLIC FINANCES UKRAINE""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.minfin.gov.ua/en/news/view/pokaznyky-vykonannia-biudzhetu-ukrainy--rik?category=bjudzhet&subcategory=bjudzhet-potochnogo-roku"",""descValue"":""Budget directly downloadable in xlsx""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.ua/"",""descValue"":""Data Portal Ukraine""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.minfin.gov.ua/en/news/view/za-propozici%D1%94ju-ministerstva-finansiv-urjad-zatverdiv-proekt-zakonu-pro-derzhavnij-bjudzhet-na-2016-rik-ta-podav-jogo-do-verhovnoi-radi?category=bjudzhet&subcategory=bjudzhet-potochnogo-roku"",""descValue"":""Draft Law with all different tables in xlsx ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The link is changed on year to year basis.""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept. Due to my limited knowledge of the cyrillique alphabet I could not search well on the data.gov.ua portal, but I suspect that there all budget files are even easier available. Now I managed to find all files for 2017 on the ministry of finance website, all the files for budget + expenditure for 2016 are also updated and online on the same portal.
Also, when the spending website is fully developed and online, this could be a very extensive resource for budget and spending data for Ukraine. ","Overall, budgetary data in Ukraine could've been better.","Yes","Yes","Vanya Yani","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"0cd0ff23-4935-4e44-8ab8-9ebc90096fe6","global","2016-12-13T06:32:52","2016","gb","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Reports in PDF supported by tables in Excel format.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""I've answered Yes to this question but really this depends on whether the user thinks the PESA documents provide the detail they require. If not they may need to supplement with annual reports from individual departments, which are spread far and wide.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searches on navigation on Gov.uk. Additional searches on Data.gov.uk and Google did not return any additional sources."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The annual budget documents are easily discoverable by searching Gov.uk. There is structured data but it is not a particular focus. In the UK the annual budget is public-facing and the emphasis is on taxation and strategic economic decisions rather than planned expenditure at the departmental level. Data on departmental spending limits is available in the PESA documents, which are also discoverable on Gov.uk but difficult to find if you don't know exactly what you've looking for. It is likely that to gain a full understanding of this subject the user would also need to look at annual reports of individual departments, which are not collected centrally and tend not to contain much structured data. Generally speaking in my view this is not an area when UK open data is particularly transparent.""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/version/3/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Open Government Licence is linked from all pages of GOV.UK and applies by default to material published there.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Again this depends on what the user wants to get out of it, but in my view the data is lacking if the user expects to be able to do a mechanical analysis or interrogation of budget data across government and in-depth.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""HM Treasury"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This material is mainly in the PESA documents. There are descriptions for budget sections but it is debatable whether they are verbose enough for readers to understand the functions of each sub-department.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/budget-2016-documents"",""descValue"":""Budget 2016: documents""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/public-expenditure-statistical-analyses-pesa"",""descValue"":""Public Expenditure Statistical Analyses (PESA)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept, however the document displayed as the ""Budget 2016"" is a pdf/html file that is mainly the summary of the proposed budget and policies, which would be in other countries covered in the parliamentary summary/budget speech. The data itself is hidden in the PESA PDF/PESA tables that provides an overview of the previous expenditure and revenues, and planned budgets and estimated expenditures. ",,"Yes","Yes","Owen Boswarva","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"825c8985-fa38-4fae-8e84-fde38988a3ab","global","2017-02-03T16:08:11","2016","us","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Also pdf with some other information""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to the archive of last administration and there is a direct link in the whitehouse page. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.whitehouse.gov/copyright"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""White House Official Budget"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/omb/budget/Overview"",""descValue"":""Budget overview with documents""},{""urlValue"":""https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/omb/budget/Supplemental"",""descValue"":""Tables of budget as suplemental materials""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Comment reviewer: there is also an interactive website: https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/interactive-budget but unfortunately the github link for downloading all the underlying data and code is broken. Also the 2017 budget seems only available in PDF. ",,"Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Anna Alberts","85","85"
"c8dc066f-25b6-4b87-991d-685e6f5e74c2","global","2016-12-13T12:27:20","2016","uy","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched the National Open Data Catalogue"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://datos.gub.uy/wps/wcm/connect/7fe4b346-b24c-4889-af2f-073897a1e97d/terminos-catalogodatos.pdf?MOD=AJPERES&ContentCache=NONE&CACHEID=7fe4b346-b24c-4889-af2f-073897a1e97d"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Open Spending visualization available""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Área de Gestión y Evaluación del Estado (AGEV)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://catalogodatos.gub.uy/dataset/credito-presupuestal-asignado-y-ejecutado"",""descValue"":""Nat""},{""urlValue"":""https://agev.opp.gub.uy/advni/acceso_datos.html"",""descValue"":""AGEV downloads""},{""urlValue"":""https://agev.opp.gub.uy/advni/#/~/cr-eacute-dito-total-2016"",""descValue"":""Open Spending Interface""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept",,"Yes","Yes","Daniel Carranza","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"186177ad-51fa-4368-b303-2e4fc3a4d87d","global","2017-01-05T12:52:34","2016","ve","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Los documentos de dominio público donde se difunden las tablas de datos que corresponde al presupuesto nacional son archivos XML transformados en formato PDF abierto. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Hay que aplicar herramientas de scraping para extraer la información y convertirla en un formato que puede ser reutilizable y fácil de analizar y manejar. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""El Estado venezolano publica anualmente el presupuesto nacional para cada año. Y si hay alguna modificación en el transcurso de ese tiempo, lo publica en Gaceta Oficial. No se publica un nuevo documento conjunto que incluya los cambios y cómo quedó el presupuesto final. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Los datos disponible son tablas publicadas en la Ley de Presupuesto Anual, un documento público en formato PDF abierto""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Hice la búsqueda directamente en la página oficial del organismo del Estado encargado de levantar la información e hice clic sobre el enlace relacionado con los datos. Como sólo encontré la información que corresponde a los últimos tres años, acudí a la web oficial de una ONG que recolecta la información y encontré un margen más amplio de datos."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.onapre.gob.ve/index.php/publicaciones/descargas/viewcategory/54-ley-de-presupuesto-ejercicio-fiscal-2016"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""La base de datos disponible se publica en la Ley de Presupuesto anual y se encuentra en formato PDF abierto. La información es registrada por la Oficina Nacional de Presupuesto del Ministerio del Poder Popular para la Banca y Finanzas. ""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Oficina Nacional de Presupuesto del Ministerio del Poder Popular para la Banca y Finanzas"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.onapre.gob.ve/index.php/publicaciones/descargas/viewcategory/26-leyes"",""descValue"":""Leyes de Presupuesto de la Nación de 2014-2016 / Fuente: Sitio web oficial de la Oficina Nacional de Presupuesto del Ministerio del Poder Popular para la Nación""},{""urlValue"":""https://transparencia.org.ve/project/presupuesto-ciudadano-2016/"",""descValue"":""Leyes de Presupuesto de la Nación de 2009-2016 / Fuente: Sitio web oficial de la ONG Transparencia Venezuela""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""El sitio web oficial del organismo encargado de levantar la información sobre el presupuesto nacional sólo tiene publicado los datos de 2014 a 2016. Sin embargo, los presupuestos nacionales, una vez aprobados por el Parlamento, se publican en Gaceta Oficial (el boletín diario del Estado) pero éste está en formado PDF cerrado. Cuando se colocan en la web, convierten el texto XML en un PDF abierto. ""}]","Yes","Yes","Comment reviewer: the links provided only refer to the 2016 budget laws (which are published in full) in PDF. Thus question B8 is changed, if the link to the xls data is not provided, I cannot review that.
Also question B7 is changed to ""No"" as the cited website was just to the download section of the above mentioned website, not to the actual license/impressum etc. And I could not find additional information on the website. ","El Gobierno de Venezuela publica su presupuesto nacional a través de la Ley de Presupuesto Nacional (por año), que se hace pública en Gaceta Oficial para informar a la población sobre su aprobación y luego se coloca en la página oficial del organismo encargado de levantar los datos, en formato PDF abierto. Son más de 1.000 páginas, entre texto y tablas, que los ciudadanos tienen que revisar para entender cómo están distribuidos los recursos de la nación. Revisar y entender ese documento es un esfuerzo sobrehumano. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Anna Alberts","45","45"
"86abe295-029c-4feb-afe0-efe81f1d088c","global","2017-01-15T17:14:26","2016","zm","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No evidence of copyright given on website.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""DOCX, PPTX, PDF, PNG""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Comment reviewer: the data website as linked by the submitter does not provide downloads for the budget beyond 2014-2015. The 2017 \""yellow book\"" budget is available in PDF.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled Government Budget Data Zambia and this resource appeared in the first page of search results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Republic of Zambia Ministry of Finance "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://zambiamf.africadata.org/"",""descValue"":""Republic of Zambia Ministry of Finance Data Portal""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mofnp.gov.zm/index.php/budgetdata/summary/17-budget-yellow-book/15260-yellow-book-budget-2017"",""descValue"":""Republica of Zambia Ministry of Finance - budget website - PDF""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted, changed question B8 because the budget for 2017 is only available in PDF. The data website of the ministry of finance is one of the best I have ever seen in terms of download, functionality, explanations, search functions etc. However, it was absolutely not up to date. Therefore, the score is based on the most up to date budget in PDF. ",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Anna Alberts","60","60"
"270a83ca-5cb6-489f-b2f8-f0ce9fe41700","global","2016-12-31T08:29:20","2016","mm","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Myanmar Posts and Telecommunications (MPT) (Burmese: မြန်မာ့ဆက်သွယ်ရေးလုပ်ငန်း)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is a state owned enterprise in Myanmar under the supervision of Ministry of Transport and Communications""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Couldn't found the data and there is no evidence that the data exist."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"683957f8-109a-4cbd-97c8-6b8a5e859ba9","global","2017-01-17T12:21:38","2016","zw","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I google searched Government Budget Zimbabwe and found this source on the first page of search results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Republic of Zimbabwe Ministry of Finance and Economic Development"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Cannot open up PDF to be sure of what data is available.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.zimtreasury.gov.zw/"",""descValue"":""Zimbabwe Treasury (Ministry of Finance and Economic Development)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.zimtreasury.gov.zw/index.php/treasury-quartery-bulletins?download=48:2017-estimates-of-expenditure"",""descValue"":""2017 estimate of expenditure""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Comment Reviewer: added the actual budget estimates for 2017 and thus updated question B3: budget details are provided. ",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Anna Alberts","60","60"
"65f2ea89-d87e-4a5d-bacd-f1900a1475ef","global","2017-03-19T15:00:54","2016","ro","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" Agentia Nationala de Cadastru si Publicitate Imobiliara"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Arianit Dobroshi for the contribution.","Boundaries of parcels and parcels ID are available on the Imobile ANCPI, the official geoportal.","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"29d26a95-4e3a-482f-9195-e39c4bae3794","global","2017-03-19T14:52:29","2016","ro","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Romanian Post"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Oana Funaru for her contribution. ","The postcodes are available, without georeference under the Romanian Government open license. There are extensive efforts to geocode all postcodes and to add street and number references, but the process is not trivial at all. Additionally, the Romanian Post is also involved, as the official party. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"57965906-fc3f-4ade-b4db-eaa728325789","global","2016-12-12T18:29:21","2016","ro","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The TopRo5 :Topographic Plan Reference Framework in digital format, scale 1: 5,000 is not openly licensed. There has been some openness from the officials regarding the subject, but nothing has happened until now. ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""view service only""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried a web search engine for \""Geoportal Romania\"". Once at the ANCPI, Inis Viewer is on the left menu."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://geoportal.ancpi.ro/geoportal/catalog/content/disclaimer.page"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Disclaimer page linked in the footer says it is public information. No restrictions are mentioned ""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" Agentia Nationala de Cadastru si Publicitate Imobiliara"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://geoportal.ancpi.ro/geoportal/viewer/index.html"",""descValue"":""Inis Viewer - Inspire Geoportal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Codrina Maria Ilie","45","45"
"399cbfb1-4cec-45d6-a2f1-38fcb3814b96","global","2016-12-31T09:10:38","2016","mm","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""There is no information nor evidence shown that the Myanmar President's Office is collecting the data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The official website to the Myanmar President's Officer https://www.president-office.gov.mm/en/""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The UN Country Team and Humanitarian Country Team initiate a website Myanmar Information Management Unit (MIMU) that provides information management services to strengthen analysis and decision-making of the humanitarian and development community in Myanmar. MIMU is under the direct management of the UN Resident and Humanitarian Coordinator. Place codes (zip codes or postal codes) are downloadable from this link https://www.themimu.info/place-codes","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"aece938c-b10d-4197-bc4f-70ddbf713d2c","global","2017-01-19T17:07:11","2016","mz","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"b362a0a1-cfd3-44d8-b5dd-66485d697e52","global","2017-03-19T10:39:33","2016","mz","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Correios de Moçambique"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Tricia Govindasamy for the contribution."," https://www.correios.co.mz/","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"30a90f94-510a-4f2b-a287-5bb194c7f72d","global","2017-01-19T16:35:12","2016","mz","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"85a9ff74-76f7-4cc8-a576-bb0566f3d3f7","global","2017-03-19T10:07:55","2016","me","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Real Estate Administration of Montenegro"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Arianit Dobroshi for his contribution.","There is land information available through viewing/discovery service from the Real Estate Administration of Montenegro Geoportal. However, the dataset is not fully compliant, property value and tenure type are missing. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"ea5bb633-92a3-49bb-88bb-92096e7f28e4","global","2016-12-15T13:07:40","2016","me","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Couldn't find a source. Emails to the postal regulatory authority \tekip@ekip.me and Montenegro Post info@postacg.me have not been answered at this point.""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Pošta Crne Gore"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Unclear. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"0577b7d5-ae61-45ec-a29c-6815fb03e6d4","global","2017-01-19T15:14:24","2016","bw","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Surveys and Mapping, Ministry of Lands and Housing"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","FYI https://www.fig.net/resources/proceedings/fig_proceedings/accra/papers/ts14/ts14_05_morebodi.pdf",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"212bc64c-8bad-490e-9d7b-48778ccc60a9","global","2017-01-19T15:09:48","2016","bw","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""BotswanaPost"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","https://www.botspost.co.bw/",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"964967fc-4f45-47a7-a3f6-ddff81b7c667","global","2017-01-19T15:14:37","2016","bw","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Surveys and Mapping, Ministry of Lands and Housing"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","https://www.atlas.gov.bw/index.html",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"ed8d94fb-fbaa-4286-a20f-5b1850177ca0","global","2016-12-14T14:59:24","2016","me","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""WMS service""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""WMS service""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried an online search engine for \""Geoportal Montenegro\"". Once on the Geoportal website, looked at the services available."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""I found it while looking for administrative borders."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Real Estate Administration of Montenegro"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://213.149.105.122/geoportal/visiosviewer/mapviewer.page"",""descValue"":""Geoportal - Real Estate Administration of Montenegro ""},{""urlValue"":""https://213.149.105.122/geoportal/catalog/search/browse/browse.page"",""descValue"":""Catalog of Services - Geoportal - Real Estate Administration of Montenegro ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Codrina Maria Ilie","65","65"
"b9701af9-08bd-4edc-892e-6bfbe1186008","global","2017-03-19T09:21:23","2016","mx","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The data is collected at local government level. There are 32 cadastral state offices and 32 public property registry offices. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Enrique Zapata for the contribution.","Land information data for some states can be found here:
https://datos.gob.mx/busca/dataset?q=catastro&sort=score+desc%2C+metadata_modified+desc&page=1 state and municipal government cadasters
https://datos.gob.mx/busca/organization/ran National Agricultural land Registry
Open license: https://datos.gob.mx/libreusomx
","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"3c014215-d7d0-4b1f-a23f-8ceecfec65a0","global","2016-12-29T22:27:58","2016","mx","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""KML"",""SHP"",""SHX"",""TXT"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Mexican government started a campaign to redirect mexican agencies to one portal. \n\nNow, sepomex.gob.mx redirect to gob.mx/correosdemexico \n\nbut if I google it sepomex i can find \nwww.correosdemexico.com.mx\n\nCan be confusing""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.sepomex.gob.mx/lservicios/servicios/descarga.aspx"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""SEPOMEX"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Zipcodes"",""Addresses"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Data available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.sepomex.gob.mx/lservicios/servicios/descarga.aspx"",""descValue"":""Mexican Postal Service""},{""urlValue"":""https://datos.gob.mx/busca/dataset/codigos-postales-coordenadas-y-colonias"",""descValue"":""National Open Data Portal ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","Yes","Sergio Araiza","Codrina Maria Ilie","100","100"
"9a3c5315-bd99-4202-8dc9-d0888822b036","global","2017-03-19T01:34:47","2016","nz","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Clicked on the link for the election in question. There are summaries and details by electorate. The \\\""statistics\\\"" link holds advanced detailed reports, in HTML and CSV formats"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.elections.org.nz/privacy\"",\""commentValue"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""New Zealand Electoral Commission (Māori: Te Kaitiaki Take Kōwhiri)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.electionresults.govt.nz/"",""descValue"":""Official New Zealand election results""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Submission accepted. Navigation through the website to find elections results is pretty straightforward and it is possible to quickly access a summary of results, besides downloading the CSV file. These files present a complete form of the results. Data is up to date. Invalid votes and spoiled ballots are recorded as “Informal votes”.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","85","85"
"910483b8-9012-4912-b682-8267ace73825","global","2017-01-12T16:09:37","2016","nl","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""GML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":"" raster formats (GeoTIFF) as well. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to the index of 2015, went to the website listed there, searched on the page for the relevant link (the 2015 link gave a 404 error)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Publieke Dienstverlening op de Kaart (PDOK)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.pdok.nl/nl/producten/pdok-downloads/downloadservice-basisregistratie-topografie-brt"",""descValue"":""Downloadservice Basisregistratie Topografie (BRT)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","Yes","Ploegerieke L","Codrina Maria Ilie","100","100"
"6ae1f4e0-5afc-4819-81fd-4519dde73e89","global","2017-03-19T00:36:51","2016","nz","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Land Information New Zealand"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"There are significant information related to land information. Unfortunately, there is no data on property value and thus not fully compliant with the survey.
Data is available at: https://data.linz.govt.nz/layer/772-nz-primary-parcels/ and https://data.linz.govt.nz/data/. License: https://data.linz.govt.nz/data/
available data formats: https://help.koordinates.com/using-data/file-formats-data-types/introducing-file-formats/
There's some other functionality not mentioned, like being able to preview the data on the map and crop it to a specific area prior to download.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"97a2d1a2-a30b-487b-88ff-b7ba758a402c","global","2017-01-23T09:29:28","2016","nz","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Requires substantial license fees for each file, along with restrictive usage conditions.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""PAF and GeoPAF is in .dat files""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Visited NZ Post website based on prior knowledge of NZ Post's curation of postal addresses and postcodes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""NZ Post Limited"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Zipcodes"",""Addresses"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Data available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.nzpost.co.nz/business/direct-marketing/direct-marketing-products-services/quality-addressing/postal-address-file-paf"",""descValue"":""NZ Post Postal Address File (PAF)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.nzpost.co.nz/business/direct-marketing/direct-marketing-products-services/quality-addressing/geopaf"",""descValue"":""NZ Post GeoPAF""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.nzpost.co.nz/business/direct-marketing/direct-marketing-products-services/quality-addressing/postcode-network-file"",""descValue"":""NZ Post Postcode Network File (PNF)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Once again NZ's ranking will be diminished because address data is not openly licensed.","Yes","No","Jonathan Hunt","Codrina Maria Ilie","50","50"
"4446e95d-33ca-4e96-b236-8e12bb83775c","global","2016-12-15T16:08:43","2016","nir","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Land and Property Services (LPS)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.nidirect.gov.uk/articles/how-find-out-ownership-details-property-and-land"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"https://www.nidirect.gov.uk/articles/searching-the-land-registry","Yes","No","Bob Harper","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"b9d0c356-f55f-45e0-b152-560bf3375739","global","2016-12-15T10:46:56","2016","nir","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""GML"",""GeoJSON"",""HTML"",""JSON"",""KML"",""SHP"",""WFS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Each dataset must be downloaded separated. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched on www.opendatani.gov.uk "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""ALL data on OpenDataNI is available under the Open Government Licence - https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/version/2/ "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Land & Property Services "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.opendatani.gov.uk/dataset/osni-open-data-50k-transport-line"",""descValue"":""transport lines 1:50,000""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.opendatani.gov.uk/dataset/osni-open-data-50k-transport-text"",""descValue"":""transport text 1:50,000""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.opendatani.gov.uk/dataset/osni-open-data-50k-transport-points"",""descValue"":""transport points 1:50,000""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.opendatani.gov.uk/dataset/osni-open-data-midscale-raster"",""descValue"":""1:10,000 map of Northern Ireland ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.opendatani.gov.uk/dataset/osni-open-data-50m-digital-terrain-model-csv"",""descValue"":""50m DTM - height data ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.opendatani.gov.uk/dataset/osni-open-data-10m-dtm-sheets-1-50"",""descValue"":""10m height data ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.opendatani.gov.uk/dataset/osni-open-data-10m-dtm-sheets-101-150"",""descValue"":""10m height data ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.opendatani.gov.uk/dataset/osni-open-data-10m-dtm-sheets-151-200"",""descValue"":""10m height data ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.opendatani.gov.uk/dataset/osni-open-data-10m-dtm-sheets-201-250"",""descValue"":""10m height data ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.opendatani.gov.uk/dataset/osni-open-data-10m-dtm-sheets-251-293"",""descValue"":""10m height data ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.opendatani.gov.uk/dataset/https-www-daera-ni-gov-uk-sites-default-files-publications-doe-lakewaterbodygml-zip"",""descValue"":""lakewater bodies ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.opendatani.gov.uk/dataset/https-www-daera-ni-gov-uk-sites-default-files-publications-doe-riversegmentgml-zip"",""descValue"":""rivers ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.opendatani.gov.uk/dataset/osni-open-data-50k-admin-boundaries-ni-outline"",""descValue"":""National border dataset ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Open DataNI","Codrina Maria Ilie","85","85"
"b6ee020a-7422-4282-ae9b-84c0e6f31e51","global","2016-12-15T11:47:06","2016","my","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Director General of Lands and Mines and Department of Survey and Mapping Malaysia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""These departments is under the Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment (NRE)""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"In Malaysia, land ownership at national level is managed by 2 agencies; Department of Lands and Mines (JKPTG) & The Department of Survey and Mapping Malaysia (JUPEM). Link: https://www.nre.gov.my/ms-my/Tanah/Pages/default.aspx. Since, JKPTG and JUPEM are under the federal territory, the data available are not open to the public and entrance fees are required to request the data. However, there are several cases whereby Malay reserve land owner able to request the data at their respective state from the Land Department Office, which for Selangor and Penang case, the FOI act is available. Thus, the owners have their right to request access of the data.","Yes","No","Hazwany Jamaluddin","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"f758647f-aa1b-4199-8d64-55e38995424b","global","2016-12-15T13:14:46","2016","my","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Survey and Mapping Malaysia and Pos Malaysia Berhad"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Department of Survey and Mapping is under the Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment (NRE). Pos Malaysia Berhad is a public company owned by a parent company DRB-HICOM.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Hazwany Jamaluddin","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"2e2451c8-ea3c-4ff8-9a2f-7282d3b21dc5","global","2016-12-14T17:17:12","2016","my","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Survey and Mapping Malaysia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Reference link to the Department of Survey and Mapping Malaysia website: https://www.jupem.gov.my/v1/my/","Yes","No","Hazwany Jamaluddin","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"be82fd82-f9f6-4c74-aa13-ad2bb235d75b","global","2017-01-21T19:17:24","2016","no","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Only viewable through web site. Some details require login via national ID-portal.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Some information is, but some details require registering.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Knew the address from filling out the index a previous year"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Norwegian Mapping Authority (Kartverket)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""You can do 10 searches in the Land Register per login. ""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Parcel boundaries (inc. latitude and longitude)"",""Parcel ID"",""Property value (i.e. Price Paid, Property Tax Value)"",""Tenure Type (ie. leasehold, freehold, protected lands, public lands, customary lands)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.seeiendom.no/"",""descValue"":""www.seeiendom.no""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Bergheimivar L","Codrina Maria Ilie","30","30"
"b3649e20-5d6d-46f6-ad7f-90a21c53ede6","global","2016-12-11T13:22:53","2016","om","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Ministry of Housing"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The Ministry of Housing of Oman has an electronic database for lands in the country that it uses to administer land registrations. An interface has been made available for residents in the capital to access the data for own property on the system ( https://eservices.housing.gov.om/arb/Pages/Maps.aspx ). It is not possible to generally browse the database or look up properties owned by other people.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"c383aa46-3741-472d-afaa-08c81d21bb3a","global","2017-01-27T16:51:03","2016","om","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""There is no zipcode system in Oman, the zipcodes are only for regions, not for houses. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"2dccfe63-1aad-46b0-b79e-e78e16a9a69a","global","2016-12-11T13:19:39","2016","om","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""View service. I only viewed the web based map, but it is possible to download the data in other formats. I don't have an account to verify what formats are available. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Download feature is only available to registered users. Sample screen is shown on FAQ. I did not register because registration requires contacting the authority and acquiring individual approval.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The maps can be viewed without registration, but registration is required to download the data offline and to request additional services.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The website is a bit slow and not very user friendly.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Go the website of NSCI (www.nsci.gov.om), select Geospatial Oman from the main menu, then click on Browse Geospatial Data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I did not have access to the data to verify this.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Centre for Statistics and Information"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://nsdig2gapps.ncsi.gov.om/geoplatform/#"",""descValue"":""The Official Portal for Geospatial Data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The National Centre for Statistics and Information has a dedicated portal for Geospatial Data, the maps are detailed and offer a variety of information lawyers. However, to download the data, you must register. Registration is free, but requires contacting the authority and individual approval.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Codrina Maria Ilie","45","45"
"f4745a43-42f6-4aff-88a3-d0747a573dd7","global","2017-02-02T02:15:56","2016","pk","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of States and Frontier Regions"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"84541bd4-e8b5-4a55-9fd6-92befd33939f","global","2017-03-18T22:39:33","2016","pk","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Pakistan Post"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Nouman Nazim for the contribution.","un-georeferenced list of postcodes https://www.pakpost.gov.pk/postcode/postcode.html","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"890233e5-863a-4bd7-8f23-7523adc399b4","global","2017-03-18T22:36:37","2016","pk","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Survey of Pakistan "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Nouman Nazim for the contribution.","https://www.surveyofpakistan.gov.pk/ - 3000k un-georeferenced raster map. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"06c85e8a-f5d5-4f49-a9a7-a82ffaa1e03f","global","2016-12-15T17:37:49","2016","pa","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Autoridad Nacional de Administración de Tierras"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The website of the Public Registry of Panama, (https://www.rp.gob.pa/ValidacionDigital.aspx), prior registration in its interface allows access to certain cadastral information, and public documentes in PDF format, where you could extract the information on price, boundaries, improvements, etc. but with a lot of human effort.","Yes","No","Victor Díaz Navarro","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"5ab93cfb-8d17-4008-abd2-22caea643827","global","2016-12-15T14:52:26","2016","pa","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Unfortunately in Panama, this information is not collected, at least not at the government level, probably disordered way in which the city was developed, together with the lack of interest of the different governments in establishing a policy aimed at improving this issue."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Victor Díaz Navarro","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"6031de7d-2032-40c1-8d87-b56776ac0015","global","2017-03-18T22:13:38","2016","pa","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Autoridad Nacional de Administración de Tierras (ANATI) /Instituto Geográfico Nacional (IGN)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":"" IGN is a sub-division of ANATI (Land Administraion Authority)""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Victor Díaz Navarro for the contribution.","https://datos.geored.opendata.arcgis.com/ Maps geoportal
https://www.ipde.gob.pa/ Geoespacial information
https://ignpanama.anati.gob.pa/ National Geográphic Institute
Comments from the first submitter: I think they are making a great effort in collecting this information but again theres a lack of difusion and comunication strategies.
Therea lack of information that is useful for the population and is up to date.
I and the population in general had no knowledge that this portal was there.
They should share information between the two portals www.datosabiertos.gob.pa, and https://datos.geored.opendata.arcgis.com/ to unify and strength datasets.","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"c7bf4d18-a92b-4c38-b8cb-9613e710ba00","global","2016-12-06T15:37:04","2016","py","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Servicio Nacional de Catastro"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is a map but without the possibility to download or explore the data: https://www.catastro.gov.py/visor/?snc=geo""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Lupinupa L","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"fc320e49-dab8-44cb-b2e3-30bc1559cac9","global","2016-12-02T15:40:15","2016","py","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Dirección Nacional de Correos del Paraguay"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Lupinupa L","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"d7a3c4e3-2ffb-48ce-adc6-7c82197b8f7f","global","2017-03-18T21:55:58","2016","py","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""DBF"",""GeoJSON"",""KML"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""+ svg""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I have to ask some experts"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Dirección General de Estadística, Encuestas y Censos"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.datos.gov.py/organization/direccion-general-de-estadisticas-encuestas-y-censos-dgeec"",""descValue"":""national open data portal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Lupinupa L for the contribution.","Also, there are some maps in Dirección Nacinal de Catastro but don't satisfy any of the criteria. This is the web: https://www.catastro.gov.py/cartocad.html","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","85","85"
"7d8c1ced-edcc-4bf2-91b3-4b5e1fa666d3","global","2017-02-02T21:38:27","2016","pe","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is a WMS service but it won't load""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Sistema nacional integrado información catastral predial"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","https://www.sncp.gob.pe:8087/ServicioSNCP/ - not working during the review. ","A WMS service exists but couldn't access ","Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"e29914c9-ee1c-4f55-b58d-0b43367f404b","global","2017-01-12T15:32:32","2016","pe","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""search and discovery service""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Need to find your community or district, later select the polygon and check the zipcode"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Transporte y Comunicaciones"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Zipcodes"",""Addresses"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Data available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.codigopostal.gob.pe/pages/invitado/consulta.jsf"",""descValue"":""Peruvian Zip codes system""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","
",,"Yes","No","Antonio Cucho Gamboa","Codrina Maria Ilie","45","45"
"79699a61-331b-46ea-810c-653c0c09b39c","global","2017-01-11T14:57:06","2016","pe","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""view service""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Select layers (on the right) and explore the especific zone that you want explore, also if you have the zone number you could find it faster"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Transportes y Comunicaciones"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.mtc.gob.pe/transportes/caminos/renac.html"",""descValue"":""Registro Nacional de Carreteras""},{""urlValue"":""https://geocatmin.ingemmet.gob.pe/geocatmin/index.html"",""descValue"":""Registro de Mapas""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Antonio Cucho Gamboa","Codrina Maria Ilie","15","15"
"bd0b7f4d-9761-4325-9ae6-10d11588d9cb","global","2016-12-20T11:48:51","2016","ph","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""DENR - Land Management Bureau"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The LMB does not seem to publish any of this data publicly.""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"6225c484-600d-4888-81c3-6d95e9aa9297","global","2017-03-18T20:44:08","2016","ph","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Philippine Postal Corporation (PHLPost)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"https://www.phlpost.gov.ph/zip-code-search.php : PHLPost website allowing for zip code search by province","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"eab706cb-65fc-4b26-aab6-fb9115309108","global","2016-12-15T09:35:31","2016","ph","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data from the Geoportal can be sourced for use with GIS applications (e.g. QGIS, ArcGIS, QGIS) but not for direct download.\n\nShapefiles are available from PhilGIS in multiple formats, which is great! However, they are lacking in resources, as a volunteer effort, and so are lacking in up-to-date data.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""NAMRIA: Home page -> Downloads page. PhilGIS: Click region for desired data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Mapping and Resource Information Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Terrain basemap available to view online via the Geoportal.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.namria.gov.ph/download.php"",""descValue"":""Map download page""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.philgis.org/"",""descValue"":""Unofficial GIS data resource website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.geoportal.gov.ph/"",""descValue"":""Map viewer designed for web and use in conjunction with GIS applications.""},{""urlValue"":""https://philgis.org/node/91"",""descValue"":""PhilGIS: country-wide datasets""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""On NAMRIA: Only thumbnails of 1:250,000 scale maps available,\nhigh-res 1:50,000 available for download\n\nGeoportal: basemap available for download, but only after requesting access.""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Some data is available, but not to the scale/openness needed to allow for ""Open Data"".","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","50","50"
"a0b127f8-ce70-4f5b-9f30-c3e2c5913949","global","2017-03-18T14:42:08","2016","pl","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Land ownership data is collected by Ministry of Justice but it's not geolocated and it's not really open. A lot of data is also gathered by subgovernmental agencies. \n""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministertwo Sprawiedliwości (Ministry of Justice), Główny Urząd Geodezji i Kartografii (GUGiK, Head Office of Land Surveying and Cartography) "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Krzysztof Madejski for the contribution.","https://ekw.ms.gov.pl Registry of land ownership; One has to know land registry ID
https://mapy.geoportal.gov.pl/imap/ Parcel boundaries with IDs
However, knowing the ID of the parcel one has to go physically to the regional office and ask for a ownership information (land registry entry) and pay for it.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"9ade4552-635c-47cc-a5db-7cd91de75482","global","2017-03-18T14:23:20","2016","pl","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Poczta Polska (Polish Post Office) "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Krzysztof Madejski for the contribution.","There is a search service available, but the data has not been geocoded. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"8abcf2ab-29e8-4ebd-aea5-5e2979cefaf6","global","2016-12-27T13:46:32","2016","pl","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Most of it is licensed commercially: https://www.geoportal.gov.pl/regulamin""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Web Map Service, Web Map Tile Service, Catalogue Service for Web, Web Coverage Service""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Only some datasets from above mentioned list are available for free to download: borders national and administrative and hights. For the others ones has to pay.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is updated regularly.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Geoportal web-browser allows to view most of the data for free without the need to registration.\nMost data available through web services (WFS etc) are paid and registration is needed. ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Geoportal web-browser allows to view most of the data for free without the need to registration.\nMost data available through web services (WFS etc) are paid and registration is needed. ""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google search's first page of results for \""country map\"" links to GeoPortal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Web-browser default viewing mode does not allow to change layers. Viewing data bulks requires proficiency in GIS software.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Główny Urząd Geodezji i Kartografii (GUGiK, Head Office of Land Surveying and Cartography) (1), Centralny Ośrodek Dokumentacji Geodezyjnej i Kartograficznej (CODGiK, Central Geodetic and Cartographic Documentation Centre) "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""## Sources\n(1): https://www.gugik.gov.pl/\n(2): https://codgik.gov.pl/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://geoportal.gov.pl/"",""descValue"":""Web-browser, links to data, catalog of services (WFS,WMS, etc.)""},{""urlValue"":""https://codgik.gov.pl/index.php/darmowe-dane.html"",""descValue"":""Some free key datasets available to download""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The WFS service requires authentication ""DescribeFeatureType failed for url restrictToRequestBBOX='1' srsname='EPSG:4326' typename='tbd:Przewod_rurowy' url='https://mapy.geoportal.gov.pl/wss/service/pub/guest/kompozycjaG2_TBD_WFS/MapServer/WFSServer' version='auto' table="""" sql=: Download of feature type failed: Host requires authentication"". ",,"Yes","No","Krzysztof Madejski","Codrina Maria Ilie","45","45"
"353f0cb0-6ab8-41f9-9eb4-b1be44971851","global","2017-03-18T13:13:48","2016","pt","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Direção-Geral do Território"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""As said in the last year) Existing data is based on a mid-20th century survey; it has been scanned and it's available to see it in the browser on DG Território but the PDF it's not downloadable (and last year it was apparently) and it's still useless. Efforts to make a digital survey are still ongoing but far from complete.""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Joana Ventura for the contribution.","According to the Direção-Geral do Território is the national official organization with a formal mandate: ""Responsible for the National Geodetic Network and Cadastre. The organization is a National reference on Catrography, and the official co-ordinator for the National System of Geographical Information, the Portuguese Spatial Data Infrastructure. It is also responsible for pursuing public policies for territorial planning and urbanism.""","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"31d825bb-449d-4624-a682-262858ed1e1f","global","2017-03-18T12:38:07","2016","pt","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""CTT - Correios de Portugal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Search service provided (no georeference): https://www.ctt.pt/feapl_2/app/open/postalCodeSearch/postalCodeSearch.jspx;jsessionid=wv-tew4b6Cj9EiuEPpZkBg__.si_part6_node3","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"9a7c9a65-ab47-4e98-981a-f25849403d9c","global","2017-03-18T12:29:01","2016","pt","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" Informação geográfica"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"On the Ingeo Portal there are datasets that could qualify for this category. However, the WxS services are not working [SERVICO TEMPORARIAMENTE INDISPONIVEL. ---- RASTER das Series Cartograficas da DGT.] and I found no way to download the data. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"20781fc3-0225-4d76-abfb-5695b533799e","global","2016-12-31T08:56:06","2016","mm","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is a website of the Budget department and some mention of fiscal transparency. So it is most likely that spending data is collected by a government department. \nhttps://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=my&tl=en&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.mof.gov.mm%2Fmy%2Fcontent%2Fရသံုးမွန္းေျခေငြစာရင္းဦးစီးဌာန\n\nHowever, due to translation, it's not possible to find respective government spending data. ""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""There is no information nor evidence shown that the Myanmar President's Office is collecting the data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The official website to the Myanmar President's Officer https://www.president-office.gov.mm/en/""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The 2015 result from the Open Budget Index shown that the data is exist https://survey.internationalbudget.org/#rankings","Yes","No","anonymous","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"75ecab08-084d-421a-b46d-dceb943c50a6","global","2016-12-14T16:12:35","2016","me","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Copyright is claimed on websites looked.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Mostly PDF. Some XLS as well.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""In weekly files.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Weekly files running about 3-4 weeks behind the closing of the reported week.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I noticed analytical cards (analiticke karte) links while browsing for other data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Every government institution presents weekly data on their own."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Individual record of transactions"",""Government office which had the transaction"",""Date of transaction"",""Name of vendor"",""Amount of the transaction""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.mif.gov.me/rubrike/analiticke_kartice_i_putni_nalozi/analiticke_kartice/166634/Izvjestaj-za-period-od-31-10-06-11-2016-godine.html"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Finance""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.msp.gov.me/vodici/Analiticke"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Transport""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Diana Krebs","45","45"
"ebad9fc0-d534-4e2c-bfad-68fc32e91c29","global","2016-12-12T22:04:35","2016","mx","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""In the main page there is a slide show where it is directly linked to the data. I didn't find any other way to do it. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.transparenciapresupuestaria.gob.mx/es/PTP/Terminos_y_Condiciones"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.transparenciapresupuestaria.gob.mx/es/PTP/datos_presupuestarios_abiertos"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","Yes","Oscar Montiel","Diana Krebs","100","100"
"475f1627-8ef7-417a-918b-3c047b7410e5","global","2016-11-21T17:39:31","2016","mk","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Ministry of Finance provides budget revenues and expenditures monthly, with the latest available being September. Transactional data is not available to the public, although it may be assumed that it exists as the final accounts represent aggregated data. The report is provided in PDF https://www.finance.gov.mk/en/node/699""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"8cd8f851-dbbd-4fd5-850d-55da513fac1b","global","2017-03-17T14:35:55","2016","ls","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""The government websites, such as Parliament, Senate and National Assembly are all down."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The government websites, such as Parliament, Senate and National Assembly are all down. Without access to these sites, I am unable to confirm the availability of the data.","Originally submitted by Tricia Govindasamy, which pointed to this source: https://www.lesotholii.org/, where only a selection of laws are available.","Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","0","0"
"b1517ace-9f22-4339-a3ea-0b63a2c3eacf","global","2017-03-17T14:24:50","2016","jm","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Jamaica Houses of Parliament"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","On the website for the Houses of Parliament, both public (https://www.japarliament.gov.jm/index.php/publications/bills/public-bills) and private bills (https://www.japarliament.gov.jm/index.php/publications/bills/private-bills) are listed. While the website states that these bills are ""currently being considered by Parliament,"" the status of the bills is unclear. The content and author of the bills are available to view and download in PDF format. ","Originally submitted by Alesha Aris: ""I visited the Ministry of Justice Jamaica website, I was then directed to the house of Parliament website. It is under the publications tab that I was able to find documents related to the data.""","Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","0","0"
"8bd3e99d-e84e-44df-9856-d0873a3d58b9","global","2017-03-17T13:19:22","2016","fi","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.finlex.net/fi/kayttoehdot/""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML, PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Web search with keywords"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Justice"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.finlex.net/fi/#sd"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","From the Finlex website that is easily searchable, one of the three main tabs on the main page is ""Recent Legislation and Bills,"" under which data for the latest draft bills are clearly identified. The title, status and author, alongside other pertinent information such as the dates it has been discussed, and by whom, are all available to view in HTML. The content of the bill is available to view and download in PDF.","Original submission by Aleksi Knuutila, stated ""Some data is in the process of being opened, as of January 2017. This data includes documents related to the legislative process, the discussions held in parliament, as well as votes on bills. According to the civil servants working on the issue, this data will be available in February 2017, though there might be some delays from this schedule.""","Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","45","45"
"99ee504b-f196-480f-b87e-e4e558de6a7c","global","2016-12-14T11:11:20","2016","lv","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""According to the Freedom of Information Law the information that is published by institutions providing state functions can be interpreted as \""generally accessible information\"" that is compatible with Public domain approach. The law does not require for the institutions to publish declarations or licences with the information (they can be provided on voluntary basis).""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is not clear when the latest data is available, for example for year 2016, there is no data from August to December, but it is possible to find information from June / July.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Yes, but only after selecting data and CAPCHA code infput.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I knew where the data was."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.vvc.gov.lv/export/sites/default/docs/LRTA/Likumi/Freedom_of_Information_Law.doc "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Treasury"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Individual record of transactions"",""Government office which had the transaction"",""Date of transaction"",""Amount of the transaction""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.kase.gov.lv/?module=maks&object_id=7446"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Toms Ceļmillers","Diana Krebs","50","50"
"12246f46-cb87-4942-8fca-55a068dd6aa6","global","2016-12-05T11:53:36","2016","jp","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled for the data and found the data in the first search result."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.bb.mof.go.jp/hdocs/bxssenv.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Individual record of transactions"",""Government office which had the transaction"",""Name of vendor"",""Amount of the transaction""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.mof.go.jp/budget/budger_workflow/account/index.html"",""descValue"":""in Japanese""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bb.mof.go.jp/hdocs/bxsselect.html"",""descValue"":""published in PDF, Excel, and XML format (in Japanese). ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.cas.go.jp/jp/seisaku/gyoukaku/H27_review/H27_Review_Sheet001/H28_Review_Sheet001.html"",""descValue"":""Expenditure review sheet of 5000 projects by all ministries.""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.cas.go.jp/jp/seisaku/gyoukaku/H27_review/H27_Review_Sheet_Database001/H28_Review_Sheet_Database001.html"",""descValue"":""Expenditure review sheet of 5000 projects by all ministries (database).""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Masahiko Shoji","Diana Krebs","85","85"
"f6e32ac8-d2ad-4216-817e-200a5bb060a8","global","2017-03-17T13:03:05","2016","bt","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Web search with keywords"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Council of Bhutan"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.nationalcouncil.bt/en/business/view_bill_detail/62"",""descValue"":""Bills for Public Feedback""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The National Council of Bhutan hosts Bills, available under ""Business"" on the main menu, https://www.nationalcouncil.bt/en/business/bills. The status is available in HTML, while the content of the draft is available to view and download in PDF. While the author is not necessarily included for all bills, it was included in the content of some therefore I have modified this submission to account for the availability of the data. ",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","30","30"
"5fc8dc4e-8f33-442c-9663-5d88752c39a4","global","2017-01-27T18:23:19","2016","il","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://foi.gov.il/he/node/117 License is not open""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There are multiple file, one for each department and quarter. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Most government offices did not publish this data on time ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I had knowledge on the subject, so I knew where to look, but it doesn't not come up on google search or the Israeli gov portal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Freedom of Information Unit - Ministry of Justice"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Individual record of transactions"",""Government office which had the transaction"",""Date of transaction"",""Name of vendor"",""Amount of the transaction""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://foi.gov.il/he/search/site/?f%5B0%5D=im_field_mmdsubjects%3A367"",""descValue"":""Spending report""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This page hold all the links to all of the government offices reports. ""}]","Yes","Yes",,"This is a new procedure by the government of Israel","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Diana Krebs","50","50"
"ce49e261-d1b6-425b-a619-5d943c947198","global","2016-12-04T20:31:26","2016","im","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""reports on https://financereports.gov.im include aggregated expenditures and revenues not at itemised transactional level""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Treasury"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Graeme Jones","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"4ff96247-515f-4b22-a59c-d4fc87a0c40a","global","2017-03-17T12:48:36","2016","bd","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bangladesh Parliament"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission pointed to Bangladesh's Law and Justice Division (https://lawjusticediv.portal.gov.bd/) and the Ministry of Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs (https://www.minlaw.gov.bd/), however both only have law data. The parliament's website has a section for ""Bill and Legislation,"" with a link to a ""Bill Monitoring System"" here, https://www.parliament.gov.bd/index.php/bill-and-legislation-2#, however these links are unpopulated. ","Original submission by Nurunnaby Hasive","Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","0","0"
"4c645809-18c4-4d56-84ef-afb3b35e7602","global","2017-03-17T12:38:03","2016","bw","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Attorney General's Chambers"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The Botswana e-laws website, initiated by the Attorney General's Chambers has a section on the website for bills here, https://www.elaws.gov.bw/default.php?UID=659, however there is only one bill listed, and the link to view the content doesn't work. For these reasons, the data is not available online.","Original submission by Tricia Govindasamy ","Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","0","0"
"dc87ad40-ed07-47c3-9914-12a587436d79","global","2017-03-17T12:30:19","2016","bw","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Attorney Generals Chambers"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","New legislation in Botswana is available here: https://www.elaws.gov.bw/default.php?UID=660, however the links to the view the content of this legislation do not work. Historical laws are searchable here: https://www.elaws.gov.bw/default.php?UID=602#, where they are available to view and download in DOC and PDF, however I was unable to locate amendments. For these reasons, I have classified the data as not available online. ","Original submission by Tricia Govindasamy","Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","0","0"
"1f38cb58-b551-46b9-955e-bd0626721d45","global","2016-12-17T15:21:01","2016","de","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Finanzministerium, Statistisches Bundesamt"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.destatis.de/DE/ZahlenFakten/GesellschaftStaat/OeffentlicheFinanzenSteuern/OeffentlicheFinanzen/AusgabenEinnahmen/Tabellen/Tabellen_AusgabenEinnahmenFinanzierungssaldoJaehrlich.html"",""descValue"":""not detailed data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bundeshaushalt-info.de/"",""descValue"":""projected data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"couldn't find transaction based overview,
","Yes","No","anonymous","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"2d2cff1f-a6ed-41f4-8527-8513755a781a","global","2016-12-28T20:16:00","2016","fr","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance and Public Accounts (Ministère des Finances et des Comptes Publics)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Also, the National Institute of Statistics and Economy Studies seems to collect expenditure and receipts of general government, in XLS. \n\nHowever, document are difficult to find and in the end browsers have trouble to open files: \nhttps://www.insee.fr/en/statistiques/2387925?sommaire=2387999#consulter\n\nAlso, some spending data up to 2010 can be found here: https://www.data.gouv.fr/fr/datasets/depenses-des-administrations-publiques-par-fonction-de-depense-564176/\nStill, accessibility in alignment with open data requirements is not given. \n\n\n""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Public spending data are collected and stored at transactional level on the financial information system named CHORUS. However, the data is not available online as, according to the Etalab open data mission, the database is covered by commercial and statistical secrets.","Yes","No","Open Knowledge","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"93b7926e-0f89-45c5-ba0e-e9acc907dbc2","global","2016-12-19T18:44:54","2016","do","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Hacienda"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"La información que ofrece el portal https://www.transparenciafiscal.gob.do no detalla la información de la manera requerida por OKI para que califique para este índice. ","Yes","No","Miguel Reyes Taveras","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"325046b2-72b7-46e3-b214-5f6ddf2042df","global","2017-02-02T19:39:13","2016","dk","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data exists distributed in local ERP systems but are not collected centrally at transaction level only at a higher level with fewer details. Most government agencies uses \""Navision Stat\"" which is an ERP-system that do send detailed information to central systems but still not at transaction level. See https://www.modst.dk/Systemer/Navision-Stat/Hvad-er-Navision-Stat""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry for Economic Affairs and the Interior for regional and local spending. Ministry of Finance for national level spending"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""To provide independence of different agencies and decrease bureaucracy"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Data are not collected into a single database at transaction level","Yes","No","Niels Erik Kaaber Rasmussen","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"6c37d39a-e2a0-4736-b594-17a72b5bc81b","global","2016-12-03T18:20:45","2016","cz","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Probably Ministry of Finance or Ministry of Interior"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Actual spending data (paid invoices) are available only for a tiny fraction of the government. First office to make such data accessible was the Ministry of Finance, which publishes invoices backdating to 2010. They have also built their own visualisation app to present the data.
Data: https://data.mfcr.cz/cs/dataset/prehled-faktur-ministerstva-financi-cr
Visualisation: https://data.mfcr.cz/supervizor/
Couple of ministries (Justice, Regional development) inspired by them built their data own catalogues, even though the coverage is modest.
In 2016, after a long political fight, a register of contracts awarded was launched. While the data is incomplete (e.g. some prices not published due to trade secret), it is a good info source. Data are also available as monthly XML dumps. However, this will not satisfy the ""actual detailed spending on national level"" criteria. I just wanted to mention the initiative, because it was quite a big step towards govt transparency. https://smlouvy.gov.cz/","Yes","No","Michaela Rybičková","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"a19cc07f-15d5-4619-873f-fcaef909a62e","global","2017-01-05T14:50:31","2016","cm","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Economy, Planning and Regional Development"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Ministry of Public Contracts collect these informations as there is an online public contract system (COLEPS), set up at the beginning of 2016, but the system is not available at this time. On the ministry of economy website, there is a journal of projects for the year, but there is no reporting of expenditures related to last year projects.","Yes","No","Charlie Martial NGOUNOU","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"25e3cf04-092b-40ef-94b9-fcbb66acc431","global","2016-12-31T09:41:30","2016","kh","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Economy and Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The link to the official website https://www.mef.gov.kh/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"There are no evidence found from the Ministry of Economy and Finance official website to confirm that the data exist.","Yes","No","anonymous","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"80d50893-690f-4a10-a26c-74459f05cdfc","global","2016-11-25T17:51:55","2016","br","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There is an Open Data section at the Senado Federal website which provides 46 datasets openly licensed, among them the data from SIGA Brasil System. The license type is “OKD Compliant::Other (Open).”""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""TXT"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""It is also available in PDF. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is necessary to build a query choosing the information you need. You could include all the variables at once, but then you would probably get problems for downloading the file because it would be too much data. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There is a variable “Last Updated” (Data Atualização Dados) indicating this. \n""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""In the case of Portal da Transparência (Ministry of Transparency, Fiscalization and General Controllership of the Union), SIGA (Federal Senate) and SIOP ( from Ministry of Planning, Budget and Management), yes. ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""If you type \""Despesas Governo Federal\"" in google, the first option will be the Transparency Portal. For accessing Federal Senate system (SIGA) although it is not so easy. You must know they have this system available. ""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Type \""SIGA Senado Federal\"", click at the first option and click at the \""Acesso Livre\"" button. After that you must choose one of the datasets available and then build a query using the its variables. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://dadosabertos.senado.leg.br/dataset/or-amento-anual-diretrizes-ppa-etc/resource/1b20b64c-bc6e-4d96-b979-aaad4025701b"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""All the accounting transactions from Brazil federal government are registered at the Integrated Government Financial Management System (SIAFI) from the National Treasury, a department of the Ministry of Finance. However, this system is restricted only for public servers. There is another system from the National Treasury for accessing Government Spending, Management Treasury (Tesouro Gerencial), which is also restricted.\nThe information can be accessed by anyone in others systems such as Portal da Transparência (Ministry of Transparency, Fiscalization and General Controllership of the Union), SIGA (Federal Senate) and SIOP ( from Ministry of Planning, Budget and Management).\n\n\n""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no API and there is no way to easily get the whole dataset at once. Although it is possible to download data in processable format. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Treasury (Tesouro Nacional) "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This is the agency who collects the data, but it will not be the source for this evaluation since it is not open for public access. ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Individual record of transactions"",""Government office which had the transaction"",""Date of transaction"",""Name of vendor"",""Amount of the transaction""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""All these characteristics are available in SIGA and there are also lots of other information about the transactions. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://transparencia.gov.br/"",""descValue"":""Transparency Portal""},{""urlValue"":""https://www12.senado.leg.br/orcamento/sigabrasil"",""descValue"":""Federal Senate""},{""urlValue"":""https://www1.siop.planejamento.gov.br/QvAJAXZfc/opendoc.htm?document=IAS%2FExecucao_Orcamentaria.qvw&host=QVS%40pqlk04&anonymous=true"",""descValue"":""Integrated planning and budgeting system (SIOP)""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""We will consider the source coming from Federal Senate in this case because it allows more flexible queries than others. ""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Andressa Falconiery","Diana Krebs","85","85"
"ac6410e2-3759-4248-9a21-934312f27835","global","2017-03-16T14:35:56","2016","no","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""JSON"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""earched online"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.norge.no/nlod"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Storting"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Read technical documentation and tried the API myself: - Sak (\""agenda item\"") contains names of authors of a bill:""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://stortinget.no/no/Saker-og-publikasjoner/Saker/"",""descValue"":""Official Stortinget website""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.stortinget.no/"",""descValue"":""Parliamentary Data Services offers extracts from databases used in Parliament's parliamentary proceedings. Currently, this means mainly data about voting, issues, questions, and representatives.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The initial submission was missing the main portal for reviewing draft legislation. This has been added and the review amended.""}]","Yes","Yes","The main source for Draft Legislation is the Stortinget website. It provides all necessary required data to qualify as open data. It is the primary source for the content of legislation, transcripts, votes, authors, and status. The Strotinget website is coupled with an official database site that allows for data querying in various formats as well as table and graph building. This source does not include content of legislation, but does provide ability to query (including downloading XML data) on status, authors, voting and the like. Thus, the data is considered to be downloadable at once.","Original submission by Bergheimivar L.","Yes","Yes","Anton Shaffer","Anton Shaffer","100","100"
"d26e8e6b-e797-4b11-93fc-25ed3173619b","global","2017-03-16T14:21:16","2016","de","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search Engine"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bundestag"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://dip21.bundestag.de"",""descValue"":""Bundestag Information System""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. • While content of a bill and authors are available, information regarding votes cannot be found. • The original submission was missing some crucial data indicators and was modified accordingly on the following counts: status of the bill can be found for most legislation, detailed transcripts of debate are available, data from last week can be found. Full bill information is in PDF. Some are available in HTML and CSV – however the latter format does not always work. As such, data is not downloadable at once.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Anton Shaffer","65","65"
"9f933597-6864-46b6-b195-37f33a03039b","global","2017-03-16T14:15:12","2016","de","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search Engine"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bundesministerium für Justiz und Verbraucherschutz / Federal Ministry of Justice and Consumer Protection"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/"",""descValue"":""Law Database of the Federal Ministry of Justice and Consumer Protection ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. • Primary source URL was missing a description -- the proper name of the source was added. during review.","While the information is provided ""free of charge"", no indicate of an open license according to a short search. Laws also available in PDF.","Yes","No","anonymous","Anton Shaffer","65","65"
"5872b548-c2b5-4657-881b-ec4e100c560d","global","2017-03-16T14:06:15","2016","cz","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""TXT""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""The official site in not among top search results, but fits on the first page. On the site law(s) can be searched for by name or number."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://portal.gov.cz/app/zakony/zakonPar.jsp?idBiblio=47807&name=106~2F1999&rpp=15#local-content"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerstvo vnitra / Ministry of Interior"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://portal.gov.cz/app/zakony/?path=/portal/obcan/"",""descValue"":""Search interface National Laws Portal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. • The submission was modified to reflect the fact that the data is indeed openly licensed. Law 106/1999 stipulates Free Access to Information provisions and can be found at the footer (bottom) of the National Laws Portal.","Original submission by Michaela Rybičková","Yes","No","Anton Shaffer","Anton Shaffer","85","85"
"bd78dd71-c172-4f52-8dd5-4c03a14659ac","global","2016-12-11T13:17:55","2016","ba","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Certain data are provided here https://www.fbihvlada.gov.ba/bosanski/budzet/ and here https://mft.gov.ba/bos/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=145&Itemid=95 however there is no indication that such data are kept at the transactional level or in monthly basis as required. Quarterly reports are compiled by the Government at a higher level, see here for Q1-Q3 2016 https://mft.gov.ba/bos/images/stories/budzet/izvrsenje/2016/Izvjestaj_o_%20izvrsenju_Budzeta_institucija_BiH_medjunarodnih_obaveza_BiH_za_I-III_2016-bosanski.pdf""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Design of government process."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no information to this. ""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Diana Krebs","0","0"
"a3c19bd8-58ae-440e-ba85-e45497533b16","global","2016-12-01T20:19:42","2016","tr","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Going on High Council website and click \""The Achieve of election\"" and find the data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""High Council for Elections "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ysk.gov.tr/ysk/faces/Secimler?_adf.ctrl-state=yf0y6pzey_54&training_id%3DYSKPWCN1_4444014427%26=&wcnav.model=YSKUstMenu&_afrLoop=3316812976458607"",""descValue"":""High Council for Elections""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Submission is valid. All fields satisfied. ",,"Yes","No","Adem Emre Topçu","Paola Mosso","80","80"
"9b509a32-2f77-431b-9064-3bb4c6aeba88","global","2017-01-06T23:07:55","2016","ua","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It requires scraping""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search for \""цвк\"" which means Central Election Commission, go to its website, see links to different elections"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Central Election Commission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.cvk.gov.ua/vp_2014/"",""descValue"":""Central Election Commission""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Submission is valid. All fields satisfied. Website would require extensive scraping to collect data.
",,"Yes","No","Vanya Yani","Paola Mosso","45","45"
"fae2b028-46e9-4b41-9ca4-c9f793a9b672","global","2016-12-27T11:30:51","2016","tn","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google and a lot of institutional website put a link to www.isie.tn"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.isie.tn/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""ISIE"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.isie.tn/resultats/"",""descValue"":""L’Instance Supérieure Indépendante pour les Élections ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Submission is valid. Data is available first buy constituency, then per polling station. Data is presented in PDF format.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","80","80"
"32249018-b5de-44ed-add6-1579c5d83697","global","2016-12-23T15:52:08","2016","ch","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search the national OGD portal, then the national information portal ch.ch"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://opendata.swiss/de/dataset/volksabstimmungen-anzahl-angenommene-und-verworfene-abstimmungsvorlagen-nach-typ-seit-1848"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Swiss Federal Statistical Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://opendata.swiss/de/dataset/volksabstimmungen-anzahl-angenommene-und-verworfene-abstimmungsvorlagen-nach-typ-seit-1848"",""descValue"":""Election result counts since 1848""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ch.ch/en/elections2015/"",""descValue"":""Federal elections of 18 October 2015""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bk.admin.ch/themen/pore/nrw/index.html?lang=fr"",""descValue"":""Elections of the National Council""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bfs.admin.ch/bfs/fr/home/statistiques/politique/elections.html"",""descValue"":""Election Statistics portal""},{""urlValue"":""https://opendata.swiss/de/dataset/volksabstimmungen-ergebnisse-ebene-gemeinde-seit-1981"",""descValue"":""Election results on a commune level since 1981""},{""urlValue"":""https://opendata.swiss/de/dataset/volksabstimmungen-ergebnisse-ebene-kanton-seit-1866"",""descValue"":""Election results on a cantonal level since 1866""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Submission is valid, all fields satisfied. For the Federal Assembly, there is at this time still no low-level data (polling station or at least municipality) available.
","For the Federal Assembly, there is at this time still no low-level data (polling station or at least municipality) available.","Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","Paola Mosso","85","85"
"afb15e32-fe28-457f-921d-00405e7dcd1b","global","2017-03-16T08:08:59","2016","rs","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Republic Electorial Commission, Statistical Office of the Republic of Serbia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Submission was rejected since latest parliamentary elections results (2016) are not available. Archive with press releases and results is available (https://www.rik.parlament.gov.rs/arhiva.php). As submitter notes, different pieces of data are provided in various formats (PDF, DOC, XLS) which complicates reuse.
As for license, in accordance with Article 6 of the Law on Copyright and Related Rights, the official documents of state institutions do not enjoy copyright protection i.e. are in public domain.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"ea893ac2-9400-435b-8520-cd00b4cb5549","global","2016-12-13T20:05:41","2016","lv","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Uncertain how to answer this. In practice election results are public domain but there is no explicit statement saying this. ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Entered \""vēlēšanu rezultāti\"" in a search engine, followed the 1st result. Clicked on a submenu for the most recent parliamentary election, followed a link to a separate site with election results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The last part - getting to a data file - is the difficult part. Once you get to the election result site (https://sv2014.cvk.lv/index_rez.html) you have to figure that the dataset is hidden under a link saying \""XML\"".""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Centrālā vēlēšanu komisija (Central Election Commission)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Central Election Commission: https://www.cvk.lv/pub/public/28018.html""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.cvk.lv/pub/public/27093.html"",""descValue"":""Main landing page for election results""},{""urlValue"":""https://sv2014.cvk.lv/index_rez.html"",""descValue"":""12. Saeimas vēlēšanas (Parliamentary election 2014)""},{""urlValue"":""https://sv2014.cvk.lv/RezultsXml.gzip"",""descValue"":""Data file""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Election commission also has results for the European Parliament election 2014 but not in a machine-readable form: https://ep2014.cvk.lv/Part-7-Strukt-1.html""}]","Yes","Yes","Submission is valid. Data is available in XML format. Submitter states that getting to a data file is the difficult part. Once you get to the election result site you have to figure that the dataset is hidden under a link saying ""XML"".
","12th Saeima election (2014) is the most recent general election. The situation is the same as last year as there has not been an election since.","Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","80","80"
"d554bf9a-7965-4b9b-8373-a5bfd4efb08b","global","2017-03-16T07:49:00","2016","jm","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Electoral Commission of Jamaica"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission because not all required data is available. As submitter noted, results available (https://www.eoj.com.jm/content-183-179.htm / https://www.eoj.com.jm/content-183-181.htm) include registered votes, major results and invalid votes, no information for spoiled ballots.
All data available with the submitted characteristics and is downloadable, although in PDF files. HTML format is not available for all datasets, being more common on Parliamentary elections than in Parish Council Elections. The information available via HTML only accounts for a Summary of the election results (https://www.eoj.com.jm/content-70-290.htm) and it does not include all the required data characteristics. The document detailed the number of Rejected Ballots however they did not detail if they case was a spoiled ballot. Finding the information has a straightforward process.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"a30e1c72-090a-4a49-bd26-a12e276169c8","global","2016-12-08T20:18:11","2016","it","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""This is the first entry on google for the search \""opendata eleziioni\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.normattiva.it/uri-res/N2Ls?urn:nir:stato:legge:1941-04-22;633!vig="",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministero degli Interni"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://elezioni.interno.it/opendata.html"",""descValue"":""Open Data section of the all italian elections""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Submission in valid. Submitter makes a precision that information being stated as public domain is available specifically in Article 5 of the italian Copyright Law (linked in the submission).
",,"Yes","Yes","Maurizio Napolitano","Paola Mosso","100","100"
"2c9d1aac-7d66-4619-9e8c-7aa59fc63a01","global","2017-01-20T23:02:13","2016","gy","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF download format""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Upon searching in google for election results for Guyana i was easily directed to the Guyana Elections Commission (GECOM) website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Guyana Elections Commission (GECOM) was launched in December 2005 with the approval of the Commission""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I was unable to find a history of election results which would have been valuable to users of the data""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Guyana Elections Commission (GECOM) "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.gecom.org.gy/results2015.html"",""descValue"":""Guyana Elections Commission (GECOM) ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.guyana.org/Elections/elections_2015.html"",""descValue"":""Election 2015 OFFICIAL RESULTS ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Included in submission spoiled ballots and invalid votes, both of them are available by polling station for the last General Elections results (2015). Data is available in PDF format. Historical data available, in different formats, in https://www.gecom.org.gy/pastresults.html + https://www.guyana.org/Elections/past_results.html
",,"Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Paola Mosso","60","60"
"316a1332-2558-4f51-a559-dd034097fa63","global","2017-03-16T07:10:10","2016","ca","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Elections Canada"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.elections.ca/content.aspx?section=ele&lang=e&document=index"",""descValue"":""Elections Canada""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is valid. The licence has a non-commercial re-use clause (https://www.elections.ca/content.aspx?section=pri&lang=e&document=index). You can download the poll by poll results for each election but not all of the elections at once.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","80","80"
"f402c103-4bac-4005-a029-35ddf4edb588","global","2017-03-16T06:41:54","2016","cl","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""For historic results I went to the SERVEL site, then to the statistics section and then to the \""Resultados en Excel\"" option. But, for recent results (2016 municipal elections) I went to the \""Municipales 2016\"" site at SERVEL website, and then tu \""Resultados\"" which led me to another site: www.servelelecciones.cl "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.leychile.cl/Navegar?idNorma=276363"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Servicio Electoral de Chile (SERVEL)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.servel.cl/estadisticas-2/"",""descValue"":""Statistics section at the SERVEL website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.servelelecciones.cl/"",""descValue"":""Another SERVEL url with recent elections results""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Datasets are divided in two websites run by Servicio Electoral, the autonomous State institution that is responsible for the electoral administration in Chile. The first website is main organisational website, and it hosts the municipal, legislative and presidential elections data between 1989-2013. The data contained in this datasets includes all the required information, inclusive data available at polling state level, even though some of the data categories change through datasets, in XLSX format. The second website shows municipal data from the latest municipal elections (2016)
As for licenses, there is no mention in both of the websites, although by looking at the Government open data portal there are two mentions at licenses for some parts of the datasets. Even though there is no mention in these websites, access to Info law regards a public domain status to this data. Especifically Article 5 and 6 of the FOI law, which states: “Under the principle of transparency of public service, acts and Resolutions of the organs of the Administration of the State, its foundations, the documents that serve them Of direct or essential support and complement, and Procedures used for their Except for the exceptions established by this law and Those provided for in other qualified quorum laws”.
",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Paola Mosso","100","100"
"cc08d0d5-caef-4fbe-9a2e-22c957c47da4","global","2017-03-16T06:07:12","2016","at","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Umweltbundesamt - Environmental Agency Austria"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Austria has several water quality related databases and reports, however not all the parameters were apparent. Fecal Coliform and Total Dissolved Solids were not in the drinking water reports or database. That is why the answer to B2 is changed to No.
https://www.umweltbundesamt.at/umweltsituation/wasser/
Homepage Umweltbundesamt
https://www.bmlfuw.gv.at/wasser.html
Homepage Ministry for environment
https://www.trinkwasserinfo.at
Infoportal Trinkwasser
https://wasser.umweltbundesamt.at/h2odb/fivestep/abfrageQdPublic.xhtml
water quality database
https://www.trinkwasserinfo.at/trinkwasserdatenbank/
water quality database","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"425cddf2-62f2-42bd-a4bc-7e8f7babc5af","global","2017-03-16T05:54:33","2016","pe","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio del ambiente,"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","The data does not have all parameters, Total Dissolved Solids and Fluoride are missing. For this reason the answer to B2 was changed to No. You can find the other datasets here:
https://snirh.ana.gob.pe/consultassnirh/ConsVert2.aspx#","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"670b47ec-c7c5-48ac-aed5-968e31af8c3e","global","2017-03-16T05:43:40","2016","tr","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Forrest and Water"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","The reports do not have any of the parameters.","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"2ffb3d85-5b2e-4da5-9e85-a03a6420a2dd","global","2017-03-16T05:25:38","2016","pl","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Główny Inspektorat Sanitarny (Chief Sanitary Inspectorate)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","There are reports on water quality however several parameters are missing; Fecal Coliform and Total Dissolved Solids. For this reason the answer to B2 was changed to No.","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"18d09d08-fbf9-40fe-b682-a62959f6afdc","global","2017-03-16T05:20:59","2016","tz","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Water"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","The Ministry of water has a GIS portal of water points with some water quality data but doesn't have all the parameters; Fecal Coliform, Arsenic, Nitrates, and Total Dissolved Solids is missing. This is why the answer to B2 has been changed to No.
https://wpm.maji.go.tz/?x=c8i8ZGbnUrZ6LE-CcJ3abjZOkfVyik8d","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"fd71efae-7c5e-4404-acf0-be8a41a084ec","global","2017-03-16T05:11:28","2016","kh","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Water Resources and Meteorology"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Only a map of water quality monitoring sites was available. B2 was changed to a no because no data is being published. ","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"2d08a5a7-7668-4c60-9a37-a2032e1acd86","global","2017-03-16T05:09:12","2016","bg","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Executive Environment Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Data did not have all the parameters; Arsenic, Fluoride, and Total Dissolved Solids was not available, this is why the answer to B2 was changed to No.","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"1d8bec39-b0d7-41dc-a6d6-51272945fe30","global","2017-03-16T05:05:19","2016","ke","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Water and Irrigation, Kenya and National Environment Management Authority and OpenData.go.ke"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","The data on the Kenya Open Data portal did not cover the entire country and was not all government sources. Also not all the parameters specified were present in the data specifically Arsenic was missing. On researching the government sites there was no data available. ","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"124c0b29-1860-40ad-ba93-27d50273ce37","global","2017-03-16T04:36:53","2016","im","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Isle of Man Government Laboratory, Department of Environment, Food and Agriculture"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Isle of Man has good statistical reports of aggregated water quality from treatment plants. However the data does not contain all parameters it is missing Fecal Coliform and Total Dissolved Solids. Because of this B2 has been changed to a No.
chrome-extension://oemmndcbldboiebfnladdacbdfmadadm/https://www.manxutilities.im/media/1382/statistical-digest-final-15-16.pdf","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"68fd6a99-89e4-44c6-a3ba-e96824b0da10","global","2017-03-16T04:33:42","2016","be","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Regions: Vlaamse Milieumaatschappij, Leefmilieu Brussel, Environnement Wallonie"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Belgium is decentralized there is no central Ministry that is collecting and using water quality data for monitoring. They have a GIS portal for environmental mapping of sediments and some pollutants being used by businesses however not all the parameters are present. This is why B2 was changed to No.
https://geoloket.vmm.be/Geoviews/map.phtml","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"f6b889c4-d22a-4b72-a9a7-1e4c74faeb38","global","2017-03-16T04:21:38","2016","al","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministria e mjedisit"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","The Ministry does put up reports on the general state of water quality in the country the data is aggregated from the whole country. However not all parameters are in the reports and the actual data the analysis is based on is not provided. This is the reason B2 was changed to No.","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"fb829149-6bce-4b10-bdce-d913ef2887ac","global","2017-03-16T04:15:52","2016","cz","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Státní zdravotní ústav / National Institute of Public Health"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","The MInistry does have reports on water quality but the data at source is not there or the parameter detailed data. It is also missing total dissolved solids from the criteria. For this reason B2 is no. You can find the reports here:
https://www.szu.cz/tema/zivotni-prostredi/monitoring-pitne-vody?lang=1","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"59f8897c-dbb6-4ae8-bdfc-87ace9953121","global","2017-03-16T03:59:20","2016","ko","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ajgencioni per mbrojtjen e mjedisit te kosoves"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","The Ministry has reports on the state of the environment but no actual data tables for all the parameters. This does not meet the criteria of the survey.
https://www.ammk-rks.net/repository/docs/Raporti_i_ujrave_i_2015_shqip_(2).pdf","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"5023804c-fc32-4218-a881-416ba68f08a7","global","2017-03-16T03:55:46","2016","ba","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bosna i Hercegovina Agencija za statistiku"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","The statistics agency has aggregated reports of samples of water that exceed acceptable parameters but not the data from the breakdown of parameters.
https://www.bhas.ba/?option=com_content&view=article&id=226","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"ed218aec-27c1-4a26-8484-3f079c7efb7c","global","2017-03-16T03:51:27","2016","tt","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Environmental Management Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","There are state of the Environment reports but they are old and do not contain the actual data for the water quality.
https://www.ema.co.tt/new/index.php/publications/reports","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"042c873d-d425-439c-91a1-28d8f6256460","global","2017-03-16T03:41:31","2016","dk","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched for \""Water quality data\"" in Danish. The first and second results are the data for quality in the country."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""GEOLOGICAL SURVEY OF DENMARK AND GREENLAND"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Arsenic"",""Fluoride levels"",""Nitrates"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Data per water source"",""Available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.geus.dk/geusmap/?lang=en&mapname=rapportdb#zoom=5.482599709211326&lat=6225000&lon=661930&visiblelayers=Topographic&filter=&layers=&mapname=rapportdb&filter=&epsg=25832&mode=map&map_imagetype=png&wkt="",""descValue"":""GEUS interactive map""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.geus.dk/geusmap/?lang=en&mapname=grundvandzoom=6&lat=6225000.006&lon=661930.006&visiblelayers=Topographic&filter=&layers=mc_grp_analyse&mapname=grundvand&filter=&epsg=25832&mode=map&map_imagetype=png&oldfilter=arsenic&oldmapname=rapportdb&mc_grp_analyse_filter=stofgruppe.num%253D40&wkt="",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","30","30"
"190479cb-2921-4230-a54e-ea4da99f6bf6","global","2017-03-16T03:27:27","2016","mk","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Environment and Physical Planning"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","There are environmental reports that have charts and graphs referencing data but no actual datasets.
Ministry of Environment and Physical Planning
","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"9e0ed120-7b33-4e0c-917d-ecd27be4e0ca","global","2017-03-16T03:05:03","2016","th","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Pollution Control Department and Electronic Government Agency (Public Organization) (EGA)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","The Thai government does collect water quality data related to environmental pollution and make it open however the parameters we specify are not all included in the datasets. B2 is no for this reason you can find the data that is available below:
https://data.go.th/DatasetDetail.aspx?id=6e013d65-0643-477e-9640-f4a12e3007c9
Data Set of Pollution Control Department to place their government data on the www.data.go.th in an open format and data being free of charge.
https://iwis.pcd.go.th/index.php
Data Set of Pollution Control Department There are ten divisions as internal arrangement in the Pollution Control Department. - Office of the Secretary - Legal Division - Planning Analysis and Evaluation Division - Waste and Hazardous Substance Management Bureau - Water Quality Management Bureau - Air Quality Management Bureau - Environmental Quality and Laboratory Division - Inspection and Enforcement Division - Management System Development Group - Coordinating Center for Environmental Law Enforcement (CCEE)","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"72f86fe6-17ed-4937-a425-2293afd77f35","global","2017-02-20T19:16:06","2016","co","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""JSON"",""RDF"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Entrar a Sisaire y buscar en mediciones /calidad de aire"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.ideam.gov.co/web/atencion-y-participacion-ciudadana/condiciones-y-terminos-de-uso-de-la-informacion"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto de Hidrología, Meteorología y Estudios Ambientales-IDEAM"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.sisaire.gov.co:8080/faces/indiceIndicador/indiceNacionalDepartamentos.jsp"",""descValue"":""Sistema de Informacíon sobre Calidad del Aire: es la principal fuente de información para el diseño, evaluación y ajuste de las políticas y estrategias nacionales y regionales de prevención y control de la calidad del aire del país.""},{""urlValue"":""https://oab.ambientebogota.gov.co/es/indicadores?id=43&v=l"",""descValue"":""Datos e indicadores para medir la calidad del aire en Bogotá""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.cali.gov.co/dagma/"",""descValue"":""Datos e indicadores para medir la calidad del ambiente en Cali""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.metropol.gov.co/CalidadAire/Paginas/inicio.aspx"",""descValue"":""Datos e indicadores para medir la calidad del aire en Medellín""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.datos.gov.co/Ambiente-y-Desarrollo-Sostenible/INMISIONES-DATOS-DE-CONTAMINANTES-Y-CLIMATOL%C3%93GICOS/v3ny-6yj9"",""descValue"":""INMISIONES - DATOS DE CONTAMINANTES Y CLIMATOLÓGICOS 2016""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.datos.gov.co/Ambiente-y-Desarrollo-Sostenible/INMISIONES-DATOS-DE-CONTAMINANTES-Y-CLIMATOL%C3%93GICOS/3mty-ev99"",""descValue"":""INMISIONES - DATOS DE CONTAMINANTES Y CLIMATOLÓGICOS 2015""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.datos.gov.co/Ambiente-y-Desarrollo-Sostenible/INMISIONES-DATOS-DE-CONTAMINANTES-Y-CLIMATOL%C3%93GICOS/ie26-cpc9"",""descValue"":""INMISIONES - DATOS DE CONTAMINANTES Y CLIMATOLÓGICOS 2014""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted new data without corrections.",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","100","100"
"05526f60-bb0d-4000-aaff-9e1f7c87db00","global","2017-01-18T00:01:51","2016","nz","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""KML"",""SHP""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""As I know that these data exist, I searched google for \""emission mfe dataset\"" and then searched the portal for \""particulate emissions\""."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.mfe.govt.nz/license/attribution-3-0-new-zealand/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry for the Environment and Statistics New Zealand"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.mfe.govt.nz/layer/2666-gas-and-particulate-matter-emissions-20012013/"",""descValue"":""Ministry for the Environment Data warehouse""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections.",,"Yes","No","Gustavo Olivares","Ricardo Alanís","85","85"
"7b3924a7-037e-4b49-a1e3-364bb719d689","global","2016-12-17T14:36:40","2016","il","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data published separately per election. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched for \""election results\"" (Hebrew) in Google, and found the recent election results, and right next to it the link to the parliament website."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Central Election Comission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data published separately per election. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.votes20.gov.il/"",""descValue"":""Central Election Comission""},{""urlValue"":""https://main.knesset.gov.il/mk/elections/Pages/default.aspx"",""descValue"":""Kneseet (Israeli parliament) website""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Each national election commission published results on a separate website. The Knesset website includes links and general statistics on each election.""}]","Yes","Yes","Submission is valid. Invalid votes include votes stating something other than the list’s letter or shorthand, a vote in an envelope that has a mark that may identify the voter, an envelope containing more than two identical notes, an envelope that is not the envelope supplied by the committee and an envelope that is not signed by two member of the polling station. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","65","65"
"dfc8bd90-957b-4626-89f6-3a0c437114ec","global","2016-11-22T20:20:43","2016","br","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is public and regulated by the brazillian law of access to information (https://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/_ato2011-2014/2011/lei/l12527.htm), but there is no specific open license for electoral data.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""TXT""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There are plenty of different datasets, depending on what kind of data is needed. They are usually downloaded via ZIP file containing a text file per unit established in the dataset choice.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data for 2016 Mayoral Elections was available one day after the counting process took place.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I'm acquainted with this kind of data, since I’ve been working with them recently, so it was really easy to me. But if you search “Eleições resultados”, portuguese for “Election Results” in google, the first links are those from TSE.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1) I knew before that TSE was responsible for Election Results data, so I just went to TSE webpage (https://www.tse.jus.br/), 2) I searched the menu \""Elections\"" and then \""Elections Statistics\"", 3) I clicked the link for \""Election Data Repository\""."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.tse.jus.br/eleicoes/estatisticas/repositorio-de-dados-eleitorais"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The link is the same of the homepage of the Electoral Data Repository from TSE. The text shows its public use intention, but there is no specific license for it. The information is regulated by the brazilian Law of Access to Information, as shown above, and because of that, it is considered public. This link (https://dados.gov.br/dataset/resultado-das-eleicoes/resource/bfd28046-7236-4a4a-82ef-3e0fcd92771c) shows that there is no specific license.\nI'll use this space to ask: is it considered to be an international best practice to have specific data licenses for each dataset? I answered Yes in this question because data is public, even though there is no specific data use license.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Some effort is required, since data is provided encoded. But all files come with a read-me file containing the correspondence between codes and descriptions.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""TSE - Tribunal Superior Eleitoral"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is collected by the Brazilian Superior Electoral Court, the highest judiciary institution in Brazil for electoral issues.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""1) Both National and Mayoral Contests are available at the same platform. For example: 2016 we had Municipal Contests and 2014, National Contests. Both happen every 4 years.\n2) One of the datasets available is \""Detalhe da apuração por município e zona\"" (Counting detail per municipality and electoral ward), which shows the total number of registered votes per municipality and electoral ward.\n3) The number of invalid votes can be obtained in the same dataset above. This dataset also includes abstentions.\n4) In Brazil, the voting process takes place with electronic ballot boxes. So, it doesn't makes sense to have spoiled ballots data, but the number of invalid votes from subjury ballot boxes can be obtained through the same dataset above. Those are invalid votes until a electoral judge decides if they are actually valid or nullified. \n5) The \""Detalhe da apuração por seção eleitoral\"" (Counting detail per electoral section) dataset shows data per polling station (ballot box).""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.tse.jus.br/eleicoes/estatisticas/repositorio-de-dados-eleitorais"",""descValue"":""Main page for all brazilian election data (Repositório de dados eleitorais, which means Election Data Repository). The session \""results\"" in the left panel shows election results since 1945.""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Here there is the general link for the TSE webpage. There are no specific links to get the information required for the dataset, but they are accessible through navigation. First, you choose the year and then you select what kind of dataset you need.""}]","Yes","Yes","Voting process takes place with electronic ballot boxes. According to the legislation in place, invalid votes include: blank votes -those in which voters do not express preference for any of the running candidates- and void votes -spoiled votes that result from voters´ intention to spoil their vote by typing numbers that do not correspond to any candidate or political party when casting their vote in an electronic voting machine-. So submission is considered valid.
Both National and Mayoral Contests are available at the same platform. For example: 2016 we had Municipal Contests and 2014, National Contests. One of the datasets available is ""Detalhe da apuração por município e zona"" (Counting detail per municipality and electoral ward), which shows the total number of registered votes per municipality and electoral ward.
The ""Detalhe da apuração por seção eleitoral"" (Counting detail per electoral section) dataset shows data per polling station (ballot box).
As for navigation, if you search “Eleições resultados”, portuguese for “Election Results” in google, the first links are those from TSE.
Data is public and regulated by the brazillian law of access to information (https://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/_ato2011-2014/2011/lei/l12527.htm), but there is no specific open license for electoral data.
",,"Yes","Yes","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Paola Mosso","100","100"
"c7c9aefa-5c22-4eef-9d98-e2afe6c87670","global","2017-03-16T00:01:27","2016","gt","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Tribunal Supremo Electoral (TSE)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission since not all required data is available and it is stated at the top of the website that data contained in this report is provisional data (redirected from https://www.tse.org.gt/index.php/informacion-electoral/resultados-electorales). Data available for the last national elections (https://resultados2015.tse.org.gt/2v/resultados-2015/index.php) include results for major electoral contests, registered votes and invalid votes, but no information on spoiled ballots.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"4be57507-a5f2-4cf6-a79c-3d114e19c617","global","2016-12-24T09:45:43","2016","il","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""on the referral data.gov.il it is defined as a public domain, but on the official ministry website, it is copyrighted""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""JSON"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""NC file""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is update hourly""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""During check an announcement about possible difficulties in data providing, due to ending contract with service provider, appeared on site ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""searched for \""air quality' (Hebrew) both on google and data.gov.il. On the data.gov.il had to fix my my spelling from \""אויר\"" to \""אוויר\"" to find the the link."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.il/terms"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Environmental Protection"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.svivaaqm.net/Default.rtl.aspx"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Enviroment Protection website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.sviva.gov.il/subjectsEnv/SvivaAir/AirQualityData/NationalAirMonitoing/Pages/Developers.aspx"",""descValue"":""API to the data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I will refer to the daily forecast of air quality (data.gov.il). The actual measurements (ass appears on the official ministry website) is a calculated model.""}]","Yes","Yes","I added the right source of the data which is the Ministry API. While the government portal says it is open data, the ministry of Environment keeps it copyrighted. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","80","80"
"e87f9f42-be6c-4235-925a-d8be56f524b1","global","2017-03-15T22:06:45","2016","tt","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML, PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""After perusing the Ministry of Legal Affairs site I was connected to the Trinidad and Tobago Parliament Site. From there it was easy to find the tab about Bills/ Draft Legislation"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Parliament Republic of Trinidad and Tobago"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ttparliament.org/publications.php?mid=28"",""descValue"":""Bills Introduced during the 2nd Session of the 11th Republican Parliament""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I have modified the submission (by Alesha Aris, reviewed by Brenna Slawich) to represent the openness of the data. Bills are listed, with status, title and date introduced. When you click on the title, the proponent of the bill is show, along with any debate transcripts and a link to the content both available in PDF. As such, the data is not available in bulk.",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","45","45"
"620304fc-048a-4674-a465-67e2d9bb9a8f","global","2017-03-15T21:58:41","2016","tt","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""By doing a quick google search i was able to find the Ministry of legal affairs website and follow the directions to the laws"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of the Attorney General and Legal Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://laws.gov.tt/"",""descValue"":""DIGITAL LEGISLATIVE LIBRARY""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I have modified the original submission (by Alesha Aris, reviewed by Brenna Slawich) to represent the availability and openness of the data--the data is not available in an open format, nor is it available for bulk download. Laws are available here, https://laws.gov.tt/ from 1838 to 2014. Amendments are included alongside laws, and are linked depending on which view (not linked when browsing alphabetically/chronologically). The content is available for download in PDF format.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Alyssa Beaton","30","30"
"c9718b3c-760f-49fb-b19b-b907766abdd9","global","2017-03-15T21:46:32","2016","vc","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Financial Services Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I have modified the original submission to reflect the availability of the data. While a small selection of laws and amendments are available on the website for the Financial Services Authority, https://svgfsa.com/laws.html#Other, a more complete database of laws is not available. ",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","0","0"
"b7de76d9-40bc-4a0b-84c7-541b34903b97","global","2017-03-15T21:38:51","2016","vc","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Government of Saint-Vincent and the Grenadines"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I have modified the original submission (made by Alesha Aris and reviewed by Brenna Slawich) to reflect the openness of the data. While a small selection of draft legislation is available here, https://www.gov.vc/index.php/48-acts-and-bills/policies-acts-and-bills, only the title and content are available to view and download in PDF. ",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","0","0"
"00214871-46de-4f02-ba1e-b894cbbe373e","global","2017-03-15T21:08:39","2016","pk","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML, PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched on google"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Assembly of Pakistan"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.na.gov.pk/en/debates.php"",""descValue"":""Debates""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.na.gov.pk/en/bills.php?type=1"",""descValue"":""Gov't bills introduced""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.na.gov.pk/en/bills.php?type=2"",""descValue"":""Private members' bills introduced""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.na.gov.pk/en/bills.php?status=pass"",""descValue"":""Bills passed""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Pakistan's bills are available here: Govt' bills introduced, https://www.na.gov.pk/en/bills.php?type=1, and Private members' bills introduced, https://www.na.gov.pk/en/bills.php?type=2. The title and date are available in HTML, while the content and author are available to view and download in PDF format. I have modified the original submission (by Nouman Nazim, and reviewed by Brenna Slawich) to account for the availability of this data, and to correct the openness of the data. A selection of debates are included here, https://www.na.gov.pk/en/debates.php, available in PDF format. Bills that have been passed are listed here, https://www.na.gov.pk/en/bills.php?status=pass.",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","45","45"
"ee406eca-068a-4678-a4a6-a5fb825d3551","global","2017-03-15T20:54:08","2016","pk","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML, PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched on Google"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Assembly of Pakistan, Punjab Government"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.na.gov.pk/en/acts-tenure.php"",""descValue"":""Acts of Parliament - National Assembly of Pakistan""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.punjablaws.gov.pk/"",""descValue"":""Punjab Laws""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Pakistan's laws are available for consultation from two sources: the National Assembly, https://www.na.gov.pk/en/acts-tenure.php, and the Punjab law database, https://www.punjablaws.gov.pk/index2.html. The title and date of amendment are available to view in HTML, while the content of the law is available to view and download in PDF format. This submission/review was modified to reflect that the data is not available for bulk download, and to include the data from the National Assembly .",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","45","45"
"c4519e96-02ed-4c26-9e1f-6233c000270e","global","2017-03-15T19:58:04","2016","om","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Ministry of Legal Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Per the original submitter (Riyadh Al-Balushi) and reviewer (Michael Beatty), ""the Ministry of Legal Affairs is responsible for publishing laws in Oman. Laws are published on weekly basis in the Official Gazette, which is uploaded to the website as a PDF document. The individual laws, in addition to primary and secondary legal instruments, are uploaded to the website as separate PDFs, too. There is no option on the website to view the laws in pure text format and there is no option on the website to download all the laws in bulk."" The titles of Oman laws are available view in HTML, while the content of the law is available to download in PDF format. Amendments (and dates of) are not listed, therefore I have modified the submission accordingly to reflect the availability of the data. The data is available here: https://www.mola.gov.om/mainlaws.aspx.",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","0","0"
"e5540a6d-335c-4f57-a43c-6e11156f528d","global","2017-03-15T19:39:04","2016","na","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML, PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Navigating the Parliament's website, \""Bills\"" are listed under \""Legislation\"" on the main page"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Parliament of Namibia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.parliament.na/index.php?option=com_phocadownload&view=category&id=1&Itemid=1265"",""descValue"":""Bills - Parliament of Namibia""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The bills are available for consultation here: https://www.parliament.na/index.php?option=com_phocadownload&view=category&id=1&Itemid=1265. The bills are up-to-date, including the title, bill number and authoring ministry of the bill, available to view in HTML. The content of the bill is available for download in PDF. The status of bills for 2017-2018 are contained within the PDF document titled ""BILLS THAT MAY BE TABLED IN THE NATIONAL ASSEMBLY 2017-2018,"" that is available for download within the list of 2017 bills. For these reasons, I have modified the original submission/review to demonstrate the availability of the data. ",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","45","45"
"f0f5454b-6234-4791-92da-c0cdebb589f3","global","2017-03-15T19:30:29","2016","na","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML, PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""It took about 5 minutes of google searching to find these sources."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Republic of Namibia Parliament"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.parliament.na/index.php?option=com_phocadownload&view=category&id=43&Itemid=1497"",""descValue"":""Acts of Parliament""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Laws are available on the Parliament's website, where the title, date of assent and date of publication (in the Gazette) are listed in HTML, while the content of the law is available for download in PDF format. Amendments are listed alongside laws, with reference in text to the laws they are amending, but without direct links. The website is not up-to-date at this time, the data is not openly licensed, nor is it available to be downloaded in bulk. For these reasons, I have modified the original submission/review to reflect the availability of the data. ",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","30","30"
"5690af63-f5ab-4b97-b56f-278f5874b928","global","2017-03-15T19:17:33","2016","my","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Attorney’s General Chambers of Malaysia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission/review directed the user to this database: https://www.agc.gov.my/agcportal/index.php?r=portal2/lom&menu_id=VXlsMDlEclhJVXlGcUd6c0JreVhEUT09. The database lists the title of laws, with the year of publication/revision. The content of the law is available to view and download in PDF, however I was unable to locate amendments to laws. For this reason, I have modified the submission to reflect the availability of the data.",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","0","0"
"fe88ab88-f6a6-4cfd-b42c-466df7be025d","global","2017-03-15T19:09:14","2016","my","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Parliament of Malaysia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission/review included this link: https://www.parlimen.gov.my/bills-dewan-rakyat.html?uweb=dr&searchref=bills-dewan-rakyat&str=&doctype%5B%5D=DR-bill&dokumen%5B%5D=ruu&searchref=bills-dewan-rakyat&searchrefcode=dr&str=&str2=&DATETYPE=0&DATERANGE%5B%5D=&DATERANGE%5B%5D=&takwimnum%5B%5D=13%7C1%7C1&takwimnum%5B%5D=1%7C5%7C2, where the title and status of bills are available to view, with a link to download the content of the bill in PDF format. Only the status and content are available, while the author, transcripts and votes are not posted. As such, I have modified the submission/review to reflect the availability of the data.
",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","0","0"
"54237222-4b7a-4630-89a3-1972668a2c7c","global","2017-02-03T15:31:56","2016","ua","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Data is collected city by city. There is no centralized data set for the whole country. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted and confirmed.",,"Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"fc553351-063e-49c3-9081-212393ca556d","global","2017-03-15T18:47:20","2016","mw","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I google searched for national laws, constitution, legalisation in Malawi."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Malawi Legal Information Institute"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.malawilii.org/"",""descValue"":""Malawi Legal Information Institute""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","While laws are listed on the Malawi Legal Information Institute, up to 2017 (https://www.malawilii.org/consol_leglist/legislation_promulgated/numbered-acts), I was unable to locate amendments, and dates of amendments. For this reason, not all data characteristics are available and the submission has been modified accordingly. ",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","0","0"
"10b2079a-f2b3-4bd3-9260-7fd235972a01","global","2017-01-27T15:02:04","2016","tn","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Agency Tunisian Air Quality Monitoring Network"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections. Confirmed data is not, at least easily, available.","Could not find a website for Agency Tunisian Air Quality Monitoring Network. In the Environment ministry there is no trace for the dataset. Also not on the open data portal. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"90581303-27e4-4a4b-b506-3c972540a23f","global","2017-03-15T18:41:47","2016","mw","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""I was unable to assess if the information is collected at the Malawi government websites, such as the Parliament and Judiciary, are down."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission/review has been modified to reflect that draft legislation data is not available for Malawi. The Parliament and Judiciary websites are down, and the website for Malawi Legal Information Institute (included in the original submission https://www.malawilii.org/content/databases) does not have this information available, only laws.","The original submission/review has been modified to reflect that draft legislation data is not available for Malawi. The Parliament and Judiciary websites are down, and the website for Malawi Legal Information Institute (included in the original submission) does not have this information available, only laws.","Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","0","0"
"48986289-e08d-4156-8454-f19fb875109d","global","2017-03-15T18:26:59","2016","ls","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled national laws Lesotho and found this on the first page of search results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Lesotho Legal Information Institute"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.lesotholii.org/"",""descValue"":""Lesotho Legal Information Institute""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I have modified the original submission/review to reflect that not all data characteristics are available, nor is the data available up to date. A selection of laws are available here: https://www.lesotholii.org/indexpage/num_act, however, as stated on the site: ""This information is: not necessarily comprehensive, complete, accurate or up to date; sometimes linked to external sites over which LesLII has no control and for which LesLII assumes no responsibility."" The parliament's website (https://www.parliament.ls/assembly/index.php?option=com_docman&Itemid=89) contains links for laws, bills and more, however there is no documentation available. For these reasons, I have modified the submission to reflect that the data is not available.",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","15","15"
"1af95f5d-677d-42ab-a8af-772569c5779c","global","2017-01-31T18:24:22","2016","it","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data only until 2012""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched for air quality data in search engine and found the data and metadata site."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Istituto superiore per la protezione e la ricerca ambientale"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.brace.sinanet.apat.it/web/struttura.html?p_livello_1=3&p_main=web/sh_dg.inizio&p_scroll=yes"",""descValue"":""Sito della rete del Sistema Informativo Nazionale Ambientale""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections.","No license found. You can only access data until 2012","Yes","No","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","50","50"
"c839272a-85dc-4b72-ba8a-f34f7d7f1b05","global","2016-12-31T21:01:22","2016","ir","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""PDF, XLS by request""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""some of the data are available, some of them need request.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled pollutant emission in Persian and easily found them"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Environment and some Municipalities."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.doe.ir/Portal/home/?232142/%DA%AF%D8%B2%D8%A7%D8%B1%D8%B4%20%D8%B1%D9%88%D8%B2%D8%A7%D9%86%D9%87%20%D9%85%D8%B1%DA%A9%D8%B2%20%DA%A9%D9%86%D8%AA%D8%B1%D9%84%20%D9%88%20%D9%BE%D8%A7%DB%8C%D8%B4"",""descValue"":""daily report by Department of Environment""},{""urlValue"":""https://air.tehran.ir/%DA%A9%DB%8C%D9%81%DB%8C%D8%AA-%D9%87%D9%88%D8%A7/%D8%B4%D8%A7%D8%AE%D8%B5-%DA%A9%DB%8C%D9%81%DB%8C%D8%AA-%D9%87%D9%88%D8%A7"",""descValue"":""Tehran Municipality (as an example of municipality)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted: Added xlsx as a format in which data is available.",,"Yes","No","MohammadHossein Khani","Ricardo Alanís","65","65"
"035da5d1-2207-461f-9256-c246a51a90ed","global","2017-03-15T18:18:16","2016","ch","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal Office for the Environment"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","There is no water quality data available for download. There are a few portals and reports but the actual data isn't there and not all the parameters are represented.
https://www.bafu.admin.ch/bafu/en/home/topics/water/info-specialists/state-of-waterbodies/state-of-groundwater/naqua-national-groundwater-monitoring/trend-and-spez-modules.html
https://map.geo.admin.ch/?lang=en&topic=bafu&X=190000.00&Y=660000.00&zoom=1&bgLayer=ch.swisstopo.pixelkarte-farbe&layers=ch.bafu.hydroweb-messstationen_grundwasser,ch.bafu.gewaesserschutz-chemischer_zustand_nitrat,ch.bafu.gewaesserschutz-chemischer_zustand_nitrit,ch.bafu.naqua-grundwasser_nitrat&layers_timestamp=,,,&layers_opacity=1,1,1,0.75&catalogNodes=2771,2772,2780,2822,2827,2832,2805,2828,2833","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"c06f8ddb-f3ff-4461-88da-40727c3a6b12","global","2017-03-15T18:05:23","2016","ke","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML, PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Nothing came up when I typed \""legislation\"" into https://www.opendata.go.ke/ so I typed \""Kenya draft legislation 2016\"" into google. 4th result"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Parliament of Kenya"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.parliament.go.ke/the-national-assembly/house-business/bills"",""descValue"":""Parliament of Kenya""},{""urlValue"":""https://kenyalaw.org/kl/index.php?id=5991"",""descValue"":""Bill - Kenya Law (semi-autonomous state body)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.parliament.go.ke/the-national-assembly/house-business/hansard"",""descValue"":""Parliament of Kenya - transcripts of debates""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.parliament.go.ke/the-national-assembly/house-business/votes-and-proceedings"",""descValue"":""Parliament of Kenya - votes and proceedings""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.parliament.go.ke/the-national-assembly/house-business/bills-tracker"",""descValue"":""Parliament of Kenya - bills tracker""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission/review has been modified to reflect the openness of the data: the Parliament's information is not openly licensed, and the information is not available in an open format. I have added additional links to point to the availability of votes and transcripts. Navigating the Parliament's website, the listed dates for bills appear to be a few years out of date, however when considering the Bill Tracker PDF document that is updated on a weekly/bi-weekly basis, provides up-to-date information regarding the reading dates, bill sponsors and status. The content of the bill is available for download in PDF format. Votes and proceedings are available for PDF download here: https://www.parliament.go.ke/the-national-assembly/house-business/votes-and-proceedings, while transcripts of debates are available here: https://www.parliament.go.ke/the-national-assembly/house-business/hansard.",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","45","45"
"d9245ee7-109b-46e9-a2d2-dec1dd858b4c","global","2016-12-16T10:31:09","2016","id","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""It's differed per year.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Go to One Data Portal and search for \""water quality\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.opendefinition.org/licenses/cc-by"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Environment and Forestry Indonesia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.go.id/dataset/data-indeks-kualitas-lingkungan-hidup"",""descValue"":""Open Data Portal managed by Presidential Staff Office""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections: Data available but outdated.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","85","85"
"2ce97886-3d87-4b1d-852a-b6ef9b6da21c","global","2017-03-15T17:47:16","2016","ke","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML, PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search for Laws of Kenya, Kenya Law website is listed first"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The National Council for Law Reporting"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.kenyalaw.org"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission/review were modified to accurately represent the openness of the data, the data is not available in an open format, only HTML and PDF, and the data is not openly licensed. Kenyan laws are searchable using this database: https://www.kenyalaw.org/lex//index.xql. Laws, amendments and all relevant dates are listed therein in HTML, with links to documents available for download in PDF.",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","45","45"
"8b7e0112-6449-4f9b-b6e6-34f922d56a78","global","2017-03-15T17:49:14","2016","ke","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Submission is rejected since not all required data is available. Results available include results for major electoral contests, registered votes and invalid votes, which are referred as “rejected ballots”. Also, name of vote category changes between webpage stating the data in HTML (https://www.iebc.or.ke/election/?election-results) and a document elaborated by the same organisation (https://www.iebc.or.ke/docs/4TH%20MARCH%202013%20GENERAL%20ELECTION%20DATA.pdf). This category of votes is stated as Spoilt votes in the first one, and as Rejected votes on the second one. Both documents differ also on the final count number.
Submitter stated that data publishes on the especial results website by the Comission (https://vote.iebc.or.ke/) was not timely published, since the 2013 election was on 4 March 2013, data was added by IEBC on the 9 March 2013. The site also states that all data published is provisional.
You need to register to get access to the API.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"4acbec77-56d4-4783-a395-8cdedbce47f9","global","2017-03-15T17:48:25","2016","il","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Water Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","The National Water Authority has the monitoring role even though the treatment is decentralized to individual municipalities. The original submission went through all the regional websites to find data because it was not aggregated to the central monitoring authority. For this reason the submission was rejected. The data has to be with the central authority by source covering the entire country. ","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"47414f51-2008-4355-945c-40fc8bcc794f","global","2017-03-15T17:30:33","2016","za","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Republic of South Africa National Department of Water and Sanitation "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","THey do have a water quality and information portal
https://niwis.dws.gov.za/niwis2/rwqo
However this portal doesn't have the parameters the survey has specified and can't find reports or other documentation with the parameters required. ","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"406dcc29-318d-4dd1-aab0-a6a8a68eedfc","global","2017-03-15T17:21:59","2016","gr","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML, PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""google search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Hellenic Parliament"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.hellenicparliament.gr/en/Nomothetiko-Ergo/Anazitisi-Nomothetikou-Ergou"",""descValue"":""Search for Laws""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission/review have been modified to reflect the availability of laws, searchable through the Hellenic Parliament portal: https://www.hellenicparliament.gr/en/Nomothetiko-Ergo/Anazitisi-Nomothetikou-Ergou?type=0_0_1_0_0. The title, Ministry and supporting committee, all relevant dates and author are listed in HTML, while the content of the law, the original law (in the event of an amendment), and all other amendments are listed, with links to PDF documents for viewing or download. ",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","45","45"
"e7daa52b-8de4-4284-9514-762633562672","global","2017-03-15T17:16:22","2016","gr","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML, PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""google search with the related term"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Greek Parliament - ΒΟΥΛΗ ΤΩΝ ΕΛΛΗΝΩΝ"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.hellenicparliament.gr/Nomothetiko-Ergo/Anazitisi-Nomothetikou-Ergou"",""descValue"":""search for available draft legislations""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The data is available at the following link: https://www.hellenicparliament.gr/Nomothetiko-Ergo/Anazitisi-Nomothetikou-Ergou?lawPhase=d19eafe2-7f8b-4cec-95c5-a4c50073763b&type=0_1_0_0_0. Bills are searchable. The title, status and date are available in HTML, while content and bill proponents are available for view/download in PDF. The original submission/review was modified to reflect that the information is not available in an open format, nor is it available for bulk download. ",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","45","45"
"8f9c360a-5d19-471a-b9c1-7bf25bb7a081","global","2017-03-15T17:14:01","2016","tn","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""The websites of the Ministry of Health does not specify water monitoring and the drinking water provider's site is not loading. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"6810c25b-1cf8-4f71-96d8-ec15217ddcf8","global","2017-03-15T17:05:28","2016","tt","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Election and Boundaries Commission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Submission is rejected since not all required data is available. Results available include results for major electoral contests, registered votes and invalid votes, which are referred as “rejected ballots”. On the other hand, file format is not consistent, it varies through elections, although the latest Parliamentary Elections results are available in XLS format.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"4df61b9f-7356-4f8b-9934-7095deef3639","global","2017-03-15T17:05:32","2016","ro","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Health, Ministry of Environment"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","First submission had said there was data but there was no data on the sites they listed. After research there is no reports or datasets with the parameters specified.","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"3c176caf-ed4f-468b-8703-c70154315c5e","global","2017-03-15T16:52:47","2016","mx","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Commission of Water (SINA)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Original Submission didn't have all the parameters had to reject because the parameters are not available and there is no dataset. ","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"ceddb9f0-b996-434f-a12f-663e75cf441d","global","2016-12-15T10:51:34","2016","my","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Environment"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","Hazwany Jamaluddin","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"6e08f256-33e2-4841-99dc-0a9ad5fadd9f","global","2016-12-13T15:16:05","2016","np","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No any illustrative content available so far.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Internet Research, Visit to the Department of Water Supply and Sewerage"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Water Supply and Sewerage (DWSS)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.dwss.gov.np/"",""descValue"":""Government of Nepal, Department of Water Supply and Sewerage (DWSS)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","Manish Marahatta","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"2e5c0288-1f7a-4471-8750-b4f41740092b","global","2017-03-15T16:22:32","2016","dk","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML, PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""The original submitter was aware of the portal link "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Civilstyrelsen"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.retsinformation.dk"",""descValue"":""Government document portal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Danish laws are available to view by searching this portal: https://www.retsinformation.dk/. When you click on an act/law or amendment, the whole text is displayed in HTML, with additional documents (bills, ombudsman reports) and, if applicable, the original law, are linked in PDF/HTML depending. The signing and imposition dates are equally listed for all. ",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","45","45"
"cc7271d9-78fe-4554-8114-3f4af1b90f79","global","2017-03-15T15:59:59","2016","bt","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.nab.gov.bt/en/page/terms-of-use/""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""web search for acts, laws for Bhutan"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Assembly of Bhutan, Office of Attorney General of Bhutan, Royal Court of Justice"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.nab.gov.bt/en/business/acts"",""descValue"":""National Assembly of Bhutan - Acts""},{""urlValue"":""https://oag.gov.bt/resources/acts/"",""descValue"":""Office of the Attorney General - Acts""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.judiciary.gov.bt/index.php/Welcome/get_pages?id=4"",""descValue"":""Judiciary of Bhutan - Acts and Rules""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The laws for Bhutan are listed on the websites for National Assembly of Bhutan, Office of Attorney General of Bhutan, and Royal Court of Justice. The laws are listed in alphabetical order. While amendments are listed, they do not seem to be linked accordingly. The year of law/amendment is listed, but the exact date is not readily apparent. The title is available to view in HTML, while the content of the law is available to download in PDF. The data is not openly licensed, as indicated on the website, ""the information available on this Site including the media resources, are protected by copyright, trademark and other forms of proprietary rights. All rights, title and interest in the Contents are owned by, licensed to or controlled by Parliament of Bhutan only.""",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","30","30"
"593f9f04-9bf0-42ce-a6c9-d8f45095cbb5","global","2017-03-15T15:48:50","2016","be","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""In accordance with Article 8 § 2 of the Act of June 30, 1994 on copyright and related rights, copyrights do not apply to official government documents. Parliamentary documents, which are in accordance with Belgian law, official documents may be so freely copied. It is recommended to indicate the site of the Chamber in order to inform the user as possible.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML, PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Go to the website dekamer.be"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.dekamer.be/kvvcr/showpage.cfm?section=/searchlist&language=nl&html=/site/wwwroot/searchlist/faqN.html#item0-parldoccopy"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""De Kamer (Parliament)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.dekamer.be/kvvcr/showpage.cfm?section=/flwb&language=nl&cfm=ListDocument.cfm"",""descValue"":""Documents - The Belgian Chamber of Representatives""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Upon reviewing the review, I found a more accurate link to draft bills and proposals here: https://www.dekamer.be/kvvcr/showpage.cfm?section=/flwb&language=nl&cfm=ListDocument.cfm. I found this page by navigating to the Parliament's website, under ""documents,"" and clicked on ""Full overview"" of Parliamentary documents of the chamber. The title, author and status are available in HTML, while content is available to view and download in PDF. As stated on the website: ""In accordance with Article 8 § 2 of the Act of June 30, 1994 on copyright and related rights, copyrights do not apply to official government documents. Parliamentary documents, which are in accordance with Belgian law, official documents may be so freely copied. It is recommended to indicate the site of the Chamber in order to inform the user as possible.""",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","65","65"
"106e6e2e-0b93-4ecd-8f7e-06d082e27f2f","global","2017-03-15T15:34:24","2016","uy","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Vivienda, Ordenamiento Territorial y Medio Ambiente"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","There are reports and data but not for all the parameters for this reason had to reject the first submission.
https://mvotma.gub.uy/estado-del-ambiente.html","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"537e076f-925e-4d9c-ad80-7e13448f955c","global","2017-03-15T15:14:41","2016","af","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Website of Ministry of Justice, Laws Tab"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Justice"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://moj.gov.af/Content/files/index.htm"",""descValue"":""Laws""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submitter provided the following link: https://moj.gov.af/Content/files/index.htm, where the titles of Afghan laws are available for view in HTML and download in PDF format. The site was last updated in 2006. Amendments to laws are listed, along with the publication date and status, however they are not linked accordingly.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Alyssa Beaton","30","30"
"fdf46d10-e451-4c03-9f5f-6ef989830b8f","global","2017-03-15T14:57:59","2016","au","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The laws are available for download as PDF., Doc., and Zip. files. After some feedback by tobybellwood on the forum, it was determined that html is also an available format.\n\nhttps://discuss.okfn.org/t/entry-for-national-laws-australia/4800/3""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This URL leads to the part of the website where reference to Creative Commons License is made. https://www.legislation.gov.au/Content/Disclaimer#downlo""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Office of Parliamentary Counsel"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""All required characteristics can be easily found.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.legislation.gov.au/"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The original submission had listed the following URL as a source: www.commlaw.gov.au ok However, the listed URL is more up to date.""}]","Yes","Yes","This updated review includes a new comment regarding the format of the data. The original submission was accepted because the data contains all the required characteristics. ","I changed the URL in B2 to one that is more up do date. All other sections are unchanged
This updated review includes a comment that data is available in html (following tobybellwood's feedback on the forum). ","Yes","No","anonymous","Juela Xhaferraj","80","80"
"6f8da5c9-d40a-4003-942a-8cc082da72e2","global","2017-02-03T15:40:25","2016","ua","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of the Environment"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""A list of different monitoring exists. They explain that water bodies are monitored but no real data is shown"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","https://www.menr.gov.ua/index.php/monitoring","Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"05916395-ffea-4db0-b539-7788e4f50bf9","global","2017-03-15T12:25:34","2016","ve","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Environment and Natural Resources, Ministerio del Poder Popular para Ecosocialismo y Aguas"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Data was not available on any of the Ministries sites though they are responsible for monitoring the resource. Changed the answer to B2 to no.","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"fb24513f-3801-467b-a4d5-ab0a78b08aae","global","2017-01-27T18:52:21","2016","cm","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No indication. Update: website 'Copyright © 2010 Institut National de la Statistique du Cameroun'""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Largely outdated info on GDP, the news page of the National Statistics Office shows a GDP value from 2014""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I had to use special queries \""site:https://www.stat.cm [query] to understand where the data is"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Institut National de la Statistique du Cameroun"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://slmp-550-104.slc.westdc.net/~stat54/nada/index.php/auth/login/?destination=catalog/89/get_microdata"",""descValue"":""National statistics office, Microdata for census""},{""urlValue"":""https://slmp-550-104.slc.westdc.net/~stat54/nada/index.php/catalog/89"",""descValue"":""National statistics office, General census data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.stat.cm/downloads/2016/CNT_T4_2015_final.pdf"",""descValue"":""For GDP (PDF, and from 2014)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Danny Lämmerhirt for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. ",,"Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Sophie Lafayette","30","30"
"2e6757ac-8ca4-42fe-aa0a-b5eea0b9aafe","global","2017-03-14T23:34:47","2016","dk","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""DBF"",""PX"",""TXT"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Also SAS, TSD, ASB""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Population quarterly, latest Q1 2017; unemployment monthly, latest Jan 2017; GDP quarterly, latest Q4 2016""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Within StatBank, data can be found by subject area, variables selected, and then data downloaded"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.dst.dk/en/omds/omweb"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""'You are free to re-use and reproduce contents from dst.dk and statbank.dk. This includes even commercial use. You should, however, always include a source accreditation to Statistics Denmark.'""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Specific variables can be selected when creating table and data downloaded in multiple formats. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Danmarks Statistik/Statistics Denmark"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.dst.dk/en"",""descValue"":""Statistics Denmark main site (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dst.dk/da"",""descValue"":""Danmarks Statistik (Danish)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statbank.dk"",""descValue"":""StatBank""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Approval of re-submission following rejection of initial entry. ","Re-submission following rejection of initial entry. The submission was rejected as it was about the city of Copenhagen not the country of Denmark.","Yes","Yes","Sophie Lafayette","Sophie Lafayette","100","100"
"539d62c1-05a9-44ed-9b79-2bd7e4030b7f","global","2016-12-19T16:16:31","2016","do","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Los datos económicos se encuentran en la Página de Inicio del BCRD, por lo cual fue fácil encontrarlos. En cuanto a los datos demográficos, procedí a buscar en google y este me envió a la página web de la Oficina Nacional de Estadística (ONE). "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.one.gob.do/Portada/terminosDeUso"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended terms to ONE (from submitted https://www.bancentral.gov.do/terminos/) as this is main stats site. ""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Oficina Nacional de Estadística (ONE)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended agency title from Banco Central de la República Dominicana to Oficina Nacional de Estadística (ONE) as this is the main statistics office. ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.bancentral.gov.do/"",""descValue"":""Portal Web del Banco Central de la República Dominicana. Indicadores sobre Producto Interno Bruto. ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bancentral.gov.do/estadisticas_economicas/mercado_trabajo/encft/"",""descValue"":""Portal Web del Banco Central de la República Dominicana. Datos sobre Fuerza de Trabajo en RD. ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.one.gob.do/"",""descValue"":""Oficina Nacional de Estadística (ONE)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.one.gob.do/Estadisticas/173/poblacion-estimada-y-proyectada"",""descValue"":""Estadísticas demográficas Oficina Nacional de Estadística (ONE)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""El Banco Central ofrece en su página web información sobre los indicadores económicos. Los datos demográficos se ofrecen en la página de la Oficina Nacional de Estadística (ONE). ""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Miguel Reyes Taveras for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. ",,"Yes","Yes","Miguel Reyes Taveras","Sophie Lafayette","100","100"
"24985019-7db6-4d0b-aa96-1c4ebf33692b","global","2016-12-03T16:31:59","2016","gt","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Although the data is downloadable free of charge, the webpage states Copyright and Reserved Rights.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""You click on the option and download a XLS document""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Estimates are up to date, but data from census is not due to the fact that there's no census since 2002. Update: population yearly, latest 2015; GDP quarterly, latest Q3 2016.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Go to the INE webpage, click on the \""Statistics\"" section at the main menu. Click on the different options on the site to go to actual data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Nacional de Estadistica (INE)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.gob.gt/"",""descValue"":""INE webpage""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.gob.gt/index.php/estadisticas"",""descValue"":""Statistics section of the INE""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.banguat.gob.gt/inc/main.asp?id=84369&aud=1&lang=1"",""descValue"":""Gross Domestic Product is collected by the national bank (Banco de Guatemala) instead of the INE.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Daniel Villatoro for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. ",,"Yes","No","Daniel Villatoro","Sophie Lafayette","65","65"
"6fae056c-5c5e-4a14-ab1b-3a2de775cf7c","global","2016-12-18T19:47:45","2016","il","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: added XML format""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Each of the mentioned datasets is is available in a separate file.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: population yearly, latest 2015; GDP monthly, latest Jan 2017; unemployment monthly, latest Jan 2017""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search for \""Statistics Israel\"" in google, and navigate within the site of the Central Bureau of Statistics website. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.cbs.gov.il/www/usage.pdf"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Central Bureau of Statistics (LAMAS)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.cbs.gov.il/reader/shnatonhnew_site.htm"",""descValue"":""Statistical Abstract of Israel 2015 in the Central Bureau of Statistics website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.cbs.gov.il/reader/?MIval=cw_usr_view_SHTML&ID=314"",""descValue"":""Economic Characteristics in the Central Bureau of Statistics website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.cbs.gov.il/reader/?MIval=cw_usr_view_SHTML&ID=710"",""descValue"":""GDP in the Central Bureau of Statistics website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.cbs.gov.il"",""descValue"":""Central Bureau of Statistics (LAMAS) main website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.cbs.gov.il/reader/?MIval=cw_usr_view_SHTML&ID=417"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added link to unemployment data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Added XLM format. ",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Sophie Lafayette","100","100"
"ec6386ed-7f73-4fc8-b47f-19db088eca40","global","2016-12-08T20:42:57","2016","it","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: added formats XML, PC-Axis""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: GDP quarterly, latest Q4 2016; population yearly, latest 2016; unemployment quarterly, latest Q4 2016""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: Select data from I.Stat database menu""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.istat.it/it/note-legali"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""CC-by""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""ISTAT - Istituto nazionale di statistica "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://dati.istat.it"",""descValue"":""I.Stat database""},{""urlValue"":""https://datiopen.istat.it/"",""descValue"":""LOD ISTAT""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.istat.it/en/"",""descValue"":""IStat main site (English)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Maurizio Napolitano for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Database easy to navigate, find, and download relevant data for up to date time ranges. Added XLM format. ",,"Yes","Yes","Maurizio Napolitano","Sophie Lafayette","100","100"
"040fb57d-facc-43ff-a603-9966ae0154b6","global","2017-01-18T20:20:34","2016","bw","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: see https://www.statsbots.org.bw/terms-use - copyright to Statistics Botswana but allows users to make use of data. ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF, SVG, JPEG, PNG""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to no, data is split across different PDF documents ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to no - population latest 2011, predictions until 2026; unemployment latest 2011; GDP quarterly latest Q3 2016""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I google searched national statistics Namibia and found this source on the first page of search results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended from 2 to 1 as data in PDFs only so requires extraction before use. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Statistics Botswana"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.statsbots.org.bw/"",""descValue"":""Statistics Botswana""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statsbots.org.bw/demography"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statsbots.org.bw/labour"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statsbots.org.bw/publication-by-sector/national-accounts"",""descValue"":""GDP reports (Q3 2016 latest)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statsbots.org.bw/sites/default/files/publications/population_projection.pdf"",""descValue"":""Population predictions until 2026""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added links to population, GDP, and unemployment data.""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Tricia Govindasamy for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. B9 amended from 2 to 1 as data split across multiple PDFS (B5 amended to no) and limited formats. Data is not up to date (B6 amended to no). ",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Sophie Lafayette","30","30"
"d563317e-30e5-42cc-a9a2-07125894d2dc","global","2016-12-15T05:47:02","2016","my","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There were no clear statement/message stated in the dataset nor in the webpage whether the data is openly licensed. It is assumed by the public that the data is owned by the author and the publisher. Update: some data listed in 'open data' section but no details regarding license. ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to no as GDP data is in multiple files/pages""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The latest update found was until 2015 and that data is based on preliminary analysis. Update: latest population 2015; GDP quarterly, latest Q4 2016; unemployment monthly Dec 2016.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I did in-depth search in the website and found sub category for \""Open Data\"" in a drop down menu of \""Statistics\""."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended from 3 to 1 as limited file formats exist, latest statistics have to be taken from updates on website""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Statistics Malaysia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added GDP ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.dosm.gov.my/v1/"",""descValue"":""Department of Statistics Malaysia""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statistics.gov.my/index.php?r=column3/accordion&menu_id=aHhRYUpWS3B4VXlYaVBOeUF0WFpWUT09"",""descValue"":""Department of Statistics Malaysia open data statistics""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.data.gov.my/data/ms_MY/dataset/population-and-demographic-statistics-malaysia"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dosm.gov.my/v1/index.php?r=column/ctwoByCat&parent_id=99&menu_id=TE5CRUZCblh4ZTZMODZIbmk2aWRRQT09"",""descValue"":""National accounts (GDP data)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.data.gov.my/data/ms_MY/dataset/labour-force-statistics-malaysia-1091"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dosm.gov.my/v1/index.php?r=column/cthemeByCat&cat=100&bul_id=aG1XUTl0YmhLQjYvR01kWXp4V3ZWUT09&menu_id=TE5CRUZCblh4ZTZMODZIbmk2aWRRQT09"",""descValue"":""Latest GDP update - Q4 2016""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dosm.gov.my/v1/index.php?r=column/cthemeByCat&cat=124&bul_id=VWl4c2VyZ0Q3MEUxU0NzOVBPMnlDUT09&menu_id=U3VPMldoYUxzVzFaYmNkWXZteGduZz09"",""descValue"":""Latest unemployment update Dec 2016""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dosm.gov.my/v1/index.php?r=column/cthemeByCat&cat=155&bul_id=OWlxdEVoYlJCS0hUZzJyRUcvZEYxZz09&menu_id=L0pheU43NWJwRWVSZklWdzQ4TlhUUT09"",""descValue"":""Population update 2016""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added link to main site, population, GDP, and unemployment data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Hazwany Jamaluddin for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Added GDP to list of datasets available. Updates are made on the main website but not in downloadable files so effort is required to make data usable (B9 amended from 3 to 1), both in terms of collating data (B5 changed to no) and formats available. ",,"Yes","No","Hazwany Jamaluddin","Sophie Lafayette","50","50"
"abd5a167-c7b1-4c41-83ed-7e49a332dce2","global","2017-01-19T07:51:03","2016","pk","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: no license information found""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: removed HTML - data in PDF documents""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to no, data in multiple PDF documents""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: latest unemployment 2014-15 (2013-14 available but previous years not found); GDP yearly, latest 2012-13 with projections until 2015-16; latest population 2007""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched on Google"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to 1 (from 3) as data has to be extracted from PDF documents to be usable ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Pakistan Bureau of Statistics"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Updated: added GDP""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.pbs.gov.pk/"",""descValue"":""Pakistan Bureau of Statistics""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.pbs.gov.pk/content/national-accounts"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.pbs.gov.pk/population-tables"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.pbs.gov.pk/content/labour-force-statistics"",""descValue"":""Labour data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added links to population, GDP, and labour data.""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Nouman Nazim for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Added GDP to list of datasets available (B3). Amended B5 to no as data for same category found in multiple documents. Removed HTML from list of formats, data found within PDF documents. Amended B9 from 3 to 1 as all data in PDF and requires effort to make usable. ",,"Yes","No","Nouman Nazim","Sophie Lafayette","30","30"
"9c0460c8-e375-40bc-9b4f-5a7e3af51a55","global","2016-12-14T04:28:20","2016","pa","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: no license found, website 'Copyright © 2010 Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Censo'""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: GDP quarterly, latest 2015; latest unemployment data as of August 2016, no previous data found; latest population 2014""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1. Search for Panama Statistics 2. Enter INEC Website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Censo (INEC)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.contraloria.gob.pa/inec/"",""descValue"":""INEC website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.contraloria.gob.pa/inec/publicaciones/Publicaciones.aspx?ID_SUBCATEGORIA=26&ID_PUBLICACION=736&ID_IDIOMA=1"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.contraloria.gob.pa/inec/Publicaciones/Publicaciones.aspx?ID_SUBCATEGORIA=38&ID_PUBLICACION=784&ID_IDIOMA=1&ID_CATEGORIA=5"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.contraloria.gob.pa/inec/Publicaciones/Publicaciones.aspx?ID_SUBCATEGORIA=45&ID_PUBLICACION=699&ID_IDIOMA=1&ID_CATEGORIA=17"",""descValue"":""Population data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Victor Díaz Navarro for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. ",,"Yes","No","Victor Díaz Navarro","Sophie Lafayette","65","65"
"8fdae6f4-3b19-4165-8f17-91fa5d757acf","global","2016-12-02T14:50:51","2016","py","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: no license found""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Only sav inside a .rar is available. Update: data found in PDF files.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to no, data for GDP in various PDF files e.g. Statistical Yearbooks""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""In this case is annually and last one is 2015. Update: amended to no - latest unemployment from 2010 (yearly); latest population 2002, 2012 prediction - five year estimates until 2050; GDP yearly, latest 2011, predictions 2012-2014""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search site of DGEEG and then there are some buttons on front page. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Since I cannot use it because I don't have SPSS, they provide dictionaries and forms, so it would be easy to use making some efforts. Update: amended to 1 as data is not available in formats that are easily usable. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Dirección General de Estadística, Encuestas y Censos"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Information is about population but using statistical sampling. Update: added GDP (found in Statistics Yearbooks)""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.dgeec.gov.py/microdatos/index.php"",""descValue"":""Microdatos - Encuesta Permanente de Hogares""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.datos.gov.py/dataset/encuesta-permanente-de-hogares"",""descValue"":"" Encuesta Permanente de Hogares - SECCIÓN 2. CARACTERÍSTICA DE LA VIVIENDA E INVENTARIO DE BIENES DURADEROS""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dgeec.gov.py/"",""descValue"":""Dirección General de Estadística, Encuestas y Censos - main website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dgeec.gov.py/Publicaciones/tasaactividad.php"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dgeec.gov.py/Publicaciones/evoluciontotal.php"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dgeec.gov.py/Publicaciones/Biblioteca/anuario2014/Anuario%20Estadistico%202014.pdf"",""descValue"":""Latest Statistical Yearbook (2014), including GDP ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added link to main website, unemployment and population data, and Statistical Yearbook which includes GDP""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Added GDP dataset (B3) - found within Statistical Yearbooks. B5 amended to no as GDP data in various PDF files. B6 amended to no as data not updated at required frequency and not up to date. B9 amended to 1, data is not in formats that are easily usable. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Sophie Lafayette","30","30"
"baa63e9b-dd3e-4d90-a9f4-c6e415e8502a","global","2017-03-14T20:22:44","2016","ag","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML, PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""The data was very easy in being connected , by merely carrying out a google search for the keywords \"" antigua and barbuda gov law\"" I found the data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Parliament of Antigua and Barbuda"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://laws.gov.ag/new/detail_page.php?page=content/year.php"",""descValue"":""Laws or Acts of Parliament By Year""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The laws are listed up to 2015 at the following link: https://laws.gov.ag/new/detail_page.php?page=content/year.php. The title, and year it was enacted are listed on the website, while the content and date of enactment are listed in a PDF document. The amendments are listed alongside the laws within the same list, however they do not appear to be linked. Within the PDF for the amendments, the original law that it affects is listed accordingly. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Alyssa Beaton","30","30"
"f30fc51b-beb4-4286-bdc5-76a52283df12","global","2017-03-14T20:08:54","2016","al","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML, DOC, PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I searched the 2015 index of the given country. Upon second review, I found the other link while completing a web search, where I was directed to the parliament's website. The laws are listed under \""documentation.\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Justice, Albanian Parliament"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.qbz.gov.al/botime/botimetf15.htm"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Justice""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.parlament.al/dokumentacioni/libraria-e-akteve/"",""descValue"":""Albanian Parliament""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The first link is to the Official Gazette, where Laws are published. The second link points to the Parliament's website, which lists laws from 2013-2017. Laws, resolutions, decisions and amendments are listed here, with the title, year and adoption date. Content is available to view or download in DOC and/or PDF. The data is searchable, however amendments/decisions to laws don't appear to be linked accordingly.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Alyssa Beaton","45","45"
"45262293-80c7-4595-bf65-b2ea3b7843df","global","2017-03-14T20:10:36","2016","pr","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" United States Postal Service (USPS) "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Jacobo Orenstein for the contribution.","Puerto Rico follows the United States of America postal system. Its state code is PR and its postal codes range from 00601 to 00799 and from 00901 to 00999, but there is no known publicly available dataset that georeferences this information. Official pertinent available geodata has not been discovered on the governmental official portal: https://www2.pr.gov/agencias/gis/descargaGeodatos/Pages/default.aspx. Boundaries are available at: https://www2.pr.gov/agencias/gis/descargaGeodatos/Delimitaciones/Pages/Limites-legales.aspx. Data has some terms of use: https://www2.pr.gov/Pages/NormasdeUso.aspx.","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"acc8b51e-f4c4-4030-b6c5-bba85c145e5c","global","2017-01-11T15:08:36","2016","pe","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: unknown, no license found""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: population, yearly - based on projections from census years; GDP yearly until 2012, projections until 2015; employment yearly, latest 2015""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Expand the categories on the left, choose the category, select the variables and submit"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""INEI - Nacional Institute of Statistics and Informatics"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added GDP (see link above)""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.inei.gob.pe/"",""descValue"":""INEI - Data base section""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.inei.gob.pe/sistemas-consulta/"",""descValue"":""INEI - System information ""},{""urlValue"":""https://iinei.inei.gob.pe/iinei/siemweb/publico/"",""descValue"":""Economic information""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.inei.gob.pe/estadisticas/indice-tematico/poblacion-y-vivienda/"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.inei.gob.pe/estadisticas/indice-tematico/economia/"",""descValue"":""Economic data (including GDP)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.inei.gob.pe/estadisticas/indice-tematico/ocupacion-y-vivienda/"",""descValue"":""Employment data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added links to GDP, population, and employment data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Antonio Cucho Gamboa for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Added GDP to list of datasets available. ",,"Yes","No","Antonio Cucho Gamboa","Sophie Lafayette","50","50"
"1cf1f811-1a6a-435d-b024-495da3df157d","global","2017-03-14T19:59:53","2016","al","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML, PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Web search for draft bills/legislation in Albania, directed to the Parliament's website, the link to draft legislation is listed under \""documentation.\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Albanian Parliament"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.parlament.al/dokumentacioni/projektligje/"",""descValue"":""Albanian Parliament""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Upon reviewing the review, I found a more accurate link to Albanian draft legislation with a web search for draft bills/legislation in Albania, I was directed to the Parliament's website, where the link to draft legislation is listed under ""documentation."" Draft legislation is listed here: https://www.parlament.al/dokumentacioni/projektligje/, where the status and initiators are listed. The content is downloadable in PDF format, and the author of the bill is included there. ",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","45","45"
"dd85dbb4-dd6e-4201-96e6-299da56f9feb","global","2016-12-13T09:09:13","2016","ph","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data also in PDF. Mostly in PDF.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""GDP and unemployment are regularly updated, but population data takes years (e.g. last censuses were 2000, 2007, 2010, 2015). Update: projections exist for future but only at five year intervals. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""The summary data are found on the front page of the PSA site. Datasets can be found via links from the main site (e.g. clicking on the summary data) or a quick search from the search box (e.g. \""employment 2016\"", \""census 2015\"")."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://psa.gov.ph/article/privacy-policy"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The footers of both the PSA website and Data.gov.ph say, \""All content is in the public domain unless otherwise stated.\"" ""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Since a lot of the data is in PDF, a lot of effort is required to turn them to text that can be analyzed.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Philippine Statistics Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://psa.gov.ph/"",""descValue"":""Main site of the Philippine Statistics Authority""},{""urlValue"":""https://psa.gov.ph/content/highlights-philippine-population-2015-census-population"",""descValue"":""2015 Census""},{""urlValue"":""https://psa.gov.ph/nap-press-release"",""descValue"":""Economy press release with GDP""},{""urlValue"":""https://psa.gov.ph/content/employment-rate-october-2016-estimated-953-percent"",""descValue"":""Employment data for October 2016""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.ph/catalogue/dataset/employment-rate-in-april-2016"",""descValue"":""Open Data entry on April 2016 employment data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Sophie Lafayette","85","85"
"122eedd5-6fba-4f2d-a9e8-39ce942a9a45","global","2017-03-14T19:47:29","2016","id","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""House of Representatives"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Per the original reviewer, the Draft legislation is available only a very limited basis. ""After reviewing over 20 random examples, the content of draft legislation cannot be found. Some of the legislation offers basic descriptions (about, date, status, assigned governmental body and some limited history). As it currently stands, the structure for providing draft legislation online is in place, but much of the content in missing. For example, some of the bills have a related PDF document available for download – the downloaded PDF (which appears to be automatically generated) is a one page document containing only the title of the bill. This showcases that the structure of the database is in place, but the content has not been populated. Other items like basic descriptions, dates, and the like are also missing for many bills; the user is presented with a “Data not found” message instead."" The review has been modified to account for the missing content of draft legislation.",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","0","0"
"5477ad28-7fb3-47e2-8da3-786e05bb393a","global","2016-12-10T23:11:12","2016","pl","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Also PDF files. Update: latest data also posted on website as HTML.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""You can download datasets on xml format. Update: data in XLS & for latest data have to combine data in files with data updates from website. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I've chosen the basic data from the main menu, it's also possible to use the search or detailed menu "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://bip.stat.gov.pl/prawo/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to 2 as limited file formats and have to pull data from multiple sources for most up to date data. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Główny Urząd Statystyczny (GUS) - Central Statistical Office of Poland"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://stat.gov.pl/podstawowe-dane/"",""descValue"":""Basic data (among others: population, unemplyment, GDP per capita)""},{""urlValue"":""https://stat.gov.pl/en/topics/national-accounts/quarterly-national-accounts/"",""descValue"":""GDP data (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://stat.gov.pl/en/topics/population/"",""descValue"":""Population data (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://stat.gov.pl/en/topics/labour-market/"",""descValue"":""Labour data (English)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added links to population, GDP, and unemployment data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Data is up to date however latest data may not be in downloadedable file - i.e. for latest data combine files with information posted on website. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Sophie Lafayette","85","85"
"ee6be3c5-88aa-4686-9e41-a5e9b1d69545","global","2016-12-14T18:48:07","2016","pr","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Datasets are downloadable from the second URL: https://www2.pr.gov/agencias/gis/Pages/default.aspx (example used points to the PR Planning Board as the source).""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The data from the second URL, https://www2.pr.gov/agencias/gis/Pages/default.aspx, has information from 2015.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""An expert in GIS technology was consulted."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""The data is available publicly, but Copyrighted by the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, at https://www2.pr.gov/agencias/gis/Pages/default.aspx."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Junta de Planificacion de Puerto Rico - Puerto Rico Planning Board"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Not clear what agency is in charge of this webpage, but it is very complete,""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.jp.pr.gov/portal_jp/Servicios/GIS/PuertoRicoInteractivoPRI/tabid/81/Default.aspx?PageContentID=38"",""descValue"":""viewer ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www2.pr.gov/agencias/gis/Pages/default.aspx"",""descValue"":""Collection of geographical data from multiple sources.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Collection of geographical data from multiple sources.""}]","Yes","Yes","According to the website and the projection file of the shapefiles, the data is referenced in a local system, State Plane Coordinate System projection Lambert Conformal Conic, Datum NAD83, revision 1997. This is a local system, meaning that if one would need to work with this data in conjunction with other datasets that are referenced, one would firstly have to geo-reference it, a process that is not trivial whatsoever, when considering vectors. ",,"Yes","No","Jacobo Orenstein","Codrina Maria Ilie","80","80"
"ce8618d2-c6a0-4991-8335-2b9e293b6d47","global","2017-03-14T19:37:36","2016","hk","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Visit Legislative Council website > Bills"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Legislative Council"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.legco.gov.hk/database_leg_pro/english/bills/bills.htm"",""descValue"":""Full List of Bills (Since 2000)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.legco.gov.hk/general/english/bills/bill1617.htm"",""descValue"":""Bills (Year 2016 - 2017)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.legco.gov.hk/general/english/bills/bill_1216.htm"",""descValue"":""Bills - Fifth Legislative Council (2012 - 2016)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The majority of data characteristics are available here, including content, status, transcripts and votes: https://www.legco.gov.hk/database_leg_pro/english/bills/bills.htm, in addition to a wealth of supporting documents. After thorough searching through the available documentation, however, I was unable to locate the author for the bills. The data is available for viewing and download in PDF format. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Alyssa Beaton","45","45"
"ed064ba2-f057-4ab5-9428-55f7af63d80d","global","2017-03-14T19:24:24","2016","cr","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF, HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I wrote on Gogle Search Proyectos de ley Costa Rica, and the first result is the draft of laws site."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Asamblea Legislativa de Costa Rica"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.asamblea.go.cr/Centro_de_informacion/Consultas_SIL/Pginas/Proyectos%20de%20ley.aspx"",""descValue"":""Legislative Assembly Republic of Costa Rica""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Draft bills are available on the website for the National Assembly: https://www.asamblea.go.cr/Centro_de_informacion/Consultas_SIL/Pginas/Proyectos%20de%20ley.aspx. The status, and proponents are available on the website, whereas author and content are downloadable in PDF format. ",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","45","45"
"1b7d5e98-5053-453e-a7f2-21b19221c8ca","global","2016-12-10T11:33:27","2016","pt","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: not clear what license data released under, however is free to use, see: https://bit.ly/2npFzgR""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: GDP available in XLS, unemployment and population CVS & XLS""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to yes - GDP quarterly, latest Q4 2016; population yearly, projection until 2060; unemployment monthly, latest Jan 2017""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Used the search feature"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Nacional de Estatística"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.pt"",""descValue"":""Instituto Nacional de Estatística""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.pt/xportal/xmain?xpid=INE&xpgid=ine_cnacionais2010&perfil=220675163&INST=220616736&contexto=am"",""descValue"":""GDP data (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.pt/xportal/xmain?xpid=INE&xpgid=ine_indicadores&indOcorrCod=0007974&contexto=bd&selTab=tab2"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.pt/xportal/xmain?xpid=INE&xpgid=ine_indicadores&indOcorrCod=0007827&contexto=bd&selTab=tab2"",""descValue"":""Population data (English)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added links to GDP, population, and unemployment data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Tiago Vieira for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Amended B6 to yes as data is up to date. Added XLS & CVS formats. No clear license for use of data. ",,"Yes","No","Tiago Vieira","Sophie Lafayette","80","80"
"8c1208a3-981a-41f8-bb56-ff5c61048717","global","2017-03-14T19:06:01","2016","gh","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF, HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Parliament of Ghana website, the link to \""Bills\"" is listed under \""Parliamentary Business\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Parliament of Ghana"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.parliament.gh/docs?type=Bills&OT"",""descValue"":""The Bills section on the Parliament of Ghana website""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original submitter: David Opoku. The bills are available here: https://www.parliament.gh/docs?type=Bills&OT and were found navigating the Parliament of Ghana website, where the link to ""Bills"" is listed under ""Parliamentary Business."" The author and status are listed in HTML, while the content is available in PDF. ",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","30","30"
"37b22d2b-4a77-4617-9c4d-ce0e0640763a","global","2017-03-14T18:56:46","2016","kh","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Looking at the website for the National Assembly, \""List of Laws\"" is indicated in the left side menu"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Assembly of Cambodia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://en.nac-kh.org/english/group-law/53"",""descValue"":""National Assembly of Cambodia""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The laws are listed on the National Assembly website, available here: https://national-assembly.org.kh. The content and amendments are indicated, and available in full-text PDF. The website, however, is not up to date, nor is it openly licensed. ","The laws are listed on the National Assembly website, available here: https://national-assembly.org.kh. The content and amendments are indicated, and available in full-text PDF. The website, however, is not up to date, nor is it openly licensed. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Alyssa Beaton","30","30"
"701bbf1d-16ce-4097-8dfc-0601d20dfa5c","global","2016-12-14T19:07:57","2016","pr","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to no as no clear license regarding use of data. ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: added CSV (population), XLS (unemployment from US Dept. of Labor and GDP from Government Development Bank of Puerto Rico)""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data on National Accounts is not updated regularly, The agency in charge of statistics on National Accounts is the Puerto Rico Planning Board. Update: unemployment monthly from Dept. of Labor. Data on GDP latest from 2012, onwards predicted yearly. Population from 2010 census. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I used a readily available Internet search engine."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""The data on the site is available publicly, but there is no reference to a specific license. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Since the Puerto Rico Institute of Statistics collects and disseminates statistics from Puerto Rico's government agencies, licensing status of the data would be attributed to the individual government agencies. ""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to 2 (from 3) as data requires some effort to make usable. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto de Estadisticas de Puerto Rico - Puerto Rico Institute of Statistics"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: GDP found on site for Government Development Bank for Puerto Rico, unemployment found on site for US Department of Labour. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://estadisticas.pr"",""descValue"":""Instituto de Estadisticas de Puerto Rico main page""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bls.gov/eag/eag.pr.htm"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data from US Department of Labor""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.gdb-pur.com/economy/statistical-appendix.html"",""descValue"":""GDP data (Government Development Bank for Puerto Rico)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.estadisticas.gobierno.pr/iepr/Estadisticas/Basesdedatos/Demografia.aspx#censo"",""descValue"":""Population data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added description to main link, added links to population, GDP, and unemployment data ""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Jacobo Orenstein for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Not easy to navigate and find data on Puerto Rico Institute of Statistics website. Additional data on Puerto Rico can also be found through US agencies, e.g. Department of Labor for unemployment data.","The Puerto Rico Institute of Statistics collects and disseminates statistics from Puerto Rico's government agencies.","Yes","No","Jacobo Orenstein","Sophie Lafayette","65","65"
"1b5ab9ab-275f-4df2-a35f-bbcb031bdf9e","global","2017-03-14T18:43:41","2016","kh","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Assembly of Cambodia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission provided this link: https://en.nac-kh.org/english/group-law/53, which hosts all enacted law.
Draft bills/legislation are not available online for public consultation, therefore I have updated this review accordingly.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Alyssa Beaton","0","0"
"5cbc76da-106a-4928-b856-5f30674b555c","global","2017-03-14T18:38:03","2016","bb","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Barbados Parliament"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Per the original review, Anton, the Barbados Draft Legislation database is searchable, available here: https://www.barbadosparliament.com/bills/search - Bills & Resolutions. While it includes the Content of a bill (via PDF), the status of a bill, dates of introduction and passing, as well as relevant amendments – it does not include the author, votes, nor transcripts of the debates. For this reason, the data does not meet all required characteristics.",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","0","0"
"78bfddb9-415f-4831-9616-74e1d3a7ee65","global","2017-03-14T18:31:59","2016","ag","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""While perusing the website for national law data I was easily connected to the bills"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Justice and Legal Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://laws.gov.ag/new/detail_page.php?page=content/bills.php"",""descValue"":""Bills""},{""urlValue"":""https://legalaffairs.gov.ag/detail_page.php?page=gazette.php"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Justice and Legal Affairs""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Bill information is accessible in two places: firstly, from the Official Gazette, https://legalaffairs.gov.ag/detail_page.php?page=gazette.php, and secondly, from the Parliament's website, https://laws.gov.ag/new/detail_page.php?page=content/bills.php. In both cases, laws are available to view and download in PDF format. Author and content are available, however status is less clear. While the website is up-to-date, the PDF of the bill will indicate the version number, but little other information is provided. For this reason, not all data characteristics have been fulfilled.",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","0","0"
"9f333418-9f59-419a-ae81-823c62372b86","global","2016-12-15T09:34:56","2016","tr","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is open and available but there is no official statement that says it is openly licensed. ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data format is pdf. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is updates on the status of the bill but there are no weekly updates. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled the draft legislation query in Turkey and my findings lead me to the website of TBMM which is where the data of all draft legislations is shared."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Since the data format is pdf, it is not the most user friendly data. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Grand National Assembly of Turkey "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.tbmm.gov.tr/develop/owa/tasari_teklif_sd.sorgu_baslangic"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submitter posted this link, and while it states that the information is searchable, I was unable to find any draft laws for review. Nevertheless, the portal is available here: https://www.tbmm.gov.tr/develop/owa/tasari_teklif_sd.sorgu_baslangic. Per the submitter: ""I googled the draft legislation query in Turkey and my findings lead me to the website of TBMM which is where the data of all draft legislations is shared.""",,"Yes","No","Isil Yarimoglu","Alyssa Beaton","15","15"
"5c5756cb-54ad-488d-a1fd-0dfc02d16bde","global","2016-12-09T12:07:25","2016","tr","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""\""The gazette began to be published daily except for national holidays, general holidays and Sundays\""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""In Turkey, national laws won't go into operation until it is published in The Official Gazette. That's why I went directly to that site. From there, by choosing the date of The Gazette, we can get the data of the national laws."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/default.aspx#"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""\"" The Official Gazette web page can be accessed free of charge, with no obligation for subscription. All the editions as of the first edition dated 7/2/1921 can be found at our web site.\"" ""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Başbakanlık Mevzuatı Geliştirme ve Yayın Genel Müdürlüğü"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/default.aspx"",""descValue"":""The Official Gazette""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bimer.gov.tr/bimer-mevzuat"",""descValue"":""\""Basbakanlik Iletisim Merkezi\"" - Prime Ministry Communication Centre""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","""Basbakanlik Iletisim Merkezi"" - Prime Ministry Communication Centre. The submitter states that ""in Turkey, national laws won't go into operation until it is published in The Official Gazette. That's why I went directly to that site. From there, by choosing the date of The Gazette, we can get the data of the national laws."" Laws are accessible in HTML, and editions of the Gazette can be downloaded in full in PDF. Amendments and previous iterations of the law are referenced at the bottom of the document, stating date and issue number. The data is not readily accessible as it requires previous knowledge on behalf of the user to locate specific laws. The submitter originally stated that the data is openly licensed, however copyright ownership is retained by the Prime Ministry. The copyright is not up to date here, https://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/default.aspx, only 2006, but at the second link where there is a small selection of laws available in PDF, https://www.bimer.gov.tr/bimer-mevzuat, the copyright is up to 2017. ",,"Yes","No","Isil Yarimoglu","Alyssa Beaton","45","45"
"eae356a0-3b73-49fb-8bd0-06abada298db","global","2016-12-12T11:37:15","2016","ru","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: data found on Federal State Statistics Service (English) is in Word docs - Russian site includes more data in variety of formats. Added XLS for data in open data portal.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Through official website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.ru/information-usage"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: also see https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/deed.ru for open data portal. Main website has 'Copyright 1999 - 2017 Федеральная служба государственной статистики' ""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal State Statistics Service"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.gks.ru/opendata/"",""descValue"":""Open data section of Federal State Statistics Service""},{""urlValue"":""https://fedstat.ru"",""descValue"":""Governmental information system""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.gks.ru/opendata/dataset"",""descValue"":""Open data datasets""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.gks.ru/wps/wcm/connect/rosstat_main/rosstat/en/main/"",""descValue"":""Federal State Statistics Service""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.gks.ru/wps/wcm/connect/rosstat_main/rosstat/en/figures/labour/"",""descValue"":""Labour data (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.gks.ru/wps/wcm/connect/rosstat_main/rosstat/en/figures/population/"",""descValue"":""Population data (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.gks.ru/wps/wcm/connect/rosstat_main/rosstat/ru/statistics/accounts/#"",""descValue"":""GDP data (Russian)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.gks.ru/wps/wcm/connect/rosstat_main/rosstat/ru/statistics/population/demography/"",""descValue"":""Population data (Russian)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.gks.ru/wps/wcm/connect/rosstat_main/rosstat/ru/statistics/wages/"",""descValue"":""Labour data (Russian)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added link to main site, GDP, population, and labour data.""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Mikhail Parfentev for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Limited data available on English version of Federal State Statistics Service website. Data on Russian version appears to be up to date and available in variety of formats. Most data also available through open data portal under open license. ",,"Yes","Yes","Mikhail Parfentev","Sophie Lafayette","100","100"
"0756cb63-0972-464d-8bbd-b8aaea26e7f8","global","2017-01-23T17:53:00","2016","lc","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: website 'SO St.Lucia © 2012 - 2017'""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Population is available as a PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The GDP and unemployment data leads up to 2015, and 2012 for population. Update: GDP yearly. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""While perusing the I was connected to the Central Statistics Page"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to 2, limited formats available & some effort required. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Central Statistic Office "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://192.147.231.244:9090/stats/index.php/statistics/labour"",""descValue"":""Current Labour Force Statistics ""},{""urlValue"":""https://192.147.231.244:9090/stats/index.php/statistics/population"",""descValue"":""Population and Vital Statistics""},{""urlValue"":""https://192.147.231.244:9090/stats/index.php/statistics/economy"",""descValue"":""Economic Growth Rate 2015""},{""urlValue"":""https://192.147.231.244:9090/stats/"",""descValue"":""Central Statistics Office main site""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Alesha Aris for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. ",,"Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Sophie Lafayette","65","65"
"c58848f3-7234-4805-afd2-e8c8401bc973","global","2017-03-14T10:31:34","2016","sg","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Available in PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search on Google for Singapore legislation "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Parliament of Singapore"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.parliament.gov.sg/publications/bills-introduced"",""descValue"":""Parliament of Singapore: Bills Introduced""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The full bills are found on the Singapore Statutes Online website, while details of parliamentary debates and votes are found in the official parliamentary reports. ""}]","Yes","Yes","The submitter initially linked to https://www.parliament.gov.sg/publications-singapore-official-reports for the availability of votes and transcripts, however I was unable to find votes on any bills for the past two months. The parliament website: https://www.parliament.gov.sg/publications/bills-introduced, makes available draft bills, with PDF text for download. The author is not listed, while content and status are up-to-date.",,"Yes","No","Zhaowei Lin","Alyssa Beaton","30","30"
"0d9c0436-2ee6-4720-9c06-8870a5d20576","global","2016-11-25T08:08:17","2016","rs","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: no license found, website '© 2010 Statistical Office of the Republic of Serbia'""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: added XLS format""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: while data sets can be downloaded in single files, for most up to date data, must be combined with latest stats found on website""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search on official statistical site."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""After generating report for defined criteria, the results could be downloaded as XML. Human have to define criteria.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Републички завод за статистику (Рзс) (Statistical Office of the Republic of Serbia)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended agency title""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://webrzs.stat.gov.rs/WebSite/public/ReportView.aspx"",""descValue"":""Statistical Office of the Republic of Serbia database""},{""urlValue"":""https://webrzs.stat.gov.rs/WebSite/Public/PageView.aspx?pKey=2"",""descValue"":""Latest data""},{""urlValue"":""https://webrzs.stat.gov.rs/WebSite/Public/PageView.aspx?pKey=163"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://webrzs.stat.gov.rs/WebSite/Public/PageView.aspx?pKey=61"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://webrzs.stat.gov.rs/WebSite/Public/PageView.aspx?pKey=24"",""descValue"":""Employment data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added links to population, GDP, employment, and latest data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Aleksandar Ivić for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. ","The data are aggregated by regions, mostly. ","Yes","No","Aleksandar Ivić","Sophie Lafayette","65","65"
"dc79435a-9405-442c-8913-2ed9ec5e106a","global","2016-11-10T15:00:11","2016","tw","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""search on Taiwan's open data portal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.tw/license#eng"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry Of Justice"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://law.moj.gov.tw/ENG/index.aspx?type=l"",""descValue"":""Acts""},{""urlValue"":""https://law.moj.gov.tw/ENG/index.aspx?type=m"",""descValue"":""Regulations""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submitter's initial link was for a bulk download (https://law.moj.gov.tw/PublicData/GetFile.ashx?DType=XML&AuData=CF), but I was unable to access/open the downloaded XML file and have modified the answer to ""bulk availability"" accordingly. I changed the link to point to laws and amendments listings in HTML, some with accompanying PDF docs for download.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Alyssa Beaton","65","65"
"881cdf9b-e510-42d1-84e5-f6b2a448f78d","global","2016-11-22T07:38:49","2016","sg","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: added XLS format""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: population yearly, latest 2016; GDP quarterly, latest Q4 2016; unemployment quarterly, latest Q4 2016""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Keyword search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.sg/open-data-licence"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: terms of use for main Statistics website https://www.singstat.gov.sg/terms-of-use""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Statistics Singapore"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.sg/"",""descValue"":""Data.gov.sg Singapore's open data portal""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.tablebuilder.singstat.gov.sg"",""descValue"":""Department of Statistics Singapore table builder""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.singstat.gov.sg/"",""descValue"":""Department of Statistics Singapore main site""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.singstat.gov.sg/statistics/latest-data"",""descValue"":""Latest key data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added link to main site and latest data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. ",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Sophie Lafayette","100","100"
"8d3de7cc-69d5-4d9a-afb1-92763f306c0a","global","2016-12-05T12:58:22","2016","sk","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: open data portal has data in additional formats including JSON""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: unemployment quarterly, latest Q4 2016; GDP quarterly, latest Q4 2016; population twice yearly, latest 2016""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I followed the listing from last year and they still work. Thankfully."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://slovak.statistics.sk/wps/portal/ext/aboutus/webpage/terms/!ut/p/b1/jZLZcqMwFES_JR_gIBAIeBSYRWxGYrN5ceENL2CITbzw9eOkXFOVydjJfVPV6St1t7icG3P5vjhtyqLbNPui-jjnaJp6oaJpPAaK7fOAmF6YhkbMMw3cgMkNAA8Gg089lcldHzADkBiHFnNEHogSl3FjewK9YUPOhpFN22PnFIOUVXtkybpU6eu00RkfqKPOTKfLuaSzsSofYDQucjUV8lCL_YtR56QdNtflfLc3aC4uha7317N9iQwdu6msh9nCd08eI2PX81fKaK6YsL_qCjmgabC-KHRb9ZvqNN2J6HQyh4fc5NNhgNztG7bJe4bb87Q-zN7LuubzToaeZC1H3eDu_Ym5L9lZcnzLLgiiJFUoRAL8Vw80DwLiuFFg66YgAv53et3Ctih7ACieJQGC7YSpFEKA4e-6e3LB1-60VABEDhjvUmq5vPjN_zfgQ29GoYBV0dKHbGTe4tEFJfKQACx01z8Bfnh_xuWfyLMEPoFn3_Oryf908JOL58DfDY9iSuQ78KAHqgpcYDf1kpvcMPlhXVjgYm4MxGm0vbak3_Vs21MQbck17ukF9GkQz-IkmJl-HET80Sh7sOO9ziiFYEtgkBx7P1iFi5QlGh72RXE0OYfLN7P69TyvX8ErVCWIZBkiKEEg8IhLvQm4GI1_HuJ4Rd_sKLPTJe2I04jYFqZO6UwKxT6Odu8bXpAGl3Ivdm-rEut81cqhMltGNJ5PQGn6lnLFCdq1xqKm-sIZFZUKZ_rBplrleXQSN3pVLFB-OkeNTdRsLjGpked7igqiXFhUKscOVUs0Pm74QXGzdVVaTc7X8qGJMyLG7fnlhWvr5OR-jIeYwYzVcNzjPyVFwsM!/dl4/d5/L2dJQSEvUUt3QS80SmtFL1o2X1ZMUDhCQjFBME9SSjQwSUZDQTBCVFEzSUw2/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended link to terms of use (initial submission linked to GDP data (https://data.gov.sk/dataset/nu0007rs) - from the open data portal)""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Štatistický úrad SR (Statistical Office of the Slovak Republic)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended agency title""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://slovak.statistics.sk/"",""descValue"":""Official Portal of Statistical Office (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.sk/organization/f4787c6f-9fa3-406c-b8d5-d374f1e1f2d3"",""descValue"":""Official Data Catalogue of Slovak Republic - listing of datasets of Statistical Office""},{""urlValue"":""https://statdat.statistics.sk/cognosext/cgi-bin/cognos.cgi?b_action=xts.run&m=portal/cc.xts&cpstarget=FAAAALeRqncBNsuD9SAz*4q6OAnrW*-kI1nDSCcM-C0ua1Sh5vl4TAT*9IA_|H4sIAAAAAAAAAAMAAAAAAAAAAAA_&cps-portlet=8BF18D3F4BF799274CE22265E78C4028&wsrp-navigationalState=FAAAALeRqncBNsuD9SAz*4q6OAnrW*-kR4Kflt1yPF28m-KKp0tV6MzdZRw_%7cH4sIAAAAAAAAAG3MQQrDIBBA0asUL1AdHVGwgU7Va4igBSFpgrrp7UsL3WX9%2bc8dueft8spbvbHSxrHmd3rua6mdLakFxT0S4YMkKcBAHAUZGwO3nFCAu%2f7%2bxZ0xraQx86xfyGpAjCBJW6Mk13evLJgogcDyIPwpNPY%2b2fJPH9lKFeKrAAAA&wsrp-urlType=render&backURL=&wsrp-windowState=wsrp:normal"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://slovak.statistics.sk/wps/portal/ext/themes/macroeconomic/accounts/indicators/!ut/p/b1/jZXblqI6EEC_ZT7AMQlXHwkgF7knoPLiUlRaAUFFuXz9oWd6zlq20_bAE4tdJLWriozj8WIcn9b3Q7quD-Vpnb8_x_zKFwwRYygBkRMAMBwSAhARQGZoAJYDAL64JPAp3glUYFDJ0wKThYDlxvPxQk8gVq5GqqpKAAQ5SWfy_JJsy23n2PMsKIqjAcHW22y9guZMIyBStJfLZQnoG7fNOwlZh9tZjrCaxwcn5Kv9El7myu5tdujqyqia85nPy5NmF8gvkGnvkvOKzRrxfE-y3aGNTl1NrV7b5dmNKTd9ngipir1wzi7vsmRlQdP0Clvotm1ss_mCFVcBjtel9OPHR-4vknvPPbK83681gcLB3SAvEn2GR8zneIAtBhjmjDi6PEUsgP8WL2uSzgoWAKKlccCQ9DCY-AwDJObR_ePntZD7iH-xwGPtcISAITgBnPm-NoPsU_5PwHv8lHhImrCarATudNAjI5FYPAIa_xH_AnjIX9TtYXtTy4s8lcIAg8_7fwYe4t2hKsNrWQKY-oxh8Z_jn4F_8vcC-GZ25uP4F_Kqgr-AV-P1apO_eui7KrwG_v_CV2UOhQ_giz7yJ-gz4AbSu2gSylObIF5jn5ZwFDwsYQm-aGDGxegJeHSpwW8A8EeU5Ps-saIIaBEa0mSgBpxwgDD_DUD5saOXxW68HDDhy6GR0JiOF4BdkWNXGX3WB8feB-RodLT3W9BHDt3Q0NlMbeoQeFXTHmTQqtUUOUeDccJrbzt7bxsFIZaUfr2-TsfmOD5sip9NUvwEP5kJx_CCwPAMxwAE-XFkLUGrlnajSHTvn3Uy16OdXxtmyUo6WpmpuVyL-tXNbgeIuFGbntj6vE8lGeaV4ImbHfFpsgTp1NbETgr5rFK3hS9vTXedT5iNfNF9nFuWv6SlnK-3fHxvSKkbk3nCBVwpJCefXxtiG5BUvNZ8vuMX1wMcrYe0OrHCQvwmXEo6N1haNcMf87e8ryYGCk_yQNPS7NrZCp6BY8g4dE-cMOuJM4NEhTY8hi1Vwt4GbEt6bZBH_8g7jCo-fpQniAJgBEFkETvhOYYZR3oSm2ppNKqkSDUjL5diasyIO8JW60xLQiwzsq_7dtdBl9HdObDd5GS4uNVdePaLmg41UqaHOrWuGXYL6zBjaqnoLKHzLNiLeYfVrgAHU8TT_nhSy3Rx35dBgqaTtG4uHLvyxGE-1gROOdhF58FVE1YBmrF9WMH4qKy9G0WbqrzPuThU_iLwU5vLzF-6r6NURY7iuFAFgFwW_iAQOLXpOIqMgBI2Tp8w1-zNvFIJ0XrzR6C0V5eLR4EiN5lAgeVEdug9yIhD9yWgVd67bzi7rz1mFU9Psgm-mXmak8LUW0xLPri9bU4TFtx3dM9zxcRXjR3udc1NOnxAUiyeiOTeCnmE5eAURzhtzm1hjbbJttqnVnjb6ue5hDdxr7FeYwDrbZuWG78y27C2SdDVqJyrjTqbLLUGsQ68kT3PlzvbXt1FvVzuF2q_M97P66oI77OPy-ID9fe9Vxb9bj3a9It-gP4DHsJJPA!!/dl4/d5/L2dBISEvZ0FBIS9nQSEh/"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://slovak.statistics.sk/wps/portal/ext/themes/demography/labour/indicators/!ut/p/b1/hZBJcqNAFETP4gPIFBQUxbKEGAoBEvOwIQAhNDBZYCRx-la7vbX7737Ey8h4yaRMzKRdPp_rfDr3Xd78_VOUheYer9csAZros4DatheE2IGIgy8geQHghyPgK--I9F8e264CqE_2mmvwLOAFJmJiPYHmpqd3RYmyYZyMfBW6TYc0URYa-RT2ssva0m5Sw6wqBdmNJfEGvThPpZBL92vfeihtSodN_6zKa6c4KV9x02Kdiq5Giky2oSjvo4O1nU2XxlvTOuJdiVW4PGVMbyizTw_sXJrl3MzZlUfzrG5uqcqGGxttLx9Ep58RGe5Zeys-67Zl00mEpqBVu2n17f6L3H-2i5j0C5E1ovOiCQA2NQFQogeu5EAICPwGfpnX1vu2YpIXJv5YRTjGZ2LAZ97lOdDluriXxQHehT79xXmAJbT9wg_sQrV822NHpV7AlTUnpebsC4V2MC6WfdwfQjdYk82S56PKGEx6Ltr3e9m-g3coCRCJIkRQgIBjEROaCXgovXXfEP_ofOhepIeVM1Gj54nOZUZtJDnWx93188xywupRd_z0cayJzDaDuMdF5Tl-mYBatTT8JAG6DsqhdeSDscsbCRbyTXfWjWk6id_LTX5A6Xz3ep1KUSm4Qi-WnYNyih-uV-NxQk2F4vHMrvKX1hMPazE9ibfejyjvD_e3N2Zog9lELraPFvkDIr0Eig!!/dl4/d5/L2dBISEvZ0FBIS9nQSEh/"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added links to population, GDP, and unemployment data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Peter Hanecak for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Open Data Portal (https://data.gov.sk/en/) also exists which contains some of the datasets above. ","Data is generally accessible via portal of Statistical Office and linked via Slovak National Data Portal. Thanks to Data Portal, we know the licensing for the data: CC-BY-SA.
Not all data is consistently available this way but at least those few mentioned in Census are available:
- Population (up to 2015, updated yearly): https://statdat.statistics.sk/cognosext/cgi-bin/cognos.cgi?b_action=cognosViewer&ui.action=run&ui.object=storeID(%22i700C5B7ABED1414B8B23B4A69E91D146%22)&ui.name=Population%20(absolute%20data)%20%5Bom0001rs%5D&run.outputFormat=&run.prompt=true&cv.header=false&ui.backURL=%2Fcognosext%2Fcps4%2Fportlets%2Fcommon%2Fclose.html&run.outputLocale=en
- Unemployment (up to 2016 Q2, updated quarterly): https://statdat.statistics.sk/cognosext/cgi-bin/cognos.cgi?b_action=cognosViewer&ui.action=run&ui.object=storeID(%22iB193D1C87387465B954B10BE9F45111D%22)&ui.name=Employed%20by%20the%20Labour%20Force%20Sample%20Survey%20%5Bpr0002qs%5D&run.outputFormat=&run.prompt=true&cv.header=false&ui.backURL=%2Fcognosext%2Fcps4%2Fportlets%2Fcommon%2Fclose.html&run.outputLocale=en
- GDP (up to 2016 Q2, updated quarterly): https://statdat.statistics.sk/cognosext/cgi-bin/cognos.cgi?b_action=cognosViewer&ui.action=run&ui.object=storeID(%22iA188D5A85FEF4EA9B48BC102C7C66758%22)&ui.name=Quarterly%20GDP%20data%20for%202013%20at%20curent%20prices%20%5Bnu0002qs%5D&run.outputFormat=&run.prompt=true&cv.header=false&ui.backURL=%2Fcognosext%2Fcps4%2Fportlets%2Fcommon%2Fclose.html&run.outputLocale=en","Yes","Yes","Peter Hanecak","Sophie Lafayette","100","100"
"7c8152e1-61b2-48a0-87e4-81e79d52999c","global","2016-11-30T19:56:17","2016","si","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Attribution of the source is required.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""JSON"",""PX"",""TSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data portal makes it easy to find and download in several formats specific datasets https://pxweb.stat.si/pxweb/dialog/statfile1.asp""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried a web search engine for the Statistical Office of Slovenia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.stat.si/StatWeb/en/StaticPages/Index/Copyright"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Updated: amended link ""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Statistical Office of the Republic of Slovenia (SURS)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.stat.si/StatWeb/en"",""descValue"":""Statistical Office of the Republic of Slovenia (SURS)""},{""urlValue"":""https://pxweb.stat.si/pxweb/Dialog/varval.asp?ma=05A1002E&ti=&path=../Database/Demographics/05_population/05_Basic_data/05_05A10_Population_Q/&lang=1"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://pxweb.stat.si/pxweb/Dialog/varval.asp?ma=0762003E&ti=&path=../Database/Demographics/07_labour_force/02_07008_active_pop_ADS/01_07620_active_pop_ADS_quart/&lang=1"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.stat.si/StatWeb/en/Field/Index/1"",""descValue"":""GDP data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added link to main site, unemployment, population, and GDP data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Very easy to navigate website and link to stats database where data can be downloaded in multiple formats.",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Sophie Lafayette","100","100"
"625bd7ed-7680-4d80-a7a0-7e1d2107ec3c","global","2017-01-12T20:13:24","2016","za","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: latest statistics in PDF reports/public releases""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to no as latest unemployment & population rates were found across multiple PDF documents""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: quarterly labour force survey includes unemployment, GDP quarterly, population twice yearly""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""A quick google search and prior knowledge on statistics data sources. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Statistics South Africa, South African Reserve Bank, Republic of South Africa National Department of Trade and Industry, Republic of South Africa National Treasury"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.statssa.gov.za/"",""descValue"":""Statistics South Africa""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.resbank.co.za/Research/Statistics/Pages/Statistics-Home.aspx"",""descValue"":""South African Reserve Bank""},{""urlValue"":""https://tradestats.thedti.gov.za/ReportFolders/reportFolders.aspx?sCS_referer=&sCS_ChosenLang=en"",""descValue"":""Republic of South Africa National Department of Trade and Industry,""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.treasury.gov.za/publications/tax%20statistics/"",""descValue"":"" Republic of South Africa National Treasury""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statssa.gov.za/?page_id=737&id=1"",""descValue"":""Labour data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statssa.gov.za/?page_id=1854&PPN=P0441&SCH=6981"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statssa.gov.za/publications/P0302/P03022016.pdf"",""descValue"":""Latest population data ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added links to labour, GDP, and population data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Tricia Govindasamy for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Website does contain up to date data but difficult to find all in one location, often displayed only as graph rather than link to a data set or report. ",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Sophie Lafayette","65","65"
"3a695d1f-e37e-435d-8eeb-04852d3c1821","global","2016-11-14T17:27:42","2016","se","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""TSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Also available in PC-AXIS format.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added response to 3""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Googled for \""statistik öppna data\"" (statistics open data)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.scb.se/sv_/Topmeny/Om-webbplatsen/Anvandningsvillkor/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Custom license but similar to CC-BY""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""SCB, Statistics Sweden"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Tables:\n1. \""BNP, arbetskraftsinsats och arbetskraftskostnad, kvartalsdata, faktiska värden\""\n2. \""Arbetslösa från och med 2005\""\n3. \""Folkmängd\""\n\n""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.statistikdatabasen.scb.se/"",""descValue"":""Specific website by Statistics Sweden""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.scb.se/en/finding-statistics/statistics-by-subject-area/population/population-composition/population-statistics/"",""descValue"":""Population data (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.scb.se/en/finding-statistics/statistics-by-subject-area/national-accounts/national-accounts/national-accounts-quarterly-and-annual-estimates/"",""descValue"":""GDP data (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.scb.se/en/finding-statistics/statistics-by-subject-area/labour-market/"",""descValue"":""Labour data (English)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added links to population, GDP, and labour data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Peter Krantz for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. ",,"Yes","Yes","Peter Krantz","Sophie Lafayette","100","100"
"03db4c00-1fde-42ff-baa9-a7d252881821","global","2016-12-23T16:10:14","2016","ch","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""See https://www.bfs.admin.ch/bfs/en/home/fso/swiss-federal-statistical-office/terms-of-use.html Update: 'Any reproduction requires the prior written consent of the copyright holder.'""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""GDP is 2 years out of date""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search engine, organisations page of the national open data portal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bundesamt für Statistik/Office fédéral de la statistique (Federal Statistical Office)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.bfs.admin.ch/bfs/en/home/statistics/catalogues-databases.html"",""descValue"":""Catalogues and Databases with statistical results""},{""urlValue"":""https://opendata.swiss/en/organization/bundesamt-fur-statistik-bfs"",""descValue"":""FSO datasets on the national OGD portal""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bfs.admin.ch/bfs/en/home/statistics/catalogues-databases/tables.assetdetail.1180568.html"",""descValue"":""Gross domestic product (GDP) per region and canton""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bfs.admin.ch/bfs/en/home/statistics/catalogues-databases/tables.assetdetail.300189.html"",""descValue"":""Population data ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bfs.admin.ch/bfs/en/home/statistics/catalogues-databases/tables.assetdetail.1080811.html"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bfs.admin.ch/bfs/en/home.html"",""descValue"":""Federal Statistical Office (English)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Oleg Lavrovsky for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. ",,"Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","Sophie Lafayette","65","65"
"a891c13c-8b48-49e2-a461-140b3a2e0193","global","2017-01-25T08:48:30","2016","ru","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""view service""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""view/discovery service""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""two clicks from the main page of the official website of the governmental publisher"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.ru/information-usage"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal Service or State Registration, Cadastre and Cartography"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Parcel boundaries (inc. latitude and longitude)"",""Parcel ID"",""Property value (i.e. Price Paid, Property Tax Value)"",""Tenure Type (ie. leasehold, freehold, protected lands, public lands, customary lands)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://pkk5.rosreestr.ru"",""descValue"":""Public cadastrial map""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I did not find on the official geoportal for land information any links for terms of data usage, neither WFS services that would allow a bulk download or a per/file bulk download from the web interface. ",,"Yes","No","Михаил Парфентьев","Codrina Maria Ilie","45","45"
"ea8f08cd-d991-4699-9369-b05efae0fd31","global","2016-11-10T16:11:45","2016","ru","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""View/discovery service""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""view service""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""through the official website of the federal executive body"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.ru/information-usage"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""THE FEDERAL SERVICE FOR STATE REGISTRATION, CADASTRE AND CARTOGRAPHY"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://pkk5.rosreestr.ru/#x=11554711.454933215&y=10055441.599232893&z=3"",""descValue"":""Public cadastral map""},{""urlValue"":""https://rosreestr.ru/wps/portal/p/cc_ib_portal_services/cc_ib_opendata2/!ut/p/c5/hU69DoIwGHyk76pAWRswLSBYlERgIQ0hSMKPgzHx7a26uKB34_1STZazuQ-9uQ3LbEYqqfYaMFcw5SBCyH0IscsKncCCW73ymkjGWiWSQeZ7IArCE9OCAxp_0ufX3pfjkG5d6wiKOOXHDXzno__qf-dXIECZWqaOKqr56g_pUjV2vWkfdJ1KDPqSPwHqEtmb/dl3/d3/L0lJSklna21DU1EhIS9JRGpBQU15QUJFUkNKRXFnLzRGR2dzbzBWdnphOUlBOW9JQSEhLzdfMDE1QTFINDBJMEQ3ODBBQUVOVFBLMDAwRzUvRGZ4OkE5Nzk3MDAxMS9zYS5ydS5mY2NsYW5kLmlibXBvcnRhbC5zcHJpbmcucG9ydGxldC5kaXNwYXRjaGVyLkRpc3BhdGNoZXJBY3Rpb25FdmVudC1NVUxUSVBBUlQ!/?PC_7_015A1H40I0D780AAENTPK000G5000000_ru.fccland.ibmportal.spring.portlet.handler.BeanNameParameterHandlerMapping-PATH=%2fShowInfoblockPageController¶m_infoblock_document_path=pkk_metadannie.htm"",""descValue"":""open data dataset Cadastral map (metadata)""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I have found no links on the official geoportal of the Federal Service for State Registration, Cadastre and Cartography to the license that has been provided by the submitter [https://data.gov.ru/information-usage]. Moreover, I have found no license terms on the portal. ",,"Yes","No","Михаил Парфентьев","Codrina Maria Ilie","45","45"
"8f072838-f5af-46c8-bbdd-e496f8862ef6","global","2017-01-29T20:50:22","2016","kn","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" High Court"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"It was reported in 2014 that a new Land Registry in St. Kitts and Nevis was to be developed following the approval of a new Land Registry Bill (2014) that established a dedicated and separate land registry with branch offices in both Nevis and St. Kitts. However I was unable to identify an online government portal for the given datasets.
https://www.nevispages.com/new-land-registry-to-result-in-a-central-electronic-repository-for-records/","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"950a0c14-3243-40dd-84a5-c2a2b73711e4","global","2017-01-26T02:26:13","2016","kn","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""St Kitts and Nevis Postal Services"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Reported the official launch of the St Kitts and Nevis Postal Code System took place on World Post Day, October 9, 2016
However I was unable to locate substantial online data to meet the survey requirements.
https://sknis.info/st-kitts-nevis-postal-code-system-skn-pcs/","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"20ddff74-f7d9-4fdb-96de-282248068762","global","2017-01-25T19:51:57","2016","kn","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Land and Survey Department"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The responsible organisation appears to be the Department of Lands and Surveys within the Ministry of Sustainable Development but I was unable to identify a government portal for the given datasets.
The closest representation I was able to find was from the Ministry of Tourism
https://www.stkittstourism.kn/feel-st-kitts-interactive-map.php","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"597fb44e-0750-4b19-9fb5-e99f29b134ad","global","2017-03-14T09:29:12","2016","ca","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Quick Google Search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Environment Canada"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Probability"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://weather.gc.ca/forecast/public_bulletins_e.html?Bulletin=fpcn53.cwwg"",""descValue"":""Extended forecast""},{""urlValue"":""https://weather.gc.ca/forecast/public_bulletins_e.html"",""descValue"":""Linklist to short-term and extended forecasts for all regions""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission was changed. It stated that forecasts can be downloaded and that they are available as xml and csv. However, the reviewer was unable to find the data online. Data is not openly licensed, as the submitter states
Thank you, Paul R Pival and Tracey P. Lauriault, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Note the modification to the licence GRANT OF LICENSE - The Government of Canada (Environment Canada) is the owner of all intellectual property rights (including copyright) of this Software and Data Product. You are granted a limited, non-exclusive, non-assignable and non-transferable license to use this software and data product subject to the terms below. This license is not a sale of any or all of the owner's rights. This product may only be used by you, and you may not rent, lease, lend, sub-license or transfer the data product or any of your rights under this agreement to anyone else, except under the following terms and conditions. REDISTRIBUTION RESTRICTIONS - You are authorized to further distribute the data or software, including any portion of it, contained in this product under the following conditions only. No fee will be charged explicitly for this Environment Canada product to any party to whom it is distributed. (Charges for value-added services are permitted.). In consideration of the license you are herein granted, you have the obligation to acknowledge the source of the Environment Canada Data with the following layout or something similar: based on Environment Canada data. Redistribution must occur so that any other party must agree to the same redistribution restrictions before use of the redistributed product is allowed.
","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"0d2a9cda-712b-4e10-9621-32936eb57996","global","2017-01-25T01:44:16","2016","lc","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Economic Development, Housing, Urban Renewal, Transport and Civil Aviation - Land registry"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The Land registry appears to be the responsible agent for the collection and registration of deeds. However we're unable to find a reputable online database","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"ede65a8f-9e00-4ef0-975a-b198b7cb85a5","global","2017-03-14T09:27:59","2016","lc","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""St Lucia Postal Service"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Alesha Aris for the contribution.","There is a list of postcodes on the website, but there are no coordinates assigned. (points/polygons)","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"4a1ab6bb-869c-4488-9bc6-108c47fd7669","global","2017-03-14T09:12:33","2016","bb","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""CORPORATE AFFAIRS AND INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY OFFICE"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The Corporate Affairs and Intellectual Property Office offers a Limited Internet Search Facility as a free service to the public as a quick reference for the purpose of enabling persons to ascertain whether or not a particular company, business name, charity or society could possibly be registered in our various statutory registers. However, the results, viewed separately for each individual entity and given in .HTML format, only consist of Company Name, ID number, and Date Registered / Incorporated. No Company Address is provided. Furthermore, the database is updated only periodically by a private contractor and accordingly, search results will not give a real-time reflection of all the entries made in the various registers held in the Office. The database will therefore never be a substitute for the official records held in the various statutory registers and the Office does not and cannot guarantee the accuracy or integrity of any of the search results which are obtained from this site and no representations or warranties are made by the Office with respect thereto. Company inquiries can be purchased for a fee of $5.00. It is worth noting that I had to review this entry more than once as the CAIPO website took down their Search feature at some point during the past month, but have now restored it once more. Still, as not all four required characteristics can be found online, the dataset is marked as non-existent.
https://caipo.gov.bb/site/index.php/search/search-our-database",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"b08cc1f1-ebaf-4902-9b07-92e6e0017b52","global","2017-03-14T09:10:12","2016","lc","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Economic Development, Housing, Urban Renewal, Transport and Civil Aviation - Survey & Mapping Section, Central Statistics Office -The Mapping Unit"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Alesha Aris for the contribution.","There are some maps in pdf format, non-georeferenced for each district, at small scales [https://192.147.231.244:9090/stats/index.php/statistics/2013-05-13-12-49-24/maps]. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"95c84049-14da-487c-9343-79959ce474ae","global","2017-01-25T06:29:56","2016","vc","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Land Registry Department"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"It reported that in 2010 the Government would proceed in the implementation of the National Land titling project with specific focus on digitisation of data/records, and training of relevant staff however I was unable to identify any documentation from a government source
https://svgedfpmcu.com/national-land-titling-project/","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"6459dae0-7c73-4ce7-87ce-af8e2b14156a","global","2017-03-14T08:36:01","2016","vc","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Location data: St Vincent and the Grenadines Postal Corporation "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Alesha Aris for the contribution.","There is an available dataset, but not full compliant with the requirements of the theme. https://www.svgpost.gov.vc/postoffice/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=3&Itemid=7","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"8eb50c87-190a-4c4f-8a05-ddf9bf86d04a","global","2017-03-14T08:25:16","2016","vc","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Land and Surveys Department"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Alesha Aris for the contribution.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"97e80947-24aa-49bc-a528-b9d6ce34a614","global","2017-03-14T06:28:43","2016","bo","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""In GeoBolivia, search for \""Administrative Boundaries\""; in the result page \""Sub-National Administrative Units of Bolivia\"", click the download link."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""GeoBolivia, VICEPRESIDENCIA DEL ESTADO PLURINACIONAL DE BOLIVIA"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://geo.gob.bo/geonetwork/srv/spa/catalog.search#/search?resultType=details&any=administrative&from=1&to=20&sortBy=relevance"",""descValue"":""Sub-National Administrative Units of Bolivia""},{""urlValue"":""https://geo.gob.bo/geonetwork/srv/spa/catalog.search#/metadata/aeeb85a9-23df-48d4-a4e5-dd19e8b206db"",""descValue"":""Municipal (Boundary Level 2)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Found the site GeoBolivia; under the office of the Vice President which has much better and easier to download ""Administrative Boundaries"". Dataset links, formats have been updated to reflect this.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","80","80"
"f6b90fe5-1153-4afb-a29f-aaba09d5af3f","global","2017-03-14T06:19:40","2016","bt","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Visited website to look for information"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Land Commission of Bhutan"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.geo.gov.bt/Home/DataDetail?metadataId=52"",""descValue"":""Administrative boundaries 1""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.geo.gov.bt/Home/DataDetail?metadataId=53"",""descValue"":""Boundaries Level 2""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Changed to indicate that it is not licensed liberally; as there are copyright on commercial use. Other than that; the datasets covers all needed characteristics.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","80","80"
"29043364-6d5b-430f-ac6c-97c64b3b9698","global","2017-03-14T06:12:20","2016","bb","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Electoral & Boundaries Commission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No dataset fulfilling the characteristics are available online.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Rejected as there is no coordinates projection and polygon borders.","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","0","0"
"fc97b0b3-b591-417a-a361-d6c079ef873b","global","2017-03-14T03:49:21","2016","bo","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Órgano Electoral Plurinacional"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission since not all required data is available. Results available include registered votes, major results, invalid and blank votes, no information for spoiled ballots.
Website presents several navigation obstacles, such as heavy load, broken links for results, captcha for most the consults. Submitter also refers to incomplete datasets. 2016 Referendum results are announced with a banner in the homepage (https://resultados2016.oep.org.bo/) but they are only available through HTML at polling station. PDF files are also available (https://tse.oep.org.bo/images/resultados_referendo_constitucional_2016.pdf). 2015 Referendum results are announced as well but the link is broken (https://resultados.oep.org.bo/ResultadosRef/). 2012, 2013, 2014 Elections results and 2015 Subnational elections results (https://www.oep.org.bo/index.php/elecciones-subnacionales-2015/990-resultados-elecciones-subnacionales-2015) are only available through PDF format (ie. https://www.oep.org.bo/index.php/procesos-electorales/elecciones-generales-2014). By the end of the 2016 Referendum results webpage there’s a “All rights reserved” disclaimer, similar in organization’s webpage.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"9c2efe2e-a21b-4bb0-a386-b73bccd6be3f","global","2017-03-14T03:46:00","2016","kh","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The National Election Committee (NEC)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission since not all required data is available. Results available only account for major results. Results are only available in PDF format, as scanned images. The data is available at the Khmer language version only, in exception at 2012 election results for the Senate Election, 3rd Legislature
(https://necelect.org.kh/english/content/2012result-senate-election-3rd-legislature).
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"eeedf78b-3110-4a78-8dc8-aac8faa84fad","global","2017-03-14T03:41:40","2016","ve","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Consejo Nacional Electoral, Órgano del Poder Electoral"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission since not all required data is available. Results available for Parliamentary Elections 2014 and Presidential Elections 2013 include registered votes, major results, invalid and blank votes, no information for spoiled ballots.
Information is available at HTML format only by electoral zones. It is not possible to download data on bulk or have an overall view of the data. For a major analysis, it would be required to do extensive scraping to gather data. Website holds a “All rights reserved” disclaimer.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"a8cb3478-38fc-45b5-ab28-bc8973973f86","global","2016-11-14T13:05:02","2016","ko","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Some data are available some of them missing. The list is very incomplete. ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I knew about this institution and googled it directly. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Central Election Commision "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Only Parliamentary Election results are published on the website. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.kqz-ks.org/en/home"",""descValue"":""Central Election Commision ""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted submission, not all required data is available. Results available (https://www.kqz-ks.org/en/results-2014) include results for major electoral contests, registered votes and invalid votes, but no information on spoiled ballots. Data is up to date, available in PDF, downloadable at once for each election. Results can be found by municipalities and by polling stations. Historical results findable in the same webpage. Navigation for results is straightforward.
",,"Yes","No","Blina Meta","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"088e1d06-908e-40ec-aba2-31f12f07176d","global","2016-12-23T16:26:49","2016","ch","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Any reproduction requires prior written consent, as per Terms and Conditions of the Federal Authorities. ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Could not find on the national OGD portal, so had to search the FOEN website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal Office for the Environment"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Reviewer: Was not able to found Volatiles as Benzene or Acetaldehyde in the Pollutants given. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.bafu.admin.ch/luft/luftbelastung/blick_zurueck/datenabfrage/index.html?lang=en"",""descValue"":""Data of the National Air Pollution Monitoring Network""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted with corrections. Removed Volatiles from list as no reports on Benzene, Acetaldehyde or any other volatile was found.",,"Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","Ricardo Alanís","65","65"
"8726fa82-60e6-47fd-9a53-385022afadbb","global","2016-12-15T14:16:25","2016","nir","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""JSON"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched www.opendatani.gov.uk "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""All data on www.opendatani.gov.uk is under a UK open government licence - https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/version/2/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs - Air and Environmental Quality Unit"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.opendatani.gov.uk/dataset/ni-air-quality"",""descValue"":""links to NI Air Quality atom feed ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewer:
Some Documentation on the links given on the services 404'ed. Was able to find https://www.airqualityni.co.uk/data/download-data?ds%5Bp%5D%5Bsqid%5D=45041 which holds the data to be Downloaded.",,"Yes","Yes","Open DataNI","Ricardo Alanís","100","100"
"e0aa49e6-bdc4-43bf-9a49-07ad3f50badf","global","2017-03-14T02:06:35","2016","ko","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Reviewer:\nData is not found in the quality needed by the project.\nExample: https://www.ammk-rks.net/?page=1,7,450""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Agjensioni për Mbrojtjen e Mjedisit të Kosovës"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Accepted for data found during research. To be Extended.","Yes","No","Ricardo Alanís","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"ba48ad43-86b7-4a89-8e45-d6c5767ba2a0","global","2017-01-27T14:47:51","2016","nl","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""License not clear: an example can be found at the website of Rotterdam's air quality stations: https://rotterdamopendata.nl/th/dataset/lucht/resource/7a5f8f0c-d45d-401f-8f61-e5a64d9fc4cf""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data will be sent after request. The requested data are validated, yet do not contain the required data elements""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is updated hourly""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Looked for air quality netherlands, replaced search term with \""luchtkwaliteit\"", consulted GODI edition 2015"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerie van Infrastructuur en Milieu"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data available after request. Data only available per single station, not as a compiled list of measurements""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.luchtmeetnet.nl/download"",""descValue"":""Mask to order data for download, leaving email address necessary""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.luchtmeetnet.nl"",""descValue"":""Map that indicates air quality per regions, air quality is ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.luchtmeetnet.nl/tabel?datetime=2017-01-27%2015:00:00"",""descValue"":""A comprehensive list of all air pollutants, hourly updated with exact amounts of pollutants available""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections. ",,"Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Ricardo Alanís","50","50"
"b523aa9d-f025-44bb-8ea0-da5f94034fd6","global","2016-12-26T13:16:29","2016","fr","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""TXT""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Searching for a specific election results can be quite hard using data.gouv.fr's search engine. Using the Etalab url helps a lot but this one is not well enough referenced to be found easily without knowing it ""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I searched \""résultats des élections bureaux de vote\"" on data.gouv.fr then I filtered the tag \""elections\"" and the source ministry of interior obtaining various datasets of different granularities https://www.data.gouv.fr/fr/datasets/?q=élections&organization=534fff91a3a7292c64a77f53&tag=elections Then I found back in last year's OpenData index the list with direct links to all good datasets"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.etalab.gouv.fr/licence-ouverte-open-licence"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data are divided in numerous files, opened with different formats and organized under various data structures. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministère de l'intérieur"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.etalab.gouv.fr/le-ministere-de-linterieur-ouvre-les-donnees-des-resultats-electoraux-par-bureaux-de-vote-depuis-1999"",""descValue"":""List of links to elections results datasets since 1999""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.data.gouv.fr/fr/datasets/elections-legislatives-2012-resultats-par-bureaux-de-vote/"",""descValue"":""Elections législatives 2012 ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.data.gouv.fr/fr/datasets/elections-europeennes-2014-resultats-par-bureaux-de-vote/"",""descValue"":""Elections européennes 2014 ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.data.gouv.fr/fr/datasets/election-presidentielle-2012-resultats-par-bureaux-de-vote-1/"",""descValue"":""Election Presidentielle 2012""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","As submitter states, data are divided in numerous files, opened with different formats and organized under various data structures, although elections législatives 2012, Elections européennes 2014 and Election Presidentielle 2012 are available in TXT format. Format (submitted CSV and XLS) modified for TXT. As submitter notes, data is not easily discoverable. Data at the poll stations level takes multiple searches to be found on data.gouv.fr.
",,"Yes","Yes","Open Knowledge","Paola Mosso","100","100"
"c18323d5-a174-4d91-bf24-28c7f658b09f","global","2017-03-14T01:49:44","2016","si","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""State Election Commission, Republic of Slovenia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission since not all required data is available. Data available (https://www.dvk-rs.si/) include results for major electoral contests, registered votes and invalid votes, but no information on spoiled ballots. Data is up to date. As for 2012 presidential elections results, it is available through PDF format, although it is possible to access the data by district in HTML format (https://www.dvk-rs.si/arhivi/vp2012/udelezba2/udelezba_okraji.html). As for 2014 parliamentary Election results, they are available in XLS and HTML format. Regarding the license, the disclaimer on https://www.dvk-rs.si/index.php/si/pravno-obvestilo asserts that under Slovenian Law these results are not subject to Copyright and so can be reused freely.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"91f3fed7-13de-4b53-a8b8-bf6fd1a1ffa1","global","2017-03-13T22:44:51","2016","my","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Malaysian Meteorological Department (Ministry of Science, Technology and Innovation)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission was accepted but for other reasons than the ones stated in the submitter comment.
Forecast data is provided for precipitation and temperature extremes, but not for wind speed or strength (a list of forecast services can be found at: https://www.met.gov.my/web/metmalaysia/services). Therefore the data is considered not to be entirely published online. The data is also not openly licensed (https://www.met.gov.my/web/metmalaysia/copyrightnotice). It is available in HTML.
Thank you, Hazwany Jamaluddin, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The department provides 7-days of weather forecast; general, states and districts and it is updated on a timely basis. Unfortunately, there are no data found that is downloadable for public use. Data presented strictly for public viewing.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"eff1ced6-8293-40d6-84e7-f945d12c83d2","global","2016-11-10T14:57:17","2016","tw","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""JSON"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: added XLS, data found on National Statistics page ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""search on Taiwan's open data portal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.tw/license#eng"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Directorate General of Budget, Accounting and Statistics of Executive Yuan"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.tw/node/6803"",""descValue"":""Gross Domestic Product""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.tw/node/6637"",""descValue"":""National unemployment""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.tw/node/18681"",""descValue"":""National population""},{""urlValue"":""https://eng.dgbas.gov.tw"",""descValue"":""Directorate General of Budget, Accounting and Statistics of Executive Yuan main site""},{""urlValue"":""https://eng.stat.gov.tw/mp.asp?mp=5"",""descValue"":""National Statistics main page""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added link to main site & national statistics (English)""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you lycurgus kk for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. ",,"Yes","Yes","lycurgus kk","Sophie Lafayette","100","100"
"839a4cab-65d4-4781-8c34-75b7e9c6f759","global","2016-12-23T11:27:51","2016","tz","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: no license, website '© 2017, National Bureau of Statistics'""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: XLS files do exist for some data on main website but not for required datasets.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: data is not updated regularly and is out of date""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to yes, it is possible to find data on GDP, unemployment, and population (initial submission was no, possibly more up to date data is available on request)""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Looked around in Tanzania National Bureau of Statistics and web search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to 1 as data found in multiple tables within PDF documents ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Bureau of Statistics"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.nbs.go.tz/"",""descValue"":""Tanzania National Bureau of Statistics""},{""urlValue"":""https://nbs.go.tz/tnada/index.php/catalog"",""descValue"":""Central Data Catalog""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.nbs.go.tz/nbs/takwimu/na/National_Accounts_of_Tanzania_Mainland_Publication_2015.pdf"",""descValue"":""GDP data (report)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Joachim Mangilima for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Several data portals appear to exist with statistics for Tanzania but there is no clear central location where up to data information is available in usable formats. Amended B2 to yes as data is available without having to register. ",,"Yes","No","Joachim Mangilima","Sophie Lafayette","30","30"
"48e8255a-6edb-4165-9c63-35c0bc404601","global","2017-01-18T04:15:43","2016","bs","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: T&C don't say how data can be used: https://bit.ly/2nxOSL1""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Documents are downloaded as PDFs""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: unemployment yearly, latest 2016; GDP yearly, latest 2015, population yearly (projections)""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""The keywords \""national statistics bahamas\"" lead me to the central government page however the link to national statistics was broken. Following a google result allowed me access the page however it was difficult finding adequate data and there was diffculty downloading existing documents "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to 1 as data requires extraction from PDFs before usable. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Statistics"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended agency title""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Difficulty downloading documents from the national accounts.\nUpdate: added National unemployment""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.bahamas.gov.bs/"",""descValue"":""Department of Statistics""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bahamas.gov.bs/wps/portal/public/key%20statistics/social%20statistics/population%20and%20census/!ut/p/b1/vZTJjqNIFEW_JT-AJJhhyWTGAAMGAxvEZAwYDDaGNF_f7la1SqXuSm9KxFtF6D6duDcGNEZDNO7Tua7Sqb726eXveUwnjgAcz-QInpVkEvA0yTMC5RIKSaNHNAwi-ku-wkqW3eScp57j4GmawBjvHEdqYS08rT6eTSIqn_diPk27ceqsYK5XkcWsIwaTrj1AVyOytKZlLOuh_igi2q_LQI1yscozpU-tkLjpA8NICfkI_RbvbFzM7zc16GAd5ZVeY559fYy7bBeDI9SNmDGF8XhZNNasS-Qy4-3I2SJ25nVhOROyQIRlAZ43EUlkVWnjYVg-Pl5mo5dZ8JvBg--yADvsR_83gjdZvunH359F_I-EAArkeZKFCgVooPl7k98zKm6T4IfgO4vfm8TfCTA0egmY3woCgB7QEJCJ1zwHbW1Xt1mdBQLMgg18bQEzrDbxLf9iW5NgWaarvdZsS7IsL4vAgXE1OJ32ReD6Ai9NX2qBvANiWwOJbYEKILcG0lsDqY2BCtgaiG8N_PPPQkfjOus-l7z7BJ8YRVIkoGkAWI7GAY4GevTkpKu27OT4JEQpkz-Su9HLq1QzmtOOA349IMMe97Bb2bdll_e2unwZ7CyLbKsbR39JqQeAihuYJ-Yg6AdcrnAhCk6W6NClUO37mfMWd68n4S67vdrvEaF3eNrU3k2YinFXJMVdoKZzUWYcSHL13CFdx7--fUu9duWbuNj_ufKuBf0H5snXFbRgtdr--IrLgIWCQfO4ANNfplUw7w3_BRsXwkL9N66uhVb6DshsDLTJrYHY1sCtIyX_fKS_vDGSJUmcxQjA4QxDsSwaNBHNSXdtkTT3NPiTkisRXpzJ6m7wID9eZLktdYTdZ9GXYArO_tDnSA-WXFlra7W9euJM7Y5wYj-ndsvpQ521Y-hdqCHj-ueVlrym0Zv4VrNrPlSXl9dQQijQKiA-H_p70RheYdjnkdGdrsp7bS1TPbbL-TQjVsMqt0tFPqMxMKKrjoR2PLHUqmAjKyRU1YObhsXsGni4Hx7GiJDE-GJLHiOzTKuVIlyOQr6E4tCcDFVG1DiBfrV30KGbDcOkXflk_bfIFPlZ0cdfCID7aw!!/dl4/d5/L2dBISEvZ0FBIS9nQSEh/"",""descValue"":""Population & Census""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bahamas.gov.bs/wps/portal/public/Key%20Statistics/Social%20Statistics/!ut/p/b1/vZTZjqs4FEW_pT4ghQEzPUIgTDEzBHhBIWQAwhQIkHz9pVsltVrdt-rlCp8nW9ta52x5G4uxEIvr45hfj0Pe1Mf7X_uYTmwB2O6eI3lWlCDgacgzAuWQMqSxAxYGEZhFqE471Uu25ai0V1ZqdUug5S3iZ9S3D3c8yEbK52yV1H1qdEdms6FdCaIo07dx2Gn1SeFOdQXQTZWip-7sJ9MzTf25u-haPOzuSj7Mutex6DHKqVEzKZlsSZrpmvry6EvpNvbUw4ZmV_XbcCjM6_7gC88cxmIRH8NdcH2-bQXmKHOPhXEYTsQu5ejaSuDj1lw_liGjZUjwm8WD7zwAO_zr_jeCHz2M_5aQQEY8D1kkU4AGqm_teYtRCBOCL8F3LX7fJIFFi4D5rSAAmIeFACZu8WrVd_l2irc9IYAbqEALAdeNMvEN_24ag2AYe0ddzkxDNAw3jYDHOCoaLlYWOL7Ai8OsZJufgPjaQHJdoAzg2kB6bSC1MlAGawOJtYF_PhYaFudp9Tmdqk_wiVOQgoCmAWA5mgAEFmjRixOb5feW4osQHZnTM-n1WnqLOaPaZdcSjbdpLcLFH-e6PFen2lSmWWdHacuWmn7wpyP1BEh2gv2F8QTNI6QrIUTBxdja9Fm4WvXIuZNjaUm4Sx_L9T4itYo4Frn7EIas22VJ1gvUcMvOKQeSk3KrNlXFf3xghtJU5x_sYv_nybsvQ1QnTzRfQPQnF5Ce4Um4a5i4J0oEkBYLvfPsSZSGimCPOO_Lri2-na3gJyCzMtCEawPxtYFrWwr_vKX_yhhkISRYnAQcwTAUy2JB4dOM2KuTZD2D_a1u40MsqsKVR6GthcH22FZdOWr2ybuMZI1av_fEuM_JVDV5Su0jDsJX6FcP7xk0uzkp-gfaoHl26Ll-alJ7buTgIjRJpDJ-WwlIgUvWNkrK0hBG09kn-1Y3EC3lw3TncVzmX3J5uN_fgjN3JNXhkAhvpl-GUTGFbJ1vqJeiHPL7WyrvWjqRQVXQagzkrGlO2RRbk20TuG9b9HBtufHGM8NhFNgPrK1GfU87yjv8T53lsfqnlnD_ArN9nOo!/dl4/d5/L2dBISEvZ0FBIS9nQSEh/"",""descValue"":""Social Statistics""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bahamas.gov.bs/wps/portal/public/key%20statistics/social%20statistics/labour%20force/!ut/p/b1/vZTZjqpKGIWfpR-ApijmSxBkLmRUuCHIpCCIgqA-_bFPOtnZOWe3NzvUf1WV9eertWrAY3yHx106Hat0PJ679PQ1j5nEEYHjmTwpcJJMAYGhBFakXVKhGHyL78II3qVBmyXZTfpgUg0hOo4uSdemUVGoOgHLDaNeogpGv3UFeyODU7dPUmXr5zy8tqqu3tVH0McFdUAes2-FFmKpcgEyxlyKMxFqfFSspxb6-ZXcJ-f8djxHya4XLmSi9aQziFkLaQ5Ma6NW9ILTI3b1jJ4FEpVKM-GcCfTgpr4mlIc6e8Rc70spumJDOa8oKAsfHy-T0csk-MMQwE8ZgDXx3f-D4E2Gb_rh-zOI_5WQQLEEgeIshQYM0IKNKWxYFdoU-Bb8ZPFnk_CdgMCjl4D9oyAEuI_vAJV49aPXns3TrZ_ObAECWbX12gJhoCYJUHCy0SgiZLraa81GEkLePgI-62rWWG7y0A1EQRrvao69AxJLA8llgQqglgYySwPphYEKWBoIlwb-_Weh4_Fx337OWfsJPgmaoinAMABwPAMBxEM9evDSWZvXclyKUcpmt2QwOvkpHVnNaS49PPtYv4EecS26pmizzlbnu8FN8oprdGMbzCl9A5bihmbJ-qLuQ7mCYhSWaOUwhVhtuon3ZnejJ7v1_vpqHyJSb2FaH72rOOaXdZ7kg0iPh7zY8yDJ1EOLte3Xt4_Uc1u8iYv7nyvv6harAE8KNaIhEGpYHwXN00M24ckMQUjB7EkOiZ5rC8k9GnL_O64Vv1uD9B2QXRhoU0sDiaWBS0dK_f1If3tjFEdRkCNIwEOWpTkOD-uI4aXBqmQNlboz1hn3zG9TJqZ6asjKwakCNGO7ie0u2u0iD92WjU9lKlWWuzldaHG1H6ct9lSheLGdYn70q74x_Ua329rJodP3lr5GooX6vNJOseyTiR2vijH1THPS4xM4Z-PlwDzOCSZfC85uzJBn5SzBoMujEK0ZVa965m6EQDrf7pyYzPFQpDFxi2zFOqjhcWftasmT-q1iGi1WGL5DCKOQVqVwEpAT1tM489xMXHW8byfDMBlXLtF_i0qxXxV9_AO9afkc/dl4/d5/L2dBISEvZ0FBIS9nQSEh/"",""descValue"":""Labour statistics (including unemployment)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bahamas.gov.bs/wps/portal/public/key%20statistics/economics%20statistics/national%20accounts/!ut/p/b1/vZZdr2NQFIZ_y_kBPTa2r0uKVn3bKG6EqlbVR0uL_voxk5NMJpM5vZmwr8i78lgPK1lYhAVYVCfP4pT0RVMn15_3ER3bArCRxpE8K0oQ8DTkGYFyyA2ksT0W-CE9io0-iJITn0NvRDfBHvqLdVI99VJarnGCRXoLVjkCRFv3pHWt6ugFRPYQWlbmVVSw3rrKS-rDqjDpjT2yZF-vUX-4nVQT0rJCucndKu914IIgPjGkz68o5EBUlkNJ9oFYCHGhPPZC1Kdgb-7UEZhNf3QZlyAGG6gn_OpFVLQhvI65PdYpzFqxEwjd7Ouasdm2SdfbudFwbhT84-LBdx6AjH_VfxN44_FNPfH-O0S_IiTY6DwPWX1DARoonqXxFrMlTAi-At-1-H2TxLsAjoVzgPlnwAeYiwUAxugytcqrfDmXlz3oADf0iz6_Aq4aZewZ3tU0esEwNEeZn5mGaBgoDYHLOIre51bmO57Ai_24zVbvgPjSQHJZ4AbApYH00kBqYeAGLA0klgb-_7HYYVGRVp_DofoEnzgFKQhoGgCWowlAYP4unDixUQZZinIhTJjDI-7UWnqJBaPY5a0lGnfVWgTC78e6PFaH2twOo8o-pTVb7tS9NyTUA-gbx9dyxhV2LiGdCCH0c2Nt00fhZNVPDg2OtYsDOb3P5V1I7ioiuRToLvTZTc7irBOo_pwdUw7Eh-25WlUV__GBGdumOr7Rxf79yzP24HoljsoO4D-1gQsyXHnWgnBdTCZcwjXdtclZqdm9hF3fu1-61pJWCOQ7ILMw0IRLA_GlgUsrhf9f6R8zBlkICRYnAUcwDMWymH8JaUbslHkN8-PW6zd0N3bMduRDSX5UvarsFIi4OCD3gq8JtuleaPp5P8HwoZD6KpkA6B5Tr9HaPdk3nNCKt3njsu8kslxturYkup5VZtyKeTiPIyoPybblDglakbt17j3gJDe0bYge4Qt-HO3HKweKKXtYWZ5enmy9Hh1ZnEoU8eg8L5ctuo7nPJZkLvctrSmotlRDimeyg5x6ByOEEe2MlGHxUKKqRqQiW6uIydVxtkszF1HkMM9uWz1VVaMdKTf-PjBZ_T7hxw_vNIok/dl4/d5/L2dBISEvZ0FBIS9nQSEh/"",""descValue"":""National accounts data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added link to labour statistics & national accounts""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Alesha Aris for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Data on unemployment is also available. All data found within PDF reports. Data not up to date. Licensing is unclear. ",,"Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Sophie Lafayette","45","45"
"3536bff8-73e1-43f1-9187-732771074456","global","2017-01-20T01:25:17","2016","tt","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to yes, while not ideal open license, allows for free use & reuse of data""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is downloadable as in XLS or PDF format, while the figures also loads on the website ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Population is update to date as the figure for 2016 is listed. It appears that GDP is up to date as figures for 2016 are apparent. Update: unemployment change is from Q2 2016, although no numbers only percentage change. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""By searching on google \""trinidad and tobago national statistics\"" I was easily connected to Central Statistical Office website https://cso.gov.tt "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://cso.gov.tt/terms-of-use/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is not downloadable. Update: amended to 1, although GDP & population can be downloaded in XLS it is only one file per year, work needs to be done to make usable & potential convert to additional formats. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Central Statistical Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Unemployment link is broken. Update: latest unemployment change can be found in latest indicators section but no specific numbers.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://cso.gov.tt/statistics/"",""descValue"":""Central Statistical Office""},{""urlValue"":""https://cso.gov.tt/data/?productID=31-Population-Mid-Year-Estimates"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://cso.gov.tt/latest-indicators/"",""descValue"":""Latest indicators (including unemployment change)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added links to population & latest indicators. GDP can be found under list from Statistics option in menu.""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Alesha Aris for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Added link to license. Amended usability to 1. Information on unemployment cannot be found, only percentage change (no specific numbers). ",,"Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Sophie Lafayette","85","85"
"f61177bc-53ba-4cfa-9f36-47b8440ce4df","global","2016-12-20T10:40:40","2016","tn","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to no as unclear on how data can be used, initial submission included link: https://www.ins.tn/fr/page-presentation""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""JSON"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: added XLS format, found on the main page, and within data portal data can also be downloaded in XLS, PPT, PDF, JSON, & XML.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to yes, each data set can be downloaded in one file""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: GDP quarterly, latest Q2 2016; unemployment quarterly, latest Q3 2016; population yearly, latest 2016""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Click the right rubric"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.ins.tn/fr/page-presentation"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to 2 as data in various file formats only require some effort to be made usable""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""L'Institut National de la Statistique (INS)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended title of agency ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ins.tn/"",""descValue"":""L'Institut National de la Statistique""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ins.tn/en/front"",""descValue"":""National Institute of statistics (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ins.tn/en/themes/compte-de-la-nation#sub-3667"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ins.tn/en/themes/population#sub-314"",""descValue"":""Population data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Updated: added description, link to English page, link to population, GDP, and unemployment data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Added additional file formats found on main site & data portal. Licensing of data is unclear. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Sophie Lafayette","80","80"
"f2459bb6-05e3-4751-a198-c4604355603e","global","2017-02-03T13:29:51","2016","ua","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is a copyright disclaimer at the bottom of the website, but it is hard to tell whether it is some legacy disclaimer/applies to the data""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: unemployment data as HTML tables not XLS""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""GDP, Unemployment and population are provided on a monthly basis.\n\nReviewers should look for: Registered unemployment in 2016\n\nGDP is provided quartely: Reviewer should check Gross domestic product at current prices\n\nUnfortunately the website does display subpages\n\nPopulation (by estimate) as of September 1, 2016. Average annual populations January–August 20161 \n""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched for official National Statistics Office, then translated website and browsed for information"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to 2 as unemployment data requires work to make usable""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Statistical Office Ukraine"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.ukrstat.gov.ua/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ukrstat.gov.ua"",""descValue"":""Subpage, National Statistics Office, Bulk download for annual GDP ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ukrstat.gov.ua/operativ/menu/menu_e/rp.htm"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ukrstat.gov.ua/operativ/menu/menu_e/ds.htm"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ukrstat.gov.ua/operativ/menu/menu_e/nac_r.htm"",""descValue"":""GDP data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added links to unemployment, population, and GDP data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Danny Lämmerhirt for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Amended B9 to 2 as requires work to make usable. ",,"Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Sophie Lafayette","80","80"
"3cbe8a9d-be18-4ec4-aa4e-7c2bb6d48351","global","2017-03-13T19:32:33","2016","zm","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Water Supply and Sanitation Council"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"f1abaa19-4b66-4d2f-aa4a-8cfd82398f15","global","2017-03-13T19:25:17","2016","zw","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Environment, Water and Climate; and Zimbabwe National Water Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"3d080e75-bdc6-44f3-9bca-af1702067486","global","2017-01-18T06:11:24","2016","bs","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Environment and Housing, Bahamas Environment, Science and Technology (BEST) Commission "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is assumed that this is the responsible agent for the collection of Water Quality Data""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Unable to identify a reputable source for Water Quality data for the Bahamas","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"9b99c3d5-1a49-4ca6-bf3b-2de52daf59ab","global","2016-11-10T15:21:23","2016","tw","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""search on Taiwan's open data portal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.tw/license#eng"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Economic Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Arsenic"",""Fluoride levels"",""Nitrates"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Data per water source"",""Available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.tw/node/6308"",""descValue"":""about the water quality of reservoirs in different place""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Yes","No","lycurgus kk","Nisha Thompson","85","85"
"6aef8efb-9aa2-4610-821e-a702005a237f","global","2016-11-08T16:51:07","2016","gb","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: unemployment updated monthly; population yearly, GDP quarterly""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to the old index, found the resources and started from there. Looked for specific datasets. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/version/3/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Office for National Statistics"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added National to agency title""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ons.gov.uk/employmentandlabourmarket/peoplenotinwork/unemployment#datasets"",""descValue"":""Unemployment""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/grossdomesticproductgdp/timeseries/kb82/qna"",""descValue"":""Revisions to GDP CVM growth %""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/populationandmigration/populationprojections#datasets"",""descValue"":""Population projections""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/populationandmigration/populationestimates"",""descValue"":""Population estimates""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ons.gov.uk/"",""descValue"":""Office for National Statistics""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/grossdomesticproductgdp"",""descValue"":""GDP data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added link to main site, population estimates, GDP data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Oscar Montiel for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. ",,"Yes","Yes","Oscar Montiel","Sophie Lafayette","100","100"
"fd8fd67d-f6cc-48ed-ab5d-3e2044c46def","global","2017-01-16T20:24:25","2016","us","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Very tough to answer.\n\n1. GDP (BEA): No explicit open license policy, but the data are freely available, and BEA has several specific open data commitments that would imply compliance with a general open licensing commitment (https://www.bea.gov/about/policies.htm)\n\n2. Unemployment (BLS) has no stated openness policies.\n\n3. US Census site has the following, \""\nCopyright protection is not available for any work of the United States Government (Title 17 U.S.C., Section 105). Thus you are free to reproduce census materials as you see fit. We would ask, however, that you cite the Census Bureau as the source,\"" but the site doesn't enable you to directly link to the page with that text. Very unclear, therefore, if there is a true, concrete, explicit \""open license.\""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""JSON"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Again, the wording makes it seem like I am supposed to have found one dataset, not 3 unique datasets.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""General question: How should respondents answer this question if some of the 3 data types are up-to-date, but others are not? This question wording still makes it seem like I am looking for one dataset. Again, if I had not spoken with OKF directly, I would not have know I was searching for 3 unique data types.\n\nSpecifics:\n1.Population-- hard to say if up to date, since I'm not sure what exact type of \""population\"" data OKF is referring to. Full release schedule here (as you'll see, only some population data are up-to-date at the year mark: https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/popest/about/schedule.html\n2. Unemployment: Up-to-date, according to: https://www.bls.gov/cps/lfcharacteristics.htm#unemp\n3. Unemployment: Believe it's up to date because data are updated quarterly, but the data don't have a timestamp, so I can't be absolutely sure it's within 3 months (https://www.bea.gov/newsreleases/national/gdp/gdpnewsrelease.htm)""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Again, the wording makes it seem like I am supposed to have found one dataset, not 3 unique datasets.""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""At first, I thought I was supposed to be looking for one central database with all 3 data types (GDP/unemployment/population). Had I not requested help from OKF directly, I wouldn't have understood what, exactly, I was supposed to be evaluating, and would have filled out this survey completely differently. Once I understood I was actually evaluating 3 different data types that could come from 3 unique data sources, it was very easy to find and evaluate the data.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1.) Reviewed Census.gov to look for central dataset that contained all 3 data types (GDP/unemployment/population). Site very hard to navigate, and I made no progress. 2.) Spoke directly with OKF to tell them I didn't understand why I couldn't find the data, and they informed me I had misunderstood the survey tool entirely. 3.) Now understanding what information I was supposed to be providing, I ran 3 quick Google searches to find each data type on their respective official source sites (BEA, BLS, Census)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://ask.census.gov/prweb/PRServletCustom/YACFBFye-rFIz_FoGtyvDRUGg1Uzu5Mn*/!STANDARD"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Again, the wording makes it seem like I am supposed to have found one dataset, not 3 unique datasets.\n\nThis link will not work, but if search the Census site (https://ask.census.gov) for the term \""copyright,\"" you can find the statement.\n\nUpdate: also see https://ask.census.gov/prweb/PRServletCustom/YACFBFye-rFIz_FoGtyvDRUGg1Uzu5Mn*/!STANDARD - 'All U.S. Census Bureau materials, regardless of the media, are entirely in the public domain. There are no user fees, site licenses, or any special agreements etc for the public or private use, and or reuse of any census title. As tax funded product, it's all in the public record.'""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data are sometimes in very clean, usable formats like JSON or CSV, but are sometimes hidden in very messy formats like HTML or even JPEG (see the 3rd quarter BEA GDP data: https://www.bea.gov/newsreleases/national/gdp/gdpnewsrelease.htm)""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""United States Census Bureau; Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA); Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.bea.gov/national/index.htm#gdp"",""descValue"":""GDP""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bls.gov/bls/unemployment.htm"",""descValue"":""National unemployment""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.census.gov/topics/population.html"",""descValue"":""National population""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.census.gov/"",""descValue"":""United States Census Bureau""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added link to main US statistics website, the Census Bureau ""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Katherine Wikrent for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Added additional information to B7.1.","God help us.","Yes","Yes","Katherine Wikrent","Sophie Lafayette","100","100"
"d098ea2e-2c99-496b-9966-334a7b55d9f9","global","2017-01-13T22:58:32","2016","uy","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""DBF"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Population is published on a 5 years basis. Update to no, GDP quarterly, latest Q4 2016; up to date unemployment data difficult to find - latest Household Survey 2010. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search the INE's site"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.agesic.gub.uy/innovaportal/v/161/1/agesic/ley_n%C2%BA_18381.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""See Art. 4""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to 2""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Nacional de Estadísticas"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""ine.gub.uy"",""descValue"":""Instituto Nacional de Estadísticas""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.gub.uy/actividad-empleo-y-desempleo"",""descValue"":""National employment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.es/prensa/pib_tabla_cntr.htm"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.gub.uy/poblacion"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www3.ine.gub.uy:82/Anda4/index.php/catalog"",""descValue"":""Central Data Catalog ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added link to Central Data Catalog ""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. B6 updated to no as up to data unemployment data difficult to find. B9 updated to 2 as data found in multiple documents, requires some work to make usable. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Sophie Lafayette","70","70"
"df49be54-f558-4a76-9f1b-124fbd878aaa","global","2017-01-13T12:04:29","2016","ve","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Algunos datos como exportaciones e importaciones están en línea pero no tienen la opción de descarga. Pasa lo mismo con otros tipos de datos. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""La data se puede descargar cuántas veces se desee, ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Todos los datos publicados por el Instituto Nacional de Estadísticas, a enero de 2017, están desactualizados: algunas están hasta 2010, otras hasta 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014. Ninguna pasa de 2015. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Ingresar a la página oficial del Instituto Nacional de Estadísticas, hacer clic sobre la categoría de datos que estoy buscando (físico, económico, demográfico, etc) y hacer clic sobre la bases de datos que me interesa."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.ine.gov.ve/documentos/INE/BasesLegales/pdf/reglamento.pdf"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""El Instituto Nacional de Estadísticas no cuenta con una licencia abierta o declaración de que los datos son de dominio público. Sin embargo, el Reglamento General de la Ley de la Función Pública de Estadística hace mención sobre las estadísticas oficiales y las estadísticas de interés público, que son las que están disponibles en el sitio web. Hay datos \""secretos\"" por razones de seguridad y defensa del Estado, según señala la normativa (URL adjuntada)""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Nacional de Estadísticas adscrito al Ministerio del Poder Popular para la Planificación"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.gov.ve/"",""descValue"":""Sitio web oficial del Instituto Nacional de Estadísticas, donde se encuentran los datos nacionales en los ámbitos físicos, demográficos, económicos, sociales y ambientales""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.gov.ve/index.php?option=com_content&view=category&id=98&Itemid=51"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.gov.ve/index.php?option=com_content&view=category&id=100&Itemid=59"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.gov.ve/index.php?option=com_content&view=category&id=103&Itemid=40"",""descValue"":""Labour data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added links to population, GDP, labour data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. ","Cada una de las bases de datos clasificados por categoría, sub-categoría o tema, cuenta con una ficha técnico donde la institución explica cómo se obtuvieron los datos, qué variables de evaluación se utilizaron y otras consideraciones para comprender los datos. Sin embargo, el procesamiento de los datos se realiza a gran escala y por lo tanto el esfuerzo humano de revisión es aún mayor. No hay una herramienta que permita seleccionar sólo los datos que quieres ver, clasificados por año y género por ejemplo, el acceso es al archivo XLS completo. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Sophie Lafayette","85","85"
"418a4b25-48e8-4e7f-8260-c8fece04ab07","global","2017-01-17T12:41:46","2016","zw","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: website 'Copyright © 2014. All Rights Reserved.'""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to no as not all data per dataset is found in one file ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: produces quarterly digest of statistics which includes GDP - last population 2012; latest labour survey 2014; GDP quarterly, latest Q3 2016""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I google searched National Statistics Zimbabwe and this source was the first search result."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Updated: amended to no as all data found within PDF - requires extraction (and in some cases compiling from other documents) before use. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Zimbabwe National Statistics Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.zimstat.co.zw/"",""descValue"":""Zimbabwe National Statistics Agency""},{""urlValue"":""https://196.43.99.13/population-census-vital"",""descValue"":""Population reports""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.zimstat.co.zw/employment-statistics-zimbabwe"",""descValue"":""Employment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.zimstat.co.zw/national-accounts-statistics-zimbabwe"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.zimstat.co.zw/quarterly-digest-statistics"",""descValue"":""Quarterly digests of statistics""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added links to quarterly digests, population, unemployment, and GDP data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Tricia Govindasamy for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Amended B6 to no as not all data per dataset is found in one file. Amended B9 to no as requires work to make data useable. ",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Sophie Lafayette","30","30"
"6096e8af-ac28-4516-b690-d748fb307d1b","global","2017-03-13T07:42:46","2016","ke","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Kenya Meteorological Department"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission was altered because the Kenya Meteorological Department does not provide wind forecasts (see for instance here: https://www.meteo.go.ke/pdf/five-day.pdf) Precipitation amount is described verbally (""Showers and thunderstorms over few places""). There is a data request form, but at the time of review it was still broken. It is available here: https://www.meteo.go.ke/index.php?q=datarequest
Thank you, Serah Rono, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The data request form is broken. Data on 5, 7 and 30 day forecast is available, in PDF format. Journals and reports are outdated.
","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"215d1bf1-1cef-44ac-8383-fb73c6f70684","global","2017-03-13T07:38:19","2016","al","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I verified which agency provides public weather services. It turned out that meteorological forecasts are executed by the University of Tirana. Once this was clear I had to browse through the website to find the data in the bulletin."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Hydrometeorological Institute - Polytechnic University of Tirana"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.geo.edu.al/skedaret/1486375492-PARASHIKIMI_METEO_PER_7_DITE_2017.02.06.pdf"",""descValue"":""Forecast for 5 days, including all required data""},{""urlValue"":""https://109.69.1.178:8081/meteo/index.php "",""descValue"":""Data portal (lack of precipitation data or wind direction, only for today and yesterday)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The submission was altered. It referred to Albania's Military Meteorological Service, which does not provide data for public weather services, but for military purposes. Albania's meteorological services are split into different agencies. According to the World Meteorological Organisation, the official agency for weather forecasts is the Hydrometeorological Institute. This institute resides within the Polytechnic University of Tirana - Institute of GeoSciences, Energy, Water and Environment (IGEWE). The Hydrometeorological Institute provides weather forecasts (precipitation, etc.) for public services. The Polytechnic University is a public body, and holds data. Further background can be found at: https://www.wmo.int/cpdb/albania.
The reference dataset for this review is a pdf file containing all required forecast data. The website also provides a dataportal for historical/observation data. It displays temperature extremes, wind speed, and precipitation amount, all per district. Since it does not display all required characteristics, and provides observations, it does not qualify for the review.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","60","60"
"a5c0a933-c16b-47cc-bafe-9a8496530762","global","2016-12-14T12:46:42","2016","si","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The data is in a PDF that can be found . Some can be seen as XLS.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I google searched water quality in the given country. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Environment and Spatial Planning "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Arsenic"",""Fluoride levels"",""Nitrates"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Data per water source"",""Available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.arso.gov.si/en/water/"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Environment and Spatial Planning ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.arso.gov.si/vode/podatki/arhiv/kakovost_arhiv2015.html"",""descValue"":""reports""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Water Quality can be found as a PDF under Reports and Publications. ""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Added the link to the actual reports.","Yes","No","Drenusha Myha","Nisha Thompson","50","50"
"4d53bd22-23cc-4ab7-9372-69ff5075c72d","global","2016-12-05T14:21:03","2016","sk","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Slovak Ministry of Public Health"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","The Department of Hydrology doesn't look at water quality but the Public Health Authority does. Changed the Ministry other points are correct. ","Yes","No","Peter Hanecak","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"5d62e256-0110-4f81-b955-eef9f40550e6","global","2016-12-08T21:38:19","2016","rs","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Lnk from the site of Environmental Protection Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Environmental Protection Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Arsenic"",""Fluoride levels"",""Nitrates"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Data per water source""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://80.93.233.118:8080/apex/f?p=406:2:0::NO:::"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.sepa.gov.rs/index.php?menu=305&id=8020&akcija=showExternal"",""descValue"":""monthly reports on water quality from sources""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Added another link to reports with all the parameters","Yes","No","Aleksandar Ivić","Nisha Thompson","45","45"
"179e9880-dcd4-4df7-99e2-472d0d6a72ca","global","2016-11-10T15:28:55","2016","tw","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""search on Taiwan's open data portal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.tw/license#eng"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Central Weather Bureau"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Precipitation Probability"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.tw/node/9308"",""descValue"":""one week weather forecast""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. Thank you, Lycurgus kk, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","Yes","lycurgus kk","Danny Lämmerhirt","100","100"
"52f1c51e-bcb8-429e-a274-96e061dfb0cc","global","2017-01-27T14:24:48","2016","nl","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Historical data available in txt, metadata available in XML with documentation of dataset purpose. \n\nNo documentation included in the metadata that would explain single data rows ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched for \""meteorological agency netherlands\"", then checked several sub-pages, data centrum has a search mask to find all data elements"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.knmi.nl/copyright"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Temperature and precipitation ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Royal Netherlands Meteorological Institute (KNMI)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Precipitation Probability"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.knmi.nl/datasets/radar_corr_accum_24h/1.0"",""descValue"":""Official KNMI website: Bulk access to 24-hour precipitation accumulations from radar and rain gauges""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.knmi.nl/datasets/Tx1/2?q=temperature"",""descValue"":""temperature - gridded daily maximum temperature in the Netherlands""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.knmi.nl/nederland-nu/weer/verwachtingen"",""descValue"":""KNMI forecast page, containing all relevant forecast data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Historical data available for precipitation\n\n3-hour precipitation available\n\nTemperature available for grids, historical data from 1961 until today , available in bulk.\n\n\n""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. The KNMI provides a large variety of weather information as open data at the KNMI datacentre: https://data.knmi.nl/datasets. These open data include observational data (24h precipitation, near-realtime precipitation updates, evaporation, historical temperature data from 1961 until today , available in bulk). This data is downloadable in xml, has metadata accompanying the underlying calculation models, etc.
However, the datacentre does not provide forecast data for all required characteristics. The submission therefore refers to the minimum available forecast data, accessible at: https://www.knmi.nl/nederland-nu/weer/verwachtingen. This data is available in HTML, cannot be downloaded, but can be reused for any purpose (openly licensed under CC0 license, see: https://www.knmi.nl/copyright). ",,"Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","65","65"
"ecfcf2b7-1007-4a29-9996-7ee824cd9a9d","global","2016-12-27T15:00:05","2016","pl","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I looked up the name of the official website by consulting the WMO registry of meteorological offices. Then searched the website for all required data and had to browse through several sub-pages. Some data is stored on entirely different websites."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Institute of Meteorology and Water Management"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""ICM department of University of Warsaw does the weather forecast and everyone I know are using it."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://icm.edu.pl/web/guest\nhttps://www.meteo.pl/\n\nICM UW is receiving some public donations (https://mojepanstwo.pl/dane/instytucje/195,ministerstwo-nauki-i-szkolnictwa-wyzszego/dziennik/22363) but it's not doing forecast on behalf of the government.""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.pogodynka.pl/udostepnianiedanych/"",""descValue"":""Directory to all data provided online""},{""urlValue"":""https://pogodynka.pl/polska/16dni/warszawa_warszawa"",""descValue"":""Comprehensive weather forecasts ""},{""urlValue"":""https://dane.imgw.pl/"",""descValue"":""Data service, registration needed, data can be retrieved by station and type of information,availability of forecast data could not be verified (data available in CSV)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.imgw.pl/"",""descValue"":""Website of the Institute of Meteorology and Water Management""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission was changed because it referred to an institute affiliated with the University of Warsaw. The main body to provide meteorological data is the Institute of Meteorology and Water Management.
Forecast data is available in HTML on a website. No download is provided for forecast data. Forecast data is ot downloadable at once (only historical data as it seems). This historical data can be downloaded per station.
The data is stored in many different places on the website and it is hard to find all required elements. However, one webpage provides a link list to all data (once this is found, the navigation is easier).
The terms of use seem to comply mostly with the OpenDefinition (see here: https://www.pogodynka.pl/udostepnianiedanych/). Users need to send an application if their intended use cases deviate from the original use cases of the data. This limits the modifiability of the data. Therefore the data is assessed to be not fully openly licensed.
Thank you, Krzysztof Madejski, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Krzysztof Madejski","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"31ff9ee7-595b-4863-9e4f-f369a0c96c22","global","2017-01-24T08:57:06","2016","nz","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Forecasts are available for a cost https://about.metservice.com/our-company/weather-on-your-website/weather-data-packages/""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Based on prior knowledge, visited metservice.com and browsed for About page and open data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""Refer clause 4.3 at https://about.metservice.com/our-company/about-this-site/terms-of-use/ for Open Access Data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Sadly, in their Open Access Data policy MetService have prioritised profitability and efficiency over social responsibility obligations, see https://about.metservice.com/our-company/about-this-site/data-access-policy/""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""MetService (Meteorological Service of New Zealand Limited)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Wind speed, direction and precipitation at https://www.metservice.com/maps-radar/local-observations/local-3-hourly-observations\n(note 3hr observations report rain in last hour, leaving a gap)""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://about.metservice.com/our-company/about-this-site/open-access-data/"",""descValue"":""MetService Open Access Data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.metservice.com/maps-radar/local-observations/local-3-hourly-observations"",""descValue"":""MetService, 3-hourly observations""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.metservice.com/towns-cities/auckland/manukau"",""descValue"":""Meteorological Service of New Zealand Limited, Meteogram containing all relevant forecast data""},{""urlValue"":""https://about.metservice.com/our-company/weather-on-your-website/weather-data-packages/"",""descValue"":""MetService, limited access forecast data, need to be paid, registration needed too""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission was slightly changed. The review refers to the data available at: https://www.metservice.com/towns-cities/auckland/manukau
Downloadable forecast data needs to be paid for, and is only accessible with limitations. Therefore publicly available data was taken as a reference point for the review. This data is available in HTML, shows weather forecast graphs, and is not downloadable.
A note on the official status of MetService. ""MetService is New Zealand’s designated National Meteorological Service with the World Meteorological Organisation. Under contracts with the Crown, MetService is the authorised provider of warnings and other public safety weather services to the people of New Zealand, as well as certified weather information to the aviation industry and all airlines flying into and within New Zealand."" See: https://about.metservice.com/our-company/national-weather-services/
The service provides ""Open Access Observational Data"" at: https://about.metservice.com/our-company/about-this-site/open-access-data/. This data contains observational data which can be used for any purposed as stated here: https://about.metservice.com/our-company/about-this-site/terms-of-use/
Yet, the open license does not apply to weather models (forecasts) which are handled as ""limited access data"".
Forecast data can be retrieved from a data service page: https://about.metservice.com/our-company/weather-on-your-website/weather-data-packages/. This data has to be paid.
Thank you, Jonathan Hunt, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Wind speed, direction and precipitation at https://www.metservice.com/maps-radar/local-observations/local-3-hourly-observations (note 3hr observations report rain in last hour, leaving a gap)
Sadly, in their Open Access Data policy MetService have prioritised profitability and efficiency over social responsibility obligations, see https://about.metservice.com/our-company/about-this-site/data-access-policy/
","Yes","No","Jonathan Hunt","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"f271ba30-9caa-444a-b5fb-ba37b60504a3","global","2017-03-12T11:08:04","2016","fr","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""General Directorate of Public Finance (Direction générale des Finances publiques), under the Ministry of Finance and Public Accounts (Ministère des Finances et des Comptes Publics)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"There are several websites where cadastral information can be found. However, the datasets are not fully compliant with the survey requirements.
https://www.cadastre.gouv.fr/scpc/accueil.do - Ministry of Finance and Public Accounts
https://www.impots.gouv.fr/portal/dgi/public/professionnels.applications?espId=2&pageId=prof_app_edi&sfid=2440 - dedicated website for notaries or surveyors
https://professionnels.ign.fr/bdparcellaire - The National Institute of Geographical and Forest Information (IGN)
https://opendata.montpelliernumerique.fr/Cadastre - Cadastre as open data for city of Montpellier
","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"be5f956e-7687-4975-a5b3-0945a9102aa3","global","2017-01-17T14:36:36","2016","zw","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"f7eafca4-54aa-4a8c-b313-776cd398c1fb","global","2016-12-28T20:03:40","2016","fr","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google search on données + adresse + france"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Partnership between IGN, Groupe La Poste, OpenStreetMap France and Etalab"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Zipcodes"",""Addresses"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Data available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://adresse.data.gouv.fr/download/"",""descValue"":""Data provided by IGN and La Poste""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"OpenStreetMap provides the dataset with an ODBL license but this is not the license recognized by other co-producers IGN and LaPoste which provide the data under specific non open data compliant license.","Yes","No","Open Knowledge","Codrina Maria Ilie","65","65"
"8782231c-ec27-437a-9adf-6e74c9e4440a","global","2017-01-17T14:23:11","2016","zw","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"160c46d8-f689-4259-8c16-69d97c7e88b6","global","2017-03-12T10:21:20","2016","np","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Government of Nepal, Department of Hydrology and Meteorology, Meteorological Forecasting Division"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission was not accepted because the website of the Department of Hydrology and Meteorology (https://www.mfd.gov.np/) only publishes forecast data for the current day online.
There is a data request form available at: https://dhm.gov.np/uploads/forms/952477067Meteorological%20data%20request%20Form.pdf Users need to indicate their use purpose. The ""time period"" field in the form suggests that only observational, historical data can be requested at: https://dhm.gov.np/uploads/forms/952477067Meteorological%20data%20request%20Form.pdf
Thank you, Manish Marahatta, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Following data is provided online: Maximum Temp.(°C), Minimum Temp.(°C), 24 hrs Rainfall(mm), Air Temperature, Relative Humidity, Sunrise, Sunset.
The data cannot be downloaded at once. A client (user) needs to login before he/she can download the pdf formatted dataset. Yet there is no any sign up option for general users.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"62d1fb04-2d0e-4a7b-9724-c7bb204959ec","global","2016-12-28T20:13:40","2016","fr","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google search carte + topographique + france"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Institute for Geographic and Forest Information (Institut National de l'Information Géographique et Forestière, IGN"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://professionnels.ign.fr/bdtopo"",""descValue"":""BD TOPO""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"IGN produces and offers a wide range of map data products from raster data (images) to vector format data or even 3D data. Low detailed maps are available as open data, together with some specific layers such as administrative boundaries. For instance, raster maps are available as open data at 1:100000 scale. However, map with key infrastructure in vector format is not available as open data but can be obtained against a license fee. IGN also give access to some of its data through a Web Map Service (WMS).","Yes","No","Open Knowledge","Codrina Maria Ilie","50","50"
"4360dacd-f6a1-4c53-b969-5deea5f00b03","global","2017-03-12T10:05:16","2016","id","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Indonesian Agency for Meteorological, Climatological and Geophysics"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index","The submission was not accepted because forecast data is not available for wind speed and direction for more than 12 hours ahead (see here: https://www.bmkg.go.id/cuaca/prakiraan-cuaca-bandara.bmkg?s=12)
Forecasts for precipitation and temperature are available at: https://www.bmkg.go.id/cuaca/prakiraan-cuaca-indonesia.bmkg?lang=EN. This data is available in HTML and cannot be downloaded.
There is a data portal available providing data on weather observations, however this data is patchy and does not provide data for every day. See also: https://dataonline.bmkg.go.id/home. A registration is necessary to retrieve the data.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"eae390c4-7b4a-4e9b-ae01-8b753f21932f","global","2016-12-16T04:25:22","2016","sv","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Couldn´t find any reason why not to collect it. But it was not available at all."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","The Next Services","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"96e97c32-e8e9-4771-b04d-8ad17ff34a6a","global","2016-12-08T13:44:04","2016","de","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I knew the name of the agency by heart. I browsed through the website to find forecast data. The link about brought me to the required data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.dwd.de/DE/service/copyright/copyright_node.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Deutscher Wetterdienst"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Only 4 days are forecasted"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.dwd.de/DE/wetter/vorhersage_aktuell/vhs_brd_node.html;jsessionid=FBBA84947E6239D8BCE5342CA847C42C.live11054"",""descValue"":""Deutscher Wetterdienst, Text-based forecasts for today and following 3 days""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission was changed because all required data are available online. 2-day forecasts are published online in text form. Extensive effort would be required to retrieve the core information from the text (which is available as HTML). Especially wind speed and direction are written in ""unstructured"", human-readable text.
Other data is available for a range of research services. There is a service called ""Weste XL"" allowing users to download data of weather observations (see: https://www.dwd.de/DE/leistungen/weste/westexl/weste_xl.html?nn=342632). This service is available as registered user, provides openly licensed data for temperature, precipitation, wind, and other parameters, available in xml. In the future data more data shall be opened, as this article indicates (https://www.heise.de/newsticker/meldung/Amtliche-Wetterdaten-sollen-kostenfrei-nutzbar-werden-3601117.html).
Thank you, Thomas Tursics, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","It's the same problem in the survey as last year. The Deutsche Wetterdienst provide many data as open data but only 4 days in weather forecast. The survey needs 5 days. The result is zero points - but ""no open data"" is the wrong conclusion.","Yes","No","Thomas Tursics","Danny Lämmerhirt","65","65"
"5910b291-cc16-41d4-a7cb-f49ce16f9101","global","2016-12-15T22:29:51","2016","sv","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""In El Salvador zip codes are not use for national purposes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","The Next Services","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"e01ed2a2-445b-4471-b3f4-e08e9a877614","global","2016-12-15T22:18:07","2016","sv","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""WMS""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""I have changed the initial NO, because the segmentation of the download does not imply significant difficulty in putting the data together. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""In google I typed \""mapas nacionales el salvador\"" and the first options was the one from the CNR (Centro Nacional de Registros)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Centro Nacional de Registros (National Center of Registry)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://cloud.cnr.gob.sv/CNRcloud/"",""descValue"":""official geoportal of the Centro Nacional de Registros ""},{""urlValue"":""https://cloud.cnr.gob.sv/ArcGIS/services/SVWGS84/MapOficial/mapserver/WMSServer"",""descValue"":""WMS URL""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Even the national offices express in their website it is completly available, come links dont work and the maps are in SVW and can be consumible by ArcGIS or Esri format. Also, the information is segmented in too many differents links.
The data can´t be use for commercial proposes: ""Cualquier uso no autorizado de los datos para cualquier propósito comercial está en la violación de leyes del derecho de propiedad nacional e internacional y se prohíbe estrictamente"". Any licenses statement as Registered is available, neither open licenses.
","Yes","No","The Next Services","Codrina Maria Ilie","80","80"
"425289f4-91ff-43da-b41a-7928c555e9ab","global","2017-03-12T08:49:04","2016","fi","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""GRIB2"",""WFS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Followed link from Meteorological Institute website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://en.ilmatieteenlaitos.fi/open-data-licence"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ilmatieteen laitos"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://en.ilmatieteenlaitos.fi/open-data-manual"",""descValue"":""Finnish Meteorological Institute, Open Data Manual""},{""urlValue"":""https://en.ilmatieteenlaitos.fi/open-data-manual-forecast-models"",""descValue"":""Finnish Meteorological Institute, Data model for the forecast""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is valid. One change was made: the data is available in bulk. One may choose different time ranges and geographical ranges and download forecasts for multiple regions at once. For example it is possible to get a two-day forecast for Finland in its entirety (see here for further explanations: https://en.ilmatieteenlaitos.fi/open-data-manual-forecast-models). Thank you, Aleksi Knuutila, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","FMI has decided to publish a major part of it's meteorological and oceanographic datasets as Open Data using open standard web service interfaces for geospatial data. This evolving documentation is intended to give a good head start on developing applications using weather and oceanographic data through the FMI's open data web services.","Yes","No","anonymous","Danny Lämmerhirt","85","85"
"db32945c-d0e5-4e1f-b677-0a06adeec407","global","2017-03-12T03:15:11","2016","vc","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Central Water and Sewage Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","The previous submission was rejected because the data was not water quality data. It should be mentioned that the Authority does post other data like climate and rainfall. https://www.cwsasvg.com/wrmu.html","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"0fe2cad4-027d-42a0-8fdc-2eb3b780460d","global","2017-01-25T03:13:39","2016","lc","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Water and Sewage Commission "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Home page: https://nwsc.org.lc/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Unable to find a government based data via online portal for the country ","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"87478b09-4261-41a3-8ea6-3157cd92a1a3","global","2017-01-29T20:40:57","2016","kn","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Environment"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Unfortunately I was unable to identify a government portal for the given datasets.
","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"9922de66-a62d-4b16-80ff-b339e502b69b","global","2017-01-29T11:56:28","2016","ru","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal Service for Supervision of Consumer Rights Protection and Human Welfare"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Russian water pollutants data collected by two Russian federal agencies.
Primary agency is ""Federal Service for Supervision of Consumer Rights Protection and Human Welfare"" (Rospotrebnadzor).
This agency collects data about water and air pollutants but it's network is ""shadowed"". No data available at agency website https://rospotrebnadzor.ru/ (Rus) and it's official open data repository - https://opendata.rospotrebnadzor.ru/
I've visited every website of every facility owned by Rospotrebnadzor but no one provides water quality data as open data or report.
Second agency is Federal Service for Hydrometeorology and Environmental Monitoring of Russia (Roshydromet).
Yearly water surface quality report prepared and published by Institute of Global Climate and Ecology of Roshydromet and Russian Academy of Sciences. It's subsidiary research facility of Roshydromet. Organization website - https://www.igce.ru/ (Rus)
Last report was published for 2015 year https://downloads.igce.ru/publications/obz_gidrobiol_2/og_2015.pdf (Rus)
first report was public and online since 2007 year https://downloads.igce.ru/publications/obz_gidrobiol/og_2007.pdf (Rus)
This report is highly incomplete in terms of open data.
It's dedicated to water surface quality only and has no detailed data by each chemical.
So requirement ""In order to satisfy the minimum requirements for this category, data should be available on level of the following chemicals by water source."" is not matched for this data in Russia.
Disclaimer: I am founder of NGO ""Informational Culture"" and OKI Ambassador in Russia (member of OKI Russia core team). I have no any affilation with Roshydromet or Rospotrebnadzor. ","Yes","No","Ivan Begtin","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"3c6707c8-f71f-4f07-96bc-e0caf6f1905d","global","2016-12-15T20:00:54","2016","pr","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""305(b)/303(d) Integrated Reports for the US federal Clean Water Act (CWA) are in PDF form (not machine readable).""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""305(b)/303(d) Integrated Reports for the US federal Clean Water Act (CWA) are in PDF form (not machine readable) and raw data do not seem to be available on the website.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""A search engine search on the topic leads to the Puerto Rico Environmental Quality Board website. Exploring the various menus leads to the indicated webpage."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Autoridad de Acueductos y Alcantarillados de Puerto Rico and Junta de Calidad Ambiental de Puerto Rico - Puerto Rico Environmental Quality Board"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Arsenic"",""Fluoride levels"",""Nitrates"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Data per water source"",""Available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www2.pr.gov/agencias/jca/areasprogramaticas/EvaluacionPlanificacionEstrategica/Pages/default.aspx"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.acueductospr.com/AMBIENTE/ccr_reports.html"",""descValue"":""search for water quality parameters""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Webpage includes 305(b)/303(d) Integrated Reports to comply with the US federal mandate of the Clean Water Act (CWA).""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Added another source of water quality data","Yes","No","Jacobo Orenstein","Nisha Thompson","30","30"
"ee2fc2e8-d708-4810-b9c5-6e989790a8f8","global","2016-12-10T17:04:24","2016","pt","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No information about license.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""PDF also.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""We have to get the data by county.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Only yearly data is provided.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I had to wander though a number of menus until I found the search interface. Note asy."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""ERSAR - Entidade Reguladora dos Serviços de Águas e Resíduos"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Arsenic"",""Fluoride levels"",""Nitrates"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Data per water source"",""Available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ersar.pt/"",""descValue"":""Main site""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ersar.pt/pt/consumidor/qualidade-da-agua/pesquisa-por-concelho"",""descValue"":""data by county""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Added the website where you search for data. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","50","50"
"be0791c7-c6ef-4b09-8f20-da2b33190228","global","2016-12-20T11:40:28","2016","ph","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Some data is available regarding water districts and services, but no published data for the chemicals.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Local Water Utilities Administration"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"410857b8-91e7-43c8-9740-40f409464187","global","2016-12-06T15:22:02","2016","py","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Public Health, Health Regulatory Entity "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I believe it should be collected but not sure. ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","updated the Ministry in charge of drinking water regulation. Entry was correct that no data is available. ","Yes","No","Lupinupa L","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"63a79e95-f1d4-46d4-a4fa-866d63775270","global","2016-12-19T18:28:22","2016","do","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""La Dirección General de Mensuras Catastratales y el Registro de Títulos"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Miguel Reyes Taveras","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"685f3754-87b1-450e-be0d-1d1e88c6942b","global","2016-12-19T16:33:01","2016","do","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Postal Dominicano"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Los códigos postales de la República Dominicana están publicados en el portal del Instituto Postal Dominicano mediante un mapa de google que delimita las direcciones que comprenden cada código https://inposdom.gob.do/codigo-postal/
","Yes","No","Miguel Reyes Taveras","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"35015dcd-ee9f-439e-9cbb-292e19530c54","global","2016-12-19T15:59:26","2016","do","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Cartográfico Militar"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Miguel Reyes Taveras","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"9bc7a94d-dc2d-4a7c-b45f-14a8042c373d","global","2016-12-17T14:53:46","2016","de","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Don't know.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""searching "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""on local level, not aggregated"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Parcel boundaries (inc. latitude and longitude)"",""Parcel ID"",""Property value (i.e. Price Paid, Property Tax Value)"",""Tenure Type (ie. leasehold, freehold, protected lands, public lands, customary lands)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""according to https://www.cadastraltemplate.org/cadastraltemplate/germany.php""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.grundbuchportal.de/"",""descValue"":""central portal for Germany, redirecting to local portals""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","15","15"
"e6c217ab-62a8-4cf1-bc5f-af23a3ec5c01","global","2016-12-17T14:22:47","2016","de","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Postcodes by Deutsche Post AG, a formal state owned, now private Company. Geo-locations are collected by Landesvermessungsdaten"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"31e96d09-2161-4f31-b471-8a0a4ac61200","global","2016-12-15T18:51:57","2016","de","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX"",""WFS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""+WMS""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""search engine"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.geodatenzentrum.de/geodaten/gdz_rahmen.gdz_div?gdz_spr=deu&gdz_akt_zeile=5&gdz_anz_zeile=0&gdz_user_id=0"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bundesamt Kartographie und Geodäsie"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.geodatenzentrum.de/geodaten/gdz_rahmen.gdz_div?gdz_spr=deu&gdz_akt_zeile=5&gdz_anz_zeile=1&gdz_unt_zeile=1&gdz_user_id=0#dok"",""descValue"":""page describing data avialability ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","Yes","walter palmetshofer","Codrina Maria Ilie","100","100"
"88166ba0-e3e8-430b-8d4f-ab9b6fa67894","global","2017-01-27T13:45:18","2016","gh","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Lands and Natural Resources; specifically Lands Commission "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"8e85d909-d108-441d-9e73-7f6a39198ac8","global","2017-01-27T13:58:45","2016","gh","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Ghana does not use the postcode/zipcode system. It uses House/street names - generally managed by the Municipal Assemblies but that dataset is not online. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Ghana does not use the postcode/zipcode system. It uses House/street names - generally managed by the Municipal Assemblies but that dataset is not online. ","Yes","No","Franka Vaughan","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"1d584049-e0a8-491c-bd1a-4fde52df5c92","global","2017-01-27T14:40:52","2016","gh","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Doing a search on the major government department website could not identify any national map dataset meeting the required specification."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","David Opoku","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"d5c19103-29c6-48e7-a501-1fa199505226","global","2017-03-12T00:18:59","2016","gr","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National cadastre & mapping agency SA"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Kleanthis Koupidis for the contribution.","There is an official geoportal that gives access to a ortophoto mosaic for the entire territory. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"326f32cb-e052-42e1-a949-f42d110f4eb7","global","2017-03-12T00:09:32","2016","gr","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Hellenic Post S.A. (ELTA)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Kleanthis Koupidis for the contribution. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"ef73b9ae-9ca5-4131-9e19-601d01c0766e","global","2016-12-15T14:59:23","2016","gr","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""view service. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I have reviewed the topographic map. There are no indications that that dataset is updated yearly. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""directly from the site"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Institute for the Management of Information Systems (IMIS) \""ATHENA\"" supervised by the General Secretariat for Research and Technology of the Ministry of Education and Religious Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://web.gys.gr/GeoSearch_EN/"",""descValue"":""topographic mosaic (raster) of the Hellenic Military Geographical Service""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Other source of geospatial data (not in reference with this theme): https://geodata.gov.gr/maps/?locale=el ; https://geodata.gov.gr/dataset?groups=location ",,"Yes","No","Kleanthis Koupidis","Codrina Maria Ilie","30","30"
"dcdb1c7a-f8e5-45e8-92dd-e82c23b9044a","global","2017-03-11T23:35:07","2016","gt","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Registro de la Propiedad"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The data is in a database where you pay 1 dollar per consult and you only get access to the scanned images in pdf. Page to get into the Registro de la Propiedad system can be accessed here.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"2e0b313c-6d77-4d27-a027-c6ecd7aed51d","global","2017-03-11T23:25:03","2016","gt","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""El Correo"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""According to the Universal Postal Union.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Daniel Villatoro for the contribution.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"821f10ff-001e-40a2-bb96-7de944ae444a","global","2016-12-12T22:27:00","2016","gt","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""view service ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""view service""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No reference to update activities.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""googled"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Geográfico Nacional"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ign.gob.gt/geoportal/index.html"",""descValue"":""view service""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I have changed the initial submission with an YES for B2 because I found the geoportal of the Instituto Geográfico Nacional with a view service for the data that this survey is looking for. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","30","30"
"689e84e1-e2ea-48a3-bc0e-a22d8153ae20","global","2017-01-23T05:57:37","2016","gy","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Guyana Land and Survey Commission "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The Land and Survey Commission is the responsible agent for the collection and creation of map however we were unable to identify parcel information from the site or any other portal.
https://www.glsc.gov.gy/digital.php","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"418ce575-724e-4fff-adf3-1a2991c8d827","global","2017-01-23T05:30:12","2016","gy","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Guyana Post Office Corporation"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"In Sept 2015 it was reported that the Guyana Post Office Corporation (GPOC) plans to start the process to acquire a ZIP code for Guyana.","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"080701e5-474e-4d80-9d47-1385dfbdc351","global","2017-03-11T22:53:00","2016","gy","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Lands and Surveys Department"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Alesha Aris for the contribution.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"8d026596-edde-49f8-9e4f-ebb47fc8a70b","global","2017-01-27T16:11:49","2016","hk","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Lands Department "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The geoportal indicated in the comments present some cadastral info but not fully compliant with the requirements of the theme","This link [https://www2.iris.gov.hk/eservices/common/selectuser.jsp] allows you to search for the Lands Registry but obviously you need to know what you are searching for.
","Yes","No","Franka Vaughan","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"7313bc39-ba65-4683-88fd-74a6f363cbe0","global","2017-01-27T15:14:21","2016","hk","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Not applicable. I don't think ""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""This dataset is not applicable to Hong Kong. They do not use either postcodes or zipcodes. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Franka Vaughan","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"69a20ccf-f844-4be3-8998-ae6064e0b369","global","2016-11-22T01:10:04","2016","hk","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is GeoTIFF.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Go to Data.Gov.HK"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.hk/en/terms-and-conditions"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Survey and Mapping Office, Lands Department"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.hk/en-data/dataset/hk-landsd-openmap-orthophoto-map-of-hong-kong"",""descValue"":""ortophoto and topographic maps available""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Raster data only""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","80","80"
"94beca9d-afd3-4f23-8c96-403cb640b3c4","global","2017-03-11T21:27:21","2016","id","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Agraria/National Land Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"There is some cadastral information available through the geoportal of the National Land Agency, but it is not compliant with the requirements of the survey. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"1d34fa6f-284c-4ee5-a8ad-ac63c6152e1f","global","2016-12-31T08:09:40","2016","id","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Pos Indonesia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This company is a government own corporation. Link to the official website https://www.posindonesia.co.id/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""The service is run by a private company"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"6b9030fc-0ba8-4678-a37d-7cdc83e8ad1c","global","2016-12-12T14:37:22","2016","id","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""ESRI geodatabase, DXF, DWG and DGN are also available. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""through google search and I already know the existence of the website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Geospatial Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://tanahair.indonesia.go.id/home/"",""descValue"":""The national geospatial portal""},{""urlValue"":""https://portal.ina-sdi.or.id/home/"",""descValue"":""Another national geospatial portal from the same agency""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data for the layers required by this theme must be individually downloaded, making the process cumbersome. ","The data is available in reusable format but it is not intuitive to obtain it through the website. Moreover, they have two similar website to provide public geospatial data. This is also confusing for people","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","65","65"
"0938edc7-74d6-4ca5-8dba-0d48fb071985","global","2016-12-31T21:10:31","2016","ir","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Geological Survey & Mineral Explorations of Iran"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","MohammadHossein Khani","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"ad7b9414-0067-4392-8fd2-a35625c6d68d","global","2016-12-31T20:31:32","2016","ir","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""I.R.I. Post Company"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","MohammadHossein Khani","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"759bbeb1-422d-4647-974c-d2b3b8ed8e2c","global","2016-12-31T20:06:15","2016","ir","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Iran National Cartographic Center"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","MohammadHossein Khani","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"c8ecb78d-ac6f-4c44-a730-1f7dbfd160bc","global","2017-03-11T20:53:26","2016","im","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Infrastructure"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Graeme Jones for the contribution. ","The Department of Infrastructure geoportal offers some cadastral information, but it is not sufficient for this survey. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"49c7111c-7a65-4223-849c-dd80ac02e5ab","global","2016-12-04T21:17:54","2016","im","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""footer notice and link to Open Government Licence but portal states Crown Copyright and department copyright\n""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""view/ discovery/ search service""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""google -- isle of man maps"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Isle of Man Post Office and Department of Infrastructure"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no registration needed, but one must know the address or postcode in order to see the geographical location of the postcode. ""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Zipcodes"",""Addresses"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Data available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.im/maps/"",""descValue"":""Maps""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""postcode search includes link to property on ESRI GIS portal with unique property code but no option to download latitude and longitude\n""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Graeme Jones","Codrina Maria Ilie","30","30"
"c18406a8-105b-4a08-97eb-27d6001dcb18","global","2016-12-04T21:02:40","2016","im","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""portal states Crown Copyright\n\nfooter notice and link references Open Government Licence:\nhttps://www.gov.im/about-this-site/open-government-licence/\n\nacademic non-commercial free downloads are available via eduserve:\nbroken link -- https://www.eduserv.org.uk/lns/agreements/iom\n""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This is a view/search service. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""google -- isle of man maps"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Infrastructure"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""ESRI GIS based system""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.im/maps/"",""descValue"":""Isle of Man Government Maps""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Graeme Jones","Codrina Maria Ilie","45","45"
"295897f3-c022-499a-b620-42b14139ef1c","global","2017-03-11T20:17:28","2016","il","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Israel Land Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"f8ae1ed6-24d2-46f6-9bcb-e78ec5e3a522","global","2017-03-11T20:05:26","2016","il","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Israel Post"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""According to the Universal Postal Union""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"62043f1e-c3b8-4900-ba50-00ff8687da2f","global","2016-12-17T19:26:32","2016","il","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""view service""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""A graphic copy of a map view can be saved and downloaded as PNG. Raw data can not be downloaded at the current site, some is available through data.gov.il.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""...Doesn't say""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched for \""Israel map\"" (Hebrew) on google, it was 2nd result."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""User must user filters on the site and focus on a certain area, and than download and analyse a graphic view.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Survery of Israel (MAPI)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.govmap.gov.il/"",""descValue"":""web site of Survery of Israel (MAPI)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","30","30"
"a06f790a-17a4-48a2-940e-ae2e6a49bd08","global","2016-12-08T21:03:06","2016","it","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""there is a format created for the italian cadastry named \""CXF\""\nThis format is a dialect of DXF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I never had the access"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Agenzia delle Entrate / Catasto"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Parcel boundaries (inc. latitude and longitude)"",""Parcel ID"",""Property value (i.e. Price Paid, Property Tax Value)"",""Tenure Type (ie. leasehold, freehold, protected lands, public lands, customary lands)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://sister.agenziaentrate.gov.it/Main/index.jsp"",""descValue"":""Sister""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I could not access the service because I am not able to create an account as I don't have the necessary info (VAT number). ","The Autonomous Province of Trento and the Autonomus Province of Bolzano opened the cadastry.
This is possibile only because both have the ownership of the data.","Yes","No","Maurizio Napolitano","Codrina Maria Ilie","15","15"
"cc953243-d522-484f-b2d8-1fc4ce44ec41","global","2016-12-08T20:49:20","2016","it","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Poste Italiane"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"the data is available here
https://www.poste-impresa.it/online/pmi/postali/accessori/cap_professional.shtml
To obtain you have to contact the commercial office","Yes","No","Maurizio Napolitano","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"4295c8bd-199e-423d-a32b-83998586aec7","global","2016-12-08T20:39:35","2016","it","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Istituto Geografico Militare"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"there are different agencies with geographical data: ISTAT, Ministero dell'Ambiente (Portale Cartografico Nazionale), alle the italian regions and others.
The italian law assigns the role to manage this kind of data to the Istituto Geografico Militare
https://www.isprambiente.gov.it/files/sgn-legge-68.pdf
","Yes","No","Maurizio Napolitano","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"5c26a1bc-27ce-41b5-a62a-222cdb60bb5e","global","2017-03-11T17:37:32","2016","jm","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Land Agency "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Arianit Dobroshi for the contribution.","There is cadastral information on the official National Land Agency's geoportal, however it is not fully compliant with the survey's requirements. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"873350e0-0114-4d00-9c78-1389e8388cf9","global","2017-01-18T06:43:16","2016","jm","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Jamaica Postal Corporation"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Unable to find a reputable source for a postage database for Jamaica within the government space. However there i information suggesting that a postcode system was to be introduced in Jamaica in 2005, but the project has been suspended indefinitely","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"496d8e17-a687-4dde-99d9-a126eeac6dbb","global","2017-01-16T19:48:41","2016","jm","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""view service""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I have changed the initial YES to NO, because I have checked the application via Internet Archive, thus I am skeptical of keeping regular updates. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Following the National Land Agency website, it was easy to find the iMap application because of prior knowledge, however it is not obvious to a new user"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Land Agency "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The National Borders are clearly outlined, as the user zooms into the map the traffic routes, rivers and landscape become more detailed and clearer. Unable to confirm map scale""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.elandjamaica.gov.jm/eland/jsp/index.jsp"",""descValue"":""view service ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The application was not functional during the review. However, I check using Internet Archive. ",,"Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Codrina Maria Ilie","30","30"
"6c435bd2-c458-428f-aa8c-bd61b4fb867d","global","2017-03-11T12:21:40","2016","jp","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Justice"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Masahiko Shoji for the contribution. "," https://www1.touki.or.jp/gateway.html , but the data is not fully compliant. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"a2e5c5ce-9e44-4a39-a1ad-3350b7468b66","global","2017-03-11T12:14:25","2016","jp","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Japan Post Co.,Lt"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Satoshi IIDA for the contribution. ","There is address information available on the official geoportal. However, the datasat has no coordinates, and thus not compliant with the requirements. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"fc40cbcc-229b-4baa-9ac2-2eb9ce5c586c","global","2017-01-27T14:17:29","2016","ke","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Cannot find a reason stated"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.tikenya.org/index.php/press-releases/361-15-things-you-need-to-know-about-land-administration-ownership-and-tenure-in-kenya""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","https://www.4cmr.group.cam.ac.uk/filecab/redd-law-project/20140821%20BP%20Land%20Tenure%20Classifications%20in%20Kenya.pdf ",,"Yes","No","Sierra Williams","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"5eadd0a4-3abe-4f7f-b28e-bcf6cf5a1119","global","2017-01-27T15:15:40","2016","ke","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Postal Corporation of Kenya"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"There are unofficial sources of this data, https://www.infolinks.co.ke/postal-codes-in-kenya/ and https://kenyanswag.blogspot.com/2013/05/kenya-postal-codes-addresses.html for example, but none of these contain location data (mainly because the postal system here is different and zip codes do not exist)","Yes","No","Serah Rono","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"36f56c2c-4766-40fb-bf76-00c402b3ce0d","global","2017-01-27T14:57:54","2016","ke","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" Ministry of Lands (ardhi.go.ke)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"To date, one still has to buy official boundary maps from Kenya's ministry of lands. There are many unofficial map files available online, with revised boundaries from the outdated provinces and districts format to the more recent counties format.","Yes","No","Serah Rono","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"c9d7e44e-d31c-4160-a745-9ec3ca9d099a","global","2016-11-14T10:50:07","2016","ko","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There is a section in which you ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I looked up previous submissions."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Kosovo Cadastral Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Parcel boundaries (inc. latitude and longitude)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://geoportal.rks-gov.net"",""descValue"":""State Geoportal ""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The cadastral data on the official portal is not fully compliant with the requirements of the Global Open Data Index 2017. ",,"Yes","No","Blina Meta","Codrina Maria Ilie","65","65"
"cb98d391-6191-4776-89f1-11f9bc7d3301","global","2016-12-30T09:15:13","2016","ko","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""This does not include respective geographic coordinates though.""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Post of Kosovo"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Post of Kosovo JSC is a state owned corporation.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Some data is available through the official portal with respect to the requirements of this theme, but it is not fully compliant. ",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"36fd9ad9-d995-484b-b08a-62cf5b2f7630","global","2016-11-14T14:00:35","2016","ko","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is not open format. You can selection parts of it and save them as pictures. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data can be downloaded as a picture. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I looked up "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Kosovo Cadastral Agency "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://geoportal.rks-gov.net"",""descValue"":""State Geoportal""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Blina Meta","Codrina Maria Ilie","45","45"
"12159c9f-f162-475e-bc2a-2cc4d1f6eb86","global","2016-12-14T10:49:07","2016","lv","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""According to the Freedom of Information Law the information that is published by institutions providing state functions can be interpreted as \""generally accessible information\"" that is compatible with Public domain approach. The law does not require for the institutions to publish declarations or licences with the information (they can be provided on voluntary basis).""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It can only be viewed online.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""If there actual owner of the land it is available as a paid service. ""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I knew where the data was."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.vvc.gov.lv/export/sites/default/docs/LRTA/Likumi/Freedom_of_Information_Law.doc"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Valsts zemes dienests"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Parcel boundaries (inc. latitude and longitude)"",""Parcel ID"",""Property value (i.e. Price Paid, Property Tax Value)"",""Tenure Type (ie. leasehold, freehold, protected lands, public lands, customary lands)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.kadastrs.lv/varis#"",""descValue"":""Official data portal - view and discovery service""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.kadastrs.lv"",""descValue"":""information related to what data is available and how""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Must navigate to Maps""}]","Yes","Yes","ok!",,"Yes","No","Toms Ceļmillers","Codrina Maria Ilie","65","65"
"3b50d509-88bb-4673-9529-c743a0f18514","global","2017-03-11T09:43:52","2016","lv","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""State Land Service"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Pēteris Brūns for the contribution. ","There is information related to addresses available online, offered through a view service on the official geoportal [https://www.kadastrs.lv/varis#]. However, it is not compliant with the survey. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"8653f88f-8e72-498d-9cef-97069d8a762f","global","2016-12-13T08:09:02","2016","lv","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""+ referenced GeoTIFF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Some data are update yearly, while some not.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Visited the Latvian Geospatial Information Agency homepage and product service."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""National Maps are maintained by The Latvian Geospatial Information Agency.\nThe Latvian Geospatial Information Agency is the leading institution in the realizing of the national policy in the field of geodesy, catrography and geospatial information. According with the Geospatial Information Law and Regulations the Latvian Geospatial Information Agency one of the tasks is compilation and update of geospatial information basic data.""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Depends from purpose of usage. Often data are splited by nomenclature pages and rtraffic routes, stretches of water are.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Latvian Geospatial Information Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://map.lgia.gov.lv/index.php?lang=2&cPath=4_15"",""descValue"":""Product catalogue""},{""urlValue"":""https://e-pieteikumi.lgia.gov.lv/service/geospatial"",""descValue"":""Data request system""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Apparently there is a WMS service by was done during the period of review.",,"Yes","No","Pēteris Brūns","Codrina Maria Ilie","50","50"
"056946ab-2900-4901-ae12-67dcdf584165","global","2017-01-16T21:50:04","2016","ls","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Lands, Surveys & Physical Planning"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""According to the https://en.nasg.gov.cn/partners/NationalMappingandCadastralAgencies/201502/t20150206_54464.shtml""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"fa80b3ce-bfc0-41bd-9976-dee248efab0b","global","2017-01-16T21:29:52","2016","ls","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"5c49e2af-aa67-4a5b-b240-23658c914408","global","2017-01-16T19:32:36","2016","ls","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""According to the https://en.nasg.gov.cn/partners/NationalMappingandCadastralAgencies/201502/t20150206_54464.shtml""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Lands, Surveys & Physical Planning"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://bgis.sanbi.org/Search?searchterm=lesotho provides Lesotho data in South African dataset.""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"517863a8-7322-45fa-933c-0c02980b14b8","global","2017-03-11T09:03:56","2016","mk","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Agency For Real Estate Cadastre"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","ok","Cadastral information is offered through a view/discovery service on the agency's geoportal [https://gis.katastar.gov.mk/arec]. However, there are no information related to property value. Furthermore, one must know parcel ids in order to obtain data. There is no download option, for fully cadastre data fees must be paid. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"bfa5335b-9d22-4ad2-9e9a-259280d6b468","global","2017-03-11T08:49:34","2016","mk","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is a view service. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""googled "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Real Estate Cadastre Agency of the Republic of Macedonia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://gis.katastar.gov.mk/arec"",""descValue"":""View/ discvoery service for cadastre, but offers to topo mosaic for the entire country.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Arianit Dobroshi for the contribution. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","30","30"
"d419928b-580e-4b11-8a21-6b33a3c282a1","global","2016-11-21T18:10:25","2016","mk","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Postal Agency of Republic of Macedonia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Postal Agency of Republic of Macedonia (https://www.ap.mk/) provides а free and easy to use search option (https://www.ap.mk/mk/griza-korisnici/postenski-kodovi), that lists the postal codes in the country, or lists the exact location (nearest city or village) if the postal code itself is entered. No latitudes or longitudes are provided as data.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"1a8030fa-9a2f-4030-8ee9-0aca62eff501","global","2017-03-11T02:16:54","2016","pa","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""GO to the wikipedia page on Panama water supply where it lists the agencies in charge and under the publicationns and studies section under water you will find the reports. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Autoridad Nacional de los Servicios Públicos, Ministry of the Environment"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Arsenic"",""Fluoride levels"",""Nitrates"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.miambiente.gob.pa/index.php/en/2013-02-20-08-51-24/biblioteca-virtual"",""descValue"":""Reports""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.asep.gob.pa/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=136&Itemid=118"",""descValue"":""Reports""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","The reports are old and not all of them have the tables of data, but the data is there with the parameters. The reports show that the government collects this data for the environment and for drinking water. They could put detailed data up from past years. ","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","30","30"
"ff141fb9-c618-47b6-a1a8-7c5551960dc5","global","2017-03-11T01:57:22","2016","pk","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Environmental Protection Agency and PAKISTAN COUNCIL OF RESEARCH IN WATER RESOURCES"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","The Environmental Protection Agency does have data online here:
https://environment.gov.pk/laboratory/
This data is for Dams covering limited parameters and the data is from 2005. The PCRWR is in charge of water quality measuring but no data is online. ","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"d05dbb65-2212-4244-bb95-cfc129754e3b","global","2017-01-27T16:39:22","2016","om","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Regional Municipalities and Water Resources "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Ministry of Regional Municipalities and Water Resources monitors water sources as can been seen on the website (https://mrmwr.gov.om/new/en/Search.aspx?q=water%20quality). There is data about monitoring station, but no data about water quality. They refer to water quality assessments here https://www.mrmwr.gov.om/Downloads_Files/Water%20Atlas%20E.pdf","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"8289c0de-8497-468b-b8c0-cd6481c427bb","global","2016-12-15T14:37:10","2016","nir","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched on www.opendatani.gov.uk "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""All data on www.opendatani.gov.uk is available under the UK open government licence - https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/version/2/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""NI Water "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Arsenic"",""Fluoride levels"",""Nitrates"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Data per water source"",""Available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.opendatani.gov.uk/dataset/ni-water-customer-tap-authorised-supply-point-results/resource/6de794d9-27d9-4659-b677-92f1492d9dde"",""descValue"":""2014 NI Water - Customer Tap Results""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","Open DataNI","Nisha Thompson","85","85"
"7b457ec6-5543-4da0-a1ac-be52db4e367d","global","2017-02-23T19:38:48","2016","gh","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""There is data for Accra but no data on the country level"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted and confirmed no data is available.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"322d2ec9-cd8d-430a-9048-964c6659dbfe","global","2016-11-23T21:18:58","2016","be","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""GML"",""GeoJSON"",""HTML"",""JSON"",""KML"",""SHP"",""WFS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""google open data irceline github"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Belgian Interregional Environment Agency (IRCEL - CELINE)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://geo.irceline.be/sos/api/v1/"",""descValue"":""REST-api""},{""urlValue"":""https://geo.irceline.be/sos/static/doc/api-doc/"",""descValue"":""documentation REST-api""},{""urlValue"":""https://geo.irceline.be/wms"",""descValue"":""viweing service (WMS)""},{""urlValue"":""https://geo.irceline.be/wfs"",""descValue"":""downloading service (WFS)""},{""urlValue"":""https://github.com/irceline/open_data/"",""descValue"":""documentation open data services""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.irceline.be"",""descValue"":""Website with diverent data viewers""},{""urlValue"":""https://geo.irceline.be/csw"",""descValue"":""Cataloague service (CSW)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections. ",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","100","100"
"4560105b-3dda-4be1-87a2-074ea992b2d6","global","2017-01-23T08:43:42","2016","nz","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON"",""KML"",""SHP"",""WFS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""For a given dataset, click vertical dot icon, choose download, then choose format.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Datasets for river water quality go to 2013, but not more recently.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched on https://data.govt.nz/ for 'water quality' followed links to MfE Data Service, did the same search on MfE Data Service, filtered results by Environmental Reporting > Freshwater > River water quality, Lakes or Groundwater"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This field should be a textarea.""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.mfe.govt.nz/license/attribution-3-0-new-zealand/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Water quality is typically measured in rivers, lakes and drinking supplies by regional councils, then aggregated at national level by Ministry of the Environment""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry for the Environment"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Arsenic"",""Fluoride levels"",""Nitrates"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Data per water source"",""Available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.govt.nz/search?q=water+quality&start=25"",""descValue"":""MfE Data Service""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.govt.nz/dataset/show/668"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Data isn't consistent but is there. ","Yes","No","Jonathan Hunt","Nisha Thompson","85","85"
"bfc156ce-48e2-4540-8e82-a459aeb685cc","global","2017-01-29T18:55:10","2016","bb","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Environmental Protection Department"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections. Confirmed no data available.","Unfortunately I was unable to identify an online government portal for the given datasets.
","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"403b9f07-1a93-4be8-8ec0-a36e554c6a6c","global","2016-12-13T10:20:15","2016","au","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Various sites have different methods""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Each state/territory maintains a different portal and utilises different formats""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""All Australian industrial facilities which meet the reporting criteria are required to submit annual reports of their emissions and transfers of NPI substances in waste. These reports are published on or before 31 March each year for the preceding financial year.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""google search for hourly air quality"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""Where available for download, the data is CC-BY licenced (ACT, QLD, NSW)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.environment.nsw.gov.au/help/copyright-disclaimer.htm\n""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is easy to understand and download""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Hourly air quality recording and reporting is the responsibility of the states. The National Pollutant Inventory collects annual data from businesses"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The National Pollutant Inventory (NPI) is tracking pollution across Australia, and ensuring that the community has access to information about the emission and transfer of toxic substances which may affect them locally.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Reviewer: I was not able to find Benzene or any other VOC hourly reported in the sites described.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.environment.nsw.gov.au/aqms/hourlydata.htm"",""descValue"":""NSW Data (hourly) (downloadable)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.epa.vic.gov.au/our-work/monitoring-the-environment/epa-airwatch/hourly-air-quality-data-table"",""descValue"":""VIC Data (hourly)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ehp.qld.gov.au/cgi-bin/air/xml.php?category=1®ion=ALL"",""descValue"":""QLD Data (hourly) (downloadable)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.epa.sa.gov.au/data_and_publications/air_quality_monitoring"",""descValue"":""SA Data (hourly)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.der.wa.gov.au/your-environment/air/air-quality-index"",""descValue"":""WA Data (hourly)""},{""urlValue"":""https://epa.tas.gov.au/epa/air/monitoring-air-pollution/real-time-air-quality-data-for-tasmania/all-sites-table"",""descValue"":""TAS Data (hourly)""},{""urlValue"":""https://ntepa.webhop.net/NTEPA/Default.ltr.aspx"",""descValue"":""NT Data (hourly)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.data.act.gov.au/Environment/Air-Quality-Monitoring-Live-Data-Table-/rfi5-rh86"",""descValue"":""ACT Data (hourly) (downloadable)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.npi.gov.au/npidata/action/load/browse-search"",""descValue"":""NPI download (downloadable)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""These links are to the human viewable sites (unless the downloadable is readily accessible where available)""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted with slight correction, No VOCs found reported.","There is National Australian coverage of hourly monitoring stations, and live reporting. In addition, industry reports annually on their pollutants.","Yes","No",,"Ricardo Alanís","85","85"
"82be5f58-1f7b-43c9-8a8c-d9fa8716358c","global","2017-01-27T18:24:57","2016","nl","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Regional Public Water Authorities are in charge however the Ministry Infrastructure and Environment does require reports. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""\""Water Authorities are run by a democratically elected management, led by a Chair. The General Board determines the strategy and is responsible for general management. The Executive Committee is responsible for day-to-day operations and implementing the General Board’s decisions.\"" See: https://www.agv.nl/english/?_ga=1.231011871.1454242292.1485540785""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","""Drinking water companies must monitor the quality of the drinking water they provide to ensure that it complies with the quality standards set out in the Drinking Water Decree. They report their results to the Human Environment and Transport Inspectorate (ILT)"" None of these reports are posted on any of the websites. ","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"0ccce0af-73a6-404e-9aab-c6030bef11c8","global","2017-03-11T00:35:51","2016","na","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Namwater Government owned water supplier"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Namwater website refers to its water quality services.
https://www.namwater.com.na/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&layout=edit&id=6
Says you can request water quality assessments. ","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"f93608d6-8b73-4cab-bfca-f6a2479c15b0","global","2017-03-11T00:24:39","2016","mm","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Health and Sports"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","In the health statistics report there is reference to improved drinking water. https://www.mohs.gov.mm/file/Annual%20Public%20Health%20Statistics%20Report%202013.pdf","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"01143f19-0375-4973-b2b6-d5a505b0139b","global","2017-01-19T16:50:07","2016","mz","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"264c45a0-bace-483f-a779-70885c8e1f5c","global","2016-12-15T13:17:01","2016","me","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Institute of Public Health, Montenegro"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""From the 2012 annual report which is the latest accessible from the Institute, it seems that data is being collected on quality of drinking water. This is backed up by the respective regulation which mandates water testing. It is unclear though what it is being tested for and how often. See pg. 76-80 of the report https://www.ijzcg.me/wp-content/uploads/2014/12/Godisnjak-2012.pdf\n\nI have emailed the institute at \tijzcg@ijzcg.me and pr_ijzcg@ijzcg.m and will add a comment if anything comes back ""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"f02752b1-a533-4b3c-a1e7-c32881ace8e3","global","2017-03-10T23:29:11","2016","mw","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Lands, Housing and Urban Development "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"7560103c-5aae-4f02-8355-6f4ece91171a","global","2017-01-17T16:09:12","2016","mw","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"4100a35a-0dc9-4d2f-a376-c0d02c7c1071","global","2017-03-10T23:23:32","2016","mw","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I found no references online. ""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""I found no references online. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Tricia Govindasamy for the contribution.","We have not been able to find any official references for the entity in charge of national cartography for Malawi. There is the Malawi Spatial Data Platform [https://www.masdap.mw/], but this is a platform that offers in a friendly way daily extract from OSM for the country's territory.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"dbd53fe5-e14e-4a6f-80a3-d0cda952d5ba","global","2017-03-10T23:05:45","2016","cz","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Český úřad zeměměřičský a katastrální"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The CUZK geoportal gives a view service on cadastral data, but only parcel boundaries and IDs [https://geoportal.cuzk.cz/geoprohlizec/?lng=EN].","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"d1f2a992-aaae-4b48-acf6-b5044c505976","global","2016-12-04T16:28:17","2016","cz","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is a view service - WMTS, without access to its URL: ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is just a view/discovery service. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google for \""Zabaged\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Český úřad zeměměřičský a katastrální "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://geoportal.cuzk.cz/geoprohlizec/?lng=EN"",""descValue"":""View service of the CUZK geoportal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The CUZK offers a view service - WMTS, without access to its URL. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","45","45"
"374cee98-ad03-4e84-a5bb-a8124c315dd0","global","2017-03-10T22:27:20","2016","hr","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""State Geodetic Administration, Republic of Croati"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Arianit Dobroshi for the contribution.","The State Geodetic Administration is maintaining a geoportal [https://geoportal.dgu.hr/Geoportal DGU] but the data for land information is not compliant with the requirements of the Global Open Data Index: ""The cadastral map is a graphical representation of cadastral data including the following mandatory data: 1. numbers of cadastral parcels, boundaries and other borders of cadastral parcels; 2. boundaries between different uses of cadastral parcel parts, buildings and other structures; 3. house numbers of buildings; and 4. names (fallow land, streets, squares and others names). "". ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"3d274191-a05d-4a13-8c55-5cb992cc36e5","global","2017-03-10T22:05:18","2016","hr","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Hrvatska Posta - Croatian Post"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Arianit Dobroshi for the contribution.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"84104159-6bcb-4b65-a8c7-486654343645","global","2017-01-17T16:05:58","2016","mw","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"5892d48c-60d1-44b0-b30e-b6332bbd937c","global","2016-11-24T15:39:04","2016","br","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""it's public domain.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""i can not download the data.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""i can only get the data from company to company once I've got the unique identifier number (CNPJ). and its not downloadable.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The SRF (IRS equivalent) data is updated monthly.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""To get the information i have to fill a captcha test.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""but i can only access it one by one. If i have the unique identifier i can use the IRS website, which has a captcha, to access available info. SERASA, a non government org sells a companies list info, they must buy the data from Receita (SRF), because it exists, it's not public available.""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""i know how the SRF website works, but i have to have the CNPJ information to get the data. and to get the CNPJ number is hard. There is no official list, i have to look it up on the internet the company's name individually.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled \""companies data\"". i got the IBGE, which has agregate data. i also looked it up for \""suppliers companies brazil\"" to get to the gov. suppliers. i can not get the a list of all the brazilian reistered companies that exists."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://normas.receita.fazenda.gov.br/sijut2consulta/link.action?visao=anotado&idAto=13242"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no clear license. The SRF Normative Ruling states that \""§ 2o Consideram-se de domínio público os dados das pessoas físicas ou jurídicas, que, por força de lei, devam ser submetidos a registro público.\"" which roughly translates to \""it is considered public domain data from legal and natural persons, that, by law must be subjected to public record.\""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""As I dont get to download a public list of registered companies to get the cnpj (unique identifier), it's hard to get the information about each company, let alone a list of it.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Receita Federal and IBGE - Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Receita Federal (SRF) is the national equivalent for the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), and it disposes individual information about companies. The brazilian institute for geography and statistics (IBGE) is a federal government agency and it aggregates data about brazilian companies by sector. ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Results are behind a search mask and captcha code.""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""If i have the unique identifier I can use the SRF website, which has a captcha, to access available info. but i can not have access to a list, the data is available individually. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.receita.fazenda.gov.br/PessoaJuridica/CNPJ/cnpjreva/Cnpjreva_Solicitacao2.asp"",""descValue"":""individual information""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""To look up the individual information at the Receita Federal webpage i need the CNPJ (unique identifier) numbers. I can get those numbers from the gov suppliers list, which is not a complete list of national companies, but a list of companies that are directly involved with the government.""}]","Yes","Yes","While reviewing this submission, I have taken into consideration remarks made by Augusto Herrmann on the Open Knowledge forum. Indeed, while the submitter seems to have been very thoughtful in their response, and has actually found all major official sources of company data in Brazil, each of the different official sources have quite different characteristics. More specifically:
Receita Federal do Brasil
Access to company data in Brazil - on a federal level - is very limited. In order to access data, one needs to know the identification number (CNPJ) of the company. There is no service where people can search for the identification number if they only know the name.
This is the official registry for taxation purposes, and the most reliable national registry of companies in Brazil. As the submitter mentioned, the query on their website only allows you to fetch information in one company at a time and you have to fill a Captcha to get it. Results are given in .HTML format and include Registration Number, Opening date, Business name, Title of establishment, Code and Description of the main economic activity, Code and Description of the secondary economic activities, Code and Description of the legal status, Public place, number, zip code, district, county, e-mail, phone, and registration status. Data cannot be downloaded in bulk and website's data update frequency is not known. One might argue that all company data is in the public domain in Brazil since according to Article 7, III of Law 9.610/1998 (Brazilian copyright law), databases are only copyrightable if their creation has involved a creative step (""criação intelectual""). A registry of companies is just a collection of factual information, so it is in fact not copyrightable.
Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística - IBGE
https://brasilemsintese.ibge.gov.br/servicos/numero-de-empresas-por-segmento-de-servico.html
https://www.sidra.ibge.gov.br/bda/pesquisas/cempre/
Brasil em síntese and the SIDRA system have aggregate data. While this may be useful for some purposes, aggregate data probably don't qualify for the company registry of the GODI, as it should have data on each individual company.
Also, the data is offered as tables in a webpage, and there appears to be no download option.
Ministério do Planejamento, Desenvolvimento e Gestão
https://compras.dados.gov.br/fornecedores/v1/fornecedores.html
https://dados.gov.br/dataset/compras-publicas-do-governo-federal
There is an API call (and corresponding entry on the open data portal), on government suppliers, within the open data API for government procurement, acquisition and contracts.
However, this is incomplete, as it only contains data on companies that have ever supplied goods or services to government, or those who have ever registered as a requirement for any businesses to be allowed to apply for a bid in public tenders.
As an incomplete register of companies, this has not been considered to qualify for this dataset in previous editions of the Index.
Ministério da Transparência, Fiscalização e Controladoria-Geral da União
https://transparencia.gov.br/
Portal da Transparência also offers downloads for the same data of the registry of supplier companies.
This is also incomplete and hasn't been considered to qualify in past editions of the Index.
Juntas comerciais
There is one of these in each of the 26 Brazilian states and federal district. They are the official registry of companies de jure, i.e. when you want to register a new company you go there. Some of them have a query form online that allows for some kind of search in company names, e.g. the one in the State of São Paulo.
In the São Paulo example, the information available on each company is quite detailed, but you can only get one at a time and there is no kind of bulk download available.
Some states require a login in order to search, e.g. states of Minas Gerais and Paraná.
Others require you to fill an inquiry form and wait for a response from some public official, e.g. the state of Mato Grosso.
Still others (e.g. Paraíba) offers to send you a listing of all companies registered in the state for a fee.
Finally, some (e.g. Amapá) do not appear to even offer some basic kind of name discovery service, at least not that can be used by internet.
In conclusion, it seems that the only way of accessing company data is via the Receita Federal do Brasil website but again, these are behind a search mask so one needs to know an entity's unique identifier in order to find it.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","35","35"
"e21ba5e0-f799-4b6d-b968-3e2c2bd991e1","global","2017-01-12T16:05:04","2016","no","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Haven't verified GRIB2 myself, but found that they have it last year.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There are datasets in the GRIB-format which can be downloaded. However, the API is usually used, for what I know.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Looked up data.norge.no. Know the URL for api.met.no by heart."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""For me, working with open data, it's somewhat annoying to have this question be compulsory :)""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.norge.no/data/meteorologisk-institutt/værdata-fra-meteorologisk-institutt"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""CC-BY and NLOD""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This criteria is vaguely defined. Some examples of what constitutes \""extensive\"" and what constitutes \""some\"" etc.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Norwegian Meteorological Institute"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Unsure what is meant with \""Temperature extremes\"" and \""Temperature average\"". Should be covered in the data. See documentation and try one of the Usage samples to inspect XML:\nhttps://api.met.no/weatherapi/locationforecast/1.9/documentation ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.norge.no/data/meteorologisk-institutt/v%C3%A6rdata-fra-meteorologisk-institutt"",""descValue"":""Entry on national open data portal (data.norge.no)""},{""urlValue"":""https://api.met.no/"",""descValue"":""api.met.no""},{""urlValue"":""https://api.met.no/weatherapi/locationforecast/1.9/documentation"",""descValue"":""API documentation for the available forecast data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is valid. Thank you, Livar Bergheimivar, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Would be a very useful feature to be able to populate this form with data from last year, and then review that the entries are still correct.","Yes","Yes","Bergheimivar L","Danny Lämmerhirt","100","100"
"5919bfc7-95e1-471f-858f-21afffe77854","global","2017-03-10T16:22:26","2016","cr","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Registry and Cadastre "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Ignacio Alfaro Marín for the contribution. ","I have rejected the initial submission due to 2 reasons:
1. After making an account on the National Registry and Cadastre site/ https://www.rnpdigital.com/shopping/login.jspx I couldn't find the data that GODI is searching for.
2. Looking on the geoportal Sistema Nacional de Información Territorial (SNIT) I can see that cadastral georeferenced data does not cover the entire country. https://www.snitcr.go.cr/Visor/index?k=Y2FwYTo6SUdOX1JJOjp6b25hX2NhdGFzdHJhZGE=","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"51bf79c1-29e4-4ac4-b969-6a7735b5bdd0","global","2016-12-15T16:42:53","2016","nir","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""JSON"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""A Met Office tutorial indicates the DataPoint service can now be used to download \""a complete list of the forecasts for every location in the UK at each available timestep\"" in either XML or JSON format. I have interpreted that as meaning the whole dataset is downloadable at once. (This obviates the need to revisit last year's debate about whether the separate API on Azure Marketplace really supplies bulk data.)""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Got to Met Office as trusted official source of provided data and search site for 'forecast data'."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/about-us/legal/tandc#Use-of-Crown-Copyright"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Availability of the data only in machine-readable formats via an API imposes a technical learning curve and therefore reduces the general accessibility of the data. Met Office could for example make the data more accessible by publishing a daily CSV extract of the dataset.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""UK Met Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Precipitation Probability"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/datapoint/product/uk-3hourly-site-specific-forecast"",""descValue"":""DataPoint UK 3-hourly site-specific forecast""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. Thank you, Bob Harper, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","A Met Office tutorial indicates the DataPoint service can now be used to download ""a complete list of the forecasts for every location in the UK at each available timestep"" in either XML or JSON format. I have interpreted that as meaning the whole dataset is downloadable at once. (This obviates the need to revisit last year's debate about whether the separate API on Azure Marketplace really supplies bulk data.)
Availability of the data only in machine-readable formats via an API imposes a technical learning curve and therefore reduces the general accessibility of the data. Met Office could for example make the data more accessible by publishing a daily CSV extract of the dataset.","Yes","No","Bob Harper","Danny Lämmerhirt","85","85"
"e5cfc99c-3f80-4a1e-b0c9-18b9e3aa0049","global","2016-12-12T08:58:37","2016","ru","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""official website -> open data section -> open data dataset"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.ru/information-usage"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal tax service"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.nalog.ru/opendata/7707329152-rsmp/"",""descValue"":""Open data section""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The dataset is openly available online and free of charge via the Federal Tax Service website under the Open Data section - Unified Register of small and medium-sized businesses in Zipped .XML format (2.8GB) and downloadable at once. The data are openly licensed and regularly updated.
It may be worth noting that the Federal Tax Service also offers a search feature to look for ""information on the state registration of legal entities and individual entrepreneurs, peasant (farmer) households"" were results include Name of the legal entity, Address (location) of legal entity, BIN, INN, PPC, Date of assignment BIN, winding-up date, and invalidation date in .HTML and .PDF format, however one needs to know the VAT/BIN number of an entity in order to find it and results are behind a captcha:
https://egrul.nalog.ru/#",,"Yes","Yes","Mikhail Parfentev","Evangelia Kampouri","100","100"
"d9f2e617-f155-4a4f-ba6e-423624dcfc5a","global","2017-03-10T16:01:53","2016","cr","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Correos de Costa Rica"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","ok","https://www.correos.go.cr/nosotros/codigopostal/busqueda.html ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"0b173215-42d3-4b60-924c-4f6c6d1fb818","global","2017-01-24T22:54:16","2016","cr","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I have reviewed the raster mosaic of topographic maps 1:50k, available through WMS.. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1. Google: \""national maps Costa Rica\"" (not found) / 2. Google: \""official national maps Costa Rica\"" / Select result number two: Instituto Geográfico Nacional (not found, informative page) / Select number ten: Instituto Geográfico Nacional - SNIT / Menu: \""Visor principal\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Geográfico Nacional"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://geos0.snitcr.go.cr/cgi-bin/web?map=hojas50.map&version=1.1.1&"",""descValue"":""WMS for the topo mosaic""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.snitcr.go.cr/about"",""descValue"":""Website of Sistema Nacional Información Territorial""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We thank Susana Soto for her contribution to the Global Open Data Index. We have reviewed the raster mosaic of topographic maps 1:50k, available through WMS. The reason is given by the completeness of the mosaic, it covers the entire territory, making the dataset compliant with the requirements. ","All credit of this submission goes to Susana Soto. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","30","30"
"3fb4c1ff-b881-4b92-b5e7-5ad96911dfac","global","2016-12-28T19:35:21","2016","fr","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The Sirene and Infogreffe databases are behind a search mask but the Open platform of French public data is openly available. I am basing the submission review on that one as it fulfils all requirements for open data.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google search on registre + entreprise + france"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/eli/loi/2016/10/7/ECFI1524250L/jo/texte"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Law for a digital Republic""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The National Institute of Statistics and Economic Studies (INSEE), National Institute of Industrial Property (INPI) and the Commercial Courts regrouped under Infogreffe, all collect or manage company data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.sirene.fr/sirene/public/accueil"",""descValue"":""Sirene database""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.infogreffe.fr/societes"",""descValue"":"" Infogreffe database""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.data.gouv.fr/fr/datasets/base-sirene-des-entreprises-et-de-leurs-etablissements-siren-siret/"",""descValue"":""Open platform of French public data - Entire Sirene database download""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
Company data are available online and free of charge on both the Register of Commerce and the National Institute of Statistics and Economic Studies websites. However, in both cases data are available through a search mask, in .HTML format, and cannot be downloaded in bulk. On the Register of Commerce (Infogreffe) website, search results include Company name, Address, SIREN/SIRET numbers (unique French business identification numbers), Number of establishments, and Activity. One then has the option of purchasing information such as official documents.
On the National Institute of Statistics and Economic Studies (INSEE) - Company search (Sirene) feature, one can look for company information by searching an entity's SIREN/SIRET number. Company name, SIRET number, Main activity held, Workforce, and Shelf Validity Year are included in the results.
However, like the submitter has mentioned, as of January 2017, one can download the Sirene database for free on the Open platform of French public data as data are opened under the law for a digital Republic. One can download the complete Sirene dissemination base of active institutions on the last day of the previous month, the daily update files for the current month, and monthly updates file for the previous month (Source: https://www.sirene.fr/sirene/public/static/acces-donnees). Each compressed file (ZIP format) contains a data file in .CSV format. Files contain variables of identification, address, geographical location and economic data on companies and establishments. They do not contain certain information (telephone numbers, e-mail and website addresses, names of executives, legal elements, balance sheets, geolocalized data). The dataset can be downloaded in bulk, is updated monthly, applies for the whole of France, and is openly licensed (under the law for a digital Republic).","INSEE manages a company register (SIRENE) which also includes non-for-profit entities. Access and reuse of the database is possible against charging fees. Infogreffe also manages company data collected through commercial courts. Some data can be viewed online, but reuse of the whole database is also subject to fees. It is however expected that this dataset will be made available as open data in 2017 as announced by the Minister in charge of Digital Economy.
Lastly, according to a 2015 law on Economy and Growth, company data collected by commercial courts shall now be transferred to INPI and managed through a Central Company Register (RNCS) and released as open data. However, the release of RNCS data has still to be done and there is evidence that the database is still sold to third party. In the meantime, Infogreffe has launched its own open data catalog but does not provide the full register of companies, only secondary data on the activity of Infogreffe.","Yes","Yes","Open Knowledge","Evangelia Kampouri","100","100"
"a2453508-7867-427e-b634-8d36d32497f6","global","2017-01-16T21:23:43","2016","ls","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"ac8aaeb6-da4c-4e70-b334-0eeaf4e0a1a2","global","2017-02-02T20:57:57","2016","dk","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""No license information on https://download.aws.dk/ but on can be found at https://download.kortforsyningen.dk/content/vilk%C3%A5r-og-betingelser (for a similar but not exact same) dataset""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""GeoJSON"",""JSON""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Had to ask on twitter - wasn't aware it had become part of the DAGI-dataset and didn't find it obvious""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Asked out on twitter and googled"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://download.kortforsyningen.dk/content/vilk%C3%A5r-og-betingelser"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""NOTE: No license information on https://download.aws.dk/ but on can be found at https://download.kortforsyningen.dk/content/vilk%C3%A5r-og-betingelser (for a similar but not exact same) dataset""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Rather easy, but a lot of data...""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Styrelsen for Dataforsyning og Effektivisering"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Zipcodes"",""Addresses"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Data available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://download.aws.dk/adresser"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://download.kortforsyningen.dk/content/danmarks-administrative-geografiske-inddeling-110000"",""descValue"":""Areas as polygons""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","ok",,"Yes","Yes","Niels Erik Kaaber Rasmussen","Codrina Maria Ilie","100","100"
"d5dbb8c4-e4d0-4d65-8ef0-868cece44e5e","global","2017-02-02T19:52:26","2016","dk","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Default is GDB-format. Detailed format information: https://kortforsyningen.dk/sites/default/files/formatoversigt_friedata_04_maj_2015.pdf""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There are many types of maps, each can be downloaded at once covering the full country""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""You need to register to download. The process is automated""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I knew beforehand where it was""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Typed in the URL"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://download.kortforsyningen.dk/content/vilk%C3%A5r-og-betingelser"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Formats are an issue dealing with geo-data""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Styrelsen for Dataforsyning og Effektivisering"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Don't know the English name?""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://download.kortforsyningen.dk/content/danmark-11000000-vektor"",""descValue"":""Generel map""},{""urlValue"":""https://download.kortforsyningen.dk/content/geodataprodukter"",""descValue"":""Different types of maps""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","ok",,"Yes","No","Niels Erik Kaaber Rasmussen","Codrina Maria Ilie","85","85"
"f839d627-fc4c-4961-97fc-7109014cbd54","global","2016-12-14T10:40:56","2016","lv","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""According to the Freedom of Information Law the information that is published by institutions providing state functions can be interpreted as \""generally accessible information\"" that is compatible with Public domain approach. The law does not require for the institutions to publish declarations or licences with the information (they can be provided on voluntary basis).""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Yes, but it's not a dataset, it's a yearly review in a PDF format.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The review is published once a year.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I knew where the data was."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.vvc.gov.lv/export/sites/default/docs/LRTA/Likumi/Freedom_of_Information_Law.doc"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Latvijas Vides, ģeoloģijas un meteoroloģijas centrs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Arsenic"",""Fluoride levels"",""Nitrates"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.meteo.lv/lapas/vide/udens/udens-kvalitate/udens-kvalitate?id=1100&nid=433"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","In regards to B3: These characteristics are in the published documentsm. For example:
Page
91
https://www.meteo.lv/fs/CKFinderJava/userfiles/files/Vide/Udens/stat_apkopojumi/udens_kvalit/VPUK_parskats_2015.pdf ","Yes","No","Toms Ceļmillers","Nisha Thompson","50","50"
"04a26a80-5e20-437f-82ce-5dc503400006","global","2016-12-05T13:02:16","2016","jp","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""TXT"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled for the data and found the data in the first search result. But I can get new data only in Japanese."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.env.go.jp/mail.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I am sorry that this license is only in Japanese.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Environment"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Arsenic"",""Fluoride levels"",""Nitrates"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.data.go.jp/data/en/organization/org_2000?q=%E6%B0%B4%E8%B3%AA"",""descValue"":""Japanese site""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.env.go.jp/en/water/index.html"",""descValue"":""English site""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.env.go.jp/doc/toukei/contents/index.html#5shou"",""descValue"":""Japanese site""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","There isn't a lot of water quality data but reports and references to water quality of environmental sources. Drinking water is decentralized and there doesn't seem to be a strong central management of water quality.","Yes","No","Kentaro Hatori","Nisha Thompson","85","85"
"8428d3cd-9b17-4ce3-83fd-701d870be8d9","global","2017-01-19T08:38:44","2016","pk","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched on Google"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Pakistan Meteorological Department"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.pmd.gov.pk"",""descValue"":""Pakistan Meteorological Department""},{""urlValue"":""https://nwfc.pmd.gov.pk/WeeklyWeather/NWWO.html"",""descValue"":""Synopsis of 7-day weather report""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.pmd.gov.pk/meteorogram/islamabad.php?district=Islamabad&division=Islamabad"",""descValue"":""Meteograms for cities available""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. The data is available online in different formats (such as text descriptions, or meteograms) but cannot be downloaded. There is no open license attributed, and no terms of use could be found that would state that the data is in public domain.
Thank you, Nouman Nazim, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Nouman Nazim","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"9b18fea9-35ad-4974-bbf5-adee24952a80","global","2017-03-10T07:10:26","2016","jm","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Environment and Planning Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","THere are reports about water quality here but no data or reference to data being available. ","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"2a27508b-d011-4400-8ab0-fac5ac784286","global","2017-01-31T18:27:22","2016","it","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto superiore per la Protezione e la Ricerca Ambientale"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","There are reports available for the water quality but no actual data. There is an outdated dataset based on 2015 submission here https://cdr.eionet.europa.eu/it/eu/uwwt/envt1ogcg","Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"6309960c-bbdc-4b32-8657-9994de6ba236","global","2016-12-10T12:18:48","2016","pt","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Looked for \""metereologia Portugal\"" on google"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Português do Mar e da Atmosfera"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ipma.pt/pt/index.html"",""descValue"":""Flash-based forecast map containing all required forecast characteristics""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. The data is not openly licensed as it is stated at this URL: https://www.ipma.pt/en/siteinfo/index.html?page=index.xml
""The contents of this site are protected by the Right of Intellectual Property and Connected Rights of Industrial Property under the Law of Portugal and of the European Union and other international conventions, and cannot be used except under the conditions admitted in this site. The User can freely copy, import or use information or national symbols in this site for personal or public use, provided that for no purposes of profit or offence.""
Thank you, Tiago Vieira, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The website is available in english but most descriptions and titles are still in Portuguese. The format of the information is not completely clear","Yes","No","Tiago Vieira","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"297fbb64-94a7-4954-87e0-027c48a6041d","global","2016-12-12T12:38:26","2016","ru","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""through official website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.meteorf.ru/opendata/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Federal Service for Hydrometeorology"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Precipitation Probability"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.meteorf.ru/opendata/"",""descValue"":""open data section (not available)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.meteorf.ru/product/weather/"",""descValue"":""7-day forecast displaying all required characteristics on one page""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission was changed. The open data it referred to is currently not available. Also the meteorological data is not openly licensed (there is a statement on https://www.meteorf.ru/opendata/ that the data can be re-used for any lawful purpose, however it appears that this license only applies to the data published at this same URL.
Thank you, Mikhail Parfentev, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Mikhail Parfentev","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"e24e420f-566b-4259-9e29-4fd610f7f37b","global","2016-12-15T20:48:35","2016","pr","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Unsure.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Unsure.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Unsure.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I used a readily available Internet search engine."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.nws.noaa.gov/disclaimer.php"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Unsure.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Weather Service of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Precipitation Probability"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.weather.gov/"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.nws.noaa.gov/ndfd/technical.htm"",""descValue"":""Webpage allowing to download data in XML and GRIB2 format""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","A note on the license: ""World Meteorological Organization (WMO) Resolution 40 NOAA Policy NCEI data and products that contain international data may have conditions placed on their international commercial use. They can be used within the United States or for noncommercial international activities without restriction. Redistribution of these data by others must provide this same notification. The non-U.S. data cannot be redistributed for commercial purposes. For details, please consult the WMO policy (link is external)."" See further information at: https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/customer-support
The submission was changed and refers to following URL: https://www.nws.noaa.gov/ndfd/technical.htm. As stated in this page, the U.S. National Weather Service provides all required data for Puerto Rico: https://www.nws.noaa.gov/ndfd/resources/NDFD_element_status.pdf
Thank you, Jacobo Orenstein, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","Yes","Jacobo Orenstein","Danny Lämmerhirt","100","100"
"c60c2e9a-f7b4-40ac-b4db-1d1b6bacbb38","global","2016-12-11T10:15:30","2016","ro","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":"" Copying and complete or partial reproduction, archiving or storage, by any means, including electronic, magnetic or computerized information from the site without written permission of the copyright holder is prohibited. \n\nSee Section 4 Restrictions here https://www.meteoromania.ro/anm2/link-uri/conditii-de-utilizare/""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""ANM 10-day forecast in some HTML.\n\nMeteograms (complete data product) in Javascript. \n\nPartial data in XML/RSS.\n\n\n\n""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried an online search engine for \""Meteorological Institute Romania\"". ANM is one of the results. I also looked at the links provided in 2015 GODI which led me to the older website and other products."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Administration for Meteorology (ANM)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The product including all this data is Meteograms which cover regions. Meteograms are not machine readable however. \n\nRSS 5 -day forecast includes only limited indicators.\n\n""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://vremea.meteoromania.ro/prognoza_extinsa/12"",""descValue"":""ANM 10-day forecast""},{""urlValue"":""https://vremea.meteoromania.ro/meteograma/311"",""descValue"":""Meteograms""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.meteoromania.ro/anm/prognoza-orase-xml.php"",""descValue"":""RSS 5 -day forecast (limited indicators)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. Thank you Arianit Dobroshi, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The product including all this data is Meteograms which cover regions. Meteograms are not machine readable however. RSS 5 -day forecast includes only limited indicators. Meteograms (complete data product) are published in Javascript. More partial data are published in XML/RSS.
Data is not openly licensed: Copying and complete or partial reproduction, archiving or storage, by any means, including electronic, magnetic or computerized information from the site without written permission of the copyright holder is prohibited.
See Section 4 Restrictions here https://www.meteoromania.ro/anm2/link-uri/conditii-de-utilizare/
","Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"552794b9-2ede-4c53-ab79-e86710e636e0","global","2017-01-24T22:29:52","2016","lc","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is not easily downloadable, However can be captured via copy ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""By searching the keywords \""weather forecast st lucia\"" in Gooogle I was easily connected to the St Lucia Met services website. From there the tab 5 day forecast is readily visible "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is easily understandable for a 5 day forecast. There appears to be a seasonal tab however the feature is not yet available""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""St Lucia Met Service "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Homepage: https://slumet.gov.lc/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://slumet.gov.lc/5-day-weather-forecast/"",""descValue"":""5 Day Forecast ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission was corrected. The data is available for free, but cannot be downloaded. There is no indication of terms of use, hence the data is considered not to be openly licensed. Thank you, Alesha Aris, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The data is easily understandable for a 5 day forecast. There appears to be a seasonal forecast however the corresponding webpage is not yet available.","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"0bb246b7-9e4c-455d-95cf-94d47b5274ba","global","2017-01-25T04:59:32","2016","vc","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Caribbean Meteorological Organisation"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","A database of the World Meteorological Organisation states that the Caribbean Meteorological Organisation (CMO) is responsible for monitoring weather. An official statement can also be found at: https://www.cmo.org.tt/members.html. However, no forecast data could be found online that are provided by the CMO.
Thank you, Alesha Aris, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The responsible organisations appear to be the Meteorological Office or National Emergency Management Office (NEMO) however I was unable to identify a government portal for the given datasets. ","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"7b49411a-703a-4999-868b-d067fc523d1e","global","2016-12-16T07:56:06","2016","sg","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""JSON""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Users need to register on the Data.gov.sg Developer Portal for an API key to access the data. \n\nRegistration is free and users gain immediate access after registration. ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search for \""Singapore weather forecast data\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.sg/open-data-licence"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Environment Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Access to data is granted immediately after registration. ""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Precipitation Probability"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.sg/dataset/weather-forecast"",""descValue"":""Weather Forecast (2-hour, 24-hour and 4-day)""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.sg/dataset/realtime-weather-readings"",""descValue"":""Realtime Weather Readings (Air temperature, humidity, rainfall and wind conditions)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. Thank you, Zhaowei Lin, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","There are APIs not just for forecasts but readings of temperature, humidity, precipitation and wind conditions in near-realtime. The high-frequency readings are arguably more useful than forecasts, for users who are trying to analyse weather patterns.
Users need to register on the Data.gov.sg Developer Portal for an API key to access the data.
Registration is free and users gain immediate access after registration. ","Yes","No","Zhaowei Lin","Danny Lämmerhirt","85","85"
"8eb72791-bedf-44e4-a4db-3a7afc4f0e03","global","2016-12-05T14:40:46","2016","sk","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Portal is quite well known."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Slovak Hydrometeorological Institute"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Precipitation Probability"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.shmu.sk/sk/?page=1&id=meteo_num_mgram10&nwp_mesto=32737"",""descValue"":""SHMU Portal""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.shmu.sk/en/?page=1&id=meteo_gpredpoved_sk"",""descValue"":""Forecast map""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.shmu.sk/en/?page=1&id=meteo_num_mgram&nwp_mesto=32737"",""descValue"":""Meteogram (numerical data)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.shmu.sk/en/?page=1&id=meteo_num_alad"",""descValue"":""Textual output of meteogram""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. Note on licensing:
""All the information, texts and images contained on the https://www.shmu.sk website are intellectual property of the Slovak hydrometeorological institute (SHMÚ) and may be downloaded or copied only for personal use. Appropriate acknowledgement of the SHMÚ is required if material is re-published in any format. SHMÚ disclaims responsibility for quality of meteorological and hydrological information from any other source than SHMÚ.""
Thank you Peter Hanecak, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Basic forecasts for Slovak regions is available in textual form for next two days. More detailed forecasts are available through so-called ALADIN model for many Slovak cities either for next 3 or next 10 days with data required by Census available (except average temperature) in the form of an image with several graphs.
Note: 3-day forecast provides temperature extremes, 10-day forecast does not.","Yes","No","Peter Hanecak","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"c91c27c5-0534-46ac-825e-63a8a0ef8dfe","global","2016-12-03T18:26:50","2016","si","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Re-use Conditions\n\nInformation, presented on the website meteo.arso.gov.si, is public and can be re-used in accordance with the Regulation on Transaction and Re-use of\nPublic Sector Information (ul. RS No: 76 dated 12. August 2005).\nArticle 26 of above mentioned Regulation demands the proper announcement of the information source: »Slovene Public Information«, ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried a web search engine for meteorological forecast Slovenia. Clicked on XML/RSS/HTML Service"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://meteo.arso.gov.si/met/en/about/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Meteorological Service of Slovenia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://meteo.arso.gov.si/met/en/service/"",""descValue"":""National Meteorological Service of Slovenia""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. The data is downloadable at once for several regions at this address: https://meteo.arso.gov.si/uploads/probase/www/fproduct/text/en/fcast_si-region_latest.xml.
Thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Re-use Conditions
Information, presented on the website meteo.arso.gov.si, is public and can be re-used in accordance with the Regulation on Transaction and Re-use of
Public Sector Information (ul. RS No: 76 dated 12. August 2005).
Article 26 of above mentioned Regulation demands the proper announcement of the information source: »Slovene Public Information«, ","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Danny Lämmerhirt","100","100"
"6fe2c985-58f0-49f9-8201-bf35203eb136","global","2016-12-31T21:09:06","2016","ir","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Energy"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","MohammadHossein Khani","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"6706f4a5-7e96-4d50-acf8-ad6ec59289fd","global","2016-12-31T08:19:54","2016","id","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Water Supply and Environmental Sanitation Working Group (Pokja AMPL)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The official website https://www.ampl.or.id/about/pokja-ampl-nasional/34""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Couldn't find any data or reference to data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"d04294ac-2829-444e-8cfd-9b8cc9769847","global","2017-03-10T03:12:31","2016","hk","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google drinking water quality in Hong Kong, come up with links to both sites have to search sites for water quality tab, not 100% clear where the data is. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Water Supplies Department and Environmental Protection Depatment"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Arsenic"",""Fluoride levels"",""Nitrates"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Data per water source"",""Available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://epic.epd.gov.hk/EPICRIVER/river/display/search/"",""descValue"":""Environmental water quality monitoring""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.wsd.gov.hk/en/water_resources/water_quality/water_quality_monitoring_data/index.html"",""descValue"":""Drinking water quality monitoring""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Drinking water quality hasn't been updated since Sept 2016 and is in PDF but not the data itself just whether the water met the WHO standards. Environmental water quality data is at source and also gives a list of the parameters but not updated since 2015","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","30","30"
"d0487e9b-7248-4a3c-a98b-893c155730ac","global","2017-01-22T18:41:49","2016","gy","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Natural Resources and the Environment, Environmental Protection Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Unable to find data online by a government agency with respect of the survey's criteria","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"931de7df-52d5-4c7c-aba1-623ec502cb6e","global","2017-03-10T02:35:42","2016","gt","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Ministry of Public Health and Social Assistance (MSPASA)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"fe55d9e1-03b2-41c6-a0cf-c83528d45aea","global","2016-12-15T14:42:26","2016","gr","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Direclty from the site of the Ministry"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Health"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Arsenic"",""Fluoride levels"",""Nitrates"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Data per water source"",""Available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.moh.gov.gr/articles/health/dieythynsh-dhmosias-ygieinhs/ygieinh-periballontos/prostasia-poiothtas-ydatwn/prostasia-neroy-anthrwpinhs-katanalwshs/1317-ekthesh-trietias-2008-2010-gia-thn-poiothta-toy-posimoy-neroy-se-perioxes-poy-eksyphretoyn-perissoteroys-apo-5000-katoikoys-symfwna-me-stoixeia-twn-ypeythynwn-ydreyshs-o-t-a-d-e-y-a-k-lp"",""descValue"":""Water Quality Protection, Human Consumption""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","For Bathing Water Until 2013 the data published on the website geodata.gov.gr https://geodata.gov.gr/geodata/index.php?option=com_sobi2&sobi2Task=sobi2Details&catid=30&sobi2Id=237&Itemid=
Also there are some data for 2014 but not public available in https://cdr.eionet.europa.eu/gr/eu/nbwd/envvjao5w/
For Drinking Water There are some data for 2013 in https://cdr.eionet.europa.eu/gr/eu/dwd/","Yes","No","Kleanthis Koupidis","Nisha Thompson","65","65"
"8066b63d-ca85-4884-95e5-c134a789ee57","global","2017-01-24T09:07:09","2016","gh","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ghana Water Company and the Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I first communicated with Ghana Water Company through whatsapp when i did not find anything on their website. They directed to CSIR. According to the Ghana Water Company, CSIR is in charge of collecting such data. I searched the website of CSIR but no datasets, i sent emails to all address provided on their website but no one got back to me after 4 days. ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"dd59a45f-c2fd-4995-bf6a-1e505d3e6416","global","2016-12-17T14:34:10","2016","de","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Umwelt Bundesamt"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","data is collected, sometimes available on local level","Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"e0f47997-bc13-4ae3-a2dd-913eb13828d3","global","2016-12-28T00:37:41","2016","fr","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Drinking water in HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Global data is updated 4 times a year only. Drinking water data updated 2 weeks ago""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched for \""pollution\"" on data.gouv.fr but only found individual datasets from some and not all regions, then looked on the Ministry of Environement "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.stats.environnement.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/Eider/mentions-legales.do"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is only accessible through a web form piece by piece. Automating a collect and assemble of all files is quite complex""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Environment, Ministry of Social Affairs and Health"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Arsenic"",""Fluoride levels"",""Nitrates"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Data per water source"",""Available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.stats.environnement.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/Eider/series.do"",""descValue"":""Regional and departmental environment database""},{""urlValue"":""https://social-sante.gouv.fr/sante-et-environnement/eaux/article/qualite-de-l-eau-potable"",""descValue"":""Drinking water quality for every town""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","France also has drinking water data up for the whole country. I added that to the review.","Yes","No","Open Knowledge","Nisha Thompson","70","70"
"810d03e1-648a-4672-8966-814c99dec64f","global","2017-03-10T00:20:17","2016","pe","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Oficina Nacional de Procesos Electorales (ONPE"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission since not all required data is available. As submitter noted, results available in HTML format include registered votes and major results, no information for invalid or spoiled ballots. Data at first is presented highly aggregated, afterwards is available by polling station. Dataset is not actually downloadable in bulk, you would need to scrape each polling station to get disaggregated results. License is not visible, submitter states that data is not open licensed/public domain.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"4449eaf5-1e04-4176-b642-df193b74b898","global","2017-03-10T00:11:53","2016","zm","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Web search for laws led to the Parliament website, where Bills are listed under Publications"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Assembly of Zambia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.parliament.gov.zm/publications/bills-list"",""descValue"":""National Assembly of Zambia""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission fulfills most data characteristics. Navigating to the Zambian Parliament website, the bills are accessible under ""Publications."" The status, name and a brief description of the bill are available, as well as a PDF with the content of the bill. Information on the website is not openly licensed, but requires permission (that is often granted with adequate citation) for reuse by the Clerk of the National Assembly.",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","45","45"
"ac112af6-248f-4d0b-aa58-0c217c5f1269","global","2017-03-04T20:23:58","2016","zm","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Web search for Laws of Zambia, enter the Parliament's website, and the laws are accessible under \""Publications\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Assembly of Zambia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I could not get access. ""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.parliament.gov.zm/acts-of-parliament"",""descValue"":""National Assembly of Zambia""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission fulfills data characteristics. The laws were found on the Parliament's website, under Publications. Laws are available to download in PDF, while a brief summary and date enacted are provided in HTML. ","I rejected the original submission and started a new submission. On the site provided, I was not able to obtain access. The initial submitter had answered the questions accordingly:
B1: Yes
B1.1: Zambia Legal Information Institute
B2: yes
B2.2: https://www.zambialii.org - Zambia Legal Information Institute
B2.3: 4
B2.4: I google searched National Laws Zambia and this website was on the first page of search results.
B3: Content/ Date of last amendment/ Amendments to the law
B4: Yes
B5: Yes
B6: Yes
B7: No - No copyright information is available on the website.
B8: None - RTF
B9: 3","Yes","No","Michael Beatty","Alyssa Beaton","45","45"
"f75c031e-1525-4a99-8379-582a37fde2c2","global","2016-12-12T15:01:09","2016","ru","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Through official website of the Ministry, under Documentation there is a link to the Draft Regulations Portal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.ru/information-usage"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry for Economic Development of the Russian Federation"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://regulation.gov.ru"",""descValue"":""governmental information system""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission fulfills most characteristics, excepting votes and transcripts. The data was found through the official website of the Ministry. Under Documentation there is a link to the Draft Regulations Portal. The content of the draft legislation is available in XML.",,"Yes","No","Mikhail Parfentev","Alyssa Beaton","85","85"
"110d9813-ae40-4a81-aead-6fb78ec95da9","global","2017-03-09T23:43:30","2016","me","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""State Electoral Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission since not all required data is available. Data available (https://dik.co.me/ / https://dik.co.me/kategorija-dokumenta/rezultati/) include results for major electoral contests, registered votes and invalid votes, but no information on spoiled ballots. Data is up to date, available in XLS, downloadable at once for each election. According to submitter, Article 32 of the Law
(https://dik.co.me/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/Zakon-o-izboru-odbornika-i-poslanika.pdf) would imply that data are in public domain.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"b9797bbc-5f22-448a-8755-809c5b152348","global","2016-12-08T03:23:19","2016","rs","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""DOC and PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google search \""zakoni u proceduri\"", first hit (\""laws in procedure\"", in Serbian)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""In accordance with Article 6 of the Law on Copyright and Related Rights, all laws, bylaws, other legal acts and official documents of state institutions do not enjoy copyright protection i.e. are in public domain"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Please note: data is collected by the Parliament, not the Government.""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Assembly of the Republic of Serbia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""National Assembly of the Republic of Serbia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.parlament.gov.rs/%D0%B0%D0%BA%D1%82%D0%B8/%D0%B7%D0%B0%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%BD%D0%B8-%D1%83-%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%BE%D1%86%D0%B5%D0%B4%D1%83%D1%80%D0%B8/%D0%B7%D0%B0%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%BD%D0%B8-%D1%83-%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%BE%D1%86%D0%B5%D0%B4%D1%83%D1%80%D0%B8.46.html"",""descValue"":""Serbian Parliament - Laws in Procedure""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission fulfills most data characteristics, save for votes and transcripts. Drafts are available on the Parliament website, available here: https://www.parlament.gov.rs/%D0%B0%D0%BA%D1%82%D0%B8/%D0%B7%D0%B0%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%BD%D0%B8-%D1%83-%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%BE%D1%86%D0%B5%D0%B4%D1%83%D1%80%D0%B8/%D0%B7%D0%B0%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%BD%D0%B8-%D1%83-%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%BE%D1%86%D0%B5%D0%B4%D1%83%D1%80%D0%B8.46.html. As the submitter states, ""all texts are given as either PDF or DOC (instead in some common open data format) which complicates reuse.""","All texts are given as either PDF or DOC (instead in some common open data format) which complicates reuse.","Yes","No","Slobodan Marković","Alyssa Beaton","65","65"
"e0a492f7-7287-46fa-ac06-8e9177a89a7d","global","2016-12-08T03:10:39","2016","rs","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""DOC/DOCX and PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google search for \""pravno-informacioni sistem\"" (\""legal information system\"", in Serbian)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""In accordance with Article 6 of the Law on Copyright and Related Rights, all laws, bylaws, other legal acts and official documents of state institutions do not enjoy copyright protection i.e. are in public domain"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Official Gazette of the Republic of Serbia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.pravno-informacioni-sistem.rs/SlGlasnikPortal/reg/content"",""descValue"":""The public registry of laws, bylaws and other legal acts (\""pravno-informacioni sistem\""), established by The Law on Publication of Laws, Bylaws and Other Legal Acts""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission fulfills the data characteristics. The laws are available here: https://www.pravno-informacioni-sistem.rs/SlGlasnikPortal/reg/content, in the public registry of laws, bylaws and other legal acts (""pravno-informacioni sistem""), established by The Law on Publication of Laws, Bylaws and Other Legal Acts. The laws are also made available in English here: https://propisi.pravno-informacioni-sistem.rs/. ",,"Yes","No","Slobodan Marković","Alyssa Beaton","65","65"
"8495c030-ff15-4c0f-85b8-ceeeaf4fdf36","global","2017-01-19T14:34:04","2016","fi","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""PX"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""From Statistics Finland web page"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.stat.fi/org/lainsaadanto/yleiset_kayttoehdot_en.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""This data category requires results by constituency / district for all major national electoral contests. To satisfy this category, the following minimum criteria must be met:\n\nResult for all major electoral contests\nNumber of registered votes\nNumber of invalid votes\nNumber of spoiled ballots\nAll data should be reported at the level of the polling station\n""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Statistics Finland"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://pxnet2.stat.fi/PXWeb/pxweb/en/StatFin/StatFin__vaa__evaa__evaa_2015/?tablelist=true""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.stat.fi/til/vaa_en.html"",""descValue"":""Elections Statistics""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","All the required data is available. downloadable per year and get a pre visualization. Finding the info is a straightforward process, when in the Statistics Finland webpage, by selecting Statistics > Elections. Terms of Use states that “Statistics Finland grants a universal, free-of-charge, irrevocable, parallel right of use to the aforementioned material, which may be freely: Copied and distributed, Edited and commercially exploited, Combined with other products, Used as part of an application or service”. ",,"Yes","Yes","Jaakko Korhonen","Paola Mosso","100","100"
"ec77f6c2-55cb-440b-9d3a-fb3c3beec351","global","2017-03-09T22:39:15","2016","py","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search for: \""Leyes paraguayas\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://datos.congreso.gov.py/opendata/avisolegal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Republic of Paraguay and the National Library of Congress "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.bacn.gov.py/buscador-de-leyes-paraguayas"",""descValue"":""National Library of Congress""},{""urlValue"":""https://sil2py.senado.gov.py/main.pmf"",""descValue"":""Republic of Paraguay's Legislative Information System""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"This submission fulfills the data characteristics. I modified the original submission, made by Lupinupa L, to reflect that the content and amendments to the laws are only available in PDF. CSV, JSON and XML downloads are available, however, as the submitter states ""you can download a ""dataset"" containing links to the laws but it is really is a dataset of metadata."" Laws are available for viewing and download from both sources. Amendments to laws are not necessarily linked to the original laws.","Yes","No","anonymous","Alyssa Beaton","65","65"
"c77308f3-8fbd-42e6-aea1-583c9e5d6f14","global","2016-12-17T13:33:05","2016","de","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The contents and documents accessible via the website of BaFin may in principle be stored, passed on and reproduced. If the contents or documents are different, the content is different. The transmission or duplication is only permitted with a clear indication of the source.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""search online"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.bafin.de/DE/Service/Footer/Rechtliches/Nutzungsbedingungen/nutzungsbedingungen_node.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bundesanzeiger Verlag GmbH im Auftrag im Auftrag des Bundesministeriums der Justiz und für Verbraucherschutz"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://portal.mvp.bafin.de/database/InstInfo/"",""descValue"":""Federal Financial Supervisory Authority - database of companies""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.handelsregister.de/rp_web/mask.do?Typ=n"",""descValue"":""Common register portal of the German federal states""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.handelsregisterbekanntmachungen.de/en/index.php?aktion=suche"",""descValue"":""Register notices - Find Announcement""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Company data are available online and free of charge on the Federal Financial Supervisory Authority website under ""database of companies"". Although there is a Search feature, if you leave the ""Company / Institute"" search field blank, you will get a complete list of all companies / institutes listed in the database, or all companies / institutes in a particular category. You can also use the letter fields to filter companies with their respective initial letters. ""Other"" filters companies that start with numbers, umlauts or special characters. Data are given in .HTML format once company name is selected, and include Name, Address, and ID number. The contents and documents accessible via the website of BaFin may in principle be stored, passed on and reproduced. If the contents or documents are different, the content is different. The transmission or duplication is only permitted with a clear indication of the source. Update frequency of data is not provided.
Data are also found on the Common register portal of the German federal states. These are available through a search mask and one needs to know the name of an entity in order to find it. Selecting ""UT – Entity"" from the results, Company name, HRB number and address are given in .HTML format. One then has the option of buying further company information and documents in .PDF. It is stated that the relevance to the current situation of the data you can view in the register is guaranteed. You will receive authentic data from the official register, because a search is always performed among the real-time data of the register of companies. However, the data viewed and retrieved by the subscriber may be used only for informational purposes. Use of the data to create one's own register as a counterpart to the Trade Register is not permitted. The subscriber is bound to refrain from creating or maintaining his own register as a counterpart to the Trade Register and from providing the data retrieved to anyone for such purposes. The subscriber is also bound to limit the frequency of his recalls to 60 in the hour. He may otherwise expect a temporary block of his user ID. If the user is able to prove that he has a justified reason for accessing the data more frequently it is also possible upon prior consultation with the Register Portal service department to obtain permission for additional access time for a limited period. For data retrievals from federal states in which he is not charged the subscriber is additionally bound to use the retrieved data only for those purposes for which fees are not levied and not to pass on the data to third parties.
Another source is the Land of North Rhine-Westphalia represented by the Ministry of Justice - Register notices website, under the ""Find Announcement"" feature. Again, data are available through a search mask where Company names, HRB numbers (""HR"" means ""Handelsregister"" - the Commercial Register. Section B is the part of the register where records of limited companies are maintained) and address are given in .HTML in the Announcements. Update frequency and type of license is unknown.
Lastly, it may be worth noting that the Company Register - The central platform for the storage of company data website provides only Name, District Court, HRB, Status, but no address:
https://www.unternehmensregister.de/ureg/index.html?dest=ureg&language=en","no detailed information regarding updates","Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","50","50"
"938ae36f-c0f6-408a-96c1-cbae2c6b12b4","global","2016-12-17T14:21:43","2016","il","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no link to the full data set at the official budget page on the Ministry of Finance website (https://mof.gov.il/BudgetSite/statebudget/BUDGET2017_2018/Pages/BudgetDocuments.aspx). I had to think or know of the data.gov.il search engine.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""searched for \""budget\"" on the data.gov.il portal. Searching for relevant terms on google did not link for the full data set, just to the official page on the ministry of finance website (https://mof.gov.il/BudgetSite/statebudget/BUDGET2017_2018/Pages/BudgetDocuments.aspx)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.il/terms"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.il/dataset/2017-2018"",""descValue"":""Data.Gov.il website""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"7d50739f-ef05-486a-85af-3d842eef7dd9","global","2016-12-04T20:20:25","2016","im","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""footer notice and link""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""via a Treasury dashboard, presently April 2015 to March 2016 with estimates and actuals:\nhttps://financereports.gov.im/\n""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""For 2016, the PDF file is available here: https://www.gov.im/media/1355349/isle-of-man-budget-2017-18.pdf""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""google -- isle of man budget"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.gov.im/about-this-site/open-government-licence/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Treasury"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""sub-departments available via a Treasury dashboard, presently April 2015 to March 2016 with estimates and actuals:\nhttps://financereports.gov.im/\n""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.im/media/1350454/pink-book-2016-17.pdf"",""descValue"":""Pink Book 2016-17""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.im/about-the-government/departments/treasury/budget/"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Comment Reviewer: I have changed Question B8 as the full budget for 2016 was only available in pdf. The indicated website of the treasury provides expenditures and estimates but that is not up to date and as such does not provide the full budget for the year. ",,"Yes","No","Graeme Jones","Anna Alberts","80","80"
"fbdd90e6-21a3-4559-bc15-a41ba6fb0dc8","global","2016-11-21T01:58:33","2016","hk","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Go to Hong Kong Government Website and search budget"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.hk/en/terms-and-conditions"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Financial Services and the Treasury Bureau"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.budget.gov.hk/2016/eng/estimates1.html"",""descValue"":""Estimates for the year ending 31 March 2017""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.budget.gov.hk/2016/eng/estimates.html"",""descValue"":""Estimates for all chapters in PDF""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewer: I changed question B5, because on the indicated page I could only download the different files one-by-one. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Anna Alberts","85","85"
"82c77a4c-b59f-4495-8128-52f0ee7c1185","global","2016-11-14T18:24:31","2016","se","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""CC-BY""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Geaoreferenced data is available in a WMS service. Other datasets are in various formats.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Several packages are available in an Atom feed collectable in bulk.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""https://opendata-catalog.smhi.se/explore/""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Found in the top menu of the SMHI website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.smhi.se/klimatdata/oppna-data/information-om-oppna-data/villkor-for-anvandning-1.30622"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""CC-BY""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Swedish Meteorological and Hydrological Institute (SMHI)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""SMHI, the Swedish Meteorological and Hydrological Institute""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Precipitation Probability"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://opendata-catalog.smhi.se/explore/"",""descValue"":""Open data subsite of SMHI""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. Thank you, Peter Krantz, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Several packages are available in an Atom feed collectable in bulk. Geaoreferenced data is available in a WMS service. Other datasets are in various formats.
","Yes","Yes","Peter Krantz","Danny Lämmerhirt","100","100"
"0f0e2b13-3bda-475e-966b-835cfdd90665","global","2016-12-15T03:34:09","2016","sv","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google Ministerio de Hacienda; I clicked on Novedades > Presupuestarios > Proyectos de Presupuesto > Presupuestos"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Hacienda"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.mh.gob.sv/"",""descValue"":""Página oficial del Ministerio de Hacienda""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.transparenciafiscal.gob.sv/downloads/pdf/7-1242355PTF_CONSTANCIA_DIARIO_OFICIAL_PARA_PRESUPUESTO_2016.pdf"",""descValue"":""Budget law""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.transparenciafiscal.gob.sv/ptf-services/ep/AFQ/ep1-submit-query"",""descValue"":""Detailed sections of the budget portal + download option""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Comment reviewer: on the budget transparency portal, the full budget data are hidden in the detailed data search portal, but once that is found, everything is available , up to date and for download in xls.
https://www.transparenciafiscal.gob.sv/ptf-services/ep/AFQ/ep1-submit-query
Based on this I have changed the B2.2 and B8. Although it als published on a transparency portal, in the commitment document here: https://www.transparenciafiscal.gob.sv/ptf/es/QuienesSomos/Nuestrocompromiso.html it does not mention a license and even reservations on when the government will not publish data. ","You need an OCR to scrape the data available and, also, you need to download each PDF of the government department to build a database. ","Yes","No","Omar Luna","Anna Alberts","80","80"
"c8f26443-0aad-4c18-a098-a36a8f052cb4","global","2016-12-23T16:33:12","2016","ch","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.meteoswiss.admin.ch/home/about-us/contact/terms-and-conditions.html""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search engine"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal Office of Meteorology and Climatology MeteoSwiss"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.meteoswiss.admin.ch/home/weather/forecasts.html"",""descValue"":""National forecasts""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.meteoswiss.admin.ch/home.html?tab=wind"",""descValue"":""MeteoSwiss, Webpage displaying all characteristics in different formats (weather maps, wind barbs, and others)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. Thank you, Oleg Lavrovsky, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"f207a77d-ed60-4139-ad3f-be9123f660f2","global","2017-01-17T13:35:52","2016","zw","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Terms and conditions of use: https://investzimbabwe.co.zw/terms-conditions-of-use/""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Unsure.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Unsure.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""It took me about 5 minutes to find this source. I google searched procurement Zimbabwe, tenders Zimbabwe, public tenders Zimbabwe with no luck. I searched government tenders Zimbabwe and found this source on the third page of search results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Invest Zimbabwe"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Couldn't access resource in the moment of review."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Cannot confirm without subscription.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://investzimbabwe.co.zw/"",""descValue"":""Invest Zimbabwe""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Oscar Montiel","15","15"
"ea914ac5-1ecb-4dcf-b935-24b6076546b9","global","2017-01-16T10:35:41","2016","zm","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Tenders are found on certain department websites. There is no website with all the government tenders available."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No evidence to support answer. There is a paid subscription website that collects all tenders (private and public). https://tenderszambia.com/index.php""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes made to submission",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"109d90fd-f208-4298-9a48-f3be515b6461","global","2016-12-13T12:19:40","2016","uy","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched the National Open Data Catalogue"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://datos.gub.uy/wps/wcm/connect/7fe4b346-b24c-4889-af2f-073897a1e97d/terminos-catalogodatos.pdf?MOD=AJPERES&ContentCache=NONE&CACHEID=7fe4b346-b24c-4889-af2f-073897a1e97d"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""My consideration is that having an interface to filter helps searching for specific tenders, for example. But the result is an XML, so this might be debatable.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Agencia de Compras y Contrataciones del Estado"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://catalogodatos.gub.uy/dataset/compras-estatales"",""descValue"":""National Open Data Catalogue""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.comprasestatales.gub.uy/datos_abiertos/imp_catalogo.tgz"",""descValue"":""Bulk Download""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.comprasestatales.gub.uy/comprasenlinea/"",""descValue"":""Interface""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No change made to submission ",,"Yes","Yes","Daniel Carranza","Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"81058279-fa68-47b9-bad0-855eb71655ba","global","2016-12-28T19:40:43","2016","fr","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google search on budget + france + 2016 "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.etalab.gouv.fr/en/licence-ouverte-open-licence "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance and Public Accounts (Ministère des Finances et des Comptes Publics)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.data.gouv.fr/fr/datasets/loi-de-finances-initiale-pour-2016-lfi-2016/ "",""descValue"":""Budget Law 2016""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/eli/loi/2015/12/29/FCPX1519907L/jo#JORFARTI000031732866"",""descValue"":""Budget Law on website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.economie.gouv.fr/vous-orienter/particulier/impots/chiffres-cles-budget-2016"",""descValue"":""Budget website""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept. However, the machine readable data was only available on the open data government portal, and not on the ministry of finance website itself. ",,"Yes","Yes","Open Knowledge","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"518720d9-8bc5-4e80-be59-53cd299b3e74","global","2016-12-13T06:53:16","2016","gb","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""JSON""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Daily snapshots are available in CSV. Contracts Finder notices are HTML with attachments and there is a JSON API. Some spreadsheets attached to notices on Contracts Finder are published in PDF format i.e. the data is not in a re-usable format.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The daily snapshots only cover notices added on a specific day. There is no source of bulk data covering all notices in the current Contracts Finder.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I was previously aware of all of this material so did not need to search for it. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Contracts Finder is the first Google result return based on a search for \""uk government contracts\"", so should be relatively easy for most people to find.""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/version/3/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Open Government Licence applies to the available data.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Crown Commercial Service"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is important to note that many Government departments and agencies do not (yet) participate in Contracts Finder to a meaningful extent, so it is not a cross-government body of procurement data. CCS publishes statistics on Contracts Finder use by publishers: https://www.contractsfinder.service.gov.uk/Notice/Summary""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.contractsfinder.service.gov.uk/"",""descValue"":""Contracts Finder""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.uk/publisher/crown-commercial-service"",""descValue"":""Contracts Finder Daily Snapshots""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.uk/data/contracts-finder-archive/"",""descValue"":""Contracts Finder Archive (2011-15)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Contracts Finder is an open public procurement platform administered by CCS. A daily file of notices is published as open data on Data.gov.uk. Data.gov.uk also holds a static open data archive of notices from an earlier version of Contracts Finder that was live from Feb 2011 through Feb 2015.""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes made to the submission.
Data is offered in OCDS.",,"Yes","No","Owen Boswarva","Oscar Montiel","85","85"
"347926cb-ae15-4cf2-9f69-4bee634e2b40","global","2016-12-13T20:55:24","2016","me","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Copyright is claimed on the footer \""© 2016 Skupština Crne Gore.\nSva prava zadržana.\"" however according to Article 8 of Copyright law, Copyright protection shall not include: 2) official texts in the legislative, administrative and judicial domain. https://www.wipo.int/wipolex/en/details.jsp?id=11369""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Once on the Parliament website, the two respective menu items are listed under Meetings."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.wipo.int/wipolex/en/details.jsp?id=11369"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Parliament of Montenegro"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Instead of transcripts, minutes of the meetings are given, ex https://www.skupstina.me/zakoni/web/dokumenta/zakoni-i-drugi-akti/1141/1196-7824-32-1-16-1-2.pdf""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.skupstina.me/index.php/en/sittings-of-the-parliament/laws-and-other-legislation"",""descValue"":""Laws and other Legislation""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.skupstina.me/index.php/en/sittings-of-the-parliament/sittings-of-the-parliament"",""descValue"":""Sittings of the Parliament""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission fulfills all characteristics. Once on the Parliament website, the data is accessible under the heading ""Meetings,"" clicking on either Sittings of Parliament or Laws and regulations, where draft laws are listed, with linked PDF documents, available for download. Per the submitter, while transcripts might not be available exactly, minutes are included: ""Instead of transcripts, minutes of the meetings are given, ex https://www.skupstina.me/zakoni/web/dokumenta/zakoni-i-drugi-akti/1141/1196-7824-32-1-16-1-2.pdf."" As with National Laws, the data is openly licensed, as the submitter states that ""copyright is claimed on the footer ""© 2016 Skupština Crne Gore. Sva prava zadržana."" however according to Article 8 of Copyright law, Copyright protection shall not include: 2) official texts in the legislative, administrative and judicial domain. https://www.wipo.int/wipolex/en/details.jsp?id=11369.""",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Alyssa Beaton","65","65"
"3c8bd587-6c92-43c2-96ab-a5a8e6ec0379","global","2016-12-26T04:39:27","2016","ua","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""JSON""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There's JSON API""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There's an API, but there are no regular dumps""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search for \""Prozorro API\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://zakon4.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/922-19"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Law on Procurement""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is developed in according with Open Contracting Data Standard""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Economic Development and Trade"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://api-docs.openprocurement.org/uk_UA/latest/"",""descValue"":""API Documentation""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes made to submission.
Data is available in OCDS standard",,"Yes","No","Vanya Yani","Oscar Montiel","85","85"
"2da0097c-76ba-4931-88bc-aa01e3ab145a","global","2016-12-13T20:36:15","2016","me","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Copyright is claimed on the footer \""2011 © Legal Information System of Montenegro\"" however according to Article 8 of Copyright law, Copyright protection shall not include: 2) official texts in the legislative, administrative and judicial domain. https://www.wipo.int/wipolex/en/details.jsp?id=11369""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""embedded PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried an online search engine \""Sluzbeni list Crne Gore\"". It is one of the results. On the site, it's first on the left menu."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.wipo.int/wipolex/en/details.jsp?id=11369"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Official Journal of Montenegro"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.sluzbenilist.me/SLOsnRezultati.aspx?tp=0&yr=2016&nvg=1,1,1"",""descValue"":""Official Journal""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.sluzbenilist.me/PANapRezultati.aspx?no=&it=&la=-1&ldt=-1&ai=2&eu=-1&src=-1&dt=-1&fts=&frm=&to=&kw=&nvg=6,1,3"",""descValue"":""Regulations and other acts""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission fulfills all data characteristics. The submitter initially pointed to this source: https://www.sluzbenilist.me/SLOsnRezultati.aspx?tp=0&yr=2016&nvg=1,1,1, however this link is a bit more direct https://www.sluzbenilist.me/PANapRezultati.aspx?no=&it=&la=-1&ldt=-1&ai=2&eu=-1&src=-1&dt=-1&fts=&frm=&to=&kw=&nvg=6,1,3. The laws are divided by their respective governing state bodies. The content of the law is provided in an embedded PDF, but not available for download. Amendment details are linked in a pop-up menu when you click on ""Details."" Per the submitter, ""Copyright is claimed on the footer ""2011 © Legal Information System of Montenegro"" however according to Article 8 of Copyright law, Copyright protection shall not include: 2) official texts in the legislative, administrative and judicial domain. https://www.wipo.int/wipolex/en/details.jsp?id=11369.""",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Alyssa Beaton","65","65"
"914980ab-5d18-4347-a761-cc9bd6976865","global","2016-12-16T17:03:23","2016","de","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""search or govdata.de"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.govdata.de/daten/-/details/bundeshaushalt-2015"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bundesministerium für Finanzen"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.bundeshaushalt-info.de/download.html"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept",,"Yes","Yes","walter palmetshofer","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"6b3d5f42-c8ac-4cf0-9c31-295435ee09d4","global","2017-03-09T21:23:17","2016","tz","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Tanzania Meteorological Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The original submission did not qualify for the index. The Tanzania Meteorological Agency publishes weather forecasts online for temperature for today and the following four days. But no forecasts are published for precipitation or wind. ","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"8aee12b1-1444-4ca1-b7e7-0deb2191f747","global","2016-12-13T10:13:14","2016","tr","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Go to the website, top of homepage, there is procurement section et voila or by using search engine and type 'veriler' scroll down and you will see lots of data about procurement"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Minister of Economy"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ekonomi.gov.tr/portal/faces/home"",""descValue"":""Minister of Economy website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.toki.gov.tr/"",""descValue"":""Tenders' informations""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes to submission",,"Yes","No","Onur Teksan","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"b8d76c91-eb1a-4ba3-8608-0ebdf0b7b153","global","2017-02-03T11:20:49","2016","tn","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The e-procurement system publishes tenders but I was unable to find the awards. The raw data does not appear to be available. ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""https://www.tuneps.tn/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Tuneps is the Tunisian E-Procurement system \n\nTenders are also available at: \n https://www.marchespublics.gov.tn/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes to submission",,"Yes","No","Katelyn Rogers","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"414edc7a-ad68-498c-9a72-5cbd9e0fe905","global","2017-01-20T00:31:37","2016","tt","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF Download""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The tender notices from the government are up to date however contracts awarded are not ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""The documents were easily found on the Ministry of Finance page "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.finance.gov.tt/services/central-tenders-board/"",""descValue"":""Central Tenders Board""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.finance.gov.tt/category/tender/"",""descValue"":""TENDER""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.finance.gov.tt/category/awarded-contracts/"",""descValue"":""AWARDED CONTRACTS""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.finance.gov.tt/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/Contracts-awarded-for-the-month-of-September-without-BIR.pdf"",""descValue"":""CONTRACTS AWARDED BY THE CENTRAL TENDERS BOARD FOR THE MONTH OF SEPTEMBER 2016""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes to submission",,"Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"d7b8ba2f-c566-43ae-8a44-dc897a4e60d5","global","2016-12-14T11:21:00","2016","lv","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""According to the Freedom of Information Law the information that is published by institutions providing state functions can be interpreted as \""generally accessible information\"" that is compatible with Public domain approach. The law does not require for the institutions to publish declarations or licences with the information (they can be provided on voluntary basis).""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""+ DOC / DOCX""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is possible to download each legislative act, However these systems don't provide bulk download of all legislative acts.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I knew where the data was. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.vvc.gov.lv/export/sites/default/docs/LRTA/Likumi/Freedom_of_Information_Law.doc "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Valsts kanceleja / Saeima"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://tap.mk.gov.lv/mk/tap/"",""descValue"":""Legislation submitted to the Government""},{""urlValue"":""https://titania.saeima.lv/LIVS12/saeimalivs12.nsf/webAll?OpenView"",""descValue"":""Legislation submitted to the Parliament ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission fulfills the data characteristics. While the submitter initially stated that all characteristics were available, I was unable to locate votes and transcripts. While, as the submitter states, ""it is possible to download each legislative act, However these systems don't provide bulk download of all legislative acts."" Therefore the answer was changed to no. Furthermore, each draft usually has more than one document, each of which are separately downloadable in Word doc only. Regarding whether the data is openly licensed, the submitter states that ""according to the Freedom of Information Law the information that is published by institutions providing state functions can be interpreted as ""generally accessible information"" that is compatible with Public domain approach. The law does not require for the institutions to publish declarations or licences with the information (they can be provided on voluntary basis).""",,"Yes","No","Toms Ceļmillers","Alyssa Beaton","65","65"
"0a24e91e-c1cc-488d-b38b-fa313b5e518c","global","2017-03-09T21:10:54","2016","th","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Thai Meteorological Department"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you, Phimluck Klangwichit, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The original submission did not qualify for the index. Forecasts are available for the following 24 hours, but not for the following day. The data are available at: https://www.tmd.go.th/en/region.php?RegionID=1. It can be downloaded in XLS and XML formats.
","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"885e8060-0060-4f73-b280-2bb7cba12673","global","2017-03-09T21:02:33","2016","do","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Consultoría.gov.do - consulta la legislación - leyes - buscar"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Consultoría Jurídica del Poder Ejecutivo"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.consultoria.gov.do/consulta/Default.aspx"",""descValue"":""Portal web de la Consultoría Jurídica del Poder Ejecutivo""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission fulfills all characteristics. The portal hosts laws, decrees, regulations and resolutions, and are searchable by year, title, date enacted, under which president, and so on. The portal is accessible via this site: https://www.consultoria.gov.do/. Under the heading Inquiries there is a link to Laws and Decrees. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Alyssa Beaton","45","45"
"6a868477-bb6b-4e28-b8a5-b37de5cf36e1","global","2017-01-18T04:49:07","2016","bs","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bahamas Department of Meteorology"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Meteorology Department provides weather and climate information to Bahamians and International Community.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is valid, also the reviewer was unable to access the official website of the Department of Meteorology of the Bahamas, available at https://www.bahamasweather.org.bs. Thank you, Alesha Aris, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Unable to find a reputable online source for the Bahamas Meteorology Department. The website appears to be down https://www.bahamasweather.org.bs/ ","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"d64b6d80-afaa-4696-9dc6-6ede3d2aa981","global","2017-03-09T20:53:06","2016","tt","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Trinidad and Tobago Meteorological Service"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you, Alesha Aris, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The original submission did not qualify for the Global Open Data Index because the Trinidad and Tobago Meteorological Service only provides forecasts for the current day. These can be found at: https://www.metoffice.gov.tt/forecast. ","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"0ec7bd4f-71b6-4776-8135-5c295e8c6ea8","global","2017-01-17T22:59:03","2016","bs","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The documents are available as HTML and PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The documents are available fr perusal as PDF files ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""On google.com I entered the keywords \""bahamas tender data\"" this easily lead me to the given website "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The source does not provide an abundance of information to peruse ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Government of the Bahamas"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Unable to identify the exact agency responsible for the collection and dissemination of information ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.bahamas.gov.bs/wps/portal/public/Government%20Tender%20and%20Tender%20Notices/!ut/p/b1/vZPJcqMwFEW_JR_gIMkCiSXGTDHzZMOGYvLAYLBjB5uvb9LVVT1UxelFp6WVVOfV1X1Xj4mZCHM8JPyczpkNEx_Tt8MuvRy6Y9q8n2MumQPFEARMDYUFHNACWxdsoiILshMQTQD4YAngYf0K_ah_APyV_kcABp_Vr5lNFoGbSLVBkrLE61NDy1QU7aEMpKa4nj19r1_HqljoaWQlc7gY8uRc4gFtyRrZ9TWnqOYImtl3W9y-6HJL1mrk6hfPOq9IH6AxvR_5te683bpOd5Yz2rszN7Tg5cpWwkDdTkXOUKGc3ZTicojFkx1ZfeGYFrbjOt2JPRZ8Y0sKj_pwhmpFkaY3xw9tvbv-DjyK5bNgTLVrSyaaMPIL5ocAaBAIrgcdQE3I-MwG4MSr7r021qNbjc7oVbFt-KEO_ODujVlo-rLhmyk0lgtruruZAbgZNRj9AJqXwreL0A0WgliLmmj-KWghn58ERcitAhZ4AH-1oMJadGoE8W2BRUCx4P8WnP_Xliq2Bb7c4W-fBjv_PsMXJj5k7fOQt8_gmfIcZAnFPOUAxpQwYRVhsnwfcM2eBjzPuHXYOuAwUHnHNSLufAc3QcOuKi6jJacdzF3UbkmkKvMrVcoULBzl0Jh6CrL8VO5FvUCSWG_0QNPd-p7ykiY7hq_Jt7Ui74mk5Ge8JUlvLV_lcOykU9GVUcTOzhS9jW1_snYrP79zIl9qzUUu3DEpYdEdX1b7jTVrWrnlTq-Ju47DujkSUQtqpNxeS2l7SfYX1ex5kG1kOJs7T09MGzeyrHOuOkD6cw9P3wB-N4mQ/dl4/d5/L2dBISEvZ0FBIS9nQSEh/"",""descValue"":""Government Tenders and Tender Notices""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Information is not updated and can't be filtered.
No changes in the submission",,"Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"3d49b844-52f1-46a5-9d00-1a9d484907f9","global","2017-03-09T20:45:21","2016","tn","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Institute of Meteorology "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you, Rabeb Dbebria, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The submission did not qualify for the Index because forecasts were only available for the current day (indicating weather conditions such as precipitations only in some parts of the country), and for the following day (without any indication of precipitation).
The data is embedded in HTML and cannot be downloaded. Data is not openly licensed since any reproduction is strictly forbidden (see here: https://www.meteo.tn/htmlen/divers/usagesite.html)","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"83d51d00-c229-47ca-89a9-5add7612a2c9","global","2017-02-02T19:19:32","2016","dk","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""DBF"",""HTML"",""PX"",""TXT"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I knew where it was. Otherwise it'd be easy to find it at Statistics Denmark, but nearly impossible to find the raw data download.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Typed in the url"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.dst.dk/en/OmDS/omweb.aspx"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No explicit online license information on the raw data download""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Very tricky to understand""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.oes-cs.dk/bevillingslove/data.html"",""descValue"":""Raw data""},{""urlValue"":""www.oes-cs.dk/olapdatabase/finanslov/index.cgi"",""descValue"":""Database (csv-download possible)""},{""urlValue"":""https://statistikbanken.dk/statbank5a/SelectVarVal/Define.asp?MainTable=OFF3B&PLanguage=1&PXSId=0&wsid=cftree"",""descValue"":""From Statistics Denmark""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Even more dataformats are available here: https://statistikbanken.dk/statbank5a/SelectVarVal/saveselections.asp",,"Yes","Yes","Niels Erik Kaaber Rasmussen","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"522287e2-e71c-4022-8c8b-a1f2bd582212","global","2017-03-09T20:27:03","2016","tr","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Turkish State Meteorological Service"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you, Dağ Medya, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The original submission does not qualify for the Index. The Turkish State Meteorological Service provides forecasts for the current day and the following four days only for temperature extremes and precipitation amount. Wind forecasts are only provided for the current day or for the sea (see here: https://mgm.gov.tr/en-US/marine-metu3-wind.aspx?d=a#sfB). The data is provided embedded in HTML and cannot be downloaded. There is no copyright waiver or similar notes that would indicate an open license.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"dd2ec006-32ad-43d5-a764-9945ba6ebda3","global","2016-12-04T13:13:56","2016","hr","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""It is not stated on the website however Croatian Copyright law states that: \n\nThe subject matter of copyright shall not include:\n\n1.\ndiscoveries, official texts in the domain of legislation, administration, judiciary (acts, regulations, decisions, reports, minutes, judgments, standards, and the like) and other official works and their collections, disclosed for the purpose of officially informing the public; \n\nSee Article 6 https://www.wipo.int/wipolex/en/text.jsp?file_id=230078#LinkTarget_237""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""XLS version of budget does not satisfy requirements on depth of data https://www.mfin.hr/adminmax/docs/Opci%20dio.xls. Full budget per requirement is in PDF. https://www.mfin.hr/adminmax/docs/Posebni%20dio%20Drzavnog%20proracuna%20Republike%20Hrvatske%20za%202016.%20godinu%20i%20projekcije%20za%202017.%20i%202018.%20godinu.pdf""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried a web search engine for Ministry of Finance Croatia, looked for the Budget in the menu"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.wipo.int/wipolex/en/text.jsp?file_id=230078#LinkTarget_237"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance, Republic of Croatia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.mfin.hr/hr/drzavni-proracun-2016-godina"",""descValue"":""State Budget 2016""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted",,"Yes","Yes","Arianit Dobroshi","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"31dcdce6-dc1d-48e1-a5e0-07c1d2a2d3c4","global","2016-12-23T11:46:51","2016","tz","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I went straight to PPRA's website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Public Procurement Regulatory Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://tender.ppra.go.tz"",""descValue"":""Public Procurement Regulatory Authority""},{""urlValue"":""https://tenders.ppra.go.tz/index.php?view=tender&seacrh=s&home=home&week=10&t=o"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Added link to the tender notices.
",,"Yes","No","Joachim Mangilima","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"ff7aac0a-3d62-4b57-b557-8b70162ee520","global","2016-11-27T16:32:54","2016","cz","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""SOAP API is available.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Majority of the data is updated quarterly.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""There is a dedicated analytical website for the treasury. Whereas the experts can probably find it effortlessly, it might be hard for interested public. The link from the ministry website is a little hidden under in the footer: websites/Monitor."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://monitor.statnipokladna.cz/en/2016/zdrojova-data/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This is hard for me to evaluate, as the source data require understanding of a specific accounting jargon. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerstvo financí ČR / Ministry of Finance of Czech Republic"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Not sure what is meant by sub-departments. Data are available e.g. for ministries and than broken down by type. E.g. for ministry of defense, balance sheets are provided, where on can find expenditures such as energy consumption or representative costs (aggregated). https://monitor.statnipokladna.cz/en/2015/statni-rozpocet/kapitola/307 Municipal level is more detailed (expenditures of towns an villages).""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://monitor.statnipokladna.cz/analyza/?query=4"",""descValue"":""Full Dataset for download""},{""urlValue"":""https://monitor.statnipokladna.cz/en/2016/zdrojova-data/"",""descValue"":""Data Catalogue""},{""urlValue"":""https://monitor.statnipokladna.cz/en/2016/"",""descValue"":""Homepage, current overall dataslo""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Comment reviewer: beautiful interface, up to date data and link between expenditure and budget is clearly given. ","There is also aggregated data available at ministry's own open data portal. Those data are not as detailed, but much easier to understand to an non-expert.
https://data.mfcr.cz/cs/dataset/statni-rozpocet/resource/5c0595a8-2982-4d4c-8579-84db52787439
","Yes","Yes","Michaela Rybičková","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"0889afb2-fa7f-4fc1-9412-7b4a52d12191","global","2016-11-10T15:17:55","2016","tw","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""search on government's web site"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.tw/license#eng"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Public Construction Commission of Executive Yuan"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://web.pcc.gov.tw/tpsreport/transfer/dataTransfer.do?method=getOkfnOpenDataXml"",""descValue"":""Procurement tenders""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes to the submission",,"Yes","Yes","lycurgus kk","Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"10814608-2b68-4875-9775-b0f70e12c8ee","global","2017-02-27T21:29:29","2016","do","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Only HTML information of the bills and download of the text in PDF. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Looked for \""Congreso República Dominicana\"" and got the first result. In the Legislative work section I found the data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Cámara de Diputados"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://silportal.camaradediputados.gob.do/Silweb/Iniciativas"",""descValue"":""Registry of Initiatives""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission fulfills most data characteristics, missing only the transcripts. The information is available here, https://silportal.camaradediputados.gob.do/Silweb/Iniciativas, and per the submitter, the information was readily accessible on the Congress' website. Name, status and other pertinent information is available on the site, while the content of the bill is available for download in PDF. The data is licensed to the Congress of Dominica Republic.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Alyssa Beaton","45","45"
"dd819961-e9e8-4096-9824-bc102ccc2b39","global","2017-02-03T15:36:11","2016","ua","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I checked the WMO register of meteorological organisations, found the link to the Ukrainian Hydrometeorological Centre, found the link n"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ukrainian Hydrometeorological Center"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Only data for city of Kiev is available as a HTML table. Rest of the country isn't open"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://meteo.gov.ua/en/33464/forecast/ukraine/33846/1"",""descValue"":""Ukrainian Hydrometeorological Center, Weather map including all required characteristics""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","All data is available online, however embedded in HTML and downloadable. Single information such as precipitation symbols on a weather map are not named properly in the HTML code. Significant manual work would be required to retrieve and use the data. No indication could be found online as to whether the data is openly licensed (only a copyright note that the agency holds all rights).
Thank you, Oscar Montiel, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"ca9f6509-13b9-4abb-a6f1-8f3f34458514","global","2016-12-23T16:29:14","2016","ch","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.simap.ch/shabforms/COMMON/simap/content/informationAboutSimap.jsf""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search engine"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The simap.ch Association"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.simap.ch/"",""descValue"":""Electronic platform of public procurement ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes in submission",,"Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"7e16cc2c-4dc0-4c63-b42f-9e7ee53eeb48","global","2017-01-29T19:15:59","2016","cm","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Assembly of Cameroon"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is a search mask for current laws, but I could not get one single result out of the mask. Maybe the exact title of a bill needs to be typed in.\n\nWorthwhile checking again: https://www.assnat.cm/index.php/fr/les-lois/les-lois-en-examen""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The data is not available. The submitter states: ""There is a search mask for current laws, but I could not get one single result out of the mask. Maybe the exact title of a bill needs to be typed in."" The National Assembly website (https://www.assemblenationale.cm/) is unavailable.",,"Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Alyssa Beaton","0","0"
"48a08cfd-85f8-40d2-9eb0-e3eeca466b3c","global","2017-01-05T15:48:35","2016","cm","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Cameroon National Assembly"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The data is not accessible. Per the submitter: ""At the time of this survey, the national assembly website is not available. It is the location of most of the laws voted in Cameroon. The website of the presidency of the republic used to publish laws, as the president of the republic is allowed by the constitution to issue laws. But it is difficult to find this information on both websites.""","At the time of this survey, the national assembly website is not available. It is the location of most of the laws voted in Cameroon. The website of the presidency of the republic used to publish laws, as the president of the republic is allowed by the constitution to issue laws. But it is difficult to find this information on both websites.","Yes","No","Charlie Martial NGOUNOU","Alyssa Beaton","0","0"
"d9a8cd78-fd60-4103-ab65-036d078d4da6","global","2016-11-14T16:48:03","2016","se","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched Bolagsverket website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.fi.se/en/about-fi/about-fi.se/open-data/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""FI's information may be used free of charge. State the source, FI and date. FI's data is available at no charge and may be freely processed and re-used without special permission or agreements.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bolagsverket - Swedish Companies Registration Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Har to validate without purchasing data.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.bolagsverket.se/en/us/about/e-services/foretagsfakta"",""descValue"":""Website of Swedish Companies Registration Office""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.fi.se/en/our-registers/company-register/"",""descValue"":""Financial Supervisory Authority - Company register""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submitter provided a link for the Companies Registration Office (Bolagsverket) website which offers a search feature to find company information by company name or registration number. However, the results provide only the company name and identification number, and no address. One needs to pay a fee in order to download filings which may contain further information. Needless to say, the data are not openly licensed:
https://www.bolagsverket.se/en/us/about/e-services/foretagsfakta
I have been able to find company data free of charge on the Financial Supervisory Authority website through their Company register search feature. Again, one needs to know the name or number of an entity in order to find it. Results include Name, Corporate identification number and once selected the company name, Address, Telephone, Category, and FI identification number are also given in .HTML format. While data cannot be downloaded in bulk, according to the website they are regularly updated, and may be used free of charge (though you are asked to state the source, Financial Supervisory Authority and date). Financial Supervisory Authority's data is available at no charge and may be freely processed and re-used without special permission or agreements.
https://www.fi.se/en/our-registers/company-register/","Information is available in an XML-based API but the price prohibits extensive data export. Not openly licensed.","Yes","No","Peter Krantz","Evangelia Kampouri","50","50"
"1073e4a9-5347-49ce-9659-b8f5a44766ac","global","2017-03-09T19:50:12","2016","ba","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF, RAR""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search for the Parliament website, enter in the section for citizens, and click on the heading for \""Regulations\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Parliament of BiH"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.parlamentfbih.gov.ba/dom_naroda/v2/bs/propisi.php"",""descValue"":""Regulations""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission fulfills all characteristics. The content, author(s) and status are available here: https://www.parlamentfbih.gov.ba/dom_naroda/v2/bs/propisi.php. The content of the draft legislation is available in PDF, and RAR if there is only a recording. Proposed changes, discussion and correspondence regarding the legislation are all equally available for review, linked in PDF. The information is not openly licensed, but the property of the Parliament of Bosnia and Herzegovina. The original submission linked to https://www.parlamentfbih.gov.ba/dom_naroda/v2/bs/stranica.php?idstranica=95#us_4, where laws can be found.",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","45","45"
"2c4f95a9-c180-4207-945c-886713467efb","global","2017-03-09T19:37:09","2016","ba","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Copyright © Parliament of the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina. 2017. years""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""The link was provided to me, but was found again when searching the parliament website, searching for \""laws.\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Parliament of Bosnia and Herzegovina"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.parlamentfbih.gov.ba/dom_naroda/v2/bs/stranica.php?idstranica=95#us_4"",""descValue"":""Review of laws and other acts adopted in the House of Peoples of the Federation Parliament""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission fulfills all criteria. The laws are available for review on the Parliament website, https://www.parlamentfbih.gov.ba/dom_naroda/v2/bs/stranica.php?idstranica=95#us_4, and available for download in PDF. The amendment information is contained in the link title on the page, whereas content is contained in PDF. This link replaces the original submission of data found at this link: https://www.sluzbenilist.ba/Docs/index/bih.",,"Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","45","45"
"7837e22f-f341-41b3-ae45-a89376afd043","global","2017-03-09T19:13:22","2016","do","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Salud Pública"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Couldn't find any data, reports, publications or mention of water quality datasets. Rejected previous entry because it was only for 1 city. ","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"536778a4-492e-42c6-a35a-bc5c3c119277","global","2017-03-09T18:58:56","2016","cm","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""national institute of statistics Cameroon, Ministry of Water Resources and Energy"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No where to request data""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","After searching the statistics portal there was no water quality data, then I searched the Ministry of Water Resources and there is no water quality data. However, this Ministry is in charge of water quality monitoring. ","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"bb84c871-eab1-4294-af05-29f10bc63c16","global","2017-01-27T15:49:39","2016","nl","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""House of Representatives"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""[Original submission comment]The results of the legislative process are published here: www.officielebekendmakingen.nl \n\nThe bills etc, get unique identifiers and can be traced on: www.officielebekendmakingen.nl too\n\nIt's not clear how easily the documents (PDFs) can be scraped, and whether all data can be extracted\n\nSee details:\n\""Bills submitted by the government or Members of Parliament are initially in a 'pending' status, which means that the House of Representatives will deal with them in a committee or in plenary session. All reports and documents dealing with a subject that the House of Representatives has discussed - such as a bill - have the same House document number. This number enables people to follow the outcome of the procedures in www.officielebekendmakingen.nl (Dutch language only), where also all documents regarding the work of the House can be found.\n\n[Reviewer Comment] I also think that B2 and B2.2 should be No. It is very difficult to find any bills on the website indicated by the original submitter (I have only seen one bill). Even for the one bill that I did find, the status of the bill and the author of the bill was missing. Since two required characteristics are not present, then B2 should be answered with No. ""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission will be accepted because it correctly states that data is not made available by the government. ","The original submission will be accepted because it had accurately answered B2 with No, although it appears that the original submitter provided a different reason. As a reviewer I also believe B2 should be a No, mainly because the site does not contain a clear database of bills and also because even if a bill has been made available it is missing two required characteristics. It is worth mentioning that the bill I was able to view is available for download in pdf, odt ,and xml formats.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Juela Xhaferraj","0","0"
"36c03ac9-3901-4e0c-9634-a7827145bdde","global","2016-12-13T16:45:52","2016","si","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""From the Assembly website, I navigated the menus to get to the proposed laws."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.dz-rs.si/wps/portal/en/Home/pravnoObvestilo"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""\""Unless otherwise provided, the information on this web portal is regarded as information of public character..\"" \n\nCopyright section in the same page does not mention textual content.\nhttps://www.dz-rs.si/wps/portal/en/Home/pravnoObvestilo\n\nNon-protected creations according to Article 9 of Copyright law includes official texts of legislative, administrative and judicial fields. https://www.wipo.int/wipolex/en/text.jsp?file_id=422516""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Assembly, Republic of Slovenia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.dz-rs.si/wps/portal/Home/deloDZ/zakonodaja/vObravnavi/predlogiZakonov"",""descValue"":""Predlogi zokonov - Portal DZ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
After reviewing over a dozen random examples, Could not locate Votes on Bills per member of parliament nor Transcripts of Debates on Legislation. Modified original submission to reflect this by 'unselecting' both options.
","• Content of Legislation is available in PDF format. • Copyright highlight: ""Unless otherwise provided, the information on this web portal is regarded as information of public character..""
-- https://www.dz-rs.si/wps/portal/en/Home/pravnoObvestilo --
• Non-protected creations according to Article 9 of Copyright law includes official texts of legislative, administrative and judicial fields. -- https://www.wipo.int/wipolex/en/text.jsp?file_id=422516 --","Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Anton Shaffer","65","65"
"c1836a33-9c25-4e04-9cd8-29ac28c8592f","global","2017-03-09T18:19:58","2016","kn","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""After further research, a structure for Draft Legislation is available on the Governments website -- however, the information is not properly populated. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Resubmitted by reviewer after rejecting original submission. Structure for a Draft Legislation exists, but not yet populated. The Parliamentary Proceedings section that may host future draft legislation is sub-headed as follows: ""Find out Parliamentary proceedings, track current bills, watch live footage, access public records and follow topical issues.""""","Resubmitted by Reviewer. Original submission rejected due to wrong information.
• After further research, a structure for providing Draft Legislation publicly is available on the Governments website -- however, the information is not properly populated.
(https://www.gov.kn > Government (menu item) > Parliament (secondary menu item) > Parliamentary Proceedings).","Yes","No","Anton Shaffer","Anton Shaffer","0","0"
"bf0f3cd8-e50e-4c15-a1c8-b24c0599e34d","global","2017-01-25T21:03:46","2016","kn","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Justice and Legal Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
• While the official government website (https://www.gov.kn/) contains a searchable database of some laws. There is no way to filter by date, nor can amendments be found. Not possible to verify whether this is an encompassing National Law database. (www.gov.kn > Document Center (menu item at bottom of page) > View All Documents)","The Public Safety and Law section of the government website appears to be under construction. ""This service has been scheduled for Process Engineering and will become available soon.""
https://www.gov.kn/","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Anton Shaffer","0","0"
"c730147b-aa63-446e-b705-8cd45bbd54c7","global","2017-02-27T15:42:39","2016","us","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Reviewer: Accepted, as Raw data is linked to a login and other options show a menu interactions to filter data needed; Without a multiple select option.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Looked for US air quality data EPA, the first results led to the air quality site"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.copyright.gov/title17/92chap1.html#105"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""United States Environmental Protection Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.epa.gov/outdoor-air-quality-data"",""descValue"":""Air Quality Data Collected at Outdoor Monitors Across the US""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","85","85"
"989f3bc9-47a5-42d9-b54d-d6c696fa3d8b","global","2017-01-17T13:57:35","2016","zw","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections, as no data was found.",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"148b0c9d-b81c-46f3-973d-c8fbce72edba","global","2017-01-16T11:01:17","2016","zm","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No evidence on copyright available website.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""PDF, PNG, XLSX, PPTX, Atomsvc""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled a few search terms, i.e. pollution emissions Zambia, pollution emissions data Zambia, pollution data Zambia, Emissions data Zambia, Department of environment Zambia. It took me a while to find something useful. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Zambia Data Portal Central Statistics Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Carbon monoxide (CO)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""CO2 emissions. Data is taken from https://unstats.un.org/""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://zambia.opendataforafrica.org/search?query=emissions"",""descValue"":""Zambia Data Portal Central Statistics Office""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected, as the data available is not available on monitoring stations or hourly rate; But rather, an aggregated measurement. It was found that the government does collect this data, but no source of open data found.",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Ricardo Alanís","65","65"
"57464c27-cf19-485a-8319-0766d42b3475","global","2016-12-07T11:58:55","2016","tr","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Reviewer: No explicit license is defined. ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Open the website et voila. For MFWW's website i just scrolled down the home page "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Air quality watch center, Minister of Forest and Water Works"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.havaizleme.gov.tr/Default.ltr.aspx"",""descValue"":""Air quality watch center""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ormansu.gov.tr/"",""descValue"":""Minister of Forest and Water Works""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted with slight corrections: Added Ozone to the available pollutants.",,"Yes","No","Onur Teksan","Ricardo Alanís","80","80"
"de04681b-b903-4b40-af5e-0e283036a771","global","2016-12-27T15:19:49","2016","tz","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Environment Management Council (NE"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""I don't have any specific reason why the Government is not collecting this data. But my research has not provided any leads if this data exist."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections. Reviewed different sources and no leads on measurement found.",,"Yes","No","Joachim Mangilima","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"1620dc62-1d5f-4ef0-9dfc-61dbf91f5270","global","2017-03-09T15:51:40","2016","mx","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is available in HTML only. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The original submission and my original review had marked this as YES (because one can save an html page that contains all entries in the gazette for a given day- this includes several bills). However, in this updated review I am changing B5 to No after Enrique_Zapata's feedback on the forum. B5 can be answered with No if one considers that there is no official option on the website to download data in bulk. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search for draft laws or regulations at the Coingress or Federal Regulatory Reform Commission sites"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Congress and Federal Regulatory Reform Commission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Bills are listed based on the day they were proposed. Votes on bills per member are made available but only those bills that were approved and only for the votes that took place in the Camera de Diputados (not available for Senate votes). Transcripts of debates could not be found for any bill. The journey of the bill through the legislative process is available under the title of the bill.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://gaceta.diputados.gob.mx/gp_iniciativas.html"",""descValue"":""Draft legislations in Congress""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The original submission also includedhttps://www.gob.mx/cofemer/articulos/simir?idiom=es as a source. As a reviewer I disregarded this source because it seems to be geared more toward bureaucratic transparency (it lists resolutions, regulations of various departments/agencies) and it is not necessarily directed at proposed legislation.""}]","Yes","Yes","This is an updated version on the original review. The original submission had been accepted because all the required characteristics are present in the data set. ","I chose to mark ""votes on bills"" as present. Information on votes is very consistently made available for bills approved by the House of Deputies. Because the information is made available for at least some bills, I have chosen to mark it as present. I was a bit more lax on this point because it is an optional characteristic. I made a change from the original submission to indicate that transcripts were not available, as I could not find them. There needs to be an important caveat to my decision to mark ""status of bills"" as present. I noticed that a lot of older bills (eg. from 2005) did not have any status updates on them other than ""referred to so-and-so committee). Some other bills from the same year did have updates (eg. approved by Deputies on a certain date). I am not sure of the reason why so many bills did not have updates. It could be because the bills just died in committee or it just takes very long for certain bills to move through the legislative process (eg. some bills introduced in 2005 were only voted on by the deputies in 2010). It is also a possibility that the government was not consistent on updating the status of all bills online. If this is the case than ""status of bills"" would have to be changed accordingly and the ""information up to date"" would probably also have to change. I was not able to prove the possibility of the government inconsistently providing status updates, so I am marking ""status of bills"" as present and B6 as a YES.
I updated the review after Enrique_Zapata's feedback. The only change that has been made is to change B5 to No. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Juela Xhaferraj","45","45"
"826f6d41-4080-4ebf-9306-5adb8ed9e289","global","2017-03-09T15:36:31","2016","mx","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://ordenjuridico.gob.mx/leyes.php provides texts of laws in html format (this no longer appears to be an option on the survey)\nLaws are also available as doc. and PDF files. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled \""leyes mexico\"" and I found it"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Camera de diputados (Chamber of Deputies); Supreme Court; Unidad General de Asuntos Juridicos "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The original submission had indicated that amendment to laws were not available. I changed the submission to indicate that they are made available. The content of the amendments of each law are very clearly presented inside a box on the first page of the law. The name of the amendment and date enacted are also identified.\nEnrique_Zapata also commented that all characteristics were present (but this was already indicated in the review, so B3 remains unchanged).""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.diputados.gob.mx/LeyesBiblio/index.htm"",""descValue"":""national congress website""},{""urlValue"":""https://legislacion.scjn.gob.mx/Buscador/Paginas/Buscar.aspx"",""descValue"":""Supreme Court website""},{""urlValue"":""https://ordenjuridico.gob.mx/leyes.php"",""descValue"":""Unidad General de Asuntos Juridicos - website""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The third source (https://ordenjuridico.gob.mx/leyes.php) was added after feedback from Enrique_Zapata on the forum https://discuss.okfn.org/t/joint-request-to-adjust-mexico-2016-godi-submissions/4439\nThis source provides more complete information (because it provides laws in HTML format) and therefore will be the point of reference for this updated review. ""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is an update of the previous review and it includes an added source for the data. The data set contains all the required characteristics. ","In my original review I had made only one change to the original submission, to indicate that amendments to laws were present. I updated the review after feedback from Enrique_Zapata. In this updated review I have added a third source. In light of this new source it also appears that HTML is an available format- but I did not make changes to the submission because HTML no longer appears to be an option listed in B8 (but I have indicated it on the comments). ","Yes","No","Juela Xhaferraj","Juela Xhaferraj","45","45"
"8b6d93e3-4a0d-4830-b1e6-cedd14a5d4d0","global","2016-12-09T11:22:28","2016","tr","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data are behind a search mask and captcha.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""open data index cytosine giriş yaptum. turkey'i secip company register bölümüne girdim. adımları takip ettim."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Turkish Standards Institution"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ticaretsicil.gov.tr/english/genel/veritabani.php"",""descValue"":""Union of Chambers and Commodity Exchanges of Turkey - Turkish Trade Registry Gazette""},{""urlValue"":""https://belge.tse.org.tr/Genel/FirmaArama.aspx"",""descValue"":""Turkish Standards Institution - Certified Company Search""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submitter has provided a link to the Union of Chambers and Commodity Exchanges of Turkey - Turkish Trade Registry Gazette website. However, data are available only on request and behind a paywall: ""Because the Turkish Trade Registry Gazette is not published with index information of companies, they are presented to users via the internet in exchange of a fee on a request to get information about a company. The information which exists in the Turkish Trade Registry Gazette Data-Base are shown below here: Name of Company, Trade Registry Number, Type of Announcement/ Explanation, Number of the Gazette, Page Numbers of the Announcements, City Code of the Company, Municipality Code of the Company. Index-information which have existed since 01.01.1992 till now in our web site, are given in exchange of 3.000 TL and the fee of a yearly subscription is 1.200 TL. Users wanting to get Turkish Trade Registry Gazette Index-information via the internet, have to make a remittance to the Turkish Trade Registry Gazette Bank Account, Türkiye İş Bankası Akay Branch. Branch number is 4201, Account number is 676466, then they have to post the extract of account with an application letter to BHDB.""
https://www.ticaretsicil.gov.tr/english/genel/veritabani.php
I was able to find that the Turkish Standards Institution, a related institution of the Ministry of Science, Industry and Technology, offers a ""Certified Company Search"" feature on their webpage. Company Name, Company Address, Company Phone, Fax, E-Mail, Certification Number, Last Validity Date, Province where document is given, Province of Company, Document Status, and Product Group are available online, free of charge, in .HTML format. However, one needs to know the name or certification number of an entity in order to find it, as well as enter a captcha code. Data cannot be downloaded in bulk, while update frequency and type of license are unknown.
https://belge.tse.org.tr/Genel/FirmaArama.aspx",,"Yes","No","Zeynep Yılmaz","Evangelia Kampouri","15","15"
"a0c9fae5-8f2f-43f5-a6cc-d6f7554effce","global","2016-12-02T05:33:33","2016","ua","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Though, there's no licence mentioned, terms of use are identical to Creative Commons Attribution 1.0 Generic https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/1.0/.\n\nI.e. the only requirement is to credit the source of data.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Zipped XML. XML contains non-UTF-8 charset. Previously it was CSV but changed to XML.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Direct links to full zip-archives are provided""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Updated once a week""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The data are available on demand""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Payment is required only for additional fields and API""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There are 3 places to find the data.\nIt was broadly announced on Facebook and other media.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Data can be found on Ukraine's open data portal, and on government agency's official sites"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Originally, the data were found on Facebook news feed, in the first hours of announcement. I think that technically skilled users who know nothing about it can found it in 10 minutes max.""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.ua/view-dataset/dataset?dataset-id=73cfe78e-89ef-4f06-b3ab-eb5f16aea237"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No formal license is mentioned, but the terms of use are on every page of open data portal.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""It is an official public company register in Ukraine. More info about this register on wiki: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q16157644""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Well, XML isn't quite user-friendly. You need to parse it and put to some database first. There are unofficial scripts on GitHub: https://github.com/datagovua/edrpou-uploader""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Justice of Ukraine"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""State Enterprise \""National Information Systems\"" administers registry on behalf of Ministry of Justice of Ukraine.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""In addition, economical activity NACE code, director and registration status are provided. More fields are available through online form.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://nais.gov.ua/text/248"",""descValue"":""description of dataset, source 1""},{""urlValue"":""https://nais.gov.ua/download/open_data/15-UFOP.zip"",""descValue"":""zip-archive of dataset, source 1""},{""urlValue"":""https://old.minjust.gov.ua/51257"",""descValue"":""description of dataset, source 2""},{""urlValue"":""https://old.minjust.gov.ua/downloads/15-UFOP.zip"",""descValue"":""zip-archive of dataset, source 2""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.ua/passport/73cfe78e-89ef-4f06-b3ab-eb5f16aea237"",""descValue"":""description of dataset, source 3""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.ua/view-dataset/dataset?dataset-id=73cfe78e-89ef-4f06-b3ab-eb5f16aea237"",""descValue"":""metadata of the dataset with history, source 3""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Description pages, direct and metadata links are provided""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
Company data including name, number, and address are available online free of charge, updated no later than 5 days after making changes, and downloadable at once in Zipped .XML format on three different web sources: the State Enterprise ""National Information Systems"" - Unified State Register of Legal Entities and Individuals - Entrepreneurs and Community Groups, the Ministry of Justice, and the Open Data portal. As the submitter has commented, State Enterprise ""National Information Systems"" administers registry on behalf of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine. Description pages, direct and metadata links are provided. Data can be found on Ukraine's open data portal, and on government agency's official sites. Originally, the data were found on Facebook news feed, in the first hours of announcement. In addition, economical activity NACE code, director and registration status are provided. More fields are available through online form. XML contains non-UTF-8 charset. Previously it was in .CSV but has now changed to .XML format. Payment is required only for additional fields and API. Direct links to full zip-archives are provided. No formal license is mentioned, but the terms of use are on every page of the open data portal. Though there's no licence mentioned, terms of use are identical to Creative Commons Attribution 1.0 Generic https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/1.0/ According to the submitter, .XML isn't quite user-friendly as you need to parse it and put to some database first. There are unofficial scripts on GitHub: https://github.com/datagovua/edrpou-uploader","Ukraine's company data was opened in April 2016.","Yes","Yes","Vanya Yani","Evangelia Kampouri","100","100"
"e0972a1e-dd22-46b6-aa85-79b23f831383","global","2016-12-13T07:21:30","2016","gb","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""JSON"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""A Met Office tutorial indicates the DataPoint service can now be used to download \""a complete list of the forecasts for every location in the UK at each available timestep\"" in either XML or JSON format. I have interpreted that as meaning the whole dataset is downloadable at once. (This obviates the need to revisit last year's debate about whether the separate API on Azure Marketplace really supplies bulk data.)""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Registration required.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""No steps as I was previously aware of the data source and its location. Met Office's DataPoint service is the first Google result returned based on a search for \""uk weather forecast data\"", so should be reasonably easy for unfamiliar users to find."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Met Office's DataPoint service is the first Google result returned based on a search for \""uk weather forecast data\"", so should be reasonably easy for unfamiliar users to find.""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/about-us/legal/tandc#Use-of-Crown-Copyright"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Open Government Licence applies to this data.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Availability of the data only in machine-readable formats via an API imposes a technical learning curve and therefore reduces the general accessibility of the data. Met Office could for example make the data more accessible by publishing a daily CSV extract of the dataset.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Met Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Precipitation Probability"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data source provides \""screen temperature\"" (the ambient temperature without the effect of wind chill or heat from the sun) and doesn't seem to provide separate data for averages vs extremes. The data source provides probability of precipitation based on precipitation of at lease 0.1mm but does not seem to estimate amounts.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/datapoint/product/uk-3hourly-site-specific-forecast"",""descValue"":""DataPoint UK 3-hourly site-specific forecast. Described as \""a quality controlled forecast out to 5 days for more than 5,000 locations.\""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Described as \""a quality controlled forecast out to 5 days for more than 5,000 locations.\""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is valid. Precipitation amount was added as a characteristics. The dataset describes it as ""Weather Type"" (alongside other weather types like sunny, clouded, etc.) Thank you, Owen Boswarva, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The data source provides ""screen temperature"" (the ambient temperature without the effect of wind chill or heat from the sun) and doesn't seem to provide separate data for averages vs extremes. The data source provides probability of precipitation based on precipitation of at lease 0.1mm but does not seem to estimate amounts.
A Met Office tutorial indicates the DataPoint service can now be used to download ""a complete list of the forecasts for every location in the UK at each available timestep"" in either XML or JSON format. I have interpreted that as meaning the whole dataset is downloadable at once. (This obviates the need to revisit last year's debate about whether the separate API on Azure Marketplace really supplies bulk data.)
Availability of the data only in machine-readable formats via an API imposes a technical learning curve and therefore reduces the general accessibility of the data. Met Office could for example make the data more accessible by publishing a daily CSV extract of the dataset.","Yes","No","Owen Boswarva","Danny Lämmerhirt","85","85"
"b190d234-2b3d-4a9d-9d61-5b1cc78dd2ca","global","2016-11-14T18:26:24","2016","se","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Swedish Competition Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Changed submission from no collection of data to no data available. There is a website where it is all explained but no data is published. You can download reports for every year in PDF. https://www.konkurrensverket.se/en/publicprocurement/",,"Yes","No","Peter Krantz","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"c2a06bb2-48ad-45e2-ba35-b3c77b4580f2","global","2017-02-03T17:38:04","2016","us","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""World Meteorological Organization (WMO) Resolution 40 NOAA Policy\nNCEI data and products that contain international data may have conditions placed on their international commercial use. They can be used within the United States or for noncommercial international activities without restriction. Redistribution of these data by others must provide this same notification. The non-U.S. data cannot be redistributed for commercial purposes. For details, please consult the WMO policy (link is external).\n\nhttps://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/customer-support""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google search "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""Public Domain - https://www.nws.noaa.gov/disclaimer.php"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's National Weather Service "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Precipitation Probability"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.nws.noaa.gov/ndfd/technical.htm"",""descValue"":""website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/data-access/quick-links"",""descValue"":""website""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is valid. Thank you, Katelyn Rogers, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","A note on the license: ""World Meteorological Organization (WMO) Resolution 40 NOAA Policy
NCEI data and products that contain international data may have conditions placed on their international commercial use. They can be used within the United States or for noncommercial international activities without restriction. Redistribution of these data by others must provide this same notification. The non-U.S. data cannot be redistributed for commercial purposes. For details, please consult the WMO policy (link is external)."" See further information at: https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/customer-support","Yes","Yes","Katelyn Rogers","Danny Lämmerhirt","100","100"
"977cc3be-b3b4-4772-aaaa-87cdbb1ccf29","global","2017-01-12T21:06:52","2016","za","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled tenders South Africa and found the source within the first page of search results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.etenders.gov.za/content/about-etenderpublication"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Republic of South Africa National Treasury"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.etenders.gov.za/"",""descValue"":""Republic of South Africa National Treasury""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Two sections of the platform to visualize the contract data. Changed the license information since the notice here https://www.etenders.gov.za/content/about-etenderpublication only gives information that the site is free to use, but nothing about the content and the reuse of the data. ",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Oscar Montiel","60","60"
"860e7d5d-4ed5-46e6-b604-f2308380654a","global","2017-03-09T12:16:24","2016","uy","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Navigate the website."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Uruguayo de Meteorología"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.meteorologia.com.uy/tiempo/estadoActual"",""descValue"":""Instituto Uruguayo de Meteorología, General weather data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.meteorologia.com.uy/reportes/tabla.pdf"",""descValue"":""Instituto Uruguayo de Meteorología, Metadata for weather data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.meteorologia.com.uy/reportes/pronosticos/prongral.pdf?1484166989"",""descValue"":""Instituto Uruguayo de Meteorología, Forecasts split by regional zones""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.meteorologia.com.uy/reportes/pronosticos/agro.pdf?1484166989"",""descValue"":""Instituto Uruguayo de Meteorología, Forecasts for agriculture""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.meteorologia.com.uy/modelos/prediccionNumerica/meteogramas"",""descValue"":""Instituto Uruguayo de Meteorología, Meteograms (weather maps) for all characteristics, presented on one comprehensive page""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The submission is valid, but was slightly modified. The data is not considered to be openly licensed based on a copyright note on the website (see here: https://www.meteorologia.com.uy/modelos/prediccionNumerica/gramet).
The original submission referred to following website (https://www.agesic.gub.uy/innovaportal/v/161/1/agesic/ley_nº_18381.html). But it is not clear whether this website is referring to weather data.
Thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"ce730a90-caf9-426a-861b-7685388e6fdf","global","2016-12-13T18:49:44","2016","si","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Copyright is claimed in the footer \""Uradni list d.o.o. (c) Vse pravice pridržane.\""\n\n\n""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Awarded contracts can be downloaded in CSV quarterly/yearly. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I queried an online search engine for \""e-procurement Slovenia\"". E-procurement website is one of the results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Uradni List, Republic of Slovenia (Official Journal)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.enarocanje.si/"",""descValue"":""Official Journal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes in the submission",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Oscar Montiel","65","65"
"db321069-e1a5-41ac-bdd0-beec22fce9d5","global","2016-12-05T14:14:00","2016","sk","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I followed URL from last year and I also searched data.gov.sk ."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.sk/organization/656F92FC-F8ED-4DA5-A9F5-1499E03AD575?license_id=cc-by"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Office for Public Procurement"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.uvo.gov.sk/"",""descValue"":""Portal of Office for Public Procurement""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.sk/organization/656f92fc-f8ed-4da5-a9f5-1499e03ad575"",""descValue"":""National Data Portal - list of datasets provided by Office for Public Procurement""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes in submission.","The data is available since 2009. It is updated daily and is quite detailed. In the past it was not available in structured machine-readable format but since 2016 daily dumps in XML format are being published and documented on data.gov.sk .
Regarding licensing: Licensing is assumed to be CC-BY (based on https://data.gov.sk/organization/656F92FC-F8ED-4DA5-A9F5-1499E03AD575?license_id=cc-by) but some datasets from same set lack licensing information (error in publishing automation is assumed).","Yes","Yes","Peter Hanecak","Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"37618e01-be75-4193-aaad-3f3e2bf6e60b","global","2017-03-09T11:43:26","2016","kn","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""St. Kitts and Nevis has three measurement stations. However it is unclear whether these are run by an own Meteorological Service or run by the Caribbean Meteorological Organisation (https://www.cimh.edu.bb/?p=archive). There is no official website: see here for evidence: https://www.cmo.org.tt/links.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission referred to data provided by the Meteorological Service of Antigua and Barbuda. Yet, it could not be verified which government agency is the official data producer for St. Kitts and Nevis.
Thank you, Alesha Aris, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","No other comments to add.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"dbb954df-746a-4e5a-9131-caa2bd5a6c2f","global","2017-03-09T11:37:41","2016","ve","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched for the government organisation providing weather data, using the World Meteorological Organisation database. Then I went on multiple sub-pages to find the data. The naming of these pages was not always clear, making it harder to find the data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Nacional de Meteorología e Hidrología "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.inameh.gob.ve/web/modelo_matematico.php"",""descValue"":""Instituto Nacional de Meteorología e Hidrología, Weather maps based on mathematical models""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.inameh.gob.ve/web/tiempo/tiempo.php"",""descValue"":""Instituto Nacional de Meteorología e Hidrología, ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No other comments to add","Historical data for precipitation amount, temperature extremes and wind speed can be found at: https://estaciones.inameh.gob.ve/descargaDatos/vistas/bajarArchivo.php
This interface allows to retrieve weather observations for each single measurement station (need to be requested individually). The data is available as XLS, and it seems that the original submission wrongly referred to this data.
Forecasts for current day and following two days are available at: https://www.inameh.gob.ve/web/tiempo/tiempo.php as well as under https://www.inameh.gob.ve/web/modelo_matematico.php
The forecasts are all presented as javascript features embedded on the website, or are published as PDF. They are not machine-readable.
Also it could not be verified wether the data is in public domain or not. An open license is missing, and a copyright notice states that all rights reserved to INAMEH. Therefore the reviewer changed the submission to ""No open license/no public domain"". ","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"458c8ff7-baeb-4791-bae9-1fbf67d0ffc7","global","2017-03-09T11:04:06","2016","ve","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Servicio Nacional de Contrataciones adscrito a la Comisión Central de Planificación"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The National Contracting Service - Central Planning Commission appears to be responsible for collecting company data. In fact, there is a ""Public Consultation of Registered Companies"" Search feature available on their website where one should be able to search entity information by using a company's name or RIF (Tax Information Registry) number. According to the submitter's comments, ""data including company name, address, and unique identifier are available online in .HTML and .TXT format, but can not be downloaded. In some cases the registration of the companies is updated (what must be done annually or when there are changes in the articles of incorporation), but in other cases the information is outdated, incomplete. The information is in the public domain because there are no access barriers to obtain it, but the platform does not expose any declarations of public domain to inform the user. You have to scrape the information in order to get the data and use it."" The submitter notes that the public consultation is one of the national government platforms that research journalists use the most to find information on state contracting companies. While the information is not available to download at once, the data are structured in a user-friendly way. However, I have been unable to verify this submission, as the website is not responding to any search queries. I have tried using different Venezuelan Company Names and RIF numbers (obtained through online searching) but every time, the search returns no results (note that it is not stated that no results were found, it simply does not produce any results). Perhaps it is a case of a glitch that will be resolved in the (near) future, but at the time being, I cannot obtain access to any data and therefore have no option but to mark the dataset as non-existent. https://rncenlinea.snc.gob.ve/reportes/consulta_publica?p=1 I have also tried accessing Venezuela's revenue service, SENIAT (Servicio Nacional Integrado de Administración Aduanera y Tributaria - National Integrated Service for the Administration of Customs Duties and Taxes), looking for a company tax identification code (RIF) search option, but the website seems to be down. https://www.seniat.gob.ve/",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"7fd343ac-52b4-4263-9518-5c3edd14fb71","global","2017-01-26T16:24:33","2016","us","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Terms of Use are not clearly given.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":"".HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went on the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) website, the \""search\"" feature is available under \""company filings\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Appears SEC now consolidates information, but unclear to what extent because the data are only able to be queried, not downloaded: https://www.sec.gov/edgar/searchedgar/companysearch.html\n\n""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.sec.gov/edgar/searchedgar/companysearch.html"",""descValue"":""EDGAR Company Search""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data are available free of charge on the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) website via EDGAR, the Electronic Data Gathering, Analysis, and Retrieval system. However, data are available through a search mask so one needs to know the name of an entity in order to find it. Company Name, CIK (Central Index Key) number, SIC (Standard Industrial Classification), State Location, State of Inc., Fiscal Year End, Business Address, and Filings are given in .HTML format. The dataset cannot be downloaded in bulk, and how often the data are updated is not stated. ","Similar to last year, company register data in the U.S. is maintained at the state level. However, it is worth it to take a deeper look into the SEC database to assess to what extent their dataset corresponds to state-level information.","Yes","No","Katherine Wikrent","Evangelia Kampouri","15","15"
"1a4ec037-44da-489d-80a2-f4f5cec68f19","global","2016-11-24T17:30:02","2016","rs","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No licence information, just label Open Data.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Link on portal for public procurements"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Public Procurement Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://portal.ujn.gov.rs/OpenData.aspx"",""descValue"":""CSV files with historical and up to date procurements""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes in submission.
No license information found. ",,"Yes","No","Aleksandar Ivić","Oscar Montiel","80","80"
"881143aa-a076-4b63-946e-f4f4e81e3346","global","2016-12-15T09:33:24","2016","bg","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Googled it. Also available as a link on the opendata portal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.parliament.bg/bg/rulesoftheorganisations"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""All bills are public domains per law. ""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Assembly of the Republic of Bulgaria "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.parliament.bg/bg/bills"",""descValue"":""Draft proposals""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.parliament.bg/bg/plenaryst"",""descValue"":""Voting records and discussions""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","The bills are all public as their status, authors and possible edit. The votes per party and individually per MP as well as the debates are published a few days after the sitting.
The votes are in Excel format and indicate the decision that has been voted in order throughout the day. Some of the decisions are procedural. Others affect if and how a bill will be voted. Others still affect individual parts, statements or even words of the bill. The transcripts have indications of these proceedings.
Content of bills are available in PDF and some in HTML.","Yes","No","Boyan Yurukov","Anton Shaffer","85","85"
"1d8ecf0c-2b7f-4f0e-93cd-82a3aff63140","global","2016-12-15T16:16:00","2016","th","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""National Law Assembly Website > Draft of the Law link"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Assembly"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://w3c.senate.go.th/"",""descValue"":""National Assembly Website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bb.go.th/bbweb/?page_id=6045"",""descValue"":""Thailand Bureau of the Budget website - Draft Budget Legislation only""},{""urlValue"":""https://w3c.senate.go.th/lawdraft.php"",""descValue"":""Direct Link to Draft Legislation""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
• Votes on Bills per member of parliament, nor transcripts of bill could not be located -- removed as 'checkmarked' selections from original submission.","The content of bills is available in PDF.","Yes","No","Phimluck Klangwichit","Anton Shaffer","45","45"
"d123311f-469b-4fd3-a766-66d3287f7776","global","2017-01-11T21:51:21","2016","uy","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I consider the data as updated, but now it is not updated in a monthly basis""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search National Open Data Catalogue and INE web site"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://datos.gub.uy/wps/wcm/connect/7fe4b346-b24c-4889-af2f-073897a1e97d/terminos-catalogodatos.pdf?MOD=AJPERES&ContentCache=NONE&CACHEID=7fe4b346-b24c-4889-af2f-073897a1e97d"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.agesic.gub.uy/innovaportal/v/161/1/agesic/ley_n%C2%BA_18381.html Art. 4 for INE's publication\n\n""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Industrias, Energía y Minería / Instituto Nacional de Estadísticas"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://catalogodatos.gub.uy/dataset/registro-de-empresas-industriales"",""descValue"":""Registro de empresas industriales""},{""urlValue"":""https://www3.ine.gub.uy:82/Anda4/index.php/catalog/64/related_materials"",""descValue"":""Directorio de pequeña y mediana empresa publicado por el INE""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The dataset is available online free of charge and downloadable at once on the Open Data portal via the Directory of Industrial Enterprises - Ministry of Industry, Energy and Mining, as well as on the National Institute of Statistics website - Directory of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises. However, it is updated only biannually on the Open Data portal, and the latest dataset on the National Institute of Statistics website is from 2011. Data are openly and publicly available, respectively.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","85","85"
"cb47d77f-b2c3-4517-80fb-0b372140a1ab","global","2016-12-14T20:29:59","2016","lv","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Regarding information reuse Likumi.lv points to the legislation that determines how this information can be reused and sets the fee for reuse (however, it is not clear what is meant by reuse and if, e.g., publishing law excerpts on a website requires paying the fee or not):\n\n https://likumi.lv/doc.php?id=254491\n https://likumi.lv/doc.php?id=249322#p18\n\nThe official publisher Latvijas Vestnesis does not receive budget funding for the maintenance of Likumi.lv. It is maintained from the earnings of Latvijas Vestnesis (including official publication and information reuse fees).""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Every legislative act has to be viewed separately.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I knew the URL of likumi.lv"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Almost everyone in Latvia who needs to look up laws know that it is available at likumi.lv""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Legislation is published as plain HTML pages and not in a structured format. Paragraphs have fragment identifiers (#p12, etc.) which provides some way to address parts of the legislation. Rating it as some effort required (though some might say it requires a lot of effort).""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Latvijas Vēstnesis - the official publication of the Republic of Latvia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://likumi.lv/about.php\n\nLatvijas Vēstnesis and likumi.lv is regulated by the Law on Official Publications and Legal Information: https://www.likumi.lv/doc.php?id=249322""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://likumi.lv"",""descValue"":""The official website providing free access to systematized (consolidated) legislation of the Republic of Latvia""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.vestnesis.lv/"",""descValue"":""the official publication of the Republic of Latvia""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""People are usually interested in the consolidated versions of laws available at likumi.lv while https://www.vestnesis.lv/ publishes official decisions which are incremental (you may have separate publications for the initial law and tens of amendments).\n\nIf there are any inconsistencies between these two sources, what was published in Latvijas Vēstnesis is the official version. That's why the law states that Latvijas Vēstnesis is the official publication and likumi.lv is for \""informative purposes\"".""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission fulfills all criteria. Per the submitter, ""people are usually interested in the consolidated versions of laws available at likumi.lv while https://www.vestnesis.lv/ publishes official decisions which are incremental (you may have separate publications for the initial law and tens of amendments). If there are any inconsistencies between these two sources, what was published in Latvijas Vēstnesis is the official version. That's why the law states that Latvijas Vēstnesis is the official publication and likumi.lv is for ""informative purposes""."" The reviewer was aware of the sources, although web searches with basic keywords only produce the Likumi link, and not Vestnesis. Vēstnesis translates most accurately to journal and searches including this keyword produces the link. The information is not available in a public domain, but is hosted and run by https://www.lv.lv/. The submitter provides more information in this regard, explaining that ""Likumi.lv points to the legislation that determines how this information can be reused and sets the fee for reuse (however, it is not clear what is meant by reuse and if, e.g., publishing law excerpts on a website requires paying the fee or not): see https://likumi.lv/doc.php?id=254491 or, https://likumi.lv/doc.php?id=249322#p18. The official publisher Latvijas Vestnesis does not receive budget funding for the maintenance of Likumi.lv. It is maintained from the earnings of Latvijas Vestnesis (including official publication and information reuse fees). The submitter originally indicated that the information was available in HTML, while the laws are available for download and are embedded as PDF. The submitter states that the information requires some effort as the information is contained in plain HTML. This was not my experience, however the rating remains the same to reflect the necessary effort to download the information available in PDF.",,"Yes","No","Uldis Bojars","Alyssa Beaton","60","60"
"869de9d6-0e66-45f7-a8da-fcb5513a819c","global","2016-12-08T20:54:59","2016","it","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON"",""RDF"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""cc-by https://dati.senato.it/sito/19?testo_generico=24"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Parlamento Italiano"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://dati.camera.it"",""descValue"":""Chamber of Deputies""},{""urlValue"":""https://dati.senato.it"",""descValue"":""Senate""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission fulfills all criteria. The information is readily available at both links. The link to the Senate offers draft legislation and voting information by individual senators (https://dati.senato.it) and detailed reports of draft titles and the date it was presented in Parliament, available in XML, JSON and CSV. The Parliament website provides historical and current voting, debates/discussion and chamber acts datasets available for download in RDF. I modified the submission to reflect the variety of downloadable file formats.",,"Yes","No","Maurizio Napolitano","Alyssa Beaton","85","85"
"947f2e30-a8bc-455b-9693-b24d533765d7","global","2016-12-31T09:00:32","2016","mm","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""There is no information nor evidence shown that the Myanmar President's Office is collecting the data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The official website to the Myanmar President's Officer https://www.president-office.gov.mm/en/""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","As submitter stated, there is no information nor evidence shown that the Myanmar President's Office is collecting the data.","There are no evidence to confirm that the data exist.","Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"bf4773bf-c477-4ac9-86f4-41b8cadf6cdf","global","2016-12-31T08:06:08","2016","id","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""General Election Commission (Komisi Pemilihan Umum)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The official website: https://kpu.go.id/index.php#""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted submission. Not all data is available, we are able to access only general results and number of registered votes, by electoral zone through PDF format (https://kpu.go.id/index.php# / https://www.kpu.go.id/koleksigambar/2014_Election_New_20-06-2016_LOW.pdf).",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"a4285e0a-b36a-407a-93dd-4f7ba3477a8c","global","2017-01-20T23:33:26","2016","gy","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Following through with investigating the legislative data sets on the Ministry of Legal Affairs website, I quickly connected to the draft bills"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is unofficial and has not been delivered to parliament therefore transcripts and votes are unrepresented ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Legal Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://mola.gov.gy/bills/draft-bills"",""descValue"":""Draft bills""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission does not fulfill all characteristics. While it includes content and author, the drafts are missing status, transcripts and votes. Per the submitter, the information is available at the following link: https://mola.gov.gy/bills/draft-bills. As indicated on the website, the submitter states that these drafts are unofficial and have not been read in Parliament. The data can be found by searching legislative data sets on the Ministry of Legal Affairs website. The submitter originally stated that the data is heavily out dated, though I changed the review to demonstrate that the information is up-to-date as the available drafts are all from 2016. The submitter stated that the data is not very usable without human effort, as it is unofficial and has not been delivered to parliament therefore transcripts and votes are unrepresented. Despite being unofficial and not read in parliament, these drafts are produced by the Attorney General/Minister of Legal affairs (indicated at the end of the documents) and the content of the draft is available for download.",,"Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Alyssa Beaton","45","45"
"59f009a5-425b-487e-90ef-66f433e294ba","global","2017-03-08T19:53:10","2016","gy","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Data was easily found after carrying out a google search for laws of guyana"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Legal Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://mola.gov.gy/information/laws-of-guyana"",""descValue"":""Laws of Guyana""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Laws of Guyana are available in PDF format at the following link: https://mola.gov.gy/information/laws-of-guyana. All data characteristics are available in the linked PDF documents. The original submitter, Alesha Aris, states that the data was easily found after carrying out a web search for ""laws of Guyana."" While the site is licensed to ""Copyright © 2017 Ministry of Legal Affairs. Government of Guyana. All rights reserved."" it is unclear if the information is updated within the required 3 months. However, the copyright maintains the current year, indicating that the page is current. ","Yes","No","Alyssa Beaton","Alyssa Beaton","60","60"
"14cd82b8-9508-4a44-b3ed-a684c2526a5b","global","2016-11-14T18:59:25","2016","se","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Attribution similar to CC-BY but not standardised license.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""TSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Exportable after search.\n\nReviewer: No direct bulk option was found at source. Proposing correction.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""High resolution on historical data. Unsure about near realtime.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Tried to locate it on the english version of the Swedish EPA website first but failed. Swedish version pointed to IVL."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www3.ivl.se/db/plsql/dvst_bensen_st$.startup"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""See license text at top of page.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Need to drill down search before being able to export the data.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Naturvårdsverket (IVL)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data hosting by a separate entity: IVL""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Based on list at https://www.ivl.se/sidor/omraden/miljodata/luftkvalitet.html""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ivl.se/sidor/omraden/miljodata/luftkvalitet.html"",""descValue"":""Website of IVL - data host""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted with slight correction on bulk data download: As no bulk data download is easily available(multiple selections and interactions needed).",,"Yes","No","Peter Krantz","Ricardo Alanís","85","85"
"2b3993ef-d5ea-4a83-a555-d1b1827e6990","global","2017-03-08T19:30:13","2016","kn","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Government of Saint Kitts and Nevis, Electoral Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission since website presented by submitter does not correspond to an official Government site, but a media outlet. By searching for official data, I was unable to find another website with reliable official elections information, only press releases (https://sknis.kn/prime-minister-harris-congratulates-new-prime-minister-of-saint-lucia-honourable-allen-chastanet/)
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"83822df7-9337-4f3b-922b-fb3b3ad01d06","global","2016-12-05T14:03:19","2016","sk","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I followed the link from last year and it still works."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Slovak hydrometeorological institute"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.shmu.sk/en/?page=991"",""descValue"":""SHMU Portal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections. ","Data is generally available (including benzene, thus also VOCs are assumed to be covered) and updated hourly. Data is available per monitoring station although not all station provide data for all categories.
Regarding licensing: Copyright statement at the bottom oft he portal roughly matches CC-BY-NC which does not meet Open Definition (disclaimer: IANAL).","Yes","No","Peter Hanecak","Ricardo Alanís","45","45"
"0b7020d3-3701-4535-856e-001e2e771eee","global","2016-11-22T07:13:16","2016","sg","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""JSON""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Users are required to sign up for an API key, as the data is provided in real time. ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search on Data.gov.sg"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data.gov.sg is the Singapore government portal for open data. ""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.sg/open-data-licence"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Environment Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Concentrations of SOx, NOx, CO and Ozone are published in the form of indices instead of raw measurements. \n\nReviewer: Removed NOx, CO and Ozone from the list, as raw data is needed.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.sg/dataset/psi"",""descValue"":""Hourly Pollutant Standards Index ""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.sg/dataset/pm2-5"",""descValue"":""Particular Matter 2.5""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted with corrections, Removed pollutants as they are reported in an index, instead of raw concentrations. TBD.",,"Yes","No","Zhaowei Lin","Ricardo Alanís","85","85"
"cca0d690-e66d-458e-bd93-7e098d35960f","global","2016-12-08T03:49:25","2016","rs","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Reviewer: Although some data is available in CSV format, no bulk data is available in the aggregation needed.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to SEPA.gov.rs, found the link to the newtork of automatic measurement stations in the main menu. I found SEPA's open data portal URL via data.gov.rs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""In accordance with Article 6 of the Law on Copyright and Related Rights, all official documents of state institutions do not enjoy copyright protection i.e. are in public domain"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Serbian Environment Protection Agency (SEPA)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Reviewer: Added VOC as Benzene is tracked in some stations,""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.amskv.sepa.gov.rs/?lng=en"",""descValue"":""National network of automatic stations for air quality monitoring""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.sepa.gov.rs/"",""descValue"":""SEPA open data portal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted with changes to consider Benzene as VOC.",,"Yes","No","Slobodan Marković","Ricardo Alanís","85","85"
"09f286c3-fc8a-4317-a30c-9e87c6ec94eb","global","2017-01-27T20:38:03","2016","us","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Poll-level data are not available, but state-level data are."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Federal Election Commission (FEC) does provide federal election data here, but the data are neither timely nor do they meet the OKFN criteria: https://www.fec.gov/pubrec/electionresults.shtml\n\n\""Every two years, the Commission publishes Federal Elections, a compilation of the official, certified federal election results obtained from each state’s election office and other official sources. The links provide the primary, runoff and general election results for the U.S. Senate, the U.S. House of Representatives and, when applicable, U.S. President.\""\n\n""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","As submitter stated, The Federal Election Commission (FEC) does provide federal election data here, but the data are neither timely nor do they meet the OKFN criteria (https://www.fec.gov/pubrec/electionresults.shtml). ""Every two years, the Commission publishes Federal Elections, a compilation of the official, certified federal election results obtained from each state’s election office and other official sources. The links provide the primary, runoff and general election results for the U.S. Senate, the U.S. House of Representatives and, when applicable, U.S. President.""
",,"Yes","No","Katherine Wikrent","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"075c8e1a-d801-430d-a0b1-488850242259","global","2016-12-12T19:10:36","2016","ro","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I changed the original submission to No. The original submitter provided the following URL as evidence:\nhttps://www.cdep.ro/pls/dic/site.page?id=794. \nOriginal submitter also included the following comment: \""Copyright Statement refers to copyright Law 8/1996 which states:\n\""Art. 9.— The following shall not benefit from the legal protection accorded to copyright:\n\n(b) official texts of a political, legislative, administrative or judicial nature, and official translations thereof\""\nhttps://www.wipo.int/wipolex/en/text.jsp?file_id=208582\""\n\nHowever, the website clearly states that:\""These textual data and multimedia items are the exclusive property of the Chamber of Deputies, and their reproduction is allowed only for noncommercial purposes, that the entire item is reproduced and the source\""\nFurthermore it makes clear that the data published on the site is not of official character. Therefore the law referred to by original submitter would not be applicable to the data. So B7 is a No.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Content of the bills in scanned PDF. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I queried a search engine for \""proiecte de legi România\"". Both chambers came up."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.cdep.ro/pls/dic/site.page?id=794"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Copyright Statement refers to copyright Law 8/1996 which states:\n\""Art. 9.— The following shall not benefit from the legal protection accorded to copyright:\n\n(b) official texts of a political, legislative, administrative or judicial nature, and official translations thereof\""\nhttps://www.wipo.int/wipolex/en/text.jsp?file_id=208582""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Senate and Chamber of Deputies, Romania"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I changed the original submission to indicate that \""votes\"" are not available. All other characteristics are present. For some bills, the author is just listed as \""government\"". This means that the prime minister himself proposed the bill. This is evident by the fact that he signs the \""Explanatory Memorandum\"" document, which the initiator of the bill signs. Sometimes, the name of the prime minister appears in conjunction with other ministers who are also initiators. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.cdep.ro/pls/proiecte/upl_pck.lista?cam=1&anp=2016"",""descValue"":""Legislative process in the Senate""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.cdep.ro/pls/proiecte/upl_pck.lista?cam=2&anp=2016"",""descValue"":""Legislative process in the Chamber of Deputies""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission will be accepted because all the required characteristics are present in the data set. ","As a reviewer I changed B3 to indicate ""votes"" were not present. While it was possible to find a summary of the vote (how many pro, how many against), I could not find names of each member and how they voted. I also changed B7 to No based on the information provided on the website. ","Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Juela Xhaferraj","60","60"
"c2412714-6502-4ffb-b898-2211419da53d","global","2017-01-25T08:03:19","2016","vc","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Ministry of Health, Wellness and the Environment"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://chm.pops.int/Portals/0/download.aspx?d=UNEP-POPS-NIP-SaintVincentandtheGrenadines-1.English.pdf"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections. No open data is found for this country.","I was unable to find an online portal that was suitable for this survey. However I did come across documentation that would suggest that data is being monitored in the field.
https://chm.pops.int/Portals/0/download.aspx?d=UNEP-POPS-NIP-SaintVincentandtheGrenadines-1.English.pdf","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"5e74cc80-353d-4ac0-b26f-25c4557d2609","global","2017-01-25T02:52:10","2016","lc","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Sustainable Development, Energy, Science and Technology"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted and confirmed data is not available.","According to a 2015 news report ""Air pollution is not specifically addressed in national law as an environmental concern and there are no nationally accepted standards in effect."" As such I was unable to find a reputable government based source online
https://www.stlucianewsonline.com/addressing-poor-air-quality-remains-national-priority-for-saint-lucia/","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"8c379d19-d89c-4e4d-8f24-1fa21665af1b","global","2016-12-20T20:47:40","2016","cl","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Conservador de Bienes Raíces"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is an agency for each region (state) in the country.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is a registration of land ownership but it is not public information. (https://www.conservador.cl/portal/) The site only allows you to manage your piece of land using your private information.""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Manuel Barros","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"6adbddb4-366b-477f-98fa-5bdd3a88f3f9","global","2016-12-21T14:00:29","2016","cl","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""correos de chile"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"f86a1ffa-76f6-4a97-8e9f-7f49276bbef0","global","2017-01-15T17:50:14","2016","zm","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Patents and Companies Registration Agency (PACRA) - the Zambian Ministry of Commerce, Trade and Industry as well as Zambia Revenue Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""-"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I am unsure.""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The Zambian Ministry of Commerce, Trade and Industry website doesn't seem to offer any company data online:
https://www.mcti.gov.zm/index.php/about-mcti/statutory-bodies/patents-and-companies-registration-agency
Visiting the Zambia Revenue Authority website and choosing ""Other e-Services"" from the left column, and then ""Taxpayer Search"", one can search entities by ""Tax Payer Name"" (i.e. Company Name). The results are given in .HTML however they can be exported to .XLS. They include Old TPIN No, Tax Payer Name, TPIN, Registration Date, Effective Cancellation Date, Status, and Tax Payer Type but no Company Address is given. Therefore, as not all required characteristics can be found online, the dataset is marked as non-existent:
https://www.zra.org.zm/WebContentMgmt.htm?actionCode=loadtaxPayerSearchDetail",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"3076a368-391f-4be7-9d7a-abcda3e97dd4","global","2017-01-17T14:31:52","2016","zw","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The Department of Deeds, Companies & Intellectual Property website as well as the Department of the Registrar General website are unresponsive. Thus, there is no way of knowing whether company data are collected by the government (or an official third party on behalf of the government), and if the dataset exists online.
www.dcip.gov.zw/
www.rg.gov.zw/",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"d9702c3a-8d17-49c4-983a-448373d9d4ce","global","2016-12-20T16:41:32","2016","cl","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There's no visible license.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Yo need to download different layers and datasets. Here: https://www.ide.cl/descarga/capas.html""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Not really sure. Impossible to know this. In the downloads section some datasets are up to date and some are not.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to the old index and then to de IDE website. I then explored it in search of a downloads section and the map visualization."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Infraestructura de Datos Geoespaciales - Ministerio de Bienes Nacionales"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ide.cl/"",""descValue"":""Geospatial Data Infrastructure's official website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.geoportal.cl/Visor/"",""descValue"":""Map visualization""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ide.cl/descarga/capas.html"",""descValue"":""Layers and data downloads""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Manuel Barros","Codrina Maria Ilie","50","50"
"c4bad7e3-91f6-48b2-a696-dce66c740c97","global","2016-12-20T10:54:38","2016","tn","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data are available through a search mask.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""write register ID and search "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""INNORPI - National Institute for Standardization and Industrial Property"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.registre-commerce.tn/"",""descValue"":""The Tunisian Register of Commerce (Registre de Commerece de Tunisie) website""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The Tunisian Register of Commerce (Registre de Commerece de Tunisie) website offers a company search feature. Interestingly, any searches I conducted by company name, Register of Commerce number, and tax identification number did not return any results and only after conducting a search with the Register State parameter set for ""active"" did I get a list of results. Once selected an entity's ""View More"" option, Registry Number, Legal Form, State of the Register, Company name, Trade name, and Address of Headquarters are provided. One has the option to buy available documents, including Company ID for 5,900 DT. Data are given in .HTML format and cannot be downloaded at once. The update frequency is also not known.
The Ministry of Industry and Trade - Institut National de la Normalisation et de la Propriete Industrielle website offers lists of certified companies in .PDF which include company name, scope of certification, address, and certificate number:
https://www.innorpi.tn/Fra/entreprises-certifiees_21_45
It might be worth noting that the Tunisian Industry Portal website by the Agency for the Promotion of Industry and Innovation offers the following features:
Directory of industrial enterprises search:
https://www.tunisieindustrie.nat.tn/en/dbi.asp
Directory of Service enterprises:
https://www.tunisieindustrie.nat.tn/en/dbs.asp
List of Tunisian Certified Enterprises:
https://www.tunisieindustrie.nat.tn/en/certifdbi.asp
However, while all three options provide company names and addresses, they do not include unique identifiers.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","15","15"
"7d51a7ba-f316-49dc-8830-5240e2891b6d","global","2017-01-29T19:00:47","2016","cm","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministère des domaines du cadastre et des affaires foncières"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Official website: https://www.mindcaf.cm/site/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The cadastre is currently expanded and modernized, including digitisation of cadastral data. More can be found on these two pages: https://www.mindcaf.cm/site/index.php/les-activites/direction-du-cadastre/137-modernisation-du-cadastre-pour-la-maitrise-de-la-gestion-de-l-espace-national
https://www.camerpost.com/cameroun-domaines-cadastre-affaires-foncieres-vers-linformatisation-procedures/","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"1155bd27-5ed2-4aef-bde5-6058a42ff2a3","global","2017-01-29T18:41:36","2016","cm","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""It seems that no official postal code system exists in Cameroon. This website states that instead a Global Postal Code System can be used. https://www.globalpostalcodesystem.info/Postal%20Code%20System%20of%20Cameroon.asp . Similar evidence provided by Universal Postal Union: https://www.upu.int/en/the-upu/member-countries/africa/cameroon.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","ok",,"Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"ecb16265-e45e-4b15-ab6d-64251a34d2dc","global","2017-01-27T18:38:11","2016","cm","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Institut National de Cartographie"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.inc.ayoos.com/index.php""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","ok",,"Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"2eb8ce6e-b960-42c6-9b31-1d131c836dcc","global","2017-03-07T21:35:09","2016","kh","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is a viewing service, with no available ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I don't know. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The view service is free of charge""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""googled postcodes Cambodia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It's just a view service. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Posts and Telecommunications - Cambodia Post"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Zipcodes"",""Addresses"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Data available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://cambodiapost.post/en/cambodia-post-codes-2/"",""descValue"":""View service of postcodes""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","ok","According to the Universal Postal Union, the official entity in charge of postcode management is Cambodia Post, a public enterprise of the Ministry of Posts and Telecommunications. There is also a Gazetteer Database Online, maintained by the National Committee for Sub-national Democratic Development (NCDD).
","Yes","No","Codrina Maria Ilie","Codrina Maria Ilie","30","30"
"465ed251-bbc8-47c0-8617-d06db413eb4c","global","2017-01-20T02:05:42","2016","tt","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Found the link under the \""Online Services\"" Menu on the Companies Registry - Ministry of the Attorney General and Legal Affairs website https://www.legalaffairs.gov.tt/companies.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Companies Registry - Ministry of the Attorney General and Legal Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.legalaffairs.gov.tt/companies.html""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data are behind a search mask and one needs to know the name of an entity in order to find it.""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://rgd.legalaffairs.gov.tt/"",""descValue"":""the Companies Registry Online Search Facility""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submitter was under the impression that data were not available online free of charge and without providing a type of identification. Indeed, the cost of downloading a copy of a file is $20.00 TTD (files are in PDF format). However, data are available via the Companies Registry Online Search Facility where one needs to know the name of an entity in order to find it. Results include company name, number, address, date of incorporation, name suffix, and status in .HTML format. Results cannot be downloaded in bulk, and update frequency of the data is unknown. ","Additional information found on the RGD site ""All documents filed at the Companies Registry may be searched by members of the public. Registration number of business name or company must be produced when making request. Identification Card, Driver's Permit or Passport must be produced.
Search fee: $20.00 per company file/document.""
This suggest that the data carries a fee for access and requires in person application","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Evangelia Kampouri","15","15"
"d4a84fa2-24c8-4b80-819f-63cd52542107","global","2017-01-27T17:08:27","2016","cr","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1. Google search: \""Costa Rica national budget\"" / 2. Select second result from Ministry of Finance website / 3. Look for national budget on the menu. These steps took me to the central government budget only. To find the whole national budget I had to go to the Contraloría de la República website, that is not in the Google results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Contraloría General de la República"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://cgrweb.cgr.go.cr/apex/f?p=10263:2:0:::::"",""descValue"":""Website of Contraloría General de la República""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.hacienda.go.cr/contenido/13889-ley-de-presupuesto-de-la-republica-2017"",""descValue"":""Website of Ministry of Finance""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Comment reviewer: the first link in B2.2 (https://cgrweb.cgr.go.cr/apex/f?p=10263:2:0:::::) was not working and I have based my review on this link (https://www.hacienda.go.cr/contenido/13889-ley-de-presupuesto-de-la-republica-2017).
The data is available in PDF, and xls, the xls provide a lot of detail. The problem is with the unavailability of bulk download.
The data for 2017 was available, so I changed the question B6 from no to yes, and the question B8, I removed csv, because I could not find that in the provided links. ","Submission originally made by Susana Soto","Yes","No","anonymous","Anna Alberts","65","65"
"b85fbcd0-16ee-4682-a41b-88508969c992","global","2016-12-19T18:10:00","2016","cl","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to the old index, found the resources and started from there."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/cl/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There are two different license, depending on the site where you check the data.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Dirección de Presupuestos del Ministerio de Hacienda"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://datos.gob.cl/dataset/ley-de-presupuestos-del-sector-publico-ano-2016"",""descValue"":""Portal de Datos del Gobierno""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dipres.gob.cl/594/w3-propertyvalue-22939.html"",""descValue"":""Sitio DIPRES""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Review: accept",,"Yes","Yes","Manuel Barros","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"a7d97d1f-a329-41f4-a721-5d948ac638ec","global","2017-01-16T18:55:06","2016","ca","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Note non commercial re-use clause https://www.canada.ca/en/transparency/terms.html""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""As per category""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google, then Contacted TBSC Open Data, Then Contacted CivicAccess List"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Expertise is required but excellent documentation is provided.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Treasury Board Secretariat of Canada"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.tbs-sct.gc.ca/hgw-cgf/finances/pgs-pdg/gepme-pdgbpd/index-eng.asp"",""descValue"":""Government Expenditure Plan and Main Estimates (Parts I and II) - PDFs""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.canada.ca/en/treasury-board-secretariat/services/planned-government-spending/budgets-expenditures.html"",""descValue"":""Government of Canada budgets and expenditures: Tables""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Comment Reviewer: accept. ","The data on this site are not explicitly open, however similar datasets are uploaded to the Open Data Portal. It is difficult to assess which licence applies as the producing institution states one licence and once deposited in a portal a separate licence applies. I have chose the more restrictive. Also, note, that once the data are in the open data portal, it is difficult to assess if this is a complete collection, or if incomplete to know what is missing as there is not authority stated and there is no note to explain whether or not this is a complete set.","Yes","No","anonymous","Anna Alberts","80","80"
"6300340d-3149-4cdb-acdd-3b67339bbe6c","global","2017-01-05T14:25:22","2016","cm","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Comments Reviewer: I googled the ministry of Finance of Cameroon, and in the side-bar the budget document in PDF is shown. But if you google the Law of the budget in Cameroon, the cameroon info article shows up and this a better document. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.minfi.gov.cm/"",""descValue"":""The ministry of finance website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.minfi.gov.cm/images/documents/loi_de_finances_2017_anglais.pdf"",""descValue"":""The actual budget in PDF - however scanned in""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.cameroon-info.net/article/cameroun-finances-lintegralite-de-la-loi-de-finances-2017-278037.html"",""descValue"":""Article to the budget with a proper PDF file""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Comment reviewer: at the time of the review, the budget for Cameroon 2017 was published. It was published in December 2016, so could still be used for this survey. However it was published very poorly from the governments side, in scanned in PDFs. And the data itself contained very little details. ","At this time, the Ministry of finance has not yet published the 2017 budget online.","Yes","No","Charlie Martial NGOUNOU","Anna Alberts","60","60"
"48c138dd-5469-4973-9bb0-d92dd413c582","global","2016-12-01T19:01:59","2016","si","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""For personal, non-commercial use only, see Article 14 of the Terms of Use https://www.uradni-list.si/0/legal""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF and DOC are also offered.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Updated regularly.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""For personal, non-commercial use only.""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried a web search engine for the Official Journal of Slovenia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Official Journal of Republic of Slovenia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.pisrs.si/Pis.web/"",""descValue"":""Legal Information System of Republic of Slovenia""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.uradni-list.si"",""descValue"":""Official Journal of Republic of Slovenia""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.pisrs.si/Pis.web/pravniRedRSDrzavniNivoKazalaTematskoKazalo"",""descValue"":""National Lebel - Basic Acts - Example of a category in the Legal Information System""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
Modified to include 'Dates of Amendment' and 'Amendments' as available data. Both can be found on the Law Database websitewww.pisrs.si/Pis.web/ -- The Dates of Amendments is included as a description of ""the process of preparation and adoption of this regulation"" in text form.
","Content of Laws is also offered in PDF and DOC format.
The Law Database website is ""For personal, non-commercial use only"", see Article 14 of the Terms of Use https://www.uradni-list.si/0/legal","Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Anton Shaffer","45","45"
"56ca6b4a-4d9a-47f0-932e-783f73d7f865","global","2016-12-31T10:55:38","2016","kh","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""General Department of Cadastre and Geography"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This department is under the Ministry of Land Management, Urban Planning & Construction.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","ok","There is no information nor evidence shown that the data exist","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"166d826c-1bfc-4395-aae3-89c1a792cf96","global","2017-01-29T20:35:46","2016","kn","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Sustainable Development "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections. No data was found from governmental sources.","Unfortunately I was unable to identify a government portal for the given datasets.
","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"3a92bda8-9431-4340-97aa-c7e84a22b20c","global","2016-12-30T18:09:16","2016","ru","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal Service for Hydrometeorology and Environmental Monitoring of Russia (Roshydromet)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections. Confirmed with other sources the description given by reviewer.","Russian air pollutants data collected by two Russian federal agencies. Primary agency is Federal Service for Hydrometeorology and Environmental Monitoring of Russia (Roshydromet).
Yearly air pollution quality report prepared and published by The Voeikov Main Geophysical Observatory. It's subsidiary research facility of Roshydromet. Organization website - https://www.voeikovmgo.ru/ (Rus)
Last report was published for 2015 year https://www.voeikovmgo.ru/images/stories/publications/2016/ejegodnik_zagr_atm_2015.pdf (Rus)
first report was public and online since 2006 year https://www.voeikovmgo.ru/download/publikacii/2008/Ezegodnik2006.pdf (Rus)
This report is highly incomplete in terms of open data.
Data for report collected from 688 stations from 249 cities (2015 year) but for report it's aggregated to sub-regional level and much lesser information for each city.
Very limited data like ""most polluted cities"" and ""average air pollution for regions"" available at Voeinkov facility website https://www.voeikovmgo.ru/index.php/ru/struktura/otdel-monitoringa-i-issledovanij-khimicheskogo-sostava-atmosfery/laboratoriya-analiza-i-otsenki-sostoyaniya-zagryazneniya-atmosfery (Rus) but it's not open data and even not machine-readable data too. And it's incomplete, not all cities covered and no numeric data provided.
Also this data is not published in official Roshydromet repository - https://www.meteorf.ru/opendata/ (Rus) on it's official website
2. Second agency is ""Federal Service for Supervision of Consumer Rights Protection and Human Welfare"" (Rospotrebnadzor).
This agency also collects data about water and air pollutants but it's network is even more ""shadowed"" than Roshydromet one. No data available at agency website https://rospotrebnadzor.ru/ (Rus) and it's official open data repository - https://opendata.rospotrebnadzor.ru/
I've visited every website of every facility owned by Rospotrebnadzor but no one provides not reports similar to Roshydromet report, not raw data.
So requirement ""Data should be available for all air monitoring stations or air monitoring zones in a country."" is not matched for this data in Russia.
Disclaimer: I am founder of NGO ""Informational Culture"" and OKI Ambassador in Russia (member of OKI Russia core team). I have no any affilation with Roshydromet or Rospotrebnadzor.
","Yes","No","Ivan Begtin","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"1dd9bb0f-9ff3-4b8e-a588-117f6807d976","global","2017-01-17T23:24:27","2016","bs","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Registrar General's Department."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The Registrar General's Department website offers the option of a Company Search so as to search the company's database of company files and documents. However, in order to gain access to the data, one needs to take the following steps:
1. Registration at the Government Portal (receive access codes)
2. Logon to Registry Services
3. Select Company Search
4. Enter company details
5. Enter Credit or Debit Card information
6. After approval, print receipt
7. Conduct Company Search
Link: goo.gl/a3pURa
As I am unable to verify whether the dataset is available online, I have no option but to mark it as non-existent.","Unable to identify a portal with Bahamas' Company register data ","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"b4e4d3cb-a0d8-4a2d-8f24-3b134245422d","global","2016-11-26T13:35:08","2016","ro","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Entered https://data.gov.ro and searched for \""emisii\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.ro/base/images/logoinst/OGL-ROU-1.0.pdf"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Agency for Environmental Protection"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.ro"",""descValue"":""/dataset/emisii_totale""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.ro"",""descValue"":""/dataset/emisii_in_apa""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.ro"",""descValue"":""/dataset/emisii_in_aer""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.ro"",""descValue"":""/dataset/emisii_totale_pulberi""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.ro"",""descValue"":""/dataset/emisii_in_sol""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections. Data is found as described here.",,"Yes","No","Oana Funaru","Ricardo Alanís","85","85"
"e4b0f55a-1a35-4ebf-ae73-0cf177299991","global","2016-12-15T15:06:12","2016","th","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""JSON""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I went through the https://data.go.th/ website and I found the กฎหมาย ศาล และ อาชญากรรม (Law, Crime, and Justice) section. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.go.th/LicenceDetails.aspx?id=3a937417-8ccb-42a1-8923-a920851008db&ReturnId=f628f08d-b45e-4f56-906d-ca52131c31ed https://web.krisdika.go.th/data/outsitedata/banner/file/WebsitePolicy.pdf https://web.krisdika.go.th/data/outsitedata/banner/file/PrivacyPolicy.pdf https://web.krisdika.go.th/data/outsitedata/banner/file/WebsiteSecurityPolicy.pdf"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Royal Thai Government Gazette Secretariat of the Cabinet. Office of the Prime Minister Electronic Government Agency (Public Organization) (EGA)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.krisdika.go.th/wps/portal/general"",""descValue"":""Office of the Council of State National Law Database""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.go.th/Datasets.aspx"",""descValue"":""Office of Electronic Government data center""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ratchakitcha.soc.go.th/RKJ/special/search.jsp"",""descValue"":""Royal Thai Government Gazette - Searchable Database""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
Some of the data from the original submission has been re-arranged or condensed, specifically URL and related descriptions. Links were modified to ensure more direct access.
The National Law website does not currently have a clear capacity to download all files at once, original answer has been modified to No.","• Legislation by the Ministry of the Interior at EGA has worked with all government agencies to place their government data on the www.data.go.th in an open format and data being free of charge.
• Section 1021 of the Civil and Commercial Code of Thailand requires the information to be revealed. People can search for this information on the Royal Thai Government Gazette website, www.mratchakitcha.soc.go.th At the moment, Thailand’s constitutions and every other law are regularly published on the Royal Thai Government Gazette, www.mratchakitcha.soc.go.th. The website is administered by the Secretariat of the Cabinet. People can search for Thailand’s constitutions, Acts, Emergency Decrees, Royal Decrees, Ministerial Regulations, Ministerial Announcements, and Regulations of the Office of the Prime Minister etc. on this website.
• Content of National Laws (https://www.krisdika.go.th) are also available in these additional formats: PDF, TIF. Some metadata available via JSON on (https://www.data.go.th
","Yes","No","Phimluck Klangwichit","Anton Shaffer","85","85"
"b9e19ad6-eba5-4f30-821b-88b8139e3929","global","2016-12-15T11:29:34","2016","ph","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Environment and National Resources - Environmental Management Bureau"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Not sure, but it doesn't seem like it.""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections. Other sources point on PDF reports. The WHO reports that 3 cities currently report air pollution but no data was found.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"e8db6399-8ff6-4e55-b0d7-2cf5f380a976","global","2017-02-02T02:22:14","2016","pk","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry Of Climate Change, Pakistan Environmental Protection Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections. Confirmed data is not available.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"ba21702b-2cda-4caf-bc2d-e043fd6ba9b9","global","2016-12-15T09:42:01","2016","bg","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""GeoJSON"",""KML"",""SHP"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It's aba""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""There's a link on pretty much any government website, as well as the gov registry list. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Registry agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Parcel boundaries (inc. latitude and longitude)"",""Parcel ID"",""Property value (i.e. Price Paid, Property Tax Value)"",""Tenure Type (ie. leasehold, freehold, protected lands, public lands, customary lands)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.icadastre.bg/"",""descValue"":""land ownership registry""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The parcel ID and border data is openly available, free of charge and easy to use. The ownership however is protected as personal information by law. Therefore registration and fees apply.","Yes","No","Boyan Yurukov","Codrina Maria Ilie","35","35"
"c3e76dc1-3c40-4f41-ae2a-c612a98af740","global","2017-03-07T17:40:58","2016","tn","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is provided in the following URL:https://www.arp.tn/site/projet/AR/index.jsp?c_t=17&prof=5\nThis website contains content of bill, status and transcripts of debates. However, the data is missing a required characteristic: author of the bill. As a reviewer I can not read Arabic and could not read the full text of the bill. Based on gr33ndata's feedback on the forum I came to the conclusion that author is not available. According to gr33ndata bills contain signatures of submitters, but it is difficult from the signature to determine who the person is. \nAn optional characteristic, votes, were also missing from the data (the original submission also indicated this)""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""ARP"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission was rejected because the data set did not contain all required characteristics. This submission is updated to indicate that data is not made available. ","The original submission was rejected because a required characteristic, author of bill, was missing. In my opinion (and also that of Alyssa Beaton's from Open North), mere signatures where it is difficult to discern the identity of the individual are insufficient for ""author of bill"" to be present. The original submission had indicated the following for the data:
- Free of charge: yes
- Downloadable at once: no
- Up to date: yes
-open licence: yes (actually, this should be a no)
- formats: html, rtf (I could only find data in pdf). ","Yes","No","anonymous","Juela Xhaferraj","0","0"
"7d56b264-1187-4031-a4a3-86884b3e2558","global","2017-03-07T17:37:54","2016","bg","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bulgarian Post"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""According to the Universal Postal Union. ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Drenusha Myha for the contribution.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"de96d466-8f40-4fd8-ac13-e884f93dc800","global","2017-03-07T17:25:55","2016","ba","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal Administration for Geodetic and Property Affairs and Republican Administration for Geodetic and Property Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Arianit Dobroshi for the contribution.","Some relevant data is available on
https://www.katastar.ba/geoportal/preglednik/ for the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina
https://www.geoportal.rgurs.org:9080/katastar2/action/search/index?interni=false for the Republika Srpska. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"d62617ec-af79-44c4-b203-37c1af5a4b0b","global","2016-12-15T15:19:13","2016","th","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I went through the https:www.data.go.th website and I found the เศรษฐกิจ การเงิน และอุตสาหกรรม(Economy, Finance, and Industry) or กรมพัฒนาธุรกิจการค้า (Department of Business Development) on the site."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.go.th/LicenceDetails.aspx?id=3a937417-8ccb-42a1-8923-a920851008db&ReturnId=cf4f29ce-5ebe-43b8-8c09-7352830f2f5e"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Business Development Electronic Government Agency (Public Organization) (EGA)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.go.th/DatasetDetail.aspx?id=f628f08d-b45e-4f56-906d-ca52131c31ed"",""descValue"":""Data set of Department of Business Development to place their government data on the www.data.go.th in an open format and data being free of charge. ""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.go.th/DatasetDetail.aspx?id=ffe0737c-e9d9-40be-89bb-46d2a109b383"",""descValue"":""Data set of Department of Business Development to place their government data on the www.data.go.th in an open format and data being free of charge. ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dbd.go.th/ewt_news.php?nid=12385&filename=index"",""descValue"":""Department of Business Development When the Department of Commercial Registration was firstly established, the duties of responsibilities of the department during that time are the maintenance of measurement, and the commercial registration. Originally, the measurement and the commercial registration duties, namely, company partnership, insurance, trademark, and patent, are under the responsibilities of other Ministries, Sub-ministries, and departments and we can summarize the history as follows: Measurement Commercial Registration""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
Company data are available free of charge on the Open Data portal as well as on the Department of Business Development website under ""New Establishment list"". The dataset is publicly available in .CSV and .XLS format, updated monthly and downloadable at once. Dataset includes Registration number, Corporate name, date registered, Registered capital (Baht), code objective, Objective details, and Head office (address). ",,"Yes","Yes","Phimluck Klangwichit","Evangelia Kampouri","100","100"
"b621b23c-f822-427f-bebe-7aa67285d8f9","global","2017-01-26T05:17:31","2016","kn","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: Statistics Department information can be found on main government website (https://www.gov.kn/) but no datasets available""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Statistical Department (Ministry of Sustainable Development)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended government agency name""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Alesha Aris for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Amended agency name to Statistical Department (Ministry of Sustainable Development).","Unfortunately I was unable to identify a government portal for the given datasets.","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Sophie Lafayette","0","0"
"a1b2eb05-1d7b-4706-b80d-0ecfcf0d79cd","global","2016-12-11T13:32:37","2016","ba","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""They are for BH Pošta (see box on the left-bottom here https://www.posta.ba/stranica/2/23/36.html#Postal_Network) but not for Pošte Srpske (search for settlements here https://www.postesrpske.com/sites/state/en/postal/portal/advancedsearchpost.aspx? does not return results).""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""BH Pošta and Pošte Srpske"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The two companies serve the two respective entities in Bosnia and Herzegovina.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""They are for BH Pošta but not for Pošte Srpske""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","ok",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"30df737e-5f98-4ebe-9eb0-7d612d17a1a2","global","2016-12-13T15:38:20","2016","om","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""GDP is a couple of years old, also some population sub-categories are a couple of years old. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Big icons are found on the home page that allow you to select the dataset you want toview."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.data.gov.om/Content/Oman/en/TermsOfUse.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to 2 as limited file formats available.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Centre for Statistics and Information"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: statistics bulletins contain information on labour and job seekers but not specifically unemployment""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.data.gov.om/"",""descValue"":""Official Data Portal""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ncsi.gov.om/Pages/NCSI.aspx"",""descValue"":""National Centre for Statistics and Information main site""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ncsi.gov.om/Pages/NCSI.aspx"",""descValue"":""National Centre for Statistics and Information (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.data.gov.om/en/Dashboards"",""descValue"":""Data dashboards (population & GDP)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added link to National Centre for Statistics and Information & data dashboards""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Riyadh Al-Balushi for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. B9 amended to 2 as limited file formats available. Statistics bulletins contain information on labour and job seekers but not specifically unemployment.","The official Omani data portal provides statistics on population, GDP, oil prices, international trade, public finance, and other topics, but not unemployment. The data in many of these sections does not appear to be up to date, with some not being updated for more than two years.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Sophie Lafayette","85","85"
"9d1112f4-1d4f-42f0-ad00-aaf51c41f125","global","2016-12-11T12:03:33","2016","ba","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Federation data are copyrighted. See statement in the footer \""© 2015 - Sva prava su zadržana\"". (all rights reserved)\n\nFor Srpska, \""Site content may not be distributed, modified, displayed-reproduce, sell, copy or otherwise use and make available to third parties without the written consent of RGURS.\"" https://www.geoportal.rgurs.org/termsOfUse.html""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Full offering for the Federation https://www.katastar.ba/servisi\n\nFull offering for Srpska https://www.geoportal.rgurs.org/erdas-apollo/catalog/""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""For the Federation, provided that services are counted as such.\n\nSrpska seems to be offering a download option, I was unable to test it however due to technical issues.\nreviewer: it has not worked during review. \n\n""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried a web search engine for \""E-katastar BiH\"". Two entity cadaster websites are among the results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal Administration for Geodetic and Property Affairs and Republican Administration for Geodetic and Property Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.katastar.ba/geoportal/preglednik/"",""descValue"":""FGO Geoportal""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.geoportal.rgurs.org/geoportal/"",""descValue"":""Geospatial Portal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Description of available data for the Federation also here https://www.katastar.ba/servisi\n\nSrpska portal seems very buggy.""}]","Yes","Yes"," As I understand, Bosnia and Herzegovina has 2 main entities: Republika Srpska and the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina that govern themselves. Thus, there are 2 official geoportals: https://www.katastar.ba/geoportal/preglednik/ for the Federation and https://www.geoportal.rgurs.org/geoportal/ for Srpska. They run on different systems and have different layers and categories. With respect to the national maps theme, I have to chose data is not available online as the Srpska geoportal has been unresponsive for a period of 2 weeks, during this review. Except the OSM layer, I could not see any topographic map or ortophoto. ",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Codrina Maria Ilie","30","30"
"e1f68c99-44c7-4f5f-b80b-a89cdc37864b","global","2017-01-12T16:15:00","2016","no","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON"",""TSV"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""JSON = JSON-Stat. Update: added XLS, XLM, & TSV format (can be downloaded through StatBank)""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: unemployment monthly, population & GDP quarterly""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Looked up organisation on data.norge.no and found the corresponding dataset."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.norge.no/nlod"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: Statistisk sentralbyrå/Statistics Norway also refers to open license https://www.ssb.no/en/informasjon/copyright""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Statistisk sentralbyrå/Statistics Norway "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.norge.no/data/statistisk-sentralbyr%C3%A5/api-mot-statistikkbanken-til-ssb"",""descValue"":""Entry on national open data portal (data.norge.no)""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.ssb.no/"",""descValue"":""Statistics Norway's own page about open data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ssb.no/"",""descValue"":""Statistisk sentralbyrå/Statistics Norway (Norwegian)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ssb.no/statistikkbanken/selecttable/hovedtabellHjem.asp?KortNavnWeb=regledig&CMSSubjectArea=arbeid-og-lonn&PLanguage=1&checked=true"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ssb.no/statistikkbanken/selecttable/hovedtabellHjem.asp?KortNavnWeb=folkemengde&CMSSubjectArea=befolkning&PLanguage=1&checked=true"",""descValue"":""Population data (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ssb.no/en/nasjonalregnskap-og-konjunkturer/statistikker/knr/kvartal/2017-02-09?fane=tabell#content"",""descValue"":""GDP data (English)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added link to Statistisk sentralbyrå/Statistics Norway, the main government agency & links to population, GDP, and unemployment data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Bergheimivar L for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Statistisk sentralbyrå (Statistics Norway) is the main government agency. Added XLS, XLM, & TSV formats. ","Would be a very useful feature to be able to populate this form with data from last year, and then review that the entries are still correct.","Yes","Yes","Bergheimivar L","Sophie Lafayette","100","100"
"196638dc-eb2f-4b66-abfb-027e4eb613a5","global","2016-12-15T15:01:48","2016","nir","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The Crown copyright protected material (other than departmental or agency logos) may be reproduced free of charge in any format or medium, under the terms of the Open Government Licence (www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/version/3/) This is subject to the material being reproduced accurately and not used in a misleading context. ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: files in ODS can be converted to XLS""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: amend to yes; population yearly, unemployment quarterly, GDP quarterly""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched for keywords on https://www.ninis2.nisra.gov.uk/public/Home.aspx"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.ninis2.nisra.gov.uk/public/Terms.aspx"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Northern Ireland Statistics and Research Agency (NISRA)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ninis2.nisra.gov.uk/Download/Labour%20Market/Claimant%20Count%20Long%20Term%20Unemployed%20Annual%20Averages%20(administrative%20geographies).ods"",""descValue"":""Unemployment ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ninis2.nisra.gov.uk/Download/Economy/Regional%20Gross%20Value%20Added%20(Income%20Approach).ods"",""descValue"":""Gross Value Added (GVA) is a measure of the increase in the value of the economy due to the production of goods and services. It is measured at current basic prices, which include the effect of inflation, excluding taxes (less subsidies) on products (for example Value Added Tax). GVA plus taxes (less subsidies) on products is equivalent to Gross Domestic Product (GDP).""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ninis2.nisra.gov.uk/Download/Population/Population%20Estimates%20-%205%20year%20age%20bands%20(administrative%20geographies).zip"",""descValue"":""National population ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.nisra.gov.uk/"",""descValue"":""NISRA main site""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.nisra.gov.uk/demography/default.asp3.htm"",""descValue"":""Population data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added link to main site, population, GDP, and unemployment data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Open DataNI for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Amended B6 to yes. ",,"Yes","Yes","Open DataNI","Sophie Lafayette","100","100"
"69c083fb-4de1-4d8c-a368-3b4e7b0d9211","global","2017-01-31T16:50:11","2016","bo","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Nacional de Reforma Agraria"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.inra.gob.bo/InraPb/paginaController?cmd=contenido&id=6668#""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","ok",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"b6e83c58-68da-434f-ac89-bff85dd1bb97","global","2017-01-31T16:44:06","2016","bo","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" Empresa de Correos de Bolivia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","ok",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"3752e67d-a7b4-43d4-b3e6-d390354d06c9","global","2016-12-30T09:49:40","2016","bt","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Land Commission of Bhutan"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","ok",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"ebf99aee-8748-4d3b-afd3-30879e7f24ed","global","2017-03-07T15:23:12","2016","bt","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bhutan Post "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""According to the Universal Post Union. ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"772f8515-eb35-4e88-bf75-ae5b2ef16935","global","2016-12-27T13:37:15","2016","tz","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Business Registrations and Licensing Agency (BRELA)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The Business Registrations and Licensing Agency (BRELA) responsible for collecting the data doesn't seem to openly offer company information on their website:
https://www.brela.go.tz/
There could be an Online Official Search feature via the ""Online Business Registration System - including company name clearance and official search"", however one needs to log in to access it, and registration requires providing some type of identification:
https://ors.brela.go.tz/login
The only available information I could find, was a ""list of some companies with outstanding Returns which have been verified. The list will be being updated as the auditing exercise goes on."" The list includes Company number, Company name, Date of registration, company address (but this is not provided for all companies), and years of returns not paid:
https://www.brela.go.tz/_brela_uploads/documents/news/tangazo_english.pdf
Source:
https://www.brela.go.tz/index.php/companies/companies_news
The Open Data portal (https://opendata.go.tz) also doesn't appear to have any company data available. Hence, there is no option but to mark the dataset as non-existent. ","There is no known online company register. But the data exist with Brela and it can be made available mostly in a print out upon request.","Yes","No","Joachim Mangilima","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"cae9638e-27f1-4cfa-bcb1-35795ad59c62","global","2016-11-10T14:01:19","2016","tw","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""search on Taiwan's open data portal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.tw/license#eng"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Economic Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gcis.nat.gov.tw/od/detail?oid=AD28285B-7B0E-4241-9F58-F2F0F289333E"",""descValue"":""Company Register Data""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
All required characteristics are available online free of charge from the Company Registration Inventory - Ministry of Economic Affairs on the Open Data portal. Uniform number, company name, location (address), representative, capital amount, and approved date of establishment are provided in .CSV format. Data are downloadable at once, available under the open government data licensing terms, and updated monthly.",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","100","100"
"6eba3b9f-004c-4207-8089-848f9e7bba43","global","2017-03-07T04:55:55","2016","np","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Election Commission, Nepal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Unable to review website since it presents “Resource Limit Is Reached” error, stating that “the website is temporarily unable to service your request as it exceeded resource limit. Please try again later”.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"b3b3cbc5-e7ec-4e6c-bece-eea88667cefd","global","2017-03-07T03:41:25","2016","bs","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Organization of American States (OAS)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission because not all required data is available. As submitter noted, results available include registered votes and major results, no information for invalid or spoiled ballots. Available by electoral district and in PDF format for Presidential Elections (2012), latest presidential elections. As submitter noted, this process was observed by the Organization of American States (OAS), and it is currently available through their website (https://www.oas.org/es/sap/deco/MOE_informe/Bahamas2012.pdf). Submitter also noted that there is no preexisting data sets via an official channel.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"9c7a3f41-1a0e-482a-a789-b7cd5d692d59","global","2017-03-07T03:28:08","2016","zm","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Electoral Commission of Zambia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission since not all required data is available. Data available (https://www.elections.org.zm/general_election_2016.php) include results for major electoral contests, registered votes and invalid votes (rejected votes), but no information on spoiled ballots. Data is up to date, by polling station, on HTML format. Not possible to download all at once, just by polling station or electoral zones.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"a60f4863-a533-4fbf-b979-2d6b63a1a2ef","global","2017-03-07T03:04:46","2016","zw","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Zimbabwe Electoral Commission "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission since it is not possible to access the website, due to 503 error, “no server is available to handle this request”.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"27b5df72-5465-4866-8540-2444c701b395","global","2017-01-27T16:28:26","2016","om","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There is a pollution control center in Oman, and this might indicate the data is collected, even though this office focus on oil, not air pollution. https://meca.work/en/module.php?module=pages-showpage&CatID=19&ID=36""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Ministry of Environment and Climate Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No government data was found. WHO reports only one city opening data but it was not found. Accepted without corrections.",,"Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"5e339e1d-e987-499a-9547-637527780d72","global","2016-12-13T14:53:27","2016","np","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Internet Research"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.climatenepal.org.np"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Science, Technology and Environment"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.climatenepal.org.np"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Visited the site, searched around on datasets on Air pollutions by using keywords mentioned here and None were found. Please review.",,"Yes","No","Manish Marahatta","Ricardo Alanís","65","65"
"4f93b400-3f79-433b-b85e-fbeb163659e4","global","2017-01-17T18:54:29","2016","na","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Only a PDF report can be found. Only third party sources available online.",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"e7e3b37a-a986-41e5-8cdf-9a12d3f4ba9b","global","2016-12-31T08:45:08","2016","mm","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""There is no information nor evidence shown that the Myanmar President's Office is collecting the data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The official website to the Myanmar President's Officer https://www.president-office.gov.mm/en/""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections. According to the WHO quoted by The Guardian, only one city in Myanmar records pollution.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"2ed89408-a5ce-4438-b102-7bd01cf590d7","global","2017-01-19T16:35:59","2016","mz","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Only emissions of CO2 per capita was found. Accepted without corrections.",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"4d329e08-faf3-4924-be17-f07edb7f3ac3","global","2016-12-14T15:17:28","2016","me","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""According to this link, air quaity data are collected in 17 stations and include soot and SO2, NOx, rainfwall and sediment https://www.meteo.co.me/misc.php?text=42&sektor=3 \n\nNo data are listed on the Institute website however.""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Institute for Hydrometeorology and Seismology of Montenegro"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted and confirmed data is not available.",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"84419400-dc54-46e5-b7f6-645efc74c572","global","2017-01-25T04:29:55","2016","vc","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""XLS and PDF downloads are available for the GDP data up to 2015. While XLS downloads are available for up to 2012 for population data.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data goes up to 2015""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""By visiting the official government website for St Vincent and the Grenadines, I was connected to the Statistical Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Statistical Office - Ministry of Finance & Economic Planning"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""\nHome pgae: https://stats.gov.vc/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://stats.gov.vc/Default.aspx?tabid=131"",""descValue"":""Population Statistics""},{""urlValue"":""https://stats.gov.vc/Default.aspx?tabid=98"",""descValue"":"" Economic statistics""},{""urlValue"":""https://stats.gov.vc/Default.aspx?tabid=136&ItemId=256"",""descValue"":""Labour Market Statistics 2015""},{""urlValue"":""https://stats.gov.vc/"",""descValue"":""Statistical Office main site""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Alesha Aris for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. ",,"Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Sophie Lafayette","65","65"
"92cdf8bd-5577-4aa0-835e-1bdef86f0a0c","global","2017-01-12T16:20:19","2016","nl","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: unemployment monthly, population yearly , GDP quarterly""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to the Index of 2015, went to the webpage"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/nl/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: all data on CBS StatLine is open data, see: https://www.cbs.nl/en-gb/our-services/open-data/cbs-statline-databank-as-open-data""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Centraal Bureau voor de Statistiek (CBS)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://opendata.cbs.nl/dataportaal/#/CBS/nl/"",""descValue"":""CBS StatLine (Dutch)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.cbs.nl/"",""descValue"":""Centraal Bureau voor de Statistiek (CBS) (Dutch)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.cbs.nl/en-gb"",""descValue"":""Centraal Bureau voor de Statistiek (CBS) (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://statline.cbs.nl/Statweb/selection/?VW=T&DM=SLEN&PA=80590eng&D1=3-7%2c10-14&D2=0&D3=0&D4=169-182&LA=EN&HDR=T&STB=G1%2cG2%2cG3"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://statline.cbs.nl/StatWeb/publication/?VW=T&DM=SLEN&PA=37943eng&LA=EN"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://statline.cbs.nl/StatWeb/publication/?VW=T&DM=SLEN&PA=82602ENG&D1=1&D2=0-1&D3=(l-10)-l&HD=140704-0953&HDR=G1,T&STB=G2"",""descValue"":""GDP data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added link to main site, population, GDP, and unemployment data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. ",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Sophie Lafayette","100","100"
"026d867e-222a-48be-9eab-07504ece40ca","global","2017-03-06T22:53:52","2016","ba","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Central Election Commission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission since not all required data is available. As submitter noted, results available for General Elections (https://www.izbori.ba/Potvrdjeni2014/Finalni/PredsjednistvoBiH/Default.aspx) include results for major electoral contests, registered votes and invalid votes, but no information on spoiled ballots. There are two categories for invalid votes: Invalid/blank votes and
Null votes for other criteria. Data is up to date, available in HTML.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"27c326c3-d3b7-4083-8f10-b4af0a0ce264","global","2017-03-06T22:10:13","2016","al","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Komisioni Qëndror i Zgjedhjeve"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission since not all required data is available. As submitter noted, results available (https://www.cec.org.al/Portals/0/Documents/CEC%202013/zgjedhje-vendore/2015/rez_hetml/151123_-_buletin.htm) include results for major electoral contests, registered votes and invalid votes, but no information on spoiled ballots. Data is up to date, available in HTML.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"2b196e19-ad37-4abc-b2c9-6b08c3550d48","global","2017-01-13T22:11:42","2016","uy","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The data appears to be updated on a regular basis, showing status of the legislation. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is reasonably searchable and the website is reasonably navigable. ""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Navigate the web site"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.agesic.gub.uy/innovaportal/v/161/1/agesic/ley_n%C2%BA_18381.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""See art. 4""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""As the content is in Spanish, a language barrier may exist for some persons seeking to access the legislation. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Parlamento Uruguayo"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://parlamento.gub.uy/documentosyleyes/documentos"",""descValue"":""Todos los documentos""},{""urlValue"":""https://parlamento.gub.uy/documentosyleyes/documentos/textos-aprobados"",""descValue"":""Estado final de los documentos""},{""urlValue"":""https://parlamento.gub.uy/documentosyleyes/documentos/versiones-taquigraficas"",""descValue"":""Transcripciones""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Please click \""Ver mas\"" if there is no data.""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Brenna Slawich","65","65"
"3254ee16-d441-4f19-a4f3-60347c39991a","global","2017-01-13T22:47:30","2016","uy","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The data appears to be updated on a regular basis, noting how often the laws are updated or modified. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Second website has both a searchable list and a search tool to quickly locate and find a specific law. The website content is in Spanish. ""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Navigate the site"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.agesic.gub.uy/innovaportal/v/161/1/agesic/ley_n%C2%BA_18381.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""See art. 4""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Spanish language content can be seen as a potential barrier for researchers looking to conduct research on Uruguay if they do not possess at least some Spanish language skills. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""IMPO / Parlamento"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.impo.com.uy/cgi-bin/bases/consultaBasesBS.cgi"",""descValue"":""Catalogo de leyes y actualizaciones""},{""urlValue"":""https://parlamento.gub.uy/documentosyleyes/leyes"",""descValue"":""Actualizaciones y leyes aprobadas""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Search Ley 18381. The first website requires registration to search the website. The second website is searchable and does not require registration. ""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Brenna Slawich","65","65"
"58a63463-8dd0-4ed6-a1a0-6367c181206a","global","2016-12-01T19:27:50","2016","si","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Copyright law is applied. \""The user can simultaneously use only insignificant parts of databases (qualitative and / or quantitative)\"" See Article 7 of Terms of Use https://www.ajpes.si/Terms_of_use""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF also available""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Registration required to view businesses queried ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Only for limited amount of data.""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried a web search engine for the Slovenian business register."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Slovenian Business Register - Agency of the Republic of Slovenia for Public Legal Records and Related Services"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ajpes.si/prs/"",""descValue"":""Business Register of Slovenia""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
Company information is available online free of charge on the Business Register of Slovenia website. However, data are behind a search mask, and one needs to register on the website in order to view the results (registration is free of charge). Name, Address, Registration Number, and Tax Number are available at a glance and once the entity name is selected, additional information including Status, Date of Entry into the Court Registry, Submission number, and information on shareholders among others are provided. Data are given in .HTML format, while one has the option to download the individual company information in .PDF, and cannot be downloaded in bulk.
It may be worth noting that the AJPES publishes the list of entities (as at 31. 12. 2016) enrolled in the PRS basic public data, which are available free of charge for reuse in XML format, and updated every three months, but this does not seem to include unique identifiers or addresses https://www.ajpes.si/Doc/Registri/PRS/Ponovna_uporaba/Prs.zip
Lastly, Copyright law is applied. ""The user can simultaneously use only insignificant parts of databases (qualitative and / or quantitative)"" See Article 7 of Terms of Use https://www.ajpes.si/Terms_of_use",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Evangelia Kampouri","30","30"
"a28db50c-64cf-4f92-8f3a-21cb8a17a565","global","2016-11-16T19:58:52","2016","se","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""JSON"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data available in multiple formats. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Bulk downloads of votes, proposals etc.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""A very easy to navigate and accessible website. ""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Googled for \""propositioner riksdagen data\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.riksdagen.se/anvandningsvillkor/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Terms are similar to CC-BY but some documents may contain content (images) that are copyrighted.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is well structured. Example database schemas are provided.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Riksdagen"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""See https://data.riksdagen.se/ (Swedish parliament website)""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.riksdagen.se/"",""descValue"":""Swedish parliament open data portal""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Website is very easy to navigate but again, researchers should be advised that the website contents are in Swedish. ""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Relevant data items are linked to facilitate analysis.","Yes","Yes","Peter Krantz","Brenna Slawich","100","100"
"e7833d2b-2644-451e-af9d-8caf63641ff3","global","2016-11-14T17:04:34","2016","se","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""JSON"",""TXT"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Also as SQL dumps.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Website is very functional and easy to navigate. ""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Googled for \""dokument lagar\"" (documents laws)."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.riksdagen.se/anvandningsvillkor/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Not a standardized license but similar to CC-BY.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Any researcher would need to have either good Swedish language skills to make the best use of this site or access to an excellent translator. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Riksdagen (Swedish parliament)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.riksdagen.se/data/dokument/"",""descValue"":""Open data from the Swedish parliament""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is in Swedish but appears to be complete and extensive. ""}]","Yes","Yes",,"A very easy to navigate site that makes it easy to find information quickly and easily. ","Yes","Yes","Peter Krantz","Brenna Slawich","100","100"
"d3a24938-e707-43ca-b044-77bf2c80dec4","global","2016-12-14T19:40:07","2016","cz","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No explicit licence or terms of use stated. Only a copyright icon at page footer.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF, DOC""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Every draft has its own page with multiple documents. For each version, relevant documents can be downloaded at once. But some of the bulk downloads are blocked for no apparent reason. No option to download all docs for all versions of a draft. There is a simple RSS, but i understand it only a means to follow and publish updates, not bulk downloading the data. https://apps.odok.cz/feed/-/kpl/rss""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The upload period differs, but for most of the latest data, documents are uploaded the same day as changes has been made.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I think this requires a bit of an expertise - google search will find the correct link, but it is presented as a special app with a generic name (ODok). Finding the drafts requires multiple clicks. You have to locate the right (public) interface, open it and click enter."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Úřad vlády ČR / The Office of the Government of the Czech Republic"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://apps.odok.cz"",""descValue"":""Information system operated by the Government of the Czech Republic""},{""urlValue"":""https://apps.odok.cz/vlegis-vyhledavani"",""descValue"":""Government Legislation Catalog ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Content is available in PDF and DOC formats.
Every draft has its own page with multiple documents. For each version, relevant documents can be downloaded at once. But some of the bulk downloads are blocked for no apparent reason. No option to download all docs for all versions of a draft. There is a simple RSS, but i understand it only a means to follow and publish updates, not bulk downloading the data. https://apps.odok.cz/feed/-/kpl/rss
The upload period differs, but for most of the latest data, documents are uploaded the same day as changes has been made.","Yes","No","Michaela Rybičková","Anton Shaffer","45","45"
"b9e71312-6c4f-4d4e-bde0-933074c034d3","global","2016-12-06T21:48:28","2016","gb","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""All of the data is discoverable as text records and in some parts via APIs and other mechanisms. However it is not organised sufficiently to support bulk downloads of the information.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""General exploration of the UK Parliament and Parliament.data sites."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.parliament.uk/site-information/copyright/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""All the data covered by this submission is re-usable under the terms of the Open Parliament Licence, which is compliant with the Open Definition.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""In Britain this type of information is the responsibility of Parliament, which is legally separate from government; however I have answered Yes on the basis that the institutions are equivalent in the sense of being official sources. (This submission does not cover data available from civil society sources such as mySociety.)""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Documents and debates related to bills are presented in a manner that is accessible for reading, but generally information about bills is not available as structured data; and where structured data is available users need to familiarise themselves with the Parliament.Data APIs in order to access it. Data on votes is particularly opaque. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Parliamentary Digital Service (PDS)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.parliament.uk/business/bills-and-legislation/"",""descValue"":""Bills and legislation (Parliament)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.data.parliament.uk/dataset/53"",""descValue"":""Bills Text XML (Parliament.data)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.data.parliament.uk/dataset/bills"",""descValue"":""Bills Metadata (Parliament.data)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.data.parliament.uk/dataset/09"",""descValue"":""House of Commons Divisions (Parliament.data)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","In Britain this type of information is the responsibility of Parliament, which is legally separate from government; however I have answered Yes on the basis that the institutions are equivalent in the sense of being official sources. (This submission does not cover data available from civil society sources such as mySociety.)
All the data covered by this submission is re-usable under the terms of the Open Parliament Licence, which is compliant with the Open Definition.
All of the data is discoverable as text records and in some parts via APIs and other mechanisms. However it is not organised sufficiently to support bulk downloads of the information.
Documents and debates related to bills are presented in a manner that is accessible for reading, but generally information about bills is not available as structured data; and where structured data is available users need to familiarize themselves with the Parliament Data APIs in order to access it. Data on votes is particularly opaque. ","Yes","No","Owen Boswarva","Anton Shaffer","85","85"
"2f699fa6-490b-4a21-9006-301a2cbc1abd","global","2016-12-05T22:28:27","2016","gb","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""TXT"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I was previously aware of the Legislation.gov.uk site and it is easily discoverable by searching Google for legislation uk. However the bulk download page is difficult to find; I had to rely on my own notes to relocate the link."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.legislation.gov.uk/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is re-usable under the Open Government Licence as noted in the standard footer on pages of the Legislation.gov.uk site.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is mainly plain text, i.e. not highly structured. However this follows from the subject matter.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The National Archives"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Changes to legislation are flagged and noted but not always integrated into the body of the legislation, apparently due to a longstanding backlog.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.legislation.gov.uk/"",""descValue"":""Legislation.gov.uk""},{""urlValue"":""https://leggovuk.s3-website-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/"",""descValue"":""Legislation downloads""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Changes to legislation are flagged and noted but not always integrated into the body of the legislation, apparently due to a longstanding backlog.
The data is re-usable under the Open Government Licence as noted in the standard footer on pages of the Legislation.gov.uk site.
The data is mainly plain text, i.e. not highly structured. ","Yes","No","Owen Boswarva","Anton Shaffer","85","85"
"0ebf593c-3a39-4137-8e38-dd2f90c77705","global","2016-12-13T09:01:55","2016","sg","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The data is available as a CSV download or in JSON format via API. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search for \""singapore company uen data\"" on Google."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""In Singapore, the UEN is the identifier for registered businesses, so it's the search term that people would use when looking for company-related data. The Data.gov.sg page is currently in the top 2 results. ""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.sg/open-data-licence"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""All datasets on Data.gov.sg follow a tidy, machine readable format. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Accounting and Corporate Regulatory Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""In Singapore, each postal code refers to a specific building instead of a district. The dataset provides postal code and street name of each registered company where applicable. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.sg/dataset/entities-with-unique-entity-number"",""descValue"":""Registered Entities, including businesses and non-profit organisations""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This dataset contains registration information not just for companies but also for schools, trade unions, and charities, among others. In Singapore, all of these entities are supported by ""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
Data of Registered Entities with Unique Entity Number are available for free and downloadable in bulk on the Open Data portal in .CSV format, and .JSON via API. Data can be downloaded separately for Entities Registered with Accounting and Corporate Regulatory Authority (ACRA) and Entities Registered with Other UEN Issuance Agencies in .CSV, or together in a .ZIP file. Data contain UEN Number, Issuance Agency, UEN Status, Entity Type, UEN Issue Date, Registered Street Name, and Registered Postal Code. They are updated weekly and are available under the Singapore Open Data Licence. According to the submitter, the dataset contains registration information not just for companies but also for schools, trade unions, and charities, among others. It's worth noting that in Singapore, the UEN is the identifier for registered businesses, so it's the search term that people would use when looking for company-related data. Furthermore, in Singapore each postal code refers to a specific building instead of a district. The dataset provides postal code and street name of each registered company where applicable. Lastly, all datasets on Data.gov.sg follow a tidy, machine readable format. ",,"Yes","Yes","Zhaowei Lin","Evangelia Kampouri","100","100"
"6c31124b-447b-4ac8-a328-318a47e99b18","global","2016-12-09T02:36:19","2016","au","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""[Original submitter comment]The Bill text is available as .PDF, DOC and HTML, - the votes and transcripts are available as XML as well as PDF, DOC and HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""[Original submitter comment]The Bill and it's votes and transcripts are not available for a single download, although they are collated online.\n\nCollated lists of current Bills are available in PDF and DOC format\n""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""[Original submitter comment]Data is usually updated on the day of debate""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""google search for draft legislation"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.aph.gov.au/Help/Disclaimer_Privacy_Copyright#c"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""[Original submitter comment]With the exception of the Commonwealth Coat of Arms and where otherwise noted, all material presented on the website is provided under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Australia licence.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of the House of Representatives, Department of the Senate"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""All required characteristics are present. Votes on bills is the only item that needs to be searched separately on a different page (search by date it was debated). ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Bills_Legislation"",""descValue"":""Bills legislation homepage""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Chamber_documents"",""descValue"":""Chamber documents - live updated with Bill and Votes/Proceedings""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission should be accepted because the data set contains all the required characteristics.","[Original submitter comment]On a bill page (ie https://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Bills_Legislation/Bills_Search_Results/Result?bId=r5735), the text (initial and as passed) is available under ""Text of Bill"", along with Explanatory Memoranda and a Bills Digest (if applicable). The link to Transcript of speeches refers you to the specific Hansard segments discussing the Bill, along with any Votes and Proceedings (where recorded).
[Reviewer Comments] As a reviewer I made no changes to the submission. I could verify that all answers are accurate and the dataset contains all required characteristics. ","Yes","No",,"Juela Xhaferraj","85","85"
"873e066f-2dc2-4bcf-a0e5-dc53231a328a","global","2016-12-15T11:10:49","2016","ph","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Not explicitly tagged as being licensed or in public domain.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Most documents are in PDF.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Bills and documents are downloadable file by file, but not en masse.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Senate home page -> Legislative Documents menu has all the relevant data. Similarly, House of Representatives -> Downloads Center has all the pertinent data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Senate and the House of Representatives of the Philippines"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.senate.gov.ph/lis/leg_sys.aspx"",""descValue"":""Senate catalog of legislation""},{""urlValue"":""https://congress.gov.ph/legisdocs/?v=bills"",""descValue"":""Congress catalog of legislation""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The content of legislation is available in PDF format.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Anton Shaffer","45","45"
"1b284324-eae0-4e52-b218-ae684a49a540","global","2017-03-06T19:18:19","2016","ph","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Philippine Gazette"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""After considerable review, the data does not meet proper qualification for open data. The required characteristics of "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Submitted by reviewer.","The Philippine Gazette provides some data regarding legal codes, government acts, and the like -- it does not provide any amendments regarding these laws. The data is not easily accessible, it is not downloadable but is considered to be free. The website of the Philippine Gazette Journal is not organized to properly sort through the laws of the country.
Link to Philippine Gazette legal code example:
https://www.gov.ph/the-philippine-legal-codes/
There an alternative website that lists the laws, the non-profit Philippines Laws and Jurisprudence Databank. It is not affiliated with the government. The database contains the laws in HTML format with no official amendments.
Link: https://lawphil.net/
Finally, there is a private company that claims to sell comprehensive National Law data (data provided on a CD). It is a paid service that does not qualify as open data.
Link:
https://www.cdasia.com/laws-philippine-edition/
","Yes","No","anonymous","Anton Shaffer","0","0"
"4a364d0e-0ecf-419e-a1a3-0885bf0ab02f","global","2016-11-25T06:30:30","2016","rs","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""You can view, copy or print pages with this site solely for personal, non-commercial purposes.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""First result on search engines."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Serbian Business Registers Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://pretraga2.apr.gov.rs/ObjedinjenePretrage/Search/Search"",""descValue"":""Search page for companies, entrepreneurs, associations""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
Data are available free of charge on the Serbian Agency for Business Registers Search of Companies website. At a glance, Type of entity, Identification number, Business Name, and Status are given and once the ""more details"" option is selected, additional information including but not limited to Statistic Number, Legal form, Headquarters (Municipality, Place, Street Address), Date of establishment, and Tax Identification Number (PIB) number are provided. Among others, categories such as Address data, Business information, Legal representatives, branches, and Financial reports are available from a menu at the top. However, data are behind a search mask and one needs to know the name or identification number of an entity in order to find it. Data are also given in .HTML format and cannot be downloaded in bulk. The update frequency of the dataset is not known and neither is the type of license.","The business model of the SBRA is to charge for a data.
Web services are established with businesses clients and governmental agencies for data exchange in real-time.","Yes","No","Aleksandar Ivić","Evangelia Kampouri","15","15"
"4ca974d1-ea61-4327-9e39-d611330a41af","global","2016-12-05T14:08:58","2016","np","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: website, 'Copyright © 2017 - Central Bureau of Statistics - All Rights Reserved.'""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: population & unemployment data available in PDF, GDP in XLS""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: last census 2011, population projections 2011-2031, GDP yearly (latest 2014/15), unemployment yearly (latest 2014/15)""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Previous year's GODI"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Planning Commission Secretariat Central Bureau of Statistics"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: data on unemployment found in reports on Household Survey and Labor Force Survey""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://cbs.gov.np/sectoral_statistics"",""descValue"":""Central Bureau of Statistics's website""},{""urlValue"":""https://cbs.gov.np/sectoral_statistics/population"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://cbs.gov.np/sectoral_statistics/national_accounts"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://cbs.gov.np/sectoral_statistics/poverty"",""descValue"":""Labour activity data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added links to population, GDP, and unemployment data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Shubham Ghimire for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Data not regulatory updated and primarily found within PDF reports. ",,"Yes","No","Shubham Ghimire","Sophie Lafayette","50","50"
"e560d444-d389-4527-941c-fbbde0832bf3","global","2017-01-20T13:40:47","2016","no","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Only as web pages. Not sure if this qualifies as machine-readable?\n\nAPI is available for paid subscribers.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""See note below on machine readability.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""NB! Only for private use, and only the web-version.""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Know the website from before."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Lovdata"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Note that Lovdata is a self-owning foundation, but started by the Ministry of Justice, and is the de facto publisher of legislation online. Also publishes changes/new legislation (Norsk lovtidend) as a paid task from the ministry.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://lovdata.no"",""descValue"":""www.lovdata.no""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The Lovdata portal allows users to access the National Laws free of charge as web pages only. API access is available to paid users. Thus, while the data is technically machine readable, it is not considered as such under this review as it is not Open Data proper.","Original submitter works with open data in the government agency, Difi, which is in charge of the national open data portal - https://data.norge.no/
Note that Lovdata (publisher of National Laws) is a self-owning foundation, but started by the Ministry of Justice, and is the de facto publisher of legislation online. Also publishes changes/new legislation (Norsk lovtidend) as a paid task from the ministry.
National Law data is available for free as web pages only. API access is available for paid subscribers. Thus, it is possible to access the database at once, but not on a free of charge basis.","Yes","No","Bergheimivar L","Anton Shaffer","45","45"
"cd9d46e8-a5f4-4b81-9bdf-40a41d6e0061","global","2016-12-05T08:37:06","2016","be","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No where on the website I found that NGI offers a WFS service, only WMS after registration. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Go to NGI website, click on \""topomap viewer\"" banner"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Belgian National Geographic Institute"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ngi.be/topomapviewer/public?lang=nl&"",""descValue"":""NGI topomap viewer""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ngi.be/NL/NL1-19-1.shtm"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""A WMS service is available, but only registration that requires a number of personal data (such as VAT number). ""}]","Yes","Yes","The data is online through the topomapviwer. There is WMS service provided, but only after a thorough registration and there are restrictions in its usage. ","Scale is even better dan requested (1:10.000), cartoweb.be product can be used for some purposes, complete downloads have to be purchased. ","Yes","No","Bart Hanssens","Codrina Maria Ilie","30","30"
"db9d53dc-5675-474f-ac19-a371c6c2ad6b","global","2017-01-29T19:53:43","2016","bb","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is not readily downloaded but can be copied from the website\n""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Given that this is a data set that does not incur drastic change I would assume up to date\n""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""It was easy being connected to the data, by merely carrying out a google search for the keywords \""land parcel barbados\"" I found the Barbados Land Registry"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is very limited to a small map and description of the district""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Barbados Land Registry"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Parcel boundaries (inc. latitude and longitude)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.landregistry.gov.bb/District1.aspx"",""descValue"":""Parcel Description and Map""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We appreciate the contribution of Alesha Aris. The indicated data source [https://www.landregistry.gov.bb/District1.aspx] is not compliant with the GODI requirements. ","The data is very limited to a small map and description of the regions","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Codrina Maria Ilie","30","30"
"2e6f90ae-5654-4b87-b237-32f73977821c","global","2017-01-29T19:13:02","2016","bb","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Barbados Postal Service"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Homepage\nbarbadospostal.com""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The search service works at the time of the review, but it does not prove that all the requirements of the dataset are met, so we don't know if the data, the way GODI requires exists. ","The Barbados Postal Services' website has a ipcode look up however it appears to be broken at the time of this survey
Link: https://barbadospostal.com/postalcodes/
Overall postal codes do exits for the country but I was unable to find a government portal","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"a811a1f5-6459-4967-bcd9-b5bfc55b5346","global","2017-03-06T13:36:26","2016","ua","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Infrastructure of Ukraine"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"We acknowledge and thank Vanya Yani for the contribution. Unfortunately, I had to reject the submission as the dataset provided is not fully compliant with the data theme requirements; coordinates are missing. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"3754e9ea-084a-49a4-9d64-4a35005983dd","global","2017-01-18T14:31:29","2016","bd","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Need to follow step by step process"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Land"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenure Type (ie. leasehold, freehold, protected lands, public lands, customary lands)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.minland.gov.bd/"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Land""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dlrs.gov.bd/"",""descValue"":""Land Record and Survey Department""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","We acknowledge and thank Nurunnaby Hasive for the contribution. However, we have not identified datasets compliant with GODI's requirements. ",,"Yes","No","Nurunnaby Hasive","Codrina Maria Ilie","45","45"
"74ed301d-5468-449f-9144-e4fb0e058601","global","2017-03-06T12:26:03","2016","bd","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bangladesh Post Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"We acknowledge and thank Nurunnaby Hasive for the contribution. I have changed the initial submission as I have identified that Bangladesh Post Office, department of Ministry of Posts and Tele communication is responsible for postal codes and the data is not made available only. Only a search service is offered: https://www.bangladeshpost.gov.bd/PostCode.asp","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"871bff45-35f9-4510-836f-b818c32a7560","global","2016-11-22T21:43:06","2016","at","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went for cost-free products at BEV or went for Addresses in Open Government Dta portal in Austria"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.bev.gv.at/portal/page?_pageid=713,1604469&_dad=portal&_schema=PORTAL"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Austrian Association of City and Towns"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Zipcodes"",""Addresses"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Data available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""reviewer: I have added zipcodes to the dataset because after downloading the folder indicated, I discovered all characteristics required, even though in different csv files. The files can be linked together based on common codes. In my understanding the zipcode can be considered the ADRCD code, explained as EDV - key for address; Is assigned by the address register""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.bev.gv.at/portal/page?_pageid=713,2601271&_dad=portal&_schema=PORTAL"",""descValue"":""cost-free products at BEV""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","100","100"
"afc8384f-32dc-4d68-a254-154b9c0f994c","global","2016-12-09T07:22:41","2016","at","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is available via WMTS service which is not available in the list""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""reviewer: I have changed the initial answer YES to NO because WMTS, like WMS protocol, is not constructed in such a way to support a meaningful download, especially with this kind of data. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""search for „basemap“ in Google"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.basemap.at/index_en.html#sec-nutzung "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""City of Vienna and further regional, local and national government agencies of Austria"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.basemap.at/"",""descValue"":""National open government data map of Austria""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.basemap.at/wmts/1.0.0/WMTSCapabilities.xml"",""descValue"":""WMTS URL ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.basemap.at/application/index.html#{%22center%22:[1445590,6059660],%22zoom%22:8,%22rotation%22:0,%22layers%22:%220010000000%22}"",""descValue"":""map viwer""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Answer given on behalf of Wolfgang Jörg, GIS Coordinator of Vienna.
reviewer: Austria offers WMTS services to freely access the data. However, this protocol is not suitable for data download. ","Yes","No","Robert Harm","Codrina Maria Ilie","65","65"
"657de93a-8971-4b1e-b951-f11829075823","global","2016-12-13T10:15:57","2016","ph","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data also provided in PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""The different sub-menus on the left-hand menu, as well as the dropdown menus from the top navigation bar, take the user to the relevant weather data. The navigation is somewhat confusing/overwhelming."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It's somewhat confusing/overwhelming.""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.pagasa.dost.gov.ph/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Footer: \""All content is in the public domain unless otherwise stated.\""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Philippine Atmospheric Geophysical and Astronomical Services Administration (PAGASA)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Precipitation Probability"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.pagasa.dost.gov.ph/"",""descValue"":""PAGASA Website""},{""urlValue"":""https://pubfiles.pagasa.dost.gov.ph/tamss/weather/pf.pdf"",""descValue"":""24-Hour Daily Weather Forecast""},{""urlValue"":""https://climatex.dost.gov.ph/"",""descValue"":""Rainfall Forecast""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.pagasa.dost.gov.ph/index.php/numerical-weather-prediction"",""descValue"":""Numerical Weather Prediction for wind and precipitation ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.pagasa.dost.gov.ph/index.php/20-weather/2509-extended-forecast"",""descValue"":""Extended Forecast for following days""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is valid. Thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Danny Lämmerhirt","65","65"
"44be1988-5749-434e-9232-60baabe219c5","global","2017-02-02T21:16:21","2016","pe","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searche for \""datos meteorologicos historicos peru\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""SERVICIO NACIONAL DE METEOROLOGIA E HIDROLOGIA DEL PERU"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.senamhi.gob.pe/?p=0115"",""descValue"":""Pronóstico del clima hasta 15 días""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.senamhi.gob.pe/main_mapa.php?t=dHi"",""descValue"":""National meteorological and hydrological service, Historical data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.senamhi.gob.pe/?p=0115"",""descValue"":""National meteorological and hydrological service, precipitation and temperature map""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.senamhi.gob.pe/?p=0260"",""descValue"":""National meteorological and hydrological service, wind barb map for current day + 2 days""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","There is a portal allowing to see (not download) all required characteristics (see here: https://www.senamhi.gob.pe/main_mapa.php?t=dHi). This portal is outdated, the data refer to April 2015, and the link to the terms and use section is broken. Data for the current data can be seen here: https://www.senamhi.gob.pe/?p=1201_dr03
All data is available online, however split across different sites and in different formats. Wind forecasts are available for current day + 2 days, but only as wind barbs drawn on a map.
The reviewer recommends to lower the findability-score of the data, since the data are split across places. Also some data would need to be retrieved and processed manually (such as non-machine-readable wind barb maps) to reuse them. Therefore the usability score should be lower.
Thank you, Oscar Montiel, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Can't download data, only check html of the reports and pdf of predictions","Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"1dac0477-9e37-460f-957f-aab8335cfea0","global","2016-12-15T16:14:56","2016","pa","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1. Search on the web for Panama Weather forecast, 2. Click on the link for Open Data, 3. Register and access the platform "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There could be a quick user guide.""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.hidromet.com.pa/open_data.php"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""On the bottom they have the following disclosure (Im not sure if this is consider a license):\nThe Department of Hydrometeorology makes available to its users the section OPEN DATA in Beta version.\n\nWe are open to your suggestions please email us at hidromet@etesa.com.pa\nThe use of the data must recognize the Hydrometeorology Department of ETESA as the source of the information.\nLegal Note: The information provided through this section is of an official nature, however, ETESA is not responsible for the applications and / or interpretation of the data and products generated with them.\nThe data downloaded for use with legal purposes must be requested from the Hydrometeorology Directorate for certification.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Empresa de Transmisión Eléctrica (Hidrometeorología)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Electric Transmission Company (Hydrometeorology) (Official Third party)""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Precipitation Probability"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.hidromet.com.pa/open_data.php"",""descValue"":""Beta Open Data Plataform""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.hidromet.com.pa/pdf.php?dir=pronostico_extendido"",""descValue"":""Extended report""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","There is an open data portal for weather observations (not forecasts). It allows to retrieve data such as wind speed, wind direction, humidity, air pressure, etc. This data can be downloaded as XLS files. The reviewer agrees that it was very hard to find the data portal in the first place (there is no direct link to the portal on the main website, and also no link when using the site-internal search engine. Only a link to a press announcement appears). Since the portal does not provide weather forecasts, it is not considered for the Index.
Forecasts are available for the current day for all characteristics (see here:https://www.hidromet.com.pa/pronostico_diario.php). One-week forecasts contain temperature and precipitation (downloadable as PDF here: https://www.hidromet.com.pa/pdf.php?dir=pronostico_extendido
There is a forecast for precipitation amount only, with a legend that explains what verbal descriptions of precipitation mean (e.g. strong rainfall = 25 to 75mm).
Since wind forecasts are not provided for current day and following two days, not all data is considered to be available online.
Thank you, Victor Díaz Navarro, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The Electric Transmission Company (Hydrometeorology) is a third party affiliated with government. The license states:
On the bottom they have the following disclosure (Im not sure if this is consider a license):
The Department of Hydrometeorology makes available to its users the section OPEN DATA in Beta version.
We are open to your suggestions please email us at hidromet@etesa.com.pa
The use of the data must recognize the Hydrometeorology Department of ETESA as the source of the information.
Legal Note: The information provided through this section is of an official nature, however, ETESA is not responsible for the applications and / or interpretation of the data and products generated with them.
The data downloaded for use with legal purposes must be requested from the Hydrometeorology Directorate for certification.","Yes","No","Victor Díaz Navarro","Danny Lämmerhirt","70","70"
"33545b37-bd6e-4e51-a410-f40127fa3ff2","global","2017-01-18T23:30:20","2016","ve","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""[Original submitter comment]La Asamblea Nacional lleva un registro de los borradores legislativos, sin embargo no están disponibles de manera on line, y no existen registros públicos sobre estos archivos\n[Reviewer comment] I was able to find bills for 2016 to 2017 on the National Assembly website https://www.asambleanacional.gob.ve/tabs/proyecto/fecha/2016\nThis website contains the content of the bills and status of bills (in brackets beside the title). However, it does not include the author of the bill, and that is why B2 is being answered with No. The optional characteristics, transcripts and votes are also missing. The bills are in PDF only. The site is not in open license, bulk downloads are not available, information is up to date.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Asamblea Nacional"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission should be accepted because it accurately indicates that data is not available as it missing required characteristics. ","This submission will be accepted because the original submitter had accurately answered B2 with No. As a reviewer I was able to find data that satisfied two required characteristics (content of bill and status). However, since the author of the bill is not accepted the submission should remain unchanged and should be accepted. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Juela Xhaferraj","0","0"
"436a96ac-83fc-4dce-95d2-75a41cceb462","global","2017-03-06T02:06:20","2016","ve","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The original submission included three URL where data could be found. After reviewing them I came to the conclusion that none of them had all the required characteristics. The three URLs are as follows:\nhttps://spgoin.alejandria.biz/cgi-win/be_alex.cgi?nombrebd\n- National Printing Service website\n- National Gazettes where laws, resolutions, decrees can be found. \n- Data from 2015 to 2017 only\n- No date of last amendment and no amendments https://www.asambleanacional.gob.ve/ley?id=5#Contenido\n- national assembly website\n- laws for 2009-2013 and 2016 only\n-no date of last amendment and no amendment\nhttps://www.tsj.gob.ve/es/web/tsj/gaceta-oficial\n-Official gazette website\n- gazettes contain laws, decrees, resolutions\n-only available from year 2000 and later\n- no date of last amendment and no amendments\n\nSince all three website contain laws passed only within very restricted time frames ( so not all laws are available) and because they are missing two required characteristics (no date of last amendment and no amendments), the original submission was rejected. ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Asemblea Nacional; Gaceta Oficial; National Printing Service"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission was rejected because the data was missing required characteristics. This submission is updated to indicate that data is not provided by the government.","The original submission was rejected because 1) laws are only available for very specific time frames 2) for the laws that are available the date of last amendment and content of amendments is not available.
The original submission had indicated the following for the data:
- Characteristics: content, date of last amendment, amendments (the last two are actually missing
- Free of charge: Yes
-Up to date: Yes
- Download in bulk: Yes (this should be a No)
- Public domain: Yes (actually this should be a No)
- Format: PDF only","Yes","No","anonymous","Juela Xhaferraj","0","0"
"26cdc0a8-bc28-4281-b0f3-5baccc98fe05","global","2016-12-06T15:58:28","2016","py","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""5 days forecast is only available for Asunción and it hasn't wind information. Then there is 3 days forecast for departments without wind also (and very difficult to find and access: https://www.meteorologia.gov.py/mapa2.php). ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Dirección de Meteorología e Hidrología"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. The given link (https://www.meteorologia.gov.py/mapa2.php) leads to written forecast reports for the current day +2 days. The forecasts are issued for 1 major city per region, and temperature, wind direction (no wind speed) and indication of precipitation (without telling the exact amount).
There are data services offering to send 48 hour forecasts in written form. These have to be monthly paid for a fee of 320 US Dollars (see price list here: https://www.meteorologia.gov.py/adm/uploads/Tasas.pdf). Information is transmitted via phone, fax, or internet.
Thank you, Lupinupa L, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","5 days forecast is only available for Asunción and it hasn't wind information. Then there is 3 days forecast for departments without wind also (and very difficult to find and access: https://www.meteorologia.gov.py/mapa2.php). ","Yes","No","Lupinupa L","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"38971e94-00bb-4434-815f-7c7bf5935ac7","global","2017-03-05T21:52:24","2016","pa","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Registro Público de Panamá / Public Registry of Panama"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Company data are collected by the Registro Público de Panamá / Public Registry of Panama. As mentioned by the original submitter, Victor Díaz Navarro, there are also two unofficial sources available:
https://www.panadata.net/sociedades and
https://www.panadata.net/personas
All three sources require registration. According to the submitter, all four characteristics are available online free of charge on the Public Registry of Panama website, however the dataset is not downloadable at once and one can only print and see the scanned document on .PDF format inside their platform. Again, according to the submitter, the data are up-to-date, though not openly licensed/in public domain. The submitter found the data by researching on the web for national registry, then entering the query platform, logging in and entering a captcha code, and searching by different criterias.
In order to verify the submission, I too registered on the Public Registry website (https://registro-publico.gob.pa/index.php - registration is free of charge) and from the top menu selected Web Services -> Services and Registration which leads to Registry Services and Queries Interface (the link provided by the submitter):
https://www.rp.gob.pa/ValidacionDigital.aspx
Indeed, one needs to enter their username, password, and a captcha code in order to start a session. However, there appears to be a glitch on the page and it refuses to log in, stating that ""either the username or password is not correct"". Even after changing my password and using different browsers, the problem persists and it seems that there is no way for me to actually access the company data; if they are available at all. Hence, I am unable to verify that the dataset exists and have to reject the original submission.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"6191677e-279a-4620-8ddd-dcf6194be26c","global","2017-01-25T06:24:39","2016","vc","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Commerce and Intellectual Property Office (CIPO)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.cipo.gov.vc/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
It seems that at one point the Commerce and Intellectual Property Office (CIPO) website (https://www.cipo.gov.vc/) offered a ""Company Name Search Request And Reservation"" feature (https://www.cipo.gov.vc/cipo/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=59:name-search&catid=30:name-search&Itemid=54) however clicking on the provided link directs to a ""URL Not Found"" (https://ap2.cipo.gov.vc/sysworkflow/en/green/8964538574b55d39a8ad326000442097/Name_Search_and_Reservation_%2826%29.php). The e-registry website (https://eregistry.cipo.gov.vc/) also doesn't seem to contain any relevant company information. Hence, since no evidence that company data are available online could be found, the dataset is marked as non-existent.","Upon visiting the CIPO page one can attempt to investigate the e-registry however it requires a login from users. https://eregistry.cipo.gov.vc/","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"650dd57e-95db-4fde-81ce-7f0776648c87","global","2017-01-24T22:46:19","2016","lc","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is not downloadable however a simply copy of the text can be done""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It's apparent that there are entries for 2016, I am unable to view all of the etries chronologically however considering that the webpage offers name look ups to reserve potential company names it is assumed that the database is up to date""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data are available through a search mask and one needs to know the name or number of an entity in order to find it.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I was quickly connected to the Registry of Companies and Intellectual Property webpage by searching the keywords \""st lucia registry of companies\"" on google.com. From there a user is able to perform a name search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The access to the database is limited to the keywords they enter however once found a user can peruse the available company information. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Registry of Companies and Intellectual Property "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Although not downloadable in bulk it's possible to view the company information online ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://efiling.rocip.gov.lc/#/"",""descValue"":""St Lucia Online Company Registry""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
Company Data that include Company Number, Name, Status, Type, Address and Registration Date are available for free online through a search feature on the St Lucia Online Company Registry website by the Registry of Companies and Intellectual Property. However, data cannot be downloaded in bulk, and how often or when they were last updated is not known. The type of license is also not known.",,"Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Evangelia Kampouri","15","15"
"696e0025-9d35-49c2-be7a-89b875bdae83","global","2017-01-29T20:27:22","2016","kn","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Financial Services Regulatory Commission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
As the submitter has indicated, the organisation responsible for collecting company data appears to be the Financial Services Regulatory Commission, however no way of accessing the Registrar of Companies could be found. Hence, there is no evidence that the dataset is available online.
https://www.fsrc.kn/","The responsible organisation appears to be Financial Services Regulatory Commission however its not apparent that they give access to the registry ","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"fb8287f3-fcdc-41de-8e9c-407d666ea04c","global","2017-03-05T19:48:52","2016","ro","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""the Justice Ministery - National Office of Commerce Registry"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission by Cristian Balulescu was rejected because not all four required characteristics were available online.
Company data are collected by the Justice Ministery - National Office of Commerce Registry and can be found on the Romanian Open Data portal. Company Name, Unique Registration Code, Matriculation Code, State Company, County, and Town are provided but not Company Address. Data are available for free and openly licensed (https://data.gov.ro/base/images/logoinst/OGL-ROU-1.0.pdf), downloadable at once in .CSV format, and updated every 3 months.
https://data.gov.ro/dataset?q=onrc&organization=onrc",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"d6b4cb9d-6e0c-4de7-992e-7240a9387dbd","global","2017-03-05T17:53:36","2016","pt","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministério da Justiça"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission was rejected as company addresses were not available online. The Portal da Justiça website offers a Publication Search feature where one can search entities for free by entering their name or registration identification number and a captcha code. Results provide Date, NIF/NIPC number, Entity name, Municipality, and Activity in .HTML format, but not full company address. Selecting the ""Content"" option provides no results. Data cannot be downloaded at once, and as the original submitter, Tiago Vieira, pointed out, since you can only search one company at the time, there is no evidence that the data is being updated. Also, there are no indications for it being openly licensed or in public domain on the website.
https://publicacoes.mj.pt/Pesquisa.aspx",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"2987082a-4edd-4d6b-a2e4-ead0f6c00d26","global","2016-11-23T21:03:58","2016","br","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The website content is under the following license: CC Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 Unported""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""RDF""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""As said there are files in .nt format as well, but it was not possible for me to open it. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There are links indicating the download of all the information of the annual budget (per year), but the file is in a NTriple format, which is very uncommon. It was not possible to open the file using regular programs. \nAlthough it is possible to export ( in .csv files) datasets per query from the system. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Yes, including even the 2017 proposed budget ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Type “Orçamento Federal Anual” (Federal Annual Budget) in Google, the first options are going to the ones indicated above."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www1.siop.planejamento.gov.br/siopdoc/doku.php and https://dados.gov.br/dataset/orcamento-federal/resource/90670cfb-8932-438c-ac32-2f33d9e3cbc8"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""At the page footer. ""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The Government Budget is published in different official websites (Ministry of Finance, Ministry of Planning, Budget, and Management, Federal Budget Secretary, Integrated System for Planning and Budgeting, Federal Senate and the Chamber of Deputies).\nThe Federal Budget Secretary, a subdepartment of Ministry of Planning, Budget, and Management, is in charge for the coordination of the budget process management. ""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no API and there is no way to easily get the whole dataset at once. Although it is possible to download data in processable format. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal Budget Secretary (Secretaria de Orçamento Federal) "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This is the agency responsible for the consolidation of all public agencies budgets considering the expected revenues and fiscal targets for the next year. ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.orcamentofederal.gov.br/clientes/portalsof/portalsof/orcamentos-anuais/orcamento-2016/orcamentos_anuais_view?anoOrc=2016"",""descValue"":""Federal Budget Secretary""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.planejamento.gov.br/assuntos/planeja/orcamento/orcamentos-anuais/"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Planning, Budget and Management""},{""urlValue"":""https://www12.senado.leg.br/orcamento/sigabrasil"",""descValue"":""Federal Senate (SIGA)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www2.camara.leg.br/atividade-legislativa/orcamentobrasil/loa"",""descValue"":""Chamber of Deputies""},{""urlValue"":""https://www1.siop.planejamento.gov.br/QvAJAXZfc/opendoc.htm?document=IAS%2FExecucao_Orcamentaria.qvw&host=QVS%40pqlk04&anonymous=true"",""descValue"":""Integrated planning and budgeting system (SIOP)""},{""urlValue"":""https://dados.gov.br/dataset/orcamento-federal"",""descValue"":""Open Data Portal Federal Budget""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data available in Federal Budget Secretary, Ministry of Planning, Budget and Management and Chamber of Deputies is the content of the Annual Budget Laws while SIGA and SIOP are systems with structured data about federal budget and expenditures. \nFor this evaluation we will be considering the data from SIOP because it is a structured dataset coming from a primary source. ""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept: Based on the comment section on the forum, I have added the links from the Brazilian Open Data Portal and thus changed the questions about bulk download (yes), format (RDF), license (added) and ease of use (3) to reflect this new information. ",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"57aa0729-d3cd-497b-ab3d-b5b566f13ceb","global","2016-12-07T18:08:00","2016","ba","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Scanned PDF of budget law.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried a web search engine for the \""Ministry of Finance, Bosnia and Herzegovina,\"" looked for the Budget on the menu."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.wipo.int/wipolex/en/text.jsp?file_id=180322"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Article 10 of Copyright Law states:\n1. Copyright protection shall not be afforded to:\nb) official texts from legislative, administrative and judicial areas. \n\n""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance and Treasury, Bosnia and Herzegovina"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://mft.gov.ba/bos/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=144&Itemid=111"",""descValue"":""The adopted budget""},{""urlValue"":""https://sllist.ba/glasnik/2015/broj101/Broj101.pdf"",""descValue"":""The budget law""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept: I checked all the links and could not find other budget documents nor tables, hence only the budget law is available. ",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Anna Alberts","65","65"
"32a34d21-f600-491c-862c-89db0156bb0e","global","2016-12-24T14:15:12","2016","by","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""No license specified, except the Copyright indicated at the bottom of the Ministry of Finance website\n\nhttps://www.minfin.gov.by/ru/budgetary_policy/budgetary_legislation/da8d2db88c99a337.html""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF only""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched for \""national budget law Belarus\"" on Google."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""none"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""data available as PDF only""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Very low level of details""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.minfin.gov.by/upload/bp/act/zakon_301215_341z.pdf"",""descValue"":""Budget Law for 2016""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.minfin.gov.by/ru/budgetary_policy/budgetary_legislation/da8d2db88c99a337.html"",""descValue"":""homepage of budget files""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept: the budget law is published in PDF, tabular data could not be found on the Ministry of Finance webpage and in general the budget files are hard to find.
Thus I have changed one answer: ""B5. Is the dataset downloadable at once?"" as there is only the budget law, not an actual dataset. ",,"Yes","No","Mary Loitsker","Anna Alberts","65","65"
"f9c1dc01-1064-4a03-a9a4-7dad7e8e7a50","global","2017-01-29T17:48:19","2016","bb","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance and Economic Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept: I was not able to access to website of the Ministry of Finance and Economic Affairs. The budget speech and a summary are available on the website of the parliament: https://www.barbadosparliament.com/uploads/document/e290bf642cdb3bc7e7637e760dbcb9e8.pdf and https://www.barbadosparliament.com/uploads/document/1c62bd506fa9d69e768dd2827fda4d8f.pdf. The latter two documents do not suffice as Budget Documents, nor as Open Budget Data. ","Unfortunately I was unable to identify a government portal for the given datasets.
","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Anna Alberts","0","0"
"b889deab-09d3-4ef1-abe4-89416bcb2d21","global","2017-01-25T05:51:56","2016","vc","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF download format ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""By searching the keywords \"" tender st vincent grenadine\"" I was connected to the St Vincent and the European Development Fund, provides assistance to Ministries and Project Implementation Units (PIUs) in the management of and implementation of projects and programmes. However i had spent a great deal of time attempting to source Central Supplies Tenders Board (CSTB) in an attempt to find more recent catalog of tenders and awards"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The information was not easily .""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""On the Ministry of Finance page the tender notices link connected to a World bank. I am under the assumption that they had out sourced there tender notices through the World bank for a period. The second website in collaboration with the European Union host open and closed tenders however the information appears to be fairly out dated. This disjointed collection of data can prove to be challenging in the collection, and analysis of the data""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Central Supplies Tenders Board (CSTB)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Central Supplies Tenders Board (CSTB) manages the procurement system of the central government. All purchases of goods, services and works in excess of $20,000 must be approved by the CSTB. In addition, the CSTB issue guidelines to govern the general conduct of the procurement activities undertaken by all Ministries, Departments and Autonomous bodies (MDAs).""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""On the webpage there is a collection of open and closed data""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://svgedfpmcu.com/current-tenders/"",""descValue"":""Current Tenders""},{""urlValue"":""https://projects.worldbank.org/procurement/procurementsearch?lang=en&qterm=&project_ctry_code_exact=VC&srce=both"",""descValue"":""World bank Procurement - St Vincent and the Grenadines""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Tender notices and Award notices are downloadable as .doc files. No filter per office.",,"Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"a9549dae-ca7c-42f6-a482-ed7e799e7f29","global","2016-12-12T18:20:42","2016","bd","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""First need to go website then need to collect or read this budget"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Finance Division, Ministry of Finance, Government of Bangladesh "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.mof.gov.bd/en/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=306&Itemid=1"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Finance Website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.nbr.gov.bd/budget.php?lan=eng"",""descValue"":""National Board of Revenue""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept: I have looked at the different websites indicated and also googled around and have to come to the same conclusion as the submitter, machine readable budget data seems to be not existent.
However, I did change one thing, the format of the data is not AsciiDoc, the links to the actual information are all PDF. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Anna Alberts","60","60"
"b2fc67c0-6a41-4c31-a087-9081909108f3","global","2016-11-30T11:00:39","2016","at","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Austrian Copyright Law states that official decisions and releases are in the public domain (§7, https://www.ris.bka.gv.at/GeltendeFassung.wxe?Abfrage=Bundesnormen&Gesetzesnummer=10001848). However, it is not clear if all budget related documents would be covered by this provision. The Ministry of Finance's website carries a copyright mark and specifies that republication of its content is permitted for non-commercial purposes only (https://www.bmf.gv.at/services/impressum/impressum.html)""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF only, some less granular data is available in XLSX""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Detailed budget documents and the most detailed budget data are only available in PDF files for each federal ministry/entity, these are a total of at least 58 seperate PDF files. Various tables relating to the budget, containing higher-level data (such as the budget for departments but not for sub-departments – at least I couldn't find it) are available for download in XLSX format""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is updated annually, in early December 2016, the data for 2017 was available""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Information is freely available, no payment, registration or login required""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Ministry of Finance has a prominent link to the \""Budget\"" section in the main navigation menu on its frontpage""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to the Website of the Ministry of Finance, there is a prominent link to \""Budget\"" in the main navigation menu on the homepage, go to the section \""Das Budget\"" (\""the budget\"") then click on \""Budgetentwurf 2017\"" (draft budget 2017). Second route: Googled: Budget Österreich 2017, the top four non-paid results were the website of the Ministry of Finance. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Effort is required for use of XLSX-Data, because tables provided in dozens of different worksheets. Extensive effort is provided to free data from PDF reports.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Austrian Federal Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Ministry of Finance (BMF) creates, manages and releases budget documents and submits documents related to the draft budget to the Austrian Parliament, which also has a team analyzing budget related issues (https://www.parlament.gv.at/PAKT/BUDG/)""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Detailed PDF reports for each Ministry and Federal entity are available at https://service.bmf.gv.at/Budget/Budgets/2017/bfg/teilhefte/_start_teilhefte.htm. However, there is no project-based budgeting, budget lines remain fairly general.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.bmf.gv.at/budget/das-budget/das-budget.html"",""descValue"":""Federal Ministry of Finance website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.parlament.gv.at/PAKT/BUDG/"",""descValue"":""Austrian Parliament website, section on budget analysis""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Ministry of Finance website is the primary source for data, the Parliament provides additional analysis on budgetary issues""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept: I agree with the assesment of the reviewer that the budget data - in machine readable format - is not sufficiently made available. Only overview tables and the budget law in PDF, and that does not suffice as an Open Data Set. ","No budget data is released on by the Federal Ministry of Finance on the Austrian open government data portal, data.gv.at (https://www.data.gv.at/auftritte/?organisation=bmf).
Some regional governments and cities do release budget data as open data (https://www.data.gv.at/suche/?search-term=&katFilter_finanzen-und-rechnungswesen=on&connection=and&searchIn=catalog#showresults). ","Yes","No","Mathias Huter","Anna Alberts","45","45"
"4b6a88d0-5c33-4b52-88ff-3df3a817955f","global","2017-01-24T19:16:59","2016","lc","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF download""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Noted additions ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""While perusing the Government of St Lucia webpage https://www.govt.lc/ I was connected to the Tender"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance, Economic Growth, Job Creation, External Affairs and the Public Service"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.govt.lc/news/about/contracts-and-tenders"",""descValue"":""News Articles, Notices about Contracts and Tenders""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.govt.lc/tenders"",""descValue"":""Access to Government Tenders and Tender Notices Active tender notices online""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","You can download pdf copies of the tender notices or view HTML versions. No filter or search for archive. ",,"Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"4fb64f06-370f-48c8-a2d8-d1b8697895d4","global","2016-12-09T01:38:27","2016","au","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The machine-readable Portfolio Budget Statement Line Items dataset is API-enabled inside CKAN to enable visualistion.\n\nhttps://data.gov.au/dataset/budget-2016-17-tables-and-data/resource/bd6a09a3-7687-4cc2-ae61-d03c5d03c594""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is released as soon as practicable to release of the budget - usually on the same day.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""google search for open budget data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.au/dataset/budget-2016-17-tables-and-data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is released under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Australia licence""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.au/dataset/budget-2016-17-tables-and-data"",""descValue"":""Budget 2016-17: Portfolio Budget Statements - Tables and Data""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.au/dataset/budget-2016-17-tables-and-data/resource/bd6a09a3-7687-4cc2-ae61-d03c5d03c594"",""descValue"":""Machine Readable Portfolio Line Items Dataset""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.au/dataset/2015-16-paes"",""descValue"":""Portfolio Additional Estimates Statements""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept: checked all links: perfect and CC 3.0 Australian License, full explanation etc. ","In addition to the annual budget, mid-year and additional estimates data is also made available.","Yes","Yes",,"Anna Alberts","100","100"
"f316643b-62c0-4cae-a69c-45f3898431f2","global","2016-11-17T15:53:12","2016","ar","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Hay que entrar al portal de datos del gobierno nacional y ir a los datos publicados por el Ministerio de Hacienda."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://github.com/gobabiertoAR/datasets-portal/blob/master/presupuesto/presupuesto-documentacion.md"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Hacienda. Secretaría de Hacienda. Subsecretaría de Presupuesto."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://datos.gob.ar/dataset/ejecucion-presupuestaria-de-la-administracion-publica-nacional"",""descValue"":""Datos correspondientes a la ejecución presupuestaria de la Administración Pública Nacional incluyendo apertura institucional, Fuente de Financiamiento, Carácter y Objeto del Gasto, Finalidad y Función y Clasificador Económico. A la información de sanción y vigente se incorporan las etapas del gasto (Comprometido, Devengado, Pagado).""},{""urlValue"":""https://sitiodelciudadano.mecon.gov.ar/"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I have checked all the links and it is all correct, and super user friendly. I am going to use this one in my work for how budgets should be presented. ",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Anna Alberts","100","100"
"8652b056-f86a-486c-aa2f-d851546f4603","global","2017-01-26T03:52:36","2016","ag","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I have googled the ministry of Finance in Antigua Barbuda and this website ( https://ab.gov.ag/detail_page.php?page=13) does not give any valuable links. With a further google search only the budget speech could be found: https://www.ab.gov.ag/pdf/budget_speech_2016.pdf
Also on the law portal of Antigua and Barbuda, the budget law could not be found (https://laws.gov.ag/new/index.php). ","Unfortunately I was unable to identify a government portal for the given datasets.
","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Anna Alberts","0","0"
"d8bc5a09-9043-4413-84f0-0b8e0866b17e","global","2017-01-26T05:30:20","2016","kn","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Unknown"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No government website available for procurement data.
No changes on the submission. ","Unfortunately I was unable to identify a government portal for the given datasets. The main gov website appears to be under construction
https://www.gov.kn/","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"b054eada-4006-45ce-8f02-30165732a43d","global","2016-12-31T08:48:47","2016","mm","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Meteorology and Hydrology of Myanmar"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The official website https://www.dmh.gov.mm/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. No wind or temperature forecasts could be found. Precipitation forecasts are issued for the current day, including precipitation probability (https://www.dmh.gov.mm/myanmar-daily-weather-report-298). Tabular rainfall data can be found at: https://www.dmh.gov.mm/rainfall-3172015. But they are last updated in July 2015.
","There is a single day forecast and a ten day forecast, but neither include temperature or wind data.","Yes","No","anonymous","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"022b7ba4-7010-4b32-aabd-37ade723b4bc","global","2017-01-19T16:35:40","2016","mz","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Nacional de Meteorologia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to find answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission was changed, because the reviewer verified that Mozambique has a ""Instituto Nacional de Meteorologia"". The institute is affiliated with the Ministry of Transport and Communications. See here: https://www.inam.gov.mz (link in Portuguese).
Outdated forecast information was found on the website at: https://www.inam.gov.mz and in sub-links. This data includes temperature extremes, and general weather conditions (cloud coverage, precipitation) for several cities in Mozambique. Additionally a bulletin for weather warnings is issued. It seems the data was not updated after the 22nd of December.
Thank you, Tricia Govindasamy, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. ",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"ae7ef920-9be6-4036-beaa-dfc06afec3ee","global","2017-03-04T22:39:43","2016","ph","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""the Department of Trade and Industry - Philippine Business Registry"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission was rejected as not all four required characteristics can be found online.
There is a Business Name Search feature on the Department of Trade and Industry - Philippine Business Registry website where one can search for an entity free of charge as long as they know the company's name, however the results include only Business Name and Status in .HTML format. No unique identifiers are given and although there is a column for Business Location, the address is not provided for all entities. Data cannot be downloaded in bulk and their update frequency is not known.
https://www.business.gov.ph/web/guest/bn-search",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"75285bd7-ee1e-40c0-90b5-72e5bdc70a43","global","2016-12-15T22:01:02","2016","pe","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Need to find the ID or Register Name to get results"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""SUNAT"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://e-consultaruc.sunat.gob.pe/cl-ti-itmrconsruc/jcrS00Alias"",""descValue"":""Search engine for companies""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
Data are available for free via the Company Search feature by the National Superintendency of Tax Administration (SUNAT) website which is in Spanish. However, one needs to know an entity's name or RUC (Single Taxpayer Registration number) in order to find it, as well as to enter a captcha code. Results are given in .HTML format and cannot be downloaded at once. Whether they are frequently updated is also unknown. At a glance, RUC, Name, Location (city), and State are provided. Once clicked on an entity's RUC, more information are available: Number of RUC, Type of Taxpayer, Tradename, Date of Inscription, Start Date of Activities, Taxpayer Status, Taxpayer's Status, Address, Proof of Issuance System, Accounting System, Economic activities, Proof of Payment, Electronic Emission System, Electronic Issuer since (date), Electronic Vouchers, Affiliated to PLE since (date), and Standards.
Please note that the website is not very cooperative. It crashes at almost every search request as well as almost every time a RUC is selected and shows either a message saying the page took too long to load, or a message saying ""The application has returned the following problem: There were problems processing the query by ruc number. Action to be taken: Please try again to run the option, if you continue with the problem, contact our webmaster."" Thus, one may need to submit their search query for a specific entity more than once in order to get (and then access the) results.",,"Yes","No","Antonio Cucho Gamboa","Evangelia Kampouri","15","15"
"5422c873-6cd4-4d5f-b7ac-542c963117ed","global","2017-01-06T23:37:10","2016","ua","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Texts are RTF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Texts are not available at once, metadata is""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Found on Facebook"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.rada.gov.ua/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Verkhovna Rada"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.rada.gov.ua/open/data/zpr-skl8"",""descValue"":""Bills of 8th Parliament of Ukraine""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data is available on provided website. It is difficult to figure out how to convert texts.
B5: Texts are not available at once, metadata is
B8: Texts are RTF",,"Yes","No","Vanya Yani","Michael Beatty","85","85"
"e3950c61-d25e-4130-b0da-8be7a9a68843","global","2016-12-27T14:33:15","2016","tz","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF downloadable""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went straight to Parliament's website and started searching for the data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Parliament of Tanzania"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""For the transcripts of the debates, you can find them HANSARDS but it is difficult to figure out which session is for which bill.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.parliament.go.tz/bills-list"",""descValue"":""National Parliament of Tanzania""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","All data can be found on the provided website. Easy to navigate. Downloadable in PDF.
B3: For the transcripts of the debates, you can find them HANSARDS but it is difficult to figure out which session is for which bill.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Beatty","45","45"
"24373399-597b-4060-998d-bdd711717e9e","global","2017-03-04T19:44:19","2016","pk","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission was rejected because not all four required characteristics could be found online.
According to the original submitter, Nouman Nazim, a list of registered companies that however did not include the companies' unique identifiers was available free of charge without the need to register or request access to the data in .HTML format on the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan website. Yet, the link provided directs to a page that does not contain any information:
https://www.secp.gov.pk/list-of-registered-companies/#
I was able to find a search feature provided by the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan but not only does one have to know the name of an entity in order to find it, the results also do not include companies' addresses, only Company Name, Status, CRO, Registration number, Registration Date, and Form A/B Made Upto Date:
https://eservices.secp.gov.pk/eServices/NameSearch.jsp",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"1352425a-4c1b-4dd1-9547-49c67e79d19c","global","2016-12-27T14:25:00","2016","tz","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Available in PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to Ministry of Law and judiciary websites , and later was led to the right place"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of law and constitutional affairs under law reform commission of Tanzania."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.lrct.go.tz/laws-of-tanzania-2012/"",""descValue"":""Law Reform Commission of Tanzania""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.parliament.go.tz/index.php/acts-list"",""descValue"":""Acts - Parliament of Tanzania""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Use this site to navigate through Acts and national laws. : https://www.parliament.go.tz/index.php/acts-list ""}]","Yes","Yes","It is a bit difficult to navigate the website. All information is available on the sites given.
Use this site to navigate through acts and national laws. : https://www.parliament.go.tz/index.php/acts-list
Most data is downloadable via PDF",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Beatty","45","45"
"98147eb7-284e-4381-803d-eac6179ce06a","global","2017-03-04T19:15:45","2016","om","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Commerce and Industry "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission was rejected because company addresses were not consistently provided. As stated by the original submitter, Riyadh Al-Balushi, the Ministry of Commerce and Industry provides a search engine on the InvestEasy - Government One Stop Shop Website for Investment to find the details of all registered companies. The search engine can be used in Arabic and English. Commercial Registration number, Name (in Arabic and English), Legal form, and CR Status are available at a glance, and once the ""view"" option is chosen, the Places of Activities (Business Area, Place of Activity code, PoA activities, Postal Code, PO Box, Building number, Area Number, Street, e-mail and phone numbers [where applicable]) should be available. However, the actual address, mainly the street names and numbers, are not consistently provided. Hence, not all four required characteristics could be found online. The data available are in .HTML format, free of charge, but cannot be downloaded in bulk and are behind a search mask.
https://www.business.gov.om/wps/portal/ecr/services/findbusinessinformation/searchcompanylisting",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"8be4d779-8d65-48e6-a828-e3fb3eb11537","global","2017-03-04T19:10:54","2016","mk","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" State Election Commission of Republic of Macedonia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission because not all required data is available. As submitter noted, results available (https://rezultati.sec.mk/Parliamentary/Results?cs=en-US&r=2&rd=r&eu=All&m=All) include registered votes, major results and invalid votes, no information for spoiled ballots. As submitter noted, it is possible that “Spoiled ballots” are included in the invalid votes count. Data is up to date, covering 2014 presidential and parliamentary elections, available in HTML, by polling station.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"c5d96b7d-f905-4ca7-a08a-950927bfb8ec","global","2016-11-23T06:52:20","2016","sg","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Available in PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Full Act with all the sections can be downloaded with one click""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search Singapore Statutues in search bar"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Attorney-General's Chambers "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://statutes.agc.gov.sg/aol/home.w3p"",""descValue"":""Database of Singapore Legislations and Amendments""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","All data is found on the site provided.
B5: Full Act with all the sections can be downloaded with one click
B8: Available in PDF format only",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Beatty","60","60"
"231cb796-3751-4dba-ae63-92064ed3f82e","global","2017-03-04T18:48:09","2016","ir","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Interior Affairs (Ministry of State)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission because not all required data is available. Results available for Presidential results (https://www.moi.ir/Portal/Home/Default.aspx?CategoryID=144DC85F-E825-477B-B3D1-0A2B6FB1DF9A) & Parliamentary results (https://www.moi.ir/Portal/home/?396089/%D9%86%D8%AA%D8%A7%DB%8C%D8%AC-%D8%B4%D9%85%D8%A7%D8%B1%D8%B4-%D8%A2%D8%B1%D8%A7-%D9%85%D8%AC%D9%84%D8%B394) include at most registered votes and major results, no information for invalid or spoiled ballots. Available in PDF format.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"fca4f0ed-3060-4ea5-a716-335618273d07","global","2016-12-12T08:31:39","2016","ru","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""google it"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal Security Service"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://pravo.gov.ru"",""descValue"":""Governmental Information system ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This one was a little difficult to navigate through. The information is there however, it take some time to download a translator app to convert the website information to English. I had to do this to find the information.",,"Yes","No","Mikhail Parfentev","Michael Beatty","45","45"
"d59c0468-e42d-41b5-9ada-7fd3a2f76dfd","global","2017-02-02T21:23:43","2016","pe","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Can't find any license information""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Looked for Peru congress in google, then went to the footer. There is a direct link to the proposals there. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Congreso de la república del Perú"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.congreso.gob.pe/proyectosdeley/"",""descValue"":""Proposiciones de ley o de resolución legislativa""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","All information is available on the provided website.","It's not possible to download a proper dataset, only go one by one with the proposals","Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Michael Beatty","45","45"
"4c11186b-2cc6-42f3-ba66-f2e9fccaa98f","global","2017-01-11T14:40:01","2016","pe","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Choose the number or type of law, navigate each law to find additional data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""https://www.leyes.congreso.gob.pe/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.leyes.congreso.gob.pe/"",""descValue"":""Archivo Digital de Leyes""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The data is a little difficult to navigate through; however, I am submitting this because the data can be found on the site.",,"Yes","No","Antonio Cucho Gamboa","Michael Beatty","45","45"
"d6aff5a9-7868-438c-ae06-f9529529d534","global","2016-12-15T16:05:23","2016","nir","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google 'Northern Ireland Assembly'. Go to website. Click 'Legislation'"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.niassembly.gov.uk/about-the-assembly/corporate-information/copyright"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Northern Ireland Assembly"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.niassembly.gov.uk/assembly-business/legislation/"",""descValue"":""Northern Ireland Assembly Legislation: Acts and Bills, including progress through parliament""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","All data accessible via the provided website. ","Draft Bills also provided in PDF","Yes","No","Bob Harper","Michael Beatty","65","65"
"c828bb91-d706-41af-b800-3c07b09874e5","global","2016-12-15T16:00:02","2016","nir","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""RDF"",""TXT"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""A. Google 'Northern Ireland Legislation' B. Go to NI Assembly website, click on 'Legislation'"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/version/3/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Northern Ireland Assembly draft and publish Acts. Various government departments produce and publish secondary legislation."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.legislation.gov.uk/browse/ni"",""descValue"":""Legislation related to Northern Ireland as a devolved administation ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.legislation.gov.uk/browse/uk"",""descValue"":""Legislation related to Northern Ireland as part of the UK""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.niassembly.gov.uk/assembly-business/legislation/"",""descValue"":""Northern Ireland Assembly Legislation""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","All data is in order and available on the provided websites.","Easy to access and navigated HTML data. RDF and XML will take a relative amount of programming experience.","Yes","Yes","Bob Harper","Michael Beatty","100","100"
"e1858743-f996-4ea3-b0ac-e37692dc4071","global","2017-01-19T17:08:41","2016","mz","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Again, no data is available.",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Michael Beatty","0","0"
"f88d1a65-f820-4095-a981-d077cbf1e92a","global","2017-01-16T18:53:00","2016","mz","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I couldn't find any data either.",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Michael Beatty","0","0"
"74a6ec45-17d8-4dc6-8f57-a49cb78fd521","global","2017-01-12T15:53:03","2016","no","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Can download entire dataset. Updated ~daily.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data updated daily (with some exceptions). Query to API at data.brreg.no gives real-time lookup.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Already know they are there. Went to data.norge.no and searched for \""enhetsregisteret\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.norge.no/nlod"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Can view/search/filter dataset in web-interface.\nCSV-version makes it possible to open in your preferred spreadsheet-software.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Brønnøysund Register Centre"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""norwegian name: Brønnøysundregistrene, or Registerenheten i Brønnøysund (formal name)""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.norge.no/data/registerenheten-i-br%C3%B8nn%C3%B8ysund/enhetsregisteret"",""descValue"":""Entry in national open data registry""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.brreg.no/"",""descValue"":""Home page""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
Data, collected by the Brønnøysund Register Centre (""Brønnøysundregistrene"", or ""Registerenheten i Brønnøysund""), are available online for free on the Open Data portal via the Brønnøysund Register Centre - Company Register and the Agency for Public Management and eGovernment. Data can be downloaded in bulk and are updated daily (with some exceptions). Query to API at data.brreg.no gives real-time lookup. Data include organization number, company name, and address, are available in .CSV, .JSON, and .XML formats, and are licensed with Norwegian license for public data (NLOD)","Would be nice to populate this form with data from last year, and make changes in stead of re-filling the whole form.","Yes","Yes","Bergheimivar L","Evangelia Kampouri","100","100"
"9a5c54f3-8719-4d8c-840a-a8fd2b219a1e","global","2016-12-04T19:00:12","2016","hr","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""All published data are for information purposes only and intended for personal use, and may not be used for commercial purposes or distributed to a third party. \n\nhttps://geoportal.dgu.hr/#/menu/uvjeti-koristenja""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""WMS service is available from geoportal, see offerings here https://geoportal.dgu.hr/#/menu/podaci-i-servisi""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried an online web search engine for \""E-cadaster Croatia\"". On the site of the Agency, Geoportal is listed under Links.."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""State Geodetic Administration, Republic of Croatia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://geoportal.dgu.hr/"",""descValue"":""Geoportal DGU""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Available Croatian Base Map (HOK) 1:5.000 WMS: https://geoportal.dgu.hr/services/hok/wms ","ok","Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Codrina Maria Ilie","60","60"
"a3a923d0-7d88-426f-9a7e-16dbc94323c1","global","2017-01-16T18:42:36","2016","zm","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"ok","Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"b7d118e6-d7f1-467d-8c2c-bba397e020d9","global","2017-01-15T18:22:10","2016","zm","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Zambia Postal Services Corporation (ZAMPOST)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.upu.int/nc/en/the-upu/member-countries/africa/zambia.html?sword_list[0]=zambia""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""-"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No evidence to provide answer.""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"https://www.upu.int/nc/en/the-upu/member-countries/africa/zambia.html?sword_list[0]=zambia","Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"05afb174-4662-4795-83db-d0dd7fb03bb2","global","2017-01-12T21:42:14","2016","jm","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Legislation documents are available for download in PDF formats""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The dissemination of the data/legislation is disjointed between 2 websites, The collection of data in periodic groups lead to broken links on the House of Parliament page. This page was linked from the Ministry of Justice site following the link \"" Latest Bills and Acts\"". However following the drop down menu under \""Publications\"" on the House of Parliament Site there were files observed to have been uploaded for 2016. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Upon entering the keyword \""National Laws of Jamaica\"" The results lead me to the Ministry of Justice website. Upon reading the site further it explained that Houses of Parliament website hosted more recent legislation after 2009."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The Ministry of Justice is the responsible agent for the collection and dissemination of the National Laws via an online server""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Justice "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""A PDF download of the legislation is made available ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://moj.gov.jm/laws"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Justice ""},{""urlValue"":""www.japarliament.gov.jm."",""descValue"":""Houses of Parliament""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The versions of the legislation on the Ministry of Justice website is made available for information only and any legislation printed from this website has no official status. Legislation that has been passed by the Houses of Parliament and brought into effect prior to 2010. Legislation passed by the Houses of Parliament since 2009 are located at the Jamaica Parliament website www.japarliament.gov.jm.""}]","Yes","Yes","Law are very easy to find using the filter. All information and data are available on the given websites. Comments are below:
B1: The Ministry of Justice is the responsible agent for the collection and dissemination of the National Laws via an online server
B2.2: The versions of the legislation on the Ministry of Justice website is made available for information only and any legislation printed from this website has no official status. Legislation that has been passed by the Houses of Parliament and brought into effect prior to 2010. Legislation passed by the Houses of Parliament since 2009 are located at the Jamaica Parliament website www.japarliament.gov.jm.
B6: The dissemination of the data/legislation is disjointed between 2 websites, The collection of data in periodic groups lead to broken links on the House of Parliament page. This page was linked from the Ministry of Justice site following the link "" Latest Bills and Acts"". However following the drop down menu under ""Publications"" on the House of Parliament Site there were files observed to have been uploaded for 2016.
B8: Legislation documents are available for download in PDF formats","The dissemination of the data or legislation files would benefit from adjusting the UI/UX and centralizing the data ","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Michael Beatty","60","60"
"cdd9972d-314f-43b0-ae33-7e8c7bdbed08","global","2017-01-31T18:32:47","2016","in","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""All available only in PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google India legislation"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Law and Justice, Legislative Department"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.in/catalogs/ministry_department/rajya-sabha"",""descValue"":""open data portal higher house""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.in/catalogs/ministry_department/lok-sabha-secretariat"",""descValue"":""open data portal lower house""},{""urlValue"":""https://indiacode.nic.in/welcome.htm"",""descValue"":""Legislation database""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Use this one to find the actual legislation:\nhttps://indiacode.nic.in/welcome.htm\n\nThis only has data up to 2016.""}]","Yes","Yes","The national laws are all available on the website:
https://indiacode.nic.in/welcome.htm.
Comments:
B2.2: Use this one to find the actual legislation:
https://indiacode.nic.in/welcome.htm
This only has data up to 2016.
B8: All available only in PDF",,"Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Michael Beatty","45","45"
"eea9c41b-35d6-4bdf-8b94-c3f731c1f5ca","global","2017-03-03T22:32:14","2016","lc","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""St Lucia Electoral Division "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission because not all required data is available. As submitter noted, results available (https://www.electoral.gov.lc/past-results/summary-results) include registered votes, major results and invalid votes, no information for spoiled ballots. Available in HTML.
Data is easily findable within the website of the Electoral Division website, under the tab Past Results.
As submitter notes, summary results for the 2016 are available however, detailed statistics from the recent polls for 2016 have not been updated.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"02ad5083-29c5-4cfb-b440-e3329441a0e1","global","2017-03-03T22:18:53","2016","gh","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Electoral Commission of Ghana "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission because not all required data is available. Results available (https://www.thumbsapp.com.gh/) include registered votes and major results, no information for invalid or spoiled ballots. Available in HTML format through external app. According to app, results available are the results for 271 constituencies out of 275. As for historical data (https://www.ec.gov.gh/resources/downloads/election-results.html) it is possible to acccess data of registered votes and major results in PDF format, by constituency. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"815283bc-aa1c-428d-83f1-d156b946bcb7","global","2017-03-03T22:10:43","2016","au","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""PSMA Australia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The data specification does not reveal that the dataset would have information related to property value [https://www.psma.com.au/sites/default/files/cadlite_product_description.pdf], thus the data [https://www.psma.com.au/products/cadlite] is not fully compliant with the survey requirements. The initial submitter was anonymous. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"d99dae57-85b6-4412-8ca3-6393dd418c11","global","2017-03-03T22:08:15","2016","bt","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Election Comission of Bhutan"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission because not all required data is available. As submitter noted, results (https://www.ecb.bt/?p=3842 / https://www.ecb.bt/lg2016/) available include registered votes and major results, no information for invalid or spoiled ballots. Available by electoral district and in HTML format.
Copyright disclaimer indicates: “All information and materials contained in this website are the properties of the Election Commission of Bhutan. No part of the materials or information extracted or downloaded from the website may be used for any other purpose. Anyone wishing to use the name, photo, video or any material thereof only for personal purpose may do so with the permission or acknowledgement of the Election Commission of Bhutan.”.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"23e0d0fa-b39c-4a31-94dd-b81faccd0626","global","2016-12-09T09:18:51","2016","hr","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF only""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The draft legislation is updated very frequently. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried a web search engine for Draft Legislation"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Croatian Parliament"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.sabor.hr/HR"",""descValue"":""homepage""},{""urlValue"":""https://edoc.sabor.hr"",""descValue"":""edoc search""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Although the information is all in the dataset, it is only available in PDF form. It is downloadable but it is only in PDF. All draft legislation is easy to find and easy to navigate through.",,"Yes","No","Zoran Lusha","Michael Beatty","45","45"
"074d79d3-3118-4107-bada-c81f2fab4624","global","2016-12-04T14:07:14","2016","hr","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Copyright is claimed under the law, see Opći uvjeti korištenja (Terms and conditions) at the bottom https://narodne-novine.nn.hr/""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Very easy to get to once on the page.\nhttps://narodne-novine.nn.hr/default.aspx\nFrom here you can navigate through a number of different means, including dates and names.\nThere is also a guide that teaches how to navigate , found here:\nhttps://narodne-novine.nn.hr/upute.aspx""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried a web search engine for Službeni list Hrvatska site:*.hr"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Narodne Novine - Official Journal of the Republic of Croatia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://narodne-novine.nn.hr/default.aspx "",""descValue"":""Narodne Novine""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Submission based on how all information is found on the sites given.
B2.3: Very easy to get to once on the page.
https://narodne-novine.nn.hr/default.aspx
From here you can navigate through a number of different means, including dates and names.
There is also a guide that teaches how to navigate , found here:
https://narodne-novine.nn.hr/upute.aspx
B7: Copyright is claimed under the law, see Opći uvjeti korištenja (Terms and conditions) at the bottom https://narodne-novine.nn.hr/
",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Michael Beatty","45","45"
"ca6ed1d7-57df-43b9-b9d0-7528a76d79f5","global","2016-12-15T09:20:28","2016","my","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The characteristic of data found consist of unique identifier, API (Air Pollutant Index), date, time, state and location of reading.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment and Department of Environment"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The characteristic of data found consist of unique identifier, API (Air Pollutant Index), date, time, state and location of reading.""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections, no other sources found that covered the Pollutant data that does not use the API index.",,"Yes","No","Hazwany Jamaluddin","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"d08839f7-d295-42f6-baf3-9736fe20c9d7","global","2017-01-17T15:54:13","2016","mw","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted and confirmed.",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"6a808eb7-d9b7-4110-8dad-f34d35b576ad","global","2016-12-11T14:13:39","2016","mk","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Copyright is claimed in the footer: \""Copyright © 2016, MOEPP/IT - All Rights Reserved\""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Only daily reports. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data can be viewed as a table only daily. Weekly or monthly can be viewed only as a time series graph, ex https://airquality.moepp.gov.mk/?page_id=4""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queriend an online search engine for Environmental pollution Macedonia. Website is one of the results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Environment and Physical Planning, Republic of Macedonia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://airquality.moepp.gov.mk/?page_id=2&lang=en"",""descValue"":""Air Pollution Now - Ministry of Environment and Physical Planning, Republic of Macedonia""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted and confirmed.",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Ricardo Alanís","45","45"
"bf87c418-51d8-4830-b018-18f16008344a","global","2017-01-16T20:53:17","2016","ls","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted and Confirmed.",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"498a2f88-96f0-4c89-8fc3-bd158ca6a0e2","global","2016-11-24T18:03:24","2016","br","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The Lexml project gives access to the API/webservice through HTML (research portal) and XML (all data).""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is downloadable in bulk through the API/webservice system.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is updated every time there is an amendment to the laws.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I was already acquainted with the brazilian Presidency portal, but it was quite difficult to find the information for the Lexml project. I had to ask specialists about it.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1) Tried to search in the web for the data but only retrieved the brazilian Presidency consultation webpage 2) asked for specialists in legislation data for a reference and got some links for the Senate, 3) Found the Lexml project through the Senate open data portal."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://projeto.lexml.gov.br/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The page footer shows that the content and data from the website are published under a Creative Commons 4.0 license.\nAll the webservice links also redirect to the open definition.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""You need to have programming skills to access the API/webservice and use the data.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Senado Federal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Federal Senate (Senado Federal) in Brazil keeps a data repository and documentation for downloading the webservice.\nThe brazilian Presidency (\""Palácio do Planalto\"") also keeps a comprehensive portal for searching and consulting federal laws.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://projeto.lexml.gov.br/"",""descValue"":""The Lexml project, part of “Interlegis” legislative initiative, is a webpage that contains both a research system for federal laws and also the possibility to access its API.""},{""urlValue"":""https://dadosabertos.senado.gov.br/dataset/api-search-and-retrieve-via-url-sru"",""descValue"":""The Federal Senate keeps the documentation to search and retrieve data from the Lexml project.""},{""urlValue"":""https://dadosabertos.senado.gov.br/group/legislacao2"",""descValue"":""There is also the possibility to retrieve federal juridical norms directly through the Senate in .xml format.""},{""urlValue"":""https://legis.senado.leg.br/dadosabertos/docs/resource_LegislacaoService.html#resource_LegislacaoService_listaNormasXml_GET"",""descValue"":""This documentation shows how to retrieve access to the API for the Senate.""},{""urlValue"":""https://www4.planalto.gov.br/legislacao"",""descValue"":""The brazilian Presidency keeps this webpage to federal law consultation, but download here is not possible.""},{""urlValue"":""https://legislacao.planalto.gov.br/legisla/legislacao.nsf/fraWeb?OpenFrameSet&Frame=frmWeb2&Src=/legisla/legislacao.nsf%2FFrmConsultaWeb1%3FOpenForm%26AutoFramed"",""descValue"":""The brazilian Presidency also keeps a platform for searching federal laws, but download here is not possible.""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Here I listed many different sources for data, starting with the most comprehensive open data initiative by the brazilian Legislative and ending with the consultation webpage of the brazilian Presidency, which is used very often, but doesn’t provide open data format.""}]","Yes","Yes","Well documented. All data is found on the sites provided. These comments are from the original submitter.
B1.1: The Federal Senate (Senado Federal) in Brazil keeps a data repository and documentation for downloading the webservice.
The brazilian Presidency (""Palácio do Planalto"") also keeps a comprehensive portal for searching and consulting federal laws.
B2.2: Here I listed many different sources for data, starting with the most comprehensive open data initiative by the brazilian Legislative and ending with the consultation webpage of the brazilian Presidency, which is used very often, but doesn’t provide open data format.
B2.3: I was already acquainted with the brazilian Presidency portal, but it was quite difficult to find the information for the Lexml project. I had to ask specialists about it.
B5: Data is downloadable in bulk through the API/webservice system.
B6: Data is updated every time there is an amendment to the laws.
B7.1: The page footer shows that the content and data from the website are published under a Creative Commons 4.0 license.
All the webservice links also redirect to the open definition.
B8: The Lexml project gives access to the API/webservice through HTML (research portal) and XML (all data).
B9: You need to have programming skills to access the API/webservice and use the data.
","More information about the Lexml project can be obtained through
https://projeto.lexml.gov.br/documentacao/resumo-em-ingles","Yes","Yes","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Michael Beatty","100","100"
"3617549a-a751-429d-8065-beb197d085c2","global","2016-12-15T19:25:28","2016","pr","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The first website has the information available apparently in HTML. The second website has the information available in PDF (not machine readable).""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""The first website is readily available via an Internet search. The second website was identified by consulting someone knowledgeable about the subject."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Administración de Servicios Generales"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www2.pr.gov/subasta/Pages/subastas.aspx"",""descValue"":""Notices of open calls for bids""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.asg.pr.gov/Compras-y-Suministros/Contratos"",""descValue"":""List of awards""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes in the submission. ",,"Yes","No","Jacobo Orenstein","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"5f881499-d8c4-49f6-8f42-af0df282d8ee","global","2016-12-20T10:20:58","2016","tn","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I changed the submission to NO because I do not see a statement about open license on neither of the URLs. The original submitter had answered YES and had provided this URL as evidence:\nhttps://www.iort.gov.tn/WD120AWP/WD120Awp.exe/CTX_8116-14-SIeTjCYUWH/Principal/SYNC_474349689\nThe link was broken so I could not verify.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Full texts of laws also available in PDF. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""write the right keywords"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.iort.gov.tn/WD120AWP/WD120Awp.exe/CTX_8116-14-SIeTjCYUWH/Principal/SYNC_474349689"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Official Printing Office of the Republic of Tunisia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""All the characteristics are present. Date of last amendment can be derived by checking the latest entry on the list of amendments. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.iort.gov.tn/"",""descValue"":""Official Printing Office""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.legislation.tn/"",""descValue"":""Prime Minister's Office""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Both URL seem to contain a database where it is possible to search full texts of laws. I am basing my review on the first URL listed (https://www.iort.gov.tn/) I was not able to navigate the search engine of the Prime Minister's Office (this may have been due to the fact that since I do not speak Arabic I could not type in any key word to search. Putting in a date only did not get me any results). ""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission should be accepted because all required characteristics are available in the data set. ","I am not able to asses to the website of the Prime Minister's office because I could not use search engine. Review is based on Official Printer's Website. The data on this website satisfies all the required characteristics. The only change I made was to change B7 to NO because the bottom of the Official Printer's Website states that ""all rights are reserved"" to Official Printing Office. The Prime Minister's website also contained no statement of open license. The link included by original submitter to verify open license was broken. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Juela Xhaferraj","45","45"
"ae721d27-20c3-4253-a76f-a203bdc33a74","global","2017-01-14T14:45:38","2016","pt","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Licensing details are in this page: https://www.base.gov.pt/Base/pt/PlataformasEletronicas/CredenciacaoLicenciamento""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Yes, at dados.gov.pt\n\nhttps://www.dados.gov.pt/pt/catalogodados/catalogodados.aspx#sthash.NFLIKLOZ.dpbs""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""It is possible to individually access procurement information and print it to PDF. It is also possible to download a CSV file with search results ""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""You can find this resource with a google search for procurement data in Portugal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto dos Mercados Públicos, do Imobiliário e da Construção, I.P. (IMPIC)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.base.gov.pt/"",""descValue"":""Contratos públicos online""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Awards and Tenders are separate but in the same platform. Basic information on queries for Awards and Tender Notices are exportable to XLS. The details can only be viewed in HTML.
No changes in the submission. ",,"Yes","No","Cátia Matos","Oscar Montiel","80","80"
"e0bf0b6a-3616-4e6d-b0f0-6b357749d1c4","global","2017-03-03T18:35:35","2016","ch","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The original submission had listedhttps://www.admin.ch/gov/de/start/bundesrecht/bundesblatt.html as the source for draft bills. The only access to draft bills on this website I (as the reviewer) could find was draft laws posted on the Federal Gazette. The Federal Gazette contains all other sorts of announcements, decisions, initiatives, etc. along with some bills. So the Content of the Bill could be found. The Author of the Bill could not be found (although the department to which the bill pertained was listed). The status of the bill could also not be found. Transcripts and votes were also missing. Since the dataset was missing two required characteristics and I couldn't find an alternate source, the original submission was rejected. ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal Chancellery"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission was rejected because the data was missing required characteristics. This submission is updated to reflect that data is not made available by the government. ","The original submission was rejected because two required characteristics were missing from the data set: author of bill and status of bill.
The original submission had indicated the following:
B3: Content of Bill (YES), Author of bill(YES), Status of Bill (YES) Transcripts(NO), Votes (NO)
B4: YES
B5: NO
B6: YES
B7: NO
B8: No machine readable format.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Juela Xhaferraj","0","0"
"6c38e6ae-8e46-48e5-906e-b403f2667552","global","2016-12-15T11:29:31","2016","bd","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No, the government has a copyright on all data and published laws.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is available in PDF. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Correct, yet you might need to navigate a little to find the information. I searched under the \""Laws and Rules\"" tab.\n\n""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Yes it is free of charge and can be downloaded via PDF.""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Need to visit website and then find data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data collected by the government.""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Law & Justice "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data can be found here: https://lawjusticediv.portal.gov.bd/\n\nProvided by the Ministry of Law and Justice.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://lawjusticediv.portal.gov.bd/"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Law & Justice""},{""urlValue"":""https://bdlaws.minlaw.gov.bd/index.php"",""descValue"":""Government of the People's Republic of Bangladesh - Ministry of Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""An easier site to navigate can be found here:\nhttps://bdlaws.minlaw.gov.bd/index.php\nIt leads straight to the laws. \nAlso the laws switches from English to Sanskrit after 1986.""}]","Yes","Yes","B1: Data collected by the government.
B1.1: Data can be found here: https://lawjusticediv.portal.gov.bd/
Provided by the Ministry of Law and Justice.
B2: Correct, yet you might need to navigate a little to find the information. I searched under the ""Laws and Rules"" tab.
B2.2: An easier site to navigate can be found here:
https://bdlaws.minlaw.gov.bd/index.php
It leads straight to the laws.
Also the laws switches from English to Sanskrit after 1986.
B4: Yes it is free of charge and can be downloaded via PDF.
B7: No, the government has a copyright on all data and published laws.
B8: It is available in PDF.
Overall, the data seemed to there, yet it does take time to find the database. After searching for sometime, I found a useful link that makes it a little easier to navigate. https://bdlaws.minlaw.gov.bd/index.php",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Beatty","60","60"
"46fa68bd-46b3-408e-8c1c-3a2229d8794a","global","2016-12-05T12:16:27","2016","jp","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""RDF"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: no, data is split into quarters/years""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""GDP and unemployment statistics are updated every 3 months.\npopulation statics is updated every year""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"" I did search box on top page of e-stat."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.e-stat.go.jp/estat/html/spec_en.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Statistics Bureau, Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Initial submission: 'Data is created by Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications.\nProvided by National Statistics Center.'\nUpdated to 'Statistics Bureau, Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications' - Portal Site of Official Statistics of Japan is developed by Statistics Bureau, Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications, in collaboration with ministries and agencies, and is managed by Incorporated Administrative Agency National Statistics Center. ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.e-stat.go.jp/SG1/estat/eStatTopPortalE.do"",""descValue"":""e-Stat Portal Site of Official Statistics of Japan (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.e-stat.go.jp/SG1/estat/eStatTopPortal.do"",""descValue"":""e-Stat Portal Site of Official Statistics of Japan (Japanese)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.stat.go.jp/english/"",""descValue"":""Statistics Bureau (English)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added link to Statistics Bureau""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Updated name of government agency to 'Statistics Bureau, Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications'. Amend B5 to no as data split into multiple files e.g. years/quarters.","""e-stat"" is the one-stop government statistics data site of Japan. Most of data are available in Excel, some are CSV (unfortunately PDF remains). You may use them free of charge.
This year, SPARQL endpoint and LOD data website are opened.
URL: https://data.e-stat.go.jp/lodw/","Yes","No","anonymous","Sophie Lafayette","85","85"
"09af1bc5-c5f7-4fe0-b179-b50133aa7be5","global","2017-01-17T15:28:24","2016","mw","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: website '2013 © National Statistical Office'""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF. Update: the open data portal allows for data to be downloaded in multiple formats (XLM, XLS, CVX, PNG, PDF, PPT, Atomsvc) but most data is not yet available on the portal. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to no, data is found within different PDF reports""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Not sure. Update: population yearly (latest 2014), employment yearly (latest 2013), GDP yearly (latest 2012, 2013-2015 projections). ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I google searched national statistics Malawi and this was the first search result."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Republic of Malawi National Statistics Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.nsomalawi.mw/"",""descValue"":""National Statistics Office""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dataportal.nsomalawi.mw/"",""descValue"":""Data Portal Malawi""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.nsomalawi.mw/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=3&Itemid=40"",""descValue"":""Key publications""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added additional link""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Tricia Govindasamy for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. All data found is within PDFs, although the open data portal allows for data to be downloaded in multiple formats (XLM, XLS, CVX, PNG, PDF, PPT, Atomsvc) but most data is not yet available on the portal. B5 amended to no as data is found within different PDF reports.",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Sophie Lafayette","30","30"
"ef315a87-5ea5-4751-8966-bd220ded04ca","global","2017-01-13T18:35:24","2016","jm","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: terms of use, https://statinja.gov.jm/Standardservices.aspx & website '© 2017 Statistical Institute of Jamaica'""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""TXT"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data tables are immediately loaded on the site plus users can download in the format of XLS, CSV, QCSV, TSV and TEXT and shared via various channels""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""On the site GDP data loads up to 2015, population data loaded up to 2014 however unemployment was up to date to 2016. Update: GDP latest Q3 2016 (https://statinja.gov.jm/NationalAccounting/Quarterly/NewQuarterlyGDP.aspx)""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Upon entering the keywords in Google \""national statistics jamaica\"", STATIN was the first result. The website's interface easily revealed the data sets of interest."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Statistical Institute of Jamaica (STATIN)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Statistical Institute of Jamaica's (STATIN) main functions is to collect, compile, analyse, abstract and publish statistical information relating to the commercial, industrial, social, economic and general activities and condition of the people;""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://statinja.gov.jm/"",""descValue"":""Statistical Institute of Jamaica""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.jm/"",""descValue"":""Jamaica Open Data Portal""},{""urlValue"":""https://statinja.gov.jm/NationalAccounting/Quarterly/NewQuarterlyGDP.aspx"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://statinja.gov.jm/Demo_SocialStats/Newpopulation.aspx"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://statinja.gov.jm/LabourForce/NewLFS.aspx"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added link to GDP, population, and unemployment data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Alesha Aris for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. ","STATIN has made recent changes to their website hosting a friendlier user interface and delivering various datasets via the site. ","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Sophie Lafayette","65","65"
"162190ce-802c-4421-be07-2538ad93f320","global","2016-12-31T20:18:05","2016","ir","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""We standardized all the Statistical Center of Iran's data and we have TSVs and CSVs and are going to upgrade them to LOD. but it's unofficial. The standard data is available at https://goo.gl/VMKpk6""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: amend to yes ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: no, unemployment yearly (latest 2013), population yearly (latest 2011), GDP yearly (latest 2011).""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I directly enter the website, but it's a popular website between data user, especially researchers."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""There's nothing"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There's nothing, but I asked former head of Statistical Centre of Iran and he said the data are open for all.\n""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to 2""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Statistical Centre of Iran"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.amar.org.ir/english"",""descValue"":""Statistical Centre of Iran (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.amar.org.ir/"",""descValue"":""Statistical Centre of Iran (Persian)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.amar.org.ir/english/Statistics-by-Topic/Labor-force#2222532-time-series"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.amar.org.ir/english/Statistics-by-Topic/Population#2224492-time-series"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.amar.org.ir/english/Statistics-by-Topic/National-accounts#2223535-time-series"",""descValue"":""GDP data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added links to unemployment, population, and GDP data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you MohammadHossein Khani for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. B5 amended to yes as each dataset can be downloaded. B6 amended to no as each dataset is updated yearly and is not up to date. B9 amended to 2, requires some work. ",,"Yes","No","MohammadHossein Khani","Sophie Lafayette","85","85"
"1d74238d-9657-4a45-a123-816445ad6fd9","global","2016-12-12T14:24:29","2016","id","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: access policy https://microdata.bps.go.id/mikrodata/index.php/policy""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: added XML format""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: data on main site can be downloaded at once per dataset however micro catalogue data is by year so multiple downloads may be needed in some cases""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: GDP by quarter (latest 2016), population yearly (latest 2015), population projections every five years (2010-2035), unemployment twice yearly (latest August 2016)""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: access to micro data in Central Data Catalog may require registration""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""we can easily type in the google search or go directly to National Statistics Agency's website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Updated: amended to 2 as some effort required to make data usable.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Statistics Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://bps.go.id/"",""descValue"":"" Indonesia National Statistics Agency""},{""urlValue"":""https://microdata.bps.go.id/mikrodata/index.php/catalog"",""descValue"":""Central Data Catalog""},{""urlValue"":""https://bps.go.id/Subjek/view/id/169#subjekViewTab3|accordion-daftar-subjek1"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://bps.go.id/Subjek/view/id/12#subjekViewTab3|accordion-daftar-subjek1"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bps.go.id/linkTabelStatis/view/id/981"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added links to GDP, population, and unemployment data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. B6 kept as yes although unemployment only updated twice a year, it is updated regularly - population & GDP also updated regularly. Added XML format. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Sophie Lafayette","80","80"
"4745a9ea-eae7-4a5a-9f6a-a04a69c9ae12","global","2016-12-20T11:23:25","2016","ph","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Openly licensed data is outdated; no license or statement regarding public domain for the datasets on the PhilGEPS site.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Detailed data only available until Dec 2015.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1) PhilGEPS site: \""data\"" on the navigation bar. 2) data.gov.ph: Search \""PhilGEPS\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""PhilGEPS"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.philgeps.gov.ph/data.html"",""descValue"":""Datasets until Dec 2015, and summary reports until November 2016""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.ph/catalogue/dataset/philgeps-public-data"",""descValue"":""PhilGEPS public data (detailed) until 2014.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes in submission. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Oscar Montiel","65","65"
"2f90c1a4-f853-4c20-8b5f-6bb904920c8c","global","2016-11-11T21:06:01","2016","br","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""TSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""For GDP, you have an option for \""downloading complete tables\"" in a zip file containing a single .xls file with the entire dataset.\nFor unemployment, there's also a table in .xls with many sheets. One of them contains the whole dataset since the beginning of the survey (2012).\nFor population, there's a link (https://www.ibge.gov.br/home/estatistica/populacao/estimativa2016/serie_2001_2016_tcu.shtm) with the entire time series since the beginning of this survey (2001).""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""This is being done the 11th November. GDP quarterly data was updated until the second quarter, but not the third one (ended in september). Though we find it reasonable, since it will be updated in november. It is the normal delay in releasing this kind of data.\nAs for employment data, it was updated until september, which is also fair enough.\nAs for population, IBGE releases yearly estimates every 1st of July, for the current year. So, data for 2016 was already available.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I'm acquainted with this kind of data for at least 8 years, so it was really easy to me. Maybe it i not so easy for someone that doesn't work in the field.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1) Go directly to the IBGE webpage, 2) Search for \""GDP\"", \""Population\"" and \""Unemployment\"", 3) recover the links from the respective surveys"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.ibge.gov.br/home/disseminacao/eventos/missao/principios_fundamentais_orientacoes_divulgacoes.shtm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I didn't find something as objective as a \""terms and conditions\"" or a real license, but I found at this link a list of fundamental principles for official statistics with some guidelines for publication and dissemination. It contains the idea of data provided for public domain.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""GDP data is collected through quarterly national accounts system by IBGE (Brazilian Institute for Geography and Statistics), a federal public agency. They are also responsible for yearly population data (census and projections).\nAs for employment data, they stopped releasing the \""Monthly Employment Survey - PME\"" in march 2016, which has replaced by the \""Continuous National Household Sample Survey - Continuous PNAD\"" with employment and unemployment statistics in a monthly basis.""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""All data is provided in excel spreadsheets that are easy to work and analyze.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""IBGE - Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The brazilian institute for geography and statistics is a federal government agency, associated with the brazilian ministry of planning, budget and management (Ministério do Planejamento, Orçamento e Gestão).""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ibge.gov.br/home/estatistica/indicadores/pib/defaultcnt.shtm"",""descValue"":""Quarterly GDP from the quarterly national accounts""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ibge.gov.br/home/estatistica/indicadores/trabalhoerendimento/pnad_continua_mensal/default.shtm"",""descValue"":""Monthly unemployment rates from the Continuous National Household Sample Survey""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ibge.gov.br/home/estatistica/populacao/estimativa2016/default.shtm"",""descValue"":""Yearly Population estimates based on census""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.sidra.ibge.gov.br/"",""descValue"":""All data from IBGE can also be downloaded through this system called SIDRA. But here you don't have access to the whole dataset.""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There are many ways to retrieve the same data in IBGE's website.\nAnd there are also the same data in other websites (from other institutions like the brazilian central bank of the brazilian institute for applied economic research).""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Wagner Faria de Oliveira for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. ",,"Yes","Yes","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Sophie Lafayette","100","100"
"a1296ab9-fc61-49c9-a326-08800d4d041d","global","2016-12-30T09:34:41","2016","bt","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to no information about license found (link provided to main site)""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: remove TXT, data only found within PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Updated to no: data for each year is in separate reports""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Updated to no: Population yearly (latest 2005 with projections to 2030), unemployment yearly (latest 2015), GDP yearly (latest 2015)""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Visit websites and went to the publication section"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.nsb.gov.bt/main/main.php"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to 1 - data has to be extracted from PDF before used. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" National Statistics Bureau (NSB)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.nsb.gov.bt"",""descValue"":""National Statistics Bureau""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.nsb.gov.bt/publication/publications.php?id=3"",""descValue"":""Statistical Year Books""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.nsb.gov.bt/publication/publications.php?id=5"",""descValue"":""Bhutan at a Glance - latest GDP, population figures ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added link to main site & latest figures ""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you to the Executive Director of BMF for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. B5 Updated to no as data for each year is in separate reports. B6 updated to no as unemployment available yearly. Removed TXT as format, data only found within PDF reports. Amended B9 to 1 as data has to be extracted from PDF before used. ",,"Yes","No","Executive Director, BMF","Sophie Lafayette","30","30"
"d51163bf-5b45-42bc-85b2-c1a01ab16216","global","2017-01-21T15:38:55","2016","no","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""GeoJSON""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Also in SOSI-format""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to Geonorge, searched and found (1st result)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/no/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Norwegian Mapping Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://kartkatalog.geonorge.no/metadata/kartverket/administrative-enheter/041f1e6e-bdbc-4091-b48f-8a5990f3cc5b"",""descValue"":""Entry on geonorge.no""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.norge.no/data/statens-kartverk/grenser"",""descValue"":""Entry on national opne data portal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Concur with the original submitter that the dataset has all the needed characteristics; and the dataset is available to download for free.
Only restriction is that a login is needed to download the dataset.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Bergheimivar L","Michael Leow","85","85"
"e301c36a-455a-4a1a-b19a-4d267e6a7c7e","global","2017-01-12T15:36:30","2016","pe","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Need choose the differents categories, the subject of the contracts, dates or input the RUC of each contract"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""OSCE - Organismo supervisor de contrataciones del Estado"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://prodapp2.seace.gob.pe/seacebus-uiwd-pub/buscadorPublico/buscadorPublico.xhtml"",""descValue"":""SEACE""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Sistema electrónico de Contrataciones del Estado""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes in submission. Searches are always protected by captcha, which makes obtaining data more complicated. ",,"Yes","No","Antonio Cucho Gamboa","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"39df5aed-3511-491a-8b33-b48cc14c3017","global","2017-03-03T14:14:06","2016","me","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Real Estate Administration of Montenegro"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original Submission:
Agency: Real Estate Administration of Montenegro
Links:
-https://213.149.105.122/geoportal/catalog/search/resource/details.page?uuid=%7B776FD76F-5282-4844-8F13-EE3AB239C04C%7D - Geoportal - Real Estate Administration of Montenegro
Search steps: Queried an online search engine for ""Geoportal Montenegro"". Once on the Geoportal website, i looked on the catalog of data for administrative borders.
Rejected the original submission as there is no Boundary Level 2.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Rejected the original submission as there is no Boundary Level 2.","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","0","0"
"2b87cf15-8eec-4ae3-bc76-e0cd0c774f82","global","2016-12-31T09:18:32","2016","mm","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""There is no information nor evidence shown that the Myanmar President's Office is collecting the data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The official website to the Myanmar President's Officer https://www.president-office.gov.mm/en/""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","There are no evidence to confirm that the data exist.","Yes","No","anonymous","Anton Shaffer","0","0"
"750fbf05-419e-401f-8445-d7ec0e430ac0","global","2016-12-31T09:24:41","2016","mm","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""There is no information nor evidence shown that the Myanmar President's Office is collecting the data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The official website to the Myanmar President's Officer https://www.president-office.gov.mm/en/""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","There are no evidence to confirm that the data exist.","Yes","No","anonymous","Anton Shaffer","0","0"
"24b7937a-6b32-4e46-99a3-6a055b36475c","global","2017-03-03T14:07:23","2016","sk","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Geodetický a kartografický ústav Bratislava"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original Submission:
Agency: Geodetický a kartografický ústav Bratislava
Link:
- https://www.geoportal.sk/files/sluzby/wms_ah_nahlad.html- WMS service with the boundaries, not downloadable
Search Steps: Looked for the term ""administratívne hranice"" (administrative boundaries) and got results for the government WMS servie
Open License:
Rejected the original submission as there is no Boundary Level 2.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Rejected the original submission as there is no Boundary Level 2.","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","0","0"
"79e8e140-76ab-405c-9df6-bcebd970465e","global","2016-12-12T22:12:16","2016","mk","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Content of the bills is in PDF/Word. Other data in PDF.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Reviewer: Data could not be found to be downloadable at once.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""As a non-Macedonian speaker, I had to ask for help from a native speaker on this. ""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Consulted a friend."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.sobranie.mk/home-en.nspx"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Article 16 of Copyright law states that \""Official texts of a political, legislative, administrative and judicial nature and\ntheir official translations;\"" shall not be considered protected works.\"" \nhttps://www.wipo.int/wipolex/en/text.jsp?file_id=263877\n\nFooter states Footer states \""Copyright 2014 Assembly of the Republic of Macedonia | All rights reserved.\""\n""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Assembly of Republic of Macedonia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.sobranie.mk/materijali.nspx"",""descValue"":""Assembly of Republic of Macedonia""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. -------
• Modified B5 to No as data is not available for bulk download.
• After reviewing a dozen random examples of legislation, could not locate any related transcripts of draft legislation. Unchecked selection D for B3.
• Note:** page could not be translated via the internet into English. The reviewer used their capacity to read and understand Russian (on a moderate level) in order to successfully review this submission and related site.",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Anton Shaffer","65","65"
"72a61c32-54ce-4bc4-be00-665de4868890","global","2017-03-03T13:56:27","2016","si","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Surveying Authority of Republic of Slovenia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original Submission:
Agency: Surveying Authority of Republic of Slovenia
Link:
https://www.gu.gov.si/en/services/free_access_database/administrative_units/ - Surveying and Mapping Authority of the Republic of Slovenia
Search Steps: Queried a web search engine for e-cadaster of Slovenia
Open License: https://www.e-prostor.gov.si/si/dostop_do_podatkov/dostop_do_podatkov/
Rejected the original submission as there is no Boundary Level 1.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Rejected the original submission as there is no Boundary Level 1.","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","0","0"
"2c4042b4-39b7-439a-a2eb-0fa78d612961","global","2016-11-29T20:06:46","2016","mk","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF download per issue.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Earliest available issue is December 2015.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Only those available online, up to end of 2015.""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched for the Official Journal of Macedonia in a search engine"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.wipo.int/wipolex/en/text.jsp?file_id=263877"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Official texts of a political, legislative, administrative and judicial nature and their official translations are note considered copyright works (Art 16, Law on Copyright and Related Rights, 2010))""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Laws presented in PDF.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Official Journal of the Republic of Macedonia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Laws are presented in PDF as published in the printed journal. No other relevant information is published with the text.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.slvesnik.com.mk"",""descValue"":""Official Journal of Republic of Macedonia""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Anton Shaffer","50","50"
"766c7dd6-5a5b-4a5e-9491-e1b9b22bfb69","global","2017-03-03T13:32:31","2016","th","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of interior Department of Local Administration Electronic Government Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original Submission:
Agency: Ministry of interior Department of Local Administration Electronic Government Agency
Link:
- https://data.go.th/DatasetDetail.aspx?id=c6d42e1b-3219-47e1-b6b7-dfe914f27910 - Data set of Geo-Informatics and Space Technology Development Agency (Public Organization) Delivering Values From Space
Search Steps: I went through the https:www.data.go.th website and I found the ข้อมูลพิกัด (coordinates) on the site. And I went through the www.dla.go.th or https://www.moi.go.th website
Open License: https://data.go.th/LicenceDetails.aspx
Rejected the original submission as there is no Boundary Level 1+ 2.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Rejected the original submission as there is no Boundary Level 1+ 2.","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","0","0"
"4e42939f-2272-4f91-a0d8-f8737c0b85ad","global","2017-03-03T13:26:31","2016","ve","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio del Poder Popular para Ciencia, Tecnología e Innovación"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The GeoPortal found at https://geo.gobiernoenlinea.gob.ve/ does not fulfil all the characteristics; namely does not have Boundary Level 2.
Rejected as original submission does not have Boundary Level 2.
Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Rejected as original submission does not have Boundary Level 2","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","0","0"
"cf8fcb37-2861-4539-b0f2-652312c528b7","global","2017-03-03T13:16:51","2016","tn","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""mtimet - Ministry of interior"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original Submission:
Agency: mtimet - Ministry of interior
Links:
- https://github.com/mtimet/tnelec/tree/gh-pages/data/geojson
- https://opendata.interieur.gov.tn/fr/catalog/delegations-par-gouvernorats-de-la-republique
- https://github.com/mtimet/tnmaps/tree/master/data
Search Steps: from Google
Reject original submission as it does not have Boundary Level 2
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Reject original submission as it does not have Boundary Level 2","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","0","0"
"61463ca9-00a5-42af-ab83-90b5567149fd","global","2017-03-03T12:00:37","2016","ar","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Correo Argentino"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"I have rejected the initial submission because it is not fully compliant with the requirements of the locations themes, as coordinates are missing from the dataset. The Correo Argentino offers a search service on the dataset at https://www.correoargentino.com.ar/formularios/cpa. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"c2cab74b-33b9-447a-841f-3279431de63b","global","2016-11-18T01:10:31","2016","ar","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""City of Buenos Aires government and Real Property Registry (Registro de la propiedad inmueble de la Capital Federal)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","ok","I have identified a World Bank study that shows that cadastral data is recorded. [https://www.doingbusiness.org/data/exploreeconomies/argentina/registering-property]","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"e1a8a510-fe63-4add-bee7-fd493f9066fc","global","2016-12-08T20:06:39","2016","ar","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""GML"",""KML"",""SHP"",""SHX"",""WFS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search google maps of Argentina and when you enter into the site of the national geographic institute, you have to look for the geodates."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"" "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Geográfico Nacional"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ign.gob.ar/sig"",""descValue"":""Download geodata at the end of the website""},{""urlValue"":""https://wms.ign.gob.ar/geoserver/web/"",""descValue"":""Geoserver access""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","ok",,"Yes","No","Guido López Avakian","Codrina Maria Ilie","80","80"
"4e41d8ea-8004-432c-9a3d-bb079a543fe3","global","2017-01-26T02:50:36","2016","ag","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""General Post Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","ok","Unfortunately I was unable to identify a government portal or website to properly investigate the postal system n Antigua and Barbuda","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"686b156c-9d64-4b36-8897-c27a8e321fac","global","2017-01-26T03:07:13","2016","ag","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Land Registry - "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","ok","The Antigua & Barbuda landfolio® Public Access Website has been provided by the Government of Antigua and Barbuda to allow general public users, and other to search the government’s land records and retrieve information. Searches may be performed by parcel number, by instrument number, by party or owner name, by address, or by an interactive map. The information available includes physical parcel characteristics, ownership information, parcel transaction history, document images, aerial photographs, and comprehensive parcel reports.
However at the current time, public access has been limited to performing simple searches by parcel number and/or by instrument number. To access the map sign in is required
https://www.lands.gov.ag/landfolio.publicaccess.web/Contents/Search.aspx","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"72fc84a2-cefc-4719-b8a8-1cdd4cfc01af","global","2017-03-03T10:42:09","2016","al","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Albanian Post, under the Albanian Ministry of Economy, Trade and Energy"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submitted dataset was not what the survey looked for. The initial submitter was anonymous. ","The available dataset represents a list in .docx format with address and code, available per region [https://www.en.postashqiptare.al/Services/PostalServices/PostalCode.aspx]. The ASIG geoportal (official geoportal of Albania) has a dataset with street names and building numbers but no postal code info. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"e08843d4-dedd-497d-93e3-923161c24ee0","global","2017-03-03T10:17:23","2016","al","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Autoriteti Shteteror per Informacionin Gjeohapsinor"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The initial submitter was anonymous. ","I have rejected the initial submission because the data was not fully compliant with the requirements (property value missing). ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"78a79344-0016-434a-afb0-b1d55603a967","global","2016-12-15T11:25:13","2016","af","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No agency responsible for it."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","ok",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"d7bc1f05-c25a-424f-b746-1eafe65b990e","global","2017-01-24T22:54:05","2016","us","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Appears the The State and National Parcel Data Working Group of the Federal Geographic Data Committee (FGDC), which is maintained by the Bureau of Land Management (BLM), Department of the Interior, is responsible for collecting land ownership data. Upon reviewing the site, however, I could not find the data.\n\nhttps://www.fgdc.gov/standards/projects/cadastral/index_html\n\nThe NAP site (https://www.nap.edu/read/11978/chapter/6#58) provides an excellent description of the FGDC and may also point to other potential data sources to be searched by the expert reviewer:\n\n\""As part of the FGDC, this subcommittee is charged with coordinating the interest in cadastral information of stakeholders at all levels of government. To support the coordination activities the subcommittee established an eastern and a western coordinator and steering committees. The committees focus on activities of regional concern as well as items of national interest. As discussed in Chapter 2, this subcommittee was instrumental in creating the content data standard for a modern land parcel data model. This standard is part of the Framework Content Data Standard, which is now going through its final approval at the American National Standards Institute level. Once approved, it will become an American National Standard applicable for adoption and use at all levels of government and industry.\""\n\nAdditional information: https://nationalcad.org/StateProgs/StateProgs.html\n\n\n\nOne final data source could be found under the \""Statewide Land Ownership\"" listing here (https://navigator.blm.gov/data?keyword=fl_navMetric_ViewCount:*&sort=fl_navMetric_ViewCount%20desc). However, it appears the link is broken.""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" FGDC Cadastral Subcommittee "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.fgdc.gov/standards/projects/cadastral/index_html"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","According to the Federal Geographic Data Committee, the Cadastral Subcommittee is coordinating national cadastral and land records information [https://nationalcad.org]. ",,"Yes","No","Katherine Wikrent","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"bf54237f-2e98-42f4-b951-5c801c0fba31","global","2016-12-05T20:40:26","2016","gb","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Dates, addresses and prices paid for estate property transactions in England and Wales are available as open data, but without details of ownership.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Known formats are CSV for tabular data and Esri Shapefile for polygons. Data may be available in other formats but I am unable to establish this from open sources i.e. without paying for data.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The body of data is updated incrementally during the process of conveyancing and registration of property and land.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Other than some generalised polygons for England and Wales, the relevant data is not directly accessible on the public web.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I was previously aware of the relevant data holders, so navigated from their homepages to the relevant sections of their sites."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This response refers to information about the data rather than the data itself as most is only available on commercial terms.""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is only available on commercial terms but by reputation it is as easily usable as I would normally expect for data of this type.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Land Registry and Registers of Scotland"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This response is in respect of Great Britain. Land Registry (LR) maintains data for England and Wales and Registers of Scotland (RoS) maintains data for Scotland.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Parcel boundaries (inc. latitude and longitude)"",""Parcel ID"",""Property value (i.e. Price Paid, Property Tax Value)"",""Tenure Type (ie. leasehold, freehold, protected lands, public lands, customary lands)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.uk/topic/land-registration/data"",""descValue"":""Land registration data (Land Registry)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ros.gov.uk/property-data/data-services"",""descValue"":""Property data services (Registers of Scotland)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","ok",,"Yes","No","Owen Boswarva","Codrina Maria Ilie","35","35"
"07453f4a-b0d5-49bd-b9cf-fbc65d1190a3","global","2016-12-05T20:03:57","2016","gb","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""GML"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Also GeoTIFF, TIFF-LZW ASCII Grid, MapInfo TAB, DBX and NTF for some parts or versions of this data.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The user may need to download more than one data product to cover all of the criteria, but they are available from a single source and can be selected for download in a single operation.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""This is debatable and not easy to answer as Yes/No. Users do not need to register or give their name but must provide an email address. Ordnance Survey then provides a download link by email (usually immediately). So technically users have to request the data but the process is automated and reasonably frictionless.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""No steps as I am a user of the data and have been aware of the location since the data products were launched in 2010. However the data is discoverable via Google using search terms such as: national map open data "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.ordnancesurvey.co.uk/opendata/licensing.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is re-usable under the Open Government Licence, which is compliant with the Open Definition.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""OS is the authoritative source for this type of data in Britain, so the data is high quality and as usable as I would reasonably expect. This is GIS data so there there are some intrinsic knowledge requirements, of course.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ordnance Survey"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This submission applies only to Great Britain i.e. excluding Northern Ireland.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ordnancesurvey.co.uk/opendatadownload/products.html"",""descValue"":""OS OpenData""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is available as a suite of produces that collectively meet the criteria.""}]","Yes","Yes","ok!",,"Yes","Yes","Owen Boswarva","Codrina Maria Ilie","100","100"
"17977c3f-3530-49fd-8a91-4d809adcd8c1","global","2016-12-06T17:42:06","2016","tr","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""JSON"",""KML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""It took 15 minutes to figure out where the data was. I get it in three stages."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""General Directorate of Land Registry and Cadastre"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Parcel boundaries (inc. latitude and longitude)"",""Parcel ID"",""Property value (i.e. Price Paid, Property Tax Value)"",""Tenure Type (ie. leasehold, freehold, protected lands, public lands, customary lands)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://parselsorgu.tkgm.gov.tr/"",""descValue"":""geoportal for parcel querry""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","https://parselsorgu.tkgm.gov.tr/ is a geoportal offering the possibility to search and download info on land information per parcel. I have not identified a bulk download anywhere. ",,"Yes","No","Dağ Medya","Codrina Maria Ilie","65","65"
"ed446c07-4f30-46c4-bc06-195f73ad7c28","global","2017-03-03T00:12:03","2016","tr","postcodes","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Postal and Telegraph Corporation (PTT) "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","ok","The data available at https://postakodu.ptt.gov.tr/ does not comply with the requirements of the data location theme. The zipcodes are not geo-referenced. ","Yes","No","Codrina Maria Ilie","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"d220d008-e01d-4977-98cd-42d4ae4baf5a","global","2016-12-05T22:31:29","2016","py","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""searching on web"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.contrataciones.gov.py/datos/legal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Dirección Nacional de Contrataciones Públicas"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.contrataciones.gov.py/datos/data"",""descValue"":""La siguiente tabla presenta la lista de servicios disponibles correspondientes a la Dirección Nacional de Contrataciones Públicas. Para cada conjunto de servicios se presenta un enlace para ver los datos en formato tabular, un enlace para ver la documentación del servicio, un enlace para ver el diccionario de datos, un enlace para descargar los datos, un enlace con un ejemplo de respuesta a la API y una breve descripción del servicio. ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes in submission. ",,"Yes","Yes","Lupinupa L","Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"3206fc64-caa9-455b-b9bc-f6045da4eee0","global","2017-03-02T23:50:54","2016","tr","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""General Command of Mapping (GCM)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","OK","The website provides a geoportal but it does not comply with the requirements of this theme. However, they provide samples of the geodata available [https://www.hgk.msb.gov.tr/english/u-20-sample-digital-geospatial-data.html] with a specific request of not using the data for anything other than personal use, academic studies and educational researches and testing/evaluating GCM data prior to purchasing.","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"b3afd60a-4990-4097-bc48-1c6cc75d15e9","global","2016-12-16T01:22:20","2016","pa","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF, HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1. Research on the web for Procurements in Panamá 2. Informatión is there but is complicated to navigate trough the interface."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.panamacompra.gob.pa/Portal/files/AcuerdoUsoSistema.pdf"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Not sure if this license is open""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Panadata (no government) extracted the data in https://www.panadata.net/licitaciones, You need to regiter.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Dirección General de Contrataciónes Públicas (DGCP) "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""National Procurement Authorithy""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.panamacompra.gob.pa/Portal/OportunidadesDeNegocio.aspx"",""descValue"":""DGCP procurement web interface.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The license is not available. The Terms of Use don't mention anything about use and reuse of data, it only states that any data should not be used for illicit ends. ",,"Yes","No","Victor Díaz Navarro","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"63b9935d-5f66-418d-ab54-3ecf5be750a4","global","2017-01-15T18:08:15","2016","zm","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No copyright information provided.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""PDF, PPTX, PNG, XLSX, Atomsvc""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled national statistics Zambia and went through a few websites (about 5 mins) before I found the datasets."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Zambia Data Portal Central Statistics Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://zambia.opendataforafrica.org/"",""descValue"":""Zambia Data Portal Central Statistics Office""},{""urlValue"":""https://zambia.opendataforafrica.org/ZMLBST2016/labour-statistics-of-zambia-2013"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://zambia.opendataforafrica.org/data#topic=GDP"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://zambia.opendataforafrica.org/data#topic=Population"",""descValue"":""Population data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: National Statistical System link (https://www.zamstats.gov.zm/) doesn't work - datasets on Zambia Data Portal are from Central Statistics Office, added links for unemployment, GDP, and population""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Tricia Govindasamy for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. ",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Sophie Lafayette","65","65"
"86760bca-f4dd-422d-8465-7b0b2e58d5d1","global","2017-01-19T08:40:24","2016","pk","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML, PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched on Google"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Public Procurement Regulatory Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ppra.org.pk/"",""descValue"":""PPRA""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data is up to date but only PDF versions of the entire tender are available. HTML views of basic information can be found in the site. ",,"Yes","No","Nouman Nazim","Oscar Montiel","60","60"
"dd243691-8133-4505-ad24-242b65b69fc8","global","2016-12-11T13:30:53","2016","om","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Tender Board"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","There are pdf versions of circulars with notices. No way to access archive or data with more details. ","The Tender Board used to publish tender details on its website ( https://www.tenderboard.gov.om ), but the relevant section on the newly redesigned website does not appear to be working. It is not possible to verify if this is a temporary problem or an issue that has been happening for a while.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"d7ec3f89-88fc-4f4a-b96e-b61304a1e396","global","2017-01-21T18:52:01","2016","no","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Know the address from before"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Agency for Public Management and eGovernment (Difi)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.doffin.no/"",""descValue"":""www.doffin.no — national notification database for public procurement""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No award information available. ",,"Yes","No","Bergheimivar L","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"d3e54100-7eda-47e7-8da7-fdd61750d7f2","global","2016-12-15T17:09:10","2016","nir","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Lengthy user agreement based around use of portal for tendering purposes rather than as a method of obtaining data. No licensing information https://e-sourcingni.bravosolution.co.uk/esop/toolkit/initRegistration.do?_ncp=1481821568392.110-2""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Only the first/most recent 2000 rows of opportunities/tenders can be exported""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""To be granted full access to the System, the Supplier must register each person which the Supplier wishes to be a Supplier User by providing the required registration data and specifying a user ID and password.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google procurement northern ireland. Found eSourcing tendering site. Find Past Opportunites list and export."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Unknown"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""For each past tender data is available about the tender. No data appears to be available about the contract.\n\nAggregated data is not produced.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://e-sourcingni.bravosolution.co.uk/web/login.shtml"",""descValue"":""eSourcingNI""},{""urlValue"":""https://crowncommercialservice.bravosolution.co.uk/esop/toolkit/opportunity/opportunityList.do?reset=true&resetstored=true&oppList=GLOBAL&_ncp=1481820564514.347-1"",""descValue"":""Crown Commercial Services""},{""urlValue"":""https://e-sourcingni.bravosolution.co.uk/esop/toolkit/opportunity/opportunityList.do?reset=true&resetstored=true&oppList=PAST&_ncp=1481820595622.331-1"",""descValue"":""Past Opportunities""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Tendering to Northern Ireland public agencies is carried out via the eSourcing portal which lists opportunities. NI companies can also avail of UK government opportunities via the Crown Commercial Service, however, NI public sector does not use this resource""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes to the submission",,"Yes","No","Bob Harper","Oscar Montiel","50","50"
"76977f6e-5241-4896-9afc-19e44c29b193","global","2017-01-25T05:10:25","2016","nz","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The summary tender dataset is downloadable. A further search is required to locate the name of the supplier""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There is open access for all to the website, but tenders submitters have to register in order to list the tender, and submitters have to register in order to submit.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I searched on Google for New Zealand government tenders. The sites were the top results"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.gets.govt.nz/GetsCopyright.htm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Business Innovation and Employment"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Provides a central government tenders register which also lists tenders awarded.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.gets.govt.nz/ExternalIndex.htm"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.gets.govt.nz/ExternalAwardedTenderList.htm"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.contractmapping.govt.nz/"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes"," Not every contract awarded has contract amounts, except when there is more than one contractor. No changes in the submission. Data is only available in HTML form. ","Contractmapping.govt.nz provides details of social service funding and contracting information from the Ministry of Education, Ministry of Health, Ministry of Justice, Ministry of Social Development and Te Puni Kōkiri (Ministry of Maori Development). This comprises the name of the provider, their address, the area in which they deliver their services, the type of service delivered, the number of clients or services they are contracted to provide, and how much funding they receive for their services. It is openly licensed - see https://www.contractmapping.govt.nz/tools/privacy.html
The Ministry of Culture and Heritage lists all of its awards, including funding - for example, see https://www.mch.govt.nz/westpac-new-zealand-arts-awards-2015-recipients-announced","Yes","No","Keitha Booth","Oscar Montiel","80","80"
"01f12b12-1c4c-45b7-8b6f-624a6072ec97","global","2016-12-04T20:43:12","2016","im","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: to no as GDP yearly (last 2015), although unemployment monthly, population estimates monthly (last census 2011)""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google -- Isle of Man national statistics"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.gov.im/about-this-site/open-government-licence/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Footer notice and link""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Economic Affairs Division, Cabinet Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.im/about-the-government/departments/cabinet-office/economic-affairs-division/"",""descValue"":""National Statistics""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.im/categories/working-in-the-isle-of-man/unemployment/"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.im/media/1355081/2016-q4-economic-report-public.pdf"",""descValue"":""Population data (within economic report)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.im/categories/home-and-neighbourhood/census/"",""descValue"":""Census 2011""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.im/categories/tax-vat-and-your-money/national-income/"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.im/media/1350839/2016-03-02-isle-of-man-in-numbers-2016-website-upload-data-tables.xlsx"",""descValue"":""Isle of Man in numbers (GDP, population, and unemployment)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added links to unemployment, population, and GDP data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Graeme Jones for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. B6 updated to no as GDP outdated and updated yearly (unemployment and population monthly). ",,"Yes","No","Graeme Jones","Sophie Lafayette","85","85"
"cc5c6030-3032-47b0-9306-e734408fe941","global","2016-12-07T16:01:59","2016","np","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF, HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1. Go to the web address- navigating through the options "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Public Procurement Monitoring Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Value of the award""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.bolpatra.gov.np/egp/"",""descValue"":""Newer- The centralized e-Government Procurement (e-GP) System for nation wide public procurement management. A web based one stop procurement portal covering various activities of public procurement life cycle including registration of bidders, procurement planning, e-tendering, on-line evaluation, contract management etc""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bolpatra.gov.np/ppmo/"",""descValue"":""Newer- The centralized e-Government Procurement (e-GP) System for nation wide public procurement management. A web based one stop procurement portal covering various activities of public procurement life cycle including registration of bidders, procurement planning, e-tendering, on-line evaluation, contract management etc""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I couldn't find Supplier's name in B8, changed submission accordingly.
Data is only available in PDF and HTML.
","Efforts are being laid to disclose the procurement data in compliance to Open Contracting Data Standards (OCDS). ","Yes","No","Saroj Bista","Oscar Montiel","30","30"
"3174714b-b99e-4de9-9603-e983472db385","global","2016-12-09T11:05:03","2016","ko","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: website '© Kosovo Agency of Statistics'""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""PX"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: added additional formats PX, CVS, HTM, XML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to yes, each dataset can be required in one file""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: to yes, GDP quarterly (latest Q3 2016), population yearly (latest 2016), unemployment quarterly (latest Q3 2016)""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""From the home page I selected ASK data, a link from the right side of the screen. This displayed a long list of categorized data, I then selected Country and regional data. This is the folder the required information is located in. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to 3 as data can be downloaded in a number of formats and multiple variables selected making it easy to use the data. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Agjencia e Statistikave të Kosovës"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://askdata.rks-gov.net/PXWeb/pxweb/en/askdata/?rxid=0b4e087e-8b00-47ba-b7cf-1ea158040712%2f"",""descValue"":""Agjencia e Statistikave të Kosovës""},{""urlValue"":""https://ask.rks-gov.net/en/kosovo-agency-of-statistics"",""descValue"":""Kosovo Agency of Statistics (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://askdata.rks-gov.net/PXWeb/pxweb/en/askdata/askdata__National%20accounts%20and%20government%20accounts__National%20accounts__Quarterly%20national%20accounts/gdp04.px/?rxid=cd023ca6-7f1c-4a03-922d-e96603d918a7"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://askdata.rks-gov.net/PXWeb/pxweb/en/askdata/?rxid=cd023ca6-7f1c-4a03-922d-e96603d918a7"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://askdata.rks-gov.net/PXWeb/pxweb/en/askdata/askdata__Country%20and%20regional%20data/tgs00027.px/table/tableViewLayout1/?rxid=cd023ca6-7f1c-4a03-922d-e96603d918a7"",""descValue"":""Population data 2005-2016""},{""urlValue"":""https://askdata.rks-gov.net/PXWeb/pxweb/en/askdata/askdata__Population__Population%20Structure/Number%20of%20population%20and%20household%20by%20censuses%201948-2011.px/table/tableViewLayout1/?rxid=1cc613e7-f287-4dde-be45-7d4b75d47fb3"",""descValue"":""Population data to 2011""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added links to GDP, unemployment, and population data. ""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. B5 amended to yes, each dataset can be required in one fileB6 updated to yes, data updated regularly. Added additional formats PX, CVS, HTM, XML. B6 amended to 3 as data can be downloaded in a number of formats and multiple variables selected. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Sophie Lafayette","80","80"
"d10a757c-9f24-4491-8b5b-10e42bbf1054","global","2017-03-02T22:50:23","2016","na","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No data found on policy""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF, DOC and HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Latest update is from 2015 for awarded contracts and 2016 for tender notices""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched for Namibia procurement office and in the first results it lead to their policy and from there to their archive"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.mof.gov.na/tender-awards"",""descValue"":""Tender Awards""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mof.gov.na/tender-advert"",""descValue"":""Tender Notices""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Rejected past submission that mentioned no data found. ","Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","30","30"
"fe1a489a-1c00-4c06-adc5-db85663108b0","global","2017-01-27T16:21:37","2016","ke","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: website '© 2015. Kenya National Bureau of Statistics'""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: removed TXT format, could only find data within PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: changed to no as data on unemployment not found and population outdated (yearly latest found 2013), although GDP quarterly (latest Q3 2016)""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched for Kenya Bureau of Statistics and voila!"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Kenya National Bureau of Statistics"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: remove National unemployment, not able to find any data""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.knbs.or.ke"",""descValue"":""Kenya National Bureau of Statistics website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.knbs.or.ke/index.php?option=com_phocadownload&view=category&id=17&Itemid=597"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.knbs.or.ke/index.php?option=com_phocadownload&view=category&id=20&Itemid=595"",""descValue"":""Facts & figures (including data on population)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added links to GDP, population data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Serah Rono for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Removed TXT format as could only find data with PDF. Removed unemployment data from B3 as not able to find within any documents or on website. Amended B6 to no as population outdated and no unemployment data found (GDP updated quarterly).","Statistics data is hidden in files full of text, graphs and tabular data. Not very easy to quickly find and use.","Yes","No","Serah Rono","Sophie Lafayette","45","45"
"6448cd7a-8cb8-4ab4-81d8-68e34da8c7ce","global","2017-01-16T19:40:08","2016","ls","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: Bureau of Statistics website: 'Copyright © 2004 BoS', open data portal website: no license (sponsored by African Development Bank) ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: unemployment report in DOC, population & GDP can be downloaded in multiple formats (visual: PPTX, XLS, PDF, PNG, data: CVS, XLS, Atomsvc, & JSON, SDMX, OData)""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update to no: GDP yearly (latest 2011), unemployment yearly (latest 2008), population yearly (latest 2013)""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: open data portal requires signup to download data""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I google searched National Statistics Lesotho and found this website on the first page of search results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: Population and GDP data can be downloaded as XLS, unemployment needs to be extracted from table in Word doc""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Lesotho Bureau of Statistics "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.bos.gov.ls/"",""descValue"":""Lesotho Bureau of Statistics ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bos.gov.ls/nada/index.php/catalog/7"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://lesotho.opendataforafrica.org"",""descValue"":""Lesotho Open Data Portal ""},{""urlValue"":""https://lesotho.opendataforafrica.org/LSSED2016/socio-economic-database-lesotho-2015"",""descValue"":""GDP & population data ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: Population & GDP data can be found by selecting options in the 'Socio-Economic Database, Lesotho, 2015' on the Open Data Portal""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Tricia Govindasamy for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. B6 updated to no as data is not recent. Various data sets can be found in multiple formats through the open data portal but requires signin to download.",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Sophie Lafayette","65","65"
"c5e70a70-7936-4de1-aad7-a6bdb78addcc","global","2016-12-14T09:14:43","2016","me","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: website 'Copyright © MONSTAT, 2010'""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: removed HTML format as all data in XLS or PDF format. Unemployment data XLS, population projections XLS, GDP quarterly XLS/PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: unemployment quarterly (last update Q2 2016), population yearly (projections 2000-2016), GDP quarterly (last update G3 2016)""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I searched on google for the national statistics of the given country. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended to 2 as data can be found in XLS format""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Statistical Office of Montenegro (MONSTAT)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added MONSTAT""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.monstat.org/eng/"",""descValue"":""Statistical Office of Montenegro ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.monstat.org/eng/page.php?id=22&pageid=22"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.monstat.org/eng/page.php?id=18&pageid=18"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.monstat.org/eng/page.php?id=47&pageid=47"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.monstat.org/eng/page.php?id=393&pageid=57"",""descValue"":""Census 2011 data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added links to unemployment, GDP, and population/census data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Drenusha Myha for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Added links to data sets & frequency of publication. Removed HTML as format as all data in XLS or PDF format. Amended B9 to 2 as data can be found in XLS format.
",,"Yes","No","Drenusha Myha","Sophie Lafayette","80","80"
"cd7b88ac-154f-49a0-9d68-7ecbe191a42a","global","2016-12-31T09:12:37","2016","mm","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""There is no information nor evidence shown that the Myanmar President's Office is collecting the data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The official website to the Myanmar President's Officer https://www.president-office.gov.mm/en/""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes in submission. Couldn't find the e-procurement site even though there are many notes about its existence","There are no evidence to confirm that the data exist.","Yes","No","anonymous","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"8c67dc81-0d67-432a-8bf4-2d7baaa758a0","global","2017-01-19T16:06:42","2016","mz","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: no license found""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Not sure.\n\nUpdate: GDP quarterly, population yearly (most recent 2007, then projections), last unemployment 2004/5""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""All Mozambique websites are in Portuguese and I am English speaking. I used google translator."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: able to find GDP & population data, unemployment data found within PDF report ""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Mozambique National Institute of Statistics (INE Destaques — Instituto Nacional de Estatistica)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added Portuguese title""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.gov.mz/"",""descValue"":""Mozambique National Institute of Statistics""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.gov.mz/estatisticas/estatisticas-economicas/contas-nacionais"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.gov.mz/operacoes-estatisticas/inqueritos/inquerito-integrado-a-forca-de-trabalho/inquerito-integrado-a-forca-de-trabalho-iftrab-2004-05.pdf/view"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data (within labour report)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.gov.mz/estatisticas/estatisticas-demograficas-e-indicadores-sociais/populacao"",""descValue"":""Population data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Updated: added link to GDP, unemployment, and population data data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Tricia Govindasamy for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Added additional links. Unemployment data difficult to find and out of data. ",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Sophie Lafayette","65","65"
"7a0ad8d0-4e0d-4f02-9a68-1e278135a89d","global","2017-01-19T16:41:09","2016","mz","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I had to change between google translators because most of Mozambique's content is in Portuguese."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Powermedia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No information from the government about procurement in any of their websites. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender description""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.concursos.co.mz/"",""descValue"":""Concursos""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Oscar Montiel","60","60"
"8ce4fe5c-08ed-467f-96b1-d7954cc76282","global","2017-03-02T19:41:27","2016","mm","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Central Statistical Organization"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.csostat.gov.mm""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Initial submission put link to President's office, stating no evidence of data collection can be found. This is incorrect location of data as 'Central Statistical Organization' (part of Ministry of Planning and Finance) would be correct location for national statistics. Submission resubmitted with correct link. Very limited data online but suggests population, employment, and economic indicators published in reports (which are for sale), most recently published in 2016. ",,"Yes","No","Sophie Lafayette","Sophie Lafayette","0","0"
"d135df04-9cba-4c1e-80a3-4b6157c9b626","global","2016-12-14T09:37:33","2016","me","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""In the portal it says that these two are options for the export of the data. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google searched the procurement of the given country. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Public Procurement of Administration of Montenegro "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ujn.gov.me/en/"",""descValue"":""Public Procurement of Administration of Montenegro ""},{""urlValue"":""https://portal.ujn.gov.me/delta2015/search/noticeSearch.html?locale=en&"",""descValue"":""Portal ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Basic information of notices can be exported to CSV, XLS, XML and PDF after you make a query in the search. Details are consulted individually and only visible in HTML. ",,"Yes","No","Drenusha Myha","Oscar Montiel","80","80"
"13ac223f-0b86-465e-8524-c9528e718747","global","2016-12-23T16:13:24","2016","ch","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""See https://www.admin.ch/gov/en/start/terms-and-conditions.html""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search engines"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal Chancellery"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.admin.ch/gov/en/start/federal-law/classified-compilation.html"",""descValue"":""Federal law""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission should be accepted because all the required characteristics are available on the data set. ","No changes were made to the original submission. By going to the indicated URL I was easily able to verify the accuracy of all answers. ","Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","Juela Xhaferraj","45","45"
"eefe7f4d-14cd-436c-a970-56084f7877bb","global","2017-01-18T17:54:53","2016","na","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: National Statistics 'NSA © 2017' & Open data portal: '© 2015 African Development Bank Group'""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""PDF, PNG, PPTX""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Last update was 2015. \n\nUpdate: unemployment data updated yearly but previous update 2014, GDP states updated quarterly but data only per year, last update 2015. Population last update 2011 (census) with predictions to 2031 ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: additional microdata available with a login (unable to access) ""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I took me about 15 minutes to be directed to this website. I google searched National Statistics Namibia and went to the NSA portal and looked through till I found this data portal."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Namibia Statistics Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://nsa.org.na/"",""descValue"":""Namibia Statistics Agency""},{""urlValue"":""https://namibia.opendataforafrica.org/"",""descValue"":""Namibia Data Portal""},{""urlValue"":""https://nsa.org.na/microdata1/index.php/ddibrowser/22/export/?format=pdf&generate=yes"",""descValue"":""Namibia Labour Force Survey 2014 (unemployment data)""},{""urlValue"":""https://namibia.opendataforafrica.org/NANAR2017/namibia-national-accounts"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://namibia.opendataforafrica.org/NPHCD2015/namibia-population-and-housing-census-data-2011"",""descValue"":""Population data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Portal created by African Development Bank. \n\nUpdate: added link to Statistics Agency, GDP, unemployment, and population ""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Tricia Govindasamy for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Websites not easy to navigate & some sections 'coming soon'. Added links to datasets. Data primarily in PDF reports. ",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Sophie Lafayette","65","65"
"65e18b98-775d-448b-b4b4-124b3f94889a","global","2017-01-17T12:09:27","2016","zw","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF\n[Reviewer comment]The text of bills, Hansard and status chart are also available in HTML ( so I changed B8 accordingly).""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I changed B5 to NO because there is not option to download data in bulk. Each bill has to be downloaded separately. Also, status of bills and Hansard record are on different pages altogether.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""[Original submitter comment]Last update 21 December 2016. Could be delayed in updating due to December vacation.\n[Reviewer comment] I changed this to a NO. I mainly made the decision based on the fact that Status of Bills was last updated on Jan.30, 2017 (today is Mar. 2), so a month ago. Moreover, the last bill uploaded was introduced on Feb. 13- so more than two weeks ago- which is still a bit delayed. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I found this data when I was searching for National Laws in Zimbabwe."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Parliament of Zimbabwe "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I changed the submission to indicate that votes are not present. Although on the website there is a document called \""National Assembly/Senate Votes\"" for each day the legislature was in session, I was actually not able to find a record of votes on these documents (just a summary of questions asked and Orders of the Day). Transcripts are available because the Hansard transcript for each day is provided (so by finding the day a bill was introduced, one can locate its debate on the Hansard of the day). Status of Bill is available on a separate page from the texts of bills. The page is called \""Definition of Bills and Bill Status\"" and it contains a chart of all the bills that are currently under the legislature and their status. Author of bill is the respecting ministry that proposed the bill (in the case of government bills). ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.parlzim.gov.zw/"",""descValue"":""Parliament of Zimbabwe ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission should be accepted because all required characteristics are available in the data set. ","I made a few changes to the original submission.
1) Changed B3 to indicate votes were not available.
2) Changed B5 to indicate data is not available in bulk
3) Changed B6 to claim that data is not up do date. This decision was made mainly on the fact that the last status update on bills was made a month ago. The original submitter also seemed to have noticed about a month delay in updates. This is more than the three weeks threshold of this survey.
4)Changed B8 to indicate that data is available in HTML.
See comments throughout. Despite the changes, I am accepting the submission because the required characteristics are available (even though status is found on a different page and it was a bit more difficult to locate).","Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Juela Xhaferraj","30","30"
"34d21ccb-fdaa-4134-97ae-6b440dcb902a","global","2016-12-15T15:02:16","2016","my","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There were no clear statement/message stated in the dataset nor in the webpage whether the data is openly licensed. It is assumed by the public that the data is owned by the author and the publisher.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is not downloadable at all. Users have to scrape or extract the data manually via data entry.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is not downloadable at all. Users have to scrape or extract the data manually via data entry.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled for the data and when I found the website, I did in-depth search."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender status"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://myprocurement.treasury.gov.my/?page_id=220"",""descValue"":""Website of Ministry of Finance""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes in submission",,"Yes","No","Hazwany Jamaluddin","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"76c1e4c9-2422-4916-bec4-7f2b80419117","global","2017-01-22T16:44:56","2016","gy","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Website: 2017 © Bureau of Statistics 'Information presented on this website is the property of the Bureau of Statisticsl (BoS) and thus BoS reserves the right to update or withdraw information at any time.'""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF download""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: GDP, unemployment last updated 2006 (both yearly), population 2012""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I was easily connected to the Bureau of Statistics page by doing a quick google search for \""Guyana statistics\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data appears to be very out of date, having quoted statistics from 2012, however they do have other more recent datasets available but given the criteria of this survey was out of date\n\nUpdate: all data within PDF reports, requires extraction before use""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" Bureau of Statistics"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Bureau was established as a department in 1957, but prior to this, the collection and publication of statistics was decentralised and assigned to a few key government departments.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.statisticsguyana.gov.gy/nataccts.html#natdiv"",""descValue"":"" National Accounts""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statisticsguyana.gov.gy/pubs.html#mics5"",""descValue"":""2012 Census ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statisticsguyana.gov.gy/"",""descValue"":""Bureau of Statistics""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statisticsguyana.gov.gy/download.php?file=70"",""descValue"":""Labour Force Indicators (including unemployment)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added link to main site, unemployment""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Alesha Aris for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Website not very easy to navigate. All data within PDF reports, requires extraction before use. Data not recent or updated regularly. ",,"Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Sophie Lafayette","45","45"
"bee043b9-4000-431a-8fae-a2b8b5038a26","global","2017-03-02T19:09:33","2016","mw","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Office of Director of Public Procurement in Malawi"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"There is no central site for the Procurement office. Notices for the Millenium Challenge Account can be found in PDF form. https://www.mca-m.gov.mw/index.php/procurement/2014-02-06-13-35-10/goods?start=20","Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"e630ddb1-18df-4591-871e-14e4b073dd76","global","2017-01-27T17:00:33","2016","ke","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Environment and Natural Resources"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections.","There is no official record of pollutant emissions, not from Ministry of Environment and Natural Resources or from National Environment Management Authority","Yes","No","Serah Rono","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"03302525-67f5-43fc-b68a-7d87aa0d16a6","global","2017-01-16T22:10:20","2016","jm","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Environment and Planning Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewer: Accepted and confirmed.","I was unable to find data on pollutant emissions for Jamaica. NEPA is the responsible agent for the collection and measurement of this data however there are no online data sets","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"4f8d4a4f-3882-4024-9ec0-0a138e47291a","global","2016-12-08T18:05:59","2016","sv","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Updated link to 'rights of citizen' which suggests data should be in public domain. ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Population data from last census in XLS""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: census data split into separate files, post census population data in pdf report. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: Last population data from 2007 census, from 2005 - 2025 population projections exist. Amended to no as data not found on GDP or unemployment.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google Advanced Search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.digestyc.gob.sv/index.php/contactenos/cartas-de-derechos.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: moved link initially provided to above as population data not open license. Amended to link 'Cartas de Derecho'""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Dirección General de Estadísticas y Censos"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.digestyc.gob.sv"",""descValue"":""Dirección General de Estadísticas y Censos""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.digestyc.gob.sv/index.php/novedades/avisos/590-el-salvador-estimaciones-y-proyecciones-de-poblacion-municipal-2005-2025.html"",""descValue"":""Population data (predictions)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.digestyc.gob.sv/index.php/temas/des/poblacion-y-estadisticas-demograficas/censo-de-poblacion-y-vivienda/poblacion-censos.html"",""descValue"":""Population data (2007 census)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: Added links to population data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Omar Luna for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Added XLS format for population data (from census). Not able to find data on unemployment of GDP. Clear open license doesn't exist but the 'Cartas de Derecho' suggest data should be in public domain & free of charge. ","The file is in PDF format. You need to use conversion tools to split pages and to scrape the data.","Yes","No","Omar Luna","Sophie Lafayette","70","70"
"393e6508-624c-4bd4-8c0f-911a682c01d3","global","2017-01-17T12:03:33","2016","zw","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF\n[Reviewer comment] I have added HTML as one of the available formats. As original submitter commented, it is also available in PDF.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There is no option to download several laws at once. However, as a reviewer I am not making any changes to B5 because each individual law and all the amendments can be downloaded at once. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I google searched national laws Zimbabwe and found this source on the second page of search results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Parliament of Zimbabwe"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""All amendments to the law are clearly listed near the title of the law in chronological order. The body of the law clearly identifies the amendments. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.parlzim.gov.zw/"",""descValue"":""Parliament of Zimbabwe""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission should be accepted because I could easily verify that the dataset contains all required characteristics. ","Very easy to identify all the required characteristics in the data set. As a reviewer, the only change I made was to indicate that each law is also available in HTML format, not just PDF. ","Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Juela Xhaferraj","60","60"
"0205c3de-ed44-4aeb-beb3-20836d68343a","global","2016-12-12T12:25:46","2016","im","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""previously department of environment food agriculture but amended url and now states discontinued because air quality readings were continuously good (!):\nhttps://www.gov.im/about-the-government/departments/environment-food-and-agriculture/environment-safety-and-health-directorate/environmental-protection-unit/air-quality/\n""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Airports Division, Department of Infrastructure/Department of Environment, Food and Agriculture"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted and confirmed. No data sources were found on official sites. Added possible source on the Department of Environment, Food and Agriculture","I am unclear on whether or not informal discussions with contacts on air quality readings referenced ad hoc samples or other hardware but I will need to clarify in due course, most likely GODI 2017 timescale though.
","Yes","No","Graeme Jones","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"c74286dd-71e5-4a4e-841d-f4d7b3df612f","global","2016-11-30T19:09:25","2016","mk","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is not clear what terms are used for the data. ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF version also available.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is updated daily.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried an online search engine for e-procurement in Macedonia. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is presented in HTML in response to a query through the forms. Machine readability is not supported.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Public Procurement Bureau of Republic of Macedonia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://e-nabavki.gov.mk/PublicAccess/Home.aspx#/home"",""descValue"":""Public Procurement Bureau""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","PDF of the notices can be found and the data is also viewable in the platform. ",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"44d2cddc-51f7-4a63-adfc-f26b4f41ad53","global","2016-12-14T20:10:47","2016","pr","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Only in Word and PDF (non-machine readable) format.\n[Reviewer comment] I could only find full texts of bills as Doc. files. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I changed the original submission to state that data is not available for bulk download. Each bill must be downloaded separately. There is only an option to print documents in bulk (eg. one can enter date range and print all bills introduced within that period)""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Last update to bill was two calendar days ago. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I used a readily available Internet search engine."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""[Original Submitter comment]The legislative information is available in Word format, but have to own Word in order to read the document.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Oficina de Servicios Legislativos - Office of Legislative Services"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""As a reviewer I changed the original submission to state that \""Transcripts on Bills\"" are not available because I could not find them.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.oslpr.org/buscar/"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission should be accepted because all the required characteristics are present in the data set. ","I changed the original submission to indicate that transcripts were not available. Votes are not available either (but original submitter had already indicated this). Since these are optional characteristics I am accepting the submission. The required characteristics were very easy to locate.
I also changed B5 to NO. Data can only be printed in bulk, not downloaded.","Yes","No","Jacobo Orenstein","Juela Xhaferraj","45","45"
"f63e72b9-2809-47b2-8d6c-d7a331d42ccc","global","2017-01-16T19:55:35","2016","ls","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled procurement lesotho and did not find any accurate matches. I then googled government tenders lesotho and found this source on the first page of search results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Lesotho National Government"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Value of the award""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.ls/gov_webportal/arms%20of%20state/tender%20notices/tender_notices.html"",""descValue"":""Tender Notices in Lesotho portal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The last update of data is from September 2016, you can see the notices in PDF or DOC but not get more information. Changed B5 to No, since download has to be done one by one. ",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Oscar Montiel","30","30"
"1f70374a-f469-4185-9478-e7b505b59244","global","2016-11-22T02:30:36","2016","hk","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Go to Data.Gov.HK."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.hk/en/terms-and-conditions"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Environment Protection Bureau"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.hk/en-data/dataset/hk-epd-airteam-current-aqhi-of-individual-air-quality-monitoring-stations"",""descValue"":""Current Air Quality Health Index (AQHI) at individual general and roadside Air Quality Monitoring stations""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewer: Added CSV as Bulk source.",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","100","100"
"d1a7360e-3e39-48a1-b599-20fd1acbeded","global","2016-12-14T20:48:13","2016","lv","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""According to the Freedom of Information Law the information that is published by institutions providing state functions is interpreted as \""generally accessible information\"" that is compatible with the Public domain approach. The law does not require for the institutions to publish declarations or licenses with the information (they can be provided on voluntary basis).\n\nThe https://open.iub.gov.lv/ also says that this is an open data service and that there are no conditions for the reuse of this information.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The dataset uses a custom and very detailed XML data format that is described at https://open.iub.gov.lv/download/file/XML_strukturu_apraksts_v1.0.pdf\n\n""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Downloads are broken down by date. In order to retrieve data covering more than one day you would need to retrieve multiple files but that can be done automatically.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to the IUB site (the organization in charge of public procurement, I knew its URL) and clicked the menu option \""Atvērtie dati\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The menu item \""Atvērtie dati\"" is clearly noticeable on the IUB site.""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://open.iub.gov.lv/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Freedom of Information Law: \nhttps://www.vvc.gov.lv/export/sites/default/docs/LRTA/Likumi/Freedom_of_Information_Law.doc""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is ready for automatic processing.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Iepirkumu uzraudzības birojs (IUB)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The bureau for public procurement supervision.\nhttps://www.iub.gov.lv/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://open.iub.gov.lv/"",""descValue"":""Iepirkumu uzraudzības biroja atvērto datu (Open IUB) serviss""},{""urlValue"":""ftp://open.iub.gov.lv/"",""descValue"":""FTP server holding the data files""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes to submission. ",,"Yes","No","Uldis Bojars","Oscar Montiel","85","85"
"d88409fe-f95e-422f-98bb-db9e353d4acc","global","2016-12-13T14:43:57","2016","ko","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data can be taken from the website, therefore it has been assumed that the format is HTML.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I searched the data on the 2015 index. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Public Procurement Regulatory Commission "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://krpp.rks-gov.net/Default.aspx?LID=2"",""descValue"":""Public Procurement Regulatory Commission ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Added award title, since you can find the publication if you decide to search for it. Not possible to export or download so it's only available in HTML.",,"Yes","No","Drenusha Myha","Oscar Montiel","60","60"
"95762691-6651-444b-8243-ed7c06046673","global","2017-01-27T17:10:42","2016","ke","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML, PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched for Government tenders, Kenya and opened the first link"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The National Treasury"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://supplier.treasury.go.ke/site/tenders.go/index.php/public/tenders"",""descValue"":""All Government tenders- open, closed and expired""},{""urlValue"":""https://supplier.treasury.go.ke/site/tenders.go/index.php/public/contracts"",""descValue"":""List of tender awardees/suppliers""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes to submission. Tender documents are downloadable in PDF and details can be found in HTML. Data is up to date. ",,"Yes","No","Serah Rono","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"e1093012-f5b0-49be-a24e-cf382bf2ebdc","global","2017-03-02T18:13:31","2016","pr","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The original submission had included the following URL :https://www.oslpr.org/v2/leyespuertorico.aspx\nThis website contains full texts of laws in Doc. and PDF formats. However, texts of laws older than 2005 are not available (i'm not sure if this is only temporarily). The original submission was rejected however because two required characteristics amendment to laws and dates of last amendment are not available. ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Oficina de Servicios Legislativos"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission was rejected because the data set was missing two required characteristics. This updated submission correctly states that the data is not available online. ","The original submission was rejected because two required characteristics were missing from the data set. The original submitter made the following comment:
[original submitter comment]The laws presented at this government web-site are in their original versions, as approved by the Legislature and signed into Law. Amendments to the laws are only available from costly, third party legal services.","Yes","No","anonymous","Juela Xhaferraj","0","0"
"94587b14-fd06-48d5-be4c-cda68de18b9d","global","2016-12-05T13:06:07","2016","jp","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""(Mainly PDF) ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""All tenders and awards of the national/federal government aggregated by office. Monitoring tenders can help new groups to participate in tenders and increase government compliance. Data submitted in this category must be aggregated by office, updated at least monthly & satisfy the following minimum criteria:"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Cabinet Secretariat, JETRO:Government public procurement database"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.kantei.go.jp/jp/kanbou/20tyoutatu/1_buppin/1_buppin_pdf.html"",""descValue"":""Tender for purchase information is aggregated at following page.""},{""urlValue"":"" https://www.jetro.go.jp/gov_procurement.html"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The first resource listed shows the tender data in PDF with minimum information for each of the ministries. The second database has only basic information in HTML.
Going into the resources for each of the ministries the complete info can be found but only seen in HTML form. ","Each Ministry publishes their tender on their own webpage. In those webpages, all the required information are included.
衆議院 /House of Representatives
https://www.shugiin.go.jp/internet/itdb_annai.nsf/html/statics/choutatsu/chotatsujoho.htm
参議院 /House of Councillors
https://www.sangiin.go.jp/japanese/annai/choutatu/21buppin-ekimu/21seifuchoutatu.html
https://www.sangiin.go.jp/japanese/annai/choutatu/index.html
最高裁判所 /Supreme Court
https://www.courts.go.jp/tyotatu/
会計検査院 /Board of Audit of Japan
https://www.jbaudit.go.jp/proc/info/index.html
内閣 /Cabinet
https://www.cao.go.jp/chotatsu/geps_link/geps_link.html#kanbou
人事院 /National Personnel Authority
https://www.jinji.go.jp/tyoutatu/index14.4.1.htm
内閣府 /Cabinet Office
https://www.cao.go.jp/chotatsu/
宮内庁 /Imperial Household Agency
https://www.kunaicho.go.jp/kunaicho/chotatsu/chotatsu.html
国家公安委員会(警察庁) /National Public Safety Commission
https://www.npa.go.jp/chotatu/chotatsu/newmainmenu2.htm
防衛省 /Ministry of Defence
https://www.mod.go.jp/nda/procurement/information.html
総務省 /Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications
https://www.geps.go.jp/
法務省 /Ministry of Justice
https://www.moj.go.jp/chotatsu_index.html
外務省 /Ministry of Foreign Affairs
https://www.mofa.go.jp/mofaj/annai/shocho/chotatsu/
財務省 /Ministry of Finance
https://www.mof.go.jp/procurement/
文部科学省 /Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology
https://www-gpo3.mext.go.jp/kanpo/gpoindex.asp
厚生労働省 /Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare
https://www.mhlw.go.jp/shinsei_boshu/choutatsujouhou/
農林水産省 /Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries
https://www.maff.go.jp/j/supply/
経済産業省 /Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry
https://www.meti.go.jp/information_2/publicoffer/00_bid_news_list.html
国土交通省 /Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism
https://www.i-ppi.jp/Search/Web/Index.htm
国税庁 /National Tax Agency
https://www.data.go.jp/data/dataset/mof_20160325_0048/resource/eaab1567-4c3d-48aa-a5aa-52b8af6eaeae","Yes","No","anonymous","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"c911f605-192c-4fef-b14c-c46f8c8eddcd","global","2017-01-13T20:01:13","2016","jm","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""JSON"",""RDF""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There was a challenge in downloading the data. Excel was unable to open the file""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The JIS website uploads the original tender advertisement for public perusal which was found to be up to date. However the data portal had data inclusive of awardees and value of tender up to 2013""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""On the https://data.gov.jm/ i entered the key word \""National Contract\"" whch lead me to the data set however I was unable to download the data in a csv format "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://opendefinition.org/licenses/odc-by/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Contracts Commission "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.jm/dataset/national-contracts"",""descValue"":""National Contracts""},{""urlValue"":""https://jis.gov.jm/information/procurements/"",""descValue"":""GOJ Procurements Page""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Added CSV as a format for the data available here https://data.gov.jm/dataset/national-contracts. Data is not completely up to date
",,"Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Oscar Montiel","70","70"
"21e66b56-1fb5-4ad2-9ac9-023fc7c32ca3","global","2017-03-02T17:57:34","2016","it","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""ANAC - Autorità Nazionale Anti Corruzione"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Couldn't access the data on the moment of review. The previous submission by Maurizio Napolitano mentioned it was possible to get XML of the data. In these two websites
https://dati.anticorruzione.it/ Catalogo dei dati aperti dell’Autorità Nazionale Anticorruzione
https://portaletrasparenza.anticorruzione.it/microstrategy/html/index.htm Portale dei bandi e dei contratti pubblici
Query wouldn't return any data in any search form. ","Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"e6bedcb0-5e47-40f2-8465-d2ca444e262b","global","2017-01-27T18:15:15","2016","il","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Tenders data is available, award data is not published online ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Data is in several sources, and is not easy to find on Google. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Israel publishing agency "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://jobiz.gov.il/tenders"",""descValue"":""Jobiz ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mr.gov.il/Pages/HomePage.aspx"",""descValue"":""Government Procurement administration ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes in submission. ","Procurements that get an exemption from using a tender (e.g. single supplier contracts etc.machine readable) are published in a dedicated government websmachine-readable form). This kind of procurements make 80% of the total number of procurements.
The are three different websites for tenders, and none for awards. This is very confusing for users:
https://www.mr.gov.il/Pages/HomePage.aspx
https://jobiz.gov.il/tenders
https://michrazim.lapam.gov.il/LAPAM/Tenders/","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"9840da47-1e63-42e5-9eea-0141fa3546af","global","2016-12-13T21:08:54","2016","im","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""link in footer to IM OGL ported from UK OGL""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF only\n""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""google search: isle of man procurement"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.gov.im/about-this-site/open-government-licence/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""easy and free with open data tool such as https://pdftables.com/""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""HM Attorney Generals' Chambers"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.gov.im/about-the-government/offices/attorney-generals-chambers/procurement-division/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""unclear re \""award title\"" and \""award description\""\n\nanonymised scoring percentage range re all tenders without value of the award\n""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.im/media/383300/notification-of-tender-results-nov-2016-cm.pdf"",""descValue"":""Tender Results November 2016""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","There is a section about Expressions of interest https://www.gov.im/categories/business-and-industries/expressions-of-interest/ where you can see last month's Tender Results as a PDF but there is no centralized section where you can see the history or archive. Submission has the results for November and current site has results for February.
",,"Yes","No","Graeme Jones","Oscar Montiel","65","65"
"c2f34e5e-9d27-450a-8fe1-839e7aacbd3c","global","2016-12-15T13:45:29","2016","gr","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Copyright 2009 Hellenic Statistical Society:\nhttps://www.statistics.gr/el/pneumatika-diakaiomata-kai-epanachresimopoiese-stoicheion""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Updated to yes: Labour data updated monthly, GDP updated quarterly, population yearly (latest census 2011, prediction until 2050)""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Direclty from the official site"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Updated to 2 as some data in PDF format only e.g. GDP data""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Hellenic Statistical Authority "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Contact e-mail:email: data.dissem@statistics.gr (updated, moved to comment)""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.statistics.gr/el/home"",""descValue"":""The Hellenic Statistical Authority (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statistics.gr/el/home/"",""descValue"":""Eλληνική Στατιστική Αρχή (Greek)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statistics.gr/en/statistics/-/publication/SEL84/-"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statistics.gr/en/statistics/-/publication/SJO02/-"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statistics.gr/en/statistics/pop"",""descValue"":""Population data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":"" which concern population, The Hellenic Statistical Authority collects data employment and unemployment, tourism and the economy, industry, as well as data concerning health and social insurance, education and others\n\nUpdate: added link to Greek site, GDP, population, and unemployment data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Kleanthis Koupidis for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Updated B6 to yes. Updated to B9 to 2 as some data in PDF format only e.g. GDP data.","Hellenic Statistical Society publishes the data in PDF and XLS formats , not up to date and the data are not openly licensed.","Yes","No","Kleanthis Koupidis","Sophie Lafayette","80","80"
"c40d0a40-89b6-44af-881b-cb7be00385b8","global","2017-03-01T21:32:43","2016","hk","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Survey and Mapping Office (SMO) of the Lands Department "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""The data portal has data from the regions but no data specifically on boundaries. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The Survey and Mapping Office (SMO) of the Lands Department only have TIF map for Administrative Boundaries.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","0","0"
"6dee9112-d8cf-477d-996a-acdb64e2031e","global","2016-12-30T09:42:54","2016","ko","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data are available as a service online. See the Geoportal layer \""Municipality Border\"". https://geoportal.rks-gov.net/en/search""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Cadastre Agency of Kosovo"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Based on a phone conversation with the Agency, data is made available upon payment offline.""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Concur with original submitter that dataset are not available online.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Michael Leow","0","0"
"f18f0142-8c27-46e7-b47a-5e7caf36f372","global","2017-03-02T14:11:16","2016","jm","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Land Agency (NLA)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original Submission:
Agency: Planning Institute of Jamaica
Link:
- https://www.pioj.gov.jm/Portals/0/Sustainable_Development/SPATIAL%20BOUNDARIES%20OF%20JAMAICA.pdf - SPATIAL BOUNDARIES OF JAMAICA
Search Steps:After searching on google the keywords ""administrative boundaries jamaica"" I was connected to the refered document by the PIOJ
Reject submission as the PDF Map does not have Coordinate Projection and Polygon borders.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Reject submission as the PDF Map does not have Coordinate Projection and Polygon borders.","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","0","0"
"ab6ba8b7-37d9-455a-8bb8-313ed8bf48bd","global","2017-03-02T14:05:00","2016","vc","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""House of Assembly"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original Submission:
Agency:House of Assembly
Links:
- https://www.assembly.gov.vc/assembly/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=21&Itemid=33 - The fifteen (15) constituencies
- https://www.assembly.gov.vc/assembly/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=22&Itemid=34 - Constituency Boundaries
Search steps: constituencies St Vincent and the Grenadines
Rejected original submission as the map does not have Coordinates Projection.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Rejected original submission as the map does not have Coordinates Projection.","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","0","0"
"16fcd621-3dee-49ba-beb1-7f655954e04d","global","2017-03-02T13:59:44","2016","se","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Lantmäteriet"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original Submission:
Agency: Lantmäteriet
Link:
- https://www.lantmateriet.se/sv/Kartor-och-geografisk-information/Kartor/oppna-data/hamta-oppna-geodata/#faq:gsd-oversiktskartan-vektor - Lantmäteriet website
Search: Googled
Open License: https://www.lantmateriet.se/sv/Kartor-och-geografisk-information/Kartor/oppna-data/villkor/
Rejected the original submission as there is no Boundary Level 1+ 2.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Rejected the original submission as there is no Boundary Level 1+ 2.","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","0","0"
"da514fd2-f915-42fd-bdb4-5d6f26293d30","global","2016-12-07T11:46:33","2016","tr","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""All of these maps are copyrighted to GCM, please do not use them for commercial purposes.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Open website, take a look for legislation, services or PR section, type the keywords on search engine. Go to GCM page under Downloads section, under section \""TURKEY LOCAL ADMINISTRATIVE BOUNDARIES\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""General Command of Mapping (GCM)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.hgk.msb.gov.tr/english/download"",""descValue"":""TURKEY LOCAL ADMINISTRATIVE BOUNDARIES""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The Administrative Boundaries shapefiles under the page Downloads (https://www.hgk.msb.gov.tr/english/download); the section ""TURKEY LOCAL ADMINISTRATIVE BOUNDARIES"".
There is no open license as commercial-use is forbidden.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","Onur Teksan","Michael Leow","80","80"
"07fd0858-cfec-4d30-ab10-7d38c71abfd5","global","2017-01-20T21:54:53","2016","tt","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Only online viewer""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""2 maps are available for download that give the details of the administrative boundaries. However the overview of the districts are unavailable""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""One of the border maps are for 2016, however i am unsure of the time of publication for the text on the webpage ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I revisited the Elections and Boundaries Commission and investigated the website by the given data sets"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The information is easily comprehensible however i am unsure if it has met the criteria of this survey ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Elections and Boundaries Commission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Elections and Boundaries Commission is the successor institution of two separate bodies:\n\na Boundaries Commission and\nan Elections Commission, these having been amalgamated in the Republican Constitution enacted in 1976.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ebctt.com/electoral-districts/interactive-district-map/"",""descValue"":""Administrative Boundaries Map""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The Election & Boundaries Commission (https://www.ebctt.com/electoral-districts/interactive-district-map/) map shows the Administrative Boundaries with the chracteristics. However, it is not downloadable online and does not have any open license.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Michael Leow","45","45"
"89a1a0c6-00c3-4fcd-875b-ad5717b5e146","global","2016-12-08T21:31:13","2016","rs","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""\n""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Law on register of spatial units"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Republic Geodetic Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.geosrbija.rs/rga/default.aspx?gui=1&lang=1#"",""descValue"":""administrative units section""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","GeoSerbia Portal has viewer for Administrative Boundaries with all the characteristic. However, the data is not available for download.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","It is hard to get the data, despite the fact it is free.","Yes","No","Aleksandar Ivić","Michael Leow","45","45"
"b6c09be6-23fe-4d08-8115-5f6186d47bc3","global","2017-03-02T08:32:19","2016","lc","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""St Lucia Electorial Division"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original Submission:
Agency: St Lucia Electorial Division
Link:
- https://www.electoral.gov.lc/electoral/constituences - Electoral Constituences
Search: By doing a quick Google search for the keywords ""administrative division of St Lucia"" I followed the results to the St Lucia Electoral Division webpage
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Rejected the original submission as there is no coordinates projection.","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","0","0"
"2e2b0e8d-5740-4a64-a2c6-0742f9a2f499","global","2017-02-22T12:11:22","2016","ua","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML -> Reverse engineer JSON -> WKT geometry.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""You can retrieve the data by reverse engineering API. https://atu.minregion.gov.ua/api/format/region_template/ato.ato_level_territory_view/atoid/123/wkb_geometry,name_fullua""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search for \""Geoportal of administrative division of Ukraine\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""You have to write webcrawler""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Regional Development, Construction and Housing and Communal Services of Ukraine Ukraine State Service of Geodesy, Cartography and Cadastre"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://atu.minregion.gov.ua/en/home"",""descValue"":""GEOPORTAL of administrative-territorial system of Ukraine""},{""urlValue"":""https://atu_reform.gki.com.ua/en/karta"",""descValue"":""GeoPortal Map that shows layers for Administrative Boundaries""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","GeoPortal (https://atu_reform.gki.com.ua/en/karta) Map shows the ""Administrative Boundaries"". By selecting the layer ""The boundaries of administrative units"" shows a view-only of the dataset that matches the characteristics.
However, none of the dataset is downloadable and there is no clear Open Data License.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","45","45"
"c8b82d96-9268-44cd-afe4-3bc62b9ae6aa","global","2016-11-10T15:07:20","2016","tw","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""search on Taiwan's open data portal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.tw/license#eng"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of the Interior"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.tw/node/7438"",""descValue"":"" County boundaries""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.tw/node/7442"",""descValue"":""Municipalities, prefectures and municipal boundaries ""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.tw/node/7441"",""descValue"":""Township boundaries""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Concur with the original submitters that all the characteristic are available and downloadable. Added the municipal and Township shapefile. Data are considered open as there is an open data license (as per in Data Portal).
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","Yes","lycurgus kk","Michael Leow","100","100"
"8946fd1d-24cc-4665-bded-161f4c50b7e4","global","2016-12-16T09:48:16","2016","sg","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""KML"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search for \""Singapore administrative boundary data\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.sg/open-data-licence"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Urban Redevelopment Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.sg/dataset/master-plan-2014-subzone-boundary-no-sea"",""descValue"":""Master Plan 2014 Subzone Boundary""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Concur with original submitter that the dataset fulfils all the characteristic; and it is free to download and easily downloadable with open license.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","Yes","Zhaowei Lin","Michael Leow","100","100"
"4113a53b-834f-4f2a-83ae-3427961cb2c1","global","2017-03-02T03:53:43","2016","kn","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Election Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original Submission:
Agency: Election Office
Links:
- https://www.sknvibes.com/elections/Map.cfm?name=skb - Electoral Boundaries for St Kitts - Map
- https://www.sknvibes.com/elections/map.cfm?name=nevis - Electoral Boundaries for Nevis -Map
Search steps: Having visited the site to view the election results, I found data on the boundaries easily
Reject submission as no coordinates projection and polygon borders.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Reject submission as no coordinates projection and polygon borders","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","0","0"
"b358b0d5-24cb-4e75-8fe1-0b8543fe9387","global","2016-12-31T21:06:31","2016","ir","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""There isn't any special department for procurement. each organisation and department do it's own."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes in submission. Couldn't find available data. ",,"Yes","No","MohammadHossein Khani","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"54211be7-8b63-4bc4-a183-6a0753be9b9d","global","2016-12-12T14:52:29","2016","id","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""through google search and the main website provides with all the links"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Government Procurement Policy Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.lkpp.go.id/v3/"",""descValue"":""Agency's official website""},{""urlValue"":""https://sirup.lkpp.go.id"",""descValue"":""Procurement planning""},{""urlValue"":""https://monev.lkpp.go.id/"",""descValue"":""Procurement monitoring and evaluation""},{""urlValue"":""https://inaproc.lkpp.go.id/agregasi"",""descValue"":""Aggregated data of vendors listed in the national procurement system""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes in the submission. ","the data is available but not legally and technically open. Some people actually regularly scrape the website and use the data for their own analyses. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"211b2a4f-05d9-427e-9c5b-c83fc670b10a","global","2017-02-01T05:41:36","2016","in","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Central Public Procurement Portal can be found by Googling \""tenders for Government of India\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data not downloadable.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Expenditure"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://eprocure.gov.in/cppp/tendersearch"",""descValue"":""Search tenders database""},{""urlValue"":""https://eprocure.gov.in/cppp/latestactivetenders"",""descValue"":""Latest tenders""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes in submission. Data only visible in HTML",,"Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"13704f3b-342d-40bd-bc8d-907e5235f7e6","global","2017-01-20T23:10:17","2016","gy","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Last up date was in May 2016""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Upon searching google for tender awards in Guyana i was quickly connected to the List of The National Procurement and Tender Administration Tender Awards"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is easily understandable however clearly out of date""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The National Procurement and Tender Administration"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The National Procurement and Tender Administration was established in accordance with Section 16 (1) of the Procurement Act 2003 which came into effect in November 2004, with the signing of the Order by the Minister of Finance.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Awards per government office"",""Tender description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.npta.gov.gy/tender_awards.html"",""descValue"":""\t List of NPTA Tender Awards""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes to the submission. The data shows mostly awarded contracts, the level of detail is quite low and there is no license. ",,"Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Oscar Montiel","30","30"
"b5515341-a02e-4024-99c1-eafad8bc8925","global","2016-12-12T22:47:11","2016","gt","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched for \""Public Procurement Guatemala\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Guatecompras: Sistema de Adquisiciones y Contrataciones del Estado de Guatemala"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Is not included in the law, so no government office is collecting this kind of information. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.guatecompras.gt/concursos/consultaConcursos.aspx?o=1&d=1&mod=1"",""descValue"":""Current tenders ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.guatecompras.gt/proveedores/consultaadvprovee.aspx"",""descValue"":""Awarded contracts""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Changed content of the submission. The initial submission said there was no data available.
The Guatecompras site has a search for current tenders and awarded contracts.They are only available as HTML and couldn't find any way to download the data. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"1ac7e90a-d5a8-4326-92cd-4f8b20123b7e","global","2016-12-15T13:22:25","2016","gr","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""The official site is https://www.eprocurement.gov.gr/ "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.eprocurement.gov.gr/webcenter/faces/oracle/webcenter/page/scopedMD/sd0cb90ef_26cf_4703_99d5_1561ceff660f/Page119.jspx?_afrLoop=11079046144624464&_adf.ctrl-state=2jw38gmlv_4#%2Foracle%2Fwebcenter%2Fpage%2FscopedMD%2Fsd0cb90ef_26cf_4703_99d5_1561ceff660f%2FPage152.jspx%40%3Fwc.contextURL%3D%2Fspaces%2Fprod_ministry%26_adf.ctrl-state%3D2jw38gmlv_4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""General Secretariat of Commerce"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.eprocurement.gov.gr/actSearch/faces/active_search_main.jspx"",""descValue"":""The innovation of the e - procurement platform that has been developed for public authorities in Greece by the General Secretariat of Commerce. This platform will be used in all the stages of a public procurement procedure, increasing transparency and accelerating public procurement procedures.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Changed B7. since the link provided were only the Terms of Use for the portal. No licence is available. ","The Government of Greece has online portal for procurement and issuing of tenders where one can easily browse through data and access information regarding them. [e-procurement.gr]is the main site towards this need.
All documents are available on the website [for active searchs]in a structured Excel form
The data are also available for free","Yes","No","Kleanthis Koupidis","Oscar Montiel","80","80"
"97ffe9f9-ed16-41af-a99d-debf508b26fc","global","2017-03-01T20:45:36","2016","np","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""the Ministry of Industry Office of Company Registrar"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","There are Company Data available for free and downloadable in bulk in .CSV and .XML format on the Ministry of Industry Office of Company Registrar website. They include the company's English Name, Registration Number, District, Area, Company Type, Registration Date, and NSIC Code, but not the full Company Address. Thus, the original submission was rejected. The data don't seem to be frequently updated, as the latest available .zip file contaned data from 16/06/2016.
https://www.ocr.gov.np/index.php/en/data",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"bdee03c3-b89d-4ea1-a983-a4965770e27b","global","2017-01-27T11:20:38","2016","gh","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Got to the Public Procurement Authority Website, click on the drop down of 'Tenders & Offers', there a number of drop down indicating various data. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Public Procurement Authority, Ghana "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ppaghana.org/contracts_main.asp"",""descValue"":""Open Tender Contracts already Awarded""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ppaghana.org/planning.asp"",""descValue"":""General information about the current procurement opportunities. ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ppaghana.org/biddingmain.asp"",""descValue"":""Bidding page: list of recents tenders ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Search for open tender contracts by Ministry, Region, Agency or Tender Type. Simply make your selection and press the 'search' button.\nRegarding the procurement opportunities, they listed by various Ministries, Departments, Agencies and other Government entities. ""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes in the submission. Data is available only to see details in HTML. ",,"Yes","No","Franka Vaughan","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"c9d21d25-ff69-49e3-8f58-0740f64a38e0","global","2016-12-17T14:44:50","2016","de","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bundesverwaltungsamt"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Value of the award""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.bund.de/Content/DE/Ausschreibungen/Suche/Formular.html?nn=4641482>p=4642258_list%253D2&type=0&searchResult=true"",""descValue"":""general""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.evergabe-online.de/search.html?2"",""descValue"":""Innen Minsisterium""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes in submission. Information is only available in HTML to view details. ","couldn't find central tender portal
licenses not always clear","Yes","No","anonymous","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"c917ab82-733c-43e3-8870-98ac8f765e29","global","2017-01-17T19:05:03","2016","na","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Republic of Namibia Ministry of Industrialization, Trade & SME Development"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""+\n""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Both the Republic of Namibia Ministry of Industrialization, Trade & SME Development , and the Namibia Chamber of Commerce and Industry websites don't offer any information on companies, or a company search feature.
https://www.mti.gov.na/index.html
https://www.ncci.org.na/
The data don't appear to be available online, at least provided through a valid, reliable source. However, the original submitter was able to find other business directories available, though these could contain unregistered businesses. Still, they seem to not provide entities' unique identifiers:
https://www.namibiatradedirectory.com/
https://www.namibia-1on1-business-directory.com/",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"a1cfcc3d-b485-4108-99a5-0dbc741e7b53","global","2017-01-27T20:08:49","2016","cr","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Meteorológico Nacional"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewer: Accepted without corrections.","In Costa Rica, the national inventory of greenhouse gases is done by the National Meteorological Institute
(IMN) dependency attached to MINAE: https://cglobal.imn.ac.cr/gases-efecto-invernadero.
The last one published was for 2011 and are still lacking to be the product of a national monitoring system as is established by the Kyoto Protocol, and an appropriate instrument for decision-making in both the public sector as the private sector.
Originally submitted by Susana Soto","Yes","No","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"cc876203-13c0-4454-9f60-552d3c8869ec","global","2017-01-23T04:25:59","2016","gy","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Environmental Protection Agency Guyana"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewer: Can confirm no open data was found.","Unable to find a data source from a government agent","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"9f648feb-4847-4c70-a38b-0d138271427d","global","2016-12-31T08:34:55","2016","mm","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google searched \""Directorate of Investment and Company Administration Myanmar\"", once on the website the Company Search feature is easily located on the top right of the main menu."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""the Directorate of Investment and Company Administration of the Republic of the Union of Myanmar"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The link to access the official website does not work anymore https://www.dica.gov.mm/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.dica.gov.mm/en/company-search"",""descValue"":""DICA Company Search""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","While the original submitter reported that data were not available online, there is a Company Search feature on the Directorate of Investment and Company Administration of the Republic of the Union of Myanmar website. Data are available for free online but cannot be downloaded in bulk and are behind a search mask so one needs to know the name of an entity in order to find it. Company name in English and Myanmar, registration number, expiry date and once selected, the registration date, address and director(s) name(s) and NRC number(s) are also given in .HTML format. Update frequency of data is not stated.
https://www.dica.gov.mm/en/company-search
The website also offers lists of Registered Company names in .PDF format, organised by region, which appear to be recently updated:
https://www.dica.gov.mm/en/topic/registered-companies",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","15","15"
"d1a9b18b-4ceb-41d3-8f95-53268b9456bc","global","2016-12-15T05:33:09","2016","pa","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""[Original submitter comment]All the draft projects are in PDF, above there is a small summary in CSV format\n[Reviewer comment] Bills are only available in PDF. A list of all the bills proposed under the government of the current president is available in PDF, CVS and XLS format. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""All versions of a given bill can be downloaded at once. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1. Research on the web for Panama Draft Legislation. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Asamblea Nacional de Panama"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""National Assembly""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I changed the original submission to indicate that the status of bills is available. Although the status of the bills is not made explicit it is easy to derive by looking at the document for each bill. The PDF document for each bill includes all relevant documents for the bill as it moved through the legislative process. By looking at the versions of the bills available (and the resulting law if applicable) it is possible to determine where in the legislative process the bill is. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.asamblea.gob.pa/anteproyectos-de-ley/"",""descValue"":""National Assembly website node""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""[Original Submitter Comment] Center for judicial documentation of the judicial body. \n[Reviewer comment] The original submission had also enteredhttps://www.organojudicial.gob.pa/cendoj/cendojfields/anteproyectos-de-ley/ as a source. While some bills could be found on this website, the database does not seem to be complete as the last bills that were recorded were from 2014. So I am using the website of the National Assembly to review the submission.""}]","Yes","Yes","I am accepting the submission because all the required characteristics are available in the dataset. ","[Original submitter comment] Most drafts are available . The problem lies in the quality of the documents, which for some reason are sometimes printed, then scanned into PDFs and uploaded, rendering them unsearchable (document quality is also sometimes an issue).
[Reviewer comment] I was a bit flexible in choosing to mark status of bill as present. There was no explicit statement as to the status of the bill. However, the legislative history of the bill is documented in the PDF document for each bill. The document contains all the versions of the bill. Each version of the bill is preceded by a letter by the Speaker of the House/President of Panama/Author of Bill which summarize the legislative history of the bill up to a certain point. For those bill that have become laws, the PDF document concludes with the full text of the resulting law and the date it came into force.
On the other hand, like the original submitter, I could not find the two optional characteristics (transcripts and votes).
B5 was also answered YES with some flexibility. There is no option to download in bulk all the bills. However, for any given bill one can download all the data at once (so I made no changes to B5).","Yes","No","Victor Díaz Navarro","Juela Xhaferraj","60","60"
"37f0d49e-31d8-4e32-95be-37bf083cb973","global","2017-03-01T19:44:23","2016","bb","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Barbados Electoral and Boundaries Commission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission because results for latest general election (2013) are not available. As historical data, not all required data is available. As submitter noted, results available are only major results and registered votes, no information for invalid votes or spoiled ballots. Data available at constituency level.
By-Election results (1954-2011) are available in HTML format, structured in tables. It is also possible to download as PDF, DOC files. As for General Elections (1956-2008), data is also available in HTML but it is unstructured. Would require significant scrapping efforts to collect the data. Information for the 2013 elections results not available.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"4c9c3e61-5341-4b2c-aaa6-5c3d51263d38","global","2016-12-04T14:13:32","2016","cz","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The license restricts commercial use. \nhttps://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/cz/""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Hourly data are available also as XML and JSON. But daily summaries, which are the baseline for this dataset (see B2.2) are HTML only. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Daily data are available per measuring stations, therefore you have to go through the stations individually. Also, it is HTML format.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""The official site has a prominent position in search results. Hourly data are easy to find, but for daily or monthly summaries, i had to dig through the site. I have ask about VOCs as it is hidden in a pile of links with stats and reports."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Český hydrometeorlogický ústav / Czech Hydrometeorological institute"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Pollutants except VOCs are available, but not for every measuring station (see links in B2.2). I asked a responsible clerk and was told that for some towns, thresholds are not being exceeded and therefore the coverage of measurements was reduced few years ago. \nVOCs are published on a yearly basis (data per months).""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://portal.chmi.cz/files/portal/docs/uoco/web_generator/aqindex_slide1/mp_ALEGA_GB.html"",""descValue"":""Daily measurements for a measuring station""},{""urlValue"":""https://portal.chmi.cz/files/portal/docs/uoco/web_generator/actual_hour_data_GB.html"",""descValue"":""Hourly data for all measuring stations""},{""urlValue"":""https://portal.chmi.cz/files/portal/docs/uoco/isko/tab_roc/2015_enh/pollution_month/month_VOC_CZ.html"",""descValue"":""VOCs are published yearly for just 2 stations""},{""urlValue"":""https://portal.chmi.cz/files/portal/docs/uoco/web_generator/aqindex_slide1/mp_CCBDA_CZ.html"",""descValue"":""Daily data form another station to show that some pollutants, such as SO2, are measured only for selected locations.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""After a discussion, i decided to take the 24hour measurements as a baseline. https://discuss.okfn.org/t/air-pollution-hourly-data-in-open-formats-daily-summary-not/4100""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections. ",,"Yes","No","Michaela Rybičková","Ricardo Alanís","45","45"
"c6d170e0-90e6-401f-8007-78b54a079e1b","global","2016-12-06T18:57:31","2016","hr","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Not stated either way.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""JSON"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Some even hourly.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried a web search engine for air quality Croatia in Croatian. Agency was one of the hits."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Environment Protection Agency, Croatia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Of VOCs, benzene is measured.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://iszz.azo.hr/iskzl/podatak.htm"",""descValue"":""Environment Protection Agency, Croatia""},{""urlValue"":""https://iszz.azo.hr/iskzl/exc.htm"",""descValue"":""Environment Protection Agency, Croatia""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewer: Accepted without corrections. ","With the exception of the license which is not stated, the service is very well done and should serve as an example to others in SE Europe.","Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Ricardo Alanís","80","80"
"68b2ed20-a11c-4a1b-a0c9-a0b5fc58fec0","global","2017-03-01T19:38:33","2016","bd","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Election Commission Bangladesh"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission because not all required data is available. As submitter noted, results available are only major results, no information for registered votes, invalid votes or spoiled ballots. Data available at constituency level.
Results available on PDF only, general results by constituency (https://www.ec.org.bd/MenuExternalFilesEng/304.pdf - https://www.ec.org.bd/MenuExternalFilesEng/1329.pdf). Data downloadable per election. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"342e8aad-9e6d-42e9-9fd9-6715c9f17001","global","2017-03-01T19:27:01","2016","af","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Independent Election Commission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission because not all required data is available. As submitter noted, results available are only major results, no information for registered votes, invalid votes or spoiled ballots. Data available at polling station level.
Visible elections results are the ones from 2014. 2010 results are presented by electoral zones in PDF files (https://www.iec.org.af/results_10/eng/) + HTML (https://www.iec.org.af/results_10/eng/final_by_pollingStations.html). ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"8cdccc64-d923-4c61-a930-ad4d6fcca851","global","2017-01-19T17:05:08","2016","mz","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No information on the Republic of Mozambique and its Company Register could be found online.",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"89e5774b-4bc7-4e72-a784-cfa44321d6fd","global","2016-12-15T04:30:00","2016","pa","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""[Original Submitter Comment]Most statues, resolutions and regulations are available either from government websites such as Infojurídica or third parties. \nThe problem lies in the quality of the documents, which for some reason are sometimes printed, then scanned into PDFs and uploaded, rendering them unsearchable (document quality is also sometimes an issue).\n[Reviewer comment] Laws are only available in PDF. Did not find that the quality of the PDF documents was problematic. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""As a reviewer I am changing this to NO because there is no option to download data in bulk. Moreover, each amendment to the laws has to be downloaded separately from the original text of the law. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I researched on the web for Panamanian Laws, then in both websites it was easy to find the repositories"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""On the other hand, The search interface could be more user-friendly.""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Procuraduría General de la Nación (PGN) (Attorney of the administration )"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Asamblea Nacional de Panamá""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""When accessing each individual law, there is a tab that lists the amendments to the laws and a link to the full text of the amendment. Date of last amendment can be derived only by checking the most recent entry on the amendment list. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://infojuridica.procuraduria-admon.gob.pa/Infojuridica/index.htm"",""descValue"":""Info Jurídica (PGN law repository)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.asamblea.gob.pa/legispan-y-gacetas-oficiales/"",""descValue"":""Legispan (National Assembly)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""[Original Submitter comment] InfoJuridica Database contains systematized legal information of standards, with a detailed expression of their affectations, validity and unconstitutionalities with access to the full text of the norm, from 1903 to date.\nDigital Collection of Official Gazettes from 1903 to date.\n\n[Reviewer comment] Both websites listed in the original submission contain the data set that we are looking for. For the sake of consistency I am using the URL for Info Juridicia for the review. I found that this source provided a better account of amendments to laws.""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted because I was able to verify that the data contained all required characteristics. ","Both websites listed in B2 lead to very similar data. All questions can be answered the same when considering both websites (although my review was based on the Info Juridicia website). I changed B5 to a NO because I could not see any possibility of downloading data in bulk. The website provides only the full text of the original version of a law. If one wants to download updates, one must download each amendment separately.","Yes","No","Victor Díaz Navarro","Juela Xhaferraj","45","45"
"c1ca5c90-3380-4c8d-8747-c8b589f51a71","global","2017-03-01T19:01:51","2016","ph","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Commission on Elections"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Submission was rejected since Commission on Elections site ‘Results’ section (https://www.comelec.gov.ph/?r=2016NLE/ElectionResults) states that “https://www.pilipinaselectionresults2016.com/ is no longer available to display the Election Day election results as electronically transmitted from all Vote Counting Machines (VCMs) and Consolidation/Canvassing Systems (CCS) nationwide.
Please watch out as we prepare to make these same information directly available from inside the COMELEC Website”. Submitter provides links from media (Rappler, GMA, TV5), which is not relevant for the index. Also, as submitter states, historical resources on past elections are not well-documented.",,"Yes","No","Paola Mosso","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"29e12c7b-5b02-4f5e-a7f0-3b8371e432ef","global","2017-03-01T18:51:02","2016","me","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data are behind a search mask and one needs to know the name of an entity in order to find it.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Chamber of Economy Montenegro"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Only name, location shown on map, and contact information (telephone number and e-mail address) are available. Unique Identifiers are not provided.""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission by Blina Meta had to be rejected as not all four required characteristics are available online. More specifically, the Chamber of Economy Montenegro website offers company information online for free through a search mask, so one needs to know the name of an entity in order to find it, but this only includes the company name, the location shown on the map, and ontact information (telephone number and e-mail address) but no unique identifier. The information is given in .HTML format so data cannot be downloaded in bulk. Also, the update frequency of the information is unkown. The search feature is located on the left sidebar:
https://www.privrednakomora.me/en/associations",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"f28090a5-cd0b-48a5-983e-ef6701520f23","global","2016-12-14T16:23:42","2016","my","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data are available in .PDF format after purchasing.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""One needs to register on the e-Info website and then search for an entity's information via company name or registration number.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched the Companies Commission of Malaysia website which redirected me to the e-Info service page."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Companies Commission of Malaysia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ssm.com.my/en/e-Info-Mainpage"",""descValue"":""Companies Commission of Malaysia e-Info Services""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The only available data the submitter could find for free was a list of number of registered companies and businesses according to months and categories such as local companies, foreign companies, total companies and total businesses:
https://www.ssm.com.my/en/statistic-total-business-companies
However, on the Companies Commission of Malaysia website there is the service ""e-Info"" available which is an internet based Self-Help Online System to provide search and purchase of company and business information. It is available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, anywhere, globally by accessing www.ssm.com.my. A company profile which can be purchased via the e-Info system contains the following: Corporate Information, Registered and Business Address, Summary of Share Capital, Directors/Officers, Shareholders/Members, Company/Charges, and Company Financing Statement. A business profile which can be purchased via the e-Info system contains the following: Business Information, Current Business Owner, Nature of Business, and Business Branches:
https://www.ssm.com.my/en/product-services/e-info
Company Profile Information includes company name, company registration number and check digit, previous name and date of change, total authorized and total issued, directors, managers, shareholders, officers, company charges and summary of the latest financial information. Business profile information includes business name, registration number, type of business and detail of owner and partners, business address, date of commencement, and expiry date of current registration:
https://www.ssm.com.my/en/e-Info-Mainpage
All required characteristics are available via the service e-Info (https://www.ssm-einfo.my/) but for a fee of RM15 per Company. Once registered on the e-Info website, one can search for an entity via name or registration number and can then proceed to purchase the information in .PDF format. How often the data are updated is not stated. A sample can be seen here:
https://www.ssm-einfo.my/sample/sampleroc.pdf","The data only have a list of number of registered companies and businesses according to months and categories such as local companies, foreign companies, total companies and total businesses.
Reference link: https://www.ssm.com.my/en/statistic-total-business-companies","Yes","No","Hazwany Jamaluddin","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"af4e6f25-1b8f-47e1-b225-db761d98063d","global","2016-12-08T13:53:28","2016","pl","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It should be right? I could only find bills mentioning that the results should be publicly announced.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""XLSX even""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Dataset is split into multiple files, but all are extensively described on one page""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1. https://pkw.gov.pl/ or google \""wyniki wyborów\"" (\""election's results\"") 2. https://pkw.gov.pl/352_Wybory_i_referenda_w_toku_kadencji 3. choose level and year 4. dedicated sites ie. https://parlament2015.pkw.gov.pl/ 5. results -> https://parlament2015.pkw.gov.pl/347_Wyniki"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is well documented.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Panstwowa Komisja Wyborcza (PKW, National Electoral Commission)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://parlament2015.pkw.gov.pl/355_Wyniki_Sejm_XLS"",""descValue"":""Results of last national elections, lower house""},{""urlValue"":""https://prezydent2015.pkw.gov.pl/"",""descValue"":""Results of Presidential Elections""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Dataset is split into multiple files. Although results are described on one page, info on HTML does not contain all required data. Data is not downloadable in bulk. Submitter noted that it was not possible to find a license, but only bills mentioning that the results should be publicly announced.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","65","65"
"815956ba-8806-4a3b-8aa9-fc4c4fce6b53","global","2017-01-17T16:13:33","2016","mw","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
Both the Malawi Government and the Ministry of Justice and Constitutional Affairs, where the Department of Registrar General should fall under, websites appear to be down. Thus, there is no way of verifying whether the data are indeed collected by the government (or an official third party on behalf of the government). Data do not seem to be available online.
https://www.justice.gov.mw/
https://www.malawi.gov.mw",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"472c4d30-de77-4e60-a059-cc1ddc3dbe71","global","2017-03-01T16:29:09","2016","na","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Electoral Commission of Namibia "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Rejected submission because not all required data is available. As submitter noted, results available include registered votes and major results, no information for invalid or spoiled ballots. Available by electoral district and in XLXS format. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"12138402-8090-4006-84b2-361f358ae7c8","global","2017-03-01T16:07:02","2016","mk","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""the Central Registry of the Republic of Macedonia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Names and Company Registration Numbers are available for free on the Central Registry of the Republic of Macedonia website: https://www.crm.com.mk/DS/Default.aspx However, these are available through a search mask so one needs to know the name or CRN of an entity in order to find it. Furthermore, as the original submitter, Arianit Dobroshi, pointed out on the date of submission (29/11/2016), there appears to be a technical glitch which does not show the full records, as intended. This issue is still not resolved on the date of the review (01/03/2017). Because of this, it is currently impossible to verify that company address is available. Hence, the original submission needs to be rejected as not all four characteristics could be found online.
Only Company Registration Numbers and Company Names in Cyrillic and Latin are given in .HTML format when searching for an entity's name. Clicking on a company's CRN does not provide any results. When searching for a company's CRN, entity size, status, and additional information (if applicable) are given but still no company address. Data cannot be downloaded at once.
https://www.crm.com.mk/DS/default.aspx?MainId=12
Data are not openly licensed; a notice at the bottom of the website sates: All data from the entries in the records published or available on the website of the Central Registry of the Republic of Macedonia can be used in the manner specified by the Law on the Central Registry or any other law solely for personal, non-commercial needs. The data can not be reproduced, published, distributed, modified, copied, sold, resold and / or abuse commercially in any way, in part or in whole, without prior approval from the Central Registry of the Republic of Macedonia.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"48dd2e1e-a1f4-430e-bf3d-a7e50fa49138","global","2016-12-23T16:22:57","2016","ch","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Commercial use requires permission""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search the national OGD portal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal Office of Topography swisstopo"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://opendata.swiss/en/dataset/swissboundaries3d-landesgrenzen1"",""descValue"":""swissBOUNDARIES3D national boundaries""},{""urlValue"":""https://opendata.swiss/en/dataset/swissboundaries3d-gemeindegrenzen1"",""descValue"":""swissBOUNDARIES3D municipal boundaries""},{""urlValue"":""https://opendata.swiss/en/dataset/swissboundaries3d-kantonsgrenzen1"",""descValue"":""swissBOUNDARIES3D cantonal boundaries""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Concur with original submitter that all characteristic are available for download direct from the Open Data Portal.
Dataset license is not open as it needs permission from the owner before commercial use.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","Michael Leow","80","80"
"bf7fec35-7b14-4f5e-9658-23c723fb9499","global","2017-03-01T11:52:42","2016","ru","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""THE FEDERAL SERVICE FOR STATE REGISTRATION, CADASTRE AND CARTOGRAPHY"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original Submission:
Agency: THE FEDERAL SERVICE FOR STATE REGISTRATION, CADASTRE AND CARTOGRAPHY
Links:
- https://rosreestr.ru/wps/portal/cc_ib_opendata - open data section
https://rosreestr.ru/wps/portal/p/cc_ib_portal_services/cc_ib_opendata2 - Cadastre metadata
Open License: https://data.gov.ru/information-usage
Reject original submission as there is no indication of Boundary Level 2 in the map viewer (https://pkk5.rosreestr.ru/)
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Reject original submission as there is no indication of Boundary Level 2 in the map viewer (https://pkk5.rosreestr.ru/)","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","0","0"
"7fa0168e-b941-4175-b630-40fe725135d6","global","2016-11-26T13:07:51","2016","ro","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""KMZ""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Updated Nov 23rd""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Entered data.go.ro and searched \""unitate administrativa\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.ro/base/images/logoinst/OGL-ROU-1.0.pdf"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" National Register for Cadastre and Land Registration"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.ro/dataset/unitati-administrative"",""descValue"":""Data Portal - Administrative Units""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Characteristics are available in the KMZ that can be easily downloaded from the Data Portal. Data is also available with an open license.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Michael Leow","100","100"
"ae63ce78-ccaa-47f1-9fac-72a01c3304bf","global","2017-03-01T09:29:54","2016","np","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Federal Affairs and Local Development (MoFALD)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://lgcdp.gov.np/program""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Administrative Boundaries JPG images are under: https://lgcdp.gov.np/GIS_national, https://lgcdp.gov.np/GIS_regional, https://lgcdp.gov.np/GIS_district
Reject the submission as the Administrative Boundaries map are only in JPG image; lacking Coordinates Projection and Polygons Borders.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Identified the Local Governance and Community Development Programme (LGCDP) II under Ministry of Federal Affairs and Local Development (MoFALD) as the Agency for Administrative Boundaries.
Reject the submission as the Administrative Boundaries map are only in JPG image; lacking Coordinates Projection and Polygons Borders.","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","0","0"
"7267a949-4fd6-4b47-84d2-aedbcf8de068","global","2017-01-14T12:23:14","2016","pt","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""O Utilizador pode copiar, importar ou utilizar gratuitamente informações ou símbolos nacionais existentes neste site para uso pessoal ou público desde que dessa utilização não decorram finalidades lucrativas ou ofensivas. ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX"",""WFS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Googled \""limites administrativos portugal\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.dgterritorio.pt/condicoes_de_utilizacao/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Direcção-Geral do Território"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.dgterritorio.pt/cartografia_e_geodesia/cartografia/carta_administrativa_oficial_de_portugal__caop_/caop_em_vigor/"",""descValue"":""CAOP 2016""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The Administrative Boundaries dataset can be download as a shapefile and via WFS. Concur that all the characteristics are available in the dataset.
Only restriction is that the dataset is protected by copyright for commercial-use.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Cátia Matos","Michael Leow","80","80"
"f2ad252d-d15f-4b2b-bd6e-cbf35ca4ea96","global","2016-12-20T11:32:57","2016","ph","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is only viewable online""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""In order to download data; a letter must be sent to NAMRIA""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Go to the NAMRIA Map Viewer; search under \""boundary\"" for the Layers: Regional, Provincial, Municipal Boundaries"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.ph/policy/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""5. All datasets accessible through this website are provided free of charge for use, reuse, redistribution, adaptation, sharing, or the commercialization of any derivative works.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Mapping and Resource Information Authority (NAMRIA)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.namria.gov.ph/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No reason found."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.geoportal.gov.ph/viewer/"",""descValue"":""NAMRIA Map Viewer""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","All characteristics are viewable under the NAMRIA Map Viewer; search under ""boundary"" for the Layers: Regional, Provincial, Municipal Boundaries. However, the dataset is not downloadable as a letter needs to be written to NAMRIA for access.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Data (shapefiles) for administrative boundaries can be found at https://www.philgis.org/ free for educational and nonprofit use. Other sites also have this data published online.","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","65","65"
"a4b03660-eb0d-4b3e-bc2b-afb742a3a32f","global","2017-01-29T06:04:50","2016","cm","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""the Ministry of environment does not state to collect this information."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections. Confirmed with external data.","Data portal available at: https://www.minep.gov.cm/index.php?option=com_content&view=category&id=27&Itemid=72&lang=fr
Yet, no indication of air quality data availability","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"85caafd2-f366-4b2c-b168-cfa9aad98ecf","global","2016-12-31T10:16:08","2016","kh","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Environment"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The link to the official website https://moe.gov.kh/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections.","There are no evidence to confirm that the data exist.","Yes","No","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"9539934b-23f4-47b4-9a42-37a366cb2709","global","2017-01-27T17:37:03","2016","bo","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Visited the source URL and selected the section under Estadisticas Del Medio Ambiente. Under that, I selected Residuos Solidos. This brings up a simple form to select the datasets you want. Data for other pollutants can also be found under the Estadisticas Del Medio Ambiente section."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Nacional de Estadistica"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Ozone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.gob.bo/indice/EstadisticaSocial.aspx?codigo=80501"",""descValue"":""Solid residue/pollutants dataset for 2003 through 2013""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","David Opoku","Ricardo Alanís","65","65"
"006cf668-68ae-41e1-ba07-c59a3b86f08d","global","2017-01-18T21:55:59","2016","bw","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is collected at internal level but not by Botswana Gov.""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Confirmed no data was found.",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"f2cff598-027a-4074-a4de-c5d7dff63594","global","2016-12-30T09:44:40","2016","bt","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Reviewer: No license data was found.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Reviewer: No link to bulk data is available.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Reviewer: Data is updated Daily""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""visited website and looked for particular data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.nec.gov.bt/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Environment Commission "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.nec.gov.bt/"",""descValue"":""Air Pollution Index""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted with small corrections.",,"Yes","No","Executive Director, BMF","Ricardo Alanís","45","45"
"8dc6dd85-b11b-4d6a-ae82-4565eba50b43","global","2017-03-01T01:13:12","2016","ag","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Only external sources found."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"0dee573a-85ad-44c4-8348-68e6ecff844f","global","2017-03-01T01:12:01","2016","ar","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google \""Estadisticas ambientales Argentina\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Ambiente y Desarrollo Sustentable"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://estadisticas.ambiente.gob.ar/?idarticulo=13951#estadi"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Originally rejected, data updated to reflect changes.",,"Yes","No","Ricardo Alanís","Ricardo Alanís","65","65"
"dfcc76a8-4821-4b5e-8d7b-33bb12305b1c","global","2016-12-02T22:01:27","2016","ua","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Some data is available through https://map.land.gov.ua/kadastrova-karta but that's hardly what's required by this dataset.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search for \""public map of Ukraine\"", go to government announcement which contains a link to it"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The State Service of Ukraine for Geodesy, Cartography and Cadastre"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""According to law https://zakon5.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/661-2013-%D0%BF#n8""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There's no evidence that topographical maps are available to the public directly from government agencies.""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No relief maps""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://map.land.gov.ua/kadastrova-karta"",""descValue"":""map of boundaries and ortophotos""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","ok!","While cadastre map is available, it is different from national map as described by this dataset.","Yes","No","Vanya Yani","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"e0a24615-c17f-4e3b-8942-8bcca46f83ba","global","2017-01-30T16:10:08","2016","us","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""SHP""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""They are available as shapefiles and file geodatabases (ESRI formats) for either all of the U.S. or for indivudula states""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I have previous knowledge of the existence of this data and was able to discover easily from the main webpage of the USGS"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www2.usgs.gov/laws/info_policies.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""United State Geological Survey"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://viewer.nationalmap.gov/basic/"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","ok!",,"Yes","Yes","Tyler Kleykamp","Codrina Maria Ilie","100","100"
"d0beba06-bfa0-4644-81d1-1a3cfee59c4f","global","2017-02-28T23:52:53","2016","bg","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Geodesy, Cartography and Cadastre Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The initial submission presented what seems to be the official INSPIRE for Cadastre Information in Bulgaria, available at https://geonames.cadastre.bg/index.php#, where only queries are provided. After asking in the forum, I received the endpoint https://inspire.cadastre.bg:6080/arcgis/rest/services/inspire/iServices/MapServer. The data (not available for download, not openly licensed) stored is not compliant with this data theme. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"3bad01d2-a8f7-4ead-94c5-294349abba45","global","2016-12-28T00:51:15","2016","fr","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The awards dataset is only updated yearly and has been published on an irregular basis and inconsistent formats for the last five years""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched \""marchés publics\"" on data.gouv.fr, found tenders data and various incomplete datasets for awards"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.etalab.gouv.fr/licence-ouverte-open-licence"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.data.gouv.fr/fr/datasets/boamp/"",""descValue"":""BOAMP Procurement tenders database""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.data.gouv.fr/fr/datasets/marches-publics-conclus-recenses-sur-la-plateforme-des-achats-de-letat/"",""descValue"":""PLACE Partial procurement awards yearly datasets""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Procurements data (both tenders and awarded contracts) is available as open data. However awards data only provides procurement from a portion of the central governmental entities (see here and here), estimated to represent only 40 to 60% of the global amount awarded each year.\nThe dataset on the last years procurement tenders is an extract of PLACE, the national procurement marketplace, still not mandatory and only including volunteer administrations (about 50%). It includes tenders name, description of the tenders and status of the buying unit, supplier name, award title, date of the notification (DAY/MONTH) city, zip code, value of the award, description of the award, if it was attributed to an SME.\n\nData on procurement tenders by some sub-national entities (city, departments, regions) and independant administrative authorities are generally not present on data.gouv.fr but there are some, such as CNIL and the City of Poitiers.""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes made to the submission.
The format in which files are compressed makes use of the data really complicated.
",,"Yes","No","Open Knowledge","Oscar Montiel","70","70"
"665f31fc-fe4c-490e-b2aa-f805b2c98828","global","2016-12-19T18:21:09","2016","do","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Buscar en google \""compras dominicanas\"". Muestra en el primer resultado el portal de la Dirección General de Contrataciones Públicas. Una vez allí uno hace click en \""acceso ciudadano\"" para acceder a los procesos de compras y licitaciones del gobierno dominicano."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Dirección General de Contrataciones Públicas"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://comunidad.comprasdominicana.gob.do/Public/Tendering/ContractNoticeManagement/Index"",""descValue"":""Portal Transaccional de la Dirección General de Contrataciones Públicas""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Changed the formats of the data. The details for each tender are only visible as HTML on the website.
",,"Yes","No","Miguel Reyes Taveras","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"4416f1f2-c134-44ca-86a9-9c5468380297","global","2017-01-16T21:38:43","2016","ls","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data are available through a search mask so you need to know the name or number of an entity in order to find it.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I google searched company register Lesotho and found this source on the first page of search results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Lesotho Ministry of Trade & Industry, Cooperatives and Marketing"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.obfc.org.ls/companyInfo/default.php"",""descValue"":""One-Stop Business Facilitation Centre website""},{""urlValue"":""www.companies.org.ls/"",""descValue"":""Companies Register - Ministry of Trade, Industry, Cooperatives and Marketing website""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The ""Search"" feature on the One-Stop Business Facilitation Centre website proposed by the submitter appears to not be working: https://www.obfc.org.ls/companyInfo/default.php
However, data are available for free online on the Companies Register - Ministry of Trade, Industry, Cooperatives and Marketing website. Using the Company Search option you can find details of both internal and external companies. Details include Business name and number, shareholdings, directors, addresses, date of incorporation and business activity. You can export the data for each entity as .PDF or .XLS files but there is not a dataset that can be downloaded at once. Moreover, data are available through a search mask so you need to know the name or number of an entity in order to find it. Update frequency and type of license are unknown:
www.companies.org.ls/
More detailed information about companies registered in Lesotho is available from the Registrar on request and payment of a search fee.",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Evangelia Kampouri","35","35"
"920ab890-4982-43b5-9ab1-ce209d9fced9","global","2017-02-06T16:51:08","2016","dk","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of modernization "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes to submission","There is a centralized area where governments can share information called IndFak but it's not open for the public https://www.modst.dk/Systemer/OES-LDV/Formaal","Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"b0acc69c-7a99-4b8f-af55-4acfb4de4a99","global","2016-11-14T13:43:13","2016","ko","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""We have no way of knowing if the data is updated every month. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The companies register of Kosovo can be searched through, or browsed by inputting a blank search. There is no dataset available. ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I knew about this institution before. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Kosovo Business Registration Agency "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.arbk.org/"",""descValue"":""Kosovo Business Registration Agency""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The companies register of Kosovo can be searched through, or browsed by inputting a blank search on the Ministry of Trade and Industry - Business Registration Agency website. However, there is no dataset available to download in bulk. Name, Business/Registration Number, Municipality, Business Type, and Status are available for free at a glance and once an entity is selected, Fiscal Number, Address, Workers Number, Date of Establishment and Application, Telephone, E-mail, Capital, Authorised Persons, Owner, and Activity are also given in .HTML format. Still, there is no way of knowing if the data is updated every month and the type of license is unknown.",,"Yes","No","Blina Meta","Evangelia Kampouri","30","30"
"6e6ddacf-1ccf-4ea1-83e8-4826d9567138","global","2016-12-14T08:48:37","2016","lv","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I knew where that data was."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Latvian Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre, (Latvijas Vides, ģeoloģijas un meteoroloģijas centrs)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.meteo.lv/en/laiks/?nid=638"",""descValue"":""Latvian Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre, weather maps for all required characteristics (freely accessible)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.meteo.lv/pakalpojumi/prognozes/meteorologiskas-prognozes/laikapstaklu-prognoze-turpmakajam-3-diennaktim-latvijai?id=3190&nid=325&cid=911"",""descValue"":""Latvian Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre, 3-day forecasts for all required characteristics, data download, XML format""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission referred to weather forecast maps, freely available online without the need to register. I corrected the submission and referred it to downloadable data that is already available in machine-readable and open formats.
This data is not available online without signing up for a paid service. There was no note of terms of use. It could not be verified whether these are compliant with the OpenDefinition. Therefore it was stated that the data is not openly licensed.
The paid service provides three day forecasts for wind, precipitation and temperatures. Downloadable at: https://www.meteo.lv/pakalpojumi/prognozes/meteorologiskas-prognozes/laikapstaklu-prognoze-turpmakajam-3-diennaktim-latvijai?id=3190&nid=325&cid=911
Thank you, Toms Ceļmillers, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The data is available to download only as paid service. ","Yes","No","Toms Ceļmillers","Danny Lämmerhirt","50","50"
"1e9e10e8-273a-4f42-8138-f387b3c382aa","global","2017-01-27T15:44:09","2016","ke","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""google \""Kenya company register access\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Office of the Attorney General and Department of Justice collects the data https://www.statelaw.go.ke/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Couldn't verify as you have to be a citizen or resident to request access""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""can't confirm""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://accounts.ecitizen.go.ke/register"",""descValue"":""citizen services portal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Couldn't verify as you have to be a citizen or resident to request access""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The Kenya State Law Office - Registrar General website does not offer any data on Companies https://www.statelaw.go.ke/registrar-general-division/
According to the submitter, one has to be a citizen or resident to request access to data, but I was unable to find any indication that one can actually request access. The Registration of Business Names and Companies page that, although unlikely, might offer some more information on companies, appears to be down: https://www.attorney-general.go.ke/index.php/company-forms
Hence, after going through the website responsible for collecting the data, I conclude that the dataset is not available online.",,"Yes","No","Sierra Williams","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"523e34bb-8810-409a-81b3-173a9748b969","global","2016-12-29T20:16:38","2016","ko","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Hydrometeorological Institute of Kosovo monetizes weather data pursuant to Ministry of Environment and Spatial Planning Regulation no. 1/2015, Art 12 link to the Regulation in English https://archive.org/details/MinistriRregullorja0120152""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Hydrometeorological Institute of Kosovo"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. There was no evidence of a public web presence of the Hydrometeorology Institute of Kosovo. Several searches do not lead to any results of a web presence. See here: https://www.ammk-rks.net/?page=2,90
Thank you, Arianit Dobroshi, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Hydrometeorological Institute of Kosovo monetizes weather data pursuant to Ministry of Environment and Spatial Planning Regulation no. 1/2015, Art 12 link to the Regulation in English https://archive.org/details/MinistriRregullorja0120152","Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"056e732d-243a-4c10-bd66-86d374afee53","global","2017-01-27T15:04:10","2016","nl","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""TXT"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""See original submitters comment on B2 and B5 for more information on how information can be downloaded in bulk.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""See update frequency here: https://data.overheid.nl/data/dataset/basis-wetten-bestand""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""I changed the original submission to indicate that data is available without need to register because I am able to get access to the full text of laws and their amendments without need to register. It seems the original submitter made his decision based on whether the data is available in bulk without registration. The original submission had indicated that data was available only after registering. \n[Original Submitter comment] \""Bulk download is not available due to the size of data package (90GB). User has to send a USB stick to receive data - see here: https://data.overheid.nl/data/dataset/basis-wetten-bestand/resource/4659e19b-06a3-4b1a-85f2-863babd11263\n\nNon-bulk data is available online without any registration need \""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""[Reviewer comment]I changed the original submission to answer B4 with YES. Again, the original submitter had answered with NO based on an assessment of bulk download of the data. \n[Original Submitter Comment] USB stick needs to be sent in to download data (large filesize of 90GB)""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Once the legal term for national law was known, it was easy to find the data, but it was a bit trial and error to go to data.overheid.nl""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search for \""national wet nederlands\"" then checked the first search results, verification necessary if basiswetten is actually national law"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.overheid.nl/data/dataset/basis-wetten-bestand"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Netherlands publication office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The original submission had marked as absent \""Date of last amendment\"" and \""Amendments to the law\"". I changed the submission to indicate that all characteristics are available. If one clicks on \""Legislative Information\"" for each law, the history of the amendments and their dates are clearly recorded. Moreover, the text of the law itself marks the dates that articles were repealed and the date that the law was last amended. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.overheid.nl/data/dataset/437583e6-a783-4367-81c8-a51c27a2dbc1"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I am accepting the submission with some alteriations. I was able to verify that the dataset actually meets all required characteristics.","I changed B2 to indicate that data was available without the need to register. The original submitter had indicated that it is only available after registering. As the comment indicates the original submitter's decision was made on bulk downloads. Since bulk downloads are only a consideration for B5 I changed the submission, since texts of individual laws could be accessed without registration.
I changed B3 to indicate that the dates of last amendments to laws and amendments were available.
I changed B4 to YES because everything is free of charge. The original submitter's comment applies only to bulk downloads.
In B8 I added that data is available for download in HTML and TXT format as well (in addition to XML). Before downloading a law, a dialogue box appears asking in which format you prefer to download. ","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Juela Xhaferraj","100","100"
"d7129f6f-3da9-453f-8482-28aa6a66f59f","global","2016-12-01T21:21:13","2016","je","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""A download of the whole dataset is only available by emailing the registry and then making arrangements for payment of the fee.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""While the user can query the database and return a limited number of search results without registering they cannot access the data in bulk or in a machine-readable format.\n\nObtaining the whole result set is only possible by sending an email and making a payment.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Only the first 999 results can be accessed through the free search facility. To obtain a bulk download of all the records a fee of £100 is made.""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to the home page of the Jersey Financial Services Commission, clicked on 'Registry' in the main navigation and then clicked \""Jersey registered entities\"" under the quick search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Jersey Financial Services Commission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The registered office address is available through the search but not in the bulk download.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.jerseyfsc.org/registry/documentsearch/NameSearch.aspx"",""descValue"":""Company Registry search page""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The search page also gives instructions on how to obtain a download of data in return for a £100 fee""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
Data are available on the Jersey Financial Services Commission - Companies Registry website but through a search mask so it is necessary to know the name or registration number of an entity in order to find it. Name, Registered Office, Registration number, Registration Date, Law, Business Code, Business Type, Status are available online for free in .HTML format however the update frequency is not stated. One has also the option to order an entity's Certificate of good standing for £30.00, or a registration certificate for £4.00.
If your search criteria are not specific enough you may find that the search engine takes some time to deliver a result. In order to ensure that all search results are delivered in a timely manner the system has been design [sic] to return the first 1000 results, they will be displayed showing the first 10 entries in Alphabetical order. You may change the order of your results by sorting them, either by double clicking on Number, Type or Name. You may also select to Show your entries 10, 25, 50 or 100 entries per page, you may also refine your results by using the additional search field that is available in your “Search Results” window. Should your result contain more than 1000 entries you will be required to refine your search criteria.
Data are not openly licensed (https://www.jerseyfsc.org/legal_information.asp) and can only be accessed as individual entities, hence they cannot be downloaded at once. However, a download of active companies registered under the Companies (Jersey) Law 1991, as amended, is available for a fee of £100.00. According to the website, it includes the company's current name, registration number and date of incorporation so perhaps the Company Address may be missing. If you require a download please contact the Registry at: registry@jerseyfsc.org.",,"Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Evangelia Kampouri","15","15"
"10cc4416-528e-4bb3-bd73-f7af35b71f07","global","2017-02-28T17:41:30","2016","jp","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Japan Meteorological Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original submission by Masahiko Shoji. Thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The original submission was not accepted. The data it referred to did not meet the required data characteristics. Forecasts for wind speed and direction are not available for the following two days (based on the current day). There are 3-hour forecasts containing precipitation, temperature and wind speed/direction. The forecasts only cover the next 24 hours. They are available at: https://www.jma.go.jp/en/jikei/319.html
The data cannot be downloaded and is openly licensed. The terms of use require attribution. For more detail, see here: https://www.jma.go.jp/jma/en/copyright.html
","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"d93b0793-4e89-46d5-83d2-36606ea180fd","global","2017-01-16T18:14:51","2016","jm","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is not downloadable ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is not downloadable, the site loads the current day and next day information. The 3 day forecast is a brief text""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The data is up to date however there i no representation for pass weather information which would allow the review and tracking of trends""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Upon entering the keywords \""weather forecast Jamaica\"" on Google the The Meteorological Service of Jamaica website was quickly found on the first page. Upon visiting the site data was frequently updated data was available "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Meteorological Service of Jamaica"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""In Jamaica, the Meteorological Service of Jamaica, which is a scientific division of the Ministry of Land and Environment, handles the business of meteorology.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Precipitation Probability"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is published but not in the requisite format. The interface is old-fashioned and lead to broken links. The graph for temperature and precipitation was obscure or probably broken""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""metservice.gov.jm"",""descValue"":""The Meteorological Service of Jamaica""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.metservice.gov.jm/forecast.asp"",""descValue"":""The Meteorological Service of Jamaica, precipitation forecast""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.metservice.gov.jm/forecast_towns2.asp"",""descValue"":""The Meteorological Service of Jamaica, iconic representation of weather forecasts""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. One addition: the data is not openly licensed. There is a copyright note at the footer of the page, but no other statement of public domain status.","In Jamaica, the Meteorological Service of Jamaica, which is a scientific division of the Ministry of Land and Environment, handles the business of meteorology.
Data is published but not in the requisite format. The interface is old-fashioned and lead to broken links. The graph for temperature and precipitation was obscure or probably broken
Data is not downloadable, the site loads the current day and next day information. The 3 day forecast is a brief text
The data is up to date however there i no representation for pass weather information which would allow the review and tracking of trends","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"1b49bb6a-e25e-473c-bc8d-0551b2f554d9","global","2017-01-31T18:16:48","2016","it","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched the website and looked on several subpages of the forecast page."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.meteoam.it/page/condizioni-di-utilizzo-disclaimer"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministero della difesa, Meteo Aeronautico"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.meteoam.it/dati_in_tempo_reale Provides access to real time data per request, only for research purposes. ""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.meteoam.it/ta/previsione/5706/san_gregorio_da_sassola"",""descValue"":""Ministero della difesa, Meteo Aeronautico, Search interface, allows to get 3-day forecasts for different cities. Contains all required data ""},{""urlValue"":""https://clima.meteoam.it/RichiestaDatiGenerica.php"",""descValue"":""Ministero della difesa, Meteo Aeronautico, Archive of observations""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission was amended. All required forecast data is published online in search mask that allows to access forecasts separately by city.
Forecast data cannot be downloaded. Downloads are only available for an archive of historical data, available at: https://clima.meteoam.it/informazioni.php?type=generalita
The data is openly licensed. It can be used for free and for any purpose. There are some extended attribution clauses, which are available here: https://www.meteoam.it/page/condizioni-di-utilizzo-disclaimer
The data would have to be scraped in order to be extracted from the page. Additionally there is a data service to request data. ","A data portal provides access to real time data per request, only for research purposes. It is available at: https://www.meteoam.it/dati_in_tempo_reale ","Yes","No","anonymous","Danny Lämmerhirt","65","65"
"417cc049-6a00-454a-87f9-cbdd6f6fe813","global","2016-12-14T15:13:44","2016","fi","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No explicitly defined license""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The information is not available through a web interface with a search function. It is not provided in machine-readable form.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Information is available without registration, but not in machine-readable form.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""The website can be found with a simple searches; it is generally well known among people working in this area in the country"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Työ- ja elinkeinoministeriö"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Awards per government office"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.hankintailmoitukset.fi/fi/"",""descValue"":""Hilma: A website listing awards by national and local government""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes to submission. ","Hilma data is in https://www.hankintailmoitukset.fi/fi/, and has been at times obtained through FOI requests, but is not published as open data. Tender and award data over 120,000 Euro is available throught the European tender system TED.","Yes","No","Aleksi Knuutila","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"7da8d34d-2917-4844-ae3f-0114e306ff94","global","2016-12-16T16:01:57","2016","il","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.ims.gov.il/IMS/ODOT/TermsOfUse.htm""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""1) Data.gov.il arachive: https://ims.data.gov.il/\n\n2) XML/RSS: https://www.ims.gov.il/IMS/All_tahazit/RSSFeeds.htm""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Updates daily""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""searched \""official weather in israel\"" (Hebrew) in google. first result."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""XML and RSS are available, and so is a database with filtering options on data.gov.il.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Israel Metorological Center"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Precipitation Probability"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Precipitation Amount and Probability are available on a different page (\""Rain Radar\"": https://www.ims.gov.il/IMS/tazpiot/RainRadar.htm)""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ims.gov.il/ims/all_tahazit/"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ims.gov.il/IMSEng/All_tahazit/Model%20based%20weather%20charts/"",""descValue"":""Israel Metorological Center, Meteograms containing all required data as a GIF file. ""},{""urlValue"":""https://ims.data.gov.il/sites/default/files/isr_cities.xml"",""descValue"":""Israel Metorological Center, XML file with 3 day forecasts for 15 cities in Israel""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. As the terms of use state, the data cannot be altered: https://www.ims.gov.il/IMS/ODOT/TermsOfUse.htm. Therefore the terms of use do not comply with the OpenDefinition, the data is not openly licensed.
Thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Data is split across various places. Precipitation amount and probability are available on a different page than the rest of the forecasts (""Rain Radar"": https://www.ims.gov.il/IMS/tazpiot/RainRadar.htm)
The data can be downloaded at once: XML and RSS are available, and so is a database with filtering options on data.gov.il. 1) Data.gov.il arachive: https://ims.data.gov.il/ 2) XML/RSS: https://www.ims.gov.il/IMS/All_tahazit/RSSFeeds.htm, as well as https://ims.data.gov.il/sites/default/files/isr_cities.xml
The weather codes used in the XML file are explained in this document: https://www.ims.gov.il/NR/rdonlyres/640AB3AE-BDF8-4B82-A4BE-F56C4D21C720/0/קודיםלאתר.pdf","Yes","No","anonymous","Danny Lämmerhirt","80","80"
"cbf7b723-ad21-408f-b653-f340a649c4eb","global","2016-12-13T22:42:34","2016","im","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.gov.im/about-this-site/open-government-licence/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""OGL link in footer""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Met Office, Ronaldsway Airport, Isle of Man Government"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.im/weather/5-day-forecast/"",""descValue"":""Met Office, Ronaldsway Airport, all characteristics available in text form""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.im/weather/WeatherPdf?FiveDayForcast=1"",""descValue"":""Met Office, Ronaldsway Airport, Wind speed and direction, temperature extremes and precipitation amount in mm (downloadable as PDF)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. The data can be downloaded as PDF but it would afford human intervention first to extract the relevant information. A footer at the bottom of the page states that the data is openly licensed: the license allows to ""copy, publish, distribute and transmit the Information; adapt the Information; exploit the Information commercially and non-commercially"".
Thank you, Graeme Jones, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Graeme Jones","Danny Lämmerhirt","80","80"
"78235e38-9502-4cc4-bed1-04bf4a67666e","global","2016-12-31T21:14:38","2016","ir","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There's no data publicly available. there's data visualization on the map. \n\nyou need to officially contact the Iran Meteorological Organization by your institution, department or university.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Iran Meteorological Organization"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. There are observational weather data for wind speed/direction, temperature, and „weather“ (unclear if this includes precipitation), available at:
https://www.irimo.ir/far/wd/732-%D9%88%D8%B6%D8%B9-%D9%87%D9%88%D8%A7%DB%8C-%D8%AC%D8%A7%D8%AF%D9%87-%D8%B1%D8%A7%D9%87-%D8%A7%D8%B1%D8%A7%DA%A9-%DA%A9%D8%B1%D9%85%D8%A7%D9%86.html?road=192
Forecasts are provided for ""the coming days"" which does not specify the exact day range (see here: https://www.irimo.ir/far/wd/701-%D9%BE%DB%8C%D8%B4-%D8%A8%DB%8C%D9%86%DB%8C-%D9%88%D8%B6%D8%B9-%D9%87%D9%88%D8%A7%DB%8C-%D8%B1%D9%88%D8%AF%D8%A7%D9%86.html?id=132). This data is split into single reports per city.
Also the forecasts only provide information on temperature and general weather condition (including cloud coverage). It was not possible to detect whether there are wind forecasts provided.
Thank you, Mohammad Hossein Khani, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","There's no data publicly available. there's data visualization on the map. You need to officially contact the Iran Meteorological Organization by your institution, department or university.","Yes","No","MohammadHossein Khani","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"0b462f65-740f-48e8-b36a-59f72537aa3e","global","2016-11-22T02:37:18","2016","hk","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Go to Data.Gov.HK"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.hk/en/terms-and-conditions"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Hong Kong Observatory"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.hk/en-data/dataset/hk-hko-rss-9-day-weather-forecast"",""descValue"":""Data.gov.hk, 9-day weather forecast including all required characteristics""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.hk/en-data/dataset/hk-hko-rss-local-weather-forecast"",""descValue"":""Data.gov.hk, 2-day weather forecast (local scale)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is mostly correct. Some slight changes were made.
Open license: the XML file contains a copyright note that reads as follows
""The content available in this file, including but not limited to all text, graphics, drawings, diagrams, photographs and compilation of data or other materials are protected by copyright. The Government of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region is the owner of all copyright works contained in this website. Any reproduction, adaptation, distribution, dissemination or making available of such copyright works to the public is strictly prohibited unless prior written authorization is obtained from the Hong Kong Observatory.""
Since written authorisation is required, the data is not considered to be openly licensed (any use of data must be considered to be at the discretion of government).
Precipitation is also only fairly vaguely described (""Cloudy. Misty with one or two light rain patches at first""). Ideally precipitation amount should be published as a numerical value.
Thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Danny Lämmerhirt","80","80"
"65445883-80cc-48f1-9aa5-0d9b91a33212","global","2017-02-28T11:03:49","2016","gt","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Nacional de Sismología, Vulcanología e Hidrología"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original submission by Daniel Villatoro. Thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","There are no forecasts for two days. Therefore the data does not qualify for assessment.
Instead of a value, the Precipitation Probability is display with icons and descriptive text.
The information is at 2 different URL's. One with a very general daily forecast, and the other about the current weather data in a more detailed output. There's no forecast for the following days, instead they publish a weekly bulletin consistent of only descriptive text in a pdf format
Forecasts for precipitation are outdated and only describe weather for the following first day.
Weather forecast for current day are available at: https://www.insivumeh.gob.gt/meteorologia/bolpro.htm. Also a weather map is provided for the current day at https://www.insivumeh.gob.gt/meteorologia/mapatiempo.htm
It could not be verified whether the data is in public domain, but it is likely not to given that where is an (outdated) copyright notice at the bottom of the page.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"12035921-3cee-4e18-b1dc-5ff2be05aab3","global","2016-12-15T14:04:30","2016","gr","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""in Greek: https://www.hnms.gr/hnms/greek/legal2_html\n\nin English:\nhttps://www.hnms.gr/hnms/english/legal_html""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Users have to click on the \""Forecast\"" button the home page, then click on a fairly small button at the bottom of the page (called \""Meteogram\"") to view all data at once. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Hellenic National Meterological Service"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Precipitation Probability""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.hnms.gr/"",""descValue"":""Weather forecasts and observations for Greece.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The website provides all data at: https://www.hnms.gr/hnms/english/forecast/meteogram_city_html?dr_city=Andros
Current observations are available at: https://www.hnms.gr/hnms/english/observation/observation_region_html
The data is not openly licensed as it is stated in the terms of use:
""The content of this website is freely available for informational purposes. The Hellenic National Meteorological Service (HNMS) reserves the copyright for all material presented in these pages. Commercial use of this website, or parts of it by third parties is prohibited. For non-commercial public use of this site, authorization by the HNMS is required.""
Also manual transcriptions would be necessary to make the data usable - they are stored in an image file, embedded in HTML. That's why the submitter's original assessment of data usability was changed by the reviewer.
Thank you, Kleanthis Koupidis, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The data are not machine readable and not openly licensed","Yes","No","Kleanthis Koupidis","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"370a28e6-8fcf-418e-bff5-f252f8e00dc2","global","2017-02-02T12:04:29","2016","pe","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no information about licensing""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Started with a google search for the administrative boundaries, went to all the different results but ended in the geoservidor page. There I couldn't really find the data I was looking for and can't remember how I got to a list of all the "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio del Ambiente"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://geoservidor.minam.gob.pe/geoservidor/download.aspx"",""descValue"":""\""Geoserver\"" with maps for different subjects""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Confirmed and concur with original submitter (https://geoservidor.minam.gob.pe/geoservidor/download.aspx) that the GeoServidor page contains the needed characteristic to be downloaded under the Departmental Limit, Provincial Limit and District Limit links.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","65","65"
"67747a55-0b4b-412c-84a2-1a1bc144f168","global","2016-12-02T16:02:34","2016","py","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""2012 is the last year available ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Going to geodata portal of DGEEC"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Next to each dataset""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""i'm not sure""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Dirección General de Estadística, Encuestas y Censos"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I don't know what is level 1 and 2""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://geo.stp.gov.py/user/dgeec/datasets"",""descValue"":""General Directorate of Statistics, Surveys and Censuses Datasets""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","General Directorate of Statistics, Surveys and Censuses has the datasets with the needed characteristics. The datasets Boundary Level 1 + 2 can be found under paraguay_2012_departamentos and barrios_y_localidades.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","Yes","Lupinupa L","Michael Leow","100","100"
"420558ca-afed-46b6-8ee5-be5f01592f50","global","2016-12-28T00:32:37","2016","fr","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""GRIB2""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is only accessible through a web form piece by piece. Automating a collect and assemble of all files is quite complex""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Checked last year's index, requirements are still fulfilled"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.etalab.gouv.fr/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/Licence_Ouverte.pdf"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""While open, the GRIB format is not easily accessible, trying and just map temperatures for the next day from this data requires some experience.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Météo France"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://donneespubliques.meteofrance.fr/?fond=produit&id_produit=130&id_rubrique=51"",""descValue"":""ARPEGE Atmospheric global forecast model up to 102H""},{""urlValue"":""https://donneespubliques.meteofrance.fr/?fond=produit&id_produit=131&id_rubrique=51"",""descValue"":""AROME forecast model containing all required characteristics""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission was accepted. Thank you, Open Knowledge France, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Data is only accessible through a web form piece by piece. The files are split per hour. Automating a collection and assembling of all files is quite complex. Therefore the data is not considered to be downloadable at once.
The data is available in GRIB2 format. While open, the GRIB format is not easily accessible, trying and just map temperatures for the next day from this data requires some experience.","Yes","No","Open Knowledge","Danny Lämmerhirt","85","85"
"860d6e3e-9453-41b1-af76-865a7cd0e6a7","global","2016-12-15T21:53:41","2016","pa","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Autoridad Nacional de Administración de Tierras (ANATI) /Instituto Geográfico Nacional (IGN)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Concur with original submitter that there are no available characteristic online.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","All i found was this:
https://www.contraloria.gob.pa/INEC/archivos/0.3232691Distrital.pdf","Yes","No","Victor Díaz Navarro","Michael Leow","0","0"
"72e0be9d-d968-42f3-9b54-874fc7df9a46","global","2017-02-02T02:10:10","2016","pk","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Inter Provincial Coordination"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Concur with original submitter. The Administrative Boundaries is only available online in JPG format (https://www.pbscensus.gov.pk/sites/default/files/gis_maps/historical_1951-2017.jpg); and thus fail to fulfil the characteristics.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","0","0"
"0b04a029-6e9f-4241-babd-720f0a692060","global","2017-02-28T08:52:08","2016","do","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Oficina Nacional de Meteorología"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original submission by Miguel Reyes Taveras. Thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Forecasts are available for 3 days, but these forecasts are not updated every day, but only once a forecast range expires.
The forecast is not split per day which does not qualify for the index. It contains verbal descriptions of cloud coverage and precipitation.
In different format forecasts are available at: https://www.onamet.gov.do/?param=region_este But here wind forecasts are missing. In addition there are current observations, available at: https://186.120.187.237/ema/index.html.
The terms of use in the footer of the website do not link to a statement explaining the legal status further. Because terms of use are unclear, the data does not count as openly licensed.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"d5fba92f-e301-40c3-89ab-06d38220de8d","global","2016-12-03T17:48:18","2016","cz","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The licence restricts commercial use. CC BY-NC-ND 3.0 CZ https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/cz/""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""For a simple google search, the official site is not listed on the top, but fist on first page of search results. Navigation on the site is fairly easy, even though the UX and readability of the data is not very good."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Český hydrometeorologický ústav / Czech hydrometeorological institute"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://portal.chmi.cz/?l=en#"",""descValue"":""Czech hydrometeorological institute, 3-day forecast for the whole country""},{""urlValue"":""https://portal.chmi.cz/historicka-data/pocasi/uzemni-teploty#"",""descValue"":""Czech hydrometeorological institute, Historical data about temperatures""},{""urlValue"":""https://portal.chmi.cz/files/portal/docs/meteo/ov/aladin/results/ala.html#prec?"",""descValue"":""Czech hydrometeorological institute, Precapitations forecast""},{""urlValue"":""https://portal.chmi.cz/files/portal/docs/meteo/rad/data_jsradview.html"",""descValue"":""Czech hydrometeorological institute, Radar data""},{""urlValue"":""https://portal.chmi.cz/files/portal/docs/meteo/ov/aladin/results/ala.html#v10mmslp?"",""descValue"":""Czech hydrometeorological institute, Map with wind forecast (wind barbs)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. Data cannot be downloaded. The data also needs to be searched for in different places on the website. The data is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 3.0 CZ. This license is not open, because it does not allow for derivative work to be disseminated.
Thank you, Michaela Rybičková, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","
","Yes","No","Michaela Rybičková","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"4073c435-9860-4e01-9aa5-75295e38995a","global","2017-02-28T07:51:31","2016","hr","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Meteorological and Hydrological Service, Republic of Croatia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original submission by Arianit Dobroshi. Thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The original submission was not accepted, because not all required data characteristics are available online. The website of the Meteorological and Hydrological Service, Republic of Croatia (https://meteo.hr/index_en.php), shows forecasts with temperature extremes, wind direction and precipitation for the current day and the following day. Forecasts for the third day are available in weather maps for wind speed and precipitation, but not for temperature.
So there is no regional forecast for temperature for the third day.
Copyright notice linked to the footer link states in Croatian:
MHS is the exclusive holder of economic rights, ie. Has the right to use all graphic and text features on the website regarding reproduction, copying performance, processing and putting them on the market .","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"e57bea50-e5dd-4fdf-9b9c-bd085dc2a3a5","global","2017-02-28T07:35:17","2016","cr","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Meteorológico Nacional"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original submission by Ignacio Alfaro Marín. Thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The original submission by Ignacio Alfaro Marín was not accepted because the data found online did not qualify. Forecast data is available from the Instituto Meteorológico Nacional at https://www.imn.ac.cr/en/web/imn/inicio. It should be noted that the Spanish version of the website could not be opened at the time of the review (date: February 28, 2017).
The website provides temperature, cloud coverage, precipitation amount, and wind forecasts for the current day. Yet, forecasts are only made available for current day and the following first day, and include only some required characteristics.
Data is available in HTML, there is no download function. The data can be requested at https://www.imn.ac.cr/en/web/imn/solicitud-de-servicios, but it is not sure which data are provided through it.","Yes","No","anonymous","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"311076c3-d30d-4713-83a4-0941088fe179","global","2017-02-28T06:59:35","2016","om","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Survey Authority (NSA)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.mod.gov.om/en-US/nsa/pages/about-us.aspx""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Reject original submission as does not match characteristic of Boundary Level 1 + 2
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Reject original submission as does not match characteristic of Boundary Level 1 + 2","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","0","0"
"f5ad492f-0b23-4b30-b45c-7b3cb1fb3430","global","2016-12-15T13:37:54","2016","nir","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""DBF"",""GeoJSON"",""KML"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched on www.opendatani.gov.uk "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""All data on OpenDataNI is available under the UK Open Government Licence https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/version/2/ "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Boundary Commission for Northern Ireland "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.opendatani.gov.uk/dataset/osni-open-data-largescale-boundaries-ni-outline"",""descValue"":""Northern Ireland outline boundary (Level 1) ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.opendatani.gov.uk/dataset/osni-open-data-largescale-boundaries-district-electoral-areas-2012"",""descValue"":""Local Government Districts (Level 2) ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","All characteristics are matched for the dataset available online.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","Yes","Open DataNI","Michael Leow","100","100"
"429138e5-32b3-4b5f-a630-e5ed4cf4708c","global","2017-01-23T09:11:14","2016","nz","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""KML"",""SHP"",""WFS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search on data.govt.nz for 'boundaries', then follow first result to https://www.stats.govt.nz/browse_for_stats/Maps_and_geography/Geographic-areas/digital-boundary-files.aspx#annual"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://datafinder.stats.govt.nz/license/attribution-3-0-new-zealand/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Statistics New Zealand"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.stats.govt.nz/browse_for_stats/Maps_and_geography/Geographic-areas/digital-boundary-files.aspx"",""descValue"":""Statistics NZ Geographic boundary files""},{""urlValue"":""https://datafinder.stats.govt.nz/layer/8405-regional-council-2016-generalised-version/"",""descValue"":""Statistics NZ Data Service Regional Council 2016 Generalised Version""},{""urlValue"":""https://datafinder.stats.govt.nz/layer/8406-ward-2016-generalised-version/"",""descValue"":""Statistics NZ Data Service Ward 2016 Generalised Version""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Specifically annual boundary files. Statistics have recently added the Statistics NZ Data Service (similar to LINZ and MfE data service portals).""}]","Yes","Yes","All characteristics are matched for the dataset available online.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","I've assumed Boundary level 1 is Regional Council, and level 2 is Ward","Yes","Yes","Jonathan Hunt","Michael Leow","100","100"
"beb5045c-df18-4f4c-9271-8150f9474e5d","global","2017-02-28T06:11:34","2016","na","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" Ministry of Regional and Local Government and Housing"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.gov.na/regional-government""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original Submission:
Agency: Association for Local Authorities in Namibia
Links:
- https://www.alan.org.na/?q=localauthorities - Association for Local Authorities in Namibia
Search Steps: I google searched for about 15 minutes using different terms such as administrative boundaries Namibia, local government, place in Namibia. I finally found this source as the first result when I searched Local authorities Namibia.
Rejected original submission as the characteristic Boundary Level 1 + 2 are not available
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Rejected original submission as the characteristic Boundary Level 1 + 2 are not available","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","0","0"
"9f9e4a90-64c5-4c4f-a43a-bc6dbab95a2e","global","2017-01-27T15:26:40","2016","nl","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""GML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search for administrative boundaries and similar search terms, then digged into single websites and found the data more by chance than anything else"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.pdok.nl/nl/over-pdok/uw-speciale-aandacht/open-data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""cannot tell, because I could not open the data (no software at hand) \n\nI'm not the right user to ask""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Basisregistratie Kadaster (BRK)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""could not open the file format but assume from descriptions of the format (GML) that all data is contained""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.pdok.nl/nl/producten/pdok-downloads/basis-registratie-kadaster/bestuurlijke-grenzen-actueel"",""descValue"":""PDOK is a national service to provide data online""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Confirmed that all the characteristics are available with the GML dataset downloaded.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","Yes","Danny Lämmerhirt","Michael Leow","100","100"
"f2bee8fd-f5af-4507-956f-5c76ba562df0","global","2016-12-16T04:17:58","2016","sv","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""PDF export of basic info. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google \""compras publicas el salvador\"" (national procurement) and then it went directly to comprasal.gob.sv"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""MInistry of Finances (Ministerio de Hacienda)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.comprasal.gob.sv/comprasal_web/busqueda"",""descValue"":""COMPRASAL is the national procurement system""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Search shows information for every process in the time range selected. The query can be exported to CSV, XLS, PDF or XML, only shows institution, process code, Contract name, call for bids date and ways to submit proposals. To see details about the contracts you need to access one by one and can only see HTML version of the data. ",,"Yes","No","The Next Services","Oscar Montiel","80","80"
"b40404ac-dfe1-4296-b73f-0a57aa304a31","global","2016-12-04T21:10:32","2016","im","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""detailed map available via ESRI GIS portal with geolocation prompt and option to select constituency and local authority but no option to download data""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search Maps under site:gov.im; the first page shows Maps page"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.gov.im/about-this-site/open-government-licence/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Infrastructure Mapping Service"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.gov.im/categories/planning-and-building-control/mapping/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.im/maps/"",""descValue"":""Maps page""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The characteristic is available for view only. However, the dataset cannot be downloaded.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Graeme Jones","Michael Leow","65","65"
"62b81bd1-60dc-4f3c-86f9-e51fed5582e5","global","2017-02-28T02:35:42","2016","id","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Geospatial Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original Submitter:
Agency: National Geospatial Agency
Links:
https://tanahair.indonesia.go.id/home/download_rbi/download_250K_bataswilayah.html - Indonesia national boundaries map
Search steps: I have prior knowledge and I can find it through google search
Rejected submission as characteristic Boundary Level 1 + 2 not available for download.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Rejected submission as characteristic Boundary Level 1 + 2 not available for download.","Yes","No","Michael Leow","Michael Leow","0","0"
"35d2d2a9-dcc9-4224-9af1-850952582d64","global","2016-11-27T19:00:23","2016","cz","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Missing an explicit licence""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Follow the \""open data\"" link on the official website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of interior of the Czech Republic"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.isvz.cz/ISVZ/Podpora/ISVZ_open_data_vz.aspx"",""descValue"":""XML dumps partitioned per year for the official public procurement register and electronic marketplaces""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.isvz.cz/ISVZ/VZ/ProfilyZadavatelu.aspx"",""descValue"":""Profiles of contracting authorities publishing feeds of procurement data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes in the submission. Dataset is not clean enough to use easily.
","The dataset's quality is low. Important information, such as business entity identifiers, is missing, while other data is duplicated, such as postal addresses, which makes the data difficult to reconcile and fuse.","Yes","No","Jindřich Mynarz","Oscar Montiel","80","80"
"0daee55f-2360-48ea-8665-c19cb2b9744f","global","2016-12-09T09:20:17","2016","hr","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF , HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried a web search engine for Central Public Procurement"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Centar State Office for Central public Procurement"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.sredisnjanabava.hr/registar-ugovora"",""descValue"":""Register of Centar State Office for Central public Procurement""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","You can find the current and past processes here https://www.sredisnjanabava.hr/postupci-javne-nabave. The link provided takes you to the archive of the procedures to procure.
",,"Yes","No","Zoran Lusha","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"59b25225-5e4f-4876-b3a8-5b20fc4ab237","global","2016-11-25T20:24:24","2016","br","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is not downloadable in any format.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The dataset is not downloadable. I could only navigate in the platform to get data from every city, but I could not download it.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""I filled the survey at 16h30. INPE platform had its last update at 14h and INMET at 16h of the same day.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""If you google \""weather forecast brazil\"" you get both websites after other non-governmental references like \""climatempo\"". Then you just have to search for a specific city.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google \""weather forecast brazil\"" 2) Get both websites 3) Search for a specific city."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.inmet.gov.br/portal/index.php?r=home/page&page=termo_uso"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""For INMET, the link provided shows the terms and conditions for using the data, where it is stated that \""the replication and publishing of public content is permitted only if the source is quoted with title and author\"".\nFor INPE, the main webpage footer (https://www.cptec.inpe.br/) states that \""the users must always mention the source of information and data as CPTEC/INPE\"".\nBut I couldn't find a specific license for none of the sources.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""To make informational use, the platform displays data quite easily. But if you want to do anything more complex than that it is not possible because the data is not downloadable.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""INPE - Instituto Nacional de Pesquisas Espaciais; INMET - Instituto Nacional de Meteorologia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There are two different data sources in this case. The data is not the same, though (if you search the same city in the two platforms, the results are different).\nINPE is the National Institute for Spatial Research, associated to the brazilian Ministry of Science, Technology, Innovation and Communications.\nINMET is the National Institute for Meteorology, associated to the brazilian Ministry of Agriculture, Livestock and Supply.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Precipitation Probability"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Both platforms lack information on temperature average (only extremes are shown) and precipitation amount (only probability is shown).\nThe wind speed is shown at INPE platform, but not at INMET.\nAll the information is provided for the current day and the next four days in both platforms.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://tempo.cptec.inpe.br/"",""descValue"":""INPE platform to get weather forecast for every city in Brazil.""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.inmet.gov.br/portal/"",""descValue"":""INMET platform to get weather forecast for every city in Brazil.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Both links provide the same kind of information, but due to measurement differences, they are not exactly the same.\nNone of them offers files to download.""}]","Yes","Yes","The INMEP states that public information can be republished freely. However, it becomes not clear whether weather data is public information or not. Also it becomes not clear whether data can be compiled or modified. Therefore it was answered that the data is not openly licensed.
Thank you, Wagner Faria de Oliveira, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","There are two different data sources in this case. The data is not the same, though (if you search the same city in the two platforms, the results are different).
INPE is the National Institute for Spatial Research, associated to the brazilian Ministry of Science, Technology, Innovation and Communications.
INMET is the National Institute for Meteorology, associated to the brazilian Ministry of Agriculture, Livestock and Supply.
Both links provide the same kind of information, but due to measurement differences, they are not exactly the same.
None of them offers files to download.
To make informational use, the platform displays data quite easily. But if you want to do anything more complex than that it is not possible because the data is not downloadable.
This year survey doesn't demand information on historical data but only forecasts.
For historical data, it is possible to retrieve information per measurement station, hourly, through the link https://www.inmet.gov.br/sonabra/pg_dspDadosCodigo_sim.php?QTUxMw==
Time series are provided in this link: https://www.inmet.gov.br/portal/index.php?r=estacoes/estacoesConvencionais
There is also a database that requires login and password to access it, but it is for free. You only have to register. It is called BDMEP (Banco de dados meteorológicos para ensino e pesquisa - Meteorological Database for Education and Research). The link is https://www.inmet.gov.br/portal/index.php?r=bdmep/bdmep","Yes","No","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Danny Lämmerhirt","65","65"
"095327ef-c077-4f97-a749-e5b07392f985","global","2016-12-21T14:29:43","2016","cl","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""open the main page"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""direccion meteorologica de chile"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.meteochile.cl/PortalDMC-web/index.xhtml"",""descValue"":""Dirección Meteorológica de Chile, main page""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.meteochile.cl/PortalDMC-web/index.xhtml#"",""descValue"":""Dirección Meteorológica de Chile, weather maps containing all required data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is valid. No terms of use could be found that state that the data is freely usable, or is protected. Given this unclarity the data does not count as openly licensed.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"a2fc2e7d-f98b-4ae2-983a-8b18da3ff518","global","2017-01-12T22:14:27","2016","za","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""JPEG., PDF, GIF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data can""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""A quick google search of weather forecast data South Africa led me to the website found on the first result."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""South African Weather Services"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Precipitation Probability"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.weathersa.co.za/"",""descValue"":""South African Weather Services""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.weathersa.co.za/home/city-pages#forecasttitle"",""descValue"":""South African Weather Services, Forecasts for cities,""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The website of the South African Weather Services is quite easy to navigate through. On a weather map it is possible to click to single regions. Detailed forecast data are available for singe regions: e.g. here: https://www.weathersa.co.za/home/city-pages#forecasttitle.
The submission was accepted with some slight changes. Data can be requested, but this does not qualify as being downloadable. Therefore the original submission was amended.
The forecast icons (such as cloud coverage,) are embedded in HTML. They are uploaded as single items and could individually be scraped.
The site with terms of use was empty at the date of review (Feb, 27, 2017). See here: https://www.weathersa.co.za/credits-legal.
Thank you, Tricia Govindasamy, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"f660448c-077a-4067-9fc9-0523704fe8c5","global","2016-12-15T14:29:54","2016","my","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Election Commission of Malaysia and Department of Survey and Mapping Malaysia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Concur with original submitter that there are no online datasets to be downloaded.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Hazwany Jamaluddin","Michael Leow","0","0"
"f89d6d2b-bfd4-4a42-8aec-e6664b0c1425","global","2016-12-13T07:47:36","2016","lv","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is under copyright.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Viewable online only; download will be chargeable.""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search in google. Go to https://map.lgia.gov.lv/?lang=2; click on \""Maps\""; click on \""Map Browser\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Latvian Geospatial Information Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://map.lgia.gov.lv/index.php?lang=2&cPath=4_44&txt_id=112""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.vzd.gov.lv/lv/pakalpojumi/datu-izsniegsanas-pakalpojumi/valsts-adresu-registra-dai/admin-robezu-wfs"",""descValue"":""product description, pricing, how to request data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.kadastrs.lv/arcgis/services/wfs_admin_terit/MapServer/WFSServer"",""descValue"":""Link to WFS service""},{""urlValue"":""https://kartes.lgia.gov.lv/karte/"",""descValue"":""Administrative Boundaries Map Viewer""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The characteristic are available found online at (https://kartes.lgia.gov.lv/karte/) by selecting the Administrative Boundaries category.
However, the data is not downloadable without making a purchase.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Pēteris Brūns","Michael Leow","45","45"
"cf26a757-1d3d-4d5d-b093-7ad93b70279b","global","2017-01-16T19:46:54","2016","ls","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Lesotho Bureau of Statistics"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""www.bos.gov.ls""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Agency responsible for ""Administrative Boundaries"" is identified as Lesotho Bureau of Statistics (www.bos.gov.ls). However, there are no datasets available online.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Michael Leow","0","0"
"19801bd9-4060-445d-b16d-081fecefb116","global","2017-01-17T15:46:17","2016","mw","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Lands, Housing and Urban Development"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""www.lands.gov.mw/index.php/departments/surveys.html""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Agency Ministry of Lands, Housing and Urban Development (www.lands.gov.mw/index.php/departments/surveys.html) is identified as responsible but there is no available data online.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Michael Leow","0","0"
"bb710a58-eb43-4d93-9333-71c2a5953e10","global","2016-11-29T17:38:11","2016","mk","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No available open formats.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Needs to buy the dataset for it to be downloadable.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Administrative division of Republic of Macedonia can be ordered for a fee https://www.katastar.gov.mk/en/Page.aspx?Id=474&m=1569""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Able to view it online; restricted in downloading.""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Go to the page \""Real Estate Cadastre Agency\""; click on the AREC - GIS Portal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Real Estate Cadastre Agency of the Republic of Macedonia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.katastar.gov.mk/en/Page.aspx?Id=474&m=1569""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://ossp.katastar.gov.mk/OSSP/faces/public/customMaps/administrativeBorders.xhtml#"",""descValue"":""AREC - GIS Portal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.katastar.gov.mk/en/Default.aspx - Go to the link AREC - GIS Portal""}]","Yes","Yes","Confirmed that the dataset is available online for viewing and it has the characteristics.
However, in order to download the dataset, there needs to be payment; so the dataset is not considered to be downloadable.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","45","45"
"67eff296-67d1-4086-b424-ee789c3f656b","global","2017-01-27T16:55:52","2016","ke","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of lands and physical planning"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Concur with original submitter that there is no available dataset online.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","No official records are available online. One would have to purchase them from the Ministry of Lands","Yes","No","Serah Rono","Michael Leow","0","0"
"4840d460-6967-4077-835d-58ea4f95bf62","global","2017-02-27T07:35:47","2016","ir","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Interior affairs (Ministry of State)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original submission rejected because missing characteristic Boundary Level 1 + 2. There is no available online dataset.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Original submission rejected because missing characteristic Boundary Level 1 + 2.","Yes","No","Michael Leow","Michael Leow","0","0"
"28cf974d-8043-406f-a993-4a810e656668","global","2017-02-01T04:31:00","2016","in","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Boundaries mostly available in PDF ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""You can't find all the boundaries in one place the closest is the Bhuvan portal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.mygov.in/sites/default/files/mygov_1466767582190667.pdf"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Open for use by commercial + non-commercial.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Survey of India"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Not available in a central place. Available at the local level. ""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.surveyofindia.gov.in/pages/show/86-mapsdata"",""descValue"":""Survey of India maps""},{""urlValue"":""https://bhuvan.nrsc.gov.in/bhuvan_links.php"",""descValue"":""GIS web portal with administrative boundaries""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Characteristic is available for view ""Administrative Layers""
https://bhuvan.nrsc.gov.in/gis/thematic/index.php#
However, the dataset is not available to be downloaded online.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Michael Leow","65","65"
"b258364f-89e0-4a97-9735-990bc91b4e7c","global","2017-01-19T16:55:14","2016","mz","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Concur with original submitter that no agency information in charge of the ""Administrative Boundaries"" could be found.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Michael Leow","0","0"
"5894d8f3-f8b8-4a8e-ac34-bf806ea9d9e5","global","2016-12-31T09:29:39","2016","mm","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Survey Department"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.surveydepartment.gov.mm/eng/?q=about""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""There is no information nor evidence shown that the Myanmar President's Office is collecting the data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The official website to the Myanmar President's Officer https://www.president-office.gov.mm/en/""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The Survey Department is the agency in charge (https://www.surveydepartment.gov.mm/eng/?q=about). However, no dataset is available online.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","There are no evidence to confirm that the data exist.","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","0","0"
"8bb584a4-5372-4b36-92cd-ad46b4bdb123","global","2016-12-15T19:47:14","2016","gr","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""RDF"",""SHP"",""SHX"",""WFS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google Search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://geodata.gov.gr/dataset/oria-demon-kallikrates/resource/1f27353b-8a99-4bb6-b78e-51dd8bd10c6c"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Lands and Mapping Agency Greece"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://geodata.gov.gr/dataset/oria-demon-kallikrates"",""descValue"":""Municipalities boundaries of Greece""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The characteristics are available in the dataset in WFS.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","Yes","Notis Filippidis","Michael Leow","100","100"
"e38c4499-37f2-4603-aed0-fa92e3611658","global","2017-02-27T03:42:30","2016","sk","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Statistical Office of the Slovak Republic"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Elections and Referendum results are all available through the website, but not all data is available. Presidential elections do not show invalid or spoiled ballots results, although it is possible to calculate invalid votes. Latest Parliamentary elections (2016) also available and dowloadable in XLXS & ODS format. Results are available for electoral and territorial districts and municipalities. While licensing is not stated on the official portal, all datasets are registered on National Data portal (data.gov.sk) where license (CC-BA-SA) is stated.
(https://opendefinition.org/licenses/cc-by-sa/).
","Elections and Referendum results are all available through the website, but not all data is available. Presidential elections do not show invalid or spoiled ballots results, although it is possible to calculate invalid votes. Latest Parliamentary elections (2016) also available and dowloadable in XLXS & ODS format. Results are available for electoral and territorial districts and municipalities. While licensing is not stated on the official portal, all datasets are registered on National Data portal (data.gov.sk) where license (CC-BA-SA) is stated.
(https://opendefinition.org/licenses/cc-by-sa/).
","Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"bb751949-4f61-47e5-9fc9-4a5b28ab3c5b","global","2016-12-10T16:54:49","2016","pt","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No information about licensing that I know.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The documents are available but have to be downloaded one by one.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Draft legislation is undoubtedly easier to find than National legislation. The site is easier to navigate and offers language options in Portuguese, English and French. ""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Just go to the main site and click on \""Legislative Process\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Assembleia da República"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""All data is present. But knowledge of Portuguese would be an asset in conducting a search of this website. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.parlamento.pt/ActividadeParlamentar/Paginas/default.aspx"",""descValue"":""Legislative process""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"A much better experience in browsing and searching draft legislation than attempting to search the national legislation. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Brenna Slawich","45","45"
"29238d6a-fa20-48c9-8e3d-6a113d8b4081","global","2016-12-10T17:11:02","2016","pt","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No licensing information.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""TXT""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""You have to get each document one by one.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Daily.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There's a paid version of the site that has consolidate laws.""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is not searchable, the site has upwards of 1.6 milion documents. If you do not know exactly what document to retrieve, you'll not be able to find it.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""They do not have a search interface to find the data. You need to know the document type and number, or the date in which it was published."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The government announced that it will upgrade the site to have basic search capabilities. ""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""A great deal of effort is required in order to find anything that you may need on this website. Knowledge of Portuguese would be an asset as well. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""INCM - Imprensa Nacional Casa da Moeda"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The amendments aren't attached to each law. We do not have consolidate laws available to the public.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://dre.pt"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Option to switch site's language to either Portuguese or English, making the site easier to decipher. ""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The government has announced an upgrade to the current site that will address some of the problems with the current one. It should be on-line early next year.","Yes","No","anonymous","Brenna Slawich","65","65"
"a9de9237-2133-4308-b506-5fa73d2e5b93","global","2017-02-26T14:06:29","2016","om","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Directorate General of Meteorology"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Not all required data is considered to be uploaded online, because wind strength and direction are not included in the forecasts for the following two days.
The website contains verbal and iconic forecasts. The forecasts for ""Oman Cities"" are in HTML, well-structured and the icons embedded in HTML are named in a way that makes them easily understandable if automatically retrieved.
There is no download function. Some of the forecast icons (precipitation) make it hard to assess how much rain is going to fall (they are generic statements that rain is gonna fall).
There is only a copyright notification, but no open license. The terms of use are unclear. The data does not qualify as openly licensed.","Directorate General of Meteorology provides a lot of climate data to the public. The website has a section for providing simple weather details for specific cities in Oman and shows the temperature changes for the next three (not five) days for each city. ( https://www.met.gov.om/opencms/export/sites/default/dgman/en/weather-chart/oman-cities/index.html ) There is a section for historic data for the past 12 months. The website also has a more elaborate interactive map that allows the user to overlay different weather layers and playback the predicted changes for several future days. ( https://www.met.gov.om/opencms/export/sites/default/dgman/en/weather-chart/map-data/ ) The website is difficult to navigate and browsing by map is not intuitive and very slow. Also, the raw data does not appear to be available for download directly.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"6ac22fa0-9927-4afb-8204-ad3fc0536390","global","2017-02-26T12:41:04","2016","bg","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Institut of Meteorology and Hydrology"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No further comments to add","The submission did not qualify for assessment, because no forecasts are available for wind speed and direction.
The data is available at: https://weather.bg/0index.php?koiFail=RM2bulg1&lng=1. The data is stored as a PNG file embedded in the HTML code. Single elements (precipitation icons, etc.) cannot be individually scraped. Extensive human effort would be required to transcribe the data manually.
The data can only be used for private use:
""© NIMH. All rights reserved. For personal use only! Any usage of data from Bulgarian Weather Server in public information services or for commercial purposes without explicit agreement IS PROHIBITED!""
The original submission was done by Drenusha Myha. Thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"41206225-4c63-4ecf-be89-0223b40c1f57","global","2016-12-05T13:03:02","2016","be","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.meteo.be/meteo/view/nl/506883-Algemene+voorwaarden.html""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""On the website the forecasts can directly be found at a subpage. There is a range of data services, which can be accessed from the homepage too."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""KMI"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.meteo.be/meteo/view/nl/65656-Weer.html"",""descValue"":""KMI, primary forecast website, containing all required elements""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.meteo.be/meteo/view/nl/14517220-Weerbericht+op+uw+site.html"",""descValue"":""KMI, Data services page, (javascript) widget""},{""urlValue"":""https://opendata.meteo.be"",""descValue"":""KMI, Open Data Catalogue, is currently being populated""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. The data is available on a website as weather map. The data is easily understandable and usable by humans. However, the data is only available in HTML and scraping is needed to automatically retrieve the data.
The data is not openly licensed. Also data services (such as embedding forecast widgets on third-party websites) fall under restrictive terms of use, and it is not allowed to disseminate the information contained on the website. See the terms of use here: https://www.meteo.be/meteo/view/nl/506883-Algemene+voorwaarden.html
After request, the team of https://opendata.meteo.be got back, reporting that currently an open weather data portal is being built. At time of the review the required data was not available on the portal.
Thank you, Bart Hanssens, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Bart Hanssens","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"40943e09-d916-4939-bb9d-704fd56afe0d","global","2017-02-17T18:30:47","2016","sv","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Gerencia de Meteorología. Management of Meteorology"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No further comments to add.","The original submission was rejected because forecast data is not available for all required data characteristics.
Current measurements and 24 hours forecasts are available in different heat maps at this URL: https://www.snet.gob.sv/ver/meteorologia/pronostico/pronostico+numerico/salidas+wrf/ These maps are not downloadable, and the heat map does not contain a legend that would explain the values. Forecast maps presenting precipitation symbols etc. are provided here: https://www.snet.gob.sv/ver/meteorologia/pronostico/48+horas/
The data is not downloadable, and data are scattered across the website. Significant human effort would be needed to transfer the data into a form to parse it.
The copyright is unclear. There is a disclaimer at the footer of the website, stating ""Todos los derechos reservados.
El MARN permite la reproducción total o parcial de la información,
agradeciendo de antemano consignar la fuente, así como su período de validez."" However, the exact terms of use are not clear
The original submission was provided by The Next Services. Thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"a7b27f1b-7308-4b68-87af-0404d2aa578d","global","2017-02-26T12:07:17","2016","mw","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Malawi Meteorological Services"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No further comments to add","The initial submission was amended. It stated that temperature extremes, averages, and precipitation are available online.
However, it was found that the Malawi Meterological Services provide 24h forecast for temperature extremes and cloud coverage/precipitation, wind speed and direction at https://www.metmalawi.com/weather/weather_24h.php as well as at https://www.metmalawi.com/weather/5day_forecast.php.
The forecasts are split into regions. 5-day forecasts are not separated into different days, but the website gives trends how the weather will develop in areas. Since the forecast is not very exact, not split into different days, and does not contain precipitation amount (at the date of review), it was decided that the submission does not qualify for assessment.
Thank you, Tricia Govindasamy, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"b472c6f2-9495-4865-998f-156269b1883a","global","2016-12-06T03:01:21","2016","jp","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Published under Open Government License 2.0 of Japan.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""GML"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Must select each municipality 1 by 1.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Updated with statistics data. National Statistics or Major Census are carried out every 3 or 5 year.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Slight tricky.\n\n1. open estat page.\n2. go to \""download statistics\""\n3. select municipality and click \""検索/search\""\n4. boundary data would be shown at right side box.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""see comment of B2.2. Administrative boundary data is downloadable with statistics data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.e-stat.go.jp/estat/html/spec.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""English version.\n(guideline style. modified by each ministry)\n\nhttps://www.kantei.go.jp/jp/singi/it2/densi/kettei/gl2_betten_1_en.pdf""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is provided by each municipality.\nSo if someone need the data of whole nation, he should download 1800 over data one by one and concatenate them.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications, Statistics Bureau.\n\""総務省 統計局\"" in Japanese.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://e-stat.go.jp/SG2/eStatGIS/page/download.html#"",""descValue"":""Download statistics and boundary data of each local government.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The following option needs to be selected to be brought to the right download page:
農林業センサス -> 年農林業センサス-農山村地域調査(農山村地域調査) -> 法制上の地域指定
Concur with submitter that for every Prefecture, there is one dataset to be downloaded. Thus, it is not downloadable at once.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","last year, I made entry of Kokudo Suuchi Joho (国土数値情報) administrative boundary dataset.
It changed their license to restrict the use.
https://nlftp.mlit.go.jp/ksj/gml/datalist/KsjTmplt-N03-v2_3.html","Yes","No","Satoshi IIDA","Michael Leow","85","85"
"1f939a0d-fd12-4bc7-992a-997f837f31c5","global","2016-12-17T14:28:39","2016","de","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX"",""WFS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bundesamt für Kartographie und Geodäsie"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.geodatenzentrum.de/geodaten/gdz_rahmen.gdz_div?gdz_spr=deu&gdz_akt_zeile=5&gdz_anz_zeile=1&gdz_unt_zeile=14&gdz_user_id=0"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","All characteristics are matched by the dataset, is free and easily downloadable.
The only item missing is an open license; the Geodata Access Law only covers non-commercial.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","other tool
https://github.com/opendatalab-de/simple-geodata-selector
based on that","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","80","80"
"7c8c0536-89d0-4db1-bd8e-52d8b9e8293d","global","2017-02-26T05:04:01","2016","il","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Survey of Israel"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original Submitter:
Agency: Survey of Israel
Link:
- https://data.gov.il/dataset/828/resource/74c34951-a350-4cab-bb79-68deb01d422b - data.gov.il website
Steps to find: searched on google but could not find a relevant source (except for the ministry of interior graphic system, without the ability to download the raw data). First result in data.gov.il.
License: https://data.gov.il/terms
Rejected original submission as unable to find Boundary 1 + 2.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Reject original submission as unable to find Boundary 1 + 2","Yes","No","Michael Leow","Michael Leow","0","0"
"dae2257f-139d-4efe-970b-50dee23f640d","global","2016-12-08T20:57:58","2016","it","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""istat"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""CC-BY - https://www.istat.it/it/note-legali"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""ISTAT"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.istat.it/it/archivio/124086"",""descValue"":""confini delle unità amministrative a fini statistici""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Data for all characteristic are available along with an open license.
Added extra open format SHX + DBF to shapefiles.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Dat",,"Yes","Yes","Maurizio Napolitano","Michael Leow","100","100"
"0af05caf-8cd5-49ca-bccf-4a18d780a7b7","global","2017-02-25T22:38:40","2016","ko","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Content of bills is found on https://www.kuvendikosoves.org/?cid=1,194,162.\nThe only characteristic that is available is the content of bills. The other required characteristics, status of bills and author of bills are not found. The optional characteristics, transcripts and votes on bills are not available either. For this reason B2 is being answered with NO.\n\n""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Kuvendi i Kosoves"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission was rejected. This submission more accurately indicates that data published by government is missing the required characteristics. ","The original submission was rejected for the following two reasons: 1) it was based on an URL which led to laws, not bills. As a reviewer I was able to locate the URL where the content of bills was found (I have noted in the comments). 2) The original submission had incorrectly answered B2 with yes (it had stated that content and author of bills was available). B2 should be answered with a NO because two required characteristics are missing.","Yes","No","Juela Xhaferraj","Juela Xhaferraj","0","0"
"3d5f6ae2-9ac8-4513-aea4-eb50c5b82c85","global","2016-12-24T09:12:45","2016","il","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Rights are reserved by the State of Israel. ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""[Original submission] bills and protocols published in DOC files. Synchronized protocols required Microsoft Silverlght plugin.\n[ Reviewer comments] The text of the bills is available in PDF and Doc. formats.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The content of bills and status are up to date. However the transcript on debates is not always up to date. For example, a debate that occurred on Feb.13, 2017 was not available on Feb. 25, 2017 (the page indicated that the debate occurred, but its text was not available).""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1. Searched for \""legalisation\"" or \""draft legalisation\"" (in Hebrew) on google, got diretle to the database or to the old site which referred to the new database. 2. Clicked on \""Draft Legalisation\"" tab."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Knesset (Isralei parlieamnet)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""[Original submitter comment] votes on bill can be reached separately at https://www.knesset.gov.il/vote/heb/vote_search.asp \n[Reviewer comment] I was able to find all the characteristics from the first URL listed on B2.2). The original submitter had marked \""votes on bills\"" as missing because the data is found on another page (as is indicated by the original comment above). As a reviewer, I changed the submission to indicate that votes are present since they the government still makes the data available, even though it's on a separate page. I have added the URL for this page in B2.2""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://main.knesset.gov.il/Activity/Legislation/Laws/Pages/LawSuggestionsSearch.aspx?t=LawSuggestionsSearch&st=CurrentKnesset"",""descValue"":""The Knesset Offficial Website (National Legalisatoin Database)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.knesset.gov.il/vote/heb/vote_search.asp "",""descValue"":""Record of Votes""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""As a reviewer I have added the URL where the record of votes are found (the URL was indicated by original reviewer on the comments section).\n""}]","Yes","Yes","I am accepting this submission because all the characteristics could be found in the dataset. ","The only change I made was that I indicated that ""votes on bills"" were available. I believe that the information should be marked as available even though it is found on a separate page.
I made no changes to B6 even though transcripts may not always be up to date. I made this decision because transcripts are an optional characteristic in the first place. All the required characteristics were up to date. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Juela Xhaferraj","45","45"
"c068421a-e1cb-4b81-b514-318a96f1dcb2","global","2017-02-25T21:05:22","2016","gt","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The original submission included the following link where the information was found.\nhttps://old.congreso.gob.gt/Legislacion/iniciativa.asp\nThe original submission was rejected because the link did not work after being tested on three different days. \nTherefore, the information is not available online because it cannot be accessed.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Congress of Guatemala"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission was rejected because the link was broken. This submission reflects the fact that the data is not provided online. ","The original submission was rejected because the link was broken. The original submission included the following information.
Characteristics: Content of bill, author of bill
Free of charge: Yes
Downloadable at once: No
Up to date: Yes
Free domain: No
Machine Readable format: NO (PDF only)
","Yes","No","Juela Xhaferraj","Juela Xhaferraj","0","0"
"5517306d-984c-432e-958d-e94de9ccef22","global","2016-12-05T14:20:38","2016","np","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""TXT""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Available as PDFs online in the Nepalese language. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The dataset is downloadable on a one by one basis. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Department of Printing is easily found though the Parliament of Nepal's website can be difficult to find. ""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Online search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It did take extensive effort to find the Parliament of Nepal's website but once found, it is easily navigable. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Legislature's Parliament of Nepal & Ministry of Information and Communication Department of Printing"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.dop.gov.np/downloads.php"",""descValue"":"" Department of Printing's website""},{""urlValue"":""https://parliament.gov.np/np/bills/registered-bills.html"",""descValue"":""Legislature's Parliament of Nepal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Downloads from the Department of Printing is only available in Nepalese. The Parliament of Nepal also has the registered bill available in Nepalese. ""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The information was eventually found but a good translator or knowledge of the Nepalese language is recommended to get the best use of the information. ","Yes","No","Shubham Ghimire","Brenna Slawich","50","50"
"56180a84-95a3-442c-ad85-dc753c4b26fc","global","2016-12-07T12:00:06","2016","np","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""TXT""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Available as PDFs online as you download them. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is only downloadable one act at a time. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""I can confirm that the data is free to all without needing to register or request access. ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The site is fairly easy to navigate and finding the archives for laws is easy. ""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Online search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Nepal Law Commission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""As an example, the Agricultural Development Bank Act comes with a listing showing all amendments that have been made to date since the law was first enacted in 1971. \n""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.lawcommission.gov.np/documents/"",""descValue"":""Nepal Law Commission's website""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The national laws of Nepal are easily found and are searchable for the public. However, as the submitter notes, the data is only downloadable one act at a time and is not necessarily updated at regular intervals. ","Yes","No","Shubham Ghimire","Brenna Slawich","50","50"
"a0dde406-d4da-4d56-a5fa-74c5eee2e92c","global","2016-12-13T23:04:54","2016","im","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Downloadable PDF file. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""google search: isle of man bills"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.gov.im/about-this-site/open-government-licence/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""link in government website footer\n""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Isle of Man Parliament"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Also available through a specialized site known as Isle of Man Legislation: https://www.legislation.gov.im/cms/. ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""transcripts of debates on bill available via the existing hansard search, look up the relevant chamber consideration dates via the votes and proceedings summary document:\nhttps://www.tynwald.org.im/business/vp/Pages/ByYear19972020.aspx\n\nvotes in sitting transcript\n""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.tynwald.org.im/business/bills/Pages/default.aspx"",""descValue"":""Bills in Progress""},{""urlValue"":""https://legislation.gov.im/cms/en/2013-07-08-02-47-45/bills-by-year.html"",""descValue"":""Found in side bar titled: \""Recent bills introduced into Tynwald\""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""also presented by HM Attorney Generals' Chambers:\nhttps://legislation.gov.im/cms/en/2013-07-08-02-47-45/bills-by-year.html\n""}]","Yes","Yes",,"A little harder to find the draft legislation if you try to search out the Isle of Man Parliament but the search through Isle of Man Legislation does make the search much easier. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Brenna Slawich","80","80"
"1ecf910c-b2fa-4fa3-b580-2c5cd1713867","global","2016-12-04T19:41:39","2016","im","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""the legislation system is actually XML based but presented in PDF (but hopefully with an XML option in 2017)""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Very much agreed. Other legislatures might consider adopting this very accessible web site navigation and data model. ""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""google -- isle of man legislation"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.gov.im/about-this-site/open-government-licence/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""footer notice and link""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""HM Attorney Generals' Chambers"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""An examination of one of the recent acts (the Marriage and Civil Partnership Amendment Act of 2016), demonstrates that this model is followed in the publication of this important data online. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://legislation.gov.im/cms/en/"",""descValue"":""Isle of Man Legislation""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The site is very easy to navigate and includes a very handy set of side bars that highlights New Acts, Updated Acts, New Appointed Day Orders, and Draft Legislation that has been introduced. ""}]","Yes","Yes",,"I have found this site to be one of the most accessible that I have reviewed to date. Flaws aside in locating data, as noted by the submitter, I would certainly believe that this model is a firm and dedicated step in the right direction of open data for governments. ","Yes","No","Graeme Jones","Brenna Slawich","65","65"
"06a291d7-8776-4e17-9559-f8ac88fe3acb","global","2016-12-05T11:20:48","2016","jp","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Run a work search with \""Company Registration (in Japanese)\"" or \""Company Number\"", then we can identify the sites listed above easily."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""NTA's Terms of Use, which is fully compatible with CC-BY 4.0: https://www.houjin-bangou.nta.go.jp/riyokiyaku/; METI's Terms of Use, which is fully compatible with CC-BY 4.0: https://www.meti.go.jp/main/rules.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Justice (MOJ); National Tax Agency (NTA), Ministry of Finance; and Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry (METI)."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.houjin-bangou.nta.go.jp/"",""descValue"":""NTA's company number, name and address information site.""},{""urlValue"":""https://biz-portal.datameti.go.jp/hojin/TopPage"",""descValue"":""METI's company number, name and company activities site.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
Company Name, Address and Corporation Number are available to download at once for free in .XML and .CSV formats in a .ZIP file on the National Tax Agency Corporation Number Publication Site: ""On this site, we provide the latest information on corporations publicly announced as of the end of the previous month as a data file of all cases, information specifying a new corporate number of newly established corporations, etc., the date of change and closing of trade name and location The following change information is provided as a difference data file."" One can download differential data (nationwide) https://www.houjin-bangou.nta.go.jp/download/ or all data (by prefecture) https://www.houjin-bangou.nta.go.jp/download/zenken/
Corporate activity information (Notification information, recognition information, subsidy information, and procurement information held by the government) is also available for free in .CSV format on the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry - Corporate Info website. Data is downloadable at once and updated every end of the month https://hojin-info.go.jp/hojin/TopPage
Lastly, ""any information published on the National Tax Agency corporate number publication site and on the website of the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry (METI) can be used freely, such as copying, public transmission, translation, transformation etc. Commercial use is also possible. In addition, since numerical data, simple tables, graphs, etc. are not subject to copyright, these usage rules are not applicable for these, so you can use them freely.""",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","100","100"
"b38d80a5-3c58-4515-9ba1-fd9c330a78ae","global","2017-01-16T21:01:47","2016","jm","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name or registration number of an entity in order to find it.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""By entering the keywords \""company register of jamaica\"" the Companies Office of jamaica's website was included in the Google results. From there i visited the site and was able to lookup companies by name"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Companies Office of Jamaica"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.orcjamaica.com/"",""descValue"":""Companies Office of Jamaica""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.orcjamaica.com/CompanySearch.aspx?cId1=1bb41e18-5b35-4265-96b1-f93acd97f644"",""descValue"":"" Document Request — Company/Organization Search""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The Companies Office hosts the register of companies however data can only be viewed by entering the name of the company on the website. From there a Company number, name, director, address and other details can be viewed.
One can conduct a Company Search on the Companies Office of Jamaica website where data are available for free in .HTML format, but through a search mask so one needs to know an entity's name or registration number in order to find it. Data include registration number, entity name, director/ proprietor/ shareholder/ company secretary, status, entity type. and when registered/ incorporated. Data cannot be downloaded at once and update frequency is not specified.
https://www.orcjamaica.com/CompanySearch.aspx?cId1=1bb41e18-5b35-4265-96b1-f93acd97f644","The Companies Office host the register of companies however they can only be viewed by entering the name of the company on the website. From there a Company number, name, director, address and other details can be viewed ","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Evangelia Kampouri","15","15"
"63854cdb-3f1d-4c03-9539-b22495bb6add","global","2016-12-08T20:22:19","2016","it","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""you see only an information of a company without registration and in html output""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""the register of the companies is one of the more requested data of italy "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Camera di Commercio"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.registroimprese.it/"",""descValue"":""Registro Imprese""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
It seems that all four required characteristics are available online when registered with the business register and for a fee. The business register of the Italian Chambers of Commerce website (www.registroimprese.it) offers an online service to access information in .HTML format about the companies in the Italian Business Register. The service is available for companies and the general public, exclusively for demonstration and promotional purposes. The information is freely available and includes a company profile, limited to some basic company data. More specifically, the free company data produced by a name search consist in the following: Company name, Headquarters/ Registered Office address, Economic Activity (business purpose), Address and activity of the branch offices, Telephone and fax numbers, and E-mail address (when available) but not Unique Identifiers. This service cannot be used to search for cancelled, liquidated or insolvent companies. One can then chose to buy the standard company profile for 3,50 €:
https://www.registroimprese.it/richiedi-subito-documenti
It appears that full company information including Unique Identifiers is available only when bought and if you register, since then you can make searches more structured and accurate, concerning also to branches and to closed companies, and consult not only the Italian Business Register, but also the Register of Protests and the archive of the Trademarks and Patents. Moreover, you'll have a larger choice of documents, also customized, i.e. containing only the information you need to. Registration is free of change however it requires an identification document such as an ID card, Passport, Driving License, Individual Tax ID number, or Health Insurance Card. Once registered, you can search for companies throughout the country, by name and province, by tax code and province, by REA number and province; or else you can also search for Individuals (only in the Italian Business Register) by name or by tax code. How often this data is updated and whether they can be downloaded in bulk is not specified.
https://www.registroimprese.it/visure-bilanci-protesti-ri.cerca-#page=page-1
The use of data obtained through the service at www.registroimprese.it must follow the current regulations about the handling of personal information (Legislative Decree 196/2003, as amended). To this end it should be noted that explicit consent from the recipient is required to use this information for advertising or direct sales, for market research or for commercial communications. It is also forbidden to redistribute and/or sell the data, to try to access the data for unauthorized purposes and, in particular, to perform massive batch extractions to speed up the activity or to create autonomous data banks.
I could not find any company data on the Open Data portal: https://www.dati.gov.it
A list of Companies is also available on the Commissione Nazionale per le Societa e la Borsa website, however this only includes Company name, Ownership, Share capital, Board members, New major shareholdings, and History, and not the Unique Identifier or Company Address.
https://www.consob.it/web/consob-and-its-activities/listed-companies",,"Yes","No","Maurizio Napolitano","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"7471edc8-50c2-4834-b8ac-b1e1db8817e7","global","2017-02-25T10:33:25","2016","ba","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal Administration for Geodetic and Property Affairs and Republican Administration for Geodetic and Property Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original submitter:
Agency: Federal Administration for Geodetic and Property Affairs and Republican Administration for Geodetic and Property Affairs
Link:
- https://www.katastar.ba/geoportal/preglednik/ - FGO Geoportal (Federation BiH)
- https://www.geoportal.rgurs.org/geoportal/ - Geospatial Portal (Republika Srpska BiH)
Steps to find: Queried a web search engine for ""E-katastar BiH"". Two entity cadaster websites are among the results.
- No open license - Federation data are copyrighted. See statement in the footer ""© 2015 - Sva prava su zadržana"". (all rights reserved)
For Srpska, ""Site content may not be distributed, modified, displayed-reproduce, sell, copy or otherwise use and make available to third parties without the written consent of RGURS."" https://www.geoportal.rgurs.org/termsOfUse.html
Original submission was rejected as no Boundary 1 + 2 for Republika Srpska and missing Boundary Level 2 for Federation.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Characteristic criteria not met:
Boundary 1 + 2 for Republika Srpska and missing Boundary Level 2 for Federation.","Yes","No","Michael Leow","Michael Leow","0","0"
"bc4a2d70-1d13-4e8e-94ac-354bce56b725","global","2017-02-25T10:19:43","2016","do","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Oficina Nacional de Estadística"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original submitter:
- Agency: Oficina Nacional de Estadística
Link:
- https://www.one.gob.do/SEN/317/division-politica-administrativa - Oficina Nacional de Estadística
- Steps to find:
Inicio web ONE / Informaciones cartográficas / División política administrativa
- Open license: https://optic.gob.do/nortic/index.php/certificaciones/instituciones-certificadas/item/oficina-nacional-de-estadistica-one
The original submission was rejected because only a PDF map was available which does not match all the characteristics of coordinates and polygon borders.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Only a PDF map is available https://www.one.gob.do/SEN/317/division-politica-administrativa - Oficina Nacional de Estadística","Yes","No","Michael Leow","Michael Leow","0","0"
"cb9189a3-7d85-4165-a6fc-d0c6bdbc75ce","global","2017-01-27T14:27:43","2016","gh","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" Land Administration Project (LAP) Ministry of Lands and Natural Resources "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Agency in charge of mapping: https://www.ghanalap.gov.gh/index.php/about-lap2/project-goals""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No administrative boundary datasets could be identified on any of the government department websites. The most accessible dataset is provided by the Humanitarian Data Exchange: https://data.humdata.org/dataset/ghana-administrative-boundaries."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Updated the agency in charge of Administrative Boundaries to "" Land Administration Project (LAP) Ministry of Lands and Natural Resources ""
There is no online data available.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","David Opoku","Michael Leow","0","0"
"e4caf6b4-4713-4d5a-98b4-e0c1a141ffc3","global","2017-01-12T19:59:31","2016","uy","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""You have to search to download the data for each monitoring station\nReviewer: I can confirm this.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is updated anually""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Googled and search in different sites"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.agesic.gub.uy/innovaportal/v/161/1/agesic/ley_n%C2%BA_18381.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""See art. 4""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de vivienda, ordenamiento territorial y medio ambiente (MVOTMA)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.dinama.gub.uy/indicadores_ambientales/fichas/"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","70","70"
"da84e1c9-b06f-4b46-bf18-90d47abad9a0","global","2016-12-05T20:54:25","2016","gb","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data from monitoring stations is available via an interface that allows the user to select individual or groups of stations, pollutants, date ranges, etc. but the user would need to submit numerous searches in order to download all the data.\nReviewer: User is able to select all the regions in the UK country and all of the pollutants with a multi-select. Not very user friendly, but a feature that allows bulk data download. But we may discuss this, as the 256 column limit is one that disallows for bulk data download.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""No steps. I am a user of the data and was previously aware of Defra's UK-AIR site. However the data is readily discoverable via Google searches for \""air pollution data\"" or \""air quality data\""."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://uk-air.defra.gov.uk/data/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is re-usable under the Open Government Licence.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is readily usable in format but given the subject matter there is an amount of underpinning knowledge necessary to understand and interpret it.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs (Defra)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://uk-air.defra.gov.uk/data/"",""descValue"":""UK-AIR Data Archive""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This facility provides downloadable data from 1500 sites across the UK that monitor air quality.""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted with one correction: Data may be downloaded in bulk by multi-selecting data on the link provided. Not a very user friendly way for bulk data, but the feature is present whatsoever. But we may discuss this, as the 256 column limit is one that disallows for bulk data download.",,"Yes","Yes","Owen Boswarva","Ricardo Alanís","100","100"
"d068d77d-7676-49e5-aa09-5493ad7a0f1b","global","2016-11-10T15:13:40","2016","tw","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""search on Taiwan's open data portal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.tw/license#eng"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Environmental Protection Administration of Executive Yuan"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.tw/node/6074"",""descValue"":""Pollutant Emissions""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.tw/node/9844"",""descValue"":""Factory air pollution""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections.",,"Yes","Yes","lycurgus kk","Ricardo Alanís","100","100"
"fd09dd1d-f907-486c-a236-18914b3ce1be","global","2016-12-15T18:01:28","2016","pr","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I used a readily available Internet search engine, but had to refine parameters and also search the EPA website."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""No indication to the contrary that the data are in public domain."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.epa.gov/outdoor-air-quality-data"",""descValue"":""US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Air Data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.emisionestoxicaspr.org/"",""descValue"":""Interactive portal relating geospatial information to pollutants in air and on water surfaces""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The website https://www.epa.gov/outdoor-air-quality-data provides information on air contamination (concentration of pullutants). The website https://www.emisionestoxicaspr.org/, maintained by the Puerto Rico Institute of Statistics, provides georeferenced information on air pollutant emissions (levels, measured in pounds), The information source for the latter is the EPA's Toxic Release Inventory (TRI), which is self-reported industry data (data on Puerto Rico is stored at https://www.estadisticas.gobierno.pr/iepr/Estadisticas/Basesdedatos/Ambiente.aspx#toxic, derived from https://www.epa.gov/toxics-release-inventory-tri-program/tri-basic-data-files-calendar-years-1987-2015).""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections. Data found both in daily and bulk data.",,"Yes","Yes","Jacobo Orenstein","Ricardo Alanís","100","100"
"11e227eb-c836-44fc-aefc-3997e71d1a2a","global","2016-12-15T19:30:59","2016","pa","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Universidad Nacional de Panamà (UP)/ National University of Panama "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Although the Ministry of the Environment publishes certain reports in open formats, I could not find any related to pollutant emissions and air quality, the National University of Panama (UP) has the Air Quality Laboratory, only site In the country that does this type of measurements, however do not have on their website any kind of report.\nHttp://www.up.ac.pa/portalup/IEA.aspx?submenu=1030""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted. No data was found from the Panama Government",,"Yes","No","Victor Díaz Navarro","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"8552a604-552b-45c5-a2a0-30dacf4b50ea","global","2016-12-05T12:19:38","2016","jp","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Please access data catalogue site (https://www.data.go.jp/?lang=english) and search by words regarding \""Environment\"" then you will find urls linking to the website of datasets released by Ministry of the Environment. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.env.go.jp/mail.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of the Environment "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.data.go.jp/data/dataset/env_20140904_0933"",""descValue"":""An main page of datasets list that Ministry of the Environments has published in accordance with the copyright license Attribution 2.1 Japan of the Creative Commons License (hereafter referred to as the CC License). For details ,see https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.1/jp/legalcode. the pollutant emissions.""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.env.go.jp/doc/toukei/contents/index.html#6shou"",""descValue"":""Datasets regarding Pollutant Emissions are available the following url.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections. Data is presented in bulk, with no recent updates.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","85","85"
"2caf10c4-5b65-4243-aa97-5aa2823dfcc5","global","2016-12-15T14:33:09","2016","gr","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":"" For Thessaloniki and Patra data can be re-distributed freely (please see openly licenced). In terms of Athens authorisation for the re-distribution of data must be granted by the Ministry of Environment & Energy.\n\nLicence for Thessaloniki: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Licence for Patra: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/gr/""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""DOC (Word)""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data in bulk is only available for the city of Patra.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""directly from the Ministry's site"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Environment & Energy, District of Western Greece, District of Central Macedonia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ypeka.gr/Default.aspx?tabid=708&language=en"",""descValue"":""Daily Bulletin Atmospheric Pollution""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.pkm.gov.gr/default.aspx?lang=el-GR&page=507"",""descValue"":""City of Thessaloniki""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ypeka.gr/Default.aspx?tabid=708&language=en"",""descValue"":""City of Athens""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.pde.gov.gr/gr/enimerosi/anartitea/airpollutionofpatras.html"",""descValue"":""City of Patra""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections. Data was uploaded city wise, but covers the minimum requirements.","Is the data available online?
We have identified three (3) different sources of data for the following cities: Athens, Thessaloniki, Patra.
The URLs are as follows:
Athens: https://www.ypeka.gr/Default.aspx?tabid=708&language=en
Thessaloniki: https://www.pkm.gov.gr/default.aspx?lang=el-GR&page=507
Patra:https://www.pde.gov.gr/gr/enimerosi/anartitea/airpollutionofpatras.html
Does the data exist? No data available for VOCs
Openly licenced? For Thessaloniki and Patra data can be re-distributed freely (please see openly licenced). In terms of Athens authorisation for the re-distribution of data must be granted by the Ministry of Environment & Energy.
Licence for Thessaloniki: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Licence for Patra: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/gr/
Is the data machine readable? No it is not. All sources are either HTML text or DOC (word)
Available in bulk?
Data in bulk is only available for the city of Patra.","Yes","No","Kleanthis Koupidis","Ricardo Alanís","45","45"
"7e96642a-6fa5-49fa-880b-eda7a0ff6f4e","global","2016-12-17T13:20:14","2016","de","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.umweltbundesamt.de/en/disclaimer-privacy-policy\nData must be requested in order to obtain clearance.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Umwelt Bundesamt"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.umweltbundesamt.de/en/data/current-concentrations-of-air-pollutants-in-germany"",""descValue"":""overview page""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections.","The search for the license was not successful within acceptable time.
""Umweltbundesamt offene daten luftverschmutzung""
no indication on the page itself,
the bulk download could be easier","Yes","No","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","80","80"
"97ab20b8-d3d6-4ac6-930e-29f3d589ae53","global","2016-12-28T00:42:14","2016","fr","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Reviewer: One may select several variables and download ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Global data is updated 4 times a year only.\nReviewer: This may be considered as up to date data.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched for \""pollution\"" on data.gouv.fr but only found individual datasets from some and not all regions, then looked on the Ministry of Environement "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.stats.environnement.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/Eider/mentions-legales.do"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is only accessible through a web form piece by piece. Automating a collect and assemble of all files is quite complex""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Environment"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.stats.environnement.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/Eider/series.do"",""descValue"":""Regional and departmental environment database""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted, with a change on update periodicity considered as up to date.",,"Yes","No","Open Knowledge","Ricardo Alanís","85","85"
"a74287e7-6690-41a3-b367-2f5fdc60937d","global","2016-12-19T17:24:59","2016","do","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewer: I can confirm the action plan. Could not find the data alternatively. Accepted.","El Ministerio de Medio Ambiente, como parte del segundo plan de acción de la República Dominicana ante la Alianza para el Gobierno Abierto, se comprometió a instalar varios monitores de contaminación del aire en cinco ciudades del país. Sin embargo, a la fecha no ha cumplido con esta promesa.
En la RD no existen datos públicos sobre este tema.","Yes","No","Miguel Reyes Taveras","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"8deaa90b-442f-49cd-accc-32d9de533618","global","2017-02-07T08:03:29","2016","dk","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There are to my knowledge no specific license on the data""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The hourly updated data is aviable through a table in a website: https://www2.dmu.dk/atmosphericenvironment/byer/forside.htm \nHistorical data is availble through specifying tables here: https://www2.dmu.dk/1_Viden/2_miljoe-tilstand/3_luft/4_maalinger/5_database/hentdata.asp ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went through the Environmental Protection Agencys website to find the website of the National Centre for Environment and Energy under Aarhus University who are collecting the data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is in HTML table formats and needs to be scraped""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""DCE - National Center for Miljø og Energi, Aarhus Universitet on behalf of: Miljøstyrelsen, https://mst.dk/virksomhed-myndighed/luft/overvaagning-af-luftforurening/ "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It's not all the charateristics that are avialble for all the meassuring stations""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www2.dmu.dk/atmosphericenvironment/byer/forside.htm"",""descValue"":""Hourly updated air pollution data for around 14 measuringsstations ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www2.dmu.dk/1_Viden/2_miljoe-tilstand/3_luft/4_maalinger/5_database/hentdata.asp"",""descValue"":""Historical data from 1983 to 2014""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted. Source found as described and confirmed data available.",,"Yes","No","Michael Tornøe","Ricardo Alanís","65","65"
"fbed792d-7075-4f1f-9230-e3c03aecce27","global","2016-12-24T08:49:08","2016","il","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""last update: Oct 2015.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name of an entity in order to find it.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Website was mentioned on the Open Data portal (https://data.gov.il/dataset/766)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.il/terms"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Registrar of Companies, Israeli Corporations Authority, Ministry of Justice"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://havarot.justice.gov.il/"",""descValue"":""Registrar of Companies, Israeli Corporations Authority""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission has been edited as the link to the Open Data portal provided by the submitter did not contain all four required characteristics. More specifically, the file contains the list of companies registered in the Registrar of Companies administrator, with the exception of companies having been deleted. The .CSV file, which is updated every week, includes company name, company number and date of registration with the Registrar of Companies for free, but no company address. The database is updated every seven days and is available under open license:
https://data.gov.il/dataset/766
Still, I was able to find the Registrar of Companies, Israeli Corporations Authority website. Company Name, Number, and Address are available for free in .HTML format through a search mask so it is necessary to know the name of an entity in order to find it. However, data are not guaranteed to be up to date, cannot be downloaded in bulk, and the type of license is not specified.
https://havarot.justice.gov.il/
I also came across IsraelBizReg, an Israel Company Register service in English: ""All information for the reports produced by IsraelBizReg are obtained from the Israel Companies Authority. This is the national body in Israel that is responsible for registering corporations and is the most accurate source of information on Israeli business. Our process involves requesting and paying for the appropriate documents and information from the Israel Companies Authority, formatting, and translation from Hebrew to English."" Company Name, Location, and Registration Number are available for free in .HTML both in a list form as well as through a search mask where one needs to type in the name or registration number of an entity in order to find it. More detailed information can be purchased. How often the data are updated is not made clear, and neither is the type of license. The data cannot be downloaded at once.
https://www.israelbizreg.com/
The ""Locating a Company"" feature on the Ministry of Justice appears to be down - the page won't load.
https://www.justice.gov.il/En/Services/Pages/OnLineServices.aspx
A list of 662 Company Names is available on the Israel Export Institute - Catalogue of Member Companies. No Identification Numbers or Addresses are available.
https://www.export.gov.il/eng/companiesindex/.aspx?branch=&searchcompany=
A list of Public companies is available on the Israel Securities Authority website. Information include Company Name, Field, Register of Companies Number, Phone and Fax numbers, Website, but no Address.
https://www.isa.gov.il/sites/ISAEng/Supervised%20Departments/Public%20Companies/Pages/List-Of-Companies.aspx",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","15","15"
"a420bfe5-02ce-4f29-a22d-96f9d0a20af4","global","2016-12-04T19:29:55","2016","im","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""footer notice and link""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name or number of an entity in order to find it.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""google -- isle of man companies search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.gov.im/about-this-site/open-government-licence/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""no download search results option or download corporate entity details option -- copy paste text""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Companies Registry, Department of Economic Development"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://services.gov.im/ded/services/companiesregistry/viewcompany.iom?Id=56144\n""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.im/categories/business-and-industries/companies-registry"",""descValue"":""Companies Registry""},{""urlValue"":""https://services.gov.im/ded/services/companiesregistry/companysearch.iom"",""descValue"":""Company Registry - Company Search""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
Through the Official Isle of Man Government website (https://www.gov.im/) one can be directed to the Company Registry - Company Search. There, data are available for free online in .HTML format through a search mask, so it is necessary to know the name or number of an entity in order to find it. Data include Company Name, Number, Registered Office Address, Registry Type, Company Type, Date of Incorporation, Presence of Charges, whether it's in Liquidation, Appointed Receiver(s), Status, Documents (for purchase), and Previous Names. They cannot be downloaded in bulk as each entity is viewed separately. All content is available under the Open Government Licence, except where otherwise stated.
https://services.gov.im/ded/services/companiesregistry/companysearch.iom",,"Yes","No","Graeme Jones","Evangelia Kampouri","50","50"
"72f05a1f-7e20-45df-94ea-012b26e09666","global","2017-02-24T19:24:57","2016","id","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Directorate General of Legal Administration (Direktorat Jenderal Administrasi Hukum Umum)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission has been rejected on the basis that not all four required characteristics are published online.
According to the original submitter, the Indonesian company register is the most closed online available company register they've ever seen.
Though full company profiles are available on the Directorate General of Legal Administration (Direktorat Jenderal Administrasi Hukum Umum) website, they are not for free and not openly licensed. More specifically, the names and addresses of companies are available for free in .HTML format, but not their unique identifiers. Names and addresses are available through a search mask so it is necessary to already know the name of an entity in order to find it. In order to access a company's full profile (which one can only assume whether it includes the unique identifier), one needs to select the company of interest, fill in an online form, and buy the information through a pre-paid voucher. Information is then sent via e-mail in .PDF format. The update frequency is not known and the dataset cannot be downloaded at once:
https://ahu.go.id/pencarian/profil-pt
On the Ministry of Commerce - Company Directory Data Center Collection website there is a free list in .HTML format of Company Names, Addresses, and Products, but no Identification numbers are available:
https://www.kemendag.go.id/en/perdagangan-kita/company-directory/data-center-collection
On the Ministry of Industry - Business Directories website there is also a free list in .HTML format of Company Names, Addresses, and Commodity, but no Identification numbers are available:
https://www.kemenperin.go.id/direktori-perusahaan","The original submission has been rejected on the basis that not all four required characteristics are published online.
According to the original submitter, the Indonesian company register is the most closed online available company register they've ever seen.
Though full company profiles are available on the Directorate General of Legal Administration (Direktorat Jenderal Administrasi Hukum Umum) website, they are not for free and not openly licensed. More specifically, the names and addresses of companies are available for free in .HTML format, but not their unique identifiers. Names and addresses are available through a search mask so it is necessary to already know the name of an entity in order to find it. In order to access a company's full profile (which one can only assume whether it includes the unique identifier), one needs to select the company of interest, fill in an online form, and buy the information through a pre-paid voucher. Information is then sent via e-mail in .PDF format. The update frequency is not known and the dataset cannot be downloaded at once:
https://ahu.go.id/pencarian/profil-pt
On the Ministry of Commerce - Company Directory Data Center Collection website there is a free list in .HTML format of Company Names, Addresses, and Products, but no Identification numbers are available:
https://www.kemendag.go.id/en/perdagangan-kita/company-directory/data-center-collection
On the Ministry of Industry - Business Directories website there is also a free list in .HTML format of Company Names, Addresses, and Commodity, but no Identification numbers are available:
https://www.kemenperin.go.id/direktori-perusahaan","Yes","No","Evangelia Kampouri","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"01d95770-5e46-4346-b4fb-3c54cd2b3a0c","global","2016-12-31T20:02:57","2016","ir","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""All required characteristics are only available in .PDF format.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Found the Legal Entities' National ID Portal through the Company Registration General Office website."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Legal Entities' National ID Portal, Company Registration General Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ilenc.ir/"",""descValue"":""Legal Entities' National ID Portal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I could not find any relevant information of interest on the Official Gazette of the Islamic Republic of Iran website proposed by the submitter:
https://www.rrk.ir/
However, I was able to find through searching the Company Registration General Office website (sherkat.ssaa.ir/Default.aspx?tabid=4767), the Legal Entities' National ID Portal. Company data are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name of an entity and submit it in Persian (not Latin characters) in order to find it. National ID, Registration, Name, Personality, Registrar, and Situation are available in .HTML format, but no Company Address. Yet, when clicking on the National ID of an entity, one is redirected to a .PDF which contains all information mentioned above as well as Legal Residence info. The document is in Persian. Update frequency of data is not known and data cannot be downloaded in bulk:
https://www.ilenc.ir/
The Tehran Chamber of Commerce and Industries and Mines Trade Directory also offers the Company Name, Manager Director, and E-Mail address of companies through a search mask in .HTML format, but not the unique identifier or company address:
https://dir.tccim.ir/english/",,"Yes","No","MohammadHossein Khani","Evangelia Kampouri","30","30"
"300bfac5-6a9b-4b03-be71-12c3918e9214","global","2016-11-27T14:58:09","2016","cz","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Up-to-date files can be downloaded as XLS, sometimes broken down by type (raw, cleaned from seasonal trends etc). This is the case of GDP which is available like a bunch of files, divided by types of expenditure, resources, etc. There is no \""master document\"" but i would still consider those data bulk. Some historical data can be queried and exported as XML. Example: https://vdb.czso.cz/vdbvo2/faces/cs/index.jsf?page=vystup-objekt&pvo=ZAM01-A&z=T&f=TABULKA&skupId=426&filtr=G~F_M~F_Z~F_R~F_P~_S~_null_O~2016_&katalog=30853&pvo=ZAM01-A&str=v178&c=v3~6__RP2016QP1""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Unemployment and GDP updated quarterly, population monthly""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Data such as unemployment are linked from the homepage. Each topic is presented as a short article explaining the current trend and linking to the data and methodology. For some data, it might take more clicks to download the most current stats."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.czso.cz/csu/czso/conditions_for_use_and_further_dissemination"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Český statistický úřad / Czech Statistical Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.czso.cz/csu/czso/home"",""descValue"":""Homepage""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.czso.cz/csu/czso/hdp_cr"",""descValue"":""GDP""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.czso.cz/csu/czso/cri/zamestnanost-a-nezamestnanost-podle-vysledku-vsps-3-ctvrtleti-2016"",""descValue"":""(Un)employnment""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.czso.cz/csu/czso/oby_cr_m"",""descValue"":""Population""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Michaela Rybičková for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Added frequency of data publication.
",,"Yes","Yes","Michaela Rybičková","Sophie Lafayette","100","100"
"e3c209fa-645e-4f87-a0fe-f7988a8510fe","global","2016-12-09T09:16:10","2016","hr","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Updated to 'no' as although there is an open data portal where data sets have open license (e.g. https://data.gov.hr/dataset/statistika-u-nizu-gospodarstvo-osnovni-pokazatelji has license https://opendefinition.org/od/1.1/hr/) not all data is under open license, the main national statistics website has footer 'Copyright © 2006 - 2015 Republika Hrvatska - Državni zavod za statistiku'""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: added HTML. Unemployment and GDP available as XLS.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""GDP quarterly, unemployment monthly, population yearly""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried a web search engine for National Statistics and Croatian open data portal search engine"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://opendefinition.org/od/1.1/hr/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Croatian Bureau of Statistics"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.dzs.hr/default_e.htm"",""descValue"":""Croatian Bureau of Statistics""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dzs.hr/default.htm"",""descValue"":""GDP, employment, and population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.hr/publisher/dr-avni-zavod-za-statistiku"",""descValue"":""Croatian Bureau of Statistics at Open Data Portal""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.hr/dataset/statistika-u-nizu-bruto-doma-i-proizvod"",""descValue"":""GDP data in XLS""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Difficult to put direct link to data set as embedded within frames of website""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Zoran Lusha for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. B7 updated to 'no' as although there is an open data portal where data sets have open license (e.g. https://data.gov.hr/dataset/statistika-u-nizu-gospodarstvo-osnovni-pokazatelji has license https://opendefinition.org/od/1.1/hr/) not all data is under open license, the main national statistics website has footer 'Copyright © 2006 - 2015 Republika Hrvatska - Državni zavod za statistiku'",,"Yes","No","Zoran Lusha","Sophie Lafayette","80","80"
"7429bb01-d3cb-4419-b9fd-f28fc218b12c","global","2017-01-17T14:08:59","2016","zw","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Meteorological Services Department of Zimbabwe"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Meteorological Services Department of Zimbabwe (https://www.weather.co.zw/) website is currently under construction. This website possibly contains weather forecast data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The initial submission was amended, because weather data is collected by the Meteorological Services Department of Zimbabwe.
However their official website (https://www.weather.co.zw/) was under construction during the time of submission (Jan 17, 2017) and review (February 24, 2017). This website possibly contains weather forecast data.
Thank you, Tricia Govindasamy, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"d6e41e0a-24c9-4a53-92d2-168de32c53d3","global","2017-02-24T14:42:45","2016","cr","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Registro Nacional"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission had to be rejected as not all four required characteristics can be found online.
A list of companies, published in La Gaceta for dissolution, pursuant to article 6 of Law 9024, that contains entity names and ID numbers is available for free and downloadable at once in .XLS format on the National Registry website: https://www.rnpdigital.com/ https://www.rnpdigital.com/LISTADO%20DE%20EDICTOS.xlsx According to the submitter (originally submitted by Ignacio Alfaro Marín), one can buy company information on the National Registry website, which is the only public access online: https://www.rnpdigital.com/shopping/login.jspx Name, Unique Identifier, and Address of Costa Rican entities are available in a .PDF document sent to you when you buy it. In the online results one can only see the Name and Unique Identifier of the company in .HTML format, and data are not downloadable at once. However, accessing this information requires an account and is restricted with a captcha. I have been unable to verify the submitter's statements as the website does not make clear where one can register on the National Registry in order to buy/view the data; only the ""sign in"" option is available for those who already have a registered account. How often the data are updated is not specified, and the National Registry reserves, or holds for its own use, all the rights provided by copyright law (2013).","The original submission had to be rejected as not all four required characteristics can be found online.
A list of companies, published in La Gaceta for dissolution, pursuant to article 6 of Law 9024, that contains entity names and ID numbers is available for free and downloadable at once in .XLS format on the National Registry website: https://www.rnpdigital.com/ https://www.rnpdigital.com/LISTADO%20DE%20EDICTOS.xlsx According to the submitter (originally submitted by Ignacio Alfaro Marín), one can buy company information on the National Registry website, which is the only public access online: https://www.rnpdigital.com/shopping/login.jspx Name, Unique Identifier, and Address of Costa Rican entities are available in a .PDF document sent to you when you buy it. In the online results one can only see the Name and Unique Identifier of the company in .HTML format, and data are not downloadable at once. However, accessing this information requires an account and is restricted with a captcha. I have been unable to verify the submitter's statements as the website does not make clear where one can register on the National Registry in order to buy/view the data; only the ""sign in"" option is available for those who already have a registered account. How often the data are updated is not specified, and the National Registry reserves, or holds for its own use, all the rights provided by copyright law (2013).","Yes","No","Evangelia Kampouri","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"6042e23f-17d7-49a5-8be8-6b0637069aa3","global","2016-12-26T13:06:18","2016","fr","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Last update in 2016 (archives until 2011 are also available)""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""We searched for \""contours communes france\"" on Google and found this result"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://professionnels.ign.fr/geofla"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is licensed under Etalab's Open Licence (\""Licence Ouverte\"") compatible with CC-BY 2.0""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Institut national de l'information géographique et forestière"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://professionnels.ign.fr/geofla"",""descValue"":""GeoFLA contains all administrative boundaries in France and in overseas departments and territories (regions, departments, cantons, municipalities)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Departments and Arrondissements cover Boundary Level 1 + 2; with all the needed characteristics. The dataset can be easily downloaded for free and has open license.
Submission was minorly modified to add the formats SHX + DBF with the shapefiles.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","Yes","Open Knowledge","Michael Leow","100","100"
"744c7f88-b02a-42df-9035-ec53b6fe87d4","global","2016-12-07T07:40:52","2016","fi","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""GML"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""WFS only in test service. Mapinfo MIF also available (not in the list).""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Just google or look from the main page of NLS Finland."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.maanmittauslaitos.fi/en/professionals/digital-products/datasets-free-charge/terms-use-license/national-land-survey-open-data-cc-40-licence"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is collected by National Land Survey of Finland, which is governmental organisation responsible of national mapping, cadastre and land ownership in Finland.""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Land Survey of Finland."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://tiedostopalvelu.maanmittauslaitos.fi/tp/kartta?lang=en"",""descValue"":""Open data file service""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Since the site requires user to enter email before the files are sent as a link to be downloaded, the submission was modify to indicate that a login is needed to download the data.
Under the ""File Service of Open Data"" page, select the Municipal Division 1:250000, TietoaKuntajaosta_2017_250k.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","85","85"
"aed0fe2a-ea2d-49b8-8e8a-32b24701de0b","global","2017-02-24T12:52:47","2016","gy","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Hydrometeorological Service, Ministry of Agriculture Guyana"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission by Alesha Aris was amended. The dataset does not qualify for submission, because three-day forecasts are only available for precipitation amount (available at: https://hydromet.gov.gy/weather/forecast/). Other forecasts are available as PDF files in fair detail, see here: (https://hydromet.gov.gy/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/Weather-Brief-February-20-2017.pdf). These forecasts are valid for the coming 24 hours, are irregularly updated, and do not exist for the date of assessment (February 24, 2017). Other links are broken (see here: https://hydromet.gov.gy/weather/wrf-24-hrs-tendency/).
Data can be requested via: https://hydromet.gov.gy/data-request/.
Thank you, Alesha Aris, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"9b2420a2-d644-4cdc-aab4-f6d127b1883b","global","2017-02-06T18:58:19","2016","dk","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Looked for denmark weather. They have an English version so that makes it easier to find. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""DMI"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.dmi.dk/vejr/"",""descValue"":""DMI site, with weather data for the whole country""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dmi.dk/en/vejr/til-lands/national-weather/"",""descValue"":""DMI site, national 6-day forecasts, including all required characteristics""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dmi.dk/en/vejr/til-lands/regionaludsigten/fyn/"",""descValue"":""DMI site, regional 6-day forecasts, including all required characteristics""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The data is very easily understandable, because all data (be it icons, or graphs) have a legend explaining the data clearly (so humans can interpret bar charts easily). However, the data itself is only available as PNG file embedded in HTML. So manual transcription is necessary to retrieve the data. To make the data usable through machines would require extensive effort.
Data cannot be downloaded. There is no open license on the website, but a copyright notification. The website states that one part of the business model is to cater numerical forecasts to private customers (see: https://www.dmi.dk/en/about/profile/introduction-to-dmi/#c5054). It does not appear that the data is in the public domain. Therefore it is not considered to be openly licensed. Thank you, Oscar Montiel, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Only available to see the information, not possible to download the data. ","Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"b6d6a1ff-e977-45c3-a268-d947459a21b1","global","2016-11-21T18:01:45","2016","mk","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Current weather forecast updated every 3 hours is available here https://meteo.gov.mk/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=84&Itemid=90&lang=en as open data however there is no 5 day forecast available.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Hydrometeorological Service"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://meteo.gov.mk/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=49%3Avrnezi-i-struene-na-vozduhot-nmm-mk&catid=9%3Anumericki-modeli&Itemid=6&lang=en"",""descValue"":""Numerical model, highly outdated (historical data)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission was accepted and amended. The 3-day forecast exists, but only indicates minimum and maximum temperature as well as a general weather description (about cloud coverage). There is no indication of wind speed or direction. It could not be verified whether the general weather description describes precipitation amount.
Forecasts for the current and following day are a slightly more informative. Weather maps show the wind direction and temperature (without any indication of measurement unit like Celsius). The data is embedded in HTML, but quite unprecise - the names of weather symbols are not self-explaining and do not indicate how much rain is falling in a region for example.
Besides that, the website contains highly outdated information (historical data from 2015) and there seems to be no consistent pattern how historical data is archived. Thank you, Arianit Dobroshi, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"4fc70390-d1dd-4d3c-a287-07a1f9744737","global","2016-12-04T19:17:25","2016","hr","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""All published data are for information purposes only and intended for personal use, and may not be used for commercial purposes or distributed to a third party. \n\nhttps://geoportal.dgu.hr/#/menu/uvjeti-koristenja""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""WMS service is available from geoportal, see offerings here https://geoportal.dgu.hr/#/menu/podaci-i-servisi""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Same source as the National Map"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""State Geodetic Administration, Republic of Croatia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://geoportal.dgu.hr/"",""descValue"":""State Geodetic Administration, Republic of Croatia""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","All characteristic is available to be viewed online.
However, this dataset is not downloadable and those have no open formats available.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Michael Leow","45","45"
"27328c40-d0af-4924-9e87-a134e7db8302","global","2017-02-24T11:22:35","2016","cz","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Czech Office for Surveying, Mapping and Cadastre"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original submitter provided:
- Czech Office for Surveying, Mapping and Cadastre
- The data can be viewed without registration,but download is paid and requires a registration
Links:
- https://geoportal.cuzk.cz/(S(utnrdljggb32abmpknlfwckx))/Default.aspx?lng=EN&mode=TextMeta&side=dSady_hranice10&metadataID=CZ-CUZK-SH-V (A page with basic info about the dataset)
- https://geoportal.cuzk.cz/geoprohlizec/?wmcid=523 (View-only version (download is chargeable))
Found via: Link for the official source is shown on the first page of google search results (7th link).
The original submission was rejected because Boundary Level 2 was missing.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Boundary Level 2 is missing for https://geoportal.cuzk.cz/geoprohlizec/?wmcid=523 (View-only version (download is chargeable))","Yes","No","Michael Leow","Michael Leow","0","0"
"875ad445-2767-4c9f-b396-0eda400c12b1","global","2017-02-24T11:03:06","2016","gy","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Guyana Lands and Surveys Commission (GLSC)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Found the responsible party for Administrative Boundaries:\nhttps://www.glsc.gov.gy/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original submitter's was rejected as not all the characteristics was available. Correct agency was identified: Guyana Lands and Surveys Commission (GLSC) but there is no online data.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","No online data is available. Order for the digital maps must be made and a fee is charged, and copyright exists.","Yes","No","Michael Leow","Michael Leow","0","0"
"279d3cbc-c638-459a-ad14-5a9a13415c8e","global","2017-02-20T17:08:48","2016","ee","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Land Board webpage > Geoportal > Maps and Data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://geoportaal.maaamet.ee/eng/Maps-and-Data/Administrative-and-Settlement-Division-p312.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Maa-amet / Estonian Land Board"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://geoportaal.maaamet.ee/eng/Maps-and-Data/Administrative-and-Settlement-Division-p312.html"",""descValue"":""Estonian Land Board Geoportal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Added additional open format SHX + DBF from shapefiles. All other characteristics check out.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Spatial data for Estonian Administrative and Settlement Classification is also available in GeoJSON and TopoJSON format at https://github.com/buildig/EHAK","Yes","Yes","Tormi Tabor","Michael Leow","100","100"
"111772ab-2486-410e-b798-bee01729d611","global","2017-02-23T22:53:30","2016","hk","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Companies Registry "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission was rejected as not all four dataset characteristics can be found online. More specifically, Company Names and CR numbers are available, but not Company Addresses.
One way to access data is through the Cyber Search Centre of the Integrated Companies Registry Information System (ICRIS). However, data are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name of an entity in order to find it. Only CR No. and Company Name are provided. Data are free and in .HTML format, so they cannot be downloaded at once. There are also terms of use to which one must agree with as well as provide a reason for conducting the search in order to access the data. Update frequency is not stated:
https://www.icris.cr.gov.hk/csci/
There is also a list of old company names available for free in .PDF format. This provides neither a CR number nor a company's address:
https://www.icris.cr.gov.hk/csci/cnsResultLink.do
Final way of accessing data is through the Companies Registry by visiting data.gov.hk > Data Providers > Companies Registry. There is a List of Newly Incorporated /Registered Companies and Companies which have changed Names available for free, downloadable at once, and updated weekly in .XLS format. However, this also does not include company addresses, only CR numbers and Company names:
https://data.gov.hk/en-data/dataset/hk-cr-crdata-list-newly-registered-companies","The original submission was rejected as not all four dataset characteristics can be found online. More specifically, Company Names and CR numbers are available, but not Company Addresses.
One way to access data is through the Cyber Search Centre of the Integrated Companies Registry Information System (ICRIS). However, data are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name of an entity in order to find it. Only CR No. and Company Name are provided. Data are free and in .HTML format, so they cannot be downloaded at once. There are also terms of use to which one must agree with as well as provide a reason for conducting the search in order to access the data. Update frequency is not stated:
https://www.icris.cr.gov.hk/csci/
There is also a list of old company names available for free in .PDF format. This provides neither a CR number nor a company's address:
https://www.icris.cr.gov.hk/csci/cnsResultLink.do
Final way of accessing data is through the Companies Registry by visiting data.gov.hk > Data Providers > Companies Registry. There is a List of Newly Incorporated /Registered Companies and Companies which have changed Names available for free, downloadable at once, and updated weekly in .XLS format. However, this also does not include company addresses, only CR numbers and Company names:
https://data.gov.hk/en-data/dataset/hk-cr-crdata-list-newly-registered-companies","Yes","No","Evangelia Kampouri","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"85f7a97c-e13c-4dac-9435-d999aecff87b","global","2017-01-23T04:53:25","2016","gy","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Business, Guyana Office for Investment"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Ministry of Business""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The Georgetown Chamber of Commerce & Industry website has a Directory of Members with an alphabetical list of company names in .HTML format. Selecting an entity's name provides the company's Address, Telephone and Fax numbers, and e-mail but not Unique Identifier. Information are for free, but obviously not for the entire country:
https://gcci.gy/members-of-gcci/
Companies are registered at the Commercial Registry however both the original submitter and I were unable to identify an online portal with data on the companies.
The Guyana Office for Investment doesn't seem to have any company information:
https://goinvest.gov.gy/investment/incorporation/
The Republic of Guyana Ministry of Business - Industry and Commerce Departments also appear to have no relevant information:
https://minbusiness.gov.gy/industry/
https://minbusiness.gov.gy/commerce/
The Ministry of Legal Affairs - Deeds Registry also doesn't hold any information of interest:
https://mola.gov.gy/6-general-information/deeds-registry/4-deeds-registry
Could not find anything relevant on the Guyana Government Information Agency (Gina) website either:
https://gina.gov.gy/
The dataset could not be found online, hence it is marked as non-existent.","Companies are registered at the Commercial Registry however I was unable to identify an online portal with data on the companies. ","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"c20acd55-79cc-4399-a8ca-c19f2d3ef331","global","2016-12-12T22:25:59","2016","gt","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Registro Mercantil"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
There is a company search option on the Registro Mercantil General De La Republica de Guatemala website, however one needs to have a registered account in order to access it and registration requires submitting a form of identification such as ID card or passport. Since verifying whether the dataset exists or which characteristics (if any) are met is not possible, I accept the original submission and mark the dataset as non-existent.
https://www.registromercantil.gob.gt/eConsultas/Wfrm_login.aspx",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"55b7c826-39cd-4ed5-becd-b32251896805","global","2016-11-21T20:01:19","2016","at","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Updated: replaced license for Open Data Portal (https://data.statistik.gv.at/web/?page=terms) with terms of use for Statistics Austria which includes a wider range of data. ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""JSON"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: added JSON (population), XLS, HTML (unemployment)""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Unemployment updated monthly end 2016. Population updated yearly (last update 2014). GDP updated quarterly (last update 2010)""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Only 32 datasets are available in the Statistik Austria Open Data portal which is a very tiny subset of all their data available through the non-open-data channels""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Only 32 datasets are available in the Statistik Austria Open Data portal which is a very tiny subset of all their data available through the non-open-data channels"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://statcube.at/statistik.at/ext/statcube/jsf/terms.xhtml"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Statistik Austria"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: initial submission had looked only on Open Data Portal - data on unemployment can be found on Statstics Austria webpage""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.statistik.gv.at/"",""descValue"":""Open Data Portal""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statistik.at"",""descValue"":""Statstics Austria ""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.statistik.gv.at/web/catalog.jsp#collapse5"",""descValue"":""Population data (open data portal)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statistik.at/web_en/statistics/PeopleSociety/labour_market/unemployed_seeking_work/unemployed_ilo_definition_monthly_estimates/index.html"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statistik.at/web_en/statistics/PeopleSociety/population/index.html"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statistik.at/web_en/statistics/Economy/national_accounts/gross_domestic_product/index.html"",""descValue"":""GDP data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added link to Statistics Austria (government statistics page), population, unemployment, and GDP data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Robert Harm for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Initial submission had only included information from Austria's Open Data Portal - added information from government statistics, Statistics Austria, including additional links, amending license, and additional formats. ",,"Yes","No","Robert Harm","Sophie Lafayette","65","65"
"cf92707d-5be2-476f-8521-2a821559b91d","global","2017-02-23T20:14:13","2016","af","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Central Statistics Organization has a website but it is no longer functioning (404 error) - initial submission suggested GDP, population, and unemployment data had previously been available. ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Central Statistics Organization"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The initial submission was rejected as the Central Statistics Organization website is no longer active - initial submission suggested GDP, population, and unemployment data had previously been available. ",,"Yes","No","Sophie Lafayette","Sophie Lafayette","0","0"
"be2dae32-1abc-4df2-a521-cdaf3b4a53a5","global","2017-02-23T20:07:22","2016","kh","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Footer of site includes: 'Copyright © 2014, NIS, MOP, Government of Cambodia'""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""GDP in HTML, other data within PDF. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Very limited data on population & unemployment which is found as part of PDF report. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Latest data on population and unemployment from 2008. GDP updated yearly, latest 2009 (after predicted)""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Website has limited infomation & data, could find basic information under menus"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data required to be extracted from PDF. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Institue of Statistics"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.nis.gov.kh"",""descValue"":""National Institute for Statistics""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.nis.gov.kh/nis/census2008/Census.pdf"",""descValue"":""Population and unemployment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.nis.gov.kh/nis/NA/NA2015.htm"",""descValue"":""GDP data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Initial submission rejected by reviewer (Sophie Lafayette) as had stated no data available. NIS website is very limited but does have datasets required, although not update at requited frequency or recently. Entry resubmitted with links & additional information. ",,"Yes","No","Sophie Lafayette","Sophie Lafayette","30","30"
"6546afaf-2da2-4c84-9dee-27b15f822f0f","global","2017-01-24T09:14:44","2016","gh","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Registrar General's Department and Ghana Revenue Authority "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No such datasets on their website. I sent an email but no response after 5days. ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The Ghana Revenue Authority (https://www.gra.gov.gh/) and the Registrar General's Department, Ministry of Justice and Attorney General (https://rgd.gov.gh/) websites contains no company data. Submitter had sent an email to the websites but five days later they had yet to receive a response.
On the Public Procurement Authority website, under ""Registered Suppliers and Contractors"", one can search for Suppliers, Contractors and Consultants which are registered currently with the Public Procurement Board in Ghana (https://www.ppaghana.org/suppliersearch.asp). One can chose the company name from the drop-down menu, rather than by typing it in so in that sense, one doesn't need to know the name of an entity in order to find it. Alternatively, one can simply request ""search"" with all fields marked as ""all"" and a list with all companies will come up over several pages in .HTML format. Once clicked on an entity's name, one can see information including Company Registration number, Postal, Web, and E-mail Addresses, Telephone and Fax numbers, category, sector, products, and contact person. However, the list probably does not contain all Ghanaian companies as after looking for specific entities such as AngloGold Ashanti, Accra Brewery Company, and Aluworks, I could not find them. Hence, I am accepting the original submission and conclude that the required dataset was not available online.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"fcda4f76-ec59-40b7-bdfd-4ff110f89c00","global","2016-12-14T13:02:41","2016","me","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Copyright is claimed in the footer, \""Copyright 2006. HMI of Montenegro\"". A regulation on the database of HMI data does not mention their status https://www.meteo.co.me/zakoniipravilnici/Pravilnik%20o%20sadrzaju%20jedinstvene%20baze%20podataka%20o%20stanju%20vremena,%20klime%20i%20voda.pdf Data can be requested based on FOI law see guidance document (MNE) https://www.meteo.co.me/Vodic1.pdf and request form https://www.meteo.co.me/Request.pdf""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Partially HTML. Symbology is used.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried an online search engine for Meteorological Institute of Montenegro. Institute website is one of the results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Institute for Hydrometeorology and Seismology of Montenegro"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.meteo.co.me/misc.php?text=121&sektor=1"",""descValue"":""Five day forecast - numerical modelling""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.meteo.co.me/misc.php?text=103&sektor=1"",""descValue"":""7 day forecast - Automated weather stations""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.meteo.co.me/misc.php?text=124&sektor=1"",""descValue"":""3-day forecast - Weather map with text description of wind speed (for several regions)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.meteo.co.me/misc.php?text=106&sektor=1"",""descValue"":""Forecast for current day - XML file""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Forecast are primarily available as weather maps. The data must be scraped, and even then it lacks detail to make it fully understandable. The data is embedded in HTML, presented in text form or weather symbols. Looking at the source code, some symbols can be interpreted by their name (e.g. wind direction). Cloud symbols show the amount of precipitation but there is no indication how much rain is falling precisely. The actual amount of rain cannot be understood from the symbol, if it would be scraped. Given that the data is embedded in HTML, the submission was changed.
There is no download for forecasts available. Data for the current day can be retrieved as XML.
Wind speed and direction are available for large regions in the country (no local forecasts) and are verbally described (strong winds can occur in region X).
The submitter correctly stated that ""copyright is claimed in the footer, ""Copyright 2006. HMI of Montenegro"". A regulation on the database of HMI data does not mention their status https://www.meteo.co.me/zakoniipravilnici/Pravilnik%20o%20sadrzaju%20jedinstvene%20baze%20podataka%20o%20stanju%20vremena,%20klime%20i%20voda.pdf""
Data can be requested based on FOI law see guidance document (MNE) https://www.meteo.co.me/Vodic1.pdf and request form https://www.meteo.co.me/Request.pdf
The original submission was sent by Arianit Dobroshi. Thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"da66c75a-7413-4c29-951d-69068d260f6c","global","2017-01-17T10:50:56","2016","gh","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: removed link (https://opendefinition.org/licenses/odc-odbl/) as couldn't find license. Ghana Statistical Service footer includes 'Copyright © 2017 Ghana Statistical Service'. Couldn't find license on Open Data Initiative website. ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Majority of the dataset I looked at were in PDFs but some especially the GDP was in Excel ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""They are all downloadable \n\nUpdate: amended to no as unemployment data not downloadable as single data set, found within reports.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Note: There is quarterly reports for the GDP but that is not so for employment. For example, the Ghana Statistical Services is still using the 2010 Census to work out the data on employment and unemployment status. \n\nUpdate: amended to no as couldn't find recent data on unemployment""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: data sets in B3 did not require a login but accessing some data within 'Central Data Catalog' requires registration. ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""I was able to download the data without having to login or pay any money. ""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to the Ghana Statistical services website and looked for specific datasets - GDP, population, unemployment etc. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Finding data on unemployment was particularly hard as this is not made stand alone but infused with employment data and so one need to search through about five or more datasets on employment status to get information on un-employment. ""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://opendefinition.org/licenses/odc-odbl/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ghana Statistical Service (GSS)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.statsghana.gov.gh/"",""descValue"":""Ghana Statistical Service""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.gh/dataset"",""descValue"":""Ghana Open Data Initiative""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statsghana.gov.gh/gdp_new.html"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statsghana.gov.gh/pop_stats.html"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statsghana.gov.gh/docfiles/glss6/glss6_labour_force_4th_to_6th_cycle_report.pdf"",""descValue"":""Report with unemployment data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended descriptions, added links to population, GDP, and unemployment data""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Franka Vaughan for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Amended B6 to no as couldn't find recent data on unemployment. Added additional links to data. Amended B5 to no as unemployment data not downloadable as single data set, found within reports.
",,"Yes","No","Franka Vaughan","Sophie Lafayette","50","50"
"0a263901-fb6d-48a4-91d1-b03279dc717b","global","2016-12-17T13:05:47","2016","de","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""JSON"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Update: added JSON""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Unemployment data updated monthly. GDP updated quarterly. Population updated quarterly (latest data Q4 2015)""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""search, different sources, no central point for federal data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.govdata.de/dl-de/by-2-0"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: replaced with direct link to license""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Statistisches Bundesamt (unemployment data), Bundesministerium für Bildung und Forschung (GDP)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.destatis.de"",""descValue"":""Destatis Statistisches Bundesamt""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.govdata.de/"",""descValue"":"" Das Datenportal für Deutschland (data portal)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.govdata.de/web/guest/suchen/-/details/de-bmbf-datenportal-tabelle-0_41"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.datenportal.bmbf.de/portal/en/Tabelle-0.14.html"",""descValue"":""Population data table""},{""urlValue"":""https://www-genesis.destatis.de/genesis/online/logon?sequenz=tabelleErgebnis&selectionname=13231-0002&sachmerkmal=WERTE1&sachschluessel=WERTSBR&zeitscheiben=4"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.destatis.de/EN/FactsFigures/SocietyState/Population/Population.html"",""descValue"":""Population data ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.destatis.de/EN/FactsFigures/NationalEconomyEnvironment/NationalAccounts/DomesticProduct/Tables/Q_GDP.html"",""descValue"":""GDP data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added link to Government Statistics Office, main link for data portal, and additional population link. Moved frequency of data published to B6. \n""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Added additional links and JSON format. ","different sources,
some sources provide data (destatis) but no hint for free license
takes some search to get the open datasets","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Sophie Lafayette","100","100"
"7d9f8add-15b5-4137-890c-4283e95f827e","global","2017-01-24T19:57:37","2016","ve","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""A simple search for \""Compras Públicas Venezuela\"" lets you reach the System's site, and one of the sections is specifically the tender section"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""SISTEMA CENTRALIZADO DE COMPRAS PÚBLICAS"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender status""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://evaluacion.snc.gob.ve:8080/llamados/vistas/publicaciones/index.faces"",""descValue"":""Publicación de llamados a participar en Concursos Abiertos""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No data available. Can get some reports in PDF but no actual downloadable data in the site.
No changes to submission. ","Only providers are allowed to get a user for the platform and the data is available in PDF here: https://evaluacion.snc.gob.ve:8080/llamados/vistas/publicaciones/index.faces","Yes","No","anonymous","Oscar Montiel","30","30"
"9442ecea-285c-43f1-98ad-1f1ac65fad66","global","2017-01-27T20:24:25","2016","cr","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""It was easy for me because I knew the transparency portal of the Comptroller General of the Republic, which collects all the financial information of public institutions, but this portal does not appear as a result of Internet searches. If it is done by search, the results lead to informative sites, which do not have data or to the portal https://datosabiertos.presidencia.go.cr/ that contains some data about adjudications that is incomplete and outdated."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Contraloría General de la República"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://cgrweb.cgr.go.cr/apex/f?p=307:2:0:::::"",""descValue"":""Website of Contraloría General de la República""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes to the submission.
The search allows finding most of the information about the tender, starting with the notices. ","The data found are about tenders and awards already closed. There is no centralized information about ongoing processes, as there is no single public procurement system.
Originally submitted by Susana Soto","Yes","No","anonymous","Oscar Montiel","65","65"
"fae19712-edf5-4103-9207-908dba19416e","global","2017-02-23T17:33:11","2016","bd","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Office of the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies and Firms"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Original submission was rejected as no data could be found online. The Office of the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies and Firms is the sole authority that keeps records of all registered entities (companies, trade organizations, societies and partnership firms). Any one can apply for certified copy of any of such records of an entity. However, the profit & loss account of a company is not open to all. Only authorized personnel of the respective company can apply for it. On receipt of an application and requisite fee, RJSC issues certified copy of the records applied for. One applies for certified copy of record (s) through the website. Certified copies are issued for Private, Public, and Foreign Companies, Trade Organizations, Societies, and Partnership Firms. However, what company information the copies of records include is not made known, the update frequency of the data is also not stated, and whether the data records are made available online after purchase is also not clear.
https://roc.portal.gov.bd/site/page/c3662525-9229-45a4-a80c-2e518d484c52","Original submission was rejected as no data could be found online. The Office of the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies and Firms is the sole authority that keeps records of all registered entities (companies, trade organizations, societies and partnership firms). Any one can apply for certified copy of any of such records of an entity. However, the profit & loss account of a company is not open to all. Only authorized personnel of the respective company can apply for it. On receipt of an application and requisite fee, RJSC issues certified copy of the records applied for. One applies for certified copy of record (s) through the website. Certified copies are issued for Private, Public, and Foreign Companies, Trade Organizations, Societies, and Partnership Firms. However, what company information the copies of records include is not made known, the update frequency of the data is also not stated, and whether the data records are made available online after purchase is also not clear.
https://roc.portal.gov.bd/site/page/c3662525-9229-45a4-a80c-2e518d484c52","Yes","No","Evangelia Kampouri","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"7b3582a7-f2e3-46ce-9c03-842daff4ae7a","global","2017-01-17T19:26:09","2016","ec","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""first googled the registry, then followed the links in the Superintendencia to all the information"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Superintendencia de Compañías, Valores y Seguros"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://appscvs.supercias.gob.ec/portalInformacion/sector_societario.zul"",""descValue"":""Company registry in the country""},{""urlValue"":""https://appscvs.supercias.gob.ec/portaldeinformacion/consulta_cia_param.zul"",""descValue"":""Search for Companies""},{""urlValue"":""https://181.198.3.71/portal/cgi-bin/cognos.cgi?b_action=cognosViewer&ui.action=run&ui.object=%2fcontent%2ffolder%5b%40name%3d%27Reportes%27%5d%2ffolder%5b%40name%3d%27Compa%C3%B1ia%27%5d%2freport%5b%40name%3d%27Directorio_Companias_NETEZZA%27%5d&ui.name=Directorio_Companias_NETEZZA&run.outputFormat=&run.prompt=true"",""descValue"":""Directory of Companies""},{""urlValue"":""https://181.198.3.71/portal/cgi-bin/cognos.cgi?b_action=cognosViewer&ui.action=run&ui.object=%2fcontent%2ffolder%5b%40name%3d%27Reportes%27%5d%2ffolder%5b%40name%3d%27Compa%C3%B1ia%27%5d%2freport%5b%40name%3d%27Directorio%20Resumido%27%5d&ui.name=Directorio%20Resumido&run.outputFormat=&run.prompt=true"",""descValue"":""Directory of Companies Summary""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The Superintendencia de Compañías, Valores y Seguros website offers a variety of options to access information. Of interest are the ""Search for Companies"" (Busqueda de Companias), ""Directory of Companies"" (Directorio de Companias), and ""Directory of Companies Summary"" (Directorio de Companias Resumido). The first option provides data through a search mask, and it is necessary to know the name, record/case file, or identification number of an entity in order to find it. Results are then viewed in .HTML format. The ""Directory of Companies Summary"" also has a search mask but one does not need to know the name of an entity in order to find it: choosing ""search"" with all fields marked as ""all"" returns results. Of most interest is the ""Directory of Companies"" option which offers a list of entities without any search requests. Data can be viewed online by scrolling through several pages, however one is given the option of viewing and downloading the data at once in .HTML, .PDF, .XML, .XLS, or .CSV formats. Information includes Record/Case File, Tax Identification Number (Ruc), Name, Address, State, Branch, Economic Activity, Telephone and Fax numbers, and Web address where applicable. Data are available for free, although the type of license is not made clear. I also could not find how often or when the data were last updated.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","65","65"
"544ff1c2-8bef-405e-ac81-4d7c3db7c57a","global","2016-12-15T22:35:45","2016","sv","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""License attached to the data states that for commercial use, permission needs to be obtained from CNR.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""In Google; search for the term \""site:gob.sv gis\"". The site CNR is second in the list and under the page, go under Section 3 to download shapefiles"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Centro Nacional de Registros"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.cnr.gob.sv/estructura-organizativa/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""It doesn´t exist any national website of e-government or national administration. Maybe beacuse it doesn´t exist any Ministry of the Presidency or the National Administratio"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.cnr.gob.sv/geoportal-cnr/"",""descValue"":""CNR GeoPortal""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dropbox.com/s/c5oq2rehg7s3jte/L%C3%ADmites_WGS84.zip"",""descValue"":""Under Section 3 - Political-Administrative Limits""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Found out the body responsible for ""Administrative Boundaries"" - Centro Nacional de Registros; corrected original submission.
This GeoPortal site has the requisite characteristics, the downloadable datasets and shapefile formats.
Only defect is that the license is not open for commercial use without permission.
Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Each Ministry or National Agency describe in their website their organization chart but there is not any national administrative website that describe the quantity, types and distribution of administratives units or areas thru the government.","Yes","No","The Next Services","Michael Leow","80","80"
"fc7d3f67-cf85-4119-a2d0-d0dcf1f436ef","global","2017-02-02T20:00:35","2016","dk","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""For detailed format overview see: https://kortforsyningen.dk/sites/default/files/formatoversigt_friedata_04_maj_2015.pdf""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I knew beforehand where to go""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Typed in URL"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://download.kortforsyningen.dk/content/vilk%C3%A5r-og-betingelser"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Geodata are generally not userfriendly""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Styrelsen for Dataforsyning og Effektivisering"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""However still some details are missing fx there is no updated information on polling areas (used in relation to elections)""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://download.kortforsyningen.dk/content/danmarks-administrative-geografiske-inddeling-110000"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Confirmed that after registration, the dataset can be downloaded.
Added additional formats supported SHX + DBF with the shapefiles.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","Niels Erik Kaaber Rasmussen","Michael Leow","85","85"
"17571445-0903-4ee8-9b91-2ff1a5527fa8","global","2017-01-27T20:06:32","2016","cr","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Clearly the free use is forbidden: El uso del Sistema Nacional de Información Territorial está orientado principalmente a las entidades y órganos públicos sin fines de lucro. El uso comercial de la información geográfica directa o derivada de los productos disponibles no está autorizado bajo ninguna condición. (https://www.snitcr.go.cr/about)""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""If you look up for Administrative Division Costa Rica on Google Search, the sixth link is the law that created the Division, which you have to verify on the Legislation site. For the official map you have to know there is one at the SNIT site. At the SNIT page, go to the Limit link which will show the Administrative Boundaries."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Comisión Nacional de División Territorial Administrativa"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.pgrweb.go.cr/scij/Busqueda/Normativa/Normas/nrm_texto_completo.aspx?param2=NRTC&nValor1=1&nValor2=35441¶m2=1&strTipM=TC&lResultado=3&strSim=simp"",""descValue"":""Ley sobre División Territorial Administrativa""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.snitcr.go.cr/"",""descValue"":""Sistema Nacional de Información Territorial (SNIT)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.snitcr.go.cr/Visor/index?p=cHJveWVjdG86OmxpbWl0ZXM="",""descValue"":""Limit page (shows Administrative Boundaries)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submitter's entry was expanded with more details on getting to the actual Administrative Boundaries page (via the Link page in the given SNIT homepage).
The characteristics are all available online but are not downloadable. Thus, the format is modified to remove any available open format. No law or license was found to contradict what the SNIT site says about no free use.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","Originally submitted by Ignacio Alfaro Marín","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","30","30"
"c1cd1ba7-e400-4b4f-9545-0bdf0345ad13","global","2016-12-28T20:10:16","2016","fr","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""GDP published on a quarterly basis. Unemployment published on a monthly basis. Population published on a yearly basis.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google search on PIB+France, Chomage+France, Population+France"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.etalab.gouv.fr/en/licence-ouverte-open-licence"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Institute of Statistics and Economic Studies (INSEE)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.insee.fr/fr/accueil"",""descValue"":""Institut national de la statistique et des études économiques""},{""urlValue"":""https://stmt.pole-emploi.org/publication "",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bdm.insee.fr/bdm2/choixCriteres?codeGroupe=62"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bdm.insee.fr/bdm2/affichageSeries?idbank=001690223&page=export&codeGroupe=1541"",""descValue"":""GDP data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: amended description and put publishing frequency in comment for B6. Added link to main statistics website. ""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. ","Unemployment data is hardly machine readable being a multi spreadsheet xls file with merged cells","Yes","Yes","Open Knowledge","Sophie Lafayette","100","100"
"772ace34-8f49-4231-b017-f2ac2384d619","global","2017-01-27T18:08:52","2016","cr","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Footer: 'Copyrigth 2016 - INEC Costa Rica'""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Updated: amended to 'no' as data not up to date.\nLast census (population) 2011. Employment data every three months (latest Q4 2016). Latest GPD found 2013""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I wrote Estadísticas Nacionales on Google Search and the first result if the correct. In the site, there is a thematic search on the left."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Censos (INEC)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added GDP as found additional date while searching site. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.inec.go.cr/"",""descValue"":""El Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Censos (INEC)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.inec.go.cr/poblacion/"",""descValue"":""Population data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.inec.go.cr/empleo"",""descValue"":""Employment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.inec.go.cr/anuario-estadistico/anuario-estadistico-economia"",""descValue"":""Economic data (including GDP/PIB)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: Amended source description. Added links to specific data. ""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Added GDP to data found & links to specific data. Amended B6 to no as data found not up to date. ","The statistics are only gross totals. No granularity available. And are charts that should be cleaned and structured as a database
Originally submitted by Ignacio Alfaro Marín","Yes","No","anonymous","Sophie Lafayette","65","65"
"3f637d74-3752-41e2-88af-ac71d123c803","global","2016-12-20T20:33:23","2016","cl","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No visible license""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It's necessary to make a specific search and then download the results.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There are different sites that offers the data.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to the old index and then to MercadoPúblico's website. Found the Analiza site and then different websites with parts of the data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""ChileCompra (Ministerio de Hacienda)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Inside ChileCompra there are different divisions that measure different aspects of public spending and procurement tenders, like MercadoPúblico or Chile Proveedores. MercadoPúblico only register tenders, not awards.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.mercadopublico.cl/Home"",""descValue"":""MercadoPúblico's website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.analiza.cl/web/Modulos/Reportes/ReporteDestacados.aspx"",""descValue"":""Analiza is the ChileCompra's data analysis website.""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mercadopublico.cl/Portal/Modules/Site/Busquedas/BuscadorAvanzado.aspx?qs=1"",""descValue"":""Tenders search engine""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Advanced search allows you to see all notices and see their status, and history individually in HTML form. It's only possible to export those results to excel with tender ID, Tender name, buyer, status and tender closing date.
No changes to submission. ",,"Yes","No","Manuel Barros","Oscar Montiel","65","65"
"d2806ec6-7f7b-4f23-a850-51db51f119c8","global","2016-12-13T09:59:55","2016","ko","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""TXT""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The Gazette publishes texts of laws in TXT and PDF format.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The laws can be downloaded one by one in PDF and TXT. The amendments of the laws are also seperate PDFs and TXT. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I just googled Kosovo Laws"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Assembly of the Republic of Kosovo; Prime Minister's Office (via Official Gazette)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The reason why the Gazette was chosen as the point of reference for this review is because it makes a much clear connection between a law and its amendment. The laws published on the Assembly website do not list the amendments nor their dates. Amendments appear as separate laws altogether. The Gazette however clearly lists the laws amending the original law and the date of enforcement. So all requirements are met on the Gazete website. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.kuvendikosoves.org/?cid=1,122"",""descValue"":""Laws, Republic of Kosovo Assembly""},{""urlValue"":""https://gzk.rks-gov.net/ActsByCategoryInst.aspx?Index=1&InstID=1&CatID=6"",""descValue"":""Official Gazette Website""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Texts of laws can be found on both websites. However, as a reviewer I am adding the second URL of the Official Gazette. I will use this website instead for the rest of the review as it contains more complete data.""}]","Yes","Yes","I am accepting the submission as it meets all required characteristics. ","The review was based on the Gazette website. The original submitter used the Assembly website and made no mention of the Gazette (I added this source as a reviewer). I am much more confident that all the characteristics are found when taking the Gazette as a point of reference. The Assembly data is relatively incomplete as it does not note amendments on original laws (even though amendments are still published separately). The other change I made was in B8, where I noted that data is available in TXT format (in the Gazette).","Yes","No","Blina Meta","Juela Xhaferraj","65","65"
"4257a908-ed43-441e-a471-208c17988935","global","2016-11-10T18:21:50","2016","il","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""[Comment by original submitter] Israeli laws are public domain by law, however, the license on the Knesset website does not acknowledge that. \n[Comment by reviewer] The original submission indicated that the data was openly licensed giving the rationale noted above. I am changing this to a NO. There is no indication on the website that the content is in the open domain. The URL (https://main.knesset.gov.il/About/Pages/Copyright.aspx) provided in the original submission states: \""User may make \""fair use\"" of the protected material as set out in the law, as well as a quote from the protected material in a reasonable manner\"". In addition, the bottom of the page makes a copyright claim to ”All rights reserved to the State of Israel - the Knesset or to third parties, as set out in midfield\"". The original submitter, other than generally stating that laws are in public domain provided no other convincing proof. The proof from the website indicates that the content is not in the open domain. Since for the purpose of this survey we are strictly concerned with online content, I am changing B7 to NO. ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The laws themselves only available in PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Laws and amendments are updated up to February 2017.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Going to the Knesset website and looking it in their site."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://main.knesset.gov.il/About/Pages/Copyright.aspx"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Knesset"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""All of the characteristics were very easy to find. Each law contains a \""Legislative History\"" which clearly describes its legislative progress since it was introduced as a bill. Amendments and the dates they were made are clearly identified.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://main.knesset.gov.il/Activity/Legislation/Laws/Pages/LawReshumot.aspx?t=LawReshumot&st=LawReshumotBook"",""descValue"":""The Israeli Legislation database""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is accepted. The dataset contains all the required characteristics. ","[Comment by original submitter]The legislative site will hopefully add an API in 2017.
[Comment by reviewer] One change that was needed was in B7 where I indicated that the content is not in the public domain. I made this decision purely on what was available on the website. The original submitter indicated that there is a law that laws should be in the public domain- but I do not see proof of this on the website. I also changed B8 to indicate that data is not available in HTML. The original submitter had selected HTML format even though they stated on the comment that the text of the laws is only available in PFD only (which is true). ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Juela Xhaferraj","45","45"
"6203d2b0-d0a9-4431-b772-363781e9ff1e","global","2016-12-15T22:01:35","2016","sv","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The list is available in .PDF format.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to cnr.gob.sv, then topics, then business register and then \""matriculas\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Centro Nacional de Registros (National Center of Registers)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.cnr.gob.sv/matriculas-organo-oficial-del-registro-de-comercio/"",""descValue"":""National Register of Enterprises""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The National Center of Registers website offers a list of enrolled Companies Registrations online for free, which is downloadable at once. However, the data are not up to date (latest data list is from the period of November-December 2016 and the date of last update is 20 January 2017; current date is 22/02/2017) as ""the contents and services offered by the Website are updated periodically"", and are not machine-readable as they are available in .PDF format. While the register is available for the entire country, the list contains only the names and registration numbers of companies, but not the addresses. Lastly, ""all texts, designs, forms and any other content or information contained in the Website are owned by the Centro Nacional de Registros and no person may exploit or communicate them publicly without prior authorization granted in accordance with the provisions of the Intellectual Property Law. Violation of these rights will result in the corresponding action and the claim for compensation for damages.""","All the information is available in PDF and is not update. ","Yes","No","The Next Services","Evangelia Kampouri","45","45"
"bd6a2a22-89b9-40f9-8eb7-779f1d1a212b","global","2017-02-22T17:37:14","2016","gt","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No statement of open license.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Each law is accessed separately. Amendments for each law are on a separate page. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is available up to February 2017.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""After landing on the Organismo Judicial website, it was easy to find the database. The only difficulty was in identifying which department actually provided the data. I found the relevant department through a link on the Congress webpage\nhttps://www.congreso.gob.gt/.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Followed link for Organismo Judicial from Congress website/Publicaciones/Leyes Resoluciones/Base de Datos/Normativa/Leyes Ordinarias"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The original submission had answered B1 with no and gave the rationale that Congress does not provide full texts of laws. This is true. But the data is still available, and it is instead made available by the Organismo Judicial (a government department) through the \""Centro Nacional de Análisis y Documentación Judicial\""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Organismo Judicial "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Content of the law and the date it came into force is identified.\nDate of last amendment can be derived by looking at the last entry on the chronological list of amendments. \nAmendments are listed on a separate page from the content of the law. The names of the amending laws, dates and the relevant sections with the corresponding text are made available. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.oj.gob.gt/index.php/publicaciones-oj/leyes-y-resoluciones"",""descValue"":""Page with link to national laws database""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission was rejected because it incorrectly stated that the government did not provide the data. The current submission is updated to indicate that all required characteristics could be found (on a different source from that used by the original submission).","The original submission was rejected because it stated that data was not available. As a reviewer I was able to find the data (it was just provided by a different government department). Accordingly, I filled out the rest of the survey with my findings (check comments for more information). ","Yes","No","Juela Xhaferraj","Juela Xhaferraj","45","45"
"7416265f-b217-444b-aa20-3a0f785dba5c","global","2016-12-19T15:50:48","2016","do","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google searched for \""Dominican Republic National Office of Industrial Property (ONAPI)\"" and looked through the website's options."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Office of Industrial Property (ONAPI)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name of an entity in order to find it.""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://onapi.gob.do/busqueda-consulta.html"",""descValue"":""National Office of Industrial Property (ONAPI) ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","According to the submitter, the Chamber of Commerce and Production of Santo Domingo does not have that information accessible on its website. They only claim to offer the opportunity to search registered companies by name. But the service is not available: https://www.camarasantodomingo.do/red-empresarial/busqueda/
However, I was able to find information online for free on the National Office of Industrial Property (ONAPI) website: https://onapi.gob.do/busqueda-consulta.html
Data are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name of an entity in order to find it. They include Company Number, State, Expedition, Holder, Manager, Address, Expiration date, and Activity. I also found access to data for free through a search mask on the Generate Directorate of Internal Revenue (DGII) website: https://www.dgii.gov.do/servicios/consultas/Paginas/RNC.aspx
But these only include National Taxpayer Registry (RNC) number, Business Name, Category, Payment Regime, and Status.
In both cases data are available in .HTML format and cannot be downloaded at once. How often or when they were last updated is also unknown. ","La Cámara de Comercio y Producción de Santo Domingo no tiene esa información accesible en su página web. Solo dicen ofrecer la oportunidad de buscar en su web las empresas registradas, por nombre. Pero el servicio no está disponible https://www.camarasantodomingo.do/red-empresarial/busqueda/.
","Yes","No","Miguel Reyes Taveras","Evangelia Kampouri","15","15"
"936e8a77-2583-4f6e-bfad-cc18046f2f4a","global","2017-02-22T16:26:03","2016","sv","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Assemblea Legislativa"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""URL: https://www.asamblea.gob.sv/sesion-plenaria/votaciones-electronicas""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission was rejected because two required characteristics were absent from the dataset. The current submission now indicates that ""Data is not available."" ","The original submission was rejected because two required characteristics are notavailable. Content of bill is missing. Status of the bill is also missing.
There is no way to search for a given bill. The only way to get an indication of bills being discussed is by looking at the archives of Legislative sessions since 2009 (which are listed chronologically) (
https://www.asamblea.gob.sv/sesion-plenaria/votaciones-electronicas). For each legislative session they provide a summary of the items discussed in the legislature on the day. The names of bills are mentioned, but not their content or the ensuing debate. Votes on bills per member of parliament and the author of a bill can be found on two separate documents “Electronic Voting” and “Correspondence”, respectively. It is worth mentioning that these documents provide an aggregate summary of all the items voted on/or introduced in the legislature on that day. They can only be found under the record of legislature proceedings for a given day.
The original submission had indicated that Votes on Bills and Status of Bills was available. However, even though some information is available as to the votes on bills and the authors, the information is not very useful as they are presented without context (other than the fact that the bill was introduced/voted on on a specific date). This information would be extremely difficult to find without knowing the date a particular bill was discussed or voted on in front of the legislature. Status of bills on the other hand could not be found at all.
The original submission also indicated the following:
- Downloadable at once: No
-Up to date: No
-Open license: No
-Readable format: No","Yes","No","Juela Xhaferraj","Juela Xhaferraj","0","0"
"665b197a-3fb9-41d7-9c40-7fdce3032a52","global","2017-02-22T16:20:08","2016","ca","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Single google search using the term 'canadian government procurement data'"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://open.canada.ca/en/open-government-licence-canada"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Buyandsell.gc.ca"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://buyandsell.gc.ca/procurement-data/tenders/download-tenders-data"",""descValue"":""Entitled \""Procurement Data\""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"No changes in the original submission.
Since it was originally approved, it appears as a new submission. ","Yes","Yes","Oscar Montiel","Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"535e1806-c29b-4f54-adb6-ad524161c407","global","2017-01-29T20:16:48","2016","cm","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Could not be verified, no link to license.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Each single tender needs to be downloaded separately""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched online, found the website in top search results. The website of the ARMP is quite difficult to manoeuver, I found the data by chance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Public Contracts Regulatory Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""A diagram explaining the public procurement process can be found here: https://armp.cm/Architecture_of_the_Public_Contracts_system.php#tzM11""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""An example of the datapoints can be found on this page: https://armp.cm/Details.php?P1=AO&P2=2937#A6\n\nTender status can only be implied from the open call, and the time the tender is open.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://armp.cm/Consultations_EN.php?P1=CON#tzM11"",""descValue"":""The source shows a list of tenders, each tender can be accessed or downloaded separately""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The advanced search shows a listing of the notices, you can download the PDF of the notices or look at the details in HTML format.
The status can only be implied from the call, and the time the tender is open. Depending on the status, the budget is included but not the amount of the contract. ",,"Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"8cd701ee-e1da-4dce-a1d2-2be25186b353","global","2016-12-15T03:41:53","2016","sv","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Changed to NO because there is no statement indicating information is in the public domain. The following appears at the bottom of the page: “Legislative Assembly El Salvador. All rights reserved”. \nThe original submission had indicated the following URL as proof: https://www.asamblea.gob.sv/eparlamento/indice-legislativo/buscador-de-documentos-legislativos\nBut I could not find any statements/proof on this page that the information is in the public domain.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The text of the laws can only be found in PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""In order to access amendments one must search for them individually and download them individually.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google Asamblea Legislativa de El Salvador > Clicked on eParlamento > Selected Documentos Legislativos > Búsqueda de Leyes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.asamblea.gob.sv/eparlamento/indice-legislativo/buscador-de-documentos-legislativos"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Legislative Assembly of El Salvador"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Made change to indicate that \""Amendments to the law\"" are available. At the bottom of each law all the amendments and respective dates are identified. It is then possible to find these amendments by searching the same database (URL in B2.2).""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.asamblea.gob.sv/"",""descValue"":""Legislative Assembly of El Salvador webage""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I am accepting the submission because after a review, I was able to verify that indeed all required characteristics for national laws were present in the dataset. ","[Comment by original submitter] You have to find the laws you want to start building your database from scratch!
[Comment by reviewer] I changed the original submission to indicate that the ""Amendment to the law"" were available. I found that it was easy enough to search (the same database) for the amendment listed and to obtain its full text. The record of amendments is also up to date (amendments passed within the last three months are recorded and made available online).
I also changed the submission to indicate that the information is not in open domain.
The texts of all the laws are only found in PDF format. The html webpage only provides the name of the law, the general topic, the date it was enacted, date of last amendment and a very short summary of the law. ","Yes","No","Omar Luna","Juela Xhaferraj","45","45"
"d6adb045-a8b0-4e56-a3b0-002419d6f9c4","global","2017-02-22T15:51:58","2016","bo","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Content of bills and status of bills can be found at: https://www.diputados.bo/index.php/leyes/leyes-en-tratamiento.\nBut data about author of bill is not always available. (As a reviewer I was \t\t\t\tactually not able to find the author on any bills, so I changed the original \t\t\t\tsubmission to indicate that this information was not available. All \t\t\t\t\tbills are actually written in the name of the Speaker of the House in which \t\t\tit originated- they do not show name of author). The Original Submission \t\t\t\tcorrectly indicated that information of votes on bills and transcript of \t\t\t\tdebates were not available. The status of each bill is not made explicit. \t\t\t\tBut the heading of the webpage states that these are bills not yet in force. The progress of the bills through the legislative progress can be traced by looking at the dated stamps on the first page of each bill which indicate receipt of the bill by each respective house.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Asamblea Legislativa Plurinacional Cámara de Senadores, Cámara de Diputados"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission was rejected because not all characteristics could be found. The previously published review was updated in order to accurately indicate that data is not available.","The original submission provided the URL for the Senate website (https://senado.gob.bo/legislativa) in addition to the website for the House of Deputies (www.diputados.bo/index.php/leyes/leyes-en-tratamiento). Although some data can be found on the Senate website, I used the website of the Deputies to review and score the submission because the Senate website provides very limited information. The Deputies website, however also covers the Senate (so in other words data for the Senate could still be found).
The author of the bills (a required characteristic) could not be found and so B2 was answered with ""No"" and original submission was rejected. It is also worth mentioning that two optional characterstics: Transcripts on Bills and Votes were also missing.
On the other hand two required characteristics could be found on the Deputies website: Content and Status of bills.
The following apply to the available data only:
-Free of charge: yes
-Downloadable at once: no
-Up to date: yes
- Open domain: no
- Format: PDF only. The original submission indicated that the data could be found on HTML. However, I changed this part of the submission because I could not find it on HTML. The only thing that is in HTML format is a very short summary of the bill. The actual bills are only available in PDF format.
","Yes","No","Juela Xhaferraj","Juela Xhaferraj","0","0"
"10c7e512-6f40-4b99-93d2-21ef6993db6b","global","2016-12-31T10:46:46","2016","kh","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is not in a machine readable format""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I did in-depth search in this website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Economy and Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The link to the official website https://www.mef.gov.kh/index.html""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.mef.gov.kh/old/procurement/bid-advertisement.php"",""descValue"":""Website of Ministry of Economy and Finance""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes in the submission. You can search for notices and download the pdf format.
No notice about licence. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"65499aa6-9460-4244-b4ea-e9efdb01da91","global","2017-01-15T17:56:35","2016","zm","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""-"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No evidence to be sure.""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"ok","Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"2d3ef028-4b21-4cb1-bff1-0f9c2c139150","global","2017-01-17T12:34:42","2016","zw","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"ok","Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"66dfb08f-a2c8-4eca-a25e-0f55ac0a4cb2","global","2016-12-05T21:54:23","2016","co","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""GeoJSON"",""KML"",""KMZ"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Updated Dec 1, 2016""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google for term site:www.datos.gov.co \""Límites administrativos\"" which searches under Data Portal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Entrar a IGAC y buscar los mapas temáticos""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://herramientas.datos.gov.co/es/terms-and-conditions-es"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Original submitter: https://www.igac.gov.co/wps/wcm/connect/0b3aa8004eef2fd4a7abf730262db5f2/Licencia_y_condiciones_de_uso_car.pdf?MOD=AJPERES\n\n- Data Portal has an open license""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Information and Communication Technologies"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Original Submitter:\nInstituto Geográfico Agustín Codazzi-IGAC""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.datos.gov.co/dataset/Limites-politico-administrativos-de-Colombia/wkym-ziuu/data"",""descValue"":""Data Portal \""Administrative Boundaries\""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Original submitter found below which is not very detailed:\nhttps://sigotn.igac.gov.co/sigotn/default.aspx - Sistema de información geográfica para la planeación y el ordenamiento territorial nacional""}]","Yes","Yes","The originally submission was corrected with a better more comprehensive version found in the Data Portal under the ""Administrative Boundaries"" search; published by Ministry of Information and Communication Technologies. The Data Portal has an open license as pointed by @paolamoz in the forum.
The data format list was expanded to cover the more formats available in this data portal. The data according to the metadata was from Dec 1 and thus is up to date.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","El Sistema de Información Geográfica para la Planeación y el Ordenamiento Territorial Nacional, constituye una organización de entidades, acuerdos y recursos tecnológicos que facilita el acceso y uso de información georreferenciada, con el propósito de contribuir a una eficiente y oportuna toma de decisiones por parte de las autoridades e instancias en el sistema de planeación, a nivel nacional, regional y local, en apoyo de una mejor gestión del desarrollo territorial.","Yes","Yes","Carlos Caicedo","Michael Leow","100","100"
"a7c7e39e-0e2e-4f77-a423-d54491e7966d","global","2017-01-20T20:54:56","2016","bs","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bahamas National Geographic Information Systems (BNGIS) "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Site: https://www.bahamas.gov.bs/wps/portal/public/bngis/bngis/!ut/p/b1/vZbJbqQ6FIafJQ_QwTbFtGSqgcEF2FDApkSNYYYaoODpu9LKou-9SrK4ET4Ly9J_9J3ze5CZmAmZuEq69Jzc0rpKivd1zG9dBbjEklh5IVgCWFGB8uZKA5zCMRsmBLMtycBlbQ55PRxUJ9DCXgqP1kEUHBNU2IQ6HGRKvLBsXCOhlXCrrmarOIVyczcGn-RNu9_E_LJJw8oo0yVXRlHZHovGq9vmHkWNWibIOEfJ_JJvjLYx7km1SN3EaOrYiNO4VU8JtyxUWSmQ04Fn0dGzaPDJkMFXPfES_Mj_TOBy_y__KfjW0_hLxHsFfwRftfgdJHoKhE8REDL0Y2eHZjXmo5eNLrTzARD9gcHoQzouQ0znBrklkOr9AKg_2pmBbV984Bxiets5h8DzFVkR76TafQNcgqmBaGogNzFQmtpS6ectNZg43ZWv_b58Ba9IkiSERJ57zjxiWYEJsoizVHHV6yu6TZu9hG5ovA1NpMzFs3t_zPNsR1zHPrM74VeX6GmYsdhWtrYmNyK2H29y74KsxGVhg3Y300sk1GtT906ytCHGXlJkGB6vYWJzm1Xpnefgfh9OdyCuY8NYNJyzq-pO05Ksd_vLVa6c4giFg48kteVvHaW-NgvFymsRD9ZpFJ7d02YXG0fOb8_1SA7FeTHs2eRuHJaiB1XR69RDlpU7IPK_CvGFwcu6PH7tOefN_uM5eNg2DRwCagB9aNt-RjFd9FesQqLpELz7nHkrrANg59eHLWkfnmsQFQP-DshNDRQmBgpoaiCcGshODMRTn1LMTw38-Wvxj7dvxkOEeJ7nEJrNEAuZ4MlyM7GvTVL2fha4mJw7SzpZ1L4E5Pn1CuimHmzWMGEETTUz6fMbRvT8SsjQWPpbgP1sPQ43YySdl_Wr0cwvYAVdfHLYw6wBb7O2XpS-ypuqGAxLa9hv93aQhe4IijCQXZmwFjz0Ly9MU3amafHecgz_iuOiK_8d8stvCY_PWg!!/dl4/d5/L2dBISEvZ0FBIS9nQSEh/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Confirmed the ""Bahamas National Geographic Information Systems (BNGIS) "" is the entity responsible for ""Administrative Boundaries"". However, there is no online datasets available.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Unable to identify an online government entity with the requisite data to fit the criteria of the survey.","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Michael Leow","0","0"
"14638521-754b-4458-b013-85ffffd18269","global","2016-12-15T11:14:12","2016","af","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""ARAZI. Afghanistan Indepdent Land Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","According to the website data exist but is not online (and there is not much data on the site anyway). ","The Land Authority does not publish any information on the land ownership.","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0","0"
"9c4dcefc-78b9-4728-9e3e-2c886f018c15","global","2016-12-21T16:18:17","2016","cl","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No visible license.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The file was uploaded in october 2015. There's no evidence of further updates.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to the IDE's website, then to download > layers > administrative boundaries"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""IDE - Ministerio de Bienes Nacionales"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The SHP file only has the internal administrative boundaries, it doesn't include coastal or international borders.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ide.cl/descarga/capas/item/limites-de-la-division-politica-administrativa-coordenadas-geograficas.html"",""descValue"":""IDE's download section""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","
Additional format support SHX + DBF was added as it is part of the shapefile. Additionally, there is proper Coordinates Projection support.
Corrected the field ""data being up to date"" as the metadata of the dataset indicates it is last updated April 2016 which is within the year.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
No clear license was stated for the dataset and was unable to find any national law that supports open license.
",,"Yes","No","Manuel Barros","Michael Leow","80","80"
"5fd5c9a8-00b6-487b-90fa-8b928c9d9846","global","2016-12-07T03:55:55","2016","au","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""TXT"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Dataset summaries are available for automated download.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Available from the home page. Navigate to particular locations. View information as webpage, maps, graphs."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.bom.gov.au/other/copyright.shtml"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bureau of Meteorology"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Precipitation Probability"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://reg.bom.gov.au/australia/charts/viewer/index.shtml "",""descValue"":""https://reg.bom.gov.au/australia/charts/viewer/index.shtml Bureau of Meteorology, Interactive Forecast maps for upcoming 7 days, map embedded as png file ""},{""urlValue"":""https://reg.bom.gov.au/catalogue/data-feeds.shtml#forecasts"",""descValue"":""7-day forecasts for districts, as well as towns and cities within districts. Files for towns and cities are available in bulk (published separately per district). The forecasts for 7 days include all data. Precise information for precipitation in separate dataset""},{""urlValue"":""ftp://ftp.bom.gov.au/anon/gen/fwo/IDN11051.txt"",""descValue"":""Text file containing all required information""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The initial submission was accepted, but with minor changes. More direct links to the data were added, to show where the data can be found.
Findability:
The website was fairly easy to find (first google result, when querying ""weather forecast data Australia"". The website displays ""data services"" on the homepage. Two clicks further users can find the FTP access page. It was a bit hard to understand that the required data are available without registration. The meteorological service provides various entry points to the data, and it was not immediately obvious which one to take for the assessement.
Data from the FTP server is available for free, as stated here: https://reg.bom.gov.au/reguser/
Bulk:
The data is separated per districts (including forecasts for several towns per district). Each file contains data over a certain timeframe, including all cities / towns of a district. There is a fair amount of data split across files. But the data can be directly addressed because they use consistent identifiers:
“Files are overwritten with each issue and file names are unchanging allowing for direct addressing.” See here: https://reg.bom.gov.au/catalogue/textforecasts.pdf
Therefore the data can count as bulk.
However, the data is usable for private use, redistribution is not allowed. Therefore the data is not openly licensed.
The original submitter indicated to be a ""national manager of weather services"". Thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Danny Lämmerhirt","80","80"
"6c2b22b0-e6cb-4994-9fe6-72be0b2db775","global","2017-02-20T09:29:50","2016","ca","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""GML"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Updated Nov 2016""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Statistics Canada Website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.statcan.gc.ca/eng/reference/licence"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Statistics Canada"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www12.statcan.gc.ca/census-recensement/2011/geo/bound-limit/bound-limit-2016-eng.cfm"",""descValue"":""2016 Census - Boundary files""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Original submitter put an earlier version.""}]","Yes","Yes","The link to the dataset was updated to the latest from Nov 2016 compared with the submission from the original which pointed to the 2011 dataset.
The available data format was increased to cover the .SHX and .DBF files that comes with the shapefile.
Other than the minor modifications above, all the rest checks out and is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Michael Leow","100","100"
"7aa935fe-a6f5-454c-bb52-d5494bf96d17","global","2016-12-31T10:12:06","2016","kh","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Land Management, Urban Planning and Construction (MLMUPC)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The link to the official website https://www.mlmupc.gov.kh/?page=?page=front&lg=kh""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"There are no evidence to confirm that the data exist. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"dbb81871-3b5f-4607-aa9d-2150a0b0a735","global","2017-01-27T16:27:23","2016","bo","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I could not find any link or text on the website show a license for this dataset.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""GML"",""GeoJSON"",""KML"",""SHP""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I visited the GeoBolivia website and accessed the map datasets I was interested in from the"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""GeoBolivia/ Vicepresidencia del Estado Plurinacional"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://geo.gob.bo/geoserver/web/?wicket:bookmarkablePage=:org.geoserver.web.demo.MapPreviewPage"",""descValue"":""direct download from the official geoserver""},{""urlValue"":""https://geo.gob.bo"",""descValue"":""GeoBolivia""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","ok!","Even though the layer preview in geoserver is not the friendlies interface for a non- GIS person, I think that with a little bit of attention anyone can download fast the datasets. ","Yes","No","David Opoku","Codrina Maria Ilie","80","80"
"e2fb344d-597f-4a05-93a6-b9741c5d89dc","global","2016-12-30T09:31:46","2016","bt","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.geo.gov.bt/Home/DataDetail?metadataId=75 copyright Exclusive right to the publication, production, or sale of the rights to a literary, dramatic, musical, or artistic work, or to the use of a commercial print or label, granted by law for a specified period of time to an author, composer, artist, distributor""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""SHP""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.geo.gov.bt/Home/DataDetail?metadataId=75 \nMaintenance and update frequency \tasNeeded""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Go to websites and look for particular informaiton"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.geo.gov.bt/Home/Data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Land Commission Secretariat"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Markings of national traffic routes"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.geo.gov.bt/"",""descValue"":""Link to Bhutan Geo-Portal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Executive Director, BMF","Codrina Maria Ilie","65","65"
"d845c0b4-1ccc-4285-856d-68a96003faa5","global","2016-12-15T11:50:11","2016","bd","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Following step"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://203.112.218.67/bbsdis/Home.aspx"",""descValue"":""Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics GIS Application""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The geoportal seems to be only for demographic statistics and the I couldn't find any administrative divisions, except the national border. Plus, the silverlight plugin crushes constantly when trying to download a pdf file. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","15","15"
"524baf64-c247-4a52-94ad-b0ef8e572d7a","global","2016-12-09T00:37:00","2016","au","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""KML"",""SHP""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""WMS, WMTS and ESRI REST versions are also available\nhttps://www.ga.gov.au/data-pubs/web-services/ga-web-services\n\n""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Topo250k Series 3 is the most recent release of the dataset.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google search, Geoscience Australia Search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.ga.gov.au/copyright"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Geoscience Australia material on their website is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International Licence, unless indicated.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Geoscience Australia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ga.gov.au/metadata-gateway/metadata/record/64058/"",""descValue"":""GEODATA TOPO 250K Series 3 (Shape file format)""},{""urlValue"":""https://services.ga.gov.au/gis/services/Topographic_Base_Map_WM/MapServer/WMSServer?request=GetCapabilities&service=WMS"",""descValue"":""Topographic Base Map Layers WMS""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ga.gov.au/gisimg/services/topography/NATMAP_Digital_Maps_250K_2008Edition/ImageServer/WMSServer?request=GetCapabilities&service=WMS"",""descValue"":""Topographic Base Map Image WMS""},{""urlValue"":""https://nationalmap.gov.au/#share=s-7XUy6CPlchUfm7VyhVxioydeCQt"",""descValue"":""NationalMap view of Topo250k dataset""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","OK","The datasets collated under the FSDF project will soon replace the Topo250k as the authoritative source for these datasets https://www.anzlic.gov.au/fsdf-themes-datasets ","Yes","Yes",,"Codrina Maria Ilie","100","100"
"2e7bc16f-d405-4fa4-af7a-2ea26936b658","global","2017-01-25T20:20:12","2016","ag","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Agriculture, Lands, Fishers and Barbuda Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","ok","The responsible organisation appears to be Ministry of Agriculture, Lands, Fishers and Barbuda Affairs however I was unable to identify a government portal for the given datasets.
","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"471ea928-981a-4339-a556-10b12a22bc8d","global","2016-12-07T14:37:50","2016","al","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""WMS protocol is not constructed in such a way to support a meaningful download, especially with this kind of data. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Web mapping services are provided. ""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""From the GeoPortal home page I clicked on the Map tab and it brought me to the National Map of Albania"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Autoriteti Shteteror per Informacionin Gjohapsinor"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://geoportal.asig.gov.al/Map.aspx?lang=EN"",""descValue"":""Map of Albania with subcategories""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Albania is providing WMS for a number of layers, including topographic maps at various scales. WMS protocol is not constructed in such a way to support a meaningful download, especially with this kind of data. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","45","45"
"e4e4ceb6-e5c7-4105-b9f6-a2c4ed0e0984","global","2017-01-29T19:42:45","2016","cm","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Chamber for commerce, industry, mining and craft (CCIMA), ministère camerounais de l’Economie, de la Planification et de l’Aménagement du territoire "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The website of Cameroon's Chamber for Commerce, Industry, Mining and Craft (CCIMA) appears to be down (www.minepat.gov.cm/). Like last year's index, there is no comprehensive list of companies in Cameroon. A list of companies that are verified by the National Statistics Office and the ""Ministère Camerounais de l’Economie, de la Planification et de l’Aménagement du Territoire"" shows companies with a revenue above 100 million francs. They are listed on the official website of the National Statistics Office: https://www.stat.cm/downloads/liste_entreprise_2012_fr.pdf
The list includes company name, acronym, city, address, telephone and fax numbers, e-mail address and website (where applicable), but no unique identifiers.","Like last year's index, there is no comprehensive list of companies in Cameroon. A list of companies that are verified by the national statistics office and the ""ministère camerounais de l’Economie, de la Planification et de l’Aménagement du territoire"" shows companies with a revenue above 100 million francs. They are listed on the official website of the national statistics office: https://www.stat.cm/downloads/liste_entreprise_2012_fr.pdf
","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"3d12e889-4d2c-4c46-8bec-b34fc2479b04","global","2016-12-12T23:47:06","2016","cl","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: licence is not clearly visible on National Statistics page (other government pages include license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/cl/)""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Unemployment: XLS\nPopulation: XLS\nUpdate: removed KMZ, CSV format (not found)""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Latest unemployment: 2010\nPopulation up to 2012, predictions 2013 onward""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Básicamente de acuerdo al concepto o materia que se requiere, se hace la indagación en la web, teniendo en cuenta que la web permite filtrar los tópicos esenciales que buscamos"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/cl/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Nacional de Estadísticas"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: replaced Ministerio Secretaría General de la Presidencia with Instituto Nacional de Estadísticas""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Update: added unemployment, removed GDP (unable to find, also looked on site of Central Bank)""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.cl/"",""descValue"":""Instituto Nacional de Estadísticas""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.cl/canales/chile_estadistico/mercado_del_trabajo/nene/cifrascomunales.php"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.cl/canales/chile_estadistico/familias/demograficas_vitales.php"",""descValue"":""Population data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Added link to National Statistics & removed open data portal (not source but pulls together links, doesn't have key data)""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Removed KMZ & CSV from list of data formats. Added links to specific data on population, unemployment. Removed GDP as not able to find data. Amended B7 to no as open licence exists on some government pages but is not present on National Statistics page. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Sophie Lafayette","65","65"
"5668228e-e685-412b-b894-8217803df174","global","2016-12-15T11:24:28","2016","af","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Geodezy and Cartography"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Indeed, no data available. The official website appears to not be working at all. ","There is a websiste...https://agcho.gov.af/fa....no data available online.","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0","0"
"676d08a8-0d74-4951-9fbd-3b546404c057","global","2016-11-10T13:58:36","2016","tw","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search on Taiwan's open data portal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.tw/license#eng"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Central Election Commission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.tw/node/13119"",""descValue"":""Election Results""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","Yes","lycurgus kk","Paola Mosso","100","100"
"63c94932-bc83-44df-8732-8040a1e5903f","global","2017-02-20T21:44:57","2016","na","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Namibia Meteorological Service"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No other comments to be added","The original submission was rejected. It referred to a website of the Namibia Weather Network. As the website itself states, the Network ""is an affiliation of professional personal weather stations located in Namibia. This website is neither affiliated with nor endorsed by the Namibian Meteorological Service or any other government agency."" It receives its data from Yr, the Norwegian Meteorological Institute.
The WMO lists the Namibia Meteorological Service as the official government agency. The official website is https://www.meteona.com.
Forecast data is available, but is was outdated. Clicking on forecasts for today and tomorrow (date February 20) users get to the same forecasts. These include wind strength and direction. Forecasts for today and the two following days do not contain information on wind. The data therefore does not qualify for the Index.
The data cannot be downloaded and is only available in written text or icons. The data is embedded in HTML, but icons do not have an adequate naming, to be easily interpretable, when being scraped.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"08752d02-239a-40e7-a03d-136b7c759879","global","2016-12-13T10:57:18","2016","bg","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""© 2017 National Statistical Institute""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Updated: Tables within website & data available in XLS & PDF reports""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Updated: yes, data can be downloaded as single file per data type""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Unemployment: quarterly \nGDP: quarterly \nPopulation: yearly""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I took the data from the 2015 index for the given country. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Statistical Institute (Национален статистически институт)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Added Bulgarian name ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.nsi.bg"",""descValue"":""National Statistical Institute ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.nsi.bg/en/content/6481/unemployed-and-unemployment-rates-national-level-statistical-regions"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.nsi.bg/en/content/11254/key-indicators"",""descValue"":""Key indicators, including GDP (English)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.nsi.bg/en/content/6593/population-demography-migration-and-projections"",""descValue"":""Population data (English)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Drenusha Myha for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Data available in XLS as well as PDF reports & website. Data can be downloaded as single XLS file per data type.",,"Yes","No","Drenusha Myha","Sophie Lafayette","80","80"
"107b705c-c271-42eb-8956-4e4c191ec8d8","global","2017-01-12T16:46:40","2016","bo","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""But you need full detail of information to make a request""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""But there are no dowloadable datasets.""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is not a dataset, just query forms.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""On the home page there are links in the sidebar that redirect to query forms."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""You need to have specific information about the company you're looking for.""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Fundempresa"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.fundempresa.org.bo/"",""descValue"":""Official website""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. However, information on online data availability and data update frequency has been updated.
Information on company data are available on the website FUNDEMPRESA, a non-profit foundation that operates the Trade Registry of Bolivia (Concesionaria del Registro de Comercio de Bolivia). On the home page there are links in the sidebar on the left (""Consulta de Empresas"") that redirect to query forms in the form of a pop-up window (https://www.fundempresa.org.bo/). Although the data are free of charge, they are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know an entity's name, business registration number, tax identification number, or operating license consultation in order to find it. The data include company name, registration number, legal and commercial address, operating license, phone number and e-mail address. The additional options of legal information (constitution and amendments, legal representatives, partners, kardex) and financial information also appear but if selected, the access is denied and one needs to be registered in order to access it. The data are in .HTML format and not downloadable at once as only one entity at a time can be viewed. Update frequency is not made known. FUNDEMPRESA holds all the rights provided by copyright law (2011).",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","15","15"
"98d83ac9-a354-418e-a431-6e77a3c9e340","global","2016-12-11T12:30:28","2016","ba","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Copyright statement exists in the footer.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Only available in PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Unemployment by month\nPopulation by year (latest 2015, published 2016)\nGDP every three months, latest Q3 2016""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried an online search engine for \""Statistics Agency Bosnia and Herzegovina\"". It is one of the results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Agencija za statistiku BiH (Agency for Statistics of Bosnia and Herzegovina)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.bhas.ba"",""descValue"":""Agencija za statistiku BiH (Agency for Statistics of Bosnia and Herzegovina)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bhas.ba/index.php?option=com_publikacija&view=publikacija_pregled&ids=1&id=5&n=Population"",""descValue"":""DEMOGRAPHY AND SOCIAL STATISTICS > Population""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bhas.ba/index.php?option=com_publikacija&view=publikacija_pregled&ids=1&id=2&n=Labour%20market&Itemid=&lang=en"",""descValue"":""DEMOGRAPHY AND SOCIAL STATISTICS > Labour market""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bhas.ba/index.php?option=com_publikacija&view=publikacija_pregled&ids=2&id=11&n=National%20accounts"",""descValue"":""ECONOMIC STATISTICS > National accounts""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Added additional link to main website for Agency""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Arianit Dobroshi for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. All data only found in PDF format. ",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Sophie Lafayette","60","60"
"8da36fa3-4020-4bb8-a53a-c4d851466b6a","global","2017-01-12T17:42:51","2016","bo","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Some data can be exported to XLS ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Population: 2012 onward projections \nUnemployment: latest 2010\nGDP: latest 2013, with 2014/2015 as predicted ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""There are links on the home page at sidebar and also tabs, you have deeply in the maps to obtain datasets in HTML or pdf files."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Nacional de Estadística de Bolivia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.gob.bo/"",""descValue"":""Instituto Nacional de Estadística - Official Website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.gob.bo/indice/indice.aspx?d1=0301&d2=6"",""descValue"":""Demographic statistics""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.gob.bo/indice/EstadisticaSocial.aspx?codigo=30406"",""descValue"":""Unemployment statistics""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ine.gob.bo/indice/indice.aspx?d1=0101&d2=6"",""descValue"":""GDP statistics""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Added additional links""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Additional links to specific data added. Select data can be downloaded as XLS. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Sophie Lafayette","65","65"
"f92396e2-8a32-48ca-aceb-1f0b7e34a429","global","2017-01-29T06:17:47","2016","cm","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Direction de la Météorologie Nationale du Cameroun "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The agency apparently runs several weather stations, with a significant amount of them being broken. \n\nhttps://cameroonvoice.com/news/news.rcv?id=6279 \n\nThis information might need another validation.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The link to the official website does not work: https://www.meteo-cameroon.net""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","According to the World Meteorological Organisation, Cameroon's official meteorological organisation is the 'Direction de la Météorologie Nationale du Cameroun'. The link to the official website, as indicated by the WMO, does not work: https://www.meteo-cameroon.net. An alternative website cannot be found on Google. There was no source of official weather forecasts available.",,"Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"1e71e0af-5859-409d-8a15-3a8b28fa9e66","global","2016-12-02T14:14:09","2016","bg","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""It's uploaded on the portal the next day after the election results are confirmed. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched in the opendata portal of the government"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://opendefinition.org/licenses/cc-zero/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Central Election Committee "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://opendata.government.bg/organization/centralna-izbiratelna-komisiq"",""descValue"":""Government open data portal""},{""urlValue"":""https://results.cik.bg/pvrnr2016/tur1/president/index.html"",""descValue"":""2016 President & Vice-President Elections portal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Submitter noted that results are uploaded on the portal the next day after the election results are confirmed. Navigation for results is straightforward. Data portal only contains data from 2015 and 2016. ",,"Yes","Yes","Boyan Yurukov","Paola Mosso","100","100"
"38b640ec-f21b-4bd1-ad7f-8f239b8b1f99","global","2016-12-31T10:20:11","2016","kh","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I checked the WMO register of meteorological organisations (https://www.wmo.int/cpdb/cambodia). The data are accessible from the homepage under the button \""City Forecast\"". "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Water Resources and Meteorology"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The link to the official website https://cambodiameteo.com/map?menu=3&lang=en""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.cambodiameteo.com/forecast?menu=116&lang=en&day=undefined&areaid=12"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Water Resources and Meteorology, City Forecast Page, Average temperature, wind speed and direction, as well as precipitation amount are displayed for three days ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission was changed, because 5-day forecasts are an optional data characteristic. Required are forecasts for the current day and the 3 following days.
Usability of data: The data of city forecasts, available at: https://www.cambodiameteo.com/forecast?menu=116&lang=en&day=undefined&areaid=12 are fairly easy to understand for humans (using icons). However there is no legend to interpret them. It is hard to derive the precipitation amount from the icons (checking the HTML code shows the names of the icons. These give some indication what the icons mean (""slight rain"")). Scraping is needed to make data usable.
The forecast data is represented as icons (png) embedded in HTML code. Since they can be individually addressed (and have a clear naming) it was accepted as HTML. Data cannot be downloaded at all.
Also there are neither an open license, nor terms of use displayed. It could not be verified whether data is in the public domain or not.","There are only 3-days of forecast and data visualised in a virtual map.","Yes","No","anonymous","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"05132e4e-0cb2-4468-8f3b-52002098464f","global","2016-12-30T09:24:32","2016","bt","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Economic Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
Bhutan's Company Registry Division falls under the Department of Industry, Ministry of Economic Affairs. Its function involves:
- Implement the provisions of the Companies Act of the Kingdom of Bhutan, 2000
- Formulate and enforce rules and regulations to implement the Companies Act
- Monitoring of companies
- Enforcement of Enterprise Registration Law upon adoption by Parliament
- Provide legal services to the Ministry
- Provide legal advice and guidance to the companies.
However, there are no data available on the Ministry's webpage and only the Company Registry's office number (https://www.moea.gov.bt/departments/contactus.php?id=2) and list of staff are provided (https://www.moea.gov.bt/who/whoiswho_division.php?divid=61&unit=2). No company dataset could be found online.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"12d360a0-87d7-4aa8-b191-bf06974076fe","global","2017-01-27T18:39:56","2016","bb","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""© Copyright 2016 Barbados Statistical Service""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Census document in PDF \nIndicator statistics within website main page""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is not readily downloaded but can be copied from the website\n""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Latest data on employment and population from 2010.\nLatest GDP from 2014.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""It was easy being connected to the data, by merely carrying out a google search for the keywords \""barbados national statstics\"" I found the Barbados Statistical Service website and the data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Barbados Statistical Service"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Statistical Service has a mandate to collect, compile, analyse, abstract and publish reliable and timely information relating to the social, economic and general activities or conditions of the inhabitants of Barbados. ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Very limited information available on GDP""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.barstats.gov.bb/"",""descValue"":""Barbados Statistical Service Homepage with 2014 GDP figure and unemployment rate for 2015""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.barstats.gov.bb/census/index.html"",""descValue"":""Barbados Population & Housing Census""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Alesha Aris for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. All downloadable information within PDF documents. ","The data is briefly captioned on the website; with the GDP value for 2014, unemployment rate for 2015 and population census for 2000. The lack of historical figures or even up to date ones limits online data to users","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Sophie Lafayette","30","30"
"6aeb88a1-0ad7-470f-9247-eb8d224f8638","global","2016-12-20T03:06:48","2016","cl","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Economía, Fomento y Turismo"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
Searching through the Santiago Chamber of Commerce's website, the Ministry of Finance's website, and the Open Data portal (https://datos.gob.cl) no information of interest could be found. The Ministry of Economy, Development and Tourism has a facility for checking whether company names are registered, which doubles as a search engine of sorts for registered companies and their ID numbers: https://www.empresaen1dia.cl/res.verificamarcasmp.aspx However, there is no evidence of more detailed company data being available. There is also an unofficial online directory of Chilean companies current to 2012, provided by the non-profit SOFOFA, which can be freely browsed: https://www.sofofa.cl/Net/DirectorioIndustrial/Consulta/WebForms/Buscar.aspx Company Name, Tax ID, Address/Postal/Web/E-mail Address, and Phone/Fax Numbers are available through a search mask, so it is necessary to know the name or Tax ID of an entity in order to find it.","The Ministry of Economy, Development and Tourism has a facility for checking whether company names are registered, which doubles as a search engine of sorts for registered companies and their ID numbers: https://www.empresaen1dia.cl/res.verificamarcasmp.aspx However, there is no evidence of more detailed company data being available.","Yes","No","Manuel Barros","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"11b00eb2-c821-4c93-85fc-06575defc038","global","2017-01-15T10:19:51","2016","bd","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""All data found within PDF documents""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Labor last updated 2013\nGDP updated yearly\nPopulation from last survey in 2011""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Need to search website step by step"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Added GDP and National unemployment""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.bbs.gov.bd/"",""descValue"":""Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bbs.gov.bd/site/page/dc2bc6ce-7080-48b3-9a04-73cec782d0df/Gross-Domestic-Product-(GDP)"",""descValue"":""Section on GDP""},{""urlValue"":""https://203.112.218.65/WebTestApplication/userfiles/Image/LatestReports/LabourForceSurvey.2013.pdf"",""descValue"":""Labour Force Survey 2013""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bbs.gov.bd/site/page/47856ad0-7e1c-4aab-bd78-892733bc06eb/Population-&-Housing"",""descValue"":""Section on Population""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Added additional links on GDP, Labour Force Survey, Population""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Nurunnaby Hasive for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Added links to specific data types. All data found within PDFs. ",,"Yes","No","Nurunnaby Hasive","Sophie Lafayette","45","45"
"1783373f-0a39-4f98-9fd7-3666cc056453","global","2016-12-08T23:06:59","2016","au","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The API provides functionality to export as CSV, XML and JSON.\n\nGDP is not currently available through the API""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google search to the ABS website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.abs.gov.au/websitedbs/D3310114.nsf/Home/%A9+Copyright?opendocument"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Unless otherwise noted, all material on the ABS website – except the ABS logo, the Commonwealth Coat of Arms, and any material protected by a trade mark – is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 2.5 Australia licence.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Australian Bureau of Statistics"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/abs@.nsf/mf/5206.0"",""descValue"":""5206.0 - Australian National Accounts: National Income, Expenditure and Product, Sep 2016""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/abs@.nsf/mf/6202.0"",""descValue"":""6202.0 - Labour Force, Australia, Oct 2016""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/abs@.nsf/mf/3101.0"",""descValue"":""3101.0 - Australian Demographic Statistics, Mar 2016""},{""urlValue"":""https://stat.data.abs.gov.au//Index.aspx?QueryId=96"",""descValue"":""API - Quarterly Population Estimates (ERP), by State/Territory, Sex and Age""},{""urlValue"":""https://stat.data.abs.gov.au//Index.aspx?QueryId=30"",""descValue"":""API - Labour Force""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","Yes",,"Sophie Lafayette","100","100"
"a6f0b253-884f-40b0-b727-aa792b81708b","global","2016-12-21T23:10:10","2016","ar","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Main statistics site © 2016\nCensus © 2002-2014\n""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Census data is available in XLS and PDF. GDP data is available in XLS. Unemployment data is available in CSV.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Last census 2010 - population 2010 onward is based on projections\nGDP updated quarterly\nUnemployment quarterly ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It´s difficult to find the data inside the website\n""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Serch in Google \""Estadísticas Nacionales\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Censo (INDEC)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://200.51.91.245/argbin/RpWebEngine.exe/PortalAction?&MODE=MAIN&BASE=CPV2010B&MAIN=WebServerMain.inl"",""descValue"":""Census data including national population""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.indec.gob.ar/nivel4_default.asp?id_tema_1=3&id_tema_2=9&id_tema_3=47"",""descValue"":""GDP data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.indec.gob.ar/bases-de-datos.asp"",""descValue"":""Unemployment data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.indec.gob.ar/nivel4_default.asp?id_tema_1=4&id_tema_2=31&id_tema_3=58"",""descValue"":""Section on unemployment""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.indec.gob.ar/nivel2_default.asp?id_tema=2&seccion=P"",""descValue"":""Section on population""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.indec.gob.ar/nivel4_default.asp?id_tema_1=3&id_tema_2=9&id_tema_3=47"",""descValue"":""Section on GDP""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Added additional links for sections on GDP, unemployment, and population""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Guido López Avakian for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Added additional links. ",,"Yes","No","Guido López Avakian","Sophie Lafayette","80","80"
"4ce36447-7ccd-4075-99f3-e88766b28328","global","2017-01-25T23:02:04","2016","ag","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF download format \n""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is highly outdated.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Having visited the Antigua and Barbuda’s Government Information and Services I was easily connected to the Statistics page"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Antigua and Barbuda's Government Information and Services"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data on national population and national unemployment can be found in latest (2001) census. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ab.gov.ag/detail_page.php?page=5 "",""descValue"":""Antigua and Barbuda Statistics""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ab.gov.ag/pdf/statistics_reports/statictics_glance2006-7.pdf"",""descValue"":""Glance at Statistics 2006-2007""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ab.gov.ag/pdf/statistics_reports/complete_census_summary_report.pdf"",""descValue"":""2001 Census of Population and Housing""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you Alesha Aris for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. All data found is within PDFs. Added link to 2001 Census of Population and Housing which includes additional data on population and unemployment - document is outdated (2001), in PDF format, and not easy to find and use data. ","Unfortunately the website did not include information suitable for this survey, also the data is heavily out dated","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Sophie Lafayette","45","45"
"9eb6f66d-c184-483b-a56a-e840b66a414e","global","2016-12-07T14:57:48","2016","al","statistics","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Licensed as: Copyright © 2012""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I searched National Statistics, Albania and the statistics website was the first option. I then clicked on Themes to show the different types of statistical categories."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""Copyright © 2012 Instituti i Statistikave - Tiranë | All Rights Reserved INSTAT |Bul.\""Zhan D'Ark\"", Nr .3 Tiranë, Shqipëri "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""INSTAT Republika e Shqiperise Instituti i Statistikave"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""National unemployment"",""National population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.instat.gov.al"",""descValue"":""INSTAT (Institute of Statistics)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.instat.gov.al/en/themes/national-accounts.aspx"",""descValue"":""Gross Domestic Product""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.instat.gov.al/en/themes/labour-market.aspx"",""descValue"":""National unemployment""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.instat.gov.al/en/themes/population.aspx"",""descValue"":""National population""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Updated link to main site & added links to specific data sets""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is valid, thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. Data is not openly licensed/in public domain.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Sophie Lafayette","65","65"
"d28b1e47-cbdd-4132-bda6-8737acaf90ef","global","2017-02-20T16:23:54","2016","bt","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Hydro Met Services"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No other comments to add.","The initial submission was rejected because the homepage of Bhutan's Department of Hydro Met Services (see: https://www.hydromet.gov.bt) only provides temperature forecasts (as icons).
There is a ""download"" button on the homepage. It leads to a data request form which needs to be sent via fax or post. Data is therefore not accessible without need to request data.
It could not be verified which data are accessible by government. Therefore the data does not qualify for review.
Thank you for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. ","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"60eb3d64-add7-46d7-a1e8-8fa1c84128f7","global","2017-01-17T05:27:54","2016","ca","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""It's the first result for the Google terms: canada corporations open data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://open.canada.ca/en/open-government-licence-canada"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Industry Canada"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://open.canada.ca/data/en/dataset/0032ce54-c5dd-4b66-99a0-320a7b5e99f2"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
Information on Federal Corporation is available through Industry Canada (current organization name: Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada) on Canada's Open Government portal under the Open Government Licence - Canada. Data are freely available online in .XML format and can be downloaded all at once in a single .ZIP file. They contain information such as company name, identification number, and address, and are updated on a weekly basis. However, the dataset does not include information about corporations created under financial legislation (such as financial institutions, insurance companies or loan and trust companies) or those created under provincial, territorial or other corporate legislation. The dataset provider has not responded as to where such information can be found.",,"Yes","Yes","James McKinney","Evangelia Kampouri","100","100"
"81695f83-d420-496f-8c7a-4cecee586653","global","2016-12-05T11:58:43","2016","jp","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""TXT""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""You can download dataset from each respective ministry web site.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""If you understand Japanese, you googled for the data and found the data in the first search result."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.clb.go.jp/english/rules_en.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Cabinet Legislation Bureau"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Vote results and transcripts are published at parliament web site (available only in Japanese)""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.clb.go.jp/contents/index.html"",""descValue"":""Cabinet legislation bureau - Japanese Site""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.clb.go.jp/english/index.html"",""descValue"":""Cabinet legislation bureau - English (home page only)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The content of the legislation is not available directly on the Cabinet Legislation Bureau website. It is posted by each of the ministries relevant to the legislation on their respective website (Ministry of Justice, Ministry of Public Management, etc.)
Each ministry website is clearly and visibly linked beside the legislation on the Cabinet Legislation Bureau website.","Draft legislation is available only in Japanese.","Yes","Yes","Kentaro Hatori","Anton Shaffer","100","100"
"0a68a3d8-58b8-4147-851b-57a4ad6ef99a","global","2016-12-05T11:33:51","2016","jp","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""TXT"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""PDF download also available. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled for the data and found the data in the first search result."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.japaneselawtranslation.go.jp/index/terms_of_use/?re=02"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.japaneselawtranslation.go.jp/?re=02"",""descValue"":""English Site""},{""urlValue"":""https://law.e-gov.go.jp/cgi-bin/idxsearch.cgi"",""descValue"":""Japanese Site""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
All information within the submission is correct. ","Now you can download XML file of laws with bulk at once. ","Yes","Yes","Kentaro Hatori","Anton Shaffer","100","100"
"f1c21806-f2d6-4ba1-9cb0-d26e7bdf9996","global","2017-01-27T20:25:29","2016","cr","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Public Health, Ministry of Environment, Energy and Telecommunications "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","There is one more monitoring agency but no data, added it. Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","There are laws and regulations that establish the obligation for the Ministry of Health to maintain controls on water quality. Specifically, it is established that there should be a semi-annual report, but the data was not found.
Originally submitted by Susana Soto","Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"08d6f633-7d87-47c9-9ae4-3d167fc7ec07","global","2016-12-12T14:08:52","2016","id","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Most laws are in PDF format.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Through google search. I was informed by a friend who contributed in building this portal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Law and Human Rights"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Reviewer: Amendments and history of specific laws are presented in a visual timeline based on year. Nice feature.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://peraturan.go.id/"",""descValue"":""The regulations database of Indonesia""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
• B5 modified original answer to No from Yes. Dataset is not downloadable at once.","Most of the law documents are still in PDF format. Some of the are available in HTML","Yes","No","anonymous","Anton Shaffer","45","45"
"e90c7d04-1b93-4519-afbd-35141f19ef29","global","2016-12-08T17:49:45","2016","ba","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""For the Federation in:\n© 2001-2016. Federal Hydrometeorological Institute\n(under the menu https://www.fhmzbih.gov.ba/latinica/PROGNOZA/P-klima.php))\n\nFor RS: \nThe institution has the copyright on the content of these web pages. By the Institute are authorized to view, download, print, copy, distribute and use the content published on this website under the following conditions: no modifications were made without the prior written approval of the Institute and the materials are used solely for information purposes and for personal or non-commercial purposes. \n\nhttps://rhmzrs.com/info/%D1%83%D1%81%D0%BB%D0%BE%D0%B2%D0%B8-%D0%BA%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%B8%D1%88%D1%9B%D0%B5%D1%9A%D0%B0.html""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No uniformity for the two entities. See comment under B3. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Not so for Srpska.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried a web search engine for the \""Hidrometeorological Institute of Bosnia and Herzegovina\"". A national website links to the two entity websites. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No consistency. See comment under B3. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal Hydrometeorological Institute, Hydrometerological Institute of the Republic"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""For the Federation, only current and three following days are provided in XML.\n\nFor Srpska, current day and 4-5 following days are provided as a map overlay and in PDF.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.fhmzbih.gov.ba/RSS/FHMZBIH1.xml"",""descValue"":""Federalni hidrometeorološki zavod""},{""urlValue"":""https://fhmzbih.gov.ba/RSS/FHMZBIH1.xml"",""descValue"":""Federal Hydrometeorological Institute, link to XML file, fields for precipitation amount are empty""},{""urlValue"":""https://fhmzbih.gov.ba/latinica/PROGNOZA/P-trodnevna.php"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Meteorological activities in Bosnia and Herzegovina are carried out by the two entity institutes.\n\n""}]","Yes","Yes","The initial submission was altered. Precipitation is provided, but not as numerical values. It is only shown as verbal indications such as (""there can be sporadic showers""). Wind speed is contained in an XML file, but no wind direction, which is only provided in verbal form here: https://fhmzbih.gov.ba/latinica/PROGNOZA/P-trodnevna.php
Information is split across pages, and stored in different data types (numbers, text, icons without legend) which makes it harder to retrieve a comprehensive overview of the data. Also since not all data is provided in XML, the data is not considered to be fully machine-readable.
The Federal Hydrometeorological Institute shows © 2001-2016
(under the menu https://www.fhmzbih.gov.ba/latinica/PROGNOZA/P-klima.php))
The data cannot be modified, and can only be used after agreement of the institute. Therefore the data is not compliant with the Open Definition (data must be modifiable) https://fhmzbih.gov.ba/latinica/O-NAMA/FHMZ-uslovi.php
Usability of data:
XML data is easily usable, but contains empty fields for precipitation amount. Precipitation icons on this webpage are consistently named and can be scraped, but there is no legend that makes them interpretable.
Thank you, Arianit Dobroshi, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"0b5c0847-f848-41df-a317-820f4f92a34a","global","2017-01-29T18:35:05","2016","cm","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched for carte administrative"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""MINISTERE DE L'ADMINISTRATION TERRITORIALE ET DE LA DECENTRALISATION"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://minatd.cm/index.php/fr/le-ministere/carte-administrative"",""descValue"":""MINISTERE DE L'ADMINISTRATION TERRITORIALE ET DE LA DECENTRALISATION""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Concur with the original submitter that only Boundary 1 + 2 is available as a static map image; missing all other characteristics. The data is not easily downloadable, does not have any open data format.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Administrative boundaries are available for level 1 and 2, yet only as images embedded on a website","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Michael Leow","30","30"
"e1fb6c54-eff2-4851-8650-17f4c8123681","global","2016-11-25T07:33:41","2016","rs","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Wind data is not displayed in HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search engine, appearance on the first page."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Republic Hydrometeorological Service of Serbia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Precipitation Probability"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.hidmet.gov.rs/eng/osmotreni/naslovna.php"",""descValue"":""weather, hydrological data and analysis""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.hidmet.gov.rs/eng/prognoza/index.php"",""descValue"":""2-day Forecasts available, showing temperature extremes and precipitation (icons)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.hidmet.gov.rs/eng/prognoza/stanica.php?mp_id=13278"",""descValue"":""5-day forecast available, showing temperature extremes and precipitation (icons)""},{""urlValue"":""https://rhmzrs.com/%D0%BC%D0%B5%D1%82%D0%B5%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%BB%D0%BE%D0%B3%D0%B8%D1%98%D0%B0/%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%B3%D0%BD%D0%BE%D0%B7%D0%B0-%D0%B2%D1%80%D0%B5%D0%BC%D0%B5%D0%BD%D0%B0.html"",""descValue"":""Hydrometerological Institute of the Republic, homepage with weather map, indicates temperature and precipitation. Wind speed is missing ""},{""urlValue"":""https://rhmzrs.com/service/%D0%BC%D0%B5%D1%82%D0%B5%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%BB%D0%BE%D1%88%D0%BA%D0%B8-%D0%B1%D0%B8%D0%BB%D1%82%D0%B5%D0%BD%D0%B8.pdf"",""descValue"":""Hydrometerological Institute of the Republic of Serbia, link from homepage to PDF file, contains all required information, but in verbal form (no numerical data)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission was altered as follows:
More links to the data were added. There are two websites presenting forecast data.
Data is considered to be downloadable at once, since forecasts for all reuqired information can be downloaded as PDF. However, the forecasts are fairly unprecise, meaning that the PDF file only contains verbal descriptions of wind direction and strength (""strong wind from southwest)"" as well as precipitation amount (strong precipitation).
Data usability: Temperature data is published in HTML. PDF contains all required data. It is not obvious whether the PDF follows a consistent structure. Therefore I agree with the initial submission that extensive effort would be required to parse information.
Data cannot only be used for informational or private purposes, after the right to reuse the data has been granted by the agency. The data is therefore not compliant with the Open Definition's claim for unrestricted reusability.
Thank you, Aleksandar Ivić, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Hydromet is aware of Open Data initiative but capacity and willingness are lacking.","Yes","No","Aleksandar Ivić","Danny Lämmerhirt","60","60"
"43c5226a-135b-49a9-9cbe-c4170cd3ca90","global","2016-12-31T10:39:05","2016","kh","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Original submitter answered 'No' but there exists.""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Cambodia National Mekong Committee"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Site is found here: https://portal.cnmc.gov.kh:8080/cnmc/index""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""There is no information nor evidence shown that the data exist"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://portal.cnmc.gov.kh:8080/cnmc/search/search?q=administrative&format=&max=5&offset=0&sort=title&order=ASC&pd=Administrative+Boundaries&t=Administrative+Boundaries"",""descValue"":""Search result for \""Administrative Boundaries\""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submitter did not find that there is a body called ""Cambodia National Mekong Committee"" which has the ""Administrative Boundaries"" online, this was corrected.
Since the dataset needed to be obtained via a cart which needs registration, it is deemed not available online without registration.
However, what was discovered is even after registering an account and checking out the cart for the needed dataset; no data was delivered via email, thus data is deemed inaccessible.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","There is no information nor evidence shown that the data exist","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","0","0"
"4d4340dd-964b-40d0-a898-c51823a55213","global","2017-01-31T15:48:14","2016","bo","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data cannot be downloaded. At the moment of review, the data section of the website did not display any content.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The submission stated that data is not up to date. However, during the moment of review, updated information for current day and following days was available. Therefore the answer was changed to \""Yes\"".""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Looked for \""Bolivia weather\"" in Spanish, found a government link and followed it. In the \""Information systems\"" you can find the link to Sismet."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Servicio Nacional de Meteorología e Hidrología"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Not all data is available for all the stations""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.senamhi.gob.bo/sismet/index.php"",""descValue"":""Sistema de Procesamiento de Datos Meteorológicos""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.senamhi.gob.bo/p_diario.php?ciudad=Sucre&pais=Bolivia"",""descValue"":""Servicio Nacional de Meteorología e Hidrología, Contains bar charts for some weather forecasts (excluding wind direction).""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.senamhi.gob.bo/extendidof.php?ciudad=Sucre&pais=Bolivia"",""descValue"":""Servicio Nacional de Meteorología e Hidrología, detailed forecasts, containing all information. ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.senamhi.gob.bo/tiemporeal.php"",""descValue"":""Servicio Nacional de Meteorología e Hidrología, this is a data pages, however it does not display content""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The initial submission is correct, with exception of one point. The data is considered to be timely. The submission stated that data is not up to date. However, during the moment of review, updated information for current day and following days was available. Therefore the answer was changed.
The website contains a data section. Yet, at the moment of review, the data section of the website did not display any content. Data cannot be downloaded.
The following webpage served as reference data, and all questions were applied to it: https://www.senamhi.gob.bo/extendidof.php?ciudad=Sucre&pais=Bolivia
The website also provides historical data, see here: https://www.senamhi.gob.bo/sismet/index.php
The website does not display an open license, but shows a copyright notification. It could not be assessed whether weather data is in the public domain.","Not available for download","Yes","No","anonymous","Danny Lämmerhirt","45","45"
"ab4e51b6-86ba-45ac-beed-32ff62b12ad8","global","2017-01-13T22:35:02","2016","uy","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX"",""WFS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Navigate agency web site"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.agesic.gub.uy/innovaportal/v/161/1/agesic/ley_n%C2%BA_18381.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""See art. 4""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Dirección Nacional de Catastro"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://catastro.mef.gub.uy/12360/10/areas/geocatastro.html#shape"",""descValue"":""Shape files of each department boudaries, and national boundaries""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission was accepted because the data set was confirmed to be where the submitter linked, is easily downloadable and its open license was pointed to a national law on openness.
The dataset was last updated within the year (10/2016). The format was amended with two additional DBF, and SHX which comes with the shapefiles.
Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Michael Leow","100","100"
"db42a777-df5a-4403-886a-5c1b0d5daacd","global","2016-12-15T22:46:25","2016","sv","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""We asked the Ministry of Natural Resources and they express that they work with a limited budget."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","ANDA is the water provider but they do not report quality: https://www.anda.gob.sv/informes/","Yes","No","The Next Services","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"49708505-bf43-4a25-b765-d0fe4fd3a8ac","global","2016-12-11T10:59:37","2016","hr","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Controlled at 3 levels: Water Works, county institutes of public health and National Institute of Public Health"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Based on comments made here https://discuss.okfn.org/t/croatia-global-open-data-index-2016-correct-data-and-comments/4205","Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"0bd07e8e-4a6a-41b8-abad-29e34f0f4ad9","global","2017-02-19T08:50:06","2016","cl","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google Chile water quality, link is on the front page of SISS page. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Superintendencia de Servicios Sanitarios"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Arsenic"",""Fluoride levels"",""Nitrates"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Data per water source""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.siss.gob.cl/577/w3-propertyvalue-3525.html"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Rejected original submission found data through own research. ","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","50","50"
"12b831c7-b1c9-4143-9c19-12a66d6aa298","global","2017-01-18T21:37:41","2016","bw","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Only found data contain dam levels and water availability. Did not find data on water quality.""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"61b6036a-031a-4250-9659-df684d175d93","global","2017-01-31T16:08:16","2016","bo","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Viceministerio de Agua Potable y Saneamiento Basico"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","There is a law that mentions the Viceministerio is in charge of this but the data isn't found nowhere in their page.","Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"b99f6e45-4df3-487b-a410-148dd51e26e5","global","2017-01-14T12:13:18","2016","pt","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No license is mentioned on the website.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""You can search by month and zone but there is no easy way to extract information in bulk.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The data seems to be updated every month.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched on google for polution + portugal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""QualAr"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://qualar.apambiente.pt/"",""descValue"":""Online database over Air quality in Portugal""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.pordata.pt/Subtema/Portugal/Polui%C3%A7%C3%A3o+Atmosf%C3%A9rica+e+Clima-86"",""descValue"":""PORDATA information on several atmospheric and climate polution ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is also another source with complementary information from PORDATA (which is neither open nor provides data in a easy to read format)""}]","Yes","Yes","Accept submission: All information was confirmed in the source.","A lot of the data is only filled for the bigger cities/locations.","Yes","No","Tiago Vieira","Ricardo Alanís","45","45"
"c0fc4b28-9774-4a25-bdd8-b27fb8ce8d2d","global","2017-02-02T20:31:32","2016","pe","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Reviewer: No direct reference to a open license.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Looked for the maps in google, then tried to find information in different parts of the ministry, there is a section with yearly reports. Only found information until 2009"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Reviewer: Revised this to reflect the effort of HTML source data to be useful.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio del Ambiente"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://sinia.minam.gob.pe/indicador/1405"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://infoaire.minam.gob.pe:1013/INFOAIRE/estacion?codigo=10&fecharegistro=21/12/2016%2012:00"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Reviewer: Added another source, https://infoaire.minam.gob.pe:1013/INFOAIRE/estacion?codigo=10&fecharegistro=21/12/2016%2012:00""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted with revision: Added an HTML data source with rich information but hard to get the data out of it.","Annual report until 2009","Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Ricardo Alanís","65","65"
"e3ab2fd7-3edd-40a4-bc5d-17194d1e2382","global","2016-12-15T22:41:42","2016","sv","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Looking thru google... spent to much time on it. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Confirmed this is the only data available.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.snet.gob.sv/googlemaps/calidadaire/monitoreo.php"",""descValue"":""Air quality report""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted without corrections. No more data sources available. ","Cant be download easyly. Its hard to find and it includes only the information of one city. ","Yes","No","The Next Services","Ricardo Alanís","45","45"
"40f2c8e2-84b7-4e61-bf54-ab5329b317d8","global","2016-11-25T17:05:17","2016","br","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Reviewer: No direct reference to a open license done.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I couldn't obtain data in machine readable format as demanded by the methodology, only in PDF and for visualizing plotted in an online map. .XLS and. SHP files could be obtained for the Amazon Region, but it is not per air monitoring station, not for all pollutants and it is outdated.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The dataset is not downloadable. All data is available for visualization in the web (first link) or in a report in pdf. The only link that permits data download in the third, which is only for the Amazon Region.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data provided by the MMA is from 2012. The real time data in the map from INPE doesn't show the values, So I didn't consider here for this question.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Information is very disaggregated, it took me a lot of time to come with all these links I found, and I had to ask a specialist for help.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1) Search in google for pollutant emissions data in Brazil, but this was not very successful; 2) Ask a specialist for more information; 3) Come with the INPE website where I found most of the information; 4) Search for information in the Ministry of Environment website; 5) Look for insights in 2015 index to compare; 6) Look for more information in other administrative levels; 7) Aggregate information to see what was more relevant."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.mma.gov.br/images/arquivo/80060/Diagnostico_Rede_de_Monitoramento_da_Qualidade_do_Ar.pdf"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The link is not for a license, it is the same link provided for the report from MMA. In its page 5 it says that Federal Law nº 10.650/2003 required that the National System of Environment published yearly reports on air quality, being compulsory its publication in official internet websites.\nAs for data from the Amazon Region, from INPE, there is \""other\"" attribution license, as can be seen at this link: https://dados.gov.br/dataset/inpe-em/resource/6ec5237b-dc27-4489-8ad2-17ff7548dbf6""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The comprehensive data is available only in PDF format or in a plotted dynamic map on the web, so the data is not at all ready to use.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Nacional de Pesquisas Espaciais (INPE); Ministério do Meio Ambiente (MMA)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Information on this topic is disaggregated in many different sources. I listed here the two main sources that I found. INPE (roughly translated as National Institute for Spatial Research) is a government agency of the Ministry of Science, Technology, Innovation and Communications and MMA is the brazilian Ministry of Environment.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I found all the information required per air monitoring station in the document from MMA (the second link) above, but it is on .PDF format and it is outdated (2012). Information in real time (the first link) is not available per air monitoring station and is missing for Sulphur oxides.\n\nReviewer: No data found on NOx in the quality required.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://meioambiente.cptec.inpe.br/index.php?lang=pt"",""descValue"":""Map provided by INPE with real time information on air quality and emissions covering the entire territory. Data is not downloadable.""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.mma.gov.br/images/arquivo/80060/Diagnostico_Rede_de_Monitoramento_da_Qualidade_do_Ar.pdf"",""descValue"":""Report provided by MMA with data per air monitoring station for the entire territory. In PDF and outdated (2012).""},{""urlValue"":""https://inpe-em.ccst.inpe.br/conteudo_pt/downloads.html"",""descValue"":""Data provided by INPE on emissions for the Amazon region, downloadable in .xls format.""},{""urlValue"":""https://seriesestatisticas.ibge.gov.br/series.aspx?vcodigo=IU5&t=concentracao-poluentes-ar-areas-urbanas-1"",""descValue"":""Statistical series by IBGE on emissions of some pollutants per metropolitan region. Downloadable in .xls format, but outdated.""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ibram.df.gov.br/images/Monitoramento%20fixo-%20Agosto%202016.pdf"",""descValue"":""Weekly Report on air quality monitoring by the Federal District Government. In PDF only for two pollutants. Subnational level.""},{""urlValue"":""https://sistemasinter.cetesb.sp.gov.br/Ar/php/boletim_por_poluente.php"",""descValue"":""Real Time data on air quality monitoring by the State Government of São Paulo. No download option, only for six pollutants. Subnational level.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Here I listed not only the two main sources I'm using but all the other relevant information I found, from other sources. I included subnational level links as examples of better practices beyond the Federal government.""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepting Submission, on the basis made by the Local Researcher. Made some corrections on the available data and the note of lack of direct license being described with the data.","As I said before, there are many different sources of pollutant emissions data in Brazil, but any of them seems to comply with the methodology of the open data index.
I would just like to point out some of the information I could get apart from what I focused during the process of filling the survey.
1) All information of the MMA can be obtained through this link: https://www.mma.gov.br/cidades-sustentaveis/qualidade-do-ar
2) In August 2016, the MMA complied with the creation of a transparency platform for pollutant emissions data, but it is not yet available.
https://www.brasil.gov.br/meio-ambiente/2016/08/sistema-nacional-traz-transparencia-aos-dados-de-emissao-de-poluentes
3) Data on pollutant emissions by vehicles since 1980 until 2012 is also published in pdf format by the MMA:
https://www.mma.gov.br/images/arquivo/80060/Inventario_de_Emissoes_por_Veiculos_Rodoviarios_2013.pdf
4) INPE produces the map (https://meioambiente.cptec.inpe.br/index.php?lang=pt) but also information on the Amazon region downloadable in .xls format (https://inpe-em.ccst.inpe.br/), which is also available in the brazilian open data portal (https://dados.gov.br/dataset/inpe-em/resource/6ec5237b-dc27-4489-8ad2-17ff7548dbf6)
5) IBGE used to have periodic research on emissions, but it seems to be outdated for most of the metropolitan regions (https://seriesestatisticas.ibge.gov.br/series.aspx?vcodigo=IU5&t=concentracao-poluentes-ar-areas-urbanas-1)
6) This kind of data has better quality in the subnational level. I put here two examples I found, which is from the Federal District (https://www.ibram.df.gov.br/informacoes/meio-ambiente/qualidade-do-ar.html) and from the State of São Paulo (https://sistemasinter.cetesb.sp.gov.br/Ar/php/boletim_por_poluente.php). There should be a kind of aggregation of subnational level data.","Yes","No","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Ricardo Alanís","30","30"
"a96ef1b8-3012-48f8-a358-50cf03c930ef","global","2016-12-08T19:24:14","2016","ba","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""For the Federation in:\n© 2001-2016. Federal Hydrometeorological Institute\n(under the menu https://www.fhmzbih.gov.ba/latinica/PROGNOZA/P-klima.php))\n\nFor RS: \nThe institution has the copyright on the content of these web pages. By the Institute are authorized to view, download, print, copy, distribute and use the content published on this website under the following conditions: no modifications were made without the prior written approval of the Institute and the materials are used solely for information purposes and for personal or non-commercial purposes. \n\nhttps://rhmzrs.com/info/%D1%83%D1%81%D0%BB%D0%BE%D0%B2%D0%B8-%D0%BA%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%B8%D1%88%D1%9B%D0%B5%D1%9A%D0%B0.html""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""For the Federation, an HTML table of averages is provided. Annual report is in PDF.\n\nFor Srpska, daily HTML list is provided. Monthly reports are in PDF. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Reviewer: No, data is only available to 2013.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""\n""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I found them while looking for the meteorological data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal Hydrometeorological Institute and Hydrometerological Institute of the Republic"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This work in Bosnia and Herzegovina is carried out by the two entity institutes.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Reviewer: Could not find data for SOx, CO and O3.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.fhmzbih.gov.ba/latinica/AKTUELNI/A-zrak.php"",""descValue"":""Federal Hydrometeorological Institute""},{""urlValue"":""https://rhmzrs.com/%D0%B5%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%BB%D0%BE%D0%B3%D0%B8%D1%98%D0%B0/%D0%BC%D1%98%D0%B5%D1%81%D0%B5%D1%87%D0%BD%D0%B8-%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%B5%D0%B3%D0%BB%D0%B5%D0%B4%D0%B8/"",""descValue"":""Hydrometerological Institute of the Republic""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""See comment under B1.1.""}]","Yes","Yes","Accepted with slight modifications on what is available.",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Ricardo Alanís","45","45"
"7918f62d-3bb0-42f9-8b95-409a58ac978d","global","2016-12-20T19:40:45","2016","cl","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""All rights reserved.\nReviewer: Whole site All rights reserved license found.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""TXT"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""In the map you can select a station and then the \""Ficha\"" option to enter the station site or the \""Hourly concentrations\"" options to see the detailed record. Also you can click on the \""Download CSV\"" option.\nReviewer: historical data is available""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Some data is updated regularly. Specially the PM data.\nReviewer: Almost real time is available.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to the old index and noticed that the RETC website wasn't updated and that RETC is not the responsible for the daily measurement of this data. Then went to the SINCA website -which is the responsible agency for this information- and checkout for the data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Sistema de Información Nacional de Calidad del Aire (SINCA) Ministerio del Medio Ambiente"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Reviewer confirms that only VOCs are missing.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://sinca.mma.gob.cl/"",""descValue"":""SINCA""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Confirmed all the points covered by this review.",,"Yes","No","Manuel Barros","Ricardo Alanís","80","80"
"4a7a9ca3-0aba-45f4-98fb-f9f15dfbf747","global","2017-01-24T20:23:52","2016","ve","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This was confirmed by the reviewer.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""N/A"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Open data is confirmed as non existent.","There is a law, there are reports of the air quality in certain cities but no centralized data set of air quality.","Yes","No","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"2ea8f5df-33ea-40bb-a760-8bea9c7a6280","global","2016-12-15T11:19:35","2016","af","emissions","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Envionement Protection Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Confirmed data as non existant.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Ricardo Alanís","0","0"
"474d68c0-ca88-4687-ad98-bbcc98ac47f3","global","2016-11-30T12:49:29","2016","at","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""JSON""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""API, asmx\n""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Through an API, see https://www.data.gv.at/katalog/dataset/7b30d15c-54b2-4cf5-bba3-65354b5c263c, https://data.bka.gv.at/Ris/api/V2_2/Help""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The open data portal showed that the data was updated the day this research was carried out, https://www.data.gv.at/katalog/dataset/ris-daten/resource/b996b330-44c0-4218-8fc7-30c0564a067e""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is helpful to know the name of the legal information system. Many prominent google results for laws also lead to the RIS""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I went to the Austrian open government data portal, data.gv.at, and searched for \""RIS\"". "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.data.gv.at/katalog/dataset/7b30d15c-54b2-4cf5-bba3-65354b5c263c"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Information is easily accessible and searchable at https://www.ris.bka.gv.at/, obtaining bulk data via an API requires advanced knowledge and some effort.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Austrian Federal Chancellery (Bundeskanzleramt Österreich)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ris.bka.gv.at/"",""descValue"":""Legal Information System of the Republic of Austria (\""Rechtsinformationssystem - RIS\"")""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.data.gv.at/katalog/dataset/7b30d15c-54b2-4cf5-bba3-65354b5c263c"",""descValue"":""RIS on the Austrian open government data portal, data.gv.at""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission is complete in it's entirety and verified by myself the reviewer. ",,"Yes","Yes","Mathias Huter","Veronica Green","100","100"
"1090e3dd-f66e-4a8d-be36-337475cdf23a","global","2017-01-27T17:06:06","2016","cr","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Lay 6335 of Author's Rights (art. 75) allows public reproduction of laws (and other provisionas and orders). This is not a Public License but is a legal frame of public domain and reproduction.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I wrote in Google Search Leyes Costa Rica. BUT you have to know the correct result is number TWO, because number one is the National Assembly and it contains the laws as when first drafted."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Procuraduría General de la República"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.pgrweb.go.cr/scij/main.aspx"",""descValue"":""This site contains all information of laws and other valid legislation, normally the next day of the publication of the law in the Official Dgital Gazzette.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This data set is complete . ","Cleaning of headers, foots, spacing, and some characters conversions would be required to use it as clean text.
Submission originally made by Ignacio Alfaro Marín","Yes","No","anonymous","Veronica Green","45","45"
"0d8b8ad7-b7d4-44d8-9e76-1262125385bd","global","2016-11-23T04:23:22","2016","hk","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""HTML and PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Visit https://www.legislation.gov.hk"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.legislation.gov.hk/blis/eng/terms.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Justice"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.legislation.gov.hk/eng/home.htm"",""descValue"":""Current English Ord. & Sub. Leg.""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I am the reviewer of this data set. It is complete in it's entirety although not available for download all at once. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Veronica Green","65","65"
"e2a10039-5cc1-447b-b547-49e4d35e2adf","global","2016-12-05T13:09:14","2016","sk","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I followed the link from last year. Lionk still works and among other things directs users to new portal."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Justice"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.slov-lex.sk/"",""descValue"":""Slov-Lex Legislative and Information Portal""},{""urlValue"":""https://jaspi.justice.gov.sk/"",""descValue"":""Legal Information Portal (old one, superseded now by Slov-Lex)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I am the reviewer of this data set. Like the draft legislation for Slovakia, the data set is not available in bulk. However, there is ample information provided about the nation's legislation. ",,"Yes","No","Peter Hanecak","Veronica Green","45","45"
"d9a0cd44-f966-4f8f-a6e6-5b6402c6fdac","global","2016-12-05T13:27:17","2016","sk","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I've searched a little bit with search engine and through my emails and found links to both old and new portal. Old portal contains notice about new portal."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Justice"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.slov-lex.sk/predbezna-informacia"",""descValue"":""Slov-Lex Legislative And Information Portal""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""Law Portla (now old, superseded by Slov-Lex)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.nrsr.sk/"",""descValue"":""Portla of National Parliament""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The second link here is invalid and was therefore deleted as per the source description. ""}]","Yes","Yes","I am the reviewer for this data set. It is complete in its entirety of information however it is not machine readable and there is no bulk access option.
That being said, there are many ways to access legislation and supporter materials. (Please read the comments by the author for more information). ","Data bout drafts of bills is generally available via two portals: Slov-Lex (run by Ministry of Justice) and Portal of National Parliament (run by National Parliament). While Slov-Lex covers almost whole life-cycle of the drafts, it lacks information about voting in parliament, which needs to be looked up in portal of National Parliament (along with transcriptions from debates).
Both information sources lack machine-readable bulk access option and data licensing information.","Yes","No","Peter Hanecak","Veronica Green","45","45"
"45dc32ab-503b-40fb-b619-e849fdb28c89","global","2016-12-30T09:48:42","2016","bt","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Environment Commission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Executive Director, BMF","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"21af6e50-72b5-47a3-93a7-4b9a382a7a87","global","2017-01-29T19:01:29","2016","bb","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" Barbados Water Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://barbadoswaterauthority.com/\nThe Authority is also responsible for the monitoring, assessment, control and protection of the water resources in the public’s interest""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Unfortunately I was unable to identify an online government portal for the given datasets.
","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"6ec8d015-fc2c-46d9-adfe-91c79f729e2e","global","2017-02-18T13:33:26","2016","bd","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Public Health Engineering"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Searched the various departments and websites. The database where the data could be is not up and could not find any reports with the data available. ","Searched the various departments and websites. The database where the data could be is not up and could not find any reports with the data available. ","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"0328ae9f-d861-4f48-b287-ec97883d012e","global","2017-01-12T19:31:27","2016","za","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Googled South African Election Results, found it on the first search result."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.elections.org.za/content/Copyright-Notice/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Electoral Commission of South Africa"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.elections.org.za/"",""descValue"":""Electoral Commission of South Africa ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.elections.org.za/content/Elections/Municipal-elections-results/"",""descValue"":""Municipal Elections Results""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.elections.org.za/content/Elections/National-and-provincial-elections-results/"",""descValue"":"" National and provincial election results""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.elections.org.za/content/Elections/Municipal-by-elections-results/"",""descValue"":"" Municipal by-election results""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","For Local Elections it is needed to select an electoral zone to download detailed results. Results are also available. National and provincial election results data is also available in PDF.
Copyright notice: “All of the work on this site including pages, documents and online images is protected by the copyright laws of the Republic of South Africa. The use of any material on this site for commercial purposes is a breach of copyright. Material may be retrieved and displayed, printed or reproduced in unaltered form only for personal, non-commercial use or use within your organisation. All other rights are reserved.”
",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Paola Mosso","80","80"
"c7179a48-6299-4544-a1f8-6c86afbe66ce","global","2017-01-11T19:45:19","2016","uy","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The data is available to use with no restrictions though it is not explicity expressed by an open licence. In Uruguay if the information is published on an official web site is available to use with no restrictions unless it is indicated.\n""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Navigate through the web site"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://legislativo.parlamento.gub.uy/temporales/leytemp753798.htm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""See art.4 ""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Corte Electoral"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.corteelectoral.gub.uy/gxpsites/page.aspx?3,26,294,O,S,0,"",""descValue"":""Electoral Office web site""},{""urlValue"":""https://eleccionesdepartamentales.corteelectoral.gub.uy/"",""descValue"":""Visualization of the last Sub national election results""},{""urlValue"":""https://eleccionesdepartamentales.corteelectoral.gub.uy/json/ResumenGeneral_P_DPTOS.json"",""descValue"":""Sub national election results""},{""urlValue"":""https://eleccionesdepartamentales.corteelectoral.gub.uy/json/ResumenGeneral_D_DPTOS.json"",""descValue"":""Sub national election results""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.corteelectoral.gub.uy/nacionales2014/proclamacion/ResultadosNoviembre2014.xls"",""descValue"":""Last national election results""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The data is available to use with no restrictions though it is not explicitly expressed by an open licence. Although, In Uruguay if the information is published on an official web site is available to use with no restrictions unless it is indicated. See 18.381, Article 4 (https://legislativo.parlamento.gub.uy/temporales/leytemp753798.htm): “Any information produced, obtained, held by or under the control of the subjects bound by this law, regardless of the medium in which they are contained, is publicly presumed”. Updated link on submission with official publication of this law.",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Paola Mosso","100","100"
"fb07c4c0-f335-48bf-bcef-4f50f9b65ca1","global","2016-12-04T15:06:47","2016","hr","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Reuse for purposes other than what the information is provided for is regulated through the Law on Reuse of information and decided on a case by case basis https://www.izbori.hr/ws/index.html?documentId=C3762C98F0CBCF7BC1257FCA0042A608 ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF also available. However xls is not universally available and HTML is produced through the app which limits presented data at least at electoral unit. ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Machine readable results are not consistently available for download at once. Presidential election results can be downloaded as one xls file. Parliamentary elections are available through the app or PDF.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried a web search engine for the Electoral Commission of Croatia. Results are under Archive and ongoing elections."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""State Electoral Commission of the Republic of Croatia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.izbori.hr/ws/index.html?documentId=DF2CA3FEF99BA5CBC1257C5C004BF6B4"",""descValue"":""State Electoral Commission of the Republic of Croatia""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Machine readable results are not consistently available for download at once. Presidential election results can be downloaded as one xls file. As for parliamentary elections, even though it is possible to download as XLSX files, it is divided by electoral zone (https://www.izbori.hr/izbori/ws.nsf/site.xsp?documentId=6C89525B48252E02C125802E0034FB57). HTML format is consistent but it contains only general results, not all data characteristics. As for Municipal data, it is available only in PDF. EU Parliament data available in PDF and general results in HTML.
Reuse for purposes other than what the information is provided for is regulated through the Law on Reuse of information and decided on a case by case basis (https://www.izbori.hr/ws/index.html?documentId=C3762C98F0CBCF7BC1257FCA0042A608).
",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Paola Mosso","45","45"
"5887e5a7-8812-4af4-b6f1-f30923286fdb","global","2016-11-16T02:04:25","2016","hk","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Visit https://www.elections.gov.hk/legco2016 > Election Results"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Registration and Electoral Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.elections.gov.hk/legco2016/eng/rs_gc.html"",""descValue"":""2016 Legislative Council Election""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.elections.gov.hk/dc2015/eng/results.html?1487359871269"",""descValue"":""2015 District Councils Election""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.elections.gov.hk/legco2012/eng/results.html"",""descValue"":""2012 Legislative Council Election""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.elections.gov.hk/dc2011/eng/results.html"",""descValue"":""2011 District Councils Election""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","As for findability, 2016 Legislative Council results are visible and straightforward. On the other hand, finding historical results can be challenging, although easily findable through Google search queries.
Both the Registration and Electoral Office website and the elections dedicated site contain Copyright disclaimers. The first one states that “content available on this website, including but not limited to all text, graphics, drawings, diagrams, photographs and compilation of data or other materials are subject to copyright owned by the Registration and Electoral Office (""REO"") or other entities. Except as expressly permitted herein or where prior written authorization is obtained from the REO, any reproduction, adaptation, distribution, dissemination or making available of such copyright works to the public is strictly prohibited” (https://www.reo.gov.hk/en/notices/notices.htm). The elections website explains that “unless otherwise indicated, the materials found on this site are subject to copyright owned by the Government of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region. Permission is required in adopting, reproducing or redistributing photographs, graphics, and audio and video files on this website. Visitors are permitted to download, print, make copies of and distribute all other information on this site for personal or educational purposes, subject to the following conditions: 1. the copy or copies made must not be for re-sale or commercial distribution purpose; 2. the materials must be reproduced accurately; 3. the source of the materials must be identified and the copyright status acknowledged.” (https://www.elections.gov.hk/ce2017/eng/important.html)
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","80","80"
"bfa6ef6c-9740-4393-8240-56d3f607e184","global","2016-12-21T13:55:05","2016","cl","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It does state that the information is free to access, but not comment of whether it is public domain:\n“Access to information on the website is free and without prior registration for its visitors”. ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""TXT""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Changed original submission to indicate that data is not available in XML format. Added that it is available in TXT. \nI addition it can be downloaded as a Doc. and PDF.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""You can google the name of number of the law and in the repository you can also search by several criterias"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""It is worth mentioning that the data is collected by the Library of Congress which is supposed to provide impartial service to parliamentarians and the public. However, the Speakers of the House of Deputies and Senate are both members of the High Commission which governs the Library (so I am accepting this as government data).""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Biblioteca del Congreso"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Very clear statement on the date of last amendment. Also provides access to previous versions of a law.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.leychile.cl/Consulta/homebasico"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I am accepting the submission. All the information provided could be identified on the given URL.","A bit unsure as to whether the Library of Congress should be considered as a government source because since it offers impartial service to congress, I am not sure whether is acts on behalf of government. But I decided to accept the data because 1)the speakers of the lower and upper house are among the chief decision makers 2) one of the Library's main function is to provide information to Congress (so it is closely associated with Congress)
3) Alyssa Beaton of Open North also pointed out that Library of Congress uses the same domain as other government website (.cl).","Yes","No","María Jaraquemada","Juela Xhaferraj","80","80"
"ececeed9-f2ee-495a-a4d1-ca2cd171f62d","global","2016-12-20T18:01:28","2016","cl","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There's no visible license on neither both websites.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I changed the original submission to indicate that data is not found on XLS format. All that is contained in XLS files is a chart that lists the legislative stages a bill has gone through. This is important but lacks substance in terms of the content of the bill.\nThe text of bills is available in Doc. files. The text of bills with transcripts of debates are found in PDF only. \nVotes are found in HTML format.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Some search results are downloadable in XLS format. Some are not.\nReviewer: I changed this to YES because once I found the record of a given bill I could download the entire bill, including the transcript of debates at once. Votes alone are found on a separate page.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""In the case of the Cámara de Diputados, there is no - as it is in the Senado- easy access to the record of the last bills discussed. You have to search for specific bill number or key words. Another option is to go directly to the Room Sessions section.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to each chamber website and then to each bills section. It was easier to find the data at the Senado."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Congreso de Chile: Cámara de Diputados & Senado de Chile"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Bicameral Congress""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Transcripts on debates of a particular bill are found within the transcript of all parliamentary proceedings of the day- so one must search within this record to find the portion which relates to the bill in question.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.camara.cl/pley/pley_buscador.aspx"",""descValue"":""Cámara de Diputados""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.senado.cl/appsenado/templates/tramitacion/index.php"",""descValue"":""Senado de Chile""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.camara.cl/trabajamos/sala_votaciones.aspx"",""descValue"":""Voting record for Diputados""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission should be accepted. Relevant URLs are clearly identified and all the required characteristics of the dataset could be verified. ","The URLs lead to very good data that contain all the characteristics which I believe were very easy to find.
The only changes I made were to B5 (see comments). I also removed XLS as one of the available formats because the files provided in that format contain insufficient information. ","Yes","No","Manuel Barros","Juela Xhaferraj","60","60"
"17fe1b28-65a6-43ff-b984-ee5f5fad1c9a","global","2017-01-29T17:36:55","2016","bb","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Barbados Parliament"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","National laws in Barbados are not currently available online. Submitter provides useful links to other institutions/organizations that provide access to some laws via PDF.","Although the Barbados Parliament has a website hosting a list of bills/draft legislation before Parliament I was unable to source a similar collection of national laws. However there are a few financial agencies that list a number of business related laws.
Fair Trade Commission
https://www.ftc.gov.bb/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=18&Itemid=63
Invest Barbados
https://www.investbarbados.org/legislation.php","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Anton Shaffer","0","0"
"922bbc4a-5f5b-4a18-8a9b-df48acb857c3","global","2017-02-17T17:17:25","2016","ls","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Lesotho Meteorological Services"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The original submission was rejected because the data found online does not meet the requirements. 24 hour forecasts are provided for all data characteristics, but forecasts only show temperature extremes and cloud coverage/precipitation in icon form. Data have to be requested via telephone or fax, see here: https://www.lesmet.org.ls/data-access/data-requisitions. This data is copyright protected according to following notification: https://www.lesmet.org.ls/data-access/data-use-policy
The original submission has been made by Tricia Govindasamy. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"7d60caad-84c2-4896-9b5f-ed7351c1734f","global","2016-12-15T11:07:05","2016","af","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""There is no single agency that works on draft. Three agencies share this: the government organization that requires a law, the Ministry of Justice, the Cabinet Legal Committee. None of them share drafts to the public. The National Assembly also does not share draft to the public."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Legislative Data for Afghanistan is not available to the public. User submitting data provides a reason as to why this data is not available. Comments read as follows:
""There is no single agency that works on draft [legislation]. Three agencies share this: the government organization that requires a law, the Ministry of Justice, and the Cabinet Legal Committee. None of them share drafts to the public [...] This is a huge problem in Afghanistan. Draft laws are secret to the government agencies. They hardly share with stakeholders.""
","This is a huge problem in Afghanistan. Draft laws are secret to the government agencies. They hardly share with stakeholders.","Yes","No","anonymous","Anton Shaffer","0","0"
"38aa4bf6-3ba8-49da-ada2-1e1fb9dc524f","global","2017-01-17T18:20:38","2016","bw","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Botswana Meteorological Services"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""Botswana Meteorological Services"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission stated that no evidence could be found that a government entity collects meteorological information. The World Meteorological Organisation states that the Botswana Meteorological Services are providing this information: see here https://www.wmo.int/cpdb/botswana.
However information on this agency is almost not existing on the WMO website and it is not clear what the exact tasks of the agency are, and whether it shares responsibilities (i.e. provision of data for aviation, or similar).
The WMO links to a website hosted by IBIS. It could not be verified whether it is a data provider contracted by government or not.
Therefore the submission counts as valid. Thank you, Tricia Govindasamy, for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"2a10d1d7-517d-48e0-a946-f926a53167fc","global","2017-02-17T16:07:38","2016","bb","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Barbados Meteorological Services"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The submission was rejected because weather forecast data does not meet all required data. Weather forecast data is available for current day plus four following days for: temperature extremes, as well as precipitation amount. Precipitation amount is described verbally (""brief scattered showers"" or similar).
No wind data is provided as forecast data. The data is hosted on the website as HTML, and cannot be downloaded.
Longer-term forecasts (several months) for precipitation can be downloaded as pdf files showing rain distribution on a heat map.
The submitter stated that data was quickly findable, through a google search, as well as on the websites of the meteorological service. The reviewer can confirm this.
The original submission was made by Alesha Aris. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"34e936c9-906b-4bba-8ffa-c8077f4552e2","global","2016-12-07T21:17:22","2016","at","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""CC by see: https://www.data.gv.at/katalog/dataset/9b40a0af-a6fe-47ff-9624-2ea8f40c746f""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""https://www.data.gv.at/katalog/dataset/9b40a0af-a6fe-47ff-9624-2ea8f40c746f""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""every 15 Minutes""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""My assessment of findability: It is hard to find the data (I give a score of 1). \n\nI visited the main website of ZAMG, then had to look for a long time to understand that the \""products\"" button contains weather information. Then had to click two levels deeper (the naming of the links is not obvious: I clicked through \""general forecast\"" -> \""homepage and APP\"" ). I arrived at a page that offers all our required data: https://www.zamg.ac.at/cms/de/produkte/wetter/allgemeine-vorhersagen/wetter-fuer-ihre-homepage-und-mobile-anwendungen ""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search on the website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.data.gv.at/katalog/dataset/9b40a0af-a6fe-47ff-9624-2ea8f40c746f"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""ZAMG - Zentralanstalt für Meterologie und Geodynamik"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Precipitation Probability"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I added the characteristics \""precipitation amount\"" and \""precipitation probability\""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.zamg.ac.at/cms/de/aktuell"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://warnungen.zamg.at/html/de/heute/alle/at/"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.zamg.ac.at/cms/de/wetter/wetterwerte-analysen"",""descValue"":""ZAMG, Subpage, Wind speed, temperature extremes, Wind direction and precipitation amount. Only available for current day""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.zamg.ac.at/cms/de/wetter/wetterkarte"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.zamg.ac.at/cms/de/wetter/wetteranimation"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.data.gv.at/katalog/dataset/9b40a0af-a6fe-47ff-9624-2ea8f40c746f"",""descValue"":""Data.gov.at, Subpage, currently measured data (no forecasting), available for various stations, contains all required data elements in numerical data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.data.gv.at/katalog/dataset/464ce024-8e5b-4318-88a7-2fd2898b8ffc"",""descValue"":""Data.gov.at, Subpage, historical data for accumulated precipitation amount""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.zamg.ac.at/cms/de/produkte/wetter/allgemeine-vorhersagen/wetter-fuer-ihre-homepage-und-mobile-anwendungen"",""descValue"":""ZAMG, Subpage, ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The original submission was amended, because it referred to current weather measurements (containing all required data elements for various weather stations in numerical values, it is openly licensed, available for free, downloadable at once). This data is fully open. However, it is not forecasting data.
The reviewer found a forecasting dataset, available at:
https://www.zamg.ac.at/cms/de/produkte/wetter/allgemeine-vorhersagen/wetter-fuer-ihre-homepage-und-mobile-anwendungen
This dataset contains all required characteristics for 5 days and is considered the reference forecast dataset, because it is most representative for the parameters the Index assesses. It can be retrieved at once via FTP server but is not openly licensed and has to be paid on a monthly basis. To do so, users have to sign up for the service. It is available as HTML or in raw data (XML or CSV).
I added the characteristics ""precipitation amount"" and ""precipitation probability""
Thank you, Günther Tschabuschnig, for submitting to the Global Open Data Index.
Reviewers assessment of findability: It is hard to find the data (I give a score of 1).
I visited the main website of ZAMG, then had to look for a long time to understand that the ""products"" button contains weather information. Then had to click two levels deeper (the naming of the links is not obvious: I clicked through ""general forecast"" -> ""homepage and APP"" ). I arrived at a page that offers all our required data: https://www.zamg.ac.at/cms/de/produkte/wetter/allgemeine-vorhersagen/wetter-fuer-ihre-homepage-und-mobile-anwendungen
",,"Yes","No","Günther Tschabuschnig","Danny Lämmerhirt","50","50"
"ab038ebe-26c9-46ae-b315-8f1908d871ec","global","2016-12-31T10:09:11","2016","kh","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is displayed from the website only.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name or identifier of an entity in order to find it.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I did in-depth search on the website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Commerce"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The link to the official website https://www.businessregistration.moc.gov.kh/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.businessregistration.moc.gov.kh/cambodia-master/viewInstance/view.html?id=48e104de66a7c46f1912795850b16aab9108ede1d8da77b6&_timestamp=23954179815395774"",""descValue"":""Business Registration, Website of Ministry of Commerce""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The data are available through a search mask on the Ministry of Commerce website, and it is necessary to know the name or identifier of an entity in order to find it. Company name and identifier, status, entity type and registration date are given in .HTML format, and once selected more information such as physical and postal registered addresses, directors, and business activities are also provided for free. The dataset cannot be downloaded at once as details for each entity are viewed separately. How often or when the data were last updated is unknown as is the type of license. I have updated all these categories accordingly since the original submitter described the data as available online without the need request access to them, not available for free, updated regularly, and with the unique identifier missing.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","15","15"
"bbd980a0-ba3e-4ed1-a049-6062d3d4b34c","global","2017-02-17T09:07:30","2016","bw","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There supposedly is an online database of company names that can be accessed to prevent duplicates, subject to verification by the Registrar of Companies and Intellectual Property (https://www.mtinamesearch.gov.bw/search/). Data are supposedly available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name of an entity in order to find it.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Trade and Industry, Republic of Botswana"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The website does not return any results (https://www.mtinamesearch.gov.bw/search/).""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","There supposedly is an online database of company names under the responsibility of the Ministry of Trade and Industry, Republic of Botswana, that can be accessed to prevent duplicates, subject to verification by the Registrar of Companies and Intellectual Property (https://www.mtinamesearch.gov.bw/search/). Data are supposedly available through a search mask so it is necessary to know the name of an entity in order to find it. However, the website does not return any results.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"adc9fd8c-43ab-4a82-ab70-25245cf01d73","global","2017-02-16T17:32:53","2016","bd","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Bangladesh Meteorological Department"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No other comments","The original submission was reject because the website of the Bangladesh Meteorological Department does not display forecast data.
It displays various data for the current day, such as at this URL: https://bmd.gov.bd/?/home/#Rangpur This page shows data on temperature extremes and rainfall, as well as wind speed.
To access wind direction, a click on the forecast section is needed. The forecast is only available for the current day (following 2 days indicate very vaguely how the weather will change, such as ""night temperature may rise"": see here https://bmd.gov.bd/?/p/=Weather-Forecast. This does not qualify for a submission.
Data can be downloaded as PDF file for the current day. It could not be verified wether the data is openly licensed or in the public domain.
The initial submission has been made by Nurunnaby Hasive. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"2e87d663-8ba0-4ebe-97d8-f2b62a6c9155","global","2016-12-11T12:53:37","2016","om","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Ministry of Interior"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The Ministry of Interior has a website dedicated to all popular elections such as Shura Council (Parliament) and the Municipal Councils. However, the website does not appear to have any historic data and shows only most recent election (in this case the Municipal Council), the data on the website is nominal and does not provide any numbers except list of final candidates and the list of voters.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"e88f24ca-93c9-4d79-86d8-fd6fb5d194e9","global","2016-12-27T14:00:39","2016","tz","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Electoral Commission (NEC)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","As the submitter accounted that data is available with the National Electoral Commission, but it's not available online. If you click on the Elections Results tab, it doesn’t lead you to a new page. By using a Google search query, it was possible to a Results page, but with any data on it (https://www.nec.go.tz/results).
","The data is available with the National Electoral Commission, but it's not available online.","Yes","No","Joachim Mangilima","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"774886b8-30e5-4b07-b1d6-24fa4276ada3","global","2017-01-29T19:59:48","2016","cm","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Elecam "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"429b460a-fcbb-481e-8c1b-ef0ee5580753","global","2017-01-26T00:53:25","2016","ag","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Antigua and Barbuda Electoral Commission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Webpage https://www.abec.gov.ag/""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","As submitter noted, the organization's website is currently under construction. Looked over on Government and Government Statistics unit (https://www.ab.gov.ag/detail_page.php?page=5) websites and information wasn’t available.","The organization's website is currently under construction, I was unable to identify any other other government portal for the given datasets.","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Paola Mosso","0","0"
"9a0067a3-2d5b-4d6c-8994-a9405926224f","global","2016-12-10T11:15:37","2016","ba","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is not stated either way.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name or registration number of an entity in order to find it.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried an online search engine for the \""Business registry of Bosnia and Herzegovina\"". Registry website is one of the results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal Ministry of Justice and Judiciary Commission of District Brcko BiH "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://bizreg.pravosudje.ba/pls/apex/f?p=186:20:147497591973448::NO::P20_SEKCIJA_TIP,P20_POMOC:PRETRAGA,FALSE"",""descValue"":""Registers of Business Entities in Bosnia and Herzegovina""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
All required characteristics were found online for free including company name, address, registration and unique identification numbers. However, the data are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name or registration number of an entity in order to find it. The website offers basic as well as advanced search options but results can be viewed separately in .HTML format and cannot be downloaded all at once. How often or when the data were last updated was not stated, and neither was the type of license.",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Evangelia Kampouri","15","15"
"404bb6f5-8a6a-4b94-ae72-045478b62c30","global","2016-12-02T14:23:05","2016","bg","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is provided on irregular dumps.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched the open data portal of the government"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://opendefinition.org/licenses/cc-zero/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Public Procurement Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://opendata.government.bg/organization/www-aop-bg"",""descValue"":""Contracts, orders, companies involved""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes to the submission. ",,"Yes","No","Boyan Yurukov","Oscar Montiel","85","85"
"b6f3a7b1-059d-42f6-b96e-e610d1d41cff","global","2016-11-25T12:59:41","2016","br","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""JSON"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""the most up to date data i can only get the CSV i dont think its fair to say i can get any other formats because the last time it was updated was 2014, b ut anyways, it used to be available.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I can only get the data from theme to theme. I may download the data from a single state, or of a single theme like “construction”. If i want data from a government department i have to know its code.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data from the first 2 links was updated last september (09/2016). The other weblinks, where i can get the API, were updated in 2014.\n""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""If I wasn’t directed to another website when I asked to download the data, and start the procedure all over again, I would have given a 4.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I knew that information was in the government transparency website so I accessed it and I could fill the form to look for it right on the first page. I just had to fill the form. the other links were easier, cause I just had to read the instructions."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://dados.gov.br/dataset/compras-publicas-do-governo-federal/resource/8cf6d2a9-45ba-49b9-bff1-cd619c7150d0"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""the data is under The Creative Commons Attribution license as stated in the link provided.\n""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""from the transparency webpage is quite easy. but since there are other ways to get the info that require programming skills (even though it's not updated), I give it a 2.\n""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministério da Transparência, Fiscalização e Controladoria-Geral da União"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Brazilian Transparency Ministry is a new government department created in 2016. Before that it was an autonomous government agency .""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I can access the information on the different links I used. To aggregate all this information in a single table I would probably have to do a vlookup function in excel or something like it. The downside is that the best weblink to get the data is also the one that is not up to date.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://transparencia.gov.br/"",""descValue"":""the first page to select the information.""},{""urlValue"":""https://transparencia.gov.br/downloads/"",""descValue"":""the link i'm directed when i request to download the data.""},{""urlValue"":""https://compras.dados.gov.br/docs/home.html"",""descValue"":""government purchase data via API""},{""urlValue"":""https://dados.gov.br/dataset/compras-publicas-do-governo-federal"",""descValue"":""links to all the ways i can download government procurement data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""the first link i go to check government spending is the brazilian official transparency website. The second link i got when i requested a website to download the information. I also googled it and got the other 2 websites, which were really good.""}]","Yes","Yes","Some of the data is outdated, you can get the 2016 data a bit more updated through an API but you have to do different queries for different parts of the data.
The Licence for the data in the data portal is CC, for the API the data is ODbL. https://compras.dados.gov.br/docs/home.html
Thanks to Augusto Herrmann for comments on the forum for this submission. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Oscar Montiel","70","70"
"7ba25750-3fb7-4aa8-87fe-18448cfa1898","global","2017-01-18T21:10:44","2016","bw","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I google searched tenders in Botswana and this was the sources I found on the first page of results."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Republic of Botswana Government, Tenders and Jobs for you"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.bw/"",""descValue"":""Republic of Botswana Government""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Changed the data to non-existent because there is no public portal.
There is a website for the public procurement office where there will be Tender Notices but it is under construction by Feb 16, 2017. https://www.ppadb.co.bw/tender_notices.htm",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"c65dd48c-5724-4eca-b5b4-c6b623264a26","global","2016-12-09T01:26:13","2016","au","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Unless otherwise noted in the materials excluded and rights reserved list below, material on this website, including publications, is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Australia Licence (CC BY 3.0).""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""TXT"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There is a wide range of datasets provided for download, The XML feed presents the entire download in Oasis Election Markup Language (https://docs.oasis-open.org/election/eml/v7.0/eml-v7.0.html)""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is release progressively through the election day, and is maintained as an archive ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""google search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.aec.gov.au/footer/Copyright.htm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Australian Electoral Commission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Invalid and Spoiled ballots are both recorded as Informal Votes\nhttps://www.aec.gov.au/voting/informal_voting/""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://results.aec.gov.au/20499/Website/HouseDefault-20499.htm"",""descValue"":""2016 Federal Election results site""},{""urlValue"":""ftp://mediafeedarchive.aec.gov.au/20499"",""descValue"":""2016 Bulk file in XML format (OASIS Election Markup)""},{""urlValue"":""https://results.aec.gov.au"",""descValue"":""2001-2016 Election Result Archives""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""As well as the public site, the AEC provides a live XML feed for the Media on election day. These files present a complete form of the results.""}]","Yes","Yes","Navigation through the website to find elections results is pretty straightforward: Elections > Elections results: 2001 to present > Select election. Submitter noted that as well as the public site, the AEC provides a live XML feed for the Media on election day. These files present a complete form of the results. Invalid votes and spoiled ballots are recorded as “Informal votes” (https://www.aec.gov.au/voting/informal_voting/). There is a wide range of datasets provided for download, the XML feed presents the entire download in Oasis Election Markup Language (https://docs.oasis-open.org/election/eml/v7.0/eml-v7.0.html). As for timely publication, submitter indicates that data is released progressively through the election day. The AEC data also contains the full distribution of preferences.
","The AEC data also contains the full distribution of preferences.","Yes","Yes",,"Paola Mosso","100","100"
"70c644c6-e0cc-4fa8-b682-bb7ec708aa4a","global","2016-12-09T18:23:29","2016","ba","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Statement at the bottom says \""© 2014 Public Procurement Agency of Bosnia and Herzegovina\""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF download is available.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried a search engine for \""E-nabvke BiH\"". Looked up for Search notification in the menu."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Public Procurement Agency, Bosnia and Herzegovina,"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ejn.gov.ba/Announcement/Search"",""descValue"":""Public Procurement Agency of BiH""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"7928591e-1f51-4910-b3a5-c296a95e90c4","global","2016-11-23T19:20:08","2016","at","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Single records only seem to be accessible as PDF for regular citizens""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name or register number of an entity in order to find it.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled for \""Firmenbuch\"" and found a list of data brokers at the Ministry of Justice website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The default output which can be obtained via brokers is in PDF format and needs considerable human effort to make the data machine readable & analyzable""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Justice"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.justiz.gv.at/web2013/home/e-government/firmenbuch/die_firmenbuchdatenbank~2c9484852308c2a601240b693e1c0860.de.html"",""descValue"":""list of third party companies which act as broker""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.firmenbuchgrundbuch.at/fbgb/easy/fb/search"",""descValue"":""Austrian Business Register""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
I have included a link to the Austrian Business Register where the data are available through a search mask so it is necessary to know the name or register number of an entity in order to find it. One can search the Austrian Business Register by company name or number and can then choose to get an official company register for a fee. The data requested are always up-to-date and valid. They contain the business name and register number, as well as the registered office. However they cannot be downloaded at once and are sent via e-mail in .PDF format.",,"Yes","No","Robert Harm","Evangelia Kampouri","15","15"
"81b1cc53-2f64-4cd5-9dcd-45162c0c36e5","global","2016-12-09T02:04:29","2016","au","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Company Dataset is API-enabled\nBusiness Dataset is zipped""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Updated on data.gov.au monthly""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""link from google search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://data.gov.au/dataset/asic-companies"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Entry on data.gov.au states Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Australia""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Australian Securities and Investments Commission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The public Company register doesn't contain the company address. Occasionally a location may be provided. The Public Business Register does contain a location""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.au/dataset/asic-companies"",""descValue"":""Select data from the ASIC's Company Register""},{""urlValue"":""https://asic.gov.au/online-services/search-asics-registers/#datagovau"",""descValue"":""ASIC link to download""},{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.au/dataset/abn-bulk-extract"",""descValue"":""Zipped extract of the publicly available information supplied by businesses when they register for an ABN""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The Australian Business Register contains all required characteristics in .XML format compressed in .ZIP files. The Company Register contains company names and identification numbers in .CSV format but not addresses, though occasionally a location may be provided. In both cases, the dataset is downloadable at once, it is updated on a monthly basis and is available for free under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Australia license. ","This entry also includes a dataset for the Australian Business Register as distinct to the Companies Register.","Yes","Yes",,"Evangelia Kampouri","100","100"
"6dd643d1-a419-4e6c-b0dd-d4a9a6ab74c9","global","2017-02-02T19:02:45","2016","dk","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""DBF"",""HTML"",""PX"",""TSV"",""TXT"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""But not at pooling station level (there you'll have to make many xml-requests)""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""But I've looked for them many times before""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Typed in the URL"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.dst.dk/da/omds/omweb"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Depending on the purpose of course. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Ministry of Social Affairs and the Interior"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""For generel elections. As for local elections municipals are responsible.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""To get data at pooling station level you need to use the html or xml version""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.dst.dk/valg/xml.htm"",""descValue"":""Election results in xml""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.statistikbanken.dk/statbank5a/SelectVarVal/Define.asp?Maintable=FV15TOT&PLanguage=1"",""descValue"":""Elections results from Statistics Denmark downloadable in different formats""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dst.dk/valg/Valg1664255/valgopg/valgopg.htm"",""descValue"":""Election results html""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Historical data from elections, such as parliamentary, regional and referendums, are available and easily findable through the website. About findability: On top of a search bar, on the Statistics site, there’s a subject called “Population and elections”, with a sub-category called “Elections”. There, you can find Elections to municipality councils, Elections to the European Parliament and Referendums data. After exploring selected data, it is one click to download in the selected format. By going to the websites containing XML and HTML data, the route to find the data is pretty straightforward. As the submitter stated, to get data at polling station level you need to use the HTML or XML version. You are not able to download the dataset in bulk at polling station level, for this you would need to make many XML requests.
Submitter stated that for general elections, the Ministry of Social Affairs and the Interior is in charge. As for local elections municipalities are responsible. As for timely publication, submitter stated that there are problems obtaining live data in full depth at election night. Data is given to major media sites but not in machine-readable format to the general public or minor media outlets.
","There are problems obtaining live data in full depth at election night. Data is given to major media sites but not in machine-readable format to the generel public or minor media outlets","Yes","Yes","Niels Erik Kaaber Rasmussen","Paola Mosso","100","100"
"1d35c6a8-105d-468e-b9bd-1089a3b7a951","global","2016-11-23T02:53:02","2016","ar","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Hay que entrar en el Portal de Datos de Justicia e ingresar a los datasets del Sistema Registral."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://github.com/datos-justicia-argentina/Entidades-constituidas-en-la-Inspeccion-General-de-Justicia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Justicia y Derechos Humanos. Subsecretaría de Asuntos Registrales. Inspección General de Justicia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://datos.jus.gob.ar/dataset/entidades-constituidas-en-la-inspeccion-general-de-justicia-igj"",""descValue"":""Entidades constituidas en la IGJ""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
All required characteristics are freely available online by the Ministry of Justice and Human Rights - Under-secretariat of Registry Affairs - General Inspection of Justice and can be downloaded all at once in .CSV format. Data are available under the Open Data Commons Open Database License (ODbL) and are updated monthly. ",,"Yes","Yes","Guido López Avakian","Evangelia Kampouri","100","100"
"37d3a2e0-dabf-4621-9ecc-1577cf7030d7","global","2016-11-18T01:19:16","2016","ar","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""TXT""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went on the website of the National Meteorological Service, looked for a link indicating forecasts. Found a button indicating \""data download\"" in English."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Original comment Entrar al servicio meteorológico nacional y empezar a indagar en los datos del tiempo.""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.smn.gov.ar/?mod=dpd&id=101"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Meteorological Service of Argentina (Servicio Meteorológico Nacional)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.smn.gov.ar/"",""descValue"":""Datos sobre el servicio meteorológico nacional.""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.smn.gov.ar/dpd/pron5d-calendario.php"",""descValue"":""National Meteorological Service, subpage of main website, leads to a data download of a bulk text file (containing forecasts for several regions)""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.smn.gov.ar/?mod=dpd&id=21&e=87582"",""descValue"":""National Meteorological Service, subpage linking to a search mask of forecasts per region. Contains detailed data including air pressure, humidity, etc. No forecast ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission was partly correct. Following changes have been made:
The data is indeed openly licensed. If users want to download forecast data, they need to accept terms of use. It is stated that all web content is provided under the Attribution 2.5 Argentina license, see explanations to the license here: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.5/ar/deed.en
Besides a data download data is accessible and presented in many formats: as detailed weather forecasts for the current day, available through a search mask, or as forecast maps. These maps are not interpretable, because the scales are missing a legend. So precipitation amount cannot be easily understood.",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Danny Lämmerhirt","100","100"
"343d85ba-7c36-4ef2-b55c-aea8e61ca384","global","2017-02-16T16:45:05","2016","ag","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Antigua and Barbuda Meteorological Services"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The initial submission answered all questions correctly. The submission was still rejected, because the weather forecast data does not meet the dataset characteristics the Index wants to assess:
There are no data on precipitation amount for the current day and the following two days.
Forecasts of temperature extremes, wind speed (in km/h) and direction (indicating cardinal directions and more: ESE - SE) are available for current day and following three days, all in numerical values.
However, the forecast does not indicate precipitation amount. Precipitation probability is described verbally as ""slt chnce of shwr"".
The data is available for the entire island (one aggregated national forecast). This forecast shows precipitation amount, wind speed, wind direction (for example: ESE - SE) as well as temperature extremes.
There is no download function, but the data is presented comprehensively in one table in HTML.
The data is easily findable because the homepage directly links to forecasts, and 4-day forecasts (links are named accordingly).
There is a copyright disclaimer on the website, but no specification of terms of use or similar could be found. There is no open license presented online. It could not be verified whether the data is in the public domain or not.","The initial submission answered all questions correctly. The submission was still rejected, because the weather forecast data does not meet the dataset characteristics the Index wants to assess:
There are no data on precipitation amount for the current day and the following two days.
Forecasts of temperature extremes, wind speed (in km/h) and direction (indicating cardinal directions and more: ESE - SE) are available for current day and following three days, all in numerical values.
However, the forecast does not indicate precipitation amount. Precipitation probability is described verbally as ""slt chnce of shwr"".
The data is available for the entire island (one aggregated national forecast). This forecast shows precipitation amount, wind speed, wind direction (for example: ESE - SE) as well as temperature extremes.
There is no download function, but the data is presented comprehensively in one table in HTML.
The data is easily findable because the homepage directly links to forecasts, and 4-day forecasts (links are named accordingly).
There is a copyright disclaimer on the website, but no specification of terms of use or similar could be found. There is no open license presented online. It could not be verified whether the data is in the public domain or not.","Yes","No","Danny Lämmerhirt","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"b9329e8b-457c-4258-a811-e836043a6604","global","2017-02-16T15:27:20","2016","ag","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Financial Services Regulatory Commission, Antigua and Barbuda Intellectual Property & Commerce Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","When asked whether a person can come into the Commission to conduct a company search, the Financial Services Regulatory Commission states that for a prescribed fee, a person can conduct a search of an IBC's public documents during normal working hours (https://www.fsrc.gov.ag/index.php/faqs). As proposed by the original submitter, another responsible organisation could be Antigua and Barbuda Intellectual Property & Commerce Office however no relevant data could be found on either webpage (https://www.abipco.gov.ag/home.aspx). No information on a company register or business directory could be found online hence the dataset has been marked as non-existent.",,"Yes","No","Evangelia Kampouri","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"bfa059bc-4946-4078-9b3e-374000426bcd","global","2016-12-07T15:10:59","2016","al","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data are available in .PDF form""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name, address, or identification number of an entity in order to find it.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched for \""albania company register\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Business Center"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.qkr.gov.al/search/search-in-trade-register/search-for-subject/"",""descValue"":""National Business Center""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The link provided by the submitter for the Statistical Business Register by ""INSTAT Republika e Shqiperise Instituti i Statistikave"" (https://www.instat.gov.al/en/themes/statistical-business-register.aspx) does not contain any Government Business Registry Data. The .XLS files available contain only basic statistical information that are of no interest. No data containing company names, their unique identifiers, and addresses could be found. Hence, the name of the organisation that collects the data, the link where the data can be found, and the description were replaced with those of the National Business Center where data are available for free through a search mask, so it is necessary to know the name, address, or identification number of an entity in order to find it. The data cannot be downloaded all at once, it is necessary to download a Historical Extract or Simple Extract in .PDF form for a specific entity. How often or when the data were last updated updated is unknown, as is whether the data are openly licensed/in public domain since the links to the Transparency Program's Legislation do not work.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","15","15"
"514907eb-059c-49ea-984a-ce320f112bb3","global","2016-12-15T11:01:30","2016","af","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name or license number of an entity in order to find it.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""AISA Website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Afghanistan Investment Support Agency/Ministry of Commerce"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.aisa.org.af/en/AISA/Company/Verification"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.directory.aisa.org.af/"",""descValue"":""Investors Directory""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The link provided by the submitter (https://www.aisa.org.af/en/AISA/Company/Verification) leads to a warning: ""ERROR Unhandled Exception! Sorry for the inconvenience, you request cannot be entertained at this moment. Reason: The type initializer for 'Helpers.WebMeta' threw an exception. Login failed for user 'sepiacms'."" It appears that the website https://www.aisa.org.af/ cannot be accessed at this point in time. After searching for ""afghanistan investment support agency (aisa)"", I came across the page for the Investors Directory (https://www.directory.aisa.org.af/) which offers basic company information (including company name, license number, and address) for Afghanistan. The data are free of charge but in .HTML format, and available through a search mask so it is necessary to know the name or license number of an entity in order to find it. They cannot be downloaded at once and it is unknown how often they are or when they were last updated. The page is very basic and doesn't offer any information as to whether the data are openly licensed/in public domain.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","15","15"
"c8291fed-52cc-474a-aa09-99e57b1dc052","global","2016-11-30T13:16:52","2016","at","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""CC BY 3.0 AT""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""https://www.data.gv.at/katalog/dataset/0d207682-c031-4cd0-af4d-9d40d229b57e provides an RSS feed in XML to the meta data of each bill""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I went to the website of the Austrian Parliament, https://www.parlament.gv.at, then clicked on \""Parliament aktiv\"" (\""Parliament active\"") and then clicked on \""Regierungsvorlagen und Gesetzesinitativen\"" (Government bills and initiated laws). Typing \""parlament gesetzesentwürfe\"" into Google showed the correct page on the Parliament's website as the second result (the first was for public consultations on draft bills)."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Correct. ""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.data.gv.at/katalog/dataset/0d207682-c031-4cd0-af4d-9d40d229b57e"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""To make the data usable, a scraper has to be used""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Austrian Parliament"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Correct. ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Authors are in almost all cases ministries. The site names the ministry that initiated the bill (not the civil servants who drafted it). Debates are only available when the bill is discussed in the plenary, not when earlier drafts are discussed in committee (most committees are non-public). Votes in committee and in plenary are released per party/fraction, not per member of parliament. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.parlament.gv.at/PAKT/RGES/"",""descValue"":""Website of the Austrian Parliament""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.data.gv.at/katalog/dataset/0d207682-c031-4cd0-af4d-9d40d229b57e"",""descValue"":""Entry on the Austrian open government data portal, data.gv.at""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Websites can be translated but they do not appear to be offered in English. ""}]","Yes","Yes","As per instructions, it makes sense not to be overly restrictive with draft legislation data and to accept submissions if they do not meet all our characteristics.
This data set has 3 of the 5 criteria content, author and status. It is easy to find and readily available.
To be specific - Authors are in almost all cases ministries. The site names the ministry that initiated the bill (not the civil servants who drafted it). Debates are only available when the bill is discussed in the plenary, not when earlier drafts are discussed in committee (most committees are non-public). Votes in committee and in plenary are released per party/fraction, not per member of parliament.
",,"Yes","No","Mathias Huter","Veronica Green","85","85"
"7470bd37-62e9-4c08-824d-5beb4b4ad6d9","global","2017-01-12T17:45:08","2016","bo","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Copyright of SILEP belongs to Vice-Presidency of the Plurinational State .\nNo statement on the Gaceta Oficial about the information being in the public domain.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Laws on SILEP can also be downloaded in Doc. format in addition to HTML. \nGaceta offers them in Doc. an PDF.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The updated information can be found on the Gaceta.\nThe SILEP website does not seem to provide any laws or amendments past 2015. So it is not updated regularly. But it does state on the website that it is advisable to consult the Gaceta for more updated information. \n""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""There is an advance search funcionality on the website, it allows to make search based on the number of the documents or based on words contained in the norm."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Sistema de Información legal del Estado Plurinacional; Gaceta Oficial"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://silep.vicepresidencia.gob.bo/"",""descValue"":""SILEP official website, it depends on Vicepresidency of the State""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.gacetaoficialdebolivia.gob.bo/"",""descValue"":""Official Gazzette website""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Both website provide access to national laws. Both are run by the government.""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is accepted. All the information can be verified by visiting both URLs provided above.","I have made no changes to the submission, with the exception of the comments on the side which provide some more details on the findings.
Full texts of the national laws with amendments were available on both the SILEP site and the Gaceta Oficial. The SILEP site was easier to navigate and displayed amendments more clearly. But Gaceta was the one that was regularly updated, while SILEP was out of date. The SILEP site makes it clear that the Gaceta should the authority on national laws publications. It states: ""IMPORTANT:
LAWS SHOWN ON THIS WEBSITE ARE THE RESULT OF REGISTRATION AND UPDATING AND EXPRESS REPEALS Repeals ADOPTED BY THE LEGISLATIVE BODY FROM 1825. HERE DOCUMENTS SUBMITTED IN ANY WAY THEY CAN NOT BE USED AS LEGAL REFERENCE, AS SUCH ALLOCATION APPLICABLE TO THE GAZETTE STATE OFFICER.""
It is possible that SILEP provides updated information only to registered users. It advises visitors to register in order to stay more up to date with the laws. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Juela Xhaferraj","60","60"
"010fa846-f1c1-4080-b502-97fa76c2f7ab","global","2016-12-26T15:08:57","2016","ar","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Bills and Voting Records are provided in PDF format.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Voting records are on a separate page. \nDifferent versions of the same Bill have to be downloaded separately. ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search on Google \""Proyectos de Ley presentados en el Congreso Nacional Argentino\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.hcdn.gov.ar/proyectos/buscador2016-99.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This statement appears at the bottom of the page: \""Nota: La información contenida en este sitio es de dominio público y puede ser utilizada libremente. Se solicita citar la fuente.\""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Honorable Cámara de Diputados de la Nación"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Voting records are provided on a different page of the same website (URL provided in B2.2). They are arranged chronologically, but the bill that is being voted on is clearly identified on the PDF document. \nNo explicit statement on the status of each bill, but there is a clear record of all the legislative stages the Bill has gone through and the dates (so the status of the bill can be easily deduced).\nCould not find any transcripts of the debates on the bills. Each bill contains the introductory statement that its author made in front of the legislature, but it does not include the ensuing debates. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.hcdn.gov.ar/proyectos/buscador2016-99.html"",""descValue"":"" Search for Projects presented in both chambers""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.hcdn.gov.ar/secadmin/ds_electronicos/actas_votacion-portada.html"",""descValue"":""Voting Records""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I am accepting the submission although records of transcripts on debates are not found because the rest of the information is very clear and detailed. ","I have added the URL where the voting records are found. But this page only has voting records for the House of Representatives (no records of the Senate votes).
I could not find any records of transcripts of debates per bill. But the website features videos and audio of legislative debates going as far back as 2004 (https://www.hcdn.gov.ar/sesiones/audiosyvideos.html). The videos are organized chronologically, and it would be hard to find the debates for any given bill. They are also not in an acceptable format.","Yes","No","Guido López Avakian","Juela Xhaferraj","65","65"
"92792386-6e25-458e-9942-767a6f800cf9","global","2016-12-14T10:20:50","2016","bg","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is all in the website therefore it is being assumed that the format is HTML. \n\nAbove statement from original submitter is incorrect as there is a WMS server backing the maps; but again no easy way to download.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is a WMS server backing the site but again no obvious download links are there.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Googled official administrative boundaries of the given country. Look for the words \""административни граници\"" for Bulgarian gov sites; found the GIS map."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""МИНИСТЕРСТВО НА РЕГИОНАЛНОТО РАЗВИТИЕ И БЛАГОУСТРОЙСТВОТО (Ministry of Regional Development)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The original submitters page: Point of Single Contact ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Details for at least Boundary 1 can be seen. No clear Boundary Level 2 is shown; the viewer needs to be zoomed in for it to appear.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://gis.mrrb.government.bg/"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Regional Development GIS site""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Original Submitter presented: https://psc.egov.bg/en/bulgaria-regional-structure (Point of Single Contact ) but does not seem to be correct.""}]","Yes","Yes","- Found the GIS data site under Ministry of Regional Development GIS site (https://gis.mrrb.government.bg/)
- It is backed by a WMS endpoint but that is not explicitly stated
- There is no clear way in which to download the datasets
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Drenusha Myha","Michael Leow","30","30"
"4346cab9-f834-42db-81b4-1dbe6746a4e9","global","2017-01-19T15:17:28","2016","bw","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""NGWATO LANDBOARD"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.ngwatolandboard.gov.bw/ABOUT%20US.htm\n- The department exist to provide the Land Board with advice in all maters relating to cadastral and topographic surveys, Land information Systems.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Found and updated the responsible authority. However, no datasets are available online.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Michael Leow","0","0"
"f2f45bb5-c206-4f34-969d-d96e50d0c7fe","global","2016-12-09T10:30:13","2016","al","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""WMS is NOT listed in the list.\n\nFeedback from @codrina:\nThe URL is\nhttps://geoportal.asig.gov.al/Services/host/host.ashx?url=https://localhost:8080/geoserver/asig/wms&Version=1.1.1&srs=EPSG:32634&layers=municipality_61\n\nAnd the layer is IGU with the description .""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""From the home page I selected services, then selected \""view\"" on the administrative map. Click on the \""metadata\"" link for Coordinates information and \""links\"" for the WMS end point."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Feedback from @codrina:\nWMS protocol is not constructed in such a way to support a meaningful download, especially with this kind of data.\n""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""ASIG - GeoPortal"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""From @codrina:\nWith respect to the Administrative Boundaries theme, Albania is compliant, including second level boundaries (kommune) but excluding bulk download.\n\nThey offer WMS (web mapping service) for usage in GIS clients (such as QGIS). WMS protocol is not constructed in such a way to support a meaningful download, especially with this kind of data.\n""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://geoportal.asig.gov.al/Map.aspx?lang=EN&layer=administrative"",""descValue"":""View for \""Administrative Boundaries\""""},{""urlValue"":""https://geoportal.asig.gov.al/Services/host/host.ashx?url=https://localhost:8080/geoserver/asig/wms&Version=1.1.1&srs=EPSG:32634&layers=municipality_61"",""descValue"":""WMS end point for \""Administrative Boundaries\""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Added the metadata and WMS end point for the dataset.
Thank you to @codrina for helping give feedback. Incorporating that WMS is not an easy format for download and re-use.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
","
","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","45","45"
"b300e973-776f-4005-a965-54e1ab9f40ff","global","2016-11-18T12:31:02","2016","at","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""-"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Submission was empty. I looked at the resources from the link provided. ""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Information about tender announcements are released on lieferanzeiger.at, a commercial portal operated by the state-owned newspaper Wiener Zeitung. No award data is released. It is unclear if the service covers all tenders of the federal government, aggregated by office. ""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Wiener Zeitung"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No information about tender awards is provided by the Austrian government (other than the information released through the EU's TED service)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.pep-online.at/BC/"",""descValue"":""Official Lieferanzeiger site""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.auftrag.at/WZOnlineSearch.aspx?AspxAutoDetectCookieSupport=1"",""descValue"":""Augftrag list of tenders""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The data is not available in the originally posted link. Notices go there but must be registered to access the information. The notices are available in auftrag.at and you can check the information in html of pdf. No download of the whole dataset available. ",,"Yes","No","Mathias Huter","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"c3aaacd9-58fb-4e10-a455-df6be6c261d8","global","2017-01-12T19:45:07","2016","za","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Unsure""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Unsure""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Unsure""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled company register South Africa and opened up a few search results until I found something useful."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Unsure""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""CIPC (Companies and Intellectual Property Commission)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Need to pay""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://ciproza.co.za"",""descValue"":""CIPROZA""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
Answer to whether the dataset is downloadable at once was changed as only individual entity details can be downloaded at a time. The website does not provide information as to how often the data are updated. The type of license or terms of use are also mentioned nowhere. What format the data are in cannot be known as one needs to sign up and pay in order to download them. The website only provides a .PDF sample file showing how the data look like which appears to be .HTML format (https://ciproza.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/company_search_sample.pdf). From this, it appears that the data contain all required characteristics such as company name, address, and registration number, however they are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name of the company or the registration number in order to download them.",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Evangelia Kampouri","0","0"
"84cfec35-4f67-489f-9bc4-20eda64c3b40","global","2016-11-23T14:03:14","2016","br","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""it's public domain information.\n""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""PDF also.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""You can download the data by theme in a zip file. Thats actually where you can get the shp file format.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The lastyear it was updated was 2015.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There are numerous links organized by theme.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I could find easily the pdf data, but the shapefile data is a little difficult. ""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I typed IBGE geoscience and got the pages on google. when i didn't get IBGE page, i got from another public source. I also used the search icon availabe here: https://portaldemapas.ibge.gov.br/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.ibge.gov.br/home/disseminacao/eventos/missao/principios_fundamentais_orientacoes_divulgacoes.shtm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""didn't find something as objective as a \""terms and conditions\"" ou a real license, but I found at this link a list of fundamental principles for official statistics with some guidelines for publication and dissemination. It contains the idea of data provided for public domain.\n""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""\n""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Since there are a lot of pdf available, the info is out in the open with no effort needed.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""IBGE - Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The brazilian institute for geography and statistics is a federal government agency, associated with the brazilian ministry of planning, budget and management (Ministério do Planejamento, Orçamento e Gestão)and it is responsible for all geographic data available.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is a brazilian physical map that that disposes information about water stretches and national bordes at the same time. i can also look it by theme. although, as i said before, its much easier to find a pdf file.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://portaldemapas.ibge.gov.br/portal.php#mapa1106"",""descValue"":""search tool""},{""urlValue"":""https://downloads.ibge.gov.br/downloads_geociencias.htm"",""descValue"":""bulk download""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""If i look up the name geoscience or maps and IBGE, which i know it is the official brasilian source of geographic data information, on google i'll find several links available to search for what i need.""}]","Yes","Yes","We appreciate the contributions of Lu Pa and Augusto Herrmann for this submission. ","I consider important to keep the geportal link as well, as it can be difficult for a person that's not familiar with the data to quickly find what they need. ","Yes","Yes","Bárbara Barbosa","Codrina Maria Ilie","100","100"
"f6c34aa3-5b52-40d2-8ddc-c187fac903b3","global","2016-12-02T14:17:15","2016","bg","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It's updated every few months""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Checked the open data portal of the government."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://opendata.government.bg/dataset/tbprobckn-pernctbp/resource/9655c836-89f6-4d1a-b5db-b43b930f14f5"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""On the \""More Information\"" for the \""Trade Register 22/10/2016-01/18/2017\"" it is stated that the type of Licence is Creative Commons CCZero. It is also stated that the data are freely available and can be used for commercial or non-commercial purposes and thus for the realization of applications based on them (https://opendata.government.bg/en/about).""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Registration Agency, under the auspices of the Ministry of Justice"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://opendata.government.bg/dataset/tbprobckn-pernctbp"",""descValue"":""Commercial register, Portal for open data of the Republic of Bulgaria""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The portal of open data initiative of Deputy Prime Minister in coalition politics and public administration is the result of joint work of:
- Political Cabinet of the Deputy Prime Minister in coalition politics and public administration R. Buchvarova
- Directorate ""Modernization of the administration"" in the Administration of the Council of Ministers
- Institute of Public Administration
- Ministry of Transport, Information Technology and Communications
- Foundation ""Obshtestvo.bg""
All required dataset characteristics were found online without the need to register or request access to them. The data are updated every few months, are free of charge, and downloadable at once in machine-readable .XML files (one for each day of the month). The type of Licence is Creative Commons CCZero and the data are freely available and can be used for commercial or non-commercial purposes (https://opendata.government.bg/en/about).",,"Yes","No","Boyan Yurukov","Evangelia Kampouri","85","85"
"14a5a8d2-5c8c-41bb-adc8-8ef31f4bb277","global","2016-12-12T08:57:42","2016","af","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Webiste of the Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.budgetmof.gov.af/index.php/en/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Economy and Ministry of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.budgetmof.gov.af/images/stories/DGB/BED/1395Report/Execution%20Report%2017-12-2016.xls"",""descValue"":""Executed Budget 2016 updated upto 24th Dec 2016""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.budgetmof.gov.af/index.php/en/"",""descValue"":""General Website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.budgetmof.gov.af/images/stories/DGB/BPRD/National%20Budget/1396_Budget/1396%20National%20Budget%20-%20PROVINCIAL%20ALLOCATION%20-%20Approved.pdf"",""descValue"":""PDF for national budget""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The budget file that is indicated as the xls file is the executed budget file, that is updated every month.
The actual approved budget file is in PDF, I have added it with the sources. As far as I can see, in a similar file from 2 years ago (the only english version I could find) and has sufficient level of granularity. ","Integrity Watch Afghanistan, the organization i represent, conduct national budget openness every two years in collaboration with Open Budget Survey. There is good details of information, in case required in the report published by OBS.
Afghan government has improved on opening up on the budget. But there are problems that remains. Like information on how a project is selected in the national budget? information on public consultation for development projects? The Ministry of Economy that conducts analysis of the development budget does not release any information on the project.","Yes","No","anonymous","Anna Alberts","85","85"
"5a9fcde2-fea2-4f74-a302-8290c7a61797","global","2016-12-09T10:08:28","2016","pl","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no license specified.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Simple info from KRS is shown o HTML page, full details are in PDF file.\n\nCEIDG show data in HTML tables. Also WSDL/XML webservice has recently been opened to access the data. It requires registration though.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""CEiDG is updated weekly""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data are available through a search mask, with access restricted with a captcha.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google search for \""znajdź firmę\"" / \""znajdz spółkę\"" (find company) returns Ceidg and KRS websites on the first 2 pages"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Parsing PDFs or HTML is required.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Justice, Ministry of Development"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There are two disjunctive registries KRS (National Court Register) and CEiDG (Central Registration and Information on Business). Ministry of Justice is responsible for KRS and Ministry of Development is responsible for CEIDG.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://ems.ms.gov.pl/krs/wyszukiwaniepodmiotu?t:lb=t"",""descValue"":""KRS website""},{""urlValue"":""https://prod.ceidg.gov.pl/CEIDG/CEIDG.Public.UI/Search.aspx"",""descValue"":""CEIDG website""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The answer to question B2 was changed as on both websites provided, the data are available through a search mask, with access restricted with a captcha. All 4 required characteristics are available free of charge, however they are in .HTML format, with the option to be downloaded in .PDF, and cannot be downloaded in bulk at once. I was unable to confirm whether data on CEIDG are also available in .XML format after registration so I did not include this in the available data formats.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","30","30"
"3906d416-0063-407d-9a70-aa903640acf1","global","2016-12-02T14:52:01","2016","sk","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name, identification number, registered seat, or registration number of an entity in order to find it.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched for \""Company Register\"" on the Ministry of Justice of the Slovak Republic's website."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.justice.gov.sk/Dokumenty/Informacie/Rek%20z%C3%A1kony%20211.pdf"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Justice of the Slovak Republic"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://orsr.sk/search_subjekt.asp?lan=en"",""descValue"":""Business Register on Internet""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Any search query attempts on the Register and Identifier of Legal Persons, Entrepreneurs and Public Authorities website by the Statistical Office Of The Slovak Republic proposed by the submitter (https://rpo.statistics.sk/) came up with an ""Error when communicating with the database"" warning and no results would be returned. Hence, I provided the link to the Business Register on Internet by the Ministry of Justice of the Slovak Republic (https://orsr.sk/search_subjekt.asp?lan=en) and updated the information on B1.1 accordingly. Databases on the Business Register are available for free and are usually updated every weekday but, as is also the case with the webpage provided by the submitter, they are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name, identification number, registered seat, or registration number of an entity in order to find it. The data cannot be downloaded at once. They include the business name, registered seat, and identification number .in HTML format.","This is a new portal for new registry, which unites several other registries used in the past.
The bad news is, that it is available only in in human readable form, i.e. via Search Form (search possible based on ID number, name of the subject, etc.) and results are available as HTML.
The good news is that data is licensed under CC-BY (as stated on the front page of portal) so other non-government project(s) are scrapping the data and are making it available in machine readable form (for example https://ekosystem.slovensko.digital/otvorene-data#rpo).","Yes","No","Peter Hanecak","Evangelia Kampouri","50","50"
"f02283c9-17cd-4548-8225-808861eb8a8c","global","2016-12-07T20:10:25","2016","cz","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no explicit licence, just a copyright at the bottom of the website.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Individual records can be downloaded in PDF.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is accessible only through a search interface (by company name, owners, unique identifier). Max 500 items per query. Use limited to 50 queries/minute or 3000/day. https://or.justice.cz/ias/ui/podminky""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Tech support told me data is updated on a daily basis. I had no means to verify.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data are available for free through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name, identification number, or file number of an entity in order to find it.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""First hit for a google search. The site itself is quite easy to navigate, minimalistic."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerstvo spravedlnosti / Ministry of Justice"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://or.justice.cz/ias/ui/rejstrik-firma.vysledky?subjektId=525681&typ=UPLNY"",""descValue"":""Detail of a company""},{""urlValue"":""https://or.justice.cz/ias/ui/rejstrik-%24firma"",""descValue"":""Homepage - search by company name""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The answer to question B2 was changed because data are available for free through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name, identification number, or file number of an entity in order to find it. All required characteristics are present in the data published online by the government in .HTML format and individual records can also be downloaded in .PDF form. However, results cannot be downloaded in bulk and according to the Conditions of operation and use of public records on the Internet (https://or.justice.cz/ias/ui/podminky), ""the Ministry of Justice reserves the right to limit or restrict access to a database of public records user who daily sent for processing more than 3,000 requests and / or trying to cross the protection of the web server and / or who submits to process more than 50 requests within one (1) minute.""",,"Yes","No","Michaela Rybičková","Evangelia Kampouri","30","30"
"8d4fbaa3-fffe-440d-8761-6f9081230b6b","global","2017-01-30T16:28:24","2016","us","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""A user must know that the U.S. refers to this dataset as \""Governmental Boundaiers\"" ""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Accessed the U.S. national map (nationalmap.gov) and selected the \""basic viewer\"" and selected the \""Governmental Boundaries\"" dataset"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www2.usgs.gov/laws/info_policies.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The dataset also includes a \""data distribution policy\"" with entries such as: \""Distribution_Policy = Public Domain - Free Distribution to Third Parties Via Internet \""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""United States Geological Survey"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The datasets have the proper Projection files.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://viewer.nationalmap.gov/viewer/"",""descValue"":""Administrative Boundaries are referred to as Governmental Unit Boundaries""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Downloaded a sample dataset for DC; confirmed there is indeed coordinates data; so updated that attribute; and add the missing ESRI Shapefiles data format (DBF, SHX).
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","Yes","Tyler Kleykamp","Michael Leow","100","100"
"5f9030ab-be9e-45bd-bd51-04d26f435f59","global","2016-12-05T20:21:41","2016","gb","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""KML"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""OS Boundary-Line is available as Esri Shapefile and MapInfo TAB. ONS boundaries are available as Shapefile and KML.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is updated at least annually though in practice there are not always changes between updates.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""No steps. I am a user of these datasets and have been aware of the locations since they became available. Boundary-Line is easily discoverable via a UK search for \""administrative boundaries\"" in Google. The ONS Geography site is new and does not yet have good SEO, so is less easily discoverable. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.ordnancesurvey.co.uk/opendata/licensing.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Link provided is for Boundary-Line. Licensing information for ONS boundary datasets is here:\nhttps://www.ons.gov.uk/methodology/geography/licences\nAll are subject to the Open Government Licence.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is as easy to use as I would normally expect for data in these formats, bearing in mind that this is GIS data so some knowledge of relevant software is necessary.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ordnance Survey and the Office for National Statistics (ONS)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This response is in respect of Great Britain only.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ordnancesurvey.co.uk/business-and-government/products/boundary-line.html"",""descValue"":""Boundary-Line (Ordnance Survey)""},{""urlValue"":""https://geoportal.statistics.gov.uk/datasets?q=Administrative+Boundaries"",""descValue"":""Administrative Boundaries (ONS Geography)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","Yes","Owen Boswarva","Michael Leow","100","100"
"cebfa33b-9831-448f-b7c9-a162139a5406","global","2017-01-19T08:16:44","2016","bd","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There is no explicit license either way. Since it is \""practical openness\""; it has the tools to easily share, copy, download.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""DBF"",""GML"",""GeoJSON"",""KML"",""SHP"",""SHX"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Original submitter was not able to find the GeoDash site; which can be found by using keywords like \""GIS\"" \""ArcGIS\""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""In GeoDash page; search for the keywords \""Administrative\""; look for the most comprehensive Administrative Boundary overlay which is under \""Bangladesh Administrative Map overlay\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Updated the steps.""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://geodash.gov.bd/wiki/index.php?title=Main_Page"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""GeoDASH is geo-spatial data storing and sharing initiative by Bangladesh Government. It is a web based platform for compiling, updating and sharing geospatial database which will allow facilitating the use, management, exchange and quality control of geospatial data sets in a collaborative manner.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Original submitter was not able to find the GeoDash site. However, GeoDash can be fairly easily found for someone with basic GIS knowledge.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Information & Communication Technology Department, Ministry of Post, Telecommunications & Information Technology"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""@nhasive provided detail of Ministry in the Forum""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://geodash.gov.bd/maps/739"",""descValue"":""Bangladesh Administrative Map overlay""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Updated the Ministry responsible based in info from the forum discussion. Put the link to the GeoDash dataset that contains all the layers. Detailed the steps needed to find the relevant dataset.
Changed the license to be considered ""open"" although there are no explicit license either way; based on the Wiki statement of the purpose of the GeoDash site.
Thank you to @nhasive for discussion on forum to confirm the Ministry that GeoDash falls under.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","Yes","Nurunnaby Hasive","Michael Leow","100","100"
"300eabf2-737a-4dd8-a34f-998441705266","global","2017-01-12T18:36:25","2016","bo","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Also as Word and PDF files.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""You need to dowload individually the proccess documents.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""There is information in home page and in menu tabs, the one on the home displays an advance search form and also a list with the latest process."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There are not closed or terminated processes available for review.""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Sistemas de Contrataciones del Estado SICOES"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.sicoes.gob.bo/portal/index.php"",""descValue"":""Official website for SICOES that is only a procurement website, there is no information about closed or terminated processes.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Information is correct. No editions",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"a333862d-b002-4553-aa11-fe18a9de51b7","global","2016-12-30T09:46:43","2016","bt","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Finance "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","There is an e-procurement platform in development in https://www.egp.gov.bt/
There are some test datasets with the characteristics we look for but right now there is no access.
If you're a company you can register to view the tenders but it's necessary to do a whole process to get it. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"669e1b5e-2af4-41fb-9100-64cfa713c1ea","global","2016-12-05T08:13:20","2016","be","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Also PDF of the notices and history""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Go to https://enot.publicprocurement.be"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"" https://my.publicprocurement.be/um/getPrivacy.action"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Official acts are not copyrighted in Belgium""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""FOD P&O"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://enot.publicprocurement.be"",""descValue"":""e-notification system ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Bart Hanssens","Oscar Montiel","85","85"
"f6661979-8161-47b8-b8c9-2e97e3ae93c6","global","2016-12-14T09:52:56","2016","au","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Where data is available, it is largely under cc-by licensing.\n\nGiven the involvement of the 87 utilities, It is hard to ascertain the copyright and licence status of the data included in the reports from the utilities.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Most Annually reported data is in PDF form. Where available, live/daily data is HTML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is continuously monitored, but only regularly reported by a select few entities.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""googling \""Australian Drinking Water Guidelines\"" will take you to the reports page of most water utilities."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.bom.gov.au/other/copyright.shtml?ref=ftr"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is collected by catchment area by the controlling authority.""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Water utilities measure and collect the data for their catchments."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Arsenic"",""Fluoride levels"",""Nitrates"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Data per water source""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I have been unable to confirm that every water utility publishes this information.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":"" https://www.nhmrc.gov.au/guidelines-publications/eh52"",""descValue"":""Australian Drinking Water Guidelines (2011) - Updated November 2016""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bom.gov.au/water/npr/docs/2014-15/National-performance-report-2014-15_part-A_lowres.pdf"",""descValue"":""National performance report 2014–15: urban water utilities""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bom.gov.au/water/npr/"",""descValue"":""National Water Performance Report""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.bom.gov.au/water/npr/docs/2014-15/National-performance-report-2014-15_part-B.xlsx"",""descValue"":""National Water Performance Dataset""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""A sample of annual reports and live pages are at https://www.sydneywater.com.au/SW/water-the-environment/how-we-manage-sydney-s-water/safe-drinking-water/water-analysis/index.htm\nhttps://www.yvw.com.au/about-us/reports/water-quality-reports\nhttps://www.seqwater.com.au/about/publications/water-quality-reports/customer-confidence-report?zone=2\nhttps://www.melbournewater.com.au/waterdata/drinkingwaterqualitydata/Pages/drinking-water-quality.aspx\nhttps://www.newater.com.au/learning-centre/water/water-quality/Water%20Quality%20Results.asp\nhttps://www.watercorporation.com.au/about-us/our-performance/drinking-water-quality\nhttps://www.sawater.com.au/community-and-environment/water-quality/in-your-area-whats-in-your-water/central-metro\n""}]","Yes","Yes","After reviewing the submission and verifying the research, this submission is correct. ","The 87 Water Utilities conduct their own daily assessments of water quality, against the National Guidelines, and take action should levels cross thresholds. They report annually on these levels, and these reports are in turn assessed for compliance with the guidelines. There is no continuous national set of figures, no national network of stations reporting daily, and little coordination between the utilities.","Yes","No",,"Nisha Thompson","50","50"
"adb2b2da-4e0f-450b-be5a-97b7ab7a3740","global","2017-01-26T04:13:46","2016","ag","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Antigua Public Utilities Authority (APUA) "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","After review and research assessed that submission is correct.","The responsible organisation appears to be Antigua Public Utilities Authority (APUA) however I was unable to identify a government portal for the given datasets.
https://antiguaobserver.com/no-end-in-sight-to-abs-water-crisis/
","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"f59f40ab-0732-4ab9-a501-eb914f72e7ed","global","2016-12-15T11:17:58","2016","af","water","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""There is no single agency responsible. Responsible agencies are confused. Municipalities in every city, Ministry of Health at national level and Water and Canalization Company of Afghanistan at national level are responsible for providing clean water for ctizens. There is no data online by any of the three agencies."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","After reviewing the submission and researching independently I have to agree with the assessment that there is no single agency responsible for collecting or aggregating water quality data. The system seems to be decentralized, however while other countries clearly make data collection a policy requirement, there seems to be no such requirement for Afghanistan.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","0","0"
"925e5d58-1588-46e8-85d2-a67c4ca4877a","global","2017-01-17T12:46:59","2016","zw","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Site of The Department of the Surveyor General is down —> https://www.surveyorgeneral.gov.zw/""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""In the United Nation GGIM Report for Zimbabwe (https://ggim.un.org/country%20reports/Country%20Report-Zimbabwe.pdf). The Department of Surveyor General is the National Mapping Authority established in terms of the Land Survey Act(Chapter 20:12)(LSA). It falls within the Ministry of Lands and Rural Resettlement.""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Department of the Surveyor General, Ministry of Lands and Rural Resettlement"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Did research and found the department responsible for producing the ""Administrative Boundaries"" dataset. Did this minor correction.
However, the responsible department’s page is down.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Michael Leow","0","0"
"3fcef0d2-338b-4cfd-b698-80e2213b43df","global","2017-01-15T18:28:30","2016","zm","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is official Data Portal linked from the CSO at: https://zambia.opendataforafrica.org/\n\nHowever, no datasets for Administrative Boundaries.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Central Statistical Office (CSO), Geographic Information branch "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Details about this department:\nhttps://www.zamstats.gov.zm/surveys/sur_soc.php""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""-"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No evidence to provide answer.""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Did research and found the department responsible for producing the ""Administrative Boundaries"" dataset. Did this minor correction.
However, did not find any ""Administrative Boundaries"" data set even though there is a Data Portal(https://zambia.opendataforafrica.org/data) linked from Central Statistic Office.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Michael Leow","0","0"
"4c8db743-f93c-4882-9567-3b7033651ca8","global","2017-02-03T16:04:36","2016","us","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Looked for \""bill drafts\"" and you can go to either the USGPO or Congress to find the data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.congress.gov/legal/#copyright"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""US gov publishing office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/bulkdata/BILLS"",""descValue"":""Bulk download of xml of congressional bills""},{""urlValue"":""https://docs.house.gov/floor/"",""descValue"":""bills to be considered by congress""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","Yes","Oscar Montiel","Michael Beatty","100","100"
"756c4cfc-55b7-42fb-852c-cd34e61f13a5","global","2017-02-03T16:02:03","2016","us","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to congress.gov, there is a direct link to the legislation and then it can be filtered. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.congress.gov/legal/#copyright"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Library of Congress"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.congress.gov/search?searchResultViewType=expanded&q={%22congress%22:%22all%22,%22source%22:[%22legislation%22,%22comreports%22,%22communications%22],%22bill-status%22:%22law%22}"",""descValue"":""Search of all the laws that hava passed ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Oscar Montiel","Michael Beatty","65","65"
"a1bfbdc5-8b27-4932-952c-80249cef6f75","global","2017-01-18T05:51:05","2016","bs","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The document downloads as a PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""The website https://laws.bahamas.gov.bs/ does not have the bills in the stated section. This required additional searching more so there appears to be diffciulty in collecting data from the main .gov site as stated on the site, resulting in a lengthy loading time "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Office of The Attorney-General & Ministry of Legal Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There are names but they are illegable ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.bahamas.gov.bs/wps/portal/public/General%20Legal%20Information/!ut/p/b1/vZTJmqIwFEafpR_AIpAwuERB5lCMAhs-ZRAiIA4o-PRNdW16U9amu3JXyXdyT_67CJVQEZV0u3t92N3qU7drPvYJl0LFtpw1EiyBQ0ug0T7WJPkdKpCntlSkxiNeP7RqI0epVw0RutjZZRE4uqy6RRv75IIyjV1I3l5I2wwsl1Cq6qazmmu_DYk8DpIwPKFdHxonrqze2uLhpBQEnMc9dD1c4T6VpAhig6c9ct7JrjjKaT5YLipLpByhwk6xf44T0pn9IjcOrNwnk5N3h_B-CkRmanbw4trPEo1CohxbaQ4Vz6HAF0sE32X-vA-BYoniDNiM_wGsac4IWGAg9P3Mkk_kRYc_wKsnvu7AUfEM8F8CNE_5VARQ6pGp157Hp0uero3NAFjHaQIymHw_CrC_0fHNo335yMxnjCUL9NV3gPV0TSsv3_PQDVaixKn7Mnot9MwfFhoq99NC-N-FBgNnoQlNLKxpxgA_LWT-uVCnknrfvj2y9g28IQA5JAg8x9AMIyDAUyGJeby-6qKkueUYDDYmDW8gfXNW69s9IDv3MjxKZiTbZVr0CdqYadPqvWjh7rAPC2u1VqqkuergMtSSSJ_zpYsdX5FFpakSSCviYliFd8Xg63A7ivs-89OS4Ec2tVljhm2wCbWAtfn8ZtwVj7HZc1Ek7PK0cFTjqqsHkp75jYaFOdGAXIc2mHaX2i2ZPySSVwrdqfesja5lx0oFnTXj4rKk-4rC6qktqL69Gybnqs_oryrEX78BeI3-GA!!/dl4/d5/L2dBISEvZ0FBIS9nQSEh/"",""descValue"":""Bills Before Parliament""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Michael Beatty","60","60"
"1a3f1225-da12-4415-93ae-a098c11e0897","global","2017-01-17T20:20:44","2016","bs","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is downloadable as a PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The files are easily downloadable but not machine readable""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""On google I entered the keywords \""national law bahamas\"" the easily lead me to the Bahamas Law site https://laws.bahamas.gov.bs/cms/en/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Using the search option is not possible, such as researching by keyword. The user has to peruse the database alphabetically. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Government of The Bahamas - Office of the Attorney-General & Ministry of Legal Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://laws.bahamas.gov.bs/cms/en/"",""descValue"":""Bahamas Laws On-Line""},{""urlValue"":""https://laws.bahamas.gov.bs/cms/en/legislation/laws/by-title.html#"",""descValue"":""Bahamas Laws Online Database""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Michael Beatty","60","60"
"ee833677-bebc-4244-b8a7-55c860f48f0f","global","2017-01-12T20:25:07","2016","za","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is not every week decisions are made, yet it is updated quiet frequently.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled draft legalisation South Africa and the source was the first result."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.gov.za/terms-and-conditions-use-0"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""South African Government"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.gov.za/documents/draft-bills"",""descValue"":""South African Government""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Michael Beatty","65","65"
"296b70a8-1d17-413f-9ceb-0ef029f94e78","global","2017-01-12T19:23:15","2016","za","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google search for South African National Legalisation. Found result on third search page."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.sabinet.co.za/index.php/terms-conditions"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Sabinet Legal - South Africa"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.salegislation.co.za/"",""descValue"":""Sabinet Legal - South Africa""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Michael Beatty","65","65"
"ddcc22b5-14e1-4c27-8d40-87529d0ed176","global","2017-01-25T02:26:47","2016","lc","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Legal Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Unable to identify a government based source of data ","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Michael Beatty","0","0"
"01a284d3-4a05-42ea-b62a-b7dbf977e1d0","global","2017-01-23T18:57:56","2016","lc","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""A list of laws showing to 31 December 2006""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""While on the https://www.govt.lc/ web page, I saw the Legislative tab with the Constitution available "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is a brief collection of legislative material. The data is not readily downloadable as the data is read on the webpage, this requires extra effort for users to save the data or to view it without an internet connection ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Legal Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.govt.lc/constitution"",""descValue"":""Constitution Revised Edition""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Michael Beatty","30","30"
"280b23ee-aba2-414f-bdaa-1ecd6dabd853","global","2016-12-10T22:27:43","2016","pl","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""only some PDF files""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""you can only download pdf files with the content of bills - each one separately ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""visit the Sejm website -> choose \""prace sejmu\"" (the work of the parliament) --> choose required registry"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://sejm.gov.pl/Sejm8.nsf/page.xsp/copyright"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Sejm RP"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://sejm.gov.pl/Sejm8.nsf/proces.xsp"",""descValue"":""the registry of bills registered by the parliament""},{""urlValue"":""https://sejm.gov.pl/Sejm8.nsf/agent.xsp?symbol=PROJNOWEUST&NrKadencji=8&Kol=D&Typ=UST"",""descValue"":""registry of draft bills before the registration of the parliament""},{""urlValue"":""https://legislacja.rcl.gov.pl/lista?typeId=2"",""descValue"":""governemental draft bills ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Beatty","65","65"
"b3404771-e1f1-4f97-92a9-0caf9b740be2","global","2016-12-08T13:25:00","2016","pl","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Article 6 point 1.4)a of Access to Information bill https://isap.sejm.gov.pl/DetailsServlet?id=WDU20011121198 specifies explicitly national laws""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""pdf""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Each bill and each amendment has to be downloaded separately.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""It takes roughly a week for a passed bill to be published here.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google search for \""polish law\"" (\""prawo polskie\"") links ISAP on 1st page, it's mentioned on Wikipedia, as well as on Sejm website."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://isap.sejm.gov.pl/DetailsServlet?id=WDU20011121198"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Google allows to easily find specific laws. PDF are not copy-protected so it's quite usable.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Sejm - lower house of the Polish parliament"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://isap.sejm.gov.pl/"",""descValue"":""Database of all national law""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Beatty","65","65"
"0ca164e5-1252-49fc-b4f2-7722120230d0","global","2016-11-24T16:43:22","2016","om","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The Ministry of Legal Affairs; the Council of Oman"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Draft legislation prepared by the executive branch of the government is available in the Ministry of Legal Affairs prior to passing it to the Cabinet. Draft legislation is also available at the Council of Oman (the Parliament) prior to Royal Assent, however, there is currently no mechanism in Oman to enable members of the public to access these documents. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Beatty","0","0"
"ab2e02ac-6bb9-47aa-8cd8-1274caca9269","global","2017-01-03T09:13:52","2016","je","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No machine readable format.""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no bulk download facility.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Someone not familiar with Jersey's legislative process might start with Google and find https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_Jersey and then click through the \""States Assembly\"" link to the article at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/States_of_Jersey from where they'd find a link to the States Assembly website."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Would have to extract the data from the HTML pages on the site.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""States Greffe"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""https://www.statesassembly.gov.je/Pages/Propositions.aspx""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Example of the meta information available for a proposition: https://www.statesassembly.gov.je/Pages/Propositions.aspx?infoid=84ceb098a1f5962379ac4c73a43fc595_StatesAssembly&refurl=%2fPages%2fPropositions.aspx%3fpage%3d2""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.statesassembly.gov.je/Pages/Propositions.aspx"",""descValue"":""States Assembly - propositions""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Michael Beatty","45","45"
"a00894f1-a7f4-4b8a-8a1b-775a5b02079c","global","2016-12-13T09:58:25","2016","je","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Each law would need to be downloaded one at a time in PDF format.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Jersey updates its revised legislation on an annual basis but the individual amendments to the laws, and any new legislation, are available as soon as they are passed by the legislature.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""From Google, type \""Laws of Jersey\"". The third entry is \""Jersey Law | Revised Laws - A to Z Search\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data could be programatically extracted from the HTML documents""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Jersey Legal Information Board"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.jerseylaw.je/laws/revised/Pages/search.aspx"",""descValue"":""Revised Edition - A to Z""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Michael Beatty","45","45"
"f7f35f3b-d9b2-4858-9b2f-e86aa7230c70","global","2016-12-31T20:24:52","2016","ir","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Declared by the head of the parliament research centre. No web page or official license. Although some draft legislation can be found here: https://rc.majlis.ir/en/legal_draft""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I find it with short look at the Parliament research center website."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""Declared by the head of the parliament research centre. No web page or official license."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Parliament Research Center"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://rc.majlis.ir/fa/legal_draft"",""descValue"":""from Parliament Research Center website""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","MohammadHossein Khani","Michael Beatty","45","45"
"3bcdb8ca-362d-4767-b004-c93048a4fcdf","global","2016-12-31T19:37:07","2016","ir","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""TXT""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""as always, PDF""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I directly enterd the website, but it's not common."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Parliament Research Center and office of the Legal Vice President"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://rc.majlis.ir/fa/law"",""descValue"":""Parliament Research Center""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.dotic.ir/"",""descValue"":""Office of the Legal Vice President""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","MohammadHossein Khani","Michael Beatty","50","50"
"3fb78761-a10f-4fff-b867-8ee0c117962d","global","2017-01-27T14:31:36","2016","gh","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""They are ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search for either the constitution or a specific law and it comes up online. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Parliament of Ghana [Hansard]; "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.judicial.gov.gh/index.php/preamble"",""descValue"":""The Constitution of Ghana ""},{""urlValue"":""https://laws.ghanalegal.com/"",""descValue"":""A data base of all the laws in Ghana""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.parliament.gh/docs?type=HS"",""descValue"":""An edited verbatim report of proceedings of Parliament. it contains all the laws/acts etc. ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Article 11 of the 1992 Ghana Constitution states that the laws of Ghana shall comprise:
The Constitution;
Enactments made by or under the authority of the Parliament established by the Constitution [or legislation];
Any Orders, Rules and Regulations made by any person or authority under a power conferred by this Constitution [or subsidiary or subordinate legislation];
The existing law or the written and unwritten laws of Ghana that existed immediately before the coming into force of the 1992 Constitution; and
The common law [or the English common law, English doctrines of equity, and the rules of customary law].
All these available (albeit separately online)","Yes","No","Franka Vaughan","Michael Beatty","45","45"
"0f1b17e0-ea70-470f-8ee2-13e3cbb12dab","global","2017-02-02T20:15:43","2016","dk","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""JSON"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It's available in html, but you need multiple html-pages to get the full information (debates, votes, stages etc.)""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Typed in URL"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.ft.dk/AabneData/Brugsvilkar.aspx"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Depending on purpose of course, the html-version is pretty much readable for generel public.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Folketinget (National parliament)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ft.dk/Dokumenter/Vis_efter_type/Lovforslag.aspx#dok"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ft.dk/AabneData"",""descValue"":""Open data API interface""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Niels Erik Kaaber Rasmussen","Michael Beatty","85","85"
"325eb005-83fa-4a9e-86a9-ac441840d2aa","global","2017-01-16T16:24:05","2016","ca","law","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""I had to add XML""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""It is downloadable in pdf.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""It's the first result for a Google search with the terms: laws canada"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Switched to 3 because it is not hard to access the data at all. All xml files are machine-readable. all acts are presented in XML files""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Justice Canada"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I had to make some changes:
B7: Laws are in the public domain https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/
B8: Laws are found in the html and xml files not just html. They are also found in pdf format.
B9: I had to switch from 1 to 3 because it's not hard to navigate and access the data.","The information is provided as HTML, therefore a machine cannot extract the semantics of the information without significant effort. Other jurisdictions publish this information as XML and clearly identify semantic elements like the title, dates, headers, sections, clauses, etc.","Yes","Yes","James McKinney","Michael Beatty","100","100"
"11f6cc6c-711d-476c-bc57-69ad8c329005","global","2017-01-16T19:12:22","2016","ca","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""See https://www.parl.gc.ca/ImportantNotices.aspx?Language=E""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""It is made available on the the Parliament of Canada Site.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Justice Canada Site"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Justice Laws Website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of parliament"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/"",""descValue"":""Justice Laws Website""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.parl.gc.ca/LegisInfo/BillsBeforeCommittee.aspx?Language=E&Mode=1"",""descValue"":""Parliament of Canada Web site is managed jointly by the Senate, the House of Commons, and the Library of Parliament.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"This is a dynamically changing website to complement Justice Laws website.","Yes","No","Tracey P. Lauriault","Michael Beatty","80","80"
"758eefdd-7575-44a6-8589-386b9b6a2506","global","2017-01-16T18:47:14","2016","zm","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Zambia Meteorological Department"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No evidence to provide answer."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The Zambia Meteorological Department (ZMD) produces weather (forecast) data. It is affiliated to the Ministry of Transport, Works, Supply and Communications. The ZMD holds a database with historical data as current data on temperature, precipitation and other items (see here: https://www.zmd.gov.zm/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=63&Itemid=65)
The ZMD bundles these data into several services such as Crop Weather Bulletins (presenting precipitation amount in different regions of Zambia) This service is not updated.
Also a 7-day weather forecast is provided. However, the forecast describes forecasts verbally and vaguely (slightly clouded, some rain expected). It does neither offer data on temperature, nor on wind speed.
The relevant data are therefore not provided online.
",,"Yes","No","Tricia Govindasamy","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"a96c7ee1-51d9-4477-8fe0-dc26c190be62","global","2017-01-19T05:57:02","2016","gh","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data are provided as paid services. Details can be found at: https://www.meteo.gov.gh/website/index.php?option=com_content&view=category&layout=blog&id=37&Itemid=56#\n\nThe charge is made dependent on the use case of the data. It seems that commercial applications are charged more than non-commercial ones, but there is no price list to see the pricing models.\n\nA user must email the agency with details of what exactly they need as stated on this website: https://www.meteo.gov.gh/website/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=54:how-do-i-apply-for-meteorological-data-from-meteorological-agency&catid=36:faq-items&Itemid=55. The include online form link was not working as of January 19th, 2017 as 5;55 am GMT""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ghana Meteorological Agency"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. Weather data are provided as paid services. Details can be found at: https://www.meteo.gov.gh/website/index.php?option=com_content&view=category&layout=blog&id=37&Itemid=56#
The charge is made dependent on the use case of the data. It seems that commercial applications are charged more than non-commercial ones, but there is no price list that would enable verifying pricing models.
It was not possible to verify if forecasts for several days are provided.
A user must email the agency with details of what exactly they need as stated on this website: https://www.meteo.gov.gh/website/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=54:how-do-i-apply-for-meteorological-data-from-meteorological-agency&catid=36:faq-items&Itemid=55.
A link to a request form was available, but not working as of January 19th, 2017 as 5;55 am GMT. Another try on February 10th, 2017, 1.30pm GMT brought similar results.","I am still waiting to get a response from the Ghana Meteorological Agency about access to weather forecast data. I will update the review once I have additional information.
","Yes","No","David Opoku","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"c2c92a69-2c3d-457f-bb6a-0cf81d83a8a4","global","2016-11-22T21:37:27","2016","at","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went for cost-free products at BEV"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.bev.gv.at/pls/portal/url/ITEM/88AB1D338625A5D0E040010A83211FDB"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Federal Agency of Metrology and Surveying"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.bev.gv.at/portal/page?_pageid=713,2601287&_dad=portal&_schema=PORTAL"",""descValue"":""Cost-free products of BEV""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.data.gv.at/katalog/dataset/verwaltungsgrenzen-vgd-stichtagsdaten-grundstucksgenau"",""descValue"":""Administrative Boundaries at Official Data Portal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Added the Administrative Boundaries found at the Official Data Portal --> https://www.data.gv.at/katalog/dataset/verwaltungsgrenzen-vgd-stichtagsdaten-grundstucksgenau
It points to the same data by the submitter; however it has a Creative Commons license in contradiction to what was reported by @robertharm in discussion Forum in the License accompanying the data at the publisher.
Updated and minor correction for format of data.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Michael Leow","100","100"
"fa08c5de-c9e0-40e5-b8e0-8d5978dc7fff","global","2016-11-10T22:14:28","2016","au","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Also TAB files""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""When to data.gov.au; searched \""boundaries\"", \""administrative boundaries\"", \""psma administrative boundaries\""; found dataset for collection of resources"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Files are zipped""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""PSMA Australia Limited (PSMA)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.au/dataset/psma-administrative-boundaries"",""descValue"":""PSMA Administrative Boundaries""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Just added format that were missing, dbf, shx.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.",,"Yes","Yes","Stephen Gates","Michael Leow","100","100"
"47fdb727-ec62-4cef-bc7e-0e4d8293cfa4","global","2016-11-21T15:32:22","2016","ar","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX"",""WFS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Actualizada a Agosto de 2015\n\n""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""At the main IGN page; go to the \""Download Geodato\"" section right at the bottom of the page. The dataset can be downloaded via the links or GIS software can be pointed to the WFS endpoints."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.ign.gob.ar/SIG"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Defensa"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ign.gob.ar/SIG"",""descValue"":""Base de Datos Geográfica.""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ign.gob.ar/archivos/sig250/LIMITES_POLITICO_ADMINISTRATIVOS.zip"",""descValue"":""Administrative Boundaries""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.ign.gob.ar/archivos/sig250/PROVINCIAS.zip"",""descValue"":""Province Data""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Put more details on how to download as the Download link is way to the bottom and was not obvious at first.
Changed B6 to No as dataset was last updated in 2015; so is not up-to-date.
Updated the available formats. Municipal data can be downloaded direct via WFS.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
",,"Yes","No","Guido López Avakian","Michael Leow","85","85"
"096c553f-470d-4686-a95d-f2c72b99f636","global","2017-01-26T01:15:13","2016","ag","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Agriculture, Lands, Fisheries and Barbuda Affairs"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Updated org responsible to ""Ministry of Agriculture, Lands, Fisheries and Barbuda Affairs"" (https://www.ab.gov.ag/detail_page.php?page=17); as can be seen in the United Nations initiative on Global Geospatial Information Management page (https://ggim.un.org/partners.html).
There is a portal with some boundaries at https://geonode.data.gov.ag/; but does not seem kept up to date. Also no Administrative Boundaries.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The responsible organisation appears to be Antigua and Barbuda Electoral Commission however there website is under construction and I was unable to identify any other government portal for the given datasets.
https://www.abec.gov.ag/","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Michael Leow","0","0"
"0a05d214-5d4b-4783-ae8d-cf2356058468","global","2016-12-04T15:28:24","2016","hr","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Yes, See Law on Court Register, Article 4 and 4a https://www.zakon.hr/z/271/Zakon-o-sudskom-registru""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name or business ID of an entity in order to find it.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Queried a web search engine for \""Poslovni registar Hrvatska\"". Result does not show up searching for \""Business register Croatia\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.zakon.hr/z/271/Zakon-o-sudskom-registru"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Court Register - Ministry of Justice, Republic of Croatia"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://sudreg.pravosudje.hr/registar/f?p=150:1:555862989951"",""descValue"":""Court Register""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index, your submission is valid.
The court Register (Croatian Ministry of Justice) is public and everyone, without proving legal interest, shall have access to data recorded in the general ledger. All 4 required characteristics were found online: Croatia's companies' names, addresses, MBS's (company's [court] registration numbers) and OIB's (personal identification numbers) are included in HTML format. However, I changed B2 to ""No"" as the data are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name or business ID of an entity in order to find it. Data can only be viewed individually and cannot be downloaded in bulk. More detailed company information can be viewed for free but access is restricted with a captcha. I also changed B6 to ""No"" as it is not mentioned how often the data are updated or when they were last updated. ",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Evangelia Kampouri","35","35"
"fcec5bac-eb8d-47c7-84bb-c0f8b8a05cfb","global","2016-11-10T15:54:40","2016","fi","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""JSON""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name or business ID of an entity in order to find it.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://avoindata.prh.fi/index_en.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Finnish Patent and Registration Office"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://avoindata.prh.fi/index_en.html"",""descValue"":""This website contains open data published by the Finnish Patent and Registration Office (PRH)""},{""urlValue"":"""",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
Open data are published by the Finnish Patent and Registration Office (PRH) under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license and the Public Administration Recommendations (JHS recommendations) are applied to the material. All 4 required characteristics were found online: Finland's companies' names, addresses and unique identifiers are included in a machine-readable format, and are free of charge and freely available (https://avoindata.prh.fi/index_en.html). The data are updated once a day and can be accessed over HTTP, and Javascript Object Notation (JSON) is used for transmitting the data. However, the data are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name or business ID of an entity in order to find it.
Basic company information including business ID and address can also be searched for directly on the Finnish Patent and Registration Office's website for free (https://virre.prh.fi/novus/companySearch). However, this time the data are in HTML format and are still available through a search mask so again, it is necessary to know the name or business ID of an entity in order to find it. Accessing more detailed information requires payment.",,"Yes","No","Mika Honkanen","Evangelia Kampouri","70","70"
"2af18f15-6085-44f6-ab96-2a479d8aabce","global","2017-01-17T19:18:29","2016","ec","elections","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""You need to select the province and municipality and download one each time""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Went to the website of the Electoral authority, then spent some time looking for the information and eventually found the \""Sistema Estadístico Electoral\"" with the information I was looking for. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Consejo Nacional Electoral"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for major electoral contests"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://app03.cne.gob.ec/EstadisticaCNE/Ambito/Resultados/Resultado_Electoral.aspx"",""descValue"":""Sistema Estadístico Electoral""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","To find elections results data you need to go through the general institution information (such as Mission/Vision) tab, open a sub window for “Electoral Processes” and the last option goes to “Electoral Statistical System” (https://app03.cne.gob.ec/EstadisticaCNE/Ambito/Resultados/Resultado_Electoral.aspx) , where you can find the data in XLXS and HTML format. More logical pages to find the data, such as the Statistics page, only contain PDFs with elections analysis and research papers. Submitter was also able to find another link to access the information: https://app03.cne.gob.ec/EstadisticaCNE/Ambito/Index.aspx
Changed B2.3 from a 3 score to 2.
It is possible to explore elections data by electoral zones through the app but it is not possible to download it on a unified file. Datasets do not include Spoiled ballots information. B3 was changed to dismiss this characteristic and it was added the data available at polling station (electoral zones). B8 remains consistent. Actually, there’s a Copyright license for 2013 Presidential elections data (https://resultados2013.cne.gob.ec/) and by the end of the general elections results web app.
Results are also available in HTML, so it was included this format in B8.
B9. The spreadsheets are clean, but the information is highly divided in different files, which makes it difficult to analyse and compare data. Changed the score from 3 to 1.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Paola Mosso","65","65"
"2deb707e-d834-4803-a967-1f40aac03532","global","2017-02-08T19:08:05","2016","gr","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No general disclaimers of public domain status were found.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""One can only search and view individual entities at a time.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name of an entity in order to find it.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""A Google search for \""greek company register\"" lead to the General Electronic Commercial Registry page and, after some searching on the Greek section of the page (the English section is less detailed), found a page (https://www.businessportal.gr/dynamic.php) that directed me to \""Search Corporate Public Data\"" (GEMI Publicity)(https://www.businessportal.gr/dynamic.php)."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""General Secretariat for Commerce, Ministry of Development"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.businessregistry.gr/publicity/index"",""descValue"":""General Commercial Registry""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Not all 4 required characteristics were found online. More specifically, although the register is available for the entire country, the General Commercial Registry page (https://www.businessregistry.gr/publicity/index) only offers a company's name and registry number and not the address. Hence the original submission, which stated that all 4 required characteristics were available online, was rejected. Also, the original submission did not provide a Source URL where the data could be found. Lastly, the original submission stated that the data are available online without the need to register or request access to the data. In reality, data are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the name of an entity in order to find it. Hence, only one entity can be searched and viewed/downloaded at a time and the dataset is not downloadable at once. ",,"Yes","No","Evangelia Kampouri","Evangelia Kampouri","15","15"
"7361ad0b-a3a6-4f8c-b334-9485806da313","global","2017-01-22T09:50:45","2016","nz","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The Companies Register is a public register with conditions of use covered by Crown Copyright. Crown copyright ©\n\nUnless otherwise indicated, the content and design of this website (www.companiesoffice.govt.nz/companies) is protected by copyright owned by the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment on behalf of the Crown.\n\nUnless otherwise indicated (either below or within specific items or collections), Crown copyright material provided on the New Zealand Companies Office website may be reproduced free of charge without further permission, subject to the following conditions:\n\n You must reproduce the material accurately, using the most recent version.\n You must not use the material in a manner that is offensive, deceptive or misleading.\n You must acknowledge the source and copyright status of the material.\n\n \n\nPlease note that this licence does not apply to the website’s design elements, which may not be re-used without express permission.\n\nSome images, videos and logos on this website are also subject to restrictions of use, as they may contain third-party content that does not belong to the Ministry. Additionally, material on this website may not be used in any way that infringes the Flags, Emblems, and Names Protection Act 1981. Please contact us at service@companies.govt.nz before re-using any images, videos and/ or logos on this website.\n\nThe permission to use Crown copyright material does not extend to any material on this site that is identified as being the copyright of a third party. Permission to re-use third party copyright material cannot be given by the Ministry, and you will need to contact the copyright holder directly for permission.\nhttps://www.companiesoffice.govt.nz/companies/about-this-site/copyright""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Online results and downloadable searchable PDFs. \n\nAnd historical image files :-( ""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Datasets of up to 200 records can be downloaded. More records are available on request. \nSee https://www.companiesoffice.govt.nz/companies/learn-about/searching/understanding-your-search-results/retrieve-results-large ""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""enter search terms in search field"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.companiesoffice.govt.nz/companies/about-this-site/copyright "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""New Zealand Companies Office, part of Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.companiesoffice.govt.nz/companies/"",""descValue"":""New Zealand Companies Register""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.
The website is easily found through a Google search for ""new zealand company register"" which leads to the Companies Office page (https://www.companiesoffice.govt.nz). All 4 required characteristics were found online: New Zealand's companies' names, addresses and unique identifiers are included in company extracts which can be viewed online as .HTML files or viewed and downloaded in .PDF form. Annual Returns and Financial Statements are also available in image-based .PDF form. According to user kayakr on the discuss.okfn.org forum, the data are potentially available as JSON via the NZBN API https://api.business.govt.nz/api/apis/info?name=NZBN&version=v3&provider=mbiecreator#tab0 (provided one signs up to the MBIE API Access Agreement and can successfully authenticate). The data are publicly available and can be downloaded for free from the Companies Office website. However, the data are available through a search mask and it is necessary to know the names of an entity in order to find it. For every search only the first 200 results are automatically available and one needs to complete a form to request the remaining results of their search. Data are updated on different dates. For instance, CITIBANK, N.A. (377792) was lastly updated on 01/06/2016 while DEUTSCHE BANK AKTIENGESELLSCHAFT (834338) on 19/12/2016 (today's date is 08/02/2017).","Progress towards fully open and searchable data is underway. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Evangelia Kampouri","50","50"
"a8761ea6-0ce7-40f0-9496-f6fc30171f37","global","2016-12-15T11:09:06","2016","af","boundaries","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Independent Directorate of Local Governance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""As mentioned by original submitter: \""The Ministry of Interiors formerly and now the Independent Local Governanec Directorate is responsible for this. Their websites lacks any information on the boundaries.\""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""The Ministry of Interiors formerly and now the Independent Local Governanec Directorate is responsible for this. Their websites lacks any information on the boundaries."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The body responsible for this dataset: Independent Directorate of Local Governance; nothing was found in search that contradict submitter's observation. There are internal funding from EU --> https://ec.europa.eu/europeaid/sites/devco/files/aap_financing_afghanistan_annex_3_20160906_en.pdf in which proper land survey is to be done but no output can be found.
Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index.","The Independent Local Governance Directorate has not fulfilled its mandate to take the lead on local governance that includes boundaries.","Yes","No","anonymous","Michael Leow","0","0"
"429054e8-5785-497b-83fc-cc2967b7f72d","global","2017-01-29T18:16:46","2016","bb","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Fair Trading Commission"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes in the submission. Couldn't find a centralized procurement agency or center in government. ","Unfortunately I was unable to identify a government portal for the given datasets. It appears that the tenders notices are distributed individually via the company websites seeking the bids/services
Example: Barbados Water Authority https://barbadoswaterauthority.com/?cat=14","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"8d542b40-c094-406c-824f-e1b0f1fcd1e7","global","2017-01-18T14:47:44","2016","bd","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Need to follow step by step process"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Central Procurement Technical Unit"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.plancomm.gov.bd"",""descValue"":""Ministry of Planning ""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.cptu.gov.bd/AwardNotices.aspx"",""descValue"":""Award Notices with the history of the process""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.imed.gov.bd/site/page/ade3113a-9287-4ff9-89d5-11ecde4db5d8/Tender"",""descValue"":""Tender reports""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Added the resource with the award notices, which include the history of the contract. It is not possible to download but you can see the entire archive in the search.
",,"Yes","No","Nurunnaby Hasive","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"493b40a6-f10c-485f-8a46-e1e09071fa4b","global","2016-12-09T22:05:22","2016","au","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data exports available from public website and data.gov.au.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""JSON"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The annual data""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The export tool allows for date ranges, the contract export provides weekly outputs. The aggregate yearly datasets are on data.gov.au.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data updated weekly""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""google search for government contract data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.tenders.gov.au/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""With the exception of the Commonwealth Coat of Arms, the site is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 licence (CC BY 3.0 AU). The Department of Finance is not responsible for AusTender content sourced elsewhere.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Department of Finance"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://data.gov.au/dataset/historical-australian-government-contract-data"",""descValue"":""Historical Australian Government Contract Data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.tenders.gov.au/?event=public.reports.CN.Published.form"",""descValue"":""Contract notice export tool""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.tenders.gov.au/?agencyStatus=-1&dateStart=01-Jul-2015&dateEnd=30-Jun-2016&dateType=Publish+Date&valueStart=&valueEnd=&confidentiality=&supplier_name=&ABN=&SON_ID=&submitCriteria=Display+Results&event=public.reports.CN.Published.show"",""descValue"":""Sample query for FY2015-16 data""},{""urlValue"":""https://www.tenders.gov.au/?event=public.reports.listCNWeeklyExport"",""descValue"":""Weekly contract exports""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","No changes to the submissions. All the information is there and the datasets work. ","Note that the Australian Procurement exports use UNSPSC codes for compatibility internationally.","Yes","Yes",,"Oscar Montiel","100","100"
"4c7fe27f-1df4-4635-8f6c-3216801c9aae","global","2016-12-21T22:45:24","2016","ar","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Only the data of 2015.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search in Google \""licitaciones públicas argentina\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The web site comprar.gob.ar is not easy to use. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Modernización. Oficina Nacional de Contrataciones."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://comprar.gob.ar/ListarAperturaUltimos30Dias.aspx"",""descValue"":""Tenders for the last 30 days""},{""urlValue"":""https://comprar.gob.ar/BuscarAvanzado.aspx"",""descValue"":""Advanced search of tenders""},{""urlValue"":""https://datos.gob.ar/dataset/sistema-de-contrataciones-electronicas-argentina-compra"",""descValue"":""Data of tenders in 2015""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Information is correct. The agency exists, there is no publication of the data. ",,"Yes","No","Guido López Avakian","Oscar Montiel","65","65"
"869f066c-9afd-4c91-adc1-4068f76cddb6","global","2017-01-26T03:20:41","2016","ag","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Public Procurement in Antigua and Barbuda"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Although the Public Procurement in Antigua and Barbuda website exist with tabs for Awards and Tender Notices there was no data made available as well as I was unable to identify a government portal for the given datasets.
Homepage: https://www.tendersboard.gov.ag/","Yes","No","Alesha Aris","Oscar Montiel","0","0"
"07096204-ddef-4c7e-96b7-fc5acabb656e","global","2016-12-05T19:38:22","2016","gb","companies","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""No steps. I am a user of the data and have been aware of its location since the original release in 2012. However the dataset is easily found via Google using search terms such as: company data britain"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/free_company_data_third_party_in#incoming-557695"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Companies House maintains the data in a public register under statute. CH does not claim any intellectual property rights in the Free Company Data Product and therefore does not apply the Open Government Licence to the data. I have provided a link to correspondence from 2014 in which CH explains its position on re-use of the data.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""No data are usable without human effort. The data are formatted to be both human and machine-readable. However the dataset is too large to be easily managed in a spreadsheet programme so the user will need some basic knowledge of database software to manipulate the data.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Companies House"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire country""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://download.companieshouse.gov.uk/en_output.html"",""descValue"":""Free Company Data Product""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Your submission is valid. Thank you very much for contributing to the Global Open Data Index. All 4 required characteristics were found online: UK's companies' names, addresses and unique identifiers are included in machine-readable .CSV files that are publicly available and can be downloaded for free in bulk (in 5 parts) from the Companies House website. The website is easily found through a Google search for ""uk chamber of commerce"" which leads to a page directing to Companies House (https://www.britishchambers.org.uk/business/business-faqs/where-can-i-go-to-get-a-list-of-registered-companies-in-the-uk.html). People have complained about corrupted data files and outdated data on the data.gov.uk page (https://data.gov.uk/dataset/basic-company-data) so downloading them directly from the Companies House website (https://download.companieshouse.gov.uk/en_output.html) is preferable. Data were lastly updated on 03/02/2017 (today's date is 07/02/2017). Although machine readable, some human effort is required to manipulate the data as the dataset is too large.",,"Yes","Yes","Owen Boswarva","Evangelia Kampouri","100","100"
"bd6bcc41-ab38-4a1d-8a7d-2c76d62de7af","global","2016-12-09T10:19:38","2016","al","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""TXT""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""This page can be found by selecting the e-procurement tab from the home menu."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Agjencia e Prokurimit Publik"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://app.gov.al/ep/2015_Arkiva_e_Buletineve.aspx"",""descValue"":""2015 report archive""},{""urlValue"":""https://app.gov.al/ep/Archived.aspx"",""descValue"":""Archive with a search""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","I added an archive section where you can find all the archived processes with the information about the entire process, who tendered, who won and amounts. You can also find the reports for procurement per year. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Oscar Montiel","65","65"
"c4f7c539-abde-4121-80e0-64f7fad2651b","global","2016-12-15T11:11:30","2016","af","procurement","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""NPA Website"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""National Procurement Authority"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.ppu.gov.af/Beta/English/English.aspx"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"National Procurement Authority has done a good job. However, the data is not available in PDF format to be downloaded at once.","Yes","No","anonymous","Oscar Montiel","45","45"
"b33cf669-1d62-4481-96ab-0fbd02c763d0","global","2016-12-15T11:25:57","2016","af","weather","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Afghanistan Meteorological Authority (AMA)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The AMA runs several weather stations in the country. The war in Afghanistan meant a drawback of weather forecasting. The infrastructure is rebuilt across the country, so that services such as public weather forecasting or reporting for aviation are available.\n\nMore details about the AMA can be found under this link: https://www.wmo.int/cpdb/afghanistan\n""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""No agency responsible for it."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no official website available for the AMA. \n\n\n""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The submission stated that there is not government agency in Afghanistan, collecting or producing weather data. This was corrected. The Afghanistan Meteorological Authority (AMA), attached to the Ministry of Transport and Civil Aviation, runs several weather stations across the country and provides public weather services (as well as other services such as warnings, climate research, or aviation services). More info: https://www.wmo.int/cpdb/afghanistan",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Danny Lämmerhirt","0","0"
"e5a2ba4d-f4b1-4bd4-845f-0b84f9505b2b","global","2017-01-17T18:03:43","2016","ec","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There are PDF reports in the transparency section of the ministry""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Can't access the datasets at all""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Looked for the Ministry of Finance website, then directly in the \""important information\"" tabs, go to the spending reports. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Finanzas"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Amount of the transaction""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Can't see the actual data set""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.finanzas.gob.ec/ejecucion-presupuestaria/"",""descValue"":""Budget execution updated every three months""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Oscar Montiel","15","15"
"55398143-29c1-45b0-962e-516ff933af50","global","2017-01-17T23:28:11","2016","ec","map","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""SHP""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""sistema nacional de información has different sections where data should be but it is really hard getting to the actual data set, you can visualize very easily but not download. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Secretaría Nacional de Plaeneación e información /Sistema Nacional de Información"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of national traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""National borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://sni.gob.ec/coberturas"",""descValue"":""Archivos de información geográfica""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Oscar Montiel","65","65"
"9f77bd1a-f8e6-4e7f-8eb8-fbcdb6876807","global","2017-01-16T15:10:05","2016","ca","land","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Land registry data are only made available via a land registry database lookup service run by the private sector. Land registry data management is often outsourced to third party private sector organization and require specialized knowledge to search them.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Provinces and territories land registry offices in Canada collect these data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Only on a parcel or by records basis. Land Registries are the responsibility of the provinces and territories who outsource the service.""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"This is a legacy economic arrangement and it is hoped that land registry data can be made public and taken out of these archaic pay per view data base systems only available at the locations where the land parcel is.","Yes","No","Tracey P. Lauriault","Tracey P. Lauriault","0","0"
"8260b38a-940b-4da2-a482-cc587d70cb31","global","2016-11-28T20:40:06","2016","py","spending","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""An ad-hoc license""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Also there is a visualization graph with spent did until 9/30/16""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Downloadable month by month""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Today is 28th November and October ins't there. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""From Hacienda's homepage, clic on open data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://datos.hacienda.gov.py/index.html#/license"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Graphical interface allows easy use of data. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministerio de Hacienda"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Individual record of transactions"",""Government office which had the transaction"",""Date of transaction"",""Name of vendor"",""Amount of the transaction""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://datos.hacienda.gov.py/data/pgn-gasto"",""descValue"":""Corresponde a los datos del Presupuesto General de la Nación de Gastos del ejercicio vigente aprobado por Ley Anual de Presupuesto más las modificaciones presupuestarias aprobadas por disposición legal. De acuerdo a la Ley 1535/99, la vigencia del ejercicio financiero se inicia el 1 de enero y finaliza el 31 de diciembre de cada año. El Presupuesto General de la Nación está integrado por los presupuestos de ingresos, gastos y financiamiento de los Organismos y Entidades del Estado definidos en el Art. 3 de la Ley 1535/99. La publicación de ésta información es requerida por el Art. 10 Inc. a) de la Ley 5282/2015 de Acceso a la Información Pública.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Lupinupa L","Lupinupa L","85","85"
"6a4a07a6-51c5-48c5-971e-de2945223836","global","2016-11-28T20:12:01","2016","py","budget","[{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I really got confused about budget and spent""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Going to Ministerio de Hacienda and then click on Datos Abiertos at the front page."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://datos.hacienda.gov.py/license"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Graphic section is the best for use. \nThen, csv is little difficult since you have to use a dictionary and a data analysis tool. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" Ministerio de Hacienda"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://datos.hacienda.gov.py/data/pgn-etapas"",""descValue"":""Etapas de formulación, elaboración, consolidación y aprobación del Presupuesto General de la Nación""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","Yes","Lupinupa L","Lupinupa L","100","100"